How to Get a 10/10 on The Needle Drop (feat.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 1,3 тыс.

  • @SoundFieldPBS
    @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +1225

    Add some MC Ride vocals or Kid Cudi hums to our track here soundcloud.com/soundfieldpbs/soundthony-fieldtano-type-beat Also, don't forget to subscribe! LOVE Y'ALL

    • @sothisistheend
      @sothisistheend 5 лет назад +21

      Sound Field nah that would DEFINITELY be more of a Kendrick Lamar song

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +29

      @@sothisistheend You're right, drop a verse

    • @sportsgambler6
      @sportsgambler6 5 лет назад +20

      Sound Field i’m gonna go tf in on that soon

    • @Thomas-dq9yo
      @Thomas-dq9yo 5 лет назад +2

      lmao that track title

    • @worke3896
      @worke3896 5 лет назад

      Sssssssss

  • @OMGxITZxPACMAN
    @OMGxITZxPACMAN 5 лет назад +9313

    Kid Cudi: The only artist to receive both a 0/10 and a 10/10

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +768

      huge accomplishment

    • @yearnpill
      @yearnpill 5 лет назад +98

      OMGxITZxPACMAN Technically he didn’t. KSG is a duo, he is only one part of the duo so therefore he didn’t get a 10/10 by himself.

    • @seanwestbrook2071
      @seanwestbrook2071 5 лет назад +96

      @@yearnpill neither did Kanye lmao

    • @thajuice6695
      @thajuice6695 5 лет назад +339

      @@yearnpill you can't discredit it all since it's a collaborative project. The principle of him receiving both scores is still valid regardless

    • @Rogther
      @Rogther 5 лет назад +22

      @@thajuice6695 But you're discrediting the other half of the duo, just accept he got a 5/10

  • @yeahdudejoshishere8381
    @yeahdudejoshishere8381 5 лет назад +6806

    Y’all really had to do this on the date 10/10

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +476

      You know it....

    • @b1gBud00bo1
      @b1gBud00bo1 5 лет назад +85

      josh I’m australian so it says it was released on the 11/10

    • @brm9656
      @brm9656 5 лет назад +50

      @@b1gBud00bo1 well that's even better...
      Badum-chiii

    • @jo_nm9484
      @jo_nm9484 5 лет назад +26

      @@b1gBud00bo1 but the score is upside down there so it's -11/10

    • @hellodumplings8564
      @hellodumplings8564 4 года назад

      Well they probably did it in another date, sooo...

  • @JoroJojoro
    @JoroJojoro 5 лет назад +4562

    It's easy.
    Genre: Experimental hip-hop

    • @tumppi723
      @tumppi723 5 лет назад +118

      Or no-wave.

    • @michaelurgelles937
      @michaelurgelles937 5 лет назад +345

      Anything between experimental and noise music.

    • @owengrunau5397
      @owengrunau5397 5 лет назад +89

      JoroJojoro Yeezus says otherwise

    • @johnindigo5477
      @johnindigo5477 5 лет назад +17

      @@michaelurgelles937 didn't kid cudi try that

    • @RileyMarrVideo
      @RileyMarrVideo 5 лет назад +29

      @@owengrunau5397 so does cherry bomb

  • @kobepmusic
    @kobepmusic 5 лет назад +4046

    I'm gonna call it a light to decent 7. The track itself embodies pretty much all of the qualities set out in the video, but something about the mixing made the keys go from crisp to painful at times. That said, the actual tone of the notes was fantastic. I would've loved to hear Anthony's bass get a bit more boost in the mix as well.

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +539

      Thanks Kobe, you're a real one.

    • @brianmcdonald42
      @brianmcdonald42 5 лет назад +252

      I'm glad that wasn't just me. There was definitely a crackle in the keyboards that set me on edge. Maybe that was just the Death Grips influence.

