Why did the Arabs revolt against the Ottoman Empire? DOCUMENTARY
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 июн 2024
- Play Supremacy1914 for FREE on PC, Android, and iOS and receive an amazing starter pack, only available for the next 30 days! s1914.onelink.me/TX2k/KingsAn...
Kings and Generals animated historical documentary series on the Ottoman History and World Wars continues with a video on why the Arabs revolted against the Ottomans before and during the Great War, and how the Arab Revolted affected the World War.
Cold War channel: / @thecoldwartv
Modern Warfare series: • Modern Warfare
Winter War: • Winter War - Soviet Fi...
Battle of Greece: • Battle of Greece and B...
Korean War: • Korean War 1950-1953 -...
Soviet Invasion of Afghanistan - Operation Storm-333: • Soviet Invasion of Afg...
How the USSR Lost the Afghan War - Panjshir Valley Battles: • How the USSR Lost the ...
How the German Empire Provoked Ottoman Jihad in WWI: • How the German Empire ...
Did Alliances lead to the Great War?: • Did Alliances lead to ...
Gallipoli 1915: • Gallipoli 1915 - The G...
How the World Betrayed Ethiopia: • How the World Betrayed...
Greek War of Independence 1821-32: • Greek War of Independe...
Who Financed the Great War?: • Who Financed the Great...
Why Japan Joined the Axis: • Why Japan Joined the A...
Support us on Patreon: / kingsandgenerals or Paypal: paypal.me/kingsandgenerals or by joining the youtube membership: / @kingsandgenerals We are grateful to our patrons and sponsors, who made this video possible: docs.google.com/document/d/1o...
The video was made by Yağız Bozan and Murat Can Yağbasan, while the script was developed by Christos Nicolaou. This video was narrated by Officially Devin ( / officiallydevin )
✔ Merch store ► teespring.com/stores/kingsand...
✔ Patreon ► / kingsandgenerals
✔ Podcast ► kingsandgenerals.libsyn.com/ iTunes: apple.co/2QTuMNG
✔ PayPal ► paypal.me/kingsandgenerals
✔ Twitter ► / kingsgenerals
✔ Facebook ► / kingsgenerals
✔ Instagram ► / kings_generals
Production Music courtesy of Epidemic Sound: www.epidemicsound.com
#Documentary #Arab #GreatWar 
Кино
Play Supremacy1914 for FREE on PC, Android, and iOS and receive an amazing starter pack, only available for the next 30 days! s1914.onelink.me/TX2k/KingsAndGeneralsDecember
Are these animations a new addition to your channel? Either way, they're top notch! Reminds me a _lot_ of Relic Entertainment's animation methodology from Homeworld.
MORE OTTOMAN VIDEOS PLEASE ❤❤❤❤
I am very pleasantly surprised that you guys called the Osmanli empire which is the true name of the empire I really appreciate that kind of attention to detail. That really amazes me
Please do ottoman mamluk war and add Muhammad Ali pasha war against ottomans to really understand the Arab revolt in Hejaz.
Couple mistakes Muhammad Ali pasha dynasty outlived the ottomans. From 1805 to 1952 and the Saudi state also outlived the ottomans from 1729 till now. The arab world also had dynasty and countries that are older then usa 🇺🇸 (Saudi, Oman, Morocco)
If you found two fishes fighting each other then Britain must passed by that sea
MORE OTTOMAN VIDEOS PLEASE ❤❤❤❤
Those are two gullible fishes
@@JJaqn05 exactly, skill issue
Lol
😂 evil others are responsible for all my ills!
My tribe in Somalia never revolted against the ottomans and we fought the British for 22 years from 1899 to 1921. We was the last sultanate to get help from ottomans and first country in Africa to be bombed. The british infilterated friendly tribes and brought their colonialist subjects to fight us. In 2023 Still the British regime is supporting their friendly tribes against us in northern somalia called today british Somaliland.
Big love to Somalia from Morocco, y'all are real warriors
@ zak bro chill with that qabilist motivations u know full well Somalis fought as one against the colonialists. Somaliland sought its birth way after the Ottoman Empire.
Pro when did othmans controled somalia we were alies bit they controled arabia
greetings to Somali from 🇹🇷
@@axmeddahir6487 lol I think the Ottomans maybe only controlled North Somalia
If anyone is watching the Kings and General's 'Ottoman History' playlist, I've made a list of chronological order of the videos. The number relates to the playlist video.
