I am just loving doctor Kirkpatrick. No BS kind of doc who really tries to not let the defense get over on him. He really seems to care for the research and treatment of children and adults with CRPS
He used very low doses compared to Dr. Hanna and the Ketamine infusion. Doctor Kirkpatrick ordered Hydromorphone which is 2xs stronger than morphine. This is research and not approved as well at this point. Very concerned people are so accepting of the medical care done to Maya prior to this hospitalization.
i am so tired of the defenses objections and complaints that they didn't have time to review evidence. they've had years of time!!! And tired of the judge acting like the plaintiff is wasting the courts time when it is the defense wasting time
Especially considering how many people are working for the defense. Past and present attorneys. Compared to the plaintiffs attorneys. It's like David and Goliath.
The defense is terrified that Dr. Kirkpatrick’s knowledge and simple explanations of this disease will make an impact on this jury. Trying to interrupt every question and answer. Some defense teams work hard to protect their client against false accusations but this team is trying to shield the hospital from the truth. Despicable!
I could have listened to Dr. Kirkpatrick discuss his entire history studying CRPS. It was so educational. It was a shame when Defense objected, causing the doctor to get to Maya’s case. Understandable, the need to get to the specific topic at hand, but selfishly, I wanted to hear more! Describes things to a layman very well!
@@KevlarSammyNot sure why people are so upset about ketamine. It's a very safe drug. It doesn't wipe out the respiratory drive or cardiovascular drive like all other anesthetics. John's Hopkins chose to treat Maya with propofol, a way more dangerous drug than ketamin. You'd probably are more familiar with it's other name of Diprivan, you know, the drug thay killed Michael Jackson. It's too bad the plantiffs did point that out in this trial. If I had a choice between ketamine or propofol to give my child, it would be ketanind. Additionally, I've administrator ketaninrme to children for procedures and they do well on it. We don't have to bag then to maintain their airway.
@@KevlarSammyHow are you gonna get “lit af” on ketamine if you’re unconscious in a coma? Make it make sense. Therapeutic doses are different than recreational doses.
I like how the good doctor is holding this guy to court and demanding his records be shown to him before he answers these twisted questions to try and trap him. Good on you Dr K.
Yes like these doctors see so many people over time, they should be allowed to look at records. I struggle to remember something from last week let alone years ago
@@spalanki352yup. These ppl are delusional. He spotted something 48 other doctors didn't? And the thing he spotted just happened to be treated by the treatment he sells
I agree! He is so fascinated with the medical diagnosis and cares for his patients. It's to bad he had to be cut off, I really enjoyed his information.
The way the judge talked to him was very disrespectful IMO ! The judge saying, I really need you to just answer the questions and Dr. K said I’ll try my best, or something like that and the judge said something like no you need to do it, or something like that! I thought how rude!!
This case is infuriating. I couldn’t imagine this happening to a family… low and behold, here it is. The anger they must have from the way she was treated and what mom ultimately resorted to is just inexcusable. HOW could you ever get past this?
The part about these attorneys in specific that was so appalling to me is that some of these attorneys aren’t just attorneys that represent the hospital in court but they are on staff for the hospital and were present and making decisions for Maya and her family while she was in the hospital. Wouldn’t you think that if this many of their decisions resulted in this many lawsuits that they would no longer be making any legal decisions for them? Like how are they now representing the hospital in court to defend their barbaric decisions made in the hospital?!
I’m so interested to see who the Defense brings in as a witnesses from the Hospital. It’s so funny how the defense tries to discredit Dr. Kirkpatrick & act as if he isn’t qualified to diagnose her but she’s since been diagnosed by multiple other physicians.
@@MommaSmithSally smith should be interesting. Im thinking she’ll testify over zoom as she knows how much people despise her. I didn’t hear if she’ll appear in person or not
@@SouthsideNik The plaintiff and the kowalski have made sure to discredit Sally and Cathy creating bias before they have a chance to testify. I do believe they had a job to do and that was to investigate and protect the child. I will reserve judgement until after both sides are heard. I am not without compassion, just interested in ALL the evidence which includes documents and testimony of hospital records and hosptial staff. I have not developed a n opinion of either of these women yet. So no not everybody despises Sally Smith
@@sunshine22723It was JHACH who refused to listen to the patient and the parents. They kidnapped her for 3 months for no reason at all. Knowing that they were wrong the whole time.
Those nurses notes were downright unprofessional and disrespectful. Writing away Maya’s issues as “depression” and “burning” so sarcastically. Just say you don’t want to be a nurse. Perhaps she was too “overworked” or “annoyed” to deal with a little girl who’s symptoms were too complex for her “tiny brain”
The number one complaint of CRPS (Chronic Regional Psin Syndrome) IS burning!! Feeling like you are on fire 24/7 is horrific. Shame on the lack of empathy and human kindness for those “nurses!”
@therealz360z7 it was more than her culture. Demanding the hospital give the child meds that were not normally given to a child in large doses was the trigger.
@@Estimator00 Keyword being "normally". Those were the drugs prescribed for her diagnosis. Perhaps those nurses and doctors should have taken the time to educate themselves about it instead of letting their egos tricking themselves into thinking they know everything. In this instance, they were clueless and lacked the professional integrity to admit it.
Unfortunately it's not so much that as it is the laws of evidence. Evidence has to meet very specific requirements and when you have a case like this with multiple plaintiffs, agencies, and the family courts, dcf (CPS), as well as any other agencies it means that some evidence while being very meaningful doesn't meet the evidentiary standards. It happens in every trial during the pretrial phase. I will admit there are some things that should have come in that didn't and vice versa.
This is so sickening in many ways. To see the defense lawyers treating this doctor like a criminal; someone who's dedicated his career to helping unwell people. All in the name of covering the backs of questionable hospital staff and illegitimising the totally lawful decisions a family took to give their child her life back. It truly disgusts me.
Until you experience this kind of severe pain you will never know how it effects your life and the life’s of your family members who care about you! God Bless you Maya and your family🙏❤️🩹🙏
Maybe but I think there is a lot to this story. I can’t imagine taking my 9 year old to Mexico for a treatment where there is 50% chance my child would die. Defies common sense. I also can’t imagine forging prescriptions for ketamine and I wonder if the mother was actually taking the meds herself.
