18 to 19 to 20 are SO DIFFERENT, we had 2018 when she was rlly raspy but a beautiful tone, then 2019 came and she had a clearer voice sith a girly tone, and then 2020 her tone became even more lighter probably even lighter than daydream
no, it wasn't. the last time Mariah sang this phrase live was on the first leg of The Butterfly Returns in 2018. even on the later dates of that leg, she realized she had to rely on a track (and she did) because it's obvious that she struggled with some attempts. 🤷🏻♂️
I very vaguely remembered watching one version she growls the whole GROUND and i couldnt remember which one it was. this video just gave me a shit ton of videos to choose from without me asking for a solution xD
What improvement? Ever since 1995 her voice has been changing for the worse but holy moley did 2018 to 2020 sound bad. 2019 did sound the best out of those years but not by much.
@@thebestcicinmage4485 instead of saying that, prove to me what is wrong. Don't just be an idiot and say it's "wrong", thinking the majority is going to assist you.
In order of preference, 2003; 2005; 2010 the best MIH years (in my humble opinion). I'm not including 2009 only because of that lackluster Today Show performance (not shown here)
i watched it, and say, it's not the quality she had in her early days, let's be honest, she sings the note solid ground lower now, then she did earlier in her career, or gives it an acrobatic turn.
@@daydreamera1996 they were all fake he got it from an interview and the rest he hired a voice actor and don’t act like u didn’t sleep with tommy for a record deal cause we all know u did
![[RARE UNSEEN] Mariah Carey - Emotions (Live in Perth, Butterfly Tour - 1998) Pro Shot](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MAFq0zLQdVI/mqdefault.jpg)
Only Mariah can make me sit through a whole video of her repeating the same line.
LMFAOOOOOOOOO OKAY
i mean, she's been singing for.. 33 years..?
6:10 plsss, the best “GROUNNND” of the whole career
Do you have a date ?
@@swithunis this is Los Angeles 2010, i don’t know the date specifically
UGH IT'S SO EARGASMIC OMG
1:54
While the location of Mariah’s residence is not publicly known, legend has it that she’s been living in the 5th octave since her debut in 1990
she really said "SOLID GROWL"
Ikr and she really turn into a lion in 2010 😂
@@TheLegendofMariah my era slaying 😍
I CAN'T UNHEAR SOLID GROWL NOW LMAOO
THE WAY WE HEARD HER VOICE HEAL OVER THE COURSE OF 2018 😫😫😫
2:22 gotta love that famous crack
8:13 that day her voice was HEALTHY and she wanted us to KNOW it
Thats playback 😢
5:39 was so resonant and that GROOOUUNA killed my existence.. like I jus floated off to heaven.
6:09
The best ever!!!!!
1:22 dayriah really out there growing with resonant in it
with angelic tone, periodt
@@butterflyera4628✨as u should✨
18 to 19 to 20 are SO DIFFERENT, we had 2018 when she was rlly raspy but a beautiful tone, then 2019 came and she had a clearer voice sith a girly tone, and then 2020 her tone became even more lighter probably even lighter than daydream
Because after the first leg of BTR in 2018 she started lipping it 💀
@@YoungArtistyeah yes with 2 récent prerecorded one 😅
@@YoungArtistyeah oop- 👁️💧👄💧👁️
@@YoungArtistyeah i also think confidence and her removing that damn corset was a main factor, bc she did not lip it always i feel?
cause of her nodules she has to sing more nasally
The ease and freedom to soar with her chest voice during the Daydream era was incomparable!
Rainbow ate and left no crumbs. That P#10 at 2:22 😍
6:21
HELP KEJXJEKXJENSKWKKZJSKSKS
2:22 yasss flopbow give us nothing
🦗
@@rainbowriah it’s okay rainbow they just jealous cause they don’t got your tone🙄
@@moaia5049 tone =/= good singing sis. she flopped that era 🤭🤭
crackbow
5:39 , 6:09 how these theatres still have roofs??!?!?