    • @crankypepper7343
      @crankypepper7343 5 лет назад +87

      Exactly what i thought when hearing the piece

    • @emileconstance5851
      @emileconstance5851 5 лет назад +138

      TBH, nothing novel or innovative, but rather bland and derivative. It was a song without qualities, that sounded like it could have been composed by a computer. No emotion, nothing meaningful conveyed--just a soulless combination of sounds that was equal or less than the sum of its parts. It was worse than being merely bland--it was mildly agitating, directionless, and even though it was short I couldn't wait for it to end. And the keys were too loud. P.S., Not my intention to sound overly harsh, just an honest assessment--good people sometimes make substandard art.

    • @dewnsie
      @dewnsie 5 лет назад +16

      @@emileconstance5851 that's how I felt about it as well

  • @bootleggerrosey
    @bootleggerrosey 5 лет назад +2698

    Hell yes. It's Soundthany Fieldtano.

  • @wyllmRox
    @wyllmRox 5 лет назад +2037

    fantano: "am I swearing too much for PBS?"
    PBS: *just stares back at him*

  • @deflop7741
    @deflop7741 5 лет назад +1748

    You forgot to include Cal Chuchesta's "The New CALassic" on the 10/10 list.

    • @TLOFL
      @TLOFL 5 лет назад +7

      De Flop He should have brought hin out!

    • @GabrielFelix-zl4sq
      @GabrielFelix-zl4sq 5 лет назад +30

      Xaul Quadrat Cal is too deep into the melon lore 😂 the common public wouldn’t get his genius

    • @bigdickbrutus3363
      @bigdickbrutus3363 5 лет назад +6

      The only album that truly matters

    • @alienalibi2382
      @alienalibi2382 5 лет назад +6

      Throwing up on a Tuesday pushed me through depression...
      Lets not forget how be my bae bae is the perfect baby making song.

    • @producedbykhireyakeem4340
      @producedbykhireyakeem4340 5 лет назад

      It was a 3 out of 10 bro

  • @ubermensch8022
    @ubermensch8022 5 лет назад +4397

    Someone should feed all 10/10 songs to an AI & see what it makes.

    • @def8332
      @def8332 5 лет назад +89

      kortizoll Someone did that with Eurovision songs. “Blue Jeans And Bloody Tears” ruclips.net/video/4MKAf6YX_7M/видео.html If you’re familiar with the Eurovision Song Contest, it’s right on the mark.

    • @allonmyownherewego9893
      @allonmyownherewego9893 5 лет назад +314

      OH MY GOSH
      somebody feed all the 0/10 songs to an AI and watch it make a 10/10

    • @peters5090
      @peters5090 5 лет назад +1

      it does

    • @jhonlewis5758
      @jhonlewis5758 5 лет назад +16

      It’ll make a 20/10 song!

    • @chunkyMunky329
      @chunkyMunky329 5 лет назад +46

      AI works poorly if you feed it a very small amount of data like 5 albums. It would need thousands or even millions of songs to learn effectively. Otherwise it will just create trash

  • @liamtahaney713
    @liamtahaney713 5 лет назад +1285

    The song was okay, but loses major points for cal chuchesta's absence

  • @ellie-ys3qz
    @ellie-ys3qz 5 лет назад +3758

    Be Death Grips, Swans, Kendrick Lamar, Kids See Ghosts or Daughters

  • @jaysun4069
    @jaysun4069 5 лет назад +482

    7:35 "Am i swearing too much for pbs?"
    ...*awkward silence....

  • @5XWAZM
    @5XWAZM 5 лет назад +968

    Make him wear the yellow flannel and you'll get 10/10

    • @stefan1024
      @stefan1024 5 лет назад +1

      This.

    • @yoctto3792
      @yoctto3792 5 лет назад +7

      DAMN

    • @slades_salad
      @slades_salad 5 лет назад +15

      @@yoctto3792 7

    • @michaelroy6630
      @michaelroy6630 4 года назад +4

      Some artist should send a yellow flannel to Anthony's house with the note "for when you review my album"

    • @arthurdunn4594
      @arthurdunn4594 4 года назад

      Not necessarily

  • @SoundFieldPBS
    @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +740

    Thanks to everyone who's liked this video before even seeing it, that's pretty cool.