@@rlfrohs6123Im pretty sure you cannot also imagine the level of pain that child had to go through. Although they explained it so many times - it’s worse than pain of finger amputation. But sometimes people just don’t have imagination. However try and imagine yourself feeling that pain - I bet you would be first in line to get something that stops it, whenever it’s possible. Also what’s wrong with going to the hospital in Mexico, it is still hospital, like here with excellent doctors. Maybe not so fancy though.
@@joannatomaszewska First of all, you are correct, I can’t imagine pain like that. Second, nothing is wrong with Mexico. What is wrong is that I would NEVER put myself or my child under anesthesia for a 50% chance that they would die. The child was not terminally ill, and even if she had been, I would have never agreed to a procedure that gave me only a flip of the coin chance of survival.
@@rlfrohs6123 I will agree with you regarding the 50% chance of survival, I find that very disturbing as well. But, when has it been proven that Beata forged ketamine prescriptions and took them herself?
Dr. Kirkpatrick and the psychiatrist thumbs up today. Dr. Kirkpatrick was fenomenal, very thorough and assertive, didn't put up with the charades the defense tried to pull up to discredite him, they tried but amazing job Dr. Kirkpatrick impossible to fool. The psychiatrist amazing testimony, plus just one question he answered the whole trial: you can't have Munchhausen by proxy and CRPS in the same time, that says it all.
Dr. Bewerton is telling the truth that the defense lawyers are not wanting the jurors to hear. When the media flashes to the defense lawyers they know the hospital screwed up! I glad the judge is overruling the defense team objections.
@ShopharTemple no human beings should be treated the way that boy was No Matter how Disruptive he was or misbehaving That is not right on any level from anyone and I hope the Mom gets what. She has coming for her Action The Father might have been the Main player. But she knew what he was doing and nothing to stop it much Less Report it.
@@brianmalone5006 he wasn't even treated that bad. You want to cry about undeserved abuse, check out the Shanda Vander Ark trial from Michigan a couple months ago. That is abuse
@@Estimator00 WRONG Like the mob, they follow orders from the 5 billion in fruad fines pharma cartel! Delivering us the leading cause of Death, i.e. "Pharma "medicine"! [fact!] Look up the Johns Hopkins [low-ball] iatrogenic study then the well cited book by Dr. Null, Death by Medicine, documenting pharma "medicine" kills over 2000 each & every day! Look it up, you don't have to stay ignorant!
defense continuing to not let anyone speak just proves this family's case even more. they object so much and stall so much it doesnt make them look good at all.
doctors and hospitals code things for the benefit of the insurance company. in this case they probably began with "to rule out pathology" which could include CRPS
I agree and the in some points they make is like they're still trying to say she doesn't have it. Which is confusing, idk where they're going with it but that's what my conclusion is with how they question the witnesses
here is an idea judge let the plaintiff present the case and then let the defense defend the case when it is their turn and stop trying to prevent the jury from hearing everything
I give myself IV when I'm sick! I have a port and have to administer antibiotics when needed per Dr. Attorneys trying to play Dr have no idea what the protocol is!
i think yhe hospital fails to recognize that just because they recommend a certain treatment or therapy does not mean someone HAS TO DO IT, it is their choice to or not. Also I feel the hospital had zero rights to be subpoenaing every doctor she did see after she was out of the hospital
I feel so horrible for this family. The medical system is a giant. They mistreated this family in unimaginable ways. I hope they get compensated appropriately for it. However, I can’t help but think how wrong Beata was to kill herself. It hurt her family more than it helped. Imagine if she were here. They’d have a much easier time in court and the kids would have their mother, and Jack would have his wife.
If she didn’t unfortunately they would have kept Maya once these accusations are made it takes years to resolve in court I think as a mom she truly believed this was the only way to get her daughter home.
The court and the jury are not allowed to hear about Mayas treatment prior to any of this, she was on massive amounts of steroids and that caused her GI issues, poor girl was being over medicated and harmed for years and years, JHACH weaned her off all the meds in the 3 months she was inpatient. She was able to progress and walk within 6 months following. I suspect Maya has an eating disorder, it looks serious but I hope she has it under control.
@@paytonkierce9854 yes she did. Side effects of the drugs she was taking before k. That day there were a total of 21. The plaintiffs witnesses testified about k and gi problems. Guess you missed that
Literally 7:23:30 I am livid w defense counsel 🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️ you want this doctor to respond about her interim condition without referencing the records from the interim!
They are trying to discredit Dr Kirkpatrick but honestly, I really like him. He is very passionate and clearly very knowledgeable. I have no problems trusting his opinion.
We have already had another doc talk about CRPS and ketamine to back up the treatment he gave her. And teachers and the family testified Maya was better after and with the ketamine treatment.
Am I missing something w/regard to Anderson? Is he not familiar enough w/case, nervous, disorganized? I hope 2not sound judgemental bc it’s not my intention; I’m just concerned for the Kowalski’s.
If Anderson wants sympathy from the jury for the plaintiffs, he should act like he cares when his witnesses are on the stand. The shuffling of papers and not paying attention to Dr is annoying!!
What I truly hate are his attempts at humour, like today : “So Jack’s not out hitting the bar scene” etc. It is both inappropriate and takes away from the seriousness of this case and the topic at hand.
Anderson’s lack of preparedness and professionalism is concerning. I hope he doesn’t cause the Kowalskis to lose this trial. Imho, his co-counsel should be lead attorney instead because he is much more affable, is able to swiftly rephrase questions that have been objected to and sustained, and places his focus on the witness testifying.
I've watched a hundred trials and I've never seen anyone shuffle papers and stammer and stutter and lose track of where they are in the middle of asking a question as much as Mr.Anderson. It's so annoying. I'm just glad it didn't cost them the trial.
I can't believe those a-hole doctors at JH used to call her "ketamine girl." JH hospital absolutely discriminated against the mother because she was Polish and had an accent.
I think they are threatened by a woman who is bold and knowledgeable and demands nothing less than their best for her child. I truly believe it was an ego thing of “WE and we alone will tell you what we are going to do and not going to do”.
Answer! Because Mom's body & soul are no longer there! They will all "relocate" soon, with God Jesus in glorious Heaven! That's God's plan for you! BUT most love to be their own god & hang with Satan for all eternity!
Why the doctor’s pay is revealed? Why defense asks that question and why Anderson sits and doesn’t do anything about it?? He should at least try to block that irrelevant question.
It is a common question, and the defense is trying to say that the witnesses are advocates for the plaintiff, even though technically that is exactly what a Dr is supposed to do. But they're trying to make that argument, while there's 6 of them sitting over there for this major hospital organization, and just 2 for the plaintiff, with only 1 actually arguing. And honestly, my opinion, Mr Anderson is a horrible lawyer. I'm very surprised he pulled this off, but i won't be surprised if the defense wins in appeal for some of his pretty big mistakes, such as not turning over evidence in a timely manner
I understand defense attorneys are a necessary evil, but these ones are abhorrent. Disgusting defending the hospital which clearly has dirty hands by trying to make everyone else guilty for their actions and inactions that hurt that poor child.
Medical professional here, 20 years oncology.. This hospital saved this young lady's life. I know it's not the popular opinion. If she had been released to Mom, she would most likely be dead today. Hard wrap one's mind around that, but it happens. Thank God for people who stand their ground, despite popular 'opinion'.
Let's pretend that they did "save her life" they did it in the most unprofessional, inhumane, disrespectful, unkind, abusive way. No one has died from a ketamine coma.
I got a rather sketchy feeling about Beata having recorded her visit with Dr Kirkpatrick. Why in the world would she have felt the need to do that, so early in the case? What was she trying to prove, and to whom?
" very one sided ?? You haven't even heard the defense, witnesses or experts yet, Its very very sad, I hope you , keep an open mind & pretend your a juror, write notes ECT . Remember if you have already made your decision " you would not make a fair juror, think 🤔 about that, it's scary to think that these 6 ppl haven't seen ppl magazine and the documentary, but I am putting my trust in them.
unfortunately i believe that crps totally exists however i am 1000% think her mother made this whole family a total wreck. everyone has to see that when the mother was not there anymore in a most cowardly act, maya actually got better!
Yeah. I saw she was using a diaper and couldn’t walk when she arrived at the hospital. After getting off the mother’s “treatments,” she was able to regain function in her legs through physical therapy.
There's footage of her swimming, doing activities prior to being isolated in hospital, she had a relapse. And she didn't need to be in hospital as long as she was, she could have gone home days after. She would have gotten better at home, like she has done many times. She still has relapses, she isn't cured.
The hospital, the judicial system thanks to that Beaty hag, wrecked this family. If they had just let Maya go home NONE of this would have happened. The family was managing better before that witch got her evil hands in this case.
She was majorly depressed and thought her daughter was going to die. She thought it she killed herself it would save her daughter. She did the most brave thing. Dying for your child.
Ketamine has less negative effects than Xanax or oxicontin. And is 99% less addictive, as it comes to physical withdrawl anyway. There are more people who get addicted to Marijuana than ketamine, and Marijuana isn't addictive at all either. Haha.
Am I the only one who feels Dr.K is selling his expensive treatment? Quick diagnosis of such a complex and rare illness. No concern for what multiple other docs said. Reinforcing mom’s diagnosis of her child. Feels misleading and dangerous to me. Especially since Maya walks and thrives today (without ketamine and after JH stay).
Also I would add, although maya was not a part of his study/research I think his interest in the outcome of patients with CRPS and use/benefit of K would outweigh his need or want for monetary gain from the treatments and subsequent visits. A lot of time researcher are far more interested and passionate about their study than quick cash. If he believed maya didn’t actually suffer from CRPS and just made a “quick diagnosis” it would be far less valuable for data collection.
He put the bullets in Beata's gun when he told her, while Maya was in the hospital that without ketamine Maya would have a heart attack and die. No wonder she was frantic. Dr. K carries a great deal of responsibility for the death for this poor unstable mother who believed in him
I'm really annoyed with the Attorneys from JHACH, as if someone who is wheelchair bound could jump out from one day to another just because of a Ketamine coma and Booster? Get a grip!! Always the same.. 'After the Ketamine treatment, she was still in a wheelchair, correct?'
I’m confused. Dr. Kirkpatrick is clearly an expert…why didn’t he intervene and school Sally and the other idiots?? With his expertise, couldn’t he have prevented this whole mess? He seems like he cares a ton…why didn’t he persist until they finally “got it”?
He tried. Sally Smith ignored him and did not present his diagnosis and opinion to the Judge in the DCF case. She only provided the narrative that the mother and Maya were lying.
The prosecution starts, by making the case for their claim. They explain what they believe the evidence will show the jury, in their opening statements. The defense is also allowed an opening statement on what they believe the evidence will show. The prosecuting counsel then begins by calling witnesses, to make their case. And they are to have all of their witnesses and evidences ready, labeled and organized for the claim they are making, and they give an estimate to the judge about how long it will take for them to question their witnesses and produce the evidences before the jury. Their estimated time does not count the defenses cross examinations of their witnesses. After prosecution rests their case, as in calls all their witnesses, and produce all of their evidence, then the defense begins their defense case, where they gather all their witnesses and evidences, same as prosecution did, and give an estimate to the judge to how much time they believe it will take for them to make their case for defense, sometimes there's a counter suit, which makes it a bit more complex. Really, it just flips the sides after the first case rests. But that is not the case here. So the judge takes their estimates, usually adds a bit of time, for scheduling. Because judges are actually very busy, he may have another trial scheduled shortly after this one, or other obligations. Same with the lawyers. And then they also give the jurors the time estimate, because they have to take the time off of work and away from family, and they actually take that very seriously into consideration. This is very important in civil cases as this, as it's not a priority to the judge, compared to actual criminal trials where somebody's life and freedom is on the line.
The mother altered a prescrition, assuming that it was her who put " terminal illnees" on the script! Unbelievable. Don't people think that was part of her fear? Being found out? It is a felony with prison time. Not only that, she would lose her nursing license. That is serious. It goes to her state of mind and manipulation of the medical community. If people overlook that, there is something wrong with their judgment.
Defense had it right; what a long day. Has the good doc' ever really testified? He's not board certified(?), didn't bring his own 'homework' and doesn't know how to answer a question w/o going off on tangents, narratives it seems. But, in his favor, if the prosecuting attorney could articulate a concise question might help, but then again....what a long day. The longer he talks th more $ he makes.
He’s not a designated expert witness 🤣 which means he doesn’t usually go to court proceedings let alone trials. He is most certainly not being paid nearly as much as a expert witness would. He was told his records were already in evidence which means he was not told by either defense or plaintiff to bring records. Which are usually not allowed anyways if they are not in evidence unless there is an exception to use it to refresh recollection.
@therealz360z7 Board certified "medicine" is the leading cause Death in the USA! [Fact!] see the Johns Hopkins [low-ball] iatrogenic study & the well cited book by Dr. Null, Death by Medicine, claiming Board certified "medicine" kills 800,000 a year or over 2000, a day! But who wants to know that uncomfortable fact? RIGHT?
Dr. Kirkpatrick did a phenomenal job explaining everything while he was on the stand. I can’t believe that the defense attorney was being such a jerk! I really hope that Maya and her family receive the justice that they deserve. 🫶🏽
the strategy of the defence cross-examination of the anaesthetist would appear to be aural anaesthesia of the jury, by making the q&a as irrelevantly peripheral and long-winded as possible, so as to make them fall asleep. It worked on me.
Jury is asking fantastic questions
I am just loving doctor Kirkpatrick. No BS kind of doc who really tries to not let the defense get over on him. He really seems to care for the research and treatment of children and adults with CRPS
I love how he makes the defence show him every document and refuses to let them recharacterise or misinterpret the record
But he also does this back stroke dance. He did some things wrong. So adamant but with defense he is vague.
Are u fidding me?
Here's a poem!
The longer he takes,
the more money he makes.
He used very low doses compared to Dr. Hanna and the Ketamine infusion. Doctor Kirkpatrick ordered Hydromorphone which is 2xs stronger than morphine. This is research and not approved as well at this point. Very concerned people are so accepting of the medical care done to Maya prior to this hospitalization.
The hospital, staff, social worker's, law enforcement, and children's services need to be held accountable!
i am so tired of the defenses objections and complaints that they didn't have time to review evidence. they've had years of time!!! And tired of the judge acting like the plaintiff is wasting the courts time when it is the defense wasting time
Especially considering how many people are working for the defense. Past and present attorneys. Compared to the plaintiffs attorneys. It's like David and Goliath.
The defense is terrified that Dr. Kirkpatrick’s knowledge and simple explanations of this disease will make an impact on this jury. Trying to interrupt every question and answer. Some defense teams work hard to protect their client against false accusations but this team is trying to shield the hospital from the truth. Despicable!
😮 how eye opening Dr. Bewerton statment he has made about depression, ptsd and chronic pain. So sad praying for Maya and her family! ❤❤❤
I could have listened to Dr. Kirkpatrick discuss his entire history studying CRPS. It was so educational. It was a shame when Defense objected, causing the doctor to get to Maya’s case. Understandable, the need to get to the specific topic at hand, but selfishly, I wanted to hear more! Describes things to a layman very well!
That doctor is so cool lol
Yeah, his sells pitch is so good. I could definitely see people forking over $24,000 to get their kid lit af on ketamine for 4 Days. 😂
Me too!!!
@@KevlarSammyNot sure why people are so upset about ketamine. It's a very safe drug. It doesn't wipe out the respiratory drive or cardiovascular drive like all other anesthetics. John's Hopkins chose to treat Maya with propofol, a way more dangerous drug than ketamin. You'd probably are more familiar with it's other name of Diprivan, you know, the drug thay killed Michael Jackson. It's too bad the plantiffs did point that out in this trial. If I had a choice between ketamine or propofol to give my child, it would be ketanind. Additionally, I've administrator ketaninrme to children for procedures and they do well on it. We don't have to bag then to maintain their airway.
@@KevlarSammyHow are you gonna get “lit af” on ketamine if you’re unconscious in a coma? Make it make sense. Therapeutic doses are different than recreational doses.
I like how the good doctor is holding this guy to court and demanding his records be shown to him before he answers these twisted questions to try and trap him.
Good on you Dr K.
Yes like these doctors see so many people over time, they should be allowed to look at records. I struggle to remember something from last week let alone years ago
Sorry but any physician who provides diagnosis without review of medical History is the kind to run away from
@@spalanki352yup. These ppl are delusional. He spotted something 48 other doctors didn't? And the thing he spotted just happened to be treated by the treatment he sells
@@Nick2bad4uand didn’t take insurance.
@@spalanki352 🐕 ate his 📚, but not to worry, the more time the more 💰.
Shady works for me
Maya must have felt so much guilt for her mother's passing and her illness wasn't her fault. Beautiful girl. I'm sending her all my love
I’m sending love and prayers her way💕💕💕🙏🙏🙏I hope she knows none of this was her fault!!!
Survivors guilt is so strong in this case.
Dr Kirkpatrick seems like a truly incredible & compassionate doctor. We really need more of doctors like him.
❤
He seems like a complete quack
I agree! He is so fascinated with the medical diagnosis and cares for his patients. It's to bad he had to be cut off, I really enjoyed his information.
The way the judge talked to him was very disrespectful IMO ! The judge saying, I really need you to just answer the questions and Dr. K said I’ll try my best, or something like that and the judge said something like no you need to do it, or something like that! I thought how rude!!
@therealz360z7
Huh?
he brought in a skeleton as a prop to explain CRPS but they told him not to use it and took it out. They were all laughing at it. @@goose7574
This case is infuriating. I couldn’t imagine this happening to a family… low and behold, here it is. The anger they must have from the way she was treated and what mom ultimately resorted to is just inexcusable. HOW could you ever get past this?
Another case with dame hospital
It really makes you wonder how often this type thing happens...
@@Kim-tl4wztoo often. Continuously just concerning Sally Smith alone
The part about these attorneys in specific that was so appalling to me is that some of these attorneys aren’t just attorneys that represent the hospital in court but they are on staff for the hospital and were present and making decisions for Maya and her family while she was in the hospital. Wouldn’t you think that if this many of their decisions resulted in this many lawsuits that they would no longer be making any legal decisions for them? Like how are they now representing the hospital in court to defend their barbaric decisions made in the hospital?!
Dr. Kirkpatrick has a lot to say lol 😅 if he has a chance he would be there for days talking about what he have and has done throughout his life.
I’m so interested to see who the Defense brings in as a witnesses from the Hospital. It’s so funny how the defense tries to discredit Dr. Kirkpatrick & act as if he isn’t qualified to diagnose her but she’s since been diagnosed by multiple other physicians.
Dr Kirkpatrick is a gem in this day in age!
Cathy Smith is going to testify. That should be quite interesting! She’s the one who already settled out of court for $2M.
@@MommaSmithSally smith should be interesting. Im thinking she’ll testify over zoom as she knows how much people despise her. I didn’t hear if she’ll appear in person or not
no thats cathy beedy that settles, sally smith is testifying @@MommaSmith
@@SouthsideNik The plaintiff and the kowalski have made sure to discredit Sally and Cathy creating bias before they have a chance to testify. I do believe they had a job to do and that was to investigate and protect the child. I will reserve judgement until after both sides are heard. I am not without compassion, just interested in ALL the evidence which includes documents and testimony of hospital records and hosptial staff. I have not developed a n opinion of either of these women yet. So no not everybody despises Sally Smith
Hospital needs to pay for their incompetence and overall lack of human decency! 😢
It's the physicians in 2015 who harmed Maya. they violated basic quality.of care to a child.
100%. Also I hate seeing them always trying to pass blame to courts for the separation of this family when it was them that requested it I believe.
100%
@@sunshine22723It was JHACH who refused to listen to the patient and the parents. They kidnapped her for 3 months for no reason at all. Knowing that they were wrong the whole time.
Absolutely
I hope this Family gets Justice.
Those nurses notes were downright unprofessional and disrespectful. Writing away Maya’s issues as “depression” and “burning” so sarcastically. Just say you don’t want to be a nurse. Perhaps she was too “overworked” or “annoyed” to deal with a little girl who’s symptoms were too complex for her “tiny brain”
The number one complaint of CRPS (Chronic Regional Psin Syndrome) IS burning!! Feeling like you are on fire 24/7 is horrific. Shame on the lack of empathy and human kindness for those “nurses!”
@therealz360z7 best comment!!!
@therealz360z7 it was more than her culture. Demanding the hospital give the child meds that were not normally given to a child in large doses was the trigger.
@therealz360z7 WRONG! Crepes in Power only want submersion! This wasn't Mom's first rodeo!
@@Estimator00 Keyword being "normally". Those were the drugs prescribed for her diagnosis. Perhaps those nurses and doctors should have taken the time to educate themselves about it instead of letting their egos tricking themselves into thinking they know everything. In this instance, they were clueless and lacked the professional integrity to admit it.
Im no legal eagle, i feel that the plaintiffs are having to try this case with their hands and legs tied behind their backs, by the judge and defence.
This little family going to battle with a beast, no doubt about that! This is like David vs Goliath. I hope this family receives justice ❤
Unfortunately it's not so much that as it is the laws of evidence. Evidence has to meet very specific requirements and when you have a case like this with multiple plaintiffs, agencies, and the family courts, dcf (CPS), as well as any other agencies it means that some evidence while being very meaningful doesn't meet the evidentiary standards. It happens in every trial during the pretrial phase. I will admit there are some things that should have come in that didn't and vice versa.
I felt bad for Dr Kirkpatrick. I think he is just very passionate in what he does!
Very passionate about playing dr. Feelgood, prescribing massive amounts of recreational medications for anyone with scratch and a reason
Dr K is amazing! Prayers for his continued good work!
This is so sickening in many ways. To see the defense lawyers treating this doctor like a criminal; someone who's dedicated his career to helping unwell people. All in the name of covering the backs of questionable hospital staff and illegitimising the totally lawful decisions a family took to give their child her life back. It truly disgusts me.
Until you experience this kind of severe pain you will never know how it effects your life and the life’s of your family members who care about you! God Bless you Maya and your family🙏❤️🩹🙏
What this hospital did to this family is disgraceful
Maybe but I think there is a lot to this story. I can’t imagine taking my 9 year old to Mexico for a treatment where there is 50% chance my child would die. Defies common sense. I also can’t imagine forging prescriptions for ketamine and I wonder if the mother was actually taking the meds herself.
@@rlfrohs6123 Not only was the mother mentally ill, she had co dependency issues with Maya.
@@rlfrohs6123Im pretty sure you cannot also imagine the level of pain that child had to go through. Although they explained it so many times - it’s worse than pain of finger amputation. But sometimes people just don’t have imagination. However try and imagine yourself feeling that pain - I bet you would be first in line to get something that stops it, whenever it’s possible. Also what’s wrong with going to the hospital in Mexico, it is still hospital, like here with excellent doctors. Maybe not so fancy though.
@@joannatomaszewska First of all, you are correct, I can’t imagine pain like that. Second, nothing is wrong with Mexico. What is wrong is that I would NEVER put myself or my child under anesthesia for a 50% chance that they would die. The child was not terminally ill, and even if she had been, I would have never agreed to a procedure that gave me only a flip of the coin chance of survival.
@@rlfrohs6123 I will agree with you regarding the 50% chance of survival, I find that very disturbing as well. But, when has it been proven that Beata forged ketamine prescriptions and took them herself?
Dr. Kirkpatrick and the psychiatrist thumbs up today. Dr. Kirkpatrick was fenomenal, very thorough and assertive, didn't put up with the charades the defense tried to pull up to discredite him, they tried but amazing job Dr. Kirkpatrick impossible to fool. The psychiatrist amazing testimony, plus just one question he answered the whole trial: you can't have Munchhausen by proxy and CRPS in the same time, that says it all.
I totally and completely agree! 💗 Also, I believe that the correct word is phenomenal.
His style reminded me of Dr. Jorden Peterson!
Loved the psychiatrist
Dr. Bewerton is telling the truth that the defense lawyers are not wanting the jurors to hear. When the media flashes to the defense lawyers they know the hospital screwed up! I glad the judge is overruling the defense team objections.
i feel the defense is proving their guilt every time they try to prevent someone from speaking facts and the jury will agree with me
Fantastic Psychiatrist!
I could listen to Dr. K all day! I wish I lived closer to Florida so that I could go see him as a doctor ❤
OMG Dr. Smith new what CRPS is and had worked with Dr. Kirkpatrick.... WOW, so JHAC employees knew the correct diagnosis.
On replay. This first doctor should be an expert for the Boy in the Box trial.
Tim was in the right. That boy is going to end up in prison someday for really hurting someone with his violent tendencies
@ShopharTemple no human beings should be treated the way that boy was No Matter how Disruptive he was or misbehaving That is not right on any level from anyone and I hope the Mom gets what. She has coming for her Action The Father might have been the Main player. But she knew what he was doing and nothing to stop it much Less Report it.
@@brianmalone5006 he wasn't even treated that bad. You want to cry about undeserved abuse, check out the Shanda Vander Ark trial from Michigan a couple months ago. That is abuse
This is this hospital’ s modus operandi: obnoxious attitude and cocky. Even-the MOB LAWYERS display that. Bullies
💯%.
They operate on facts over emotions.
@@Estimator00 WRONG Like the mob, they follow orders from the 5 billion in fruad fines pharma cartel! Delivering us the leading cause of Death, i.e. "Pharma "medicine"! [fact!] Look up the Johns Hopkins [low-ball] iatrogenic study then the well cited book by Dr. Null, Death by Medicine, documenting pharma "medicine" kills over 2000 each & every day! Look it up, you don't have to stay ignorant!
@@Estimator00 😆. Cute
@@leticiaarbore2979 glad you like it
defense continuing to not let anyone speak just proves this family's case even more. they object so much and stall so much it doesnt make them look good at all.
I imagine the insurance company will sue the hospital because they charged for CRPS when they were saying maya didn't have it
doctors and hospitals code things for the benefit of the insurance company. in this case they probably began with "to rule out pathology" which could include CRPS
I agree and the in some points they make is like they're still trying to say she doesn't have it. Which is confusing, idk where they're going with it but that's what my conclusion is with how they question the witnesses
I just watched the documentary, i really wish the jury could see it...wow, just wow.
here is an idea judge let the plaintiff present the case and then let the defense defend the case when it is their turn and stop trying to prevent the jury from hearing everything
Charlie Brown and the Judge have similar hair styles😂
Yeh I know it so irrelevant but yea I wish he’s just shave off that patch
I give myself IV when I'm sick! I have a port and have to administer antibiotics when needed per Dr. Attorneys trying to play Dr have no idea what the protocol is!
I know it’s his job but Hunter is VERY rude, sarcastic, and argumentative!! He’d get more bees with honey!
I get more bees with this salt blaster i have. It's amazing. Like a nerf that blasts salt. Literally knocks them out of the air.
i think yhe hospital fails to recognize that just because they recommend a certain treatment or therapy does not mean someone HAS TO DO IT, it is their choice to or not. Also I feel the hospital had zero rights to be subpoenaing every doctor she did see after she was out of the hospital
they literally have it in their policy they are allowed to reject recommended treatments and even stays.
Maya Honey, We Pray for an Hedge of Protection Over You … May Yahweh Bless And Keep You! We Support You and Love You!
I feel so horrible for this family. The medical system is a giant. They mistreated this family in unimaginable ways. I hope they get compensated appropriately for it. However, I can’t help but think how wrong Beata was to kill herself. It hurt her family more than it helped. Imagine if she were here. They’d have a much easier time in court and the kids would have their mother, and Jack would have his wife.
What's really really sad is that she killed herself and in doing so, the hospital let Maya go home!! It's like they got what they wanted!
If she didn’t unfortunately they would have kept Maya once these accusations are made it takes years to resolve in court I think as a mom she truly believed this was the only way to get her daughter home.
The court and the jury are not allowed to hear about Mayas treatment prior to any of this, she was on massive amounts of steroids and that caused her GI issues, poor girl was being over medicated and harmed for years and years, JHACH weaned her off all the meds in the 3 months she was inpatient. She was able to progress and walk within 6 months following. I suspect Maya has an eating disorder, it looks serious but I hope she has it under control.
side effect of keratine is GI issues. I agree.
She had GI issues before she was taking ketamine but good try though
@@paytonkierce9854 yes she did. Side effects of the drugs she was taking before k. That day there were a total of 21. The plaintiffs witnesses testified about k and gi problems. Guess you missed that
Her gi issues started way before the ketamine and other medications. It started if I remember from her testimony right after July 3rd.
Literally 7:23:30 I am livid w defense counsel 🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️ you want this doctor to respond about her interim condition without referencing the records from the interim!
On The Day Of Judgement…Ms Maya, These Evil Unrighteousness People will Pay for Their Evil Deeds They Did unto You! Praise Yahweh!
Love that older Dr experience enthusiasm knowledge REAL
"you're aware the maya lived her life? Boom. Got you. Then she doesn't have ptsd"
Got em. Good job, defence. 🙄🙄🙄
They are trying to discredit Dr Kirkpatrick but honestly, I really like him. He is very passionate and clearly very knowledgeable. I have no problems trusting his opinion.
We have already had another doc talk about CRPS and ketamine to back up the treatment he gave her. And teachers and the family testified Maya was better after and with the ketamine treatment.
@@bobman929 i know but they need to reinforce that to the jury. I think they are now over that as they canned other witnesses.
@@stef1986100 sorry my comment was ment to say that those others support Kirkpatrick.
Am I missing something w/regard to Anderson? Is he not familiar enough w/case, nervous, disorganized? I hope 2not sound judgemental bc it’s not my intention; I’m just concerned for the Kowalski’s.
Am I the only one here thinking the defence has a case?
Isn't Kirkpatrick the doctor that kept saying he was too sick to testify?
All these organized crime mofias get away with ruining people's lives. What counts for them is their money........I PRAY THIS FAMILY WINS!!
and I am happy to be here
The defence is clearly being argumentive with dr kirkpatrick, where is the objection to these outburts? Frustrating
If Anderson wants sympathy from the jury for the plaintiffs, he should act like he cares when his witnesses are on the stand. The shuffling of papers and not paying attention to Dr is annoying!!
What I truly hate are his attempts at humour, like today : “So Jack’s not out hitting the bar scene” etc. It is both inappropriate and takes away from the seriousness of this case and the topic at hand.
Anderson’s lack of preparedness and professionalism is concerning. I hope he doesn’t cause the Kowalskis to lose this trial. Imho, his co-counsel should be lead attorney instead because he is much more affable, is able to swiftly rephrase questions that have been objected to and sustained, and places his focus on the witness testifying.
@@sngray11 Definitely.
Judge Judy yells when people shuffle papers
I've watched a hundred trials and I've never seen anyone shuffle papers and stammer and stutter and lose track of where they are in the middle of asking a question as much as Mr.Anderson. It's so annoying. I'm just glad it didn't cost them the trial.
I can't believe those a-hole doctors at JH used to call her "ketamine girl." JH hospital absolutely discriminated against the mother because she was Polish and had an accent.
That’s awful. Haven’t seen that part yet I don’t care what Mayas issue don’t treat any patient that way never mind a child.
I think they are threatened by a woman who is bold and knowledgeable and demands nothing less than their best for her child. I truly believe it was an ego thing of “WE and we alone will tell you what we are going to do and not going to do”.
@@gretchensims6657 and people were lazy. Mayas own guardian adledum did nothing g to stop Bedi. And even she had confirmation bias.
Why doesn't Jack leave the house with his kids? I don't understand why they haven't relocated
Answer! Because Mom's body & soul are no longer there! They will all "relocate" soon, with God Jesus in glorious Heaven! That's God's plan for you! BUT most love to be their own god & hang with Satan for all eternity!
$$$$$
The psycologist went into this a bit.
Are we really trying to say that the stay in the hospital didn't cause ptsd to the family??
It disgusts me that defense really trying to saying not only didn’t do anything wrong but did so amazing she was “healed” look his well she did after.
Why the doctor’s pay is revealed? Why defense asks that question and why Anderson sits and doesn’t do anything about it?? He should at least try to block that irrelevant question.
it's a common question.
It is a common question, and the defense is trying to say that the witnesses are advocates for the plaintiff, even though technically that is exactly what a Dr is supposed to do. But they're trying to make that argument, while there's 6 of them sitting over there for this major hospital organization, and just 2 for the plaintiff, with only 1 actually arguing. And honestly, my opinion, Mr Anderson is a horrible lawyer. I'm very surprised he pulled this off, but i won't be surprised if the defense wins in appeal for some of his pretty big mistakes, such as not turning over evidence in a timely manner
He shouldn't have told beata that if she didn't get ketamine that she'd die.
This poor family 😢
Mis-diagnosed boom and they shut him down
I understand defense attorneys are a necessary evil, but these ones are abhorrent. Disgusting defending the hospital which clearly has dirty hands by trying to make everyone else guilty for their actions and inactions that hurt that poor child.
Dr Kirkpatrick was really trying to milk that clock for his hourly. 😂😂😂
Medical professional here, 20 years oncology.. This hospital saved this young lady's life. I know it's not the popular opinion. If she had been released to Mom, she would most likely be dead today. Hard wrap one's mind around that, but it happens. Thank God for people who stand their ground, despite popular 'opinion'.
I agree, it’s baffles me that people aren’t seeing this!
100%
Let's pretend that they did "save her life" they did it in the most unprofessional, inhumane, disrespectful, unkind, abusive way.
No one has died from a ketamine coma.
Leave dr Kirkpatrick alone he's a good doctor 😢
I got a rather sketchy feeling about Beata having recorded her visit with Dr Kirkpatrick. Why in the world would she have felt the need to do that, so early in the case? What was she trying to prove, and to whom?
Judge shouldn’t be asking the jury leading questions
Why do they keep bringing back the family to testify again and again?
Watching the netflix documentary now
I bawled for about an hour after I watched it. Warning. 😢
@@jjsmama401same. So very sad
" very one sided ?? You haven't even heard the defense, witnesses or experts yet, Its very very sad, I hope you , keep an open mind & pretend your a juror, write notes ECT .
Remember if you have already made your decision " you would not make a fair juror, think 🤔 about that, it's scary to think that these 6 ppl haven't seen ppl magazine and the documentary, but I am putting my trust in them.
The documentary was probably the most moving I've ever seen. It tore my heart out for this sweet family. Justice for Maya and her precious family ❤❤❤
@@lauracherebullock7288Nobody in my family has a clue about this case or documentary
unfortunately i believe that crps totally exists however i am 1000% think her mother made this whole family a total wreck. everyone has to see that when the mother was not there anymore in a most cowardly act, maya actually got better!
Yeah. I saw she was using a diaper and couldn’t walk when she arrived at the hospital. After getting off the mother’s “treatments,” she was able to regain function in her legs through physical therapy.
There's footage of her swimming, doing activities prior to being isolated in hospital, she had a relapse. And she didn't need to be in hospital as long as she was, she could have gone home days after. She would have gotten better at home, like she has done many times. She still has relapses, she isn't cured.
she unfortunately will never be cured because her mother destroyed her
The hospital, the judicial system thanks to that Beaty hag, wrecked this family. If they had just let Maya go home NONE of this would have happened. The family was managing better before that witch got her evil hands in this case.
She was majorly depressed and thought her daughter was going to die. She thought it she killed herself it would save her daughter. She did the most brave thing. Dying for your child.
what time is the trial back on im in England ?
Kirkpatrick seems like a nice guy but is this the kind of doctor that you want giving you heavy duty drugs?
Ketamine has less negative effects than Xanax or oxicontin. And is 99% less addictive, as it comes to physical withdrawl anyway. There are more people who get addicted to Marijuana than ketamine, and Marijuana isn't addictive at all either. Haha.
If these nurses come near you run for your life 🏃♀️ 💉
They should have been fired by now
The Judge is currently questioning all of his life choices
🤔
I question & wonder why no one has objected to that rat's nest on the judge's noggin?
I am brand new to watching court stuff whos on the left? The family attorney's or the hospital???? Whos the ones trying to enter all those paperwork
I'm thinking it's the family attorney's
@terri Lynn, agree 100% The AMA owns docs and nurses in this country, Heaven forbid they stray from their lane!
Dr just answer the questions stop waffling
Such is the way of a con-artist…
Am I the only one who feels Dr.K is selling his expensive treatment? Quick diagnosis of such a complex and rare illness. No concern for what multiple other docs said. Reinforcing mom’s diagnosis of her child. Feels misleading and dangerous to me. Especially since Maya walks and thrives today (without ketamine and after JH stay).
Didn't that other little girl die?
I really don’t think this is the case at all. Ketamine treatment has now been FDA approved for CRPS and has helped and saved many CRPS pts.
@@ldolan4051I don’t think her passing was due to the ketamine. I think she self unalived due to CRPS pain/symptoms.
Also I would add, although maya was not a part of his study/research I think his interest in the outcome of patients with CRPS and use/benefit of K would outweigh his need or want for monetary gain from the treatments and subsequent visits. A lot of time researcher are far more interested and passionate about their study than quick cash. If he believed maya didn’t actually suffer from CRPS and just made a “quick diagnosis” it would be far less valuable for data collection.
He put the bullets in Beata's gun when he told her, while Maya was in the hospital that without ketamine Maya would have a heart attack and die. No wonder she was frantic. Dr. K carries a great deal of responsibility for the death for this poor unstable mother who believed in him
Attorneys just love to try to catch physicians with their words
I happy to you
I'm really annoyed with the Attorneys from JHACH, as if someone who is wheelchair bound could jump out from one day to another just because of a Ketamine coma and Booster? Get a grip!! Always the same.. 'After the Ketamine treatment, she was still in a wheelchair, correct?'
Dr.K is incredible 😊’
I’m confused. Dr. Kirkpatrick is clearly an expert…why didn’t he intervene and school Sally and the other idiots?? With his expertise, couldn’t he have prevented this whole mess? He seems like he cares a ton…why didn’t he persist until they finally “got it”?
He tried. Sally Smith ignored him and did not present his diagnosis and opinion to the Judge in the DCF case. She only provided the narrative that the mother and Maya were lying.
Female defense attorney sounds like a child. " but judgeeeee!" Wah wah wah, objection
Dr Kirkpatrick looks like the Gringotts Bank Goblin from Harry Potter
Could someone explain why there is a time limit for each side?
Basically so the trial doesn’t last for eternity.
The prosecution starts, by making the case for their claim. They explain what they believe the evidence will show the jury, in their opening statements. The defense is also allowed an opening statement on what they believe the evidence will show. The prosecuting counsel then begins by calling witnesses, to make their case. And they are to have all of their witnesses and evidences ready, labeled and organized for the claim they are making, and they give an estimate to the judge about how long it will take for them to question their witnesses and produce the evidences before the jury. Their estimated time does not count the defenses cross examinations of their witnesses. After prosecution rests their case, as in calls all their witnesses, and produce all of their evidence, then the defense begins their defense case, where they gather all their witnesses and evidences, same as prosecution did, and give an estimate to the judge to how much time they believe it will take for them to make their case for defense, sometimes there's a counter suit, which makes it a bit more complex. Really, it just flips the sides after the first case rests. But that is not the case here. So the judge takes their estimates, usually adds a bit of time, for scheduling. Because judges are actually very busy, he may have another trial scheduled shortly after this one, or other obligations. Same with the lawyers. And then they also give the jurors the time estimate, because they have to take the time off of work and away from family, and they actually take that very seriously into consideration. This is very important in civil cases as this, as it's not a priority to the judge, compared to actual criminal trials where somebody's life and freedom is on the line.
Mr Hunter is doing my head in !
The mother altered a prescrition, assuming that it was her who put " terminal illnees" on the script! Unbelievable. Don't people think that was part of her fear? Being found out? It is a felony with prison time. Not only that, she would lose her nursing license. That is serious. It goes to her state of mind and manipulation of the medical community. If people overlook that, there is something wrong with their judgment.
Illness?
Low IQ moment
Source?
Except the diagnosis was right
@@spalanki352pharmacist
Defense had it right; what a long day.
Has the good doc' ever really testified? He's not board certified(?), didn't bring his own 'homework' and doesn't know how to answer a question w/o going off on tangents, narratives it seems. But, in his favor, if the prosecuting attorney could articulate a concise question might help, but then again....what a long day.
The longer he talks th more $ he makes.
He’s not a designated expert witness 🤣 which means he doesn’t usually go to court proceedings let alone trials. He is most certainly not being paid nearly as much as a expert witness would. He was told his records were already in evidence which means he was not told by either defense or plaintiff to bring records. Which are usually not allowed anyways if they are not in evidence unless there is an exception to use it to refresh recollection.
@@Jodidub forty-eight grand isn't pocket change. Excuses are lame
@therealz360z7 were you listening? Start with his organizational skills and go from there...
@therealz360z7 Board certified "medicine" is the leading cause Death in the USA! [Fact!] see the Johns Hopkins [low-ball] iatrogenic study & the well cited book by Dr. Null, Death by Medicine, claiming Board certified "medicine" kills 800,000 a year or over 2000, a day!
But who wants to know that uncomfortable fact? RIGHT?
@therealz360z7So you would take the risk with him?
As usual somebody with bid money makes the poor and suffering go through it!
Dr. Kirkpatrick did a phenomenal job explaining everything while he was on the stand. I can’t believe that the defense attorney was being such a jerk! I really hope that Maya and her family receive the justice that they deserve. 🫶🏽
Are they done for the day 😊
PCA not safe because it will fall asleep. It limits dose. If push button and dose not due it will not dispense
Dr Kirkpatrick is probably not used to being told to shut up lol
I think that Bonnie rice is actress. She doesn't fool me she's acting nice😮
I'm so bored during the defense's cross of Kirkpatrick
the strategy of the defence cross-examination of the anaesthetist would appear to be aural anaesthesia of the jury, by making the q&a as irrelevantly peripheral and long-winded as possible, so as to make them fall asleep. It worked on me.
😂😂
The defense cross is do boring and didn't prove anything at didn't already know
That district attorney are very hateful a specially that old lady in the district attorney
Those are defense attorneys for the hospital, not district attorneys
opps sorry @@ShopharTemple
@@kathrynmcnamara416 no problem.
Why does this judge look so bored?
I like Dr Kirkpatrick