Well the floor is definitely not solid enough for JHoe
@@daviontn5397 I think you mean Jello💀
@@Fishriah_Ari no, you mean I'm Fraud
@@hughw2377 no I think y’all mean thieving bitch
These comments lmao💀💀
6:08 will forever be iconic #Earthquakeriah
2:45 slayed while sick purrr
How are y’all comfortable saying that 2005 and 2010 are on the same level vocally? 2010 is just objectively better.
I love it when she's Growling. 2010 for me was the BEAST!!!
2010 rlly did it best 😍
Iconic
6:47 the F#5 sounds so cute
2009-2010 was phenomenal!!
los angeles 93 is in the same key as NYC 93, C minor instead of C# minor
6:20 the best 😍
Unironically I actually like this performance
7:41 she's so sad 😭
7:30 2016 vocals.
The "thank you lord" isn't as there is a run on the end if you listen
7:42 SHE WAS FEELING IT
Her voice was really restricted in 2018-2019 :(
@@rosemont2283 I know 😩 and despite that she still ate ikdr
Is the last 2020 one live? It sounds so clean!!
Yesss 100% live
no, it wasn't. the last time Mariah sang this phrase live was on the first leg of The Butterfly Returns in 2018.
even on the later dates of that leg, she realized she had to rely on a track (and she did) because it's obvious that she struggled with some attempts. 🤷🏻♂️
7:00 didn’t even try lmfao
Lol she was drunk or high that concert
@@TheLegendofMariah i know haha i love it
My babies 2002-2004 finished them all
Jesus christ Lol
8:03 i love her stamp 😍❤️
2003 sounds so good
@LambilyXDaydream nah 2003 is the best in this video
@LambilyXDaydream shut up I didn’t know what imo was 💀 don’t be rude
@LambilyXDaydream I just defend myself from people like you 😊
@@daydreamera1996 I have the keys to ur Prison don’t make me lock u in forever
@Dubairiah 2004 2003 has better tone
2010 was the best in this video easy
2005 Live 8 is my all time fave
2:50 YEAH
Whenever shit hit the e5 on 2018 it’s like people knew she finally hit the note right and went crazy
Thank you Mariah for solidifying Earth.
2010 literally destroys her prime E5s including Daydream.
I was just attempting this yesterday 😂
Well did u slay?
Yep 😉 I did the 2010 version
@@wildnfearless9840 post
@@lanaandthediamonds3651 Eventually dahling
@@daydreamera1996 Yeah I'm a singer and a lamb
THANK YOU LORD!!!
6:14 🤯🤯🤯
4:20 my personal favorite 🤣
This song just flourished in the late 00s and 10s
I very vaguely remembered watching one version she growls the whole GROUND and i couldnt remember which one it was. this video just gave me a shit ton of videos to choose from without me asking for a solution xD
You can hear the improvements in 19 and 20. Well rested and healthy
Yes Can hear thé pré recorded track After 2018 😬
What improvement? Ever since 1995 her voice has been changing for the worse but holy moley did 2018 to 2020 sound bad. 2019 did sound the best out of those years but not by much.
Uuuh Troll alert!
@@tonshaad1230 this statement is riddled with falseness
@@thebestcicinmage4485 instead of saying that, prove to me what is wrong. Don't just be an idiot and say it's "wrong", thinking the majority is going to assist you.
3:10!!!!!!!!
5:16 charm been quiet 🤔
You sound like ur vomiting sit down
@@lanaandthediamonds3651 u sound like a tired big old bear
@Dubairiah 2004 get video of your concert 🥰
i slayed but 2010 me slayed real hard
2003 is the real queen
03:50 where did this come from??
las vegas
But her recent ones are some of the best tho and more consistent then the 90’s
a majority of the 2018 and 2019 ones were pre recorded, but i definitely prefer them to some of the 90s ones!
In order of preference, 2003; 2005; 2010 the best MIH years (in my humble opinion). I'm not including 2009 only because of that lackluster Today Show performance (not shown here)
2010 supremacy
1998-2000 you can tell she was over worked and not resting 😢
3:50 what date was this?
that blue dress look classic ❤️
2010 slayed them all🙄✋
me slaying ofc🤩
6:13 the best
I wanna hear Beyoncé's growls on this
YESS OMGG! AN ACTUAL EARTHQUAKE WILL HAPPEN
i just know that'll be fire🔥🔥🔥
6:45 Oh My😥.....
