Surface Pro 9 vs Surface Laptop Studio - Which Is Best For Art?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 сен 2024
- A comparison of the Surface Pro 9 & Surface Laptop Studio. Giving my thoughts and opinions. If you want to see more of my work, follow me at the links below.
#digitalartist
Follow me at the links below:
/ c.wilson_art
/ cwilson_art
Music
Really sucks the Surface Book got canned. One of the best designs they've made with the best of both worlds. Great comparison.
Surface Book was a good design just needed better execution and to be better as a tablet. 👍🏾
@@C.Wilson yeah, I have the SB2… Battery life as a tablet is abysmal and the thing can get hot, depending on what you’re doing. Especially if using it while the battery is charging. And that is just using my trading platform. Not doing anything graphically intensive.
Finally got the surface laptop studio and am loving it. Great video, very informative.
Much appreciated 👍🏾. The surface laptop studio is truly a gem. My go to laptop for pretty much everything.
I really would want the pro 9 because it’s light weight and basically a better iPad. Laptops get to heavy when drawing for long periods of time.
Laptop Studio definitely can cause hand fatigue if you're not using it on a desk.
@@C.Wilson Apple Fan Boy here, SLS, it's definitely a better iPad.
@@louisrosado3295 I will always choose SLS over iPad if it came to one device because of versatility.
I don't know i tried both i still think that the surface laptop studio is better and a much smarter choice for everybody even for comfort you can just get a stand made for books (10 dollars ? ) to get all the drawing angulation you want. you will need to do the same for the surface pro 9 to don't put pressure in the integrated stand . The graphic card make a huge difference for rendering if the rendering engine make proper use of the Gpu at least so that test in blender make me wondering ... . Gaming is much better in the laptop studio .
Also if you add keyboard and pen (time to time they will gift the pen tho) to the surface pro 9 is much more expensive than the laptop studio .
the laptop studio is a full fledge laptop so can be your main machine for everything or your main laptop as well especially if you have a powerful desktop .
I think i will justify purchasing the surface 9 if you draw constantly in mobility and you don't do task that use the GPU but you pay more to have less performace and just some extra mobility ? 😥 i know the new cpu is better but trust me when i say that will not make difference at all we are talking about 3 6 second faster in standard testing everyoment and standardized tasks even on blender .. that test made me wondering for this reason .. i will do some myself to check .
I actually agree with you on this. The Pro 9 can be built to be better machine but the cost to do it is way to much. The Surface Laptop Studio is the better buy even with a slightly weaker CPU. I'm excited for what the Laptop Studio 2 will bring. If they can make it even ligter with more angles for drawing it will be an instant buy for me.
@@C.Wilson i hope so too but the old model still rocks i don't know what they can improve more than this . I love that machine x.x. Probably the battery life is the only thing not that great.
I believe that if you need mobility and you just want to do 2d artworks you can buy a ipad pro even refurbished doing the drawings there and finalize the project on your desktop maybe with your cintiq or a intuos pro .
In my opinion the surface is for the people that want to do complete professional work on the go not only drawing or sketching and 2d art but everything of course you will need to sacrify some portability unluckily .
Your videos are well done btw you got a new subscriber 😎 i love talking about these things .
@@JohnDoe-ej9mi I truly appreciate the sub! Yep the battery life for laptop studio is ok. I run mines at 120hz at all times and get some pretty decent battery life. I'm thinking Microsoft is trying to align the surface pro arm lineup to compete with the iPad but the price of an old ipad and procreate may outweigh getting an expensive pro 9.
@JohnDoe-ej9mi thank you for your point of view in this case. Thanks from Poland❤
I decided on the Surface Laptop Studio as it is on sale right now. Will see what Microsoft announces for the refresh version 2 and if it is worth exchanging it later (Microsoft 60 day return policy ftw).
A bit shocked the pro 9 was able to render faster. CPU really making the difference.
Yes, I ran the test 5 times and the Surface Pro 9 came out on top each time.
I guess it would be surprising for people who don't follow pc tech. Intels 12th gen made a huge leap from the 11th, which had the last 4 core i7. 12th has double the amount
would be great to also compare weight when using a keyboard for the pro9, to protect the screen and also be a 2in1
music choice is a VIBE
Much appreciated 🙏🏾
1. I'm interested if you have to be careful not to touch the screen when using pen... this very important for me, I'd like to keep my hand on the screen freely. So can you turn off touch? (I could perhaps only use two-finger zoom etc. and it would preferably only work when there are exactly two touch points used clearly.)