    • @caioaf2
      @caioaf2 5 лет назад +46

      this video is a solid 9/10 already

    • @hermask815
      @hermask815 5 лет назад +14

      I have the strong feeling that all the votings/likes have turned away from school grades valuing the content to a show of support for the person, not the content at the current moment.
      In consequence downvoting is no criticism of the content in question but against the person.
      Amirite?

    • @aspektx
      @aspektx 5 лет назад +4

      Oops, my mistake. I thought it said, "featuring Clem Fandango," not "feat. Anthony Fantano."

    • @elrabeechum5180
      @elrabeechum5180 5 лет назад +1

      aspektx YES I CAN HEAR YOU CLEM FANDANGO

    • @Xankill3r
      @Xankill3r 5 лет назад +5

      Sound Field + Anthony Fantano, I mean who wouldn't?

  • @arahmizori3916
    @arahmizori3916 5 лет назад +639

    "It has to be dense and lengthy"
    Kids See Ghosts (23 minutes 53 seconds)
    Makes sense

    • @doom114
      @doom114 5 лет назад +98

      Arah Mizori You can argue that KSG is dense

    • @VarietyVideoGamer
      @VarietyVideoGamer 5 лет назад +71

      @@doom114 absolutely. Also didn't he say the density makes it feel way longer than it is?

    • @arahmizori3916
      @arahmizori3916 5 лет назад +2

      @@doom114 probably my favourite from last year. there is a lot to it

    • @genesisosuna
      @genesisosuna 4 года назад +4

      If an album can say or do a lot in very little, it does not need to be lengthy. Such as kids see ghosts.

    • @johnnybensonitis7853
      @johnnybensonitis7853 4 года назад +8

      @@doom114 Yeah, seems very similar to video games. Many can appreciate a short game that is consistently great more than one that takes 80 hours to complete due to long, boring stretches of repetition where certain elements artificially legthen the experience such as grinding.

  • @marshallemmet1366
    @marshallemmet1366 5 лет назад +585

    “Don’t make background music”
    *cries in Selected Ambient Works Volume 2*

    • @philosopherking99
      @philosopherking99 5 лет назад +27

      Couple tears for Music in Airports.

    • @cheesecakelasagna
      @cheesecakelasagna 4 года назад +2

      i crie everytim

    • @chrismonzon452
      @chrismonzon452 4 года назад +15

      SAW2 is the opposite of background music to me hahaha. I feel like if I was in a situation that called for it being in the background I would be very scared

    • @marshallemmet1366
      @marshallemmet1366 4 года назад +2

      @@chrismonzon452 I used saw 2 but honestly SAW 1 is more of a background album

    • @chrismonzon452
      @chrismonzon452 4 года назад

      @@marshallemmet1366 tru

  • @achintya-7
    @achintya-7 5 лет назад +590

    We should also respect the 9/10s aswell like against all logic and igor

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +108

      Yes the 9/10s have great power!

    • @youknowhuwitis
      @youknowhuwitis 5 лет назад +72

      @@SoundFieldPBS I would say anything 8 and above is considered a 'Great album' and I think earning the accolade of greatness is enough to deserve a meticulous listen.
      I think the new Hobo Johnson album is a good example of this. Anthony gave it an 8 and while it is in no means one of best albums this year it shows an artist presenting himself from a challenging standpoint and it feels quite fresh musically.

    • @industryfungi6778
      @industryfungi6778 5 лет назад +41

      the atrocity exhibitions!

    • @deven9565
      @deven9565 5 лет назад +18

      And deaths grips, death grips and death grips

    • @justin9571
      @justin9571 5 лет назад +8

      Charli

  • @Idespiseflies
    @Idespiseflies 5 лет назад +849

    Not gonna lie all of those things y'all listed sound like MBDTF.

