Who was Dundar Bey?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 окт 2024
- IThis video was about the first traitor in Ottoman history, Dundar Bey. For more information on Dundar Bey, you may visit the the Distant Travels' Blog:
thedistanttrav...
Support us on Patreon: www.patreon.co...
History is like an answer sheet brothers.. we are able to judge from historical perspective. but , things are not easier said than done.. had'it not been for the traitors ottomon empire would exist today, traitors not to be there was not in the plan of Allah(swt) that was non-existing file. Something amaizing about Allah( subhanahu waaataala) is that He knew everything before us and everything that is to come after us. Sons of Adam killed each other in the beginning there is a powerful message to us in that story.
Amazing Intro! The Ottomans were amazing Khalifahs, May Allah have mercy on them.
mia khalifa was more amazing such a shame she retired.
Its sad to know he betrayed them because when he was young he wanted to become like ertugrul bro just imagine if ertugrul and sulayman shah saw it😔
Yah man, history is full of unfortunate stories :(
I feel really bad for dundar since his life was in a confused path
مننه حمزه جانه دیره خایسته ويديو دی جوړه کړی ده او خایسته معلومات دی راټول کړی دی بریالیتوب دی غواړم شهزاده می
Titus wounded dundar when he was a teen and that damaged his brain, thats why he did all this.
I doubt thats what made dundar become a traitor
Lol that is not in real history. That is simply fiction.
lol
No it didn’t he just took the wrong steps stop lying man
Very nice explanation🔥❤
Thanks!
He was good then he became a traitor. 😔
Dundar bey's both wife also astray from the right path, no wonder they also influence Dundar decision
Ever since season 1 of Resurrection Ertugrul, he was alright and actually saved the tribe while getting injured in the process. He then followed his brother Ertugrul's side at the end of season 2, season 3 it was just fuck ups. One was almost killing Turgut, his anger was just besting him. And the other actually getting Dogan killed in the process cause he couldn't keep his mouth shut, when he was told not to say anything to anyone. Season 4, with Ertugrul "dead" Sadettin successfully getting in Dunbar's head of getting him to almost selling the Bazaar, and Ertugrul coming back from the dead stopping Dunbar. Then giving Dundar a punishment because of it. And in Kurulus Osman, he was just a power hungry man seeking to get his brother Ertugrul's seat as the bey of the Kayi Tribe. It was so easy for their enemies to manipulate Dundar, and in the end I'm glad Dundar met his end from Osman. He was a traitor since the first season of Osman. How he didn't learn anything from his past mistakes, i really don't understand. Dundar was anything but smart. That's what i was shown from this series, i can only imagine how disappointed Suleyman Shaw and Ertugrul Ghazi were in Dundar. And in all honesty, i didn't feel bad for him in Kurulus Osman because he brought all of his wrong decisions on himself and the Kayi Tribe.
Amazing
Dundar really took after his uncle Kurdoglu. So an has a nasty habit of copy and pasting a lot from ertugrul
Savci and Lena-Gundodu and Selcen
Their son bayhoca-Gudodu and selcens own son Suleiman
Sheikh Edebali-Ibn Arabi
Goktug-Turgut
Ertugrul-Suleiman Shah
Please don't compare them, Kurdoglu was far worse than Dundar. He wanted to kill his own brother and nephews to take control of the tribe. Dundar was good-intent and pure-hearted but let his personal interests get the best of him. He stood by his brother ertugrul gazi for as long as he was alive.
Kordoglu was not real
Selcan and Bamsi are characters from tge book dede korkut who MIGHT have been real. The did not exist in the same time as Ertugrul. They existed after Alparslan death
No one knows who gondogdu was married to.
ill subscribe
This is fake ertugrul didn't die and that was not how he died he got injured by alisar with a arrow on his back
This video is not about Kurulus Osman, its about real history & facts. History is more accurate & less fake than the dramas we watch. This is the reality. And by the way, there was no such mentioning of Aliser in my video; Osman I was the one to execute his uncle, Dundar (I clearly explained the entire concept in the video, if you did not understand you may watch again). You may see what is said & at 3:49. However, make sure to not just look at the clips shown in the video, but rather, you should actually listen to the video or look at the subtitles: so that you actually understand the history that is explained in the video.
@@DistantTravels bro I have a question I heard that apparently he was shot by an arrow is that true or just fake
@@shezzy113 Yes, a few sources have said that, though, on the topic of Dundar Bey's death, there are several different theories & opinions. So it is almost impossible to be able to know in which exact way he died. That is why I am going to make a whole other separate video, just covering the death of Dundar Bey. Then your question will be fully answered Insha'Allah.
And there is kurulus osman season 2and Dundar
is still alive
This video was based on the entire history of Dundar Bey, not Kurulus Osman. Kurulus Osman is just based on historical fiction. This is a history channel, not a fictional one. And Kurulus Osman has just started; my video, on the other hand, has told the entire story in 5 & a half minutes. Soon you will see, in Kurulus Osman, that everything I have said in this video will happen in the drama too. If not, then it means that the drama is not so historically accurate. I do plan to explain these kinds of topics in future videos, hopefully. But remember: Dramas are for entertainment purposes, while history is for educational purposes.
well he's dead in the show now
@@Omega-lu9nr true
This vid is a bit wrong
Why do you think so?
Boss, I think u did not see the Kurulus Osman - Season 2. Where he dies. But he creates Havoc for the Kayi's
He uploaded 11 months ago shut UP............
Kurulus osman isn't history its a drama the only things real in osman were the ottoman empire and a few deaths
He was not the frost traitor sulymanshah blood brother was the first
Suleyman Shah's brother did not even exist in real history, and even if he did, at that time the Ottoman Empire was no where near its existence.
ok
Noty
Noty?
Dundar wasn't a traitor the history of dundar and osman and ertugrual is only in four pages
It's actually seven pages + theories, verbal accounts, research & educated guesses. Dundar being the first traitor in Ottoman history is a widely accepted by historians, despite how little we know about the era. My question for you is that why do you think that he wasn't a traitor?
@@DistantTravels yeah you are right I cant be 100% sure can you provide me with the resources
This is the wrong history
Lol how?