Pretty sure you also need everyone to be alive in order for Josh to get the best ending cutscene? I did that on my playthrough but killed everyone else to be faster, but that ending didn't pop-up after the credits.
Thanks for this! Gonna try to get Josh's ending because I don't want him to turn into a wendigo 😭 Also glad your police interview gameplay has Emily and Matt care for each other. They're the couple whose relationship I want to save most!
I knew this ending existed, but I wasn't sure how to get it. I just so happened to follow the instructions at the start of the video on my first playthrough, but Josh turned into a wendigo. I originally thought they replaced that ending with this one you have shown in the video, but perhaps this ending only happens if everyone else lives, because in my playthrough, Chirs died to Hannah after I failed the second aiming quick time event that comes after Jack dies, and Sam died after I failed the second "DON'T MOVE" event.
Luckily the remake has epidode selection after you finish the game. So you may be able to go back and change those events without having to start a new playthrough if you choose. I had heard you needed to find all clues to get it. I only got 90 percent, but everyone lived so that may be why I got it. You at least need the choice and finding the diary noted in this vid as well.
@@yuppersmeer6080 i mean if any characters alive they go to the mines. Everyone needs to be alive because if anyone dies (Not Jack, obviously.) Josh is racked with guilt and succumbs to the curse.
Everyone has to be alive to get this ending because if he sees any of his friends bodies hanging his guilt is to much and he gets karma for intentionally killing his friends so he still becomes a wendigo.
Wouldn’t he have had to eaten the flesh of the dead to become a Wendigo? That’s the part I never got with that ending. Although the whole thing is weird anyway. Kissing someone could see you consuming some of their dna in the process, so who knows how it determines what counts for turning into a Wendigo.
@@mandrews6282 Yes but at the beginning, the wendigo spirit will hunt your soul and try to get in your head. It will try to make you feel horrible, guilty, etc... Then you will become hungry and it will influence you to eat human flesh if there is.
There seems to be more to it than that. I get to this point, and choose "they hurt me", but "i'm so sorry" isn't given as an option. Clearly something else decides whether or not you can choose it. But no one seems to know what that is.
i think i know how to get the josh ending: so if u choose "they hurt me" dr hill would say that it wasnt true. so if u before this, attack josh with scissors as ashley, hit him with the bat as chris. then josh would not believe it making him feel not remorseful. but if u dont attack josh with scissors as ash, or bat with chris, then select "they hurt me" and dr hill says they didnt, then josh would realize and be aware that dr hill is right then the " im so sorry" option def pop up as it make sense for him to listen to his fake therapist in the head and change his mind about his friend as he becomes remorseful.
it makes sense that having his friends attack him could possibly cause him to think more about his actions.. i'll test out to see whether or not having him punch Ashley and then having Chris hit Josh with the bat is what you need to do in order to get the "I'm so sorry" to appear.
@@ChengTeohit worked with me Where I replayed with episode menu and started at 6 where original I stabbed Josh and hit him with the bat but when I replayed I didn’t use the scissors or hit him with the bat, then I got the “I’m so sorry “ option appear
@@ChengTeoh I didn't get that option either, it said "they need to change" instead, although I wonder if it's a translation thing. InMyFaceAndLovingIt were you playing in english? also no, none of my characters died. ChengTeoh, did you hit Josh with Chris and Mike? I didn't
@cereal, I don't think it's a translation issue ... on my first run through of the game I also got the "They need to change" & "It was just a game" after saying "They hurt me" ... hmm. the only different choices I made from one game to the next was to have Chris punch Josh because he punch Ashley, then tell him to "dismiss - shut up", "angry - we can't trust you", "aggressive - you need to shut up", and then end with Chris hitting Josh with the wood.
tried with those exact same choices for the punch and still didn't get the "i'm so sorry" maybe i shouldn't stab josh with the scissors as Ashley? or maybe me not finding the documents showing Josh was mentally ill with Sam has something to do with it? really annoying :/
I did all of this!! But he still turned into a wendigo. Is it because two characters died in my playthrough? Unfortunately, I tried saving Emily and had Matt killed. Then I got Emily killed as revenge. Idk, I'll replay it anyway lol. Do you think that could've been a reason?? Update: I did it! Collected absolutely everything, and got the best ending for Josh!! I was SO excited!! :D Big thanks to @HarryNinetyFour for the amazing videos showing us how to get everything. Agh!! So awesome!!
i'm not 100% certain now. i did this while keeping everyone alive and friendly with each other. the only animosity was between Chris and Josh after the Saw inspired trap. had Chris say "shut up", "we can't trust you" & "you need to shut up" after he punched Josh for punching Ashley. then finally had Chris hit Josh with the wood. i also had Sam be captured by Josh and picked up all the Twin collectibles. it could be that one of these things contributed to Josh being remorseful and being able to say "i'm so sorry".