  • @WarisAmirMohammad
    @WarisAmirMohammad 5 лет назад +683

    Next, make a video about "how to get a NOT GOOD on TND"

    • @therandomchicken6517
      @therandomchicken6517 5 лет назад +42

      Waris Amir Mohammad
      1. Be Dj khaled

    • @johnbeaty3191
      @johnbeaty3191 5 лет назад +3

      He's explained that before

    • @DaComebakKid
      @DaComebakKid 5 лет назад +7

      @@therandomchicken6517 ....or NAV

    • @spamsingles5948
      @spamsingles5948 5 лет назад +6

      Be Nav

    • @Gekokujo76
      @Gekokujo76 5 лет назад +5

      "Little Xan going in a more experimental direction" would be a good place to start.

  • @pugsyconglomerate
    @pugsyconglomerate 5 лет назад +382

    Bro, Corey Feldman looking this up right now

  • @tylerjohnson7950
    @tylerjohnson7950 5 лет назад +427

    I thought the recording/mixing was eh. Sounds like you had a fun time jamming together. I enjoyed the video but expected more elements and emotion from the song, vocals too. And for it to be a 10. I'm feeling a strong 5, light 6 on this one. Tran-

    • @tylerjohnson7950
      @tylerjohnson7950 5 лет назад +227

      -sition hope you liked my comment, have a wonderful existence

    • @overbeb
      @overbeb 5 лет назад +24

      @@tylerjohnson7950 ... forever

    • @Noelciaaa
      @Noelciaaa 4 года назад +14

      Same... it felt more like a good draft. I couldn't decipher what kind of emotion it was supposed to communicate and that was the biggest flaw... Asides from me just not liking the sound color of the keyboard there at all.

    • @anchorbubba
      @anchorbubba 4 года назад +5

      @@Noelciaaa thos keys have the audio texture of a razer blade

    • @Noelciaaa
      @Noelciaaa 4 года назад

      @@anchorbubba Hmm... I wouldn't put it so harshly but they're definitely too raw... I don't make music so I don't know what exactly should be done but they simply lack nuance in their tone color, something organic.

  • @CookieR3aver
    @CookieR3aver 5 лет назад +106

    I'm feeling a strong Melon/10 on this track, can't wait to see where this band goes in the future.

  • @origamikatakana
    @origamikatakana 5 лет назад +189

    The bass was too low in the mix, but the keyboard sounds helped drive the piece along with the drums. I'm feeling a light to decent 7.

  • @DW.Records
    @DW.Records 5 лет назад +104

    He's also technically given a 10 to albums like "The College Dropout, Madvillainy, The Glow Pt. 2," and some other ones on another website.

    • @aryantaywade298
      @aryantaywade298 2 года назад

      rly? Madvillainity, The Glow pt. 2 is rly suprising, if u know which website cud u reply to this comment with it?

    • @mickeydix8062
      @mickeydix8062 2 года назад

      Also queen

    • @wozaow
      @wozaow Год назад

      ​@@aryantaywade298think it's just the needle drop

  • @sunnowo
    @sunnowo 5 лет назад +612

    Two words: dark prog

    • @sunnowo
      @sunnowo 5 лет назад +3

      J M Touché

    • @youknowhuwitis
      @youknowhuwitis 5 лет назад +19

      @@AliceFlynn the uninspired TOOL album you mean?

    • @radiofloyd2359
      @radiofloyd2359 5 лет назад +11

      @@AliceFlynn Dark prog that's good*.

    • @gerson096
      @gerson096 5 лет назад

      @@youknowhuwitis so true :(

    • @rutvikrs
      @rutvikrs 5 лет назад +5

      @@youknowhuwitis it's actually a very good album

  • @ashm9953
    @ashm9953 5 лет назад +49

    1:38
    Fantano: Gives long winded, clear, well worded and vivid description while making several good points.
    Me: "That's how I think"

  • @gabevillarrealedits
    @gabevillarrealedits 5 лет назад +120

    “It’s just my opinion, it’s not doctrine...”
    Tell that to the Church of Melonology.