34. Rise of the Ottoman Empire - Bapheus -1302
35. How the Ottomans Took Over Western Anatolia - 1302
36. Maritsa 1371 - End of the Serbian Empire
1. Battle of Kosovo 1389 - Serbian-Ottoman War
2. Battle of Nicopolis 1396 Hungarian Crusade
3. Battle of Ankara 1402 Ottoman - Timurid War
23. Timur against Bayezid - Battle of Ankara 1402
8. Ottoman Wars: Skanderbeg and Albanian Rebellion - 1443
4. Battle of Varna 1444 - Ottoman Civil War
5. Fall Of Constantinople 1453
6. Siege of Belgrade 1456, Battles of Targoviste 1462 & Otlukbeli 1473
7. Battles of Vaslui (1475) and Valea Alba (1476)
9. Ottoman Wars: Battles of Otranto 1480 and Chaldiran 1514
28. Ottoman-Portuguese War - Age of Colonization - 1508
11. Ottoman-Mamluk War of 1516-1517
12. Siege of Rhodes 1522 - Ottoman Wars
13. Battle of Mohacs 1526 - Ottoman Wars
14. Siege of Vienna 1529 - Ottoman Wars
25. Ottoman-Portuguese War in Africa - Ethiopian-Adal War - 1529
16. Ottoman Wars - Battles of Gorjani and Castelnuovo 1537
15. Preveza 1538 - Ottoman Wars
24. Battle of Diu 1538 - Ottoman-Portuguese War for India
26. Ottoman-Portuguese War for the Indian Ocean - 1538
17. Ottoman Wars - Siege of Buda 1541 and Eger 1552
18. Great Siege of Malta 1565 - Ottoman Wars
19. Szigetvar 1566 - Ottoman Wars
20. Fall of Famagusta 1571 - Ottoman Wars
21. Battle of Lepanto 1571 - Ottoman Wars
33. Austro-Turkish Struggle for Romania - Long Turkish War - 1591
31. Battle of Calugareni 1595 - Long Turkish War
32. Battle of Mezokeresztes 1596 - Long Turkish War
37. Greek War of Independence 1821-32 - Greek & Ottoman Wars
38. Why did the Arabs revolt against the Ottoman Empire? - 1916
Hope it helps.
Between the Greek War of Independence and this video there should also be another video on the Gallipoli Campaign in 1915.
Ottoman serviced Islam great.
Thanks!
Thank you because the playlist is confusing
Thanks. I'll be watching
The effects of going against the Caliph can be seen till today.
Caliph?
@@sumiahaltalhi4767Turk’s are the Caliph, arabs betrayed our jihad call in ww1!
not caliph
What caliph?
Why caliph?
Thx for excellent explanation!
Ottomans handled so many conflicts during its lifetime, it is impressive how the state survived until 1922. And with only one bloodline.
yes very impressive
Funny enough the last of them got on a British ship and fled after an Ottoman army officer, a marshall gathered up the people and revolted against handing over the country to West, thanks to him and the people we now have a place to call home. Amazing story really.
@@lordshitpost31 lol a staged drama by that marshal who killed the soul of your country
@@neetard1774 Let me guess, you're a Paki? This is muslim bs I can tell from a mile. You don't get to decide what the soul of my nation is, I do.
@@lordshitpost31 what if I say I'm not
Why do you think everyone critic of your great master is some fool conservative
The last Ottomans were bad for the country but the kemalists chew it soul
Like after 1920s the country lost its charm in geopolitical sphere
Your map graphics were some of the best in this video. They are always super helpful building reference points to frame these complex events. In particular, this video had so many moving pieces but your graphics allowed for an easy tour through the ideas.
That's a fact
I think he takes a lot of it from the crusader kings game
These maps are subjective: Tibet should be on this map as it was not invaded by China in 1949 and annexed in 1951.
I love this channel mostly because of how satisfying the maps look
Take your Arab friends from Turkey to your Arabistan and the UK, these are your friends, why do you hate them, from this moment on they never had peace and they deserve it, the British turn them around as they want.
Proud to say my great-grandfather did not rebel against the Ottomans. Then again, he never knew what the Ottomans were
😂
What were they?
libyan arabs@@kasadam85
But they wipe out their own leader.. Gaddafi.. What Libyan get with revolt Gaddafi..where is Libyan Gold?
Youre great grandfather loved submission 😂
Could you please cover the Anglo-Sudan War as well.
I've been learning a lot from you.
Please keep up the good work.
I know they are fictional (although one is based on fact). two films I have just watched that might interest you. Khartoum with Charlton Heston and The Four Feathers, 1939 version. They are very old and the acting can be over done...a lot. But they are both set in the period you are interested in.
@@clownofthetimes6727 Yes, I've watched Khartoum. That's what got me interested in the subject. I wanted to know the real contextual history not the Hollywood version.
😅
@@clownofthetimes6727 thanks for the recommendation. I'll definitely watch the Four Feathers. IA.
Thanks, this was a great video (as always). The maps of the development of 19th century Arab states were amazing! I hope to see more on this topic in the future.
2:21 Arabian peninsula in the 19th century (focusing on the Hejaz)
6:24 Rise of *nationalism* in the Muslim world
9:26 Effects of the *Tanzimat* & other reforms
12:00 *Capitalism & Industrialization* in the Ottomam empire
14:09 Foreign (mostly British) roles
Hussein bin Ali
17:41 Summary
Thanks
Profit?
Love these timestamps ty!
turkey "ottomon" mostly german roled
@@shaheen5155 what?
The worst betrayal in history. The consequences are still causing so much deaths to this day. Mainly in Gaza.
Really?
@@KILLER.KNIGHT yes really
@@ahiyazlm5287 Nah the worst betrayal was Ataturk.
@@KILLER.KNIGHT atatürk was a great man and leader. you know nothing about him.
@@KILLER.KNIGHT Sorry but for what? Are today's Muslim kings very good?
They cannot go beyond being Muslim-looking countries. The closest example is the Jordanian king shooting down missiles destined for Israel with his own planes. I am not saying that Muslim countries should attack Israel, but at least they may not help Israel, but they do the opposite, many of them openly support Israel. Especially these betraying countries take the lead.
as a turkish person i love african arabs but middle eastern ones are quite pragmatic and non-loyal. You can see that by learning history as well. They revolted to ottomans to take middle east to themself and now middle east is a volcano.
Oh yes, because the Ottomans were very peaceful and good leaders. Their decisions definitely did not result in the execution of Syrians and Lebanese, nor in a famine that killed millions of them.
@@JSamadFamine affected every part of the empire, Turks died as well. The executed Arabs were the traitors.
You missed the entire point of the video... The revolt was hugely the result of the misconducts of the Ottomans not the Arabs they ruled over. Pan-Turkism, mistreatment of local populations, and frankly bootlicking and European Powers is what made the people they ruled over mistrust them, if the Ottomans did not want a revolt, they should have protected us more like the Caliphates before them.
Non-loyal? Please, Ottomans served themselves. The arabs loyalty is what blinded them from seeing that the Ottomans who rule over them are barely muslims. How many sultans went to Hajj in mecca? Famine, insecurity, shirk, illiteracy!
I can go on and one every town in Hejaz has enough stories and evidences of how the Ottomans despised the arabs... some call it inferiority complex.
I dare you to bring one thing that the Ottomans did to benfits the arabs when they were "loyal" to them.
Why would the arabs be loyal to ottomans? Who are the ottomans? The ottomans shouldnt even rule at all
Nice topic and great content as always keep rising K and G 👐.......in the future could we get a how ottomans administered the empire video?
Thanks K&G for a very informative video on a subject I've never fully understood.
The reason I love your videos is you show the whole map
Despite talking about one or two countries you always show how the world was back then
Like how all of this was happening in Europe and West Asia but you also showed Great India under British Raj so people could understand what was happening there at this time around
That's really great
Because that's what confuses Me the most
As a Syrian, whose grandfathers fought with the Ottomans, I see this revolt as a curse, the main reason of it was that nationalism overshadowed our religious values.
for years, we achieved glory not because we were Arabs, but because we were Muslims believing in Brotherhood between us despite racial differences, thats why Turks were ruled by Arabs and Arabs were ruled by turks, Islam united us and made us the greatest, once nationalism came in, we immediately collapsed.
true ! the blame is not on the arabs alone, there was a major corruption going on on muslim lands overall. just look at the cursed young turks and what they did….
curse for you heaven for the peninsula arabs! for the first in the last 2 millennium an ethnic levantine get to rule over the levant but you failed badly so blame no one but yourself.
There is no Turkish, Arab, Persian, Kurdish, Indian, African, European, etc. There is only Muslim and Islam Alhamdulillah
@@hamdiamairi4340 lol look at the state of this region before 20 th century and after it
@@hamdiamairi4340 boomed by became a slave of kafir? what a achievement!
Another remarkable piece. I look forward to more in 2023. Happy New Year!
all i have to say is mashallah , if we compare ur old videos and ur newer ones we can tell that ur work is improving by a lot and also you upload alot compared to the quality , keep it up
Happy New year Kings and Generals, I hope you enjoy a wonderful year for new videos on History.
This would be a really interesting video series to watch.
I wonder how many understand the "Yes Minister" reference. I for my part welcome it very much as it has been a great show that taught me a lot about politics and processes/language.
Truly a masterpiece of political comedy.
Ah, Sir Humphrey on the EU..
I liked that show. Anyone know where to find the 2013 remake?
@@joshuawells835 Hell
Link?
Quality content
Thank you for the video and links to refer all of the information provided here! 😁😁😁
Thank you the Video and the English subtitle.
Great as always.
Love your content, You have once again out done yourself by taking a hot topic, breaking it down and explaining it methodically, without bias. your channel consistently is out doing itself. Bravo.
Interesting stuff. I just watched the Lawrance of Arabia movie this weekend so this is a good background on what went on!
This is a Grand Topic we need follow up videos there are missing info.
This part of the Ottoman history feels like the crows feeding on the carcass of a dead Empire. As a Muslim, It really hurts 😞
Long live Arabia
Ottomans were no longer a Muslim empire then. You delude yourself in lies. It was controlled by the Young turks and they were indulged in secularism and Taghuts.
And the ottomans were also drowning in Bidah and Every Bidah is evil and every evil is gonna be in hellfire.
@@user-ul6mq1jd8f Under Jewish F 16.
@@abdussabur9535 nope, Under al Saud and other Arabian Rule Family
@@user-ul6mq1jd8f Idiots.They are controlled by the Jews.Coversation with Mohammad Asad and Chaim Wiseman,Wiseman said in 1926 Arabs will not be majority here for too long.Jews wants Arabia and get Arabs killed.
And you guys think Saud controls Arabs.Come on With some US bases inside how can someone have control.
Are you kids Totally Indulged in Girls and Wines or Some sanity is left?
Very interesting. Thank you.
immensely informative, a true eye opener, thanks!
Kings and Generals , congratulations for being the most accurate history source out there .I adore your work
Thank you!
@@KingsandGenerals ❤
@@KingsandGeneralsCan you make video about jourden victoryin 1968 and Arabs victory in 1973
Contrary to the misconceptions, Ottomans didn't see themselves as solely inheritors of Persians or Romans or even inheritors of Turkic culture. They saw themselves as Ottomans, first and foremost, not only the legit heirs of both Persian, Byzantine(Roman) and Turkic cultures, but legit overlords of them all. Hence they used the titles Sultan, Khan and Kayser all at the same time.
....
The names of the Ottomans are Arabic or Persian?? Muhammad and Abdul Hamid or Zardasht and Khosrau?
The religion of the Ottomans is Islam or Zoroastrianism??
The Ottomans alphabet is Arabic or Persian??
The caliphate is the caliphate of Omar or Khosrau??
In Hagia Sophia, the names of Muhammad, Abu Bakr, Omar, Othman, Ali, or Zardasht, Khosrau, and Cyrus?
Ottomans perform their prayers in Arabic or Persian?
The Kabah is there a place where Ottomans faces it's direction every day five time in Arabia or in persia ??
.....
@@yousuf6382 What are you talking about? Got a reading problem or cognitive issues?
@Kokoliko Loco those "uncivilised Turks" made your late ancestors their colonial chatel for half a millenium tho. At what scale of civilization that bitter fact puts you in I wonder.
Thanks for this informative video I was searching for information about this revolt
awesome video!
Another outstanding video with details, most wouldn’t even bother to mention. Outstanding. I hope my comment satisfies the algorithm gods😂
I wish you did mention the Arab revolution did reach Syria and the son of the sheriff, Faisal, became the king of Syria for few months before he was defeated in Maysalun battle against the French few miles before Damascus. It was this king that was given the puppet state in Jordan. Though he was the only one of his family to keep his kingdom and his dependences still rule Jordan till our day.
MORE OTTOMAN VIDEOS PLEASE ❤❤❤❤
The "revolt" did not reach Syria. The majority of Syrians fought for the Ottomans, despite their oppression. The Levant was conquered mainly by British troops, and Damascus itself was conquered by Australian troops. Syrians did not accept this random, unknown bedouin named Feisal son of Hussein as their king.
@@AppleCinnamonPie I can tell you there were Sunni Lebanese clans in the northern mountains of Lebanon who had tension and on an off fights for decades before the Arab revolt.
@@finalprophet813 I'm sure there were. But again, the *vast* majority of Arabs fought for the Ottomans. We can't even say that Lebanese participated in the revolt because it was only a tiny fraction of them.
@@finalprophet813 Well Lebanese fighting for against the Ottoman Empire probably thinking that it will help them to get the British Empire to kick the Catholic Christian or the Greek one out and favor them. Either way whatever the outcome. It will end up the same a total chaos for Lebanon. That region was alway a hot mess before the dismantle of the Ottoman Empire. Like Israel and Palestine years latter.
At 13:20 the letter is written from right to left. A very nice detail
Excellent channel loads of interesting content 👍
Another excellent show!
Love supporting the content!
thank you for the great video! would have been nice to have a more accurate depiction of makkah in the 19th century. In the video it looked like what it was looking like in the 6th century 😆
"Yemen Türküsü" is a folk song for Turkish soldiers from Anatolia who lost their lives in this war. It's quite a sad song.
Funny for the Arabs though
@@TS-zp7pe yeah we got good lessons from arabs thank to israel they see resulst of they actions
@@lillegion3121 Turkey - the first Islamic country to recognize Israel. Turkey- the first Islamic country to allow gay marriage and vodka manufacturing. Shows who you are.
راح انطرب عليها
my great grandfather went to Yemen all the way from our village in Kayseri, Turkiye during WW1 and was never heard of again
Excellent subject. Very good.
As an Algerian I see this as a sad part in Islamic history
Before sheriff Hussain, British tried to bribe Emir abd alkader so he can declare himself caliph of Arabs, he was Algerian figure who fought the french and was descended from the prophet cousin Ali, letters of allegiance started flowing to him but he refused and remained in Syria
@@Spartan-jg4bf It was colonized after all, by non-muslims, and became worse than ever. So this question doesn't make any sense.
@@Spartan-jg4bf it should have been done through diplomacy just like we broke away in 1671 while keeping our nominal vassal status while recognising the Ottoman as caliph of Islam similar to the Abbasid decline, however asking the Europeans for direct involvement was a big mistake made by our eastern brethren
@@Spartan-jg4bf "foreigners"?! There are no foreigners in Islam, just be a Good (in politics, military, economics, etc...) Muslim leader, and you can be Muslims' emir, sultan or imam. There is no "foreigner" in Islam. We are not nationalists, we are Muslims
@@Omer1996E.C tell that to the Arabs man, they prefer pan arabism over religion, as if Arab culture can mean anything without Islam.
LONG LİVE ALGERİA TURKİSH FRİENDSHİP ..
There are still sad Turkish songs about sending the poor Turks to die in Yemen while the rich just pay off the authorities. It was their Vietnam and the songs were their "Fortunate Son."
@@antoniosdimoulas3566 Why does every Greek person have to be this negative about the Ottoman empire? Greeks did worse things and similair things.
@@antoniosdimoulas3566 Janissaries were elite just like the Mamlukes they became Pashas and committed massacres in Yemen. Özdemir Pasha raised Sana'a, killed 10,000 of the males and enslaved 10,000 of the females who were sent to be sold into slavery in Istanbul. The city surrendered peacefully but he was just looking for an excuse, and yes Muslim empires did enslave other Muslims and their armries also had non-Muslim fighters. Resource thirsty empires only want profit, just like modern-day imperialism, but on a miniature scale.
@@antoniosdimoulas3566 I’m a Greek Muslim and you should know that the ottomans were barbaric and had nothing to do with Islam. Look to the Quran and life of Muhammad ﷺ and the sahaba. These fake ottoman boys broke every rule of Islam. Drinking alcohol while raping Muslim and Christian women. Fully disgusting.
@@antoniosdimoulas3566 An average jannisary had more rights and prosperity compared to a slave in the Roman army. Stop with the moral outcry of a system that last existed more than 250 years ago.
Is different conflict is not WW1 Turks attack yemen first don't confuse with modern day yemen because majority of yemen land never been under ottoman
amazing video, lplease more culture videos like this
great work
At the end divide and conquer by the British won.
The Ottomans were oppressing the Arabs. The Arabs had every right to stand up to the Ottomans, its just sad that the Europeans didn't hold on to their promise and only made part of it independent.
History tells Empire never last British Empire also didn't last. Now world is better place.
@@sitarampradhan8488 its not for arabs know mate they are being bombed
Yep, and they got their israel, 40 years later than intended bc the great Atatürk, as winston churchill said but they still got it
@@Zysuzuuauajz Not true, the main reason why the British supported the idea of the Jews getting their own home were the events of the Holocaust. Before the idea was not that popular in the UK.
You can't prevent something that was never would of happened in the first place.
Their revolt should be blamed for what is happening to the Palestinians people today.
Yes that is why this is happening, their kin should have never rebelled! All they had to do was bend knees, pay taxes, and breed camels 🐫
@@Yoo-yooYeshuaJEW
I am very much looking forward to your next video documentary on the illustrious career of Prime Minister Jim Hacker! :-)
Great stuff!
I just want to mention that this "Arab" revolt only concerned the bedouins of Sherif Hussein's tribe in the Hejaz. Very, very few Arabs from Syria, Palestine, Iraq, Nejd, Yemen, or other areas participated in this revolt, and it was considered "largely unsuccessful" by British authorities. In fact, the vast majority of Arabs fought _for_ the Ottomans, and even after the war, when Hussein's son Feisal was "crowned" king of Syria, the people largely did not accept him.
you are a liar !
@@yousuf6382 تكفير المسلم حرام
@@AppleCinnamonPie اعتذر تخلبطت في الردود .. لكن ما قلته غير صحيح بالمانسبة
Everywhere we go.. We see it's sins 🇬🇧🇺🇲
There were revolts in all the Arab cities, that's why the Ottoman Army retreated to Turkish areas very fast. They knew they could easier fight and defend the fatherland.
Being a long time viewer of this Rich channel, I think this bit was not enough to portray the full picture of the Arab Revolt. I think you should consider making a series about the downfall of Ottomans in the Arabia connecting them to the events from crimean war to the great war and other muslim perspectives like in Indian subcontinent. You may consider discussing the religious perspective too. You could even collaborate with Al-Muqaddimah too as he seems to be an expert on this topic. That'd be worthy of a watch. Keep up the good work. Kudos.
Great video as always, one important question:
From which books did the writer take historical facts ?
This is a great channel
you make some of the most accurate historical maps
can I know where to find them
That wasn’t an accurate map highlighting Najed as a Whabbism is a bigoted stereotype a historian should not fall for these things
@@aj3013 *Najd
and the religion would have been wahhabist as it was founded before the state existed
@@joshuafrimpong244 there is no such thing as whabbist saudis have always stated they hate this stereotype because its has always been islam calling it whabbits because Mohammed bin AbdulWAHAB was an influcing scholar is offensive af
@@aj3013 oh, that's what you are talking about
@@aj3013 yh, that is correct
Happy new year, best for next year!
love it thanks
Abu Musa al-Ashari reported: The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said, "You will never have faith until you love each other. Shall I tell you what will make you love each other?" They said, "Of course, O Messenger of Allah." The Prophet said, "Spread peace between yourselves. By the one in whose hand is my soul, you will not enter Paradise until you are merciful to others." They said, "O Messenger of Allah, all of us are merciful." The Prophet said, "Verily, it is not only mercy between yourselves, but rather it is mercy for everyone."
Al-Sunan al-Kubrä lil-Nasâ'i 5760
Looking at the middle east today im pretty sure Turkish couldn't stop laughing right now 😂
All the Gulf countries, which is the Arabian Peninsula, are better off than the Turks.
Also all the countries where the Ottomans settled are the worst cases
You should know that the Ottomans caused the backwardness of the countries they occupied.
@@user-yq7ow6dc8nThen answer this, why were there no deaths in Israel and Palestine before the Ottomans left
The Ottomans killed the people of Syria and the people of Hijaz and killed many of the people of Najd, there is no need for Israel to do so.
The Israelis entered Palestine in the time of the Ottomans Salim I and Solomon.
They did not prevent their entry and did not succeed in reconciling them and among the Arabs.
And the Israelis continued to expand until the beginning of the wars.
But what did the Ottomans do to protect Muslim citizens in their differences?
They were the cause of the destruction of many Arab peoples.
@@user-yq7ow6dc8n Your right, many Jews were accepted into the Ottoman Empire mainly because of Spanish aggression. But the Jews and Arabs in Palestine got along very well. Until Zionism came, A weak movement at the time but after the Ottoman fall it grew stronger as it was supported by the west. And eventually The Zionist israel was created and on the creation date rounded up many Palestinians.
That's right btw we are laughing and do you know that there are 10 million Arab refugee in Turkiye? They betrayed us and when the Syrian war started, they cried for help from us
Simply one of the best (and there are many) K&G to come out.
Who else noticed the Civ5 Ottoman theme in there? Nice reference!
Yes, indeed. Civ soundtrack is often used in K&G videos. Videos for Celts, Mesopotamian civilizations, Mongolian empire involved it as well. Maybe others too, haven't noticed.
There are some points that are missed. Regarding the bedouins, up until the ending decades of the 19th century they were essentially ungoverned and so untaxed. After the reforms the Ottomans decided to start governing them which meant imposition of heavy taxation and corrupt administrators. This alone had significantly contributed to their resentment. As the new governing infrastructure was based on the Hejaz railway it was especially hated.
Regarding the rural Arabs in the Levant region, the reforms brought them almost nothing creating an extremely feudal society with absentee lanlords (who frequently were christians) owning entire towns while living in Beirut or Istanbul. The reforms strengthened the rich merchants who became said landlords. The levantine arabs didn't joined the revolt but were apathetic to both sides.
Some parallels with other empires that broke up when the monarch attempted to centralise control of of the colonies, like George III losing America, or the alienation of the Hispanic elites by the Spanish Bourbon reforms. Could you do a video on the Hispanic American wars of independence? Thanks.
Thanks!
tim's 2 Broke but still gave $5 to K&G, mad respect right there
@@lioraselby5328 Prefer knowledge to wealth, for the one is transitory, the other perpetual.
- Socrates
@@crpse-qf6rh well knowledge can be temporary too if you manage to get dementia or Alzheimer’s
@@lioraselby5328 hopefully we get a cure for those diseases. i would rather die than lose my memories
@@crpse-qf6rh on the bright side after a while you won’t remember losing your memories
I hope u read this, u never dissapoint us with ur content. I am 100% sure that I would never find better videos covering Muslim/Arab history with such details. Well done!
Thanks for watching! There is always room to improvement, but we'll do our best.
You are wrong, the map that the video depends on is not true
Yeah most of the videos are somehow borderline xenophobic while K&G are actually non biased.
Yes bro i love this channel for this. I like that he doesn't just cover European history and actually branches off to alot of other parts of the world unlike so many history channels
Awesome video! I feel like the dissolution of the Ottoman Empire is a topic most of us in the West don't know much about.
Never knew about this. Learned about WW1 in school, but we were just taught that the Brits and French took that land from the Ottomans after the war during the peace treaty.
@@antoniosdimoulas3566 if you occupy something for longer than 50-60 years it's basically yours. And yes I am a giant history nerd and was aware of the medieval conquests that led to the ottoman supremacy over the middle east.
@@antoniosdimoulas3566 The people of the region didn't consider the Ottomans occupiers until the 20th century because the Ottomans were a legitimate Muslim caliphate, the British and the French were NOT. Only when the ottomans started to adopt turkish nationalism instead of Islam as a state policy did the arabs rebelled. Please refrain from talking about subjects you CLEARLY KNOW NOTHING ABOUT.
@@ibrahimmustafa2481 stop making things up pakistani guy, we never thought of them as legitamate caliphs they never prayed nor went to haj nor do zaka nor were we caring about a bash invasion
@@antoniosdimoulas3566 You definitely saying the other nation and what they doing is more justifying. As for human right. I matter little the power that rule them in those. If it not the Turk there will be other. Especially the age nationalism when human right is basically thrown out of the window for ethnicity. Never and i repeat never those time like since the medival time to discussing of a mordem era of 19th to 21th century.
That the same reason why many suffer even when got them rid of the Turk. It alway blaming the Turk when other factor also tributed to it you inogred. I don't stand with the Turk. What you saying just like those nationalism that plunged the world into a world war all for their ideal of an old passing age. Which it already did, if it not the Turk doing the thing. It the other nation or people who claimed they doing it for their nation. And i am looking at the Balkan Country who even after getting rid of the Turk didn't satisfy and caused many more like them. Only this time they was the agression one instead of the Turk to those they consider not part of them or those still loyal to the Ottoman. Hypocrites all of them. Then again we are all human. What to expect.
@@antoniosdimoulas3566
Dog literally compared turks with a kuffar Country 😂😂
Faqqot muslims didn't had any nationalistic differences until 20th century when it was introduced here by white swines like you......
Informative video. Please do the Sassanid/ Roman wars of 602-628 AD. No channel has the graphic and the narrator voice as K&G.🙏
They already covered that I think.
@@kevinyonan2147 They're outdated and too old so yep K&G will consider releasing them with better graphics and new overlook.
Is there first video btw
@@ShahanshahShahin nah is already persian history isn't fascinating btw
@@ziyadamir8187 No it is not
1- There is literally a museum for the house of British spy Lawrence in Arabia. He is honored and seen as a hero by Saudis. So I think knowing that already clears up many things on this case.
2- There is literally a Hilton Hotel upon the graveyard of first caliph of Islam
3- First wahabi revolts occurred during rule of Mahmud II (first reformist Ottoman sultan) and wahabis sacked the tomb of prophet's relatives. All of them were repaired by Turks.
4- A person from west interested in that case must learn the difference between Turkish way of Islam and Wahhabi fundamentalism. Even during under the most conservative and islamic sultan of Ottoman Empire Turks have never came in terms with Gulf Arabian way of islam which is incredibly backwards and purist. Most of Arabs (except Lebanon Iraq and Syria) anyway never accepted the caliphate of Ottomans since Selim conquered Egypt and Arab lands.
5- Arab Revolts were a reaction to Turkish nationalism in regions like Lebanon and parts of Syria however it was nothing but a British backed division plan when you look at southern parts. The amount of gold given to Saudi warlords by British during these years is beyond belief. All was to control them. Arabs were promised a large Arabia reaching to southeast of Turkey but of course they had to sit and accept what their bosses offer them while giving all rights to British to obtain their oil sources. How heroic right?
6- All in all as a Turk I am extremely happy that we could cut our ties with this part of the world and we could differentiate ourselves from them by any means.
whabies are way more closer to the traditions of islam than you. the reason why wahabies have demolished those graves is that many people were venerating the graves and even in some cases worshiping them which is strictly prohibited by the prophet himself.
You can always rely on a turk to lie
"All in all as a Turk I am extremely happy that we could cut our ties with this part of the world and we could differentiate ourselves from them by any means."
Lol you act like you were forced to be there or something you are the ones who horribly ruled that region for 300yrs straight and still dont want to accept it. And yes you did differentiate yourselves by moving away from ottoman turkish and Islam claiming you want your own identity... but then adopt latin letters for your language and westernize your traditions and culture. 😂 Fake identity
"Wahhabi fundamentalism" my goodness hhhhhhhhh
turks try to figure out the difference between the saudis and the hashemites challenge (impossible)
@@blueyy9117 like any single person cares. You live under dynasties, even your police officers are selected from a family. And the ones ruling Arabia right now were the ones shook hands with British.
Not sure if you’ll see this but I’m 15 and am making a podcast on the Punic wars. I’ve been a fan for a few year now and am wondering where you got the sound effect for 4:50? Can I use it in my podcast?
As far as I know they use epidemic sound for musics and sound fx
You can use sound effects from strategy games. But, I'm not sure it is ethical or have copyright problems.
Because they were bored of abundance and relaxedness in life and suddenly decided to look for trouble which will continue for years
Independence may be trouble for you, but not to the sensible person. Do you want the freedom of palestine? No?
I loved the reference to Yes Minister, truly the best British sitcom ever created!
I love The video
The British and French betrayal of the Arabs is rarely talked about nowadays.
Most westerners have no idea about these things and only those that dive into these things start to understand the history.
@kızgın tosbağa they are complicit because their nation benefitted. But not all Muslims betrayed the ottomans only certain tribes who still hold power in certain regions. The ottomans was not perfect either. In 18 century they wanted to become western Europeans so bad , thats when they went downhill.
Right the british presented a little gift call "nationalism" and we know what came next.
Next time just rinse it down the sewer.
"rarely talked about" okay....
@@samizakariya5155bruh i heard some arabs saying the banned a printing machine or something and now u r saying this. They wanted to make modern not western
@@muhammaduzair2674Nah,,Ottomans certainly wanted to become european so bad. How do u think they got the nickname of "Sick man of Europe". Like the guy before said both Ottomans and arabs share heavy amount of blame of this.
Very interesting video
Can you please do a video about moroccan saadis and their battles against portuguese empire and ottomans.
The Ottomans were a multi-ethnical, multi-religious, multi-ideological Empire wiith everyone wanting their own state with their own ideology and their own doctrine. Not hard to figure out, why things didn't work out, regardless of which direction the young turks could have taken.
I am betting they didn't saw the the Austrian Hungry situation or they just looking at Germany for their model. Austrian , Russian and Ottoman literally the all in the same case yet rather than fixing in the internal one they rather fought each over another ethinic piece of land.
@@thanhhoangnguyen4754 there was no fixing to it. It was the age of nationalism.
@@justsefa1843 Yeah that why i felt poor for those multi ethnic Empire like Austria Russia and Ottoman. They literally a powder keg. And of course the first world war have to be caused by nationalism.
Ottoman empire were a "succesor" of the islamic empire. Compare it to Holy roman empire, claiming they are succesors to the ancient romans. So of course its diverse, but they were horrible.
Revolt? It should be called betrayed.
It's revolt and independent diplomacy.
Lol
@@anonymoussoul3343 And in the end you got your "nice independent" Arab states in the Middle East, didn't you?
More Arabs fought and died for the ottomans
@@ouzd.19 yes, now they can kick out the dictator. But previously they used to be killed and suffered a lot.
as arabian i can say most of our afoul economic and political state is due to our fault acts in intifadaat (revaluations) and we alwayswant to change the government's without changing our mindsets .
The loss of one is the gain of many, I guess. A lot of people internally and externally seemed to want a piece of the Ottomans at that moment.
Absence of the Ottomans in middle east is still more preferable to those that haven't seen the horrors of war
a grave mistake committed by allies. very grave.
Totally true. I can give two examples approving your comment: 1) balkans 2) middle east
@@kayagurcu2814 they are healing their wounds from you, the problems caused lkke mass deportations and demographic changes after all the massacres lead to modern suffering, in short we dont want your ottomans back
Noy a mistake from the allies but mistkae of the last rulers of the ottomans tanzimat , young turks and all tgese seculars and nationalist. İf you start nationalism why every one will start nationalism.
Loved the Yes Minister reference best sitcom ever too bad the remake was lackluster
i love his videos voice is so 👌
Nice video, liked the maps, i especially like the Senussi on the side, except for one thing - those maps that showed the Sudan did not show the independent Muslim country of Darfur.
Also while you concentrated on the Hejaz and the Sharif of Mecca, you did not mention the near constant fighting between Saud Nejd and Jabal Shammar, the puppet of Ottomans. That would lead to after the WWI to house of Saud conquering all Arabia. The British allied/aided Saud early in WWI, much earlier than Hejaz revolt.
Of course so did Abir also.
But a great video over all.
Did they?
They supplied arms but most of it was literally in WW1, the british only really supplied weapons to Saud but Hussein got political support + much more weaponry. Thing is though alsaud were already at war with the Ottoman puppets before the british got involved or WW1 in general. So it was just alignment from their side, while hussein flipped.
Pretty sure the British also forced Alsaud to stop ikhwan raids constantly on their protectorate in kuwait and stopped the earlier hejaz war but then stayed neutral later in the second one
@@iberionbaratheon7927 they literally had abdulaziz in their pocket since he was a teenager in in Kuwait, it was recorded by sir Percy cox.
can you also please make the history of Harar, there seems to be minimal history on this.
Are u hariir
Supremecy 1914 one of my fav games
The “Yes Prime Minister” reference was very much appreciated
From what i heard the Arabs were revolting against the Ottomans quite often, meaning they probably saw WW1 as an ideal time when the Ottoman armies were distracted fighting entente forces.
It’s complicated. Arabs especially in the region of nejed revolted against the Ottomans frequently. Current Saud family is the royal family from the nejed region.
@@TruthSeeker8834We Arabs hated the Turks and revolted against them many times. Rightfully so, they've not place in Arabian peninsula.
@@emanalmrogi8103 Not always.
P.S: u arabs show great arrogance cause of ur oil( not all but many). Remember oil reserve will end one day but ur deeds will remain forever.
Britain (with a stick poking the Arabs) "c'mon... *poke* *poke* do a revolt"
Good graphics
If someone calls a people by their own name like Osmanlı you know he knows what he is talking about! Great content!
Does anyone know where I can read the pamphlet written by Muhammad Arif which is mentioned at 13:07
And that's how Palestine is doomed honestly ya can't blame anyone
My heart cries seeing how the sharif chose the brits over the caliph. Its only the indian muslims who supported the caliph until the abolition of caliphate.
That's why Palestine was lost.
Why aren’t these Arabs that rebelled against the Ottoman Khilafate considered Khwaraji?
As a person who comes from a Greek family from Jeddah, I appreciate the video
huh ?
Were your family present there from Ottoman times? I think Jeddah was the site of an Ottoman fort previously?
@@sagapoetic8990
Jeddah is one of the oldest cities in the world, and the meaning of Jeddah in the Arabic language is the grandmother
@@sagapoetic8990 Yes, they were many forts in Hejaz, but Jeddah didn’t have one. The city had walls tho
ايش اسمك بالله ؟
History which will alwys be remembered
Interesting.