2. Also if it's too slippery, it's not good to draw. This is one of the reasons I could not buy Surface Studio (not the lapstop studio, I haven't tried the screen yet).
3. Also while I have one Surface Pro and it's good, I'm a power laptop user also so for example I'd like to be able to be in ANY position without the screen dropping or something (so for example 180 degrees on my thighs when I'm sitting knees up), so that's why traditional laptops and Surface Book would be much better; I've decided not to buy the trad. Surface Pro model.
For both, using the Slim Pen 2 offers little to no resistance. There is a feature built in that mimics texture. It's not bad, but a matte protector would give more grip. I've not had any issues drawing and having my hands on the screen.
Would love a new Surface Book
One can always dream of a re-release. All I wanted was a kickstand for when the screen was detached.
I just begin down the path of a graphic design student so I purchased a msi laptop and surface pro 8 ... Best combination ever
Excellent tablet and laptop combo!
Bro I can't tell you have much I appreciate this video on surfaces pros and the other series. Been looking to upgrade from my super old surface 3 which to me still does a very good job art wise. Both are great tables ugh my gripe is the positioning on the surface book while it has a built in charge dock I want flexibility. Anyway thanks great vid.
No problem 👍🏾. Flexibility is key I'm hoping they do a bit more with the hinge on new pro and laptop studio coming soon.
@@C.Wilson One thing I've noticed is the screen is going bad hella fast on its own orange tinge .. I seen others with similar complaints about the screen gradual deterioration.
What egpu would you recommend? I use blender on my surface and have no problem but would like to know options. Thanks.
Personally, I'm not an eGPU type of person. If I were to go that route I'd most likely use a Razer enclosure with a RTX 4080, but it starts to get really pricey.
nice comparson SP9 is excelent for non dedicated grafic card work but SLS is 2021 product and its just matter of few months to released SLS 2
True, fingers crossed 🤞 for more for screen position and 13th gen Intel processors. Paired with a decent rtx 40 series gpu in SLS2. Maybe even a slim pen 3.
@@C.Wilson Exactly
So I'm looking to get a surface for drawing/graphic design and judging by the comments folks are saying the 9 and Laptop Studio. But, from your experience, which would be the best buy for a noob?
I would go with the Pro 9 if just starting out. It gives you a better tablet drawing experience. The Laptop Studio can become cumbersome when drawing for extended periods of time.
I’m not sure if you’ve tested Medibang Paint Pro on the Surface Laptop Studio, but I tried drawing with that program on the Pro 7+ and I couldn’t draw as smooth on there like I used to on my Pro 4. I was thinking of trading in the 7+ to get a Laptop Studio instead, but I’m not so sure about doing so since I don’t want to waste money again by purchasing something I might have the same problem with. What do you think?
Are you using the slim pen 2? The slim pen 2 with the newer surfaces is much better. The older surface pen is not as good on the newer surface devices. (7+ and up)
@@C.Wilson Oh, I actually have been using the older Surface Pen. I didn’t know that was the problem.
I'm currently using my home computer for 2D digital art, but my drawing tablet is slowly dying and I want to be more portable, I draw at about 5000x5000 350dpi images. I plan to eventually move into blender and 3D/animation, do you think I should still stick with the 9 or go for Laptop studio?
The Surface Laptop Studio is the way to go. Though now is not the best time to buy. The new Surface Laptop Studio 2 with overall better specs is dropping in about a month or 2.
@@C.Wilson ah cool cool! Then I shall wait then, I appreciate the hasty reply! Gives me time to save money. ☺️
what about for 3d modelling rigging and animation
Surface Laptop Studio will be better because of the GPU.
Very nice review
Thank you
Only wanted to ask does on a tablet working windows same full version as on laptop?? It’s full version of adobe photoshop will be or cut one?
Because i wanted Samsung tab but it’s android on tab so no access for full versions
Windows has full desktop versions for all Windows devices/tablets.
"rock steady 60 fps, as you can see"
That fps counter is showing major dips into the 40s
Question, I'm mainly going to be doing animation, using applications with many layers, and the occasional 3D art render. Which of the two devices would be better?
I'd go with the Surface Laptop Studio because of the gpu advantage. Now if you're not going to get the Laptop Studio with the gpu because of budget and prefer a lighter more portable experience then the Pro 9 will be better.
@@C.Wilson Ah okay, thank you! Do you believe these specs will be enough for what I plan to do?
Intel Core i7
16GB RAM
512GB SSD
NVIDIA GeForce RTX
@@cornonthecob9294 👍🏾 definitely that's should handle the task you throw at it.
Asus Xflow 16 blow these 2 out of the water while having the same pen protocol, although I get it, the form factor is night and day.
While I do agree when talking about performance. Asus loses on the digital art end.
I'm thinking to buy surface pro 9 or 8. Depend on my budget. What would you recommend for me? Want to run smoothly Adobe all products also I want to illustrate
For the budget the pro 8 is good and plenty powerful. Especially if you can get a good deal. I'd only recommend the pro 9 if you just want to have the latest from Microsoft and can find a good deal. Slim pen 2 works for both as well as the type cover. So you're getting the same experience but a bit cheaper.
@@C.Wilson Thank you
Do you have any other recommendations than microsoft surface? Mac Already I have. So I want this time go for a windows. MSI, DELL, HP, LENOVO, ACER,ASUS ? Any other idea?
@@gamingtricks8265 At the moment I'd say the Galaxy Book3 pro 360, Dell XPS 13 2in1. The last one that is coming out next week is Huion kamvas Studio 16.
2:22 - Is it possible to flip the laptop while the screen is in that position, so that (from the side), it's an upside down V, and draw from that angle? It's how I used the Book a lot of times when I detached & flipped the screen - so I wonder if that might work here?
Never thought of doing that before, but actually you can. I just gave it a try, and as far as stability I personally feel a little nervous with it at that position and brace with my hand. There also a possibility of scuffing up that laptop depending on the surface you do that on.
Can we fold the studio laptop to 180 degrees flat ? I am looking to buy it for my son who is going to do design course so I am confused between these to devices
@@anirudhh07 No, the Laptop Studio doesn't fold. It works off a hinge that allows you to lay the screen flat or prop it in a tent mode. The best part about that is you don't have to feel the keys when it's lays flat.
What of for general using of laptop job, assignments, paper presentations and not just for drawing, I am thinking of studio, please what is your professional advice on, durability, maintenance(replacement of parts) and simplicity?
To me the laptop studio the best. Screen size is good for assignments, presentations and more. The laptop studio is a solid laptop in general. Repairability is is more in the favor of the Pro 9. The biggest deciding factor is do you find yourself on the go more and doing presentations at different location, if you do the Pro 9 is the way to go because it's lighter a easier to take with you on the go and is less cumbersome. Hope that helps 👍🏾.
Thank you so much. I am sorry for bringing in a new one. What of compared to Hp spectre 360 13.5 12 generation?
Or spectre 14.
@@augustineopara2887 Cpu wise the spectre is better because of there 12th gen Intel CPU. Laptop Studio dgpu helps for a bit of graphic intensive work. Screen being OLED is definitely better than the Surface. I personally don't like keys on the back when folded but that's a personal preference. Spectre better for all things that don't require a gpu. The closest thing but a little cheaper with a trade in and better than the spectre at the moment would be the Samsung Galaxy Book3 pro 360 i7 13th gen.
Thank you so much Cedric. You have been really helpful. I will go for spectre because of the size and my love for hp products.🙏🙏🙏
There is delay?
what do you do with your art?
My favorite ones I print out and put them on my wall. Kind of inspiration/muse to keep going and get better.
I am considering the Surface Laptop Studio and the Acer ConceptD 3 Ezel 15.6" .....
Both are solid choices. If it were me I would probably hold out on the Surface Laptop Studio because the new one seems to be coming very soon.
@@C.Wilson Finally I've just ordered a refurb surface book 3 (15 inch , 32Gb RAM, 512Gb SSD) for just about $1300.
Anyone know what art program he's running
I'm using Clip Studio Paint 👍🏾.
@@C.Wilson thank you for the reply good sir
But the video card is integrated .. so how can it be better? Lol
I was saying with the hardware the Laptop Studio out has out box is better because of the 3050ti it comes with on the higher end. Yes the Pro 9 can be even better because all you need is an e-gpu. Both are great just depends on your priorities and how much you're willing to spend. 👍🏾
For drawing its a bit sad compared to an Ipad Pro, have you tried one yet? Surface 9 feels shitty af for drawing
I've used the iPad pro which I prefer over the pro 9. I just enjoy the laptop studio over both. The versatility is unmatched even compared to the iPad.
U cant use photoshop on iPad..
@@Guibg543There is photoshop and illustrator on ipad and everyone draw on procreate, there is no such gem on windows/android + the m1/m2 chip exterminate the processor of the last surface there is no competition
@@lantvant2256 professional artist use photoshop what are u saying photoshop for iPad is shit
@@lantvant2256 and professional also need animation programs and 3d programs the iPad dont have professional apps u cant do everything on an iPad..