@@ChengTeoh I kept it light with Josh. He was mentally ill and off his meds, grieving his sisters. He was still remorseful in the end, so I'm confused about what could've caused the wendigo ending. No WAY am I gonna treat Josh that badly - especially because I think the whole crew actually deserved it. It only went badly because of the wendigos - but other than that, if the wendigos didn't exist, they all would've just probably left the cabin and cut contact with Josh. He was blamed for things he didn't do and was punished way too severely. Also, I may be biased because it's Rami Malek.. T^T
@@robopnkwell everyone hates emily i think so its instictual to have her get killed😅 I wonder if rami malek re shot some new scenes or this was stock footage.
it is important to find the sisters clues, josh will remember hannah seeing her tattoo, the dialogue itself doesnt impact it, if you dont find the clues, the wendigo(hannah) will kill josh
@@Shlongthorpe Hi. Im a very big until dawn and dbd fan and a collab would be like a dream come true. But isnt an until dawn 2 confirmed tho? I think that it has nothing to do with the entity but its just a hint to a sequel (i hope not, a sequel is not needed in my opinion)
@maatak2155 I don't fully know tbf. I would prefer a collab rather than a sequal too but I'm not fully in tbe loop with anything to do with these horror games apart from when I want to play them
I can say I am, (and not) surprised that the Horror and terror Sam experienced that night on the mountain with her friends against supernatural cannibalistic Wendigos. Would catch the Entity's interest, and it seems to have deemed her a suitable candidate for its "game" And the Entity is most likely going to take Hannah as well, betrayed by the people she called her friends and suffered for years in Torment as a Wendigo, as a result of embarrassing prank gone wrong. She as a Wendigo killer for the Entity's game would just be too good for the Entity to pass up on all that tormented emotion.
I see a lot of people saying they followed these steps but are unable to get the ending anyway. While I haven't played the remake yet myself, I don't see anyone mentioning the scene where you have to choose between Ashley and Josh when you play as Chris. Most playthroughs I have watched always choose to save Ashley. Maybe you should pick Josh to live instead, because I'm pretty sure he mentions your choice when Mike and Chris escort him to the shed, so the game definitely remembers the choice. If you feel bad about letting Ashley die in the first trap, then remember you can always choose to sacrifice yourself for her later.
I reach those dialogue choices, all they give me after i say "they hurt me" is "they need to change" or "it was just a game". They give me no option for josh to show remorse. Clearly something else affects whether or not you get the "I'm so sorry" option. And no, I'm not the only one. So no, its not that simple. Everyone is still alive, no animals died, so idk what went wrong. No one seems to have a clear answer.
So I’ve had everyone be alive with no “I’m sorry” option, I’ve had people die and got the “I’m sorry” option, collected Hannah’s diary and Josh still turned into a wendigo… what am I missing?
Glad that this was helpful. If you need a guide on how to get Jessica to strip down to her underwear I've got you covered as well - ruclips.net/video/PxIuUmYhD_o/видео.html
This guide is definitely not accurate. It's not even possible to say "I am so sorry" unless some other specific things are done much earlier in the game. And yes, I did have everyone alive at this point. I think some of the choices during the previous Dr. Hill sessions matter.
@@Kuzashiro Dead By Daylight's Malevolent God, The Entity, is a eldritch being that takes killers and survivors into their world to play games of life and death, I think the company that made Until Dawn recently collaborated with thme to make a DBD Spin-off, so people are thinking Sam's been marked by The Entity, something that as far as I know never happens, The Entity kidnaps it's subjects through a fog instead.
I have just completed my first playthrough. Kept everyone alive, but messed up the Josh one (now i know tho :) ).. I wander, would you still get this ending if Sam didn't survive?
is really until dawn in the place of dead by daylight? ı mean ı know the same guys did the frank stone game but ı dont think the arm sign isnt about that
This seems notably worse than original in every single way. The sound design, Sam’s character design, the 3rd person camera, the new UI, even the graphics. Unless it’s just the video, this looks like crap
![Linda Shot Augustine ENDING in The Casting of Frank Stone [ Nothing Personal - Dead by Deadlight ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/a3MJhXZw62k/mqdefault.jpg)
![Natanael Cano - Amor Eterno [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EO4prCs6WpM/mqdefault.jpg)
Pretty sure you also need everyone to be alive in order for Josh to get the best ending cutscene? I did that on my playthrough but killed everyone else to be faster, but that ending didn't pop-up after the credits.
At least 1 person must be alive to tell the police to go down the mines yeo
So the rumored about a sequal in the works seems more plausible after seeing the ending
Thanks for this! Gonna try to get Josh's ending because I don't want him to turn into a wendigo 😭 Also glad your police interview gameplay has Emily and Matt care for each other. They're the couple whose relationship I want to save most!
I knew this ending existed, but I wasn't sure how to get it. I just so happened to follow the instructions at the start of the video on my first playthrough, but Josh turned into a wendigo. I originally thought they replaced that ending with this one you have shown in the video, but perhaps this ending only happens if everyone else lives, because in my playthrough, Chirs died to Hannah after I failed the second aiming quick time event that comes after Jack dies, and Sam died after I failed the second "DON'T MOVE" event.
Sam definitely needs to be alive to tell the investigators to go to the mines asap, but I wonder if you need the others to be alive too
Luckily the remake has epidode selection after you finish the game. So you may be able to go back and change those events without having to start a new playthrough if you choose.
I had heard you needed to find all clues to get it. I only got 90 percent, but everyone lived so that may be why I got it. You at least need the choice and finding the diary noted in this vid as well.
@@mandrews6282 I found the diary, but Josh still turned into a wendigo.
@@yuppersmeer6080 i mean if any characters alive they go to the mines. Everyone needs to be alive because if anyone dies (Not Jack, obviously.) Josh is racked with guilt and succumbs to the curse.
Everyone has to be alive to get this ending because if he sees any of his friends bodies hanging his guilt is to much and he gets karma for intentionally killing his friends so he still becomes a wendigo.
Wouldn’t he have had to eaten the flesh of the dead to become a Wendigo? That’s the part I never got with that ending. Although the whole thing is weird anyway. Kissing someone could see you consuming some of their dna in the process, so who knows how it determines what counts for turning into a Wendigo.
@@mandrews6282 Yes but at the beginning, the wendigo spirit will hunt your soul and try to get in your head. It will try to make you feel horrible, guilty, etc... Then you will become hungry and it will influence you to eat human flesh if there is.
There seems to be more to it than that. I get to this point, and choose "they hurt me", but "i'm so sorry" isn't given as an option. Clearly something else decides whether or not you can choose it. But no one seems to know what that is.
i think i know how to get the josh ending: so if u choose "they hurt me" dr hill would say that it wasnt true. so if u before this, attack josh with scissors as ashley, hit him with the bat as chris. then josh would not believe it making him feel not remorseful. but if u dont attack josh with scissors as ash, or bat with chris, then select "they hurt me" and dr hill says they didnt, then josh would realize and be aware that dr hill is right then the " im so sorry" option def pop up as it make sense for him to listen to his fake therapist in the head and change his mind about his friend as he becomes remorseful.
it makes sense that having his friends attack him could possibly cause him to think more about his actions.. i'll test out to see whether or not having him punch Ashley and then having Chris hit Josh with the bat is what you need to do in order to get the "I'm so sorry" to appear.
@@ChengTeohit worked with me Where I replayed with episode menu and started at 6 where original I stabbed Josh and hit him with the bat but when I replayed I didn’t use the scissors or hit him with the bat, then I got the “I’m so sorry “ option appear
@@ChengTeohI tested it, I did not stab Josh or hit him with the bat as Chris, I got the "I'm so sorry" option. So it might play a part in it.
I got the special ending even though I chose "I didn't hurt anyone."
I think only the "I'm so sorry" matters.
everyones alive but i didnt even get the therapy scene
My Dr. Hill is covered in blood and wont let me say sorry. IDK what i did wrong
Haven't played myself, but is everyone else still alive? Pretty sure people are getting different results if some of the others are dead
@@Klearith everyone is alive, i kill 0 animals, i picked up as much collectibles as possible.
@@PaulGreyrat only other thing I read is about the decision made with the punch
@PaulGreyrat You are afraid of zombies
I didn't get the "I'm so sorry" response, just "They need to change" and "It was just a game". Did I mess up an earlier interaction?
did you by any chance have a character die?
@@ChengTeoh I didn't get that option either, it said "they need to change" instead, although I wonder if it's a translation thing. InMyFaceAndLovingIt were you playing in english?
also no, none of my characters died.
ChengTeoh, did you hit Josh with Chris and Mike? I didn't
@cereal, I don't think it's a translation issue ... on my first run through of the game I also got the "They need to change" & "It was just a game" after saying "They hurt me" ... hmm. the only different choices I made from one game to the next was to have Chris punch Josh because he punch Ashley, then tell him to "dismiss - shut up", "angry - we can't trust you", "aggressive - you need to shut up", and then end with Chris hitting Josh with the wood.
@@ChengTeoh ah that's great to know! and I imagined it had something to do with the punch, I'll try that!
tried with those exact same choices for the punch and still didn't get the "i'm so sorry"
maybe i shouldn't stab josh with the scissors as Ashley? or maybe me not finding the documents showing Josh was mentally ill with Sam has something to do with it? really annoying :/
Omg bro thanks you a real one
Feel free to drop by anytime if you need a guide.
Such a sympathetic, sad character
imagine sneezing at 13:15
Not only i imagined it, but i did sneezed back in original game and killed poor Sam 🤣
I did all of these in my first playthrough of the remake and Josh still turned into a wendigo
My wish has come true!🙏😇
Yes!! This is amazing! Josh is well and not eating that snack.
I did all of this!! But he still turned into a wendigo. Is it because two characters died in my playthrough? Unfortunately, I tried saving Emily and had Matt killed. Then I got Emily killed as revenge. Idk, I'll replay it anyway lol. Do you think that could've been a reason??
Update: I did it! Collected absolutely everything, and got the best ending for Josh!! I was SO excited!! :D Big thanks to @HarryNinetyFour for the amazing videos showing us how to get everything. Agh!! So awesome!!
i'm not 100% certain now. i did this while keeping everyone alive and friendly with each other. the only animosity was between Chris and Josh after the Saw inspired trap. had Chris say "shut up", "we can't trust you" & "you need to shut up" after he punched Josh for punching Ashley. then finally had Chris hit Josh with the wood. i also had Sam be captured by Josh and picked up all the Twin collectibles. it could be that one of these things contributed to Josh being remorseful and being able to say "i'm so sorry".
@@ChengTeoh I kept it light with Josh. He was mentally ill and off his meds, grieving his sisters. He was still remorseful in the end, so I'm confused about what could've caused the wendigo ending. No WAY am I gonna treat Josh that badly - especially because I think the whole crew actually deserved it. It only went badly because of the wendigos - but other than that, if the wendigos didn't exist, they all would've just probably left the cabin and cut contact with Josh. He was blamed for things he didn't do and was punished way too severely. Also, I may be biased because it's Rami Malek.. T^T
@@robopnkwell everyone hates emily i think so its instictual to have her get killed😅
I wonder if rami malek re shot some new scenes or this was stock footage.
Thank you I've been trying to get this ending
Please tell me if this guide worked out... I've been getting messages that some people didn't get the "I'm so sorry" prompt. Any info would help out.
I'll let you know I'm just getting all the mystery man collectibles @ChengTeoh
@ChengTeoh i found out being honest and also not stabbing or hitting Josh as Chris worked
it is important to find the sisters clues, josh will remember hannah seeing her tattoo, the dialogue itself doesnt impact it, if you dont find the clues, the wendigo(hannah) will kill josh
What does the Sam scene means marked by the entity?
It's a possible hint to Sam being brought into Dead By Daylight
@@Shlongthorpe oh being brought by that entity in day by deadlight. Thanks for clarifying
@eshleon4609 no problem man
@@Shlongthorpe Hi. Im a very big until dawn and dbd fan and a collab would be like a dream come true. But isnt an until dawn 2 confirmed tho? I think that it has nothing to do with the entity but its just a hint to a sequel (i hope not, a sequel is not needed in my opinion)
@maatak2155 I don't fully know tbf. I would prefer a collab rather than a sequal too but I'm not fully in tbe loop with anything to do with these horror games apart from when I want to play them
I can say I am, (and not) surprised that the Horror and terror Sam experienced that night on the mountain with her friends against supernatural cannibalistic Wendigos. Would catch the Entity's interest, and it seems to have deemed her a suitable candidate for its "game"
And the Entity is most likely going to take Hannah as well, betrayed by the people she called her friends and suffered for years in Torment as a Wendigo, as a result of embarrassing prank gone wrong. She as a Wendigo killer for the Entity's game would just be too good for the Entity to pass up on all that tormented emotion.
I see a lot of people saying they followed these steps but are unable to get the ending anyway. While I haven't played the remake yet myself, I don't see anyone mentioning the scene where you have to choose between Ashley and Josh when you play as Chris. Most playthroughs I have watched always choose to save Ashley. Maybe you should pick Josh to live instead, because I'm pretty sure he mentions your choice when Mike and Chris escort him to the shed, so the game definitely remembers the choice. If you feel bad about letting Ashley die in the first trap, then remember you can always choose to sacrifice yourself for her later.
I reach those dialogue choices, all they give me after i say "they hurt me" is "they need to change" or "it was just a game". They give me no option for josh to show remorse. Clearly something else affects whether or not you get the "I'm so sorry" option. And no, I'm not the only one. So no, its not that simple. Everyone is still alive, no animals died, so idk what went wrong. No one seems to have a clear answer.
So I’ve had everyone be alive with no “I’m sorry” option, I’ve had people die and got the “I’m sorry” option, collected Hannah’s diary and Josh still turned into a wendigo… what am I missing?
People not die in the mines people can die outside of them like the house fire and Emily getting shot
@@kendriccoley7053 yeah I know they can but what’s that got to do with the new Josh ending?
@@LS353 I'm saying you need to have non of the friends hanged so he won't you know turn into a wendigo blow the lodge up it works
They deadass went and gave Matt the Broccoli haircut specifically because nobody asked for it
oh ths bro I was like how do I get this
Glad that this was helpful. If you need a guide on how to get Jessica to strip down to her underwear I've got you covered as well - ruclips.net/video/PxIuUmYhD_o/видео.html
@@ChengTeohLOL WUT
Man I like how I can do theses exact same choices in the original and get the exact same result
hey, can you try choose run from the last choice before ending? i've never seen people tried it before.
This guide is definitely not accurate. It's not even possible to say "I am so sorry" unless some other specific things are done much earlier in the game. And yes, I did have everyone alive at this point. I think some of the choices during the previous Dr. Hill sessions matter.
I doubt it's the Entity, there's no trademark fog.
i'm curious who is the entity ?
@@Kuzashiro Dead By Daylight's Malevolent God, The Entity, is a eldritch being that takes killers and survivors into their world to play games of life and death, I think the company that made Until Dawn recently collaborated with thme to make a DBD Spin-off, so people are thinking Sam's been marked by The Entity, something that as far as I know never happens, The Entity kidnaps it's subjects through a fog instead.
This isn't working for me, found all twin clues too and did everything, I don't get the option to say I'm so sorry
yeah nobody's clever to save everyone as ranks
I don't think it's the entity.
I have just completed my first playthrough. Kept everyone alive, but messed up the Josh one (now i know tho :) ).. I wander, would you still get this ending if Sam didn't survive?
What did they do to the soundtrack?
What was the new sound for the wendigo
i did this and didnt get the ending.......
Whose voice says Sam at the end?
I thought it was Dr Hill
This guide is full wrong and BS!!!! The Full Therapy Session most important part doesn't mention
Do you think there will be an until dawn 2 ??
probable. it'd be smart for a company to release the sequel around the time the live action movie comes out.
@@ChengTeohwhat do u think should be innovated for this kind of game genre?
"Remake" my ass 😂
is really until dawn in the place of dead by daylight? ı mean ı know the same guys did the frank stone game but ı dont think the arm sign isnt about that
This seems notably worse than original in every single way. The sound design, Sam’s character design, the 3rd person camera, the new UI, even the graphics. Unless it’s just the video, this looks like crap