Iconic vocals
3:40 OH MY GOD??
Os melhores E5/Eb5s estão aqui 😍
Awesome ⚘💖🎄🎁🦋🌞😉
Thank you 😇⚘💖🌞😉🎄🎁🎇
2018 ✨
I slayed
5:50 6:13 my gawdddddd
We all know I slayed this
Memoirs ended you with EASE
@@jmochoa8302 she sounds like she’s vomiting
@Dubairiah 2004 leave my era alone
@@lanaandthediamonds3651 other way around
@@lanaandthediamonds3651 were not gonna talk about that struggled E5 growl in you, just accept that my MIH performance will ALWAYS outsell you💕
2018 lowkey makes me feel sad
Does anyone believe she will sing that part live again...???
Probably yes
@@Pkjopjpo-zm7dyI hope really for that
I’d imagine after this long rest period- live singing will increase ^^^^^
She definitely will. But its also good she doesnt attempt it too much si her voice can rest properly
Its but ok
Nice video as always sugar❤️
Thank you!
6:10 anyone have a date ?
dallas february 18th 2010
Yaaassssssssshoneeeeee every single on solid ground is a thank you Lord!! 🙏😇💪 Hallelujah mimi is ever Triumphant GivethanXo 🙌😘🎶🎵🎼🎤 #legendary
92 and 2009/2010 are the winners
Leonriah 🦁❤️
Disappointed no one mentioned the 4: 18 iconic growl.
6:46 F#5
2008, 2009 and 2010 she was a lion 😂
I swear whoever said Mariah "lost her voice" should watch this.
i watched it, and say, it's not the quality she had in her early days, let's be honest, she sings the note solid ground lower now, then she did earlier in her career, or gives it an acrobatic turn.
'95 my fav
1995 was the best year. 1992 was the second best. 2005 was very impressive.
Angels advocate be like, I ONCE WAS LOST BUT NOW IM FOUND I GOT MY FEET ON SOLID GROOOOOOOOOUUUUUUUUUNNNNNNDDDDDAAAAAAAAA THANK YOU LAAAAAAWD
how??? just.. how does she do it...
SZUPER DRÁGA ÉDES
Wasn’t 2018 lipped?
Not the first part of butterfly returns
6:13 tho
2010 it's like: Solid GROUNDAAA
8:20 is it just me or does she sound weird there?
there must be some pitch correction going on...
Was 2019 pre recorded?
Yes.
@@martinezrangelrauloziel4804 really?
Only dubai, Curaçao was live
@@daniellamb4974 That is overplayback.
@@butterflyera Only curacao is partially live.
wheres tokyo dome?
I would get copyrighted if i used it
how did u make this whole video 60fps pls omg
with this computer app called hybrid
@@TheLegendofMariah tysm
2010>>>>
2003 was consistent
call mi queen i preocuped
Seconddd
@@daydreamera1996 😑🌚
First
@LambilyXDaydream no
@@daydreamera1996 tommy gave me the keys to ur prison
@@daydreamera1996 they were all fake he got it from an interview and the rest he hired a voice actor and don’t act like u didn’t sleep with tommy for a record deal cause we all know u did
Not her hitting an f5 in the 2013 one
which 2018 ones are live ?
All of them shown in the vid
@@TheLegendofMariah don’t lie
The first one and the one without video are fully live, the rest are partialy live, the thank you lord part is live in all of them
@@ismaelmassaferro6509 QUEEN
@@ismaelmassaferro6509 💯🙇🏻♂️
Did I do great?🥵
Yes 🥵 I loved ur attempts
@@lanaandthediamonds3651 thanks
@LambilyXDaydream ❤️
@@daydreamera1996 🙁❤️
Always
Were the 2010s lipped? They all sound exactly the same. Just curious btw.
No every attempt from 2009-2010 were live