  • @weebtrash6119
    @weebtrash6119 5 лет назад +46

    Death Grips “The Money Store” really is a 10/10 I still bump that album religiously.. it’s a ground breaking album for experimental hip-hop

    • @louiemarsden6894
      @louiemarsden6894 5 лет назад +4

      Brandon Brothers I.... agree :)

    • @phyfts
      @phyfts 5 лет назад +7

      Tbh it feels like a post punk record

    • @aadliafiq
      @aadliafiq 4 года назад

      Clipping self titled is a better noise rap album

    • @acurlyboi2944
      @acurlyboi2944 4 года назад

      adli afiq I can never get into the clipping self titled. Could you tell me what’s so great about it and maybe I’ll relisten with that stuff in mind.

    • @CausticSpace
      @CausticSpace 2 года назад

      Idk man I can listen to the most garbage tier Black Metal but somehow death grips just is so unbearable to listen too. Maybe I had too high expectations, imo just way too overrated

  • @grahamphillips1285
    @grahamphillips1285 4 года назад +52

    "He's developed a rating scale that goes from 0 to 10." What a pioneer!

  • @YoshiOST
    @YoshiOST 5 лет назад +211

    Song was 10/10, am I doing it right.

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +13

      yeah that's right

    • @TheMightyKiD38
      @TheMightyKiD38 5 лет назад +3

      The right way would be "I'm feeling a decent to strong 10 on this"

  • @kkyyee
    @kkyyee 5 лет назад +27

    This is quickly becoming one of my favorite RUclips channels. Keep it up!

  • @WesleyLutz3D
    @WesleyLutz3D 5 лет назад +22

    Having never watched The Needle Drop, I can't explain the feeling of seeing two albums I love (The Money Store and You Won't Get What You Want) but consider really weird and niche, got his perfect score. Makes it seem like my feeling of "discovering" that music was influenced by him, even without me ever seeing his videos.

    • @TheQwertyPoiuyGuy
      @TheQwertyPoiuyGuy 5 лет назад

      That seems so strange to me. It seems like Death Grips entire listenership and fanbase comes from or revolves around it being the very first artist Fantano ever gave a 10/10 to.

    • @TheZZachZZ
      @TheZZachZZ 5 лет назад

      If you love those albums Id advise vecoming an avid viewer of Fantano. I discover so many great new artist through him because our music tastes align.

  • @glumplum
    @glumplum 5 лет назад +50

    not even dropped and already a 10/10 can’t wait ☺️

  • @TheDude4077
    @TheDude4077 5 лет назад +47

    Was going to make the obvious "Not Good" joke, but that song does in fact objectively slap.

  • @Bebe-fq8yb
    @Bebe-fq8yb Год назад +3

    The Needledrop channel is great, not only for introducing a new perspective on the music you enjoy, but also for introducing you to new music.
    Fantano doesn't stick to a couple of genres, or only reviews what's popular, he reviews a wide range of music from artists around the world with various styles of music.
    My favourite new find this year was SUPER CHAMPON by Otoboke Beaver, a punk band from Kyoto, Japan. I loved it and I have fantano's review to thank for introducing me to the band, I'd never thought I could enjoy punk music, let alone punk music in a different language.

  • @wizard1370
    @wizard1370 5 лет назад +65

    Three words: experimental noise rock

    • @psychedelicpiper999
      @psychedelicpiper999 5 лет назад +3

      Nah man, he trashed MGMT and Animal Collective for doing that.

  • @teratoma.
    @teratoma. 5 лет назад +281

    easy
    make the instrumentals noisy and unusual, and yell from the bottom of your soul(remember: low energy vocals makes a project instantly trash tier) thought provoking lines by using (for the lack of a better word)"smart people" vocabulary

    • @teratoma.
      @teratoma. 5 лет назад +9

      still love you fantano tho 😘

    • @swarm69
      @swarm69 5 лет назад +19

      for lack of a better word... pfff.. bruh there is totaly a better words.. "verbose lexicon", ezpz 10/1o

    • @McDoggg
      @McDoggg 5 лет назад +16

      To counter the low-energy vocals complaint, I’m gonna have to point out that Billie Eilish got a very positive review.

    • @carlrdbro1230
      @carlrdbro1230 5 лет назад +4

      @@McDoggg Also Mount Eerie, this is a bad joke, better luck next time OP

    • @TheTheode
      @TheTheode 5 лет назад +1

      @@McDoggg he also likes elliott smith

  • @experionu869
    @experionu869 5 лет назад +6

    hearing nahre do the anthony fantano outro was something i didn't know i needed in my life but i did. i really did.

  • @AlthenaLuna
    @AlthenaLuna 5 лет назад +42

    I appreciate the trying to get a 10/10 on 10/10.

  • @pocketdialmusic
    @pocketdialmusic 5 лет назад +42

    *notices they released it on the 10th of October*
    Nice

  • @Wolyboly24
    @Wolyboly24 3 года назад +5

    I became interested in fantano after his review of Atrocity Exhibition by Danny Brown was surprisingly his top album one year. I was thrilled that someone with some cred actually agreed with me. I have since learned that we don’t share many similar tastes. Nonetheless, he is a honest critic. That’s why I respect him.

  • @salvatorefanara482
    @salvatorefanara482 4 года назад +1

    its very hard to not shed a few tears looking at fantano's life journey in retrospect, knowing full well we've all been along with him on that journey...

  • @KarlRock
    @KarlRock 5 лет назад +67

    I just downloaded his top pics. Let's see how they go. I've been neglecting keeping up with music for the last few years - even though it was my first passion in life and I worked in the industry until I started RUclips at the age of 32 😂. Maybe his channel will help me keep updated

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +10

      Karl Rock thanks for watching! How’s India?

    • @KarlRock
      @KarlRock 5 лет назад +10

      @@SoundFieldPBS India is always incredible 😊 Keep making great videos

    • @IYUN697
      @IYUN697 11 месяцев назад

      Do not dive into To be Kind without any sort of preparation, it can be harmful

    • @Huntly23
      @Huntly23 10 месяцев назад

      @@KarlRockwhat did you think?

  • @musicman6555
    @musicman6555 5 лет назад +154

    How to get a 10 on the needle drop
    Step 1: Experimental Hip Hop

    • @jo_nm9484
      @jo_nm9484 5 лет назад

      So true 😂

    • @zackzallie8735
      @zackzallie8735 3 года назад

      Kanye West: hold my liquor.
      Fantano: *HAHAHA ITS 5/10*

  • @BestName2002
    @BestName2002 5 лет назад +284

    Next episode:
    How Not to Get a 0/10 on The Needle Drop

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +25

      how not to get a not good on The Needle Drop

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +5

      @@leusuzuki763 I agree

    • @KillerChickenz01
      @KillerChickenz01 5 лет назад +8

      I love my wife

    • @EclecticoIconoclasta
      @EclecticoIconoclasta 5 лет назад +3

      Why didn´t they talk about the masterpiece of human creation Angelic 2 the Core by the musical wizard Corey "the Maestro" Feldman

    • @jamwither9847
      @jamwither9847 5 лет назад +11

      how to get a 10: be kid cudi
      how to get a 0: be kid cudi???

  • @BallotBoxer
    @BallotBoxer 5 лет назад +34

    Should have interviewed Cal Chuchesta for greater Fantano insight

  • @lynnpehrson8826
    @lynnpehrson8826 5 лет назад +49

    It it dark? Yes: plus 5
    It it proggy Yes: plus 5

  • @robbbbbbb1
    @robbbbbbb1 5 лет назад +4

    I just loved everything about this and you guys all coming together. This is the kind of stuff I come to RUclips to get blessed with. Feeling a light to decent 8 on the collab track too.

  • @jaizentorres4926
    @jaizentorres4926 5 лет назад +4

    You guys are freaking amazing! Thanks so much for talking about this very controversial topic about critics. I think you brought many great points to the forefront and I love this music. As always keep up the awesome work!

  • @adambonini3129
    @adambonini3129 5 лет назад +6

    Antwon Fantwon sounding like a Grateful Dead cover band jam and I’m loving every second.

  • @TheNicoDavis
    @TheNicoDavis 5 лет назад +3

    I have been looking for a video like this for a while thank u. I will be getting a 10/10 on my debut in no time

  • @colincasey241
    @colincasey241 5 лет назад +3

    What I love about this video is that it kind of lays bare Fantano’s music-virtuoso persona, and gives the viewer the space to make up their own mind about this method of music criticism. One takeaway question I had was how would a person close to the music they are reviewing see it? So often we privilege this mythical objectivity in our discussions to the point where we almost expect and demand mean or hypercritical analysis. Maybe there should be more room for compassion and understanding in music review. Maybe the artists who are close to the art have valuable insights an “objective” reviewer just can’t have.

  • @Maffulfish
    @Maffulfish 5 лет назад +35

    Melon Report with Jacothany Pastoritano

  • @isaac2560
    @isaac2560 5 лет назад +9

    0:00 Woah, Music Review has really changed Anthony. I’m glad he’s looking handsome, always loved those glasses!

  • @thegladys2651
    @thegladys2651 5 лет назад +5

    I really appreciate you collaborate with other people that create great content for social media. I learn sth new with you :)

  • @reaganfeher1954
    @reaganfeher1954 3 года назад

    The soft groove of that beat and talk about music that you need to actively listen to.. wow!

  • @blurvough
    @blurvough 5 лет назад +88

    epic-ness: 2/10 - preposterously short, small buildup to single bit of generic jam
    dynamics: 2/10 - flatness... where's the loud OR the soft?
    precision: 4/10 - basically a sloppy jam
    progress: 7/10 - Fantano now trying to put out a legit piece of music
    cohesive: 8/10 - stuck to groove
    troubled: 0/10 - bland, mellow, largely lacking discordance/no lyrical content
    attention demanding: 2/10 - nondescript bluesy jam (was indeed background music)
    genuineness: 2/10 - the groove had nothing to do with the styles of the 3 performers
    I'm giving this one a light 3 :(

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +19

      This is a great review! Thanks for your time and effort

    • @blurvough
      @blurvough 5 лет назад +15

      @@SoundFieldPBS thanks for the kind reception, I felt bad posting it but it seemed to be part of the point of the video to lay it all out there. I love the actual video, fwiw!

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +33

      I appreciate the effort and thoughtfulness and I think you make great points. Thanks for watching

  • @gonzaloviqueira8131
    @gonzaloviqueira8131 5 лет назад +26

    I'm feeling a decent to strong 9 on this video

    • @Computer-Woman
      @Computer-Woman 5 лет назад

      Gonzalo Viqueira god dammit i commented the same thing

  • @DominicAirola
    @DominicAirola 5 лет назад +17

    Drums were grooving and keyboards were amazing as always with Nahre, but ironically the bass was bland, both in terms of playing and tone.

  • @peteguajardo8189
    @peteguajardo8189 5 лет назад +1

    First metalcore now Fantano, absolutely appreciating this PBS YT series

  • @jimmyrustles980
    @jimmyrustles980 5 лет назад +11

    "This new track I did with PBS...... yeah it's NOT GOOD" *explosion noise*

  • @jdee0
    @jdee0 5 лет назад +1

    thank y’all for this!

  • @awesomeboston5217
    @awesomeboston5217 3 года назад +3

    2:00 is such a cool compilation of all the albums hes given a 10

  • @m.c.ravioli1521
    @m.c.ravioli1521 5 лет назад +1

    I keep coming back to this video, it's so good

  • @thirtyyearoldmulberryfield
    @thirtyyearoldmulberryfield 5 лет назад +57

    Booming 808s and rattling hi-hats ