The timeline was fucked on the highway to hell when they showed Minerva McGonagall alive in 1927 and then showed her alive in a flashback from the 1910s when she wasn't born until 1934
@@gamerstheater1187 no it wasnt her mother. the screenplay credits made sure to let us know it was Minerva McGonagall. In the books, umbride asked mcgonagall how long she has been teaching at hogwarts. She said it would be 39 years that december. Therefore 1995-39= 1956 This literally means she started working at hogwarts in 1956, therefore, even if her birthdate which is believed to be 1934-1935 by most fans wasnt this, she still couldnt be teaching in 1927 if she joined hogwarts in 1956. Also, she was taught by dumbledore. Therefore, considering dumbledore was born in 1881, and became a teacher at hogwarts in the 1920s. He was said to have started teaching transfiguration in 1927. So technically, minerva being taught transfiguration by him means she still couldnt have been in the role we see her in that memory which was around 1910 because dumbledore was teaching at hogwarts before her. Also, even if we claimed her birth did make sense to be before the accepted date, it still doesnt make sense since she was taught by dumbledore so minimum 1927 is her date of finishing hogwarts and she worked at the ministry for 2 years before joining hogwarts so it is impossible for her to work at hogwarts in 1927 considering she didnt graduate and start working there straight away. It is a mistake in the timeline that cant be denied.
@@tom-nb7dk also, she was hired by dumbledore which makes sense because he became headmaster after being transfiguration teacher so mcgonagall filled that empty space. Dumbledore became headmaster about 30 years after becoming transfiguration teacher which makes total sense because it would land on 1957. We already accept based on mcgonagall's words to umbridge that she was at hogwarts around 1956 but maybe she meant the next december which would land bang on 1957. It also makes sense because she had said before that she didnt teach tom riddle which wouldnt make sense if she was teaching at hogwarts at the time of that flashback anyway.
Imagine if they used sniper rifles instead of killing curses. Voldemort is giving a speech next thing his head goes flying of his shoulders. Tango down.
Correct, he made a mistake. In the first HP movie it's mentioned that Hogwarts was founded 1000 years ago, so I think he meant to say 990 AD not 990 BC
That should be 990 CE not BCE. BCE is "Before Common Era" so that would be the same as BC so 990 years before the start of the common era or year 1 by the Julian calander.
Just wanna state that rowena never had cunning as cunning was one of the traits owed to slytherin and as a slytherin myself i thought it important to say
Which "Harry Potter" movie is your favorite? Let us know why!
Coming up to the 20th anniversary of the release of Philosopher’s Stone. Still my favourite.
Prisoner of Azkaban!
Order of the Phoenix
order of the phoenix, but ironically it’s my least favorite book
The goblet of fire 🔥 because of the return of the dark lord
"Let's go to the start" I felt that
yes
The timeline was fucked on the highway to hell when they showed Minerva McGonagall alive in 1927 and then showed her alive in a flashback from the 1910s when she wasn't born until 1934
maybe it's her mother
@@gamerstheater1187 no it wasnt her mother. the screenplay credits made sure to let us know it was Minerva McGonagall. In the books, umbride asked mcgonagall how long she has been teaching at hogwarts. She said it would be 39 years that december. Therefore 1995-39= 1956
This literally means she started working at hogwarts in 1956, therefore, even if her birthdate which is believed to be 1934-1935 by most fans wasnt this, she still couldnt be teaching in 1927 if she joined hogwarts in 1956.
Also, she was taught by dumbledore. Therefore, considering dumbledore was born in 1881, and became a teacher at hogwarts in the 1920s. He was said to have started teaching transfiguration in 1927. So technically, minerva being taught transfiguration by him means she still couldnt have been in the role we see her in that memory which was around 1910 because dumbledore was teaching at hogwarts before her. Also, even if we claimed her birth did make sense to be before the accepted date, it still doesnt make sense since she was taught by dumbledore so minimum 1927 is her date of finishing hogwarts and she worked at the ministry for 2 years before joining hogwarts so it is impossible for her to work at hogwarts in 1927 considering she didnt graduate and start working there straight away.
It is a mistake in the timeline that cant be denied.
@@tom-nb7dk also, she was hired by dumbledore which makes sense because he became headmaster after being transfiguration teacher so mcgonagall filled that empty space. Dumbledore became headmaster about 30 years after becoming transfiguration teacher which makes total sense because it would land on 1957.
We already accept based on mcgonagall's words to umbridge that she was at hogwarts around 1956 but maybe she meant the next december which would land bang on 1957.
It also makes sense because she had said before that she didnt teach tom riddle which wouldnt make sense if she was teaching at hogwarts at the time of that flashback anyway.
Day 11 of petitioning for an “8 mile” pitch meeting again.
( ╹▽╹ )
The History of The Deathly Hallows is my Favourite part of Wizarding History!
Imagine if they used sniper rifles instead of killing curses. Voldemort is giving a speech next thing his head goes flying of his shoulders.
Tango down.
he wouldnt die though. Horcruxes.
This timeline is so fun
My favorite part is when Gandalf has a duel with Gollum.
🤣😂😂😂
Mine is when the Borg captured Capt.Picard!
Lol 😂
dont forget when darth vader andmike wizouski stopped them both by sending them into the world of cars
I confuse easily, so this will come in handy. Saved to Watch Later. Thanks Reen Scrant!
"990 BCE"?? Hogwarts isn't THAT old!
More proof that this channel is worthless but for Ryan.
Correct, he made a mistake. In the first HP movie it's mentioned that Hogwarts was founded 1000 years ago, so I think he meant to say 990 AD not 990 BC
Should be 990 CE (AD) not BCE (BC)
i want a young dumbledore trilogy or movie
Dumbledore was like Grandpapa to me! Until he yelled calmly!
- 12 yo me said, Calmly.
There once was a boy named Harry, destined to be a star...
His parents were killed by Voldemort.....
@@kerlindakhongsit9233 who gave him a lightning scar
he meets ron and hermione
That should be 990 CE not BCE. BCE is "Before Common Era" so that would be the same as BC so 990 years before the start of the common era or year 1 by the Julian calander.
Yeah that one caught me off guard.
This is the only Harry Potter video where the narrator is actually interesting
Family guy pitch meeting
3:43 Harry never cared 😂😂
Dumbledore and Grindelwald are best friends. NOT boyfriends.
No matter what Rowling says. -_-
Imagine it was Warner bros who wanted it for Promo😂
Ravenclaw has an EAGLE for its crest.
Ravenclaw did not have cunning ravenclaw was with beyond measure is man's greatest treasure
Ravenclaw had wit not cunning, cunning is a Slytherin trait
Harry POTTAH?!?
Rest In Heaven Hagrid 💫
I was about to make fun of the fact that Griffendore had a metal sword in 990 BCE, but nevermind
have i just not watched harry potter or is a lot of this knowledge from the cursed child?
A lot of it is in the books especially Half Blood Prince. The Grindwald stuff is from the Fantastic series.
0:52 CE (or AD), not BCE
I am 100% sure that there Gindlewale was around a long time before Tom Riddle
You forgot to include the best one in the series…The Cursed One…I mean Child.
Just wanna state that rowena never had cunning as cunning was one of the traits owed to slytherin and as a slytherin myself i thought it important to say
Pretty sure you meant to say 990 AD not BCE
Haaaary Potttter
Hey could you do a star wars video
Best friend. Not Boyfriend. Dumbledore isn’t gay
Is all this on the wikia? :-)
Hm. Actually wouldn't the tale of the Brothers on the Bridge predate the founding of Hogwarts?
Dont forget the part where dumbledore is a gay trans apache helicopter intergalactic alien pirate
Waaaaaay too much back and forth in time.
It's 'BC' not 'bce'. Stop trying to rewrite history. It's rude
Magic and racism
Yet here you are
Oh
12th
Ello
Harry Potter.
❤️❤️❤️
🔥🔥🔥
Mexican
First
First
Lol no
First