people keep bringing up the fact that italians and irish weren't considered white. but i think the far more relevant argument is the fact that the "one drop rule" is one of the main reasons for statistical democratic shift. if someone has 1 black grandparent and 3 white ones, they are statistically considered black. of course, if you always count mixed people as "non-white", the actual genetic representation of "white people" will be massively underrepresented in statistics. most african americans have some white ancestry (often through rape of slaves, but often also from times after slavery). by far most "latinos" have strong "white" ancestry, too. so, if we would count them as "partially white", the statistics would look VERY different. yes, a modern society mixes more, because luckily a lot of us don't chose their partners based on racist ideas anymore. so there are much more mixed people than ever before. so? it's fucking awesome.
Im mixed race. Why am i awesome? Because i dont have a culture or an identity? I feel alone and dont relate to anybody? Theres realy nothing great about it. Its terrible living in such a racist world and not having your own tribe. The liberal white person is the only peeople with no ingroup preference. You will be replaced because you violate the first law of nature, self preservation.
people are fucking stupid, they incorporate dumb physical analogies to their everyday life because their minds are too small to see the world any different , that's why the one drop rule exist, because people saw how one drop of some other color always ruins the white paint, people knew nothing about genetics so they said fuck it we're paint now, we racists now, fuck everybody who says we're not paint.
Yeah, the one drop rule is also extremely relevant, it's why Obama is considered the US's first black president and not the US's 44th white president, because he's absolutely half white.
Well, kind of. Most of the American Indian population in North America was wiped out by disease prior to any long term European settlement let alone conquest. This massive plague is sadly rarely talked about due to us having no record of it, but suffice to say some native populations had as much as 90% of people wiped out. So when the Europeans did decide to colonize much of the natives civilizations were pretty much on the brink of collapse and barely holding themselves together and much more land was empty then would have been otherwise. All in all, the situations aren’t exactly comperable.
Sometimes I wish people still had that childlike sense of love and kindness. The older I get the more bitter everyone seems especially over arbitrary nonsense. If only we could still want to be friends with everyone.
@@ObiJohnKenobi67 nah. I saw at first glance how you fuckers treat your own people, and how you treat grouos related to you. Western European people have raped Europe before they attacked Americas and Africa.
It's unfortunate and tragic indeed that qualities like love and kindness are called childlike while qualities like cunning, shrewd, suspicious are considered mature adult behaviour..No wonder white supremacy, racism and other evils prevail and continue to get stronger in the world..Love and kindness are not childlike qualities but rather a sensible strategy in a perverted, sick a s cruel world ruined by adult human beings...My simple solution..Get rid of human beings and the world will be a much better place..
It's racist to suggest Israel shouldn't be racist. They are the master race so they need to remain pure and receive billions in aid from other nations.
Fun fact: while in the US Italian migration was oftenly perceived as a pollution of inferiors (some even classifying them "non-whites"), in Argentina, Brazil and most of Latin America Italian immigrants were not just welcomed (except for some purists) but invited to migrate, since, according to the Latin American hyperdescent logic of miscegenation, they'd "improve the race". This is how nebulous the concept of "pure whiteness" is: for Latin America it was all Europeans, for Anglo-America it was only a certain kind of Europeans.
In Anglo-America it is moreso the descendants of the Aryans, which includes native Iranians and North Indians. Don't be fooled into thinking you are dealing with entirely dumb people when discussing genetic ancestry.
@@CesarAugustoRocabadoVillegas clearly you don't understand how the people I am talking about define White. It's not literal. Chinese people are white, but not White, get it?
My Mom was a child in Brooklyn NY during the 1950's. She grew up in a Irish Catholic family. Her Aunt fell in love with a man from a Italian Catholic family that lived a couple of blocks away. At that time a marriage between a Irish kid and a Italian kid was considered a bad thing. Mixing I guess. After they got married they were not welcome in the Irish neighborhood or the Italian neighborhood. They ended up moving to Florida to start their family. In 2022 we would think that's nuts. I hope that what we are talking about today loses traction is considered old fashioned and weird in a generation or two. (Hopefully sooner than that!)
@@iammrbeat I'm glad that you caught that. My mother also told me that they had two Catholic churches that were close to each other. One for Irish families and the other was for Italian families. My mother was discouraged from visiting the Italian church. I do not understand the argument that all change is bad and everything was better in the past. The evidence tells a different story IMO.
Oddly I don’t think religion mixing will ever be 100% okay with a lot of families. In the 40’s they even the 80’s there were grumblings. I had when I got married in the early 80’s. It’s hopefully changed, but sometimes people need to let other people just be happy.
@@victoriabaker6943 religion has less and less bearing on most people both of my grandmothers were swiss catholics and both of my grandfathers were swiss protestants. tge grandmothers essentially got kicked out of their families for marrying a protestant. today, in my generation i havent heard of a single case of anyone careing about things like this anymore. more and more people are atheist anyway
@@jurgnobs1308 yeah except that it had to do with the culture and not religion. And not many are atheist. A lot of them in europe are Christian and catholic. Even in Japan they have cultural Christian weddings at churches.
It makes sense that there is some overlap between support of Trump and this theory, given that especially in 2016, stopping or slowing down illegal (but truly all) immigration of those from hispanic and muslim countries was a top priority. A recent survey also shows that 6 in 10 Trump supporters agree with it, and if Trump didn't literally fully support it, it was a gateway to this type of ideology.
Yeah he did, wouldnt be surprised if it happened multiple times. Plenty of national candidates and tucker spouting this garbage, things are not looking pretty down here JJ.
The first time I heard about the WEF (couple/few years ago) I went on their website and clearly remember reading about their plan for “open borders” and “mass migration to blend poor countries with rich countries”. They’ve since then taken all that down, but they definitely intended this replacement theory issue.
You could be right , but isn't it true that in January 2024, the WEF stated that migration "could be a model for sustainable development, and that countries will need to rely on migration as populations age and birth rates decline." If the birth rates are dropping so dramatically, (since well we can't be forced to have children, how else would you solve the problem?) In 2023, the total fertility rate in the United States fell to 1.62 births per woman, the lowest rate since the government began tracking it in the 1930s. The fertility rate in Africa is gradually declining, but it remains the highest in the world. In 2024, the average number of children per woman in Africa was 4.1, down from 5.24 in 2000. By 2030, the fertility rate is projected to drop to around 3.8 children per woman. The gap between sub-Saharan Africa and other regions is closing, and the region's fertility rate is expected to drop below 2.1 by 2075 and 1.82 by the end of the century. This is due to a number of factors... Russia's fertility rate has been dropping in recent years: In 2022, Russia's total fertility rate was 1.42 children per woman, which is 6.67% lower than the previous year and the lowest on record. This is below the 2.1 children per woman needed to maintain Russia's population.
@@johnmguzman7491 People in Canada are not having kids because it's too expensive. Remember in Canada they raise our taxes so we can pay for all the immigrant's health care and housing for the first 5 years they are here. Most young people can not afford an average house in Canada which in some places here is a million dollars!!! If they want people to have kids in Canada send back 10 million immigrants so the pay of laborer's goes up and all pay goes up and housing demand decreases and infrastructure costs go down because roads last longer when you do not have millions of cars going across them and you can get a doctor and good health care and be able to afford food to feed that family. Like I said before huge populations only benefits the rich and in Canada as well as most places the government helps the rich and the rich help the government the average person is seen as a nuisance a pest and is silicened or called names to discredit them.
@@johnmguzman7491 Western Government's don't care about their citizens. It's hard to buy a house, it's expensive to raise kid's. If the government cared about it's citizens, it would incentivise an uptake in replacement birth rates of native citizens. Labor is another factor. They know Pakistani's will work for wheat, while White European's work for Gold. You have to be blind to not see the what's happening.
The population of London went from 97% ethnic English in 1961 (Scottish, Welsh, etc not included), to 36% British (so even less English) in 2021. You may not like the word “replaced” but it is a reality that London is no longer English, in one person’s lifetime. When one goes into Whitechapel / London’s East End, they will no longer find any Cockneys. This particular community who lived in this area for hundreds of years, with their own dialect, customs and traditions have been replaced by a Bangladeshi community. They were not welcomed in. They were brought in by corporations who wanted to pay less wages than the Cockneys could afford to live on. The Bangladeshi did not assimilate to Cockney culture. They built mosques instead of attending church, they spoke their own language instead of speaking Cockney, they dressed as Bangladeshi Muslims, etc. The only Cockney community in the world was replaced by a Bangladeshi community - even though they have a whole country with only Bangladeshi people in Asia. For those who live only for the almighty buck (pound in this case) then this is great. For those who believe there is more to the world, than making corporations rich, then this is certainly considered tragic. Now, times this scenario with much of the rest of Europe! It’s heartbreaking and infuriating at the same time.
14:14 - 14:24 you want an example? Immigrants in germany are getting free money monthly, to cover their living cost, without having to work even a minute. It's supposed to be a humanitarian aid, for people fleeing from war, paid from tax money, which is paid by the german citizens, who are in majority white. Meanwhile, the same people travel home for holidays to syria, which they left, because it's so unsafe and unlivable... So, they go to germany, pick up the free money and do whatever. What is that if not exploitation? (As a side note to clarify, that doesn't mean the color caused them to be exploited. Different race people are exploited elsewhere. )
@msmissy6888 Irish people and people from Côte d'Ivoire care. Mr Beat welcomes corrections when he makes mistakes because he cares about facts and accuracy. Just cus you're ignorant doesn't mean everyone else should be.
Gotta thank my dad for how he educated me,being half japanese when I was younger I didn't understand why he showed me a video and explained about japanese war crimes and how terrible they are until I grew up and had knew that if it depended on my grandmother I'd never been born cuz she was against my dad "tainting the bloodline" That still is a different example for what happens in america and those replacement theories but the end result is about the same thing in essence,just old people trying to make the world stagnate.
I'm surprised you didn't mention the shooting in New Zealand that killed people attending a mosque. That event was huge for the Great Replacement Movement online. It also directly inspired other shooters who mentioned him in thier manifestos such as the El Paso Shooter.
Or the one in a quebec mosque by which the attacker admitted to police to be persuaded to believing Replacement Theory from far right internet celebrities.
I’m surprised he didn’t mention the daily harassment of whites by moslems in Western Europe, the rapes of white girls and how they team up to ambush and beat up white boys.
He did it bc of a string of terror attacks committed against Europeans. The media response to those attacks was non existent bc of the ethnicity of the ones committing them.
You didn’t shy away from, “this was me” or “this is what I learned”. Well done. It’s hard to face the vulnerable parts of ourselves and this is a testament to your willingness to say some hard but true things. Thanks for being brave. The internet can be a trash can. Hope you received more understanding than not. 🥰
Agreed! It is important to give people the tools to recognize when they are being manipulated. Examining memes is also great because the majority of the electorate has never been formally educated on media literacy in the age of the internet and some of the examples are disinformation.
He lied, Mr beet never understood the arguments from the beginning and dishonestly represents the point he wants to attack. Also the replacement theory is obvious, you live it everyday. The longer you live, the more obvious it becomes. This is a propaganda film meant to manipulate people. It's also full of failed tropes...
@@chronometer9931 I’m sorry to inform you, but demographic changes aren’t a sign of a “great replacement”, “white genocide”, nor any of the other euphemisms that have been employed to further white supremacy. You don’t have to live in fear of non-whites, because whiteness is as arbitrary as detached earlobes or eye color for determining social caste.
This channel is big nose propaganda and is openly telling you to close your eyes and saw your ears off. Going on semantics and who is or isn't white when we all know its red hearings. Going about the history of le hecking racism and telling you its not actually happening, except it is and actually its a good thing nd if you don't like it you are rasists. It does get similar to a school teacher, you can't talk back and are forced to be lectured by someone who has a clear program. In that sense you are right.
Our French presidential election had among others 3 themes : - Le Grand Remplacement (a major campaign theme of Éric Zemmour) - Le Grand Ruissellement (« the great trickle down economics », promoted by Macron although he spent a lot in aides to fight the inflation, and communist Fabien Roussel talked about the « Roussellement ») - Le Grand Réchauffement (the emergency of the global warming)
@@iammrbeat You clearly have not been in european cities recently. As a dutch person i can assure you this agenda is very real. We have small villages with a few hundred people that get swamped by thousands of migrants. These migrants get preferential treatment from the state when it comes to housing and other resources. To lump people who are concerned about this in with white nationalists and nazi's is beyond the pale. These things you dont see on cnn i'm guessing. We dont share your american obsession with race and being "white" whatever that means but we do fear for our children and the safety of our elders. I feel you should visit here and educate yourself on the subject and the policies that advocate for this dissaster.
@@iammrbeat Why isn't mass immigration being accepted into Japan, China, The Middle East? They'd be saying the same thing if they had that. It isn't specific to white people. It's because it is a phenomenon only happening in The West.
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez Try seeking out the wef videos, where you find many of those psycho members speaking of this very issue! They also speak of 'reducing' the population! I guess you will probably claim, that you cannot find that information!!
@aarongoleman Looked it up. they were talking about the workforce. Because Developed countries have lower birthrates but they still need workers. So they need immigrants to replace the workers as they leave the workforce. It's not really that crazy for economic forums to be thinking about ways to keep an economy growing when the existing populations workforce is decreasing.
When Tony Blair became UK Prime Minister in 1997 he immediately quintupled the rate of legal migration to the UK. Andrew Neather, his former speechwriter, revealed in 2009 that the policy was designed not only to address labour shortages but also to make the UK more multicultural. Neather mentioned that ministers intended to "rub the Right's nose in diversity and render their arguments out of date." He also said that ministers were hesitant to discuss this policy openly, fearing it might alienate Labour's core working-class voters.
We've relied on immigration to fill in labour shortages since ww2. Before that we just relied on colonization and slavery. The fact is that this is nothing new and the major world powers have always had to rely on "others" to fill in the bottom of the work hierarchy. Which kind of shows how actually ineffective our economical systems are and how they need major overhauls. Our current system only works on exploitation.
@@Is_it_p Yes literally because without so our country would be in rubble and our industry in shambles for many more years through out the 20th century. It is a smart economical decision. Its funny how racism can literally lead to a faster collapse of your country, get over it, immigration fixed Britain for the time being.
@@josjos-x5s Then THAT'S the discussion that should have been had, because mass-immigration is NOT the answer. Other solutions would be to go where the workers are, or to actually encourage your own population to have children, instead of submitting them to the feminist propaganda of NOT having families like they still are doing to this day, because they want depopulation, but at the same time want to import new "workers". Everything is so backwards, illogical and stupid.
I live in Rochester, NY, me and our greater community has felt so much tension since the Buffalo attack, and I'm sure more diverse communities have felt fear from the growing radicalism in the world. I greatly appreciate that someone who has a more socially diverse fanbase covered this issue in an effort to combat hatred. I love your content, I binged your SCB series a few weeks back and hope you post more in future.
I think that the '1 drop' theory also plays a role in this. That is the idea that if a "White person" and someone of a different "race", or "ethnicity", have children together this means that none of their children or future generations can be considered "White". This is if anything, even dumber than other reasons, but you can see where a belief of this sort could make people fear for the future of "White people". I mean realistically there's no "they", there is only US. I was typing this while listening to the video, and then you said this yourself, so bonus points for you!
@@iammrbeat I certainly did. I think you did a great job on the video, it's important for people to understand this stuff, however unpleasant it may be.
What's crazy is some of the people who subscribe to the one drop rule and consider themselves White may have had ancestors that, by their own definition, were non-White.
What do people mean when they say things like “abolish whiteness”, then? I mean, there seems to be no confusion about what white is when attacking it, but when running into a defense of it, the common reply seems to be “well it doesn’t even exist so whatever lol”
Your Irish Flag was displayed incorrectly. Left to right, the flag displays green, white and orange. You displayed the flag, left to right using orange, white and green. That is actually the Ivorian Flag.
Could be the Irish flag flying to the left instead of the right. Course that would mean very strange cross gale for the Italian flag to point in the opposite direction.
Goes to show how thick he is.He is using a great lie from a debunked Canadian liar named Noel Ignatiev ( a man who hated white people).The Irish issue was NEVER about colour.It was a religious fight the Irish and English took to America.
Leftists are terrible people. There is a reasom they are the only ones that make these kinds of videos and are the only ones in the comment sections of said videos... Its bc yall make this bs up as you go and label it as conservative ideology when really it's all lies and projection. They take the reality of a situation turn it to an extreme radicalize the idea (their specialty along with projection) and turn it loose upon the world. Each leftist is like a tiny one man CNN.
Oh my lord Greek-Americans got a shoutout! Thank you so much! Discussing race as a Greek American is always difficult so I really appreciate just a mention in your video. It means a lot.
0:45 xenophobia, from xenos and phobos, two Greek words meaning stranger and fear. It actually means fear of strangers. Not so much those that are from a different place but more so those that don't belong to your family, tribe or ethnicity. Even if those people live in the same region as you.
The etymology of a word doesn't define it specifically. It can provide insight into the origins of the word but words are flexible things that change and conform to the people using them. The word xenophobia as Mr. Beat defined it is how he used and how many Americans and probably most english speakers interpret the meaning of the word. It's okay if you think it means something else but it's important to understand what definitions other people are using to understand what they are saying rather than getting bogged down into unproductive semantic arguments.
@@ThyCorruptor The difference here is that xenophobia essentially incorporates a level of racism to it, because despite not considering other races as inferior, it still distances the xenophobe from people of other races and nationalities, even tif they live in the same city or village as him. Whereas saying that the issue is where someone comes from I think downplays the problem.
@@ThyCorruptor disagree. Words are meant to be taken specifically. If its not the fear of the unknown, its not xenophobia. If its just fear of a culture you somewhat know but don't think you'll like, you're just racist. Phobias are very specific, and people tend to throw them around as if they were just emotions like sad and happy. PHOBIAS are IRRATIONAL FEARS. NOT just not liking another culture.
I was only half listening when I heard the name "Camus" and I was like "What the hell??? What does this have to do with absurdism???". I had to go back and listen again. Scared me for a bit.
I was like "well tha beach scene in the stranger was kinda sus" so it kinda bummed me then he said 2017 so i got happy cause i likey liked the stranger
I don't subscribe to the racist implications of GRT and believe in treating everyone equally and fairly, but a couple of points of contention: 1. If you have immigration to the West but not vice versa, there's going to be replacement. That's just being factual, especially with lower western birthrates. If China, India, the Middle East, Africa, and Latin America are allowed to stay relatively static with no inbound migration, but the West is the only region that needs to become more diverse, there will be replacement. 2. Progressives talk enthusiastically about replacement all the time. "Demographics is destiny" they say. It's no accident they have more immigrant friendly policies, they want to accelerate a changing demographic. 3. Western societies have implemented more social services and entitlements than in the past, meaning that immigration will become a more contentious issue because it's no longer just a matter of someone new moving here. Controlling who is a member of the 'club' also controls who is entitled to what financial benefits. 4. At a time when all demographics should have lower birthrates to fight resource scarcity, climate change, and environmental collapse, different groups will cynically use higher birthrates and population as a weapon against those who are responsibly trying to lower their footprint. 5. We have always been apprehensive of newcomers, but it is truly worrying when those new comers don't share your values. France didn't used to have to worry about professors being beheaded for free speech. Now they do. If you wouldn't let in a stranger into your home, why would you let in a group of people that wishes to strip your rights away? 6. Diversity as a strength is incidental. Japan and China have strong societies with less diversity. Diversity can be a weakness. It is much easier for China to send their best spy into American society than for America to send their best Chinese-American spy into China's society. Just some thoughts...
Here’s a thought: German-Americans are Americans, Irish-Americans are Americans, Italian-Americans are Americans, African-Americans are Americans, Hispanic-Americans are Americans, Iraqi-Americans are Americans. America is better for the German, Irish, Italian, Jewish, Asian, Hispanic, Middle Eastern, etc. immigration of the past (and African-American which is technically not immigration). Diversity makes our culture stronger and richer. Get over it!
@@mikeg2306 Are America and Europe the only places on earth that should become more diverse? Should Africa, South America, and Asia become more diverse too? Why or why not?
I appreciate that this video was very difficult to produce... thank yout! Your videos underscore the daily necessity of doing the hard work of thinking things through. This requires defining terms, being open-minded, listening, refusing distractions, writing down one's thoughts, self-examinstion... and more.
There are 2 possibilities here 1). Mr Beat did absolutely NO RESEARCH on the claim of WHITE GENOCIDE 2). He did the research and decided to make up his OWN version of White Genocide (Strawman) so he could refute that, since the ACTUAL accusation is totally undeniable
To learn who rules over you, simply find out who you are not allowed to criticize. Americans are not allowed to criticize anyone who is Jewish...otherwise it's called "hate crime" or Antisemitism. That's all you really need to know about the current situation of things in America.
Thank you for everything you do Mr beat, I got some hate by people on your why people don't like Jews video for mentioning some antisemitism experience I have and I'm glad there's someone who tries so much to educate those around him, one of the best teachers and you make things interesting to watch
You know you...or Stalin, sent Jewish people into internal exile in the USSR? You were kinda ethnically cleansy, comrade. Despite the good you accomplished... just noting.
One of my grandmas is Romanian. One of my grandmas is Irish. One of my grandpas is native American and one of my grandpas is Italian. My whole family has generational debt written into it. That’s why it makes me angry that these immigrants are getting free stuff and money while my families been here for hundreds of years and still struggling because of limits on such things like loans and homebuying processes and jobs. Now that I’m here there’s not a lot of the same limits, except for citizens. I paid off my parents debt of about 20 to 30 grand in bills for the house that I got meanwhile people that haven’t been in this country for more than three years are getting straight up home loans for houses bigger and better than mine and mine is already too big, it’s really expensive for someone my age. They’re so busy making exceptions for all the new people that they’re not considering any of the people that are still struggling that I’ve been living here for several decades. Edit: the city here is money, hungry and likes to screw people over. But the immigrants that are moving in here are getting free meals, free bus passes, free almost everything. Those little purchases mean a lot to people that are broke, but why haven’t those things been offered to us, knowing that we need them as well, I believe in people that are in need but I also believe in being responsible. if you can’t even take care of your own people, don’t take more people in so you can get more votes. None of this will strengthen our economy either. Just going to add more people that need help while we’re already giving money to other countries for wars. Why is it fair that my also brown immigrant family got crapped on, so to make up for it, they’re making it so easy for them, they will never know what hit them when all the niceties are over. That, or they will never know the struggle and will continue to invite people over with the prospect of an easy life when it’s not like that for anyone not born with a silver spoon in your mouth.
Camus may have popularized the "Great Replacement Theory", but in the 2000's I was beating the drum for the "Demographics is Destiny!" crowd... who were arguing that replacing the White Americans (and Canadians) was a GOOD thing and was quite happy that by 2050, the USA was going to be primarily non-white for the first time in the history of the United States of America. (it was going to take another 30+ years for Canada at the time - I don't even think there was an official estimate for Canada.) White Americans who hated this were almost entirely Conservatives, openly Christian, were anti-Same Sex Marriage (to the point of many were actually anti-LGBTQ+), and pro-Captialism. All of which we were quite happy to say would be destroyed by the browning of America (a sentiment often shared in the 2000's, though I don't remember if it was actually a slogan like "Demographics is Destiny!" was). America was going to become less Conservative, less Christian, pro-SSM, more anti-Capitalist and overall less Whtie, and this was a good thing to us. Toss in the argument FOR immigration that have been spread in the last 20+ years - particularly the argument that the West isn't having enough babies to fill the jobs we need, so without these immigrants doing jobs that we Westerners didn't want to do - it gets easy to read something nefarious between the lines. Because I DID mean something Nefarious. I DID mean I wanted to see less White Christian Capitalist Americans (and Westerners in general) in the world. I DID think that taking things (money, power, land, etc.) from White people was perfectly fine. I DID outright want there to be less White people in the world, to be "replaced" by non-Whties. If "White Replacement Theory" was a phrase that was used at the time, I would have been all for it and likely argued passionately in FAVOUR of it. I DID have a "black and white" view of the world, where I laughed at the idea of the Irish and Italians not being "white" - that was a red flag to me that I was dealing with a "White Christian Conservative" and so was not to be taken seriously, for instance. (You can't get much more white than most Irish people, after all, and it is still common for people to talk about the first Slaves in the Americas being Irish, not African) The places I frequented, the people I interacted with, we all held these views or at least espoused these views publicly to fit in. And it wasn't until I was literally holding someone in my arms on the day they were born that I realized that I was arguing to make their lives worse simply because of the colour of their skin, and my perceptions of the sins (ironic for an atheist to think of "sins") associated with that skin colour. I was perfectly fine living a lesser life for myself, but when it was my child that I was condemning to a lesser life... that's probably what broke me out of this line of thinking and this kind of belief far more than anything else could have. If people like me didn't do what people like me did in the 2000's (and probably before, but it wasn't until the 2000's that I because active in that kind of movement), maybe Camus wouldn't have had fodder for his "Great Replacement Theory". And yes, his reasoning (and the reasoning of the proponents of that specific theory) is irredeemable. But the sentiment DOES exist out there. The problems they are noting DO exist. The changes ARE happening. It's just that nothing is happening the way anyone predicted. The Latino's crossing the southern US border aren't becoming Lifelong Democrats - they're leaving the DNC and becoming Independent (if not outright Republican), and the Pro-Immigrant/Anti-Immigrant argument in the Latino community is as strong and divided as it is in the wider American community. Muslims are not embracing the LGBTQ+, and it's difficult to see if they're embracing Feminism either - it still seems to be a very common expectation among teenage Muslim girls that they're going to get married to someone from the Old Country and start raising a family either right out of high school or maybe they get to go to University first. None of them want Socialism or to get rid of Capitalism, and the vast majority are either Christian (latino's) or Muslim, few to none are leaving their Religion behind and becoming Secular. So what I expected to happen, and what I taunted Conservatives about happening... aren't happening. Conservatives may be more right about what's happening than I was, regardless of the path they took to get to those answers.
America at its core is a Christian nation and a white nation. That doesn’t mean you need to be a white Christian to be an American, but it does mean that as we drift farther as a society from these ideals, the pillars that hold up society will crumble and chaos will ensue.
There are whole NGOs whose entire purpose is to transport migrants from the global south into the U.S., Canada, and Europe. Obama and Bush just teamed up to create a new one a few days ago as a matter of fact. And there are people like you used to be who think it is a good thing. It drives me insane to see people running around saying what amounts to "it isn't happening but you deserve it." It is happening, any demographic chart you look at shows that the U.S. and Canada will become minority white countries by the end of the century, with Australia and New Zealand not far behind. The UK is probably the most dramatic example we can look at. In the last decade since immigration there has skyrocketed, so has crime, and their world-renowned social services are being strained to the breaking point. Mr. Beat is lying to both his audience and to himself.
It is truly marvelous to see you + your channel grow to such lengths where you can safely + thoughtfully approach more sensitive topics like this, US - Iranian history, 9/11. Your style and approach to these give me faith in education + in America as a whole. Matt you're doing truly meaningful work and I congratulate you on your success. Fuck yeah dude.
I would love to see Mr. Beat tackle the history of US regime change; your comment re Iran history made me think of how we overthrew the democratically elected president of Iran in 1953 when he wanted to nationalize their own oil industry.
Honestly, this is not a new concept or a new theory. as a Chinese. China has been doing this for thousands of years. since the first emperor of China ordered the relocation of 300,000 soldiers to Guangzhou. intermarriage. another example, the current Chinese government does the same with Uyghurs. A large number of Chinese immigrated to Xinjiang. That's why the Uyghurs protested. They want to replace Uyghurs with Han Chinese. It's no secret. And it's no secret now that we've been using Chinese immigrants to buy foreign land. buy everything. Not just Europe. South America. Africa. Asia. Same for Hong Kong. 150 Chinese immigrants to Hong Kong every day. The effect is slow but very effective.
@@rumbling3991 Prove that even people of the same race are interchangeable. Politics, culture, beliefs. There are many things that can be replaced. It's not just superficial that stays on the skin color.
There is a great video that talks about part of the subject, it's called "Tribalism: weaponizing culture". One of my favorite videos that breakdown how we fall into conflict of "we and they".
@@bryanice3313 1965 sure had lots of American xenophobia... Hm. twenty years after the end of ww2. All the baby boomers, just military age, had grown up with all their parents stories of fighting the evil Germans and Japanese. March 7 - "Bloody Sunday": Some 200 Alabama State Troopers attack 525 civil rights demonstrators in Selma, Alabama, as they attempt to march to the state capitol of Montgomery. March 8 - Vietnam War: Some 3,500 United States Marines arrive in Da Nang, South Vietnam, becoming the first American ground combat troops in Vietnam.
Before watching this video, I had never heard of this "Great Replacement Theory." When you mentioned the shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh, I remembered something that I heard on the news a few years back. My hometown had an anti-semetic synagogue shooting in April of 2019 and the shooter referenced the Pittsburgh shooter as an inspiration. When I looked into it, it turns out that his manifesto included many of the beliefs expressed by this theory. As a history major, it's always interesting learning more about my hometown, even if it isn't so great. Thank you, Mr. Beat.
It’s genuinely so disappointing reading hateful stuff online and even in this comment section cause it reminds me that it leads to real world consequences like the Pittsburgh shooting.
@David Herschel No dude I don’t think you’re some random hick from Alabama. I just can’t imagine constantly being angry and sad and hateful all the fucking time every day. I don’t think there’s anything logical about it
4:14 There is an error in the Irish flag. You stated earlier this was ‘Irish-Americans’ but that is the flag of Ivory Coast! The Ireland flag is upside down. :)
Yeahhh this video does not hold true for Europe at all. A lot of Europeans are now becoming right wing because they are being taken over by the sheer number of immigrants coming in from the Muslim world who are not assimilating into the culture of the countries they move to. In the uk for example, there has been grooming gangs in a few cities that have been run by mostly muslim men that have been allowed to operate without any consequences due to the police fearing being labeled as racist or islamophobic if they intervene. There have been Muslims shouting things such as "sharia for uk" and theres currently a case ongoing where a Muslim religious leader is trying to buy an island in Scotland amd turn it into a caliphate
I never comment on videos, but this was so well made and educational that I couldn't resist. THIS VIDEO SHOULD BE SHARED AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE. thank you @mr.beat!!!
The Great Replacement. already happened in Canada and all over the U.S, Hawaii, australia and new zealand, Palestine, all the settler colonialism already had The Great Replacement. The Great Replacement Theory. is not a Theory.
23:32 I wish the "diversity" teacher I had in college understood your closing statement. White students were not allowed to opine for about half of her class, we were segregated by race and told that anything we say is just a reflection of inherited power that must be reversed, and by not speaking, we are doing more to help the cause than by speaking
I agree with every point made in your video completely. And at the same time, there also exist racists from races other than white. And they can do damaging things out of racism as well. Try living in some So Cal neighborhoods with white skin. Gangsters target white people because of their skin color, with their head full of bullshit propaganda about "la raza," their "superior" race, and the "honor" of fighting the white race for their "noble" cause.
Really appreciate you putting this positivity into a space so often filled with the opposite. Hope all is well! (PS, still got my ENR sticker on my bumper)
ignorance and passivity is a powerfull drug. Better to close your eyes,saw your ears off and live in positive thinking fantasy land when your lineage and culture is going to be errased and replaced for profits.
The craziest thing to me about watching this was the fact that I had to keep convincing myself that anyone actually needed to be told this lol I still can't help but feel like this is like someone from early times trying to teach someone from today the benefits of cooking your food... Like yeah, dua... Right?
As much as you had to convince yourself,I have had to deal with too many people in the past few years that believe in a "raw food diet". It has to be explained to people that just because people did it that way, at some point in time, does not make it right. The convincing yourself disappears when you stay at it day to day. First horror as the shock sinks in, then ever growing sadness as the realization that it is farther spread than you could imagine.
@@targetthetank it's funny that you mentioned "raw food diet" because after I posted my comment I thought of that and how ridiculous some people get with all that... But you are right, I'm to say, there are still far too many people who are crazy and racist.
If I had seen this 5 or 6 years ago, I would've felt the same way. I didn't realize how much of the country is totally fucked. I mean, I knew it, but it was an existential knowledge, a knowledge that the status quo sucks, but real people in my day to day life were different. It was a rude awakening. I think most people are really poor observers. I always thought most people were like me, but I was wrong. It's one of the most unsatisfying conclusions I've come to, especially because I don't think I'm particularly smart.
@@berlingolingoful There are a few problems with this claim. Firstly it ignores that assimilation took the better part of a century. In some sense Irish and Italians assimilated quickly in that some of them became part of the political establishment in cities where they were a large part of the population. In other senses it took a century for them to assimilate. The Italian American Mafia wasn't broken until the 80s, and Italian Americans still to this day massively under perform in educational attainment. Italians are closer to Hispanics than to English Americans in their rate of college education. America has also never had an Italian president, and Biden was probably the first time being an Irish Catholic wasn't seen as a relevant political issue, when Kennedy was elected there were still people concerned the Pope was going to be giving him orders. By comparison, Asian Americans and African immigrants have much higher achievement in income and education, largely because they immigrated after immigration policy favoured people with money and education. Additionally Asians are more likely to marry outside their community than Europeans. A very good case can be made that Indian and Chinese Americans are better assimilated than the Italians.
@@rn6312"If you can convince the lowest white man he's better than the best colored man, he won't notice you're picking his pocket. Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he'll empty his pockets for you."- President Lyndon B. Johnson. This quote can be perfectly applied to him (Damien) and others in this comment section.
Memes are easily the biggest driving force of radicalism. Can be made by anybody, for any purpose with baseless claims and no sources. They are also really good cover for "It's just a joke" and "I wasn't serious when I made it".
@@crazyitalianguy000 They are billiant. People get radicallized all day by mainstream media etc. Of course there is going to be a counter culture towards it.
but hey thats just a theory a game theory i just simaltainiously whipped and nae naed sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness hello internet welcome to game theory!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You people serve a function. You will still be around to serve that function. We want your population to increase not decrease, silly. ☺️ If somehow it does manage to decrease significantly I'm going to be very annoyed, because that would be entirely on you. What are we supposed to do, force you breed?
@@pro-socialsociopath769 To take over the country and implement one party rule? The same way a foreign invader wants to take over a country. You can either do it via war or importing as many third world animals as possible.
Love and kindness can't be promoted if you can't first take care of your own kind. We are not all one race, we need to take care of our own, otherwise we can't help anymore.
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez His spirit shall rise from the grave, and everyone will know he was right. Even know they control every major corporation, every major bank, every media agency, every porn company, dating app, money apps, social media platforms, all the health organizations, and every major country across the world. There is and always has been one common denominator, and if you don't see who that is at this point you are clearly blind.
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez They own everything, and they censor anyone who says so because they don't want you to see it. Even now my comments are being hidden because they want to suppress the truth.
It always fascinated me why Americans claim that they don't like immigrants when they're immigrants themselves (talking about anyone who is not a native american/indian)
@@i_likemen5614 nah Palastine and Israelites have always lived there so its less Replacement and more an old grudge as old as if not older than the bible itself that just got a new religous and national spin due to the Brits carving up the Near East.
Biden has allowed more illegals in than American babies were born in the entire country. His goal is to flood the country with migrants, get them on welfare, and give them amnesty in time for the election so they will vote for him. Talk about election interference. It's not just some antisemitic conspiracy -- all Americans are being replaced -- do you think the Blacks on the South side of Chicago aren't being replaced? Or the citizens in NYC? Wake up, this isn't about Jews, this is about UN agenda 2030, and the WEF working with Biden towards the Great Reset.
Thank you so much for this video Mr.Beat! I've been a subscriber for years and I've always really admired and appreciated how responsibly you use your platform.
@@iammrbeat the people who support great replacement and other white supermisist ideas will say going back to Colonial America when the land was setter clonized by England the Brtish Empire and after American Revolution when USA became a Country after independence from Brtish Empire the 1st naturalization laws in 1790 gave American citizenship to free white people of good chacter and that the people of the 18th century the founders of America never would have allowed black African people from African countries Asian people from India China Japan Indonesia Vietnam South Korea or Korea Sir Lanka. The Middle Eastern countries Iraq Mesopotamia Iran Persia Arabs Turkish Ottoman Empire Egyptian Syria Lebanon Jordan Palestine. To come to America in fact most western countries during the colonial era would not allow non white people. So why should a country established by western Europen people allow people from non western white European backgrounds. They will say every non white country or even some other western countries like Eastern Europe Central Europen countries are allowed to keep demographic the same yet western Europen countries the ex colonial powers are not.
That's what Hitler tried to do lmao. If anyone also knows anything about a lot of history, especially with many countries in the past, they were forcibly rp ed by people from other countries to intentionally "unpure their bloodline".
Why are so many comments bringing up israel? literally nothing to do with the video Not to say that Israel's population isn't problematically xenophobic itself, but that's a different topic
@@rn6312 That's a lose lose situation for me (and you). Even if I win (which I would) I'd go to jail for life so. You're psychotic for even suggesting this and it just goes to show you how mentally broken you become when you hear different opinions. Your entire world stands still and you have another break down....
The white (not including Hispanic or Latino) has decreased by 3% over the course of 10 years between 2010 and 2020. The fact of the matter is, is that it is true that the white population in the US is actively decreasing, whether you want to attribute it to some boogeyman is up to you.
This is readily explained by the fact that more light-skinned people are choosing to identify themselves differently. Unless you think millions of people evaporated in 10 years.
@@PlatinumAltaria Non whites make more children and old whites are dying. Combine that with mass immigration of non whites and you have white numbers that decrease at a rapid rate. Is that such a difficult conclusion to get to?
I remember digging myself a rabbit hole in wikipedia until I found this conspiracy theory and I was surprise and baffled on what I was reading. Wikipedia does a good job leading me into huge rabbit holes that just makes my head spin
@@themysteriousgravityfalls sub saharan Africans were importing Europeans there? doubt any history book would say that or journals of people going there.
@@Dorkeydaze Actually it's only 20 percent. Why shouldn't it be more? Israel has a high standard of living, surely they could help out some of their neighbors.
The question or statement that race is not biological but cultural is confusing. We can determine from a skeleton the gender and race of the person with great accuracy due to bone structure and length ratio, skull thickness etc etc. Can you clarify that?
Pure bs, if you could tell the difference between a German and a French man you would have know it by now, but you can't, because they have insignificant differences between them that make them indeferent of one another, apart form regional adaptations
When you say something like "race isn't a biological reality", you NEED (seriously) to couch that with science. This may seem trivial, and like a lesson in pointless repetition, but it's critical that you explain it EVERY TIME. Because if not explained, it becomes an immediate "ah ha! this guy is an idiot" for folks that are just looking for something to discredit you.
And then again, its fake. Race is a biological reality, there are many problems of finding organs compatible for surgery for mixed-race people for that exact reason
Yeah, only one glance at a science book or a genetics course will indicate that genetic and behavioral traits are attributed to heredity. OF COURSE we all understand that cognitive ability shouldn’t be the sole factor in judging a person’s character.. but being correct 8.5 times out of ten is a much better starting point than a blind stumble. There is a reason why there is over representation of a particular nature (race, ethnicity, religion) in every place that it manifests (occupation, athletics, education, criminal justice system). This is outlined well in the book The Bell Curve which is often trashed but never challenged with data (to my knowledge). In closing, I would hope each person takes the time to judge on the content of one’s character. But, to oversimply and say that there aren’t many things that play into this equasion is just an attempt to make a uncomfortable subject into a feel good one.
Im irish, my people were persecuted by the english aswell as the americans. The british used mass migrations of anglos and scots to northern ireland to replace us natives. In total over 150,000 people over a course of over 80 years were planted in ulster. In 2023 that number was dwarfed, over 180,000 people had come to ireland. More people than the entire 80 year long plantation that stripped ireland of a quarter of her land.
The plantations stripper the lands and livelihoods from garlic irish people and gave it to Protestant Scots and English men. No land is being given to modern immigrants. They are incomparable
I've shared this video with ten of my friends of all races - I've asked them to share it - because, as a disabled veteran, it kills me to think how crazy we've become over race - when in combat, it didn't matter what color the man to my right or left was - all that mattered was did he have my back - and did I have his. And for those of us who were wounded and died - all our blood on the battlefield was RED
@@yeehaw3792 God has clearly shown us in his word we are to remain separate. what an amazing test He has set up for these days. what does a person fear more? God or being called a racist.
Thank you so much for making this video, Mr. Beat. Considering that you have a pretty diverse and wide-reaching audience, it’s particularly important that you get this message out. I’m a longtime fan, and to be fully honest I fell down the far-right rabbit hole for a bit, so I’m glad to see you speak out against such hateful and unsubstantiated claims.
The editing in this video was so high quality compared to recent videos. Did you hire an editor? Looks great! Edit: Just checked the credits in the description. Love the new editing!
he was hired to try to gaslight whites into thinking that Europe & America are not being turned non-White - that's why. They have done this before. Google/youtube hides all of the videos of Whites OBJECTING to genocide and PROMOTES videos like these that argue in FAVOR of White Genocide
If you look at UK adverts you would think that the UK only had mixed race couples which means their children would be mixed race and the country would lose the majority of white people. But the percentage of white British in the real world is about 81%, which is a big decrease since the 90s and will only decrease further because white British are having less children and the amount of immigrants arriving in the UK. So you never know if things carry on the way the UK is going it could be a possibility.
You have pointed out one of the big problems with this conspiracy theory. Even if we stopped all immigration, the percentage of white would still decrease, as would the percentage of all ethnicities because people will have mixed race children. And for these racists, a half white person is not white. They consider Obama for example to be black despite him being half black and half white, this their racist views have doomed white people to extinction regardless of immigration levels. Really the only way to address their grievances would be to ban interracial marriage, but they can't say that because it would hurt their messaging.
Why doesn't this fellow White run this video in Israel as they seem to be really worried about their demographics to the point of their current mowing of the lawn.
@@frobsonsdesenhos seems to me his ethnic group in Israel is extremely nationalistic and afraid of being replaced to the point of removing and killing the native Palestinians. He needs to stop worrying about White nationalists as no nation exists - and start worrying about actual ethnic nationalistic like his own Israel
@@frobsonsdesenhosthe correlation? No correlation, it’s just that we all have to accept that diversity is our strength, especially our greatest ally in the Middle East, Israel! Open borders! Free healthcare and housing for Refugees! Immigrants welcome!
During WWII the Army had to establish Japanese language schools, as many AJAs did not have the language skills, in spite of their parents efforts. In the Western U.S. Asians were institutionally discriminated against into the first half of the 20th Century.
“The problem is subjective framing” proceeds to commit every logical fallacy. I don’t even disagree with the message but this doesn’t acknowledge any actual evidence or argument contrary to his narrative
Is the replacement happening? I need only look out the window to confirm that. And it is speeding up. Even some liberal friends I have are starting to get worried. "Theory" my ass.
I'll do it for you: - There aren't genetic differences between races. - There are 4 times more Blacks in prisons than the general population. > There must be a systemic reason for excess Black imprisonment. > There is systemic racism in the US.
@@userlog2474 I'd reply to this comment, but my friendly melanin-coloured neighbour borrowed my laptop without giving it back. Currently writing this on my phone.
@@userlog2474 I would, but my phone was just borrowed withour given back by my friendly melanin-coloured neighbour. Typing this on my friends's computer as we speak
One important point that's often missed is that susceptibility to radicalizing rhetoric is correlated with the economic status of the listener. Germans "fell" for Nazi rhetoric in part due to the harsh economic conditions post WWI. Industry has been leaving America for decades now and so the idea to "return to a better time" (i.e. MAGA) resonates because it's based on some level of truth.
They didn't "fall" for anything - they *wanted* it. They *wanted* Uncle A to win becausr they saw just how decadent and bankrupt the internationalist and American-influenced Weimar Republic had become.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
people keep bringing up the fact that italians and irish weren't considered white. but i think the far more relevant argument is the fact that the "one drop rule" is one of the main reasons for statistical democratic shift. if someone has 1 black grandparent and 3 white ones, they are statistically considered black. of course, if you always count mixed people as "non-white", the actual genetic representation of "white people" will be massively underrepresented in statistics.
most african americans have some white ancestry (often through rape of slaves, but often also from times after slavery). by far most "latinos" have strong "white" ancestry, too. so, if we would count them as "partially white", the statistics would look VERY different.
yes, a modern society mixes more, because luckily a lot of us don't chose their partners based on racist ideas anymore. so there are much more mixed people than ever before. so? it's fucking awesome.
Im mixed race. Why am i awesome? Because i dont have a culture or an identity? I feel alone and dont relate to anybody? Theres realy nothing great about it. Its terrible living in such a racist world and not having your own tribe. The liberal white person is the only peeople with no ingroup preference. You will be replaced because you violate the first law of nature, self preservation.
people are fucking stupid, they incorporate dumb physical analogies to their everyday life because their minds are too small to see the world any different , that's why the one drop rule exist, because people saw how one drop of some other color always ruins the white paint, people knew nothing about genetics so they said fuck it we're paint now, we racists now, fuck everybody who says we're not paint.
It is like the Latino deal where they are largely European in ancestry, but not considered white.
Yeah, the one drop rule is also extremely relevant, it's why Obama is considered the US's first black president and not the US's 44th white president, because he's absolutely half white.
@@jeffreyheronemus1917 government created a whole Hispanic identity, just for them
Just wait until Native Americans hear about the "Great Replacement Theory".
okay, justify the white genocide in europe then.
It’s not a theory, it’s a fact for them.
Well, kind of. Most of the American Indian population in North America was wiped out by disease prior to any long term European settlement let alone conquest. This massive plague is sadly rarely talked about due to us having no record of it, but suffice to say some native populations had as much as 90% of people wiped out. So when the Europeans did decide to colonize much of the natives civilizations were pretty much on the brink of collapse and barely holding themselves together and much more land was empty then would have been otherwise. All in all, the situations aren’t exactly comperable.
they are in the very late stages of it, they will be gone very soon.
Of course, it can happen to the "Native Americans" but it cannot happen to whites.
Sometimes I wish people still had that childlike sense of love and kindness. The older I get the more bitter everyone seems especially over arbitrary nonsense. If only we could still want to be friends with everyone.
true bro
Children get thrown into vans, and never seen again. There's a reason people target children...
@@ObiJohnKenobi67 nah.
I saw at first glance how you fuckers treat your own people, and how you treat grouos related to you.
Western European people have raped Europe before they attacked Americas and Africa.
We're all still children at heart; we're just wiser than the new children.
It's unfortunate and tragic indeed that qualities like love and kindness are called childlike while qualities like cunning, shrewd, suspicious are considered mature adult behaviour..No wonder white supremacy, racism and other evils prevail and continue to get stronger in the world..Love and kindness are not childlike qualities but rather a sensible strategy in a perverted, sick a s cruel world ruined by adult human beings...My simple solution..Get rid of human beings and the world will be a much better place..
So what is wrong with open borders for Israel, exactly?
It's racist to suggest Israel shouldn't be racist. They are the master race so they need to remain pure and receive billions in aid from other nations.
@@savvageorge the chosen people🙂↕️
Israel is in the middle of fucking nowhere
@@ARTEMIOMENDEZHERNANDEZ-n1m So what. Why shouldn't they have open borders?
@@kugelscheier5035They have, nobody goes there
Fun fact: while in the US Italian migration was oftenly perceived as a pollution of inferiors (some even classifying them "non-whites"), in Argentina, Brazil and most of Latin America Italian immigrants were not just welcomed (except for some purists) but invited to migrate, since, according to the Latin American hyperdescent logic of miscegenation, they'd "improve the race".
This is how nebulous the concept of "pure whiteness" is: for Latin America it was all Europeans, for Anglo-America it was only a certain kind of Europeans.
Yep, the term of "Mejorar la raza" its pretty common and usual around here.
@William Pierce wtf are you talking about.
In Anglo-America it is moreso the descendants of the Aryans, which includes native Iranians and North Indians. Don't be fooled into thinking you are dealing with entirely dumb people when discussing genetic ancestry.
@@extremosaur uh. Yeah but they arent white. So doesn't count to the expression.
@@CesarAugustoRocabadoVillegas clearly you don't understand how the people I am talking about define White. It's not literal. Chinese people are white, but not White, get it?
My Mom was a child in Brooklyn NY during the 1950's. She grew up in a Irish Catholic family. Her Aunt fell in love with a man from a Italian Catholic family that lived a couple of blocks away. At that time a marriage between a Irish kid and a Italian kid was considered a bad thing. Mixing I guess. After they got married they were not welcome in the Irish neighborhood or the Italian neighborhood. They ended up moving to Florida to start their family. In 2022 we would think that's nuts. I hope that what we are talking about today loses traction is considered old fashioned and weird in a generation or two. (Hopefully sooner than that!)
And the craziest part about your story is that THEY WERE BOTH THE SAME RELIGION. Yeah I'm glad we have made progress with that.
@@iammrbeat I'm glad that you caught that. My mother also told me that they had two Catholic churches that were close to each other. One for Irish families and the other was for Italian families. My mother was discouraged from visiting the Italian church. I do not understand the argument that all change is bad and everything was better in the past. The evidence tells a different story IMO.
Oddly I don’t think religion mixing will ever be 100% okay with a lot of families. In the 40’s they even the 80’s there were grumblings. I had when I got married in the early 80’s. It’s hopefully changed, but sometimes people need to let other people just be happy.
@@victoriabaker6943 religion has less and less bearing on most people
both of my grandmothers were swiss catholics and both of my grandfathers were swiss protestants. tge grandmothers essentially got kicked out of their families for marrying a protestant.
today, in my generation i havent heard of a single case of anyone careing about things like this anymore.
more and more people are atheist anyway
@@jurgnobs1308 yeah except that it had to do with the culture and not religion. And not many are atheist. A lot of them in europe are Christian and catholic.
Even in Japan they have cultural Christian weddings at churches.
Trump tweeted something about this once, right? From like an account with the name in it or something?
It makes sense that there is some overlap between support of Trump and this theory, given that especially in 2016, stopping or slowing down illegal (but truly all) immigration of those from hispanic and muslim countries was a top priority. A recent survey also shows that 6 in 10 Trump supporters agree with it, and if Trump didn't literally fully support it, it was a gateway to this type of ideology.
I do remember the sh** hole country thing from January 2018, Trump said a lot of things, he was a right wing populist after all
Yeah he did, wouldnt be surprised if it happened multiple times. Plenty of national candidates and tucker spouting this garbage, things are not looking pretty down here JJ.
Tucker Carlson mentions it frequently.
@@SumSum030no not really
It’s not a theory, it’s actually happening in real time
Sure thing buddy, sure thing
@@ArtemioMendezHernandezeven someone as dense and racist as you can't deny the hard numbers
@@IllumirageNotice the sarcasm
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez sarcasm doesn't translate well via text comments.
@@IllumirageNah you're just a retard
I reckon Israel could do with a lot more african and indian immigrants too, what do you think?
China needs more black culture, like, last year. Why are they taking so long? 🤷🏼♂️
they pushing it to other countries, but they hate their own African jews in Israel😂
They already have more than most countries in the SWANA by percentage. Reckon harder next time.
@@axaeyexus oy vey, that's because like israel, the arabs won't take any either. no strawmen in the chat please.
Israel has a higher black population than every other country in the middle east. Cope
It's not happening > It's a right wing consipracy > It might be happening > It's happening and it's good
When did he say that
@zoomiro1622 it’s great! Just as the whites replaced the Indians, now other races will replace the whites, all the cycle of life
@@eternalelysium4944ok racist. Who alive replaced the non native Americans? So why are they being punished with threats of genocide?
@@eternalelysium4944what is wrong with you
@@IllumirageYou did, continue to do so
The first time I heard about the WEF (couple/few years ago) I went on their website and clearly remember reading about their plan for “open borders” and “mass migration to blend poor countries with rich countries”. They’ve since then taken all that down, but they definitely intended this replacement theory issue.
You could be right , but isn't it true that in January 2024, the WEF stated that migration "could be a model for sustainable development, and that countries will need to rely on migration as populations age and birth rates decline."
If the birth rates are dropping so dramatically, (since well we can't be forced to have children, how else would you solve the problem?)
In 2023, the total fertility rate in the United States fell to 1.62 births per woman, the lowest rate since the government began tracking it in the 1930s.
The fertility rate in Africa is gradually declining, but it remains the highest in the world. In 2024, the average number of children per woman in Africa was 4.1, down from 5.24 in 2000. By 2030, the fertility rate is projected to drop to around 3.8 children per woman.
The gap between sub-Saharan Africa and other regions is closing, and the region's fertility rate is expected to drop below 2.1 by 2075 and 1.82 by the end of the century. This is due to a number of factors...
Russia's fertility rate has been dropping in recent years:
In 2022, Russia's total fertility rate was 1.42 children per woman, which is 6.67% lower than the previous year and the lowest on record. This is below the 2.1 children per woman needed to maintain Russia's population.
@@johnmguzman7491 People in Canada are not having kids because it's too expensive. Remember in Canada they raise our taxes so we can pay for all the immigrant's health care and housing for the first 5 years they are here. Most young people can not afford an average house in Canada which in some places here is a million dollars!!! If they want people to have kids in Canada send back 10 million immigrants so the pay of laborer's goes up and all pay goes up and housing demand decreases and infrastructure costs go down because roads last longer when you do not have millions of cars going across them and you can get a doctor and good health care and be able to afford food to feed that family. Like I said before huge populations only benefits the rich and in Canada as well as most places the government helps the rich and the rich help the government the average person is seen as a nuisance a pest and is silicened or called names to discredit them.
@@erics9754 Yup canada is done!
@@johnmguzman7491 Western Government's don't care about their citizens.
It's hard to buy a house, it's expensive to raise kid's. If the government cared about it's citizens, it would incentivise an uptake in replacement birth rates of native citizens. Labor is another factor. They know Pakistani's will work for wheat, while White European's work for Gold.
You have to be blind to not see the what's happening.
@@michaelhutchings8599 they know exactly waht they're doing
Regardless of whether or not the grand unifying theory exists, the crisis of mass immigration has already lead to massive damage in my country
Wich country? The US? Boy you have a silver spoon in hand and you complain
@ not the US, Ireland
@Polpotdisliker not just ireland most of Western Europe.
@ I’d agree with you there, but I am mostly concerned with Irish afairs, I’m a good pattern recogniser though
*affairs
The population of London went from 97% ethnic English in 1961 (Scottish, Welsh, etc not included), to 36% British (so even less English) in 2021. You may not like the word “replaced” but it is a reality that London is no longer English, in one person’s lifetime.
When one goes into Whitechapel / London’s East End, they will no longer find any Cockneys. This particular community who lived in this area for hundreds of years, with their own dialect, customs and traditions have been replaced by a Bangladeshi community. They were not welcomed in. They were brought in by corporations who wanted to pay less wages than the Cockneys could afford to live on. The Bangladeshi did not assimilate to Cockney culture. They built mosques instead of attending church, they spoke their own language instead of speaking Cockney, they dressed as Bangladeshi Muslims, etc. The only Cockney community in the world was replaced by a Bangladeshi community - even though they have a whole country with only Bangladeshi people in Asia.
For those who live only for the almighty buck (pound in this case) then this is great. For those who believe there is more to the world, than making corporations rich, then this is certainly considered tragic.
Now, times this scenario with much of the rest of Europe! It’s heartbreaking and infuriating at the same time.
London is 100% British citizens
@@MaxSnowDude no it isn't
@@Illumirage all immigrants are British Citizens thats how they live there. Im stating facts little bitch
@@Illumirage British doesn't mean white. Ya knob.
So what you're saying is that you don't even want non-British whites immigrating to London?
14:14 - 14:24 you want an example? Immigrants in germany are getting free money monthly, to cover their living cost, without having to work even a minute. It's supposed to be a humanitarian aid, for people fleeing from war, paid from tax money, which is paid by the german citizens, who are in majority white.
Meanwhile, the same people travel home for holidays to syria, which they left, because it's so unsafe and unlivable...
So, they go to germany, pick up the free money and do whatever. What is that if not exploitation?
(As a side note to clarify, that doesn't mean the color caused them to be exploited. Different race people are exploited elsewhere. )
"Its true because i said so" Far right groypers like you cant prove anything without getting it from your ass hole.
@@adude7944 man bait used to be believable
Absolute mental retardation. Please show the Numbers. You won't because the number of "immigrants taking my money to their homeland" is close to zero.
@@adude7944 Source
Don’t forget England which is way worse. This entire video is really just idiotic, people need to open their eyes!
After watching your video, I am 100% sure that the replacement theory is not just a theory. It’s not hard to read between the lines.
Yeah, it's a delusion, keep the good work!
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez something someone living in a world of delusion would say
@@roenix1080 cope
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez How is it a cope exactly? You can get arrested for speaking out against this online.
@@Is_it_pfor a good reason it is
This video should be studied in psychology classes on propaganda gaslighting
I know, it’s mad people still try this conspiracy theory angle. They don’t even hide it anymore lmao
You should be studied in mental incapabilities
@@ARTEMIOMENDEZHERNANDEZ-n1m you said you were going to bring an AR to my home, how are you the normal one here?
@@IllumirageYou wanted to deport a briton, how are you sane?
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez .... you didn't answer me
4:18 minor correction, that flag on the left is actually the Ivory Coast flag ( 🇨🇮) not the Irish flag 🇮🇪 ^^
Lol was just coming down to say that!! Nice catch
@msmissy6888 Irish people and people from Côte d'Ivoire care. Mr Beat welcomes corrections when he makes mistakes because he cares about facts and accuracy. Just cus you're ignorant doesn't mean everyone else should be.
@msmissy6888 i care xd
Its for Australians
Wow
Him saying "goodness gracious" when the image of the KKK slid into frame is absolutely sending me
KKK? You mean the Federal Bureau of Investigation in white robes?
Shit jumped me too 🤣🤣🤣
But he approvingly shows ANTIFA or BLM in other vids. People wake the fxck up, this guy is a shill
The irony Is that probably His democrat ancestors were premium members of the kkk.
they had some extreme views but one thing they got right was racial inter breeding. why should people pollute their bloodline,? very irresponsible.
Gotta thank my dad for how he educated me,being half japanese when I was younger I didn't understand why he showed me a video and explained about japanese war crimes and how terrible they are until I grew up and had knew that if it depended on my grandmother I'd never been born cuz she was against my dad "tainting the bloodline"
That still is a different example for what happens in america and those replacement theories but the end result is about the same thing in essence,just old people trying to make the world stagnate.
@William Pierce
Muh age William pierce whose now 90 and also has been gone for the last 20 years
Your grandmother was right.
@@HighFlyingOwlOfMinerva no, she wasn’t
@@aleanajadeskywalker Cry about it.
@@HighFlyingOwlOfMinerva Bet you're a weeb who wish you were born in Japan or something 🤣
Came here after Starmer admitted it was real
I'm surprised you didn't mention the shooting in New Zealand that killed people attending a mosque. That event was huge for the Great Replacement Movement online. It also directly inspired other shooters who mentioned him in thier manifestos such as the El Paso Shooter.
Or the one in a quebec mosque by which the attacker admitted to police to be persuaded to believing Replacement Theory from far right internet celebrities.
I’m surprised he didn’t mention the daily harassment of whites by moslems in Western Europe, the rapes of white girls and how they team up to ambush and beat up white boys.
He did it bc of a string of terror attacks committed against Europeans. The media response to those attacks was non existent bc of the ethnicity of the ones committing them.
@@MAN-MILK bruh
Sounds like a fed op
You didn’t shy away from, “this was me” or “this is what I learned”. Well done. It’s hard to face the vulnerable parts of ourselves and this is a testament to your willingness to say some hard but true things. Thanks for being brave. The internet can be a trash can. Hope you received more understanding than not. 🥰
This isn't true, it's one big cope.
If you want reality - look up what the 1965 Hart-Celler Act is, and what it did to the U.S.
"The Great Replacement is a conspiracy theory, but it's also happening and you're a bigot if you have a problem with it."
Agreed! It is important to give people the tools to recognize when they are being manipulated. Examining memes is also great because the majority of the electorate has never been formally educated on media literacy in the age of the internet and some of the examples are disinformation.
He lied, Mr beet never understood the arguments from the beginning and dishonestly represents the point he wants to attack. Also the replacement theory is obvious, you live it everyday. The longer you live, the more obvious it becomes. This is a propaganda film meant to manipulate people. It's also full of failed tropes...
@@chronometer9931 I’m sorry to inform you, but demographic changes aren’t a sign of a “great replacement”, “white genocide”, nor any of the other euphemisms that have been employed to further white supremacy.
You don’t have to live in fear of non-whites, because whiteness is as arbitrary as detached earlobes or eye color for determining social caste.
This channel is like hearing my passionate middle school history teachers time travel to right now and break down the world. I love it
"The Great Replacement is a conspiracy theory, but it's also happening and you're a bigot if you have a problem with it."
This Algerian (the same people who are shooting up and burning down France right now) is telling us it isn't happening.
Yeah
This channel is big nose propaganda and is openly telling you to close your eyes and saw your ears off.
Going on semantics and who is or isn't white when we all know its red hearings. Going about the history of le hecking racism and telling you its not actually happening, except it is and actually its a good thing nd if you don't like it you are rasists.
It does get similar to a school teacher, you can't talk back and are forced to be lectured by someone who has a clear program. In that sense you are right.
He doesn’t know what the fuck he’s talking about. Total NPC
Poland is right now probably the safest county in Europe. I don't think that I have to explain why.
Poland is a 2nd world country (dump), so, no.
@@NanakiRowan oh yeah? Is Africa a dump too or do you only selectively bash white countries?
@@NanakiRowan have you even been in Poland in recent years?
@@CarmenRZ Yes. Unfortunately, it's still a 2nd world country, and is still classified as such.
@@NanakiRowan so no answer then? Wow, you're really chicken sh..
Our French presidential election had among others 3 themes :
- Le Grand Remplacement (a major campaign theme of Éric Zemmour)
- Le Grand Ruissellement (« the great trickle down economics », promoted by Macron although he spent a lot in aides to fight the inflation, and communist Fabien Roussel talked about the « Roussellement »)
- Le Grand Réchauffement (the emergency of the global warming)
That's really depressing
apparently france is now a complete hellhole though lmao
@@iammrbeat You clearly have not been in european cities recently. As a dutch person i can assure you this agenda is very real. We have small villages with a few hundred people that get swamped by thousands of migrants. These migrants get preferential treatment from the state when it comes to housing and other resources. To lump people who are concerned about this in with white nationalists and nazi's is beyond the pale. These things you dont see on cnn i'm guessing. We dont share your american obsession with race and being "white" whatever that means but we do fear for our children and the safety of our elders. I feel you should visit here and educate yourself on the subject and the policies that advocate for this dissaster.
@@iammrbeat Why isn't mass immigration being accepted into Japan, China, The Middle East? They'd be saying the same thing if they had that. It isn't specific to white people. It's because it is a phenomenon only happening in The West.
Spend money to fight inflation😂 Can you explain?
the world economic forum literally talks about replacing whites with minorities
Proof?
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez google exists
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez go on their website and look at replacement migration or just watch their speeches
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez Try seeking out the wef videos, where you find many of those psycho members speaking of this very issue!
They also speak of 'reducing' the population! I guess you will probably claim, that you cannot find that information!!
@aarongoleman
Looked it up. they were talking about the workforce.
Because Developed countries have lower birthrates but they still need workers. So they need immigrants to replace the workers as they leave the workforce.
It's not really that crazy for economic forums to be thinking about ways to keep an economy growing when the existing populations workforce is decreasing.
Mr. Beat, this is a provocative issue but props to you for making a video like this. Good job!
Thank you, Abe!
@@iammrbeat Thank you for your excellent videos!
You are great Mr. President
@@zainmudassir2964 Thank you!
See any good plays lately?
When Tony Blair became UK Prime Minister in 1997 he immediately quintupled the rate of legal migration to the UK. Andrew Neather, his former speechwriter, revealed in 2009 that the policy was designed not only to address labour shortages but also to make the UK more multicultural. Neather mentioned that ministers intended to "rub the Right's nose in diversity and render their arguments out of date." He also said that ministers were hesitant to discuss this policy openly, fearing it might alienate Labour's core working-class voters.
We've relied on immigration to fill in labour shortages since ww2. Before that we just relied on colonization and slavery. The fact is that this is nothing new and the major world powers have always had to rely on "others" to fill in the bottom of the work hierarchy. Which kind of shows how actually ineffective our economical systems are and how they need major overhauls. Our current system only works on exploitation.
@@josjos-x5scorrect however it almost unprecedented to have, post ww1 unvetted immigration like that seen in the west currently.
@@josjos-x5s Labour opened the first set of floodgates in 1948 correct.
@@Is_it_p Yes literally because without so our country would be in rubble and our industry in shambles for many more years through out the 20th century. It is a smart economical decision. Its funny how racism can literally lead to a faster collapse of your country, get over it, immigration fixed Britain for the time being.
@@josjos-x5s Then THAT'S the discussion that should have been had, because mass-immigration is NOT the answer. Other solutions would be to go where the workers are, or to actually encourage your own population to have children, instead of submitting them to the feminist propaganda of NOT having families like they still are doing to this day, because they want depopulation, but at the same time want to import new "workers". Everything is so backwards, illogical and stupid.
I live in Rochester, NY, me and our greater community has felt so much tension since the Buffalo attack, and I'm sure more diverse communities have felt fear from the growing radicalism in the world.
I greatly appreciate that someone who has a more socially diverse fanbase covered this issue in an effort to combat hatred. I love your content, I binged your SCB series a few weeks back and hope you post more in future.
Thank you so much
So do I I agree
Nice to see another Rochesterian in the comments of Mr. Beat!
pink floyd fan?
Isn't it convenient how you systemcreeps just forget all the black on white crime.
I think that the '1 drop' theory also plays a role in this. That is the idea that if a "White person" and someone of a different "race", or "ethnicity", have children together this means that none of their children or future generations can be considered "White". This is if anything, even dumber than other reasons, but you can see where a belief of this sort could make people fear for the future of "White people".
I mean realistically there's no "they", there is only US. I was typing this while listening to the video, and then you said this yourself, so bonus points for you!
You said one of the quiet parts out loud
@@iammrbeat I certainly did. I think you did a great job on the video, it's important for people to understand this stuff, however unpleasant it may be.
What's crazy is some of the people who subscribe to the one drop rule and consider themselves White may have had ancestors that, by their own definition, were non-White.
@@agentdiamond9211 That is probably even more common than we'd think.
What do people mean when they say things like “abolish whiteness”, then? I mean, there seems to be no confusion about what white is when attacking it, but when running into a defense of it, the common reply seems to be “well it doesn’t even exist so whatever lol”
Which countries that are not majority white are accepting millions of immigrants?
@@mikemalecki1178 every country
saudi arabia has the 3rd highest immigrant population, do you guys ever do any research?
Right wingers live in a fantasy
Uganda, Pakistan, Iran, Turkey, Jordan, Lebanon, Malaysia, Indonesia, Bangladesh,
@@shush6552 yeah and what position in society thosr migrants hold exactlt,
Your Irish Flag was displayed incorrectly. Left to right, the flag displays green, white and orange. You displayed the flag, left to right using orange, white and green. That is actually the Ivorian Flag.
Could be the Irish flag flying to the left instead of the right. Course that would mean very strange cross gale for the Italian flag to point in the opposite direction.
yeah this guy is a stooge, obviously promoted by the fascist communist devs at RUclips and Facebook
Goes to show how thick he is.He is using a great lie from a debunked Canadian liar named Noel Ignatiev ( a man who hated white people).The Irish issue was NEVER about colour.It was a religious fight the Irish and English took to America.
Poetic irony.
He's American not really white lol
As someone who is blind that opening line got me
Wasn't funny and he is right about being not too smart
@@annahawula2427I thought it was pretty damn funny
@@annahawula2427 OK karen.
Leftists are terrible people. There is a reasom they are the only ones that make these kinds of videos and are the only ones in the comment sections of said videos... Its bc yall make this bs up as you go and label it as conservative ideology when really it's all lies and projection. They take the reality of a situation turn it to an extreme radicalize the idea (their specialty along with projection) and turn it loose upon the world. Each leftist is like a tiny one man CNN.
@@theketaminekid1241 OK kid.
The United nations website talks about "replacement migration"
I doubt it's the same antisemitic white supremacist conspiracy theory as in this video.
@@kindnessfirst9670 Wanting to exist, isn't supremacist. You're a racist. You're genocidal.
@@Illumirage How so? Explain it.
@@pro-socialsociopath769 wow you really like to stalk me
@@Illumirage Stalk? It's a youtube video you loser lmao
I'm hard pressed to find a video that's aged worse than this one
Cry
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez lmao you are in the comments for months coping that people are just realizing its happening
go back to your country gimmiegrant
Oh my lord Greek-Americans got a shoutout! Thank you so much! Discussing race as a Greek American is always difficult so I really appreciate just a mention in your video. It means a lot.
@@mangus3433
>implying arbitrary xenophobic rhetoric is well-researched and backed up
Eat the Falafel, go to Church, and drink some alcohol. Me IQ is increasing lol
Go and shove a gyro up where the sun doesnt shine.... AND PAY YOUR DEBTS, mykonos
I love to eat your name Fettucine
@@15Monkes
It is actually well-researched and backed up.
0:45 xenophobia, from xenos and phobos, two Greek words meaning stranger and fear. It actually means fear of strangers. Not so much those that are from a different place but more so those that don't belong to your family, tribe or ethnicity. Even if those people live in the same region as you.
The etymology of a word doesn't define it specifically. It can provide insight into the origins of the word but words are flexible things that change and conform to the people using them. The word xenophobia as Mr. Beat defined it is how he used and how many Americans and probably most english speakers interpret the meaning of the word. It's okay if you think it means something else but it's important to understand what definitions other people are using to understand what they are saying rather than getting bogged down into unproductive semantic arguments.
@@ThyCorruptor The difference here is that xenophobia essentially incorporates a level of racism to it, because despite not considering other races as inferior, it still distances the xenophobe from people of other races and nationalities, even tif they live in the same city or village as him. Whereas saying that the issue is where someone comes from I think downplays the problem.
I'm Xenophobic. Have you seen xenomorphs?
Nothing wrong with that.
@@ThyCorruptor disagree. Words are meant to be taken specifically. If its not the fear of the unknown, its not xenophobia. If its just fear of a culture you somewhat know but don't think you'll like, you're just racist. Phobias are very specific, and people tend to throw them around as if they were just emotions like sad and happy.
PHOBIAS are IRRATIONAL FEARS.
NOT just not liking another culture.
I was only half listening when I heard the name "Camus" and I was like "What the hell??? What does this have to do with absurdism???". I had to go back and listen again. Scared me for a bit.
My thought too!
It's sad such a great man's name has been hijacked by such a Dingus.
@@jeffersonott4357 Very true!
@@jeffersonott4357 absolutely
I was like "well tha beach scene in the stranger was kinda sus" so it kinda bummed me then he said 2017 so i got happy cause i likey liked the stranger
-English Americans used to consider Italians nonwhite
-Therefore race is nothing more than a political tool
How?
How not? One day you are white the other you are not, simple as that
There is an agenda to destroy europeans homelands, by bringin "diveristy", but oh well.
@@somedude8468Sources: "trust me bro"
@@ARTEMIOMENDEZHERNANDEZ-n1msource: reality
@@IllumirageDelusions of maniacs aren't reality
I don't subscribe to the racist implications of GRT and believe in treating everyone equally and fairly, but a couple of points of contention:
1. If you have immigration to the West but not vice versa, there's going to be replacement. That's just being factual, especially with lower western birthrates. If China, India, the Middle East, Africa, and Latin America are allowed to stay relatively static with no inbound migration, but the West is the only region that needs to become more diverse, there will be replacement.
2. Progressives talk enthusiastically about replacement all the time. "Demographics is destiny" they say. It's no accident they have more immigrant friendly policies, they want to accelerate a changing demographic.
3. Western societies have implemented more social services and entitlements than in the past, meaning that immigration will become a more contentious issue because it's no longer just a matter of someone new moving here. Controlling who is a member of the 'club' also controls who is entitled to what financial benefits.
4. At a time when all demographics should have lower birthrates to fight resource scarcity, climate change, and environmental collapse, different groups will cynically use higher birthrates and population as a weapon against those who are responsibly trying to lower their footprint.
5. We have always been apprehensive of newcomers, but it is truly worrying when those new comers don't share your values. France didn't used to have to worry about professors being beheaded for free speech. Now they do. If you wouldn't let in a stranger into your home, why would you let in a group of people that wishes to strip your rights away?
6. Diversity as a strength is incidental. Japan and China have strong societies with less diversity. Diversity can be a weakness. It is much easier for China to send their best spy into American society than for America to send their best Chinese-American spy into China's society.
Just some thoughts...
Here’s a thought: German-Americans are Americans, Irish-Americans are Americans, Italian-Americans are Americans, African-Americans are Americans, Hispanic-Americans are Americans, Iraqi-Americans are Americans. America is better for the German, Irish, Italian, Jewish, Asian, Hispanic, Middle Eastern, etc. immigration of the past (and African-American which is technically not immigration). Diversity makes our culture stronger and richer. Get over it!
@@mikeg2306 Are America and Europe the only places on earth that should become more diverse? Should Africa, South America, and Asia become more diverse too? Why or why not?
@@Raptor302 I fully support your moving to Africa (or anywhere else but here).
@@mikeg2306 Smug, but you didn't answer the question.
@@mikeg2306 Ahh yes the beutiful cultur of california . Tents , poop and end less Narcissism XD
I appreciate that this video was very difficult to produce... thank yout! Your videos underscore the daily necessity of doing the hard work of thinking things through. This requires defining terms, being open-minded, listening, refusing distractions, writing down one's thoughts, self-examinstion... and more.
There are 2 possibilities here
1). Mr Beat did absolutely NO RESEARCH on the claim of WHITE GENOCIDE
2). He did the research and decided to make up his OWN version of White Genocide (Strawman) so he could refute that, since the ACTUAL accusation is totally undeniable
Why would it be "difficult to produce"? He's literally just parroting the globalist media's propaganda talking points.
To learn who rules over you, simply find out who you are not allowed to criticize.
Americans are not allowed to criticize anyone who is Jewish...otherwise it's called "hate crime" or Antisemitism.
That's all you really need to know about the current situation of things in America.
notice he keeps saying "immigrants" and not the more accurate "millions of *ILLEGAL*immigrants"
Walk into any highschool in the cities of Europe, Canada, Australia, or the US then tell me it isn't real.
Thank you for everything you do Mr beat, I got some hate by people on your why people don't like Jews video for mentioning some antisemitism experience I have and I'm glad there's someone who tries so much to educate those around him, one of the best teachers and you make things interesting to watch
Thanks for the kind words...uh...Stalin.
@@iammrbeat wasn't Stalin Antisemitic thank god he grew out of it lol
@@iammrbeat also thank you for blurring the faces of the shooters as to not
You know you...or Stalin, sent Jewish people into internal exile in the USSR? You were kinda ethnically cleansy, comrade. Despite the good you accomplished... just noting.
@@comradestalin1109 gulag them?
One of my grandmas is Romanian. One of my grandmas is Irish. One of my grandpas is native American and one of my grandpas is Italian. My whole family has generational debt written into it. That’s why it makes me angry that these immigrants are getting free stuff and money while my families been here for hundreds of years and still struggling because of limits on such things like loans and homebuying processes and jobs. Now that I’m here there’s not a lot of the same limits, except for citizens. I paid off my parents debt of about 20 to 30 grand in bills for the house that I got meanwhile people that haven’t been in this country for more than three years are getting straight up home loans for houses bigger and better than mine and mine is already too big, it’s really expensive for someone my age. They’re so busy making exceptions for all the new people that they’re not considering any of the people that are still struggling that I’ve been living here for several decades.
Edit: the city here is money, hungry and likes to screw people over. But the immigrants that are moving in here are getting free meals, free bus passes, free almost everything. Those little purchases mean a lot to people that are broke, but why haven’t those things been offered to us, knowing that we need them as well, I believe in people that are in need but I also believe in being responsible. if you can’t even take care of your own people, don’t take more people in so you can get more votes. None of this will strengthen our economy either. Just going to add more people that need help while we’re already giving money to other countries for wars. Why is it fair that my also brown immigrant family got crapped on, so to make up for it, they’re making it so easy for them, they will never know what hit them when all the niceties are over. That, or they will never know the struggle and will continue to invite people over with the prospect of an easy life when it’s not like that for anyone not born with a silver spoon in your mouth.
Camus may have popularized the "Great Replacement Theory", but in the 2000's I was beating the drum for the "Demographics is Destiny!" crowd... who were arguing that replacing the White Americans (and Canadians) was a GOOD thing and was quite happy that by 2050, the USA was going to be primarily non-white for the first time in the history of the United States of America. (it was going to take another 30+ years for Canada at the time - I don't even think there was an official estimate for Canada.) White Americans who hated this were almost entirely Conservatives, openly Christian, were anti-Same Sex Marriage (to the point of many were actually anti-LGBTQ+), and pro-Captialism. All of which we were quite happy to say would be destroyed by the browning of America (a sentiment often shared in the 2000's, though I don't remember if it was actually a slogan like "Demographics is Destiny!" was). America was going to become less Conservative, less Christian, pro-SSM, more anti-Capitalist and overall less Whtie, and this was a good thing to us. Toss in the argument FOR immigration that have been spread in the last 20+ years - particularly the argument that the West isn't having enough babies to fill the jobs we need, so without these immigrants doing jobs that we Westerners didn't want to do - it gets easy to read something nefarious between the lines.
Because I DID mean something Nefarious. I DID mean I wanted to see less White Christian Capitalist Americans (and Westerners in general) in the world. I DID think that taking things (money, power, land, etc.) from White people was perfectly fine. I DID outright want there to be less White people in the world, to be "replaced" by non-Whties. If "White Replacement Theory" was a phrase that was used at the time, I would have been all for it and likely argued passionately in FAVOUR of it. I DID have a "black and white" view of the world, where I laughed at the idea of the Irish and Italians not being "white" - that was a red flag to me that I was dealing with a "White Christian Conservative" and so was not to be taken seriously, for instance. (You can't get much more white than most Irish people, after all, and it is still common for people to talk about the first Slaves in the Americas being Irish, not African) The places I frequented, the people I interacted with, we all held these views or at least espoused these views publicly to fit in. And it wasn't until I was literally holding someone in my arms on the day they were born that I realized that I was arguing to make their lives worse simply because of the colour of their skin, and my perceptions of the sins (ironic for an atheist to think of "sins") associated with that skin colour. I was perfectly fine living a lesser life for myself, but when it was my child that I was condemning to a lesser life... that's probably what broke me out of this line of thinking and this kind of belief far more than anything else could have.
If people like me didn't do what people like me did in the 2000's (and probably before, but it wasn't until the 2000's that I because active in that kind of movement), maybe Camus wouldn't have had fodder for his "Great Replacement Theory". And yes, his reasoning (and the reasoning of the proponents of that specific theory) is irredeemable. But the sentiment DOES exist out there. The problems they are noting DO exist. The changes ARE happening. It's just that nothing is happening the way anyone predicted. The Latino's crossing the southern US border aren't becoming Lifelong Democrats - they're leaving the DNC and becoming Independent (if not outright Republican), and the Pro-Immigrant/Anti-Immigrant argument in the Latino community is as strong and divided as it is in the wider American community. Muslims are not embracing the LGBTQ+, and it's difficult to see if they're embracing Feminism either - it still seems to be a very common expectation among teenage Muslim girls that they're going to get married to someone from the Old Country and start raising a family either right out of high school or maybe they get to go to University first. None of them want Socialism or to get rid of Capitalism, and the vast majority are either Christian (latino's) or Muslim, few to none are leaving their Religion behind and becoming Secular. So what I expected to happen, and what I taunted Conservatives about happening... aren't happening. Conservatives may be more right about what's happening than I was, regardless of the path they took to get to those answers.
Remember: Yesterday’s immigrants always hate today’s immigrants. Today’s immigrants will probably hate tomorrow’s immigrants.
America at its core is a Christian nation and a white nation. That doesn’t mean you need to be a white Christian to be an American, but it does mean that as we drift farther as a society from these ideals, the pillars that hold up society will crumble and chaos will ensue.
Your kid will get what YOU deserve. Enjoy.
There are whole NGOs whose entire purpose is to transport migrants from the global south into the U.S., Canada, and Europe. Obama and Bush just teamed up to create a new one a few days ago as a matter of fact. And there are people like you used to be who think it is a good thing. It drives me insane to see people running around saying what amounts to "it isn't happening but you deserve it." It is happening, any demographic chart you look at shows that the U.S. and Canada will become minority white countries by the end of the century, with Australia and New Zealand not far behind. The UK is probably the most dramatic example we can look at. In the last decade since immigration there has skyrocketed, so has crime, and their world-renowned social services are being strained to the breaking point. Mr. Beat is lying to both his audience and to himself.
We're all going to suffer in the end.
It is truly marvelous to see you + your channel grow to such lengths where you can safely + thoughtfully approach more sensitive topics like this, US - Iranian history, 9/11.
Your style and approach to these give me faith in education + in America as a whole. Matt you're doing truly meaningful work and I congratulate you on your success. Fuck yeah dude.
Mr. Beat has me rethinking the ethics of human cloning :D
With the trend of book-banning and sex-ed limitations on the rise in swaths of the USA, I see Mr Beat as a necessary complement to American education
@@hobog Does the G stand for Groomer?
I would love to see Mr. Beat tackle the history of US regime change; your comment re Iran history made me think of how we overthrew the democratically elected president of Iran in 1953 when he wanted to nationalize their own oil industry.
@@jvo1464 Why would it?
Honestly, this is not a new concept or a new theory. as a Chinese. China has been doing this for thousands of years. since the first emperor of China ordered the relocation of 300,000 soldiers to Guangzhou. intermarriage. another example, the current Chinese government does the same with Uyghurs. A large number of Chinese immigrated to Xinjiang. That's why the Uyghurs protested. They want to replace Uyghurs with Han Chinese. It's no secret. And it's no secret now that we've been using Chinese immigrants to buy foreign land. buy everything. Not just Europe. South America. Africa. Asia. Same for Hong Kong. 150 Chinese immigrants to Hong Kong every day. The effect is slow but very effective.
to be fair , hong kongers are chinese . well cantonese but thats the region's name
these Baizuo simpletons will not listen to you
@@rumbling3991 Prove that even people of the same race are interchangeable. Politics, culture, beliefs. There are many things that can be replaced. It's not just superficial that stays on the skin color.
@@rumbling3991 nope.
@@chiuansheng that proves nothing, they aren't even correct.
This video aged like fine wine
No
@@IllumirageWhat a comprensible and complex argument backed by scientific research... Wow...
@@ArtemioMendezHernandezthat's ironic coming from you
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez Yeah, because OP made q so comprehensible and complex argument himself
Play stupid games, win stupid prizes
@@kidkangaroo5213 Cry
There is a great video that talks about part of the subject, it's called "Tribalism: weaponizing culture". One of my favorite videos that breakdown how we fall into conflict of "we and they".
thanks. I'll look it up>
i will never vote democrat based on the 1965 inmigration act alone
@@bryanice3313 We do not care
@@bryanice3313 1965 sure had lots of American xenophobia... Hm. twenty years after the end of ww2. All the baby boomers, just military age, had grown up with all their parents stories of fighting the evil Germans and Japanese.
March 7 - "Bloody Sunday": Some 200 Alabama State Troopers attack 525 civil rights demonstrators in Selma, Alabama, as they attempt to march to the state capitol of Montgomery.
March 8 - Vietnam War: Some 3,500 United States Marines arrive in Da Nang, South Vietnam, becoming the first American ground combat troops in Vietnam.
@@jessielove1252 It is xenophobia to want to have a nation and people?
No.
Before watching this video, I had never heard of this "Great Replacement Theory." When you mentioned the shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh, I remembered something that I heard on the news a few years back. My hometown had an anti-semetic synagogue shooting in April of 2019 and the shooter referenced the Pittsburgh shooter as an inspiration. When I looked into it, it turns out that his manifesto included many of the beliefs expressed by this theory. As a history major, it's always interesting learning more about my hometown, even if it isn't so great. Thank you, Mr. Beat.
@David Herschel based
@David Herschel but see it goes both ways. That's what a shooter could say to his alt-right buddies before "going in"
@David Herschel in facts I think that might've been what you were referring to...
It’s genuinely so disappointing reading hateful stuff online and even in this comment section cause it reminds me that it leads to real world consequences like the Pittsburgh shooting.
@David Herschel No dude I don’t think you’re some random hick from Alabama. I just can’t imagine constantly being angry and sad and hateful all the fucking time every day. I don’t think there’s anything logical about it
4:14 There is an error in the Irish flag. You stated earlier this was ‘Irish-Americans’ but that is the flag of Ivory Coast! The Ireland flag is upside down. :)
Good eye
damn, even the flag got replaced!
No left-wing bias in this video then. There is a lot of evidence show the opposite of what he says is true.
Yup, but instead he chooses to strawman and deny reality. Typical of his kind.
Literally you're just lying there isnt a shred of info that confirms the fantasy you live in sich is the life of a sad Conservative reality denier
Yeahhh this video does not hold true for Europe at all. A lot of Europeans are now becoming right wing because they are being taken over by the sheer number of immigrants coming in from the Muslim world who are not assimilating into the culture of the countries they move to.
In the uk for example, there has been grooming gangs in a few cities that have been run by mostly muslim men that have been allowed to operate without any consequences due to the police fearing being labeled as racist or islamophobic if they intervene. There have been Muslims shouting things such as "sharia for uk" and theres currently a case ongoing where a Muslim religious leader is trying to buy an island in Scotland amd turn it into a caliphate
“Fellow white people”
Every single time!
He’s not Jewish accept the fact that most people don’t agree with your nazi ideas💀
Everystein Singleberg Timeowitz
@@danielpiesto532 lol
show host is a cuck. his wife must really like the blackies.
wait ? is he ?
I never comment on videos, but this was so well made and educational that I couldn't resist. THIS VIDEO SHOULD BE SHARED AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE. thank you @mr.beat!!!
Gullermo why did your blood slaughter mine with the democrat party?
i agree!
Unfortunately he doesn't really address what people who believe in the Great Replacement actually think it is, and he contradicts himself constantly.
The Great Replacement. already happened in Canada and all over the U.S, Hawaii, australia and new zealand, Palestine,
all the settler colonialism already had The Great Replacement.
The Great Replacement Theory. is not a Theory.
@@husndymabjr6763 facts
This plank needs to revisit this video and see if he still feels the same today. Have a look around fella .
He should spend a few nights in london
23:32 I wish the "diversity" teacher I had in college understood your closing statement. White students were not allowed to opine for about half of her class, we were segregated by race and told that anything we say is just a reflection of inherited power that must be reversed, and by not speaking, we are doing more to help the cause than by speaking
I agree with every point made in your video completely. And at the same time, there also exist racists from races other than white. And they can do damaging things out of racism as well. Try living in some So Cal neighborhoods with white skin. Gangsters target white people because of their skin color, with their head full of bullshit propaganda about "la raza," their "superior" race, and the "honor" of fighting the white race for their "noble" cause.
What kind of college is this…
You are not segregated by race if u are among the 10% . Racism occurs only at…..
Sounds very progressive to me.
Sounds like american history in reverse
Really appreciate you putting this positivity into a space so often filled with the opposite. Hope all is well! (PS, still got my ENR sticker on my bumper)
ignorance and passivity is a powerfull drug. Better to close your eyes,saw your ears off and live in positive thinking fantasy land when your lineage and culture is going to be errased and replaced for profits.
Now do this same video but supporting non Jewish immigration into Israel
Non-Jews who keep the Noahide laws may live in Israel.
Oy vey! Anti-semetic attack reported to the ADL
they need diversity. Coming from a goyim myself
you know he will never.
Or any african country
“The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.”
Quoting a book doesn't make it any more real, pepe
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez do you know math?
@@69pepe420 I don't cry over numbers, pepe
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez no you just ignore reality. keep ignoring, you will be sent home or taken care of soon
@@69pepe420 LOL, dream about it pepe, I live rent free on your liberal mind
The craziest thing to me about watching this was the fact that I had to keep convincing myself that anyone actually needed to be told this lol I still can't help but feel like this is like someone from early times trying to teach someone from today the benefits of cooking your food... Like yeah, dua... Right?
As much as you had to convince yourself,I have had to deal with too many people in the past few years that believe in a "raw food diet".
It has to be explained to people that just because people did it that way, at some point in time, does not make it right.
The convincing yourself disappears when you stay at it day to day. First horror as the shock sinks in, then ever growing sadness as the realization that it is farther spread than you could imagine.
@@targetthetank it's funny that you mentioned "raw food diet" because after I posted my comment I thought of that and how ridiculous some people get with all that... But you are right, I'm to say, there are still far too many people who are crazy and racist.
If I had seen this 5 or 6 years ago, I would've felt the same way. I didn't realize how much of the country is totally fucked. I mean, I knew it, but it was an existential knowledge, a knowledge that the status quo sucks, but real people in my day to day life were different. It was a rude awakening. I think most people are really poor observers. I always thought most people were like me, but I was wrong. It's one of the most unsatisfying conclusions I've come to, especially because I don't think I'm particularly smart.
"The Great Replacement is a conspiracy theory, but it's also happening and you're a bigot if you have a problem with it."
@@jollygrapefruit786 cry harder
"Don't be racist, I am a building"
And I am a Plane.
@@patriotenfield3276 and I Am a M1 Abrams Tank
@@christianalmon4117 And I'm a genocidal racist! :)
Europeans- Irish and Italians did, in fact, assimilate in all Anglo-majority countries. Not so much, non-Europeans.
Cry harder
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez lols
@@ArtemioMendezHernandezanti white found whites invented everything
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez You're about to go home 😂
@@berlingolingoful There are a few problems with this claim. Firstly it ignores that assimilation took the better part of a century. In some sense Irish and Italians assimilated quickly in that some of them became part of the political establishment in cities where they were a large part of the population. In other senses it took a century for them to assimilate. The Italian American Mafia wasn't broken until the 80s, and Italian Americans still to this day massively under perform in educational attainment. Italians are closer to Hispanics than to English Americans in their rate of college education. America has also never had an Italian president, and Biden was probably the first time being an Irish Catholic wasn't seen as a relevant political issue, when Kennedy was elected there were still people concerned the Pope was going to be giving him orders.
By comparison, Asian Americans and African immigrants have much higher achievement in income and education, largely because they immigrated after immigration policy favoured people with money and education. Additionally Asians are more likely to marry outside their community than Europeans. A very good case can be made that Indian and Chinese Americans are better assimilated than the Italians.
Countries are absolutely changing due to immigration culturally, religiously, socially and politically.
At most, it's a slight change. Most immigrants assimilate into the culture that they arrive to.
@@El_Crononautano
@@El_Crononautait’s not a slight change
@@rn6312meds, now
@@rn6312"If you can convince the lowest white man he's better than the best colored man, he won't notice you're picking his pocket. Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he'll empty his pockets for you."- President Lyndon B. Johnson.
This quote can be perfectly applied to him (Damien) and others in this comment section.
Can we get an early life check for our good chum Mr. Beat here, anyone?
I think we all know he's a 109er bro
Always remember, no matter what you think, you are not immune to propaganda.
And this video is a tremendous piece of propaganda.
Like this video pushed by RUclipss algorithm.
@@moshow93 cope nazi
@@HighFlyingOwlOfMinerva cope nazi
@@HighFlyingOwlOfMinerva Elaborate
Barbara Specter
And people if her ilk
Shhhh,
@@lordm1889 Talk anyway
Not evidence
@@soulplexisIt is but hey ignore it
She also stated Jews should accept the hatred since they are behind it all
"They cannot replace us... Because they are us."
Wew, if only Israel subscribed to that same idea.
Ohohoho we don't talk about that here, its politcal friendly space !!!
based
Yes this applies to Jews as well,
Open borders for Israel but unironically.
Diversity and race mixing for Israel.
You mean the same country that actively supports the anti immigrant, racist, white nationalist regimes in Hungary, Poland and Brazil?
It's really happening Not a theory.
Sure thing, righhhhhhhht
Even someone as far gone as you can't argue the hard numbers. So, ad hominem it is...@@ArtemioMendezHernandez
Memes are easily the biggest driving force of radicalism. Can be made by anybody, for any purpose with baseless claims and no sources. They are also really good cover for "It's just a joke" and "I wasn't serious when I made it".
Or maybe it's because something has to be based in truth in order for it to be funny
I was dead serious.
Yeah, and it is frightening thinking about the children who could accidentally indoctrinate themselves.
Just think of stonetoss, that's an example of right wing radicalization passed as memes.
@@crazyitalianguy000 They are billiant. People get radicallized all day by mainstream media etc. Of course there is going to be a counter culture towards it.
It's not real....but it's happening and that's a GOOD thing!
Do something about it
@ArtemioMendezHernandez ooh big mad!
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez Make me a burrito
@@ippoverse Siberian Gulags await
Quiet jew
Calling it theory is beyond disingenuous.
but hey thats just a theory a game theory i just simaltainiously whipped and nae naed sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness sans is ness hello internet welcome to game theory!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You people serve a function. You will still be around to serve that function. We want your population to increase not decrease, silly. ☺️
If somehow it does manage to decrease significantly I'm going to be very annoyed, because that would be entirely on you. What are we supposed to do, force you breed?
The newcomers will be put in their place. You just have to give it time ...
Why would we want to get rid of you? What's the reason?
@@pro-socialsociopath769
To take over the country and implement one party rule? The same way a foreign invader wants to take over a country. You can either do it via war or importing as many third world animals as possible.
Love and kindness can't be promoted if you can't first take care of your own kind. We are not all one race, we need to take care of our own, otherwise we can't help anymore.
Lol
Because last time you cared for your own ended so good
@@ArtemioMendezHernandezhow is caring for your own wrong?
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez His spirit shall rise from the grave, and everyone will know he was right. Even know they control every major corporation, every major bank, every media agency, every porn company, dating app, money apps, social media platforms, all the health organizations, and every major country across the world. There is and always has been one common denominator, and if you don't see who that is at this point you are clearly blind.
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez They own everything, and they censor anyone who says so because they don't want you to see it. Even now my comments are being hidden because they want to suppress the truth.
Native Americans: Yea the great replacement is true.
It always fascinated me why Americans claim that they don't like immigrants when they're immigrants themselves (talking about anyone who is not a native american/indian)
Don't forget Palestinians and Native Australians too
@@i_likemen5614 nah Palastine and Israelites have always lived there so its less Replacement and more an old grudge as old as if not older than the bible itself that just got a new religous and national spin due to the Brits carving up the Near East.
To be fair though its usually the less powerful that gets replaced so yeah in a twisted way its correct.
@@Dac_DT_MKD its probably projection lol
Given the mass expulsion of Jews almost 2000 years ago, what is the chance that you have a Jewish ancestor? Pretty good i would think.
The fact that these group of people have been persecuted for millennias, they should begin to ask themselves if it’s “us” or “their” fault.
@@DefyLov3 109 never their fault
That thought sickens me
Biden has allowed more illegals in than American babies were born in the entire country. His goal is to flood the country with migrants, get them on welfare, and give them amnesty in time for the election so they will vote for him. Talk about election interference. It's not just some antisemitic conspiracy -- all Americans are being replaced -- do you think the Blacks on the South side of Chicago aren't being replaced? Or the citizens in NYC? Wake up, this isn't about Jews, this is about UN agenda 2030, and the WEF working with Biden towards the Great Reset.
Every single time
Thank you so much for this video Mr.Beat! I've been a subscriber for years and I've always really admired and appreciated how responsibly you use your platform.
Thank you so much, Harrison!
@@iammrbeat the people who support great replacement and other white supermisist ideas will say going back to Colonial America when the land was setter clonized by England the Brtish Empire and after American Revolution when USA became a Country after independence from Brtish Empire the 1st naturalization laws in 1790 gave American citizenship to free white people of good chacter and that the people of the 18th century the founders of America never would have allowed black African people from African countries Asian people from India China Japan Indonesia Vietnam South Korea or Korea Sir Lanka. The Middle Eastern countries Iraq Mesopotamia Iran Persia Arabs Turkish Ottoman Empire Egyptian Syria Lebanon Jordan Palestine. To come to America in fact most western countries during the colonial era would not allow non white people. So why should a country established by western Europen people allow people from non western white European backgrounds. They will say every non white country or even some other western countries like Eastern Europe Central Europen countries are allowed to keep demographic the same yet western Europen countries the ex colonial powers are not.
"Responsible" is to brainlessly parrot the propaganda of the rich and powerful elites?
Hello White (?) version of me
@@JoJoRogain Hey whats up? Are you the Asian me? Lmao
Israel NEEDS diversity! When will Israel know it’s future is multicultural and diverse!?
Shut up Biden, he never brought Israel up
That's what Hitler tried to do lmao. If anyone also knows anything about a lot of history, especially with many countries in the past, they were forcibly rp ed by people from other countries to intentionally "unpure their bloodline".
Why are so many comments bringing up israel? literally nothing to do with the video
Not to say that Israel's population isn't problematically xenophobic itself, but that's a different topic
Israel is more diverse than most countries in the middle east.
@@tadeojablonski105 Hamas is designated as a terrorist organization.
It's not wrong. Even if ppl don't like it
it's an inconvenient truth
@@rn6312 Y ou and all y ou r friends literally laugh about how y ou're doing it every f ucking day.
@@rn6312projection
@@rn6312 That's a lose lose situation for me (and you). Even if I win (which I would) I'd go to jail for life so. You're psychotic for even suggesting this and it just goes to show you how mentally broken you become when you hear different opinions. Your entire world stands still and you have another break down....
@@rn6312 That's yet another death threat by the way. I'll be screen shotting this too...
The white (not including Hispanic or Latino) has decreased by 3% over the course of 10 years between 2010 and 2020. The fact of the matter is, is that it is true that the white population in the US is actively decreasing, whether you want to attribute it to some boogeyman is up to you.
This is readily explained by the fact that more light-skinned people are choosing to identify themselves differently. Unless you think millions of people evaporated in 10 years.
@@PlatinumAltaria White birth rate levels are below replacement level, so people aren't "evaporating", they are just dying off.
@@PlatinumAltaria yes it’s called old people dying buddy
Non hispanic white population in USA :
1990 : 75,8% (188,128,296)
2000 : 69,1% (194,552,774)
2010 : 63,7% (196,817,552)
2020 : 57,8% (191,697,647)
@@PlatinumAltaria Non whites make more children and old whites are dying. Combine that with mass immigration of non whites and you have white numbers that decrease at a rapid rate. Is that such a difficult conclusion to get to?
I remember digging myself a rabbit hole in wikipedia until I found this conspiracy theory and I was surprise and baffled on what I was reading. Wikipedia does a good job leading me into huge rabbit holes that just makes my head spin
Well wikipedia has been proven to have a left wing bias and delete factual edits in posts that could discredit liberal talking points
You must not be very bright.
where is the conspiracy though?
@@gaatjeniksaan5606 what has that to do on what I’m talking about?
@@gaatjeniksaan5606 Shut up
They just admitted it in London
Watch the tune change if ever Europeans are imported into non-european countries
Cough cough South Africa... and white people oppressed blacks there too... what a surprise... learn history Chris.
@@themysteriousgravityfalls sub saharan Africans were importing Europeans there? doubt any history book would say that or journals of people going there.
Colonisation?
Two words: South Africa. They act as if nonwhites reclaiming the land are “invaders”.
South Africa?
Why doesn't Israel accept some african refugees? They could use some diversity. Maybe some Palestinians?
Israel is already 1/3 Palestinian. Why don’t you just say you’re anti Semitic and stop hiding behind dog whistles it’s not clever in the slightest
@@Dorkeydaze Actually it's only 20 percent. Why shouldn't it be more? Israel has a high standard of living, surely they could help out some of their neighbors.
@@AhhBeejams
I agree same for Europe the United States and Canada and Australia :)
@@AhhBeejams Non-Jews who keep the Noahide laws may live in Israel.
@@hrvatskinoahid1048 Open Borders For Israel.
This is why I can't find a restaurant in Texas with really good guacamole.
I'm in Texas, too. You gotta make it yourself. :(
You don't need trillions of Mexicans in your country to experience tacos. Look up a recipe.
The question or statement that race is not biological but cultural is confusing. We can determine from a skeleton the gender and race of the person with great accuracy due to bone structure and length ratio, skull thickness etc etc. Can you clarify that?
He's a lying disgrace.
@@_.Rachel_.Stick to the kitchen
Pure bs, if you could tell the difference between a German and a French man you would have know it by now, but you can't, because they have insignificant differences between them that make them indeferent of one another, apart form regional adaptations
Its deliberate. Exactly the same as with gender. They say that its culture and if you eat enough taco bell you become mexican
@@ArtemioMendezHernandez That's a strawman. OP said race, not nationality.
When you say something like "race isn't a biological reality", you NEED (seriously) to couch that with science. This may seem trivial, and like a lesson in pointless repetition, but it's critical that you explain it EVERY TIME. Because if not explained, it becomes an immediate "ah ha! this guy is an idiot" for folks that are just looking for something to discredit you.
And then again, its fake. Race is a biological reality, there are many problems of finding organs compatible for surgery for mixed-race people for that exact reason
It's also not true
Race isn't a biological reality. Phenotypes and culture are constantly being confused with race.
Yea you need to explain how it's a social construct otherwise the believers of this conspiracy will bring it up
Yeah, only one glance at a science book or a genetics course will indicate that genetic and behavioral traits are attributed to heredity. OF COURSE we all understand that cognitive ability shouldn’t be the sole factor in judging a person’s character.. but being correct 8.5 times out of ten is a much better starting point than a blind stumble. There is a reason why there is over representation of a particular nature (race, ethnicity, religion) in every place that it manifests (occupation, athletics, education, criminal justice system). This is outlined well in the book The Bell Curve which is often trashed but never challenged with data (to my knowledge). In closing, I would hope each person takes the time to judge on the content of one’s character. But, to oversimply and say that there aren’t many things that play into this equasion is just an attempt to make a uncomfortable subject into a feel good one.
Im irish, my people were persecuted by the english aswell as the americans. The british used mass migrations of anglos and scots to northern ireland to replace us natives. In total over 150,000 people over a course of over 80 years were planted in ulster. In 2023 that number was dwarfed, over 180,000 people had come to ireland. More people than the entire 80 year long plantation that stripped ireland of a quarter of her land.
The plantations stripper the lands and livelihoods from garlic irish people and gave it to Protestant Scots and English men.
No land is being given to modern immigrants.
They are incomparable
You're describing colonialism. These people are trying to say what's happening now is happening on purpose.
@@foolishgamer99 Plantation not colonialism don’t you dare lecture me on what colonialism is
@@foolishgamer99 an organised movement of people’s to replace a native population is plantation
Tough look paddy
I've shared this video with ten of my friends of all races - I've asked them to share it - because, as a disabled veteran, it kills me to think how crazy we've become over race - when in combat, it didn't matter what color the man to my right or left was - all that mattered was did he have my back - and did I have his. And for those of us who were wounded and died - all our blood on the battlefield was RED
My respect goes out to you. Veterans do more than we give em credit for.
Were you killing other races?
a dog also bleeds red. does that make you a dog?
Haha yeah we have the same color blood that means we are the same right?
@@yeehaw3792 God has clearly shown us in his word we are to remain separate. what an amazing test He has set up for these days. what does a person fear more? God or being called a racist.
Replacement theory is right though and I'm living through it right now. Xenophobia does not exist if assimilation does not exist.
Wow where you live
Thank you so much for making this video, Mr. Beat. Considering that you have a pretty diverse and wide-reaching audience, it’s particularly important that you get this message out. I’m a longtime fan, and to be fully honest I fell down the far-right rabbit hole for a bit, so I’m glad to see you speak out against such hateful and unsubstantiated claims.
Are the % of the population in Western countries who identify as 'white' decreasing or increasing?
Shame that you ended up falling in the far-left hole instead now.
This rabbit hole?
www.spectator.co.uk/article/a-post-racial-world-the-last-white-man-by-mohsin-hamid-reviewed
Sjw
Says 4 replies but I don't see any.
The editing in this video was so high quality compared to recent videos. Did you hire an editor? Looks great!
Edit: Just checked the credits in the description. Love the new editing!
he was hired to try to gaslight whites into thinking that Europe & America are not being turned non-White - that's why. They have done this before. Google/youtube hides all of the videos of Whites OBJECTING to genocide and PROMOTES videos like these that argue in FAVOR of White Genocide
funding for editor provided by the ADL lol
When you are a professional bootlicker like Mr Beat, all of the resources of the Establishment suddenly become at your disposition.
If you look at UK adverts you would think that the UK only had mixed race couples which means their children would be mixed race and the country would lose the majority of white people. But the percentage of white British in the real world is about 81%, which is a big decrease since the 90s and will only decrease further because white British are having less children and the amount of immigrants arriving in the UK. So you never know if things carry on the way the UK is going it could be a possibility.
You have pointed out one of the big problems with this conspiracy theory. Even if we stopped all immigration, the percentage of white would still decrease, as would the percentage of all ethnicities because people will have mixed race children.
And for these racists, a half white person is not white. They consider Obama for example to be black despite him being half black and half white, this their racist views have doomed white people to extinction regardless of immigration levels.
Really the only way to address their grievances would be to ban interracial marriage, but they can't say that because it would hurt their messaging.
This is a lie, all UK census show that the immigrants are not a big ethnicities
@@gahelo that was a lie. You lied
@@yoloswaggins7121 nope. The population might decrease but everyone would still be white...
Disingenuous Argument from a racist (you)
@Damien INSANE-O whenever someone says something you don't like you call them a racist 💀 The fear and projection Is hilarious
"It's not real, but if it's happening it's good"
Do something about it
@@ArtemioMendezHernandezdeport
@@ArtemioMendezHernandezoh we will :)
@@trollingimperialist9930The feds won't let you, blud
@@IllumirageDo it
Why doesn't this fellow White run this video in Israel as they seem to be really worried about their demographics to the point of their current mowing of the lawn.
Bruh what's this correlation
@@frobsonsdesenhos seems to me his ethnic group in Israel is extremely nationalistic and afraid of being replaced to the point of removing and killing the native Palestinians. He needs to stop worrying about White nationalists as no nation exists - and start worrying about actual ethnic nationalistic like his own Israel
@@frobsonsdesenhosthe correlation? No correlation, it’s just that we all have to accept that diversity is our strength, especially our greatest ally in the Middle East, Israel! Open borders! Free healthcare and housing for Refugees! Immigrants welcome!
@@frobsonsdesenhos well we only want the best , diversity, for our greatest ally...:!!!!
is he part to the tribe?
During WWII the Army had to establish Japanese language schools, as many AJAs did not have the language skills, in spite of their parents efforts. In the Western U.S. Asians were institutionally discriminated against into the first half of the 20th Century.
“The problem is subjective framing” proceeds to commit every logical fallacy. I don’t even disagree with the message but this doesn’t acknowledge any actual evidence or argument contrary to his narrative
Because the gaslighting he's doing doesn't work to anyone who goes to any major city in a white country on earth.
Is the replacement happening? I need only look out the window to confirm that. And it is speeding up. Even some liberal friends I have are starting to get worried. "Theory" my ass.
Nothing you can do unfortunately, those times have been leaved in the past
@@ArtemioMendezHernandezplenty we can do.
@@Illumirage That you can do it doesn't mean you have the will to, nobody supports your ideal lib
@@ArtemioMendezHernandezno, plenty of people suppport. You lost
@@IllumirageThe minority, you really think 76 million of people can make the rest follow them? You're in for the biggest reality slap, ever
@Mr. Beat Just stumbled across your channel. Very informative and enlightening. Subscribed!
Thanks Eric!
@@iammrbeatyou're a genocidal racist
@@iammrbeatlove that your channel supports the genocide of a minority ethnicity, very cool!
Great video! Now make a video debunking the FBI crime statistics 😍😘
He should make one debunking what happened on the USS Liberty.
_Wait..._
I'll do it for you:
- There aren't genetic differences between races.
- There are 4 times more Blacks in prisons than the general population.
> There must be a systemic reason for excess Black imprisonment.
> There is systemic racism in the US.
@@userlog2474 I'd reply to this comment, but my friendly melanin-coloured neighbour borrowed my laptop without giving it back. Currently writing this on my phone.
@@HighFlyingOwlOfMinerva You literally did reply, but that's not the point; make a counter-argument.
@@userlog2474 I would, but my phone was just borrowed withour given back by my friendly melanin-coloured neighbour. Typing this on my friends's computer as we speak
One important point that's often missed is that susceptibility to radicalizing rhetoric is correlated with the economic status of the listener. Germans "fell" for Nazi rhetoric in part due to the harsh economic conditions post WWI. Industry has been leaving America for decades now and so the idea to "return to a better time" (i.e. MAGA) resonates because it's based on some level of truth.
They didn't "fall" for anything - they *wanted* it. They *wanted* Uncle A to win becausr they saw just how decadent and bankrupt the internationalist and American-influenced Weimar Republic had become.
True true
If you believe something that I don’t that means you’re poor and stupid! Okay mutt
Yeah a lot of alt-right talking points misdiagnose issues that white young men have to breed hate.
Weimar germany had pedophilia nad trans lgntq propaganda made by jews
"The Great Replacement isn't happening, but it's good that culture is getting replaced."
What culture mf, you used to think cigarette where good for women
What culture? The United States is a mix of Mexican, English and German things, with a bit of Native American in between
@@armandoventura9043 the culture that people all over the world emulate. Keep coping though, illegal immigrant proponent...
@@IllumirageBut by the people you defend your culture is degenerate and corrupted, you're a liar
@@IllumirageSo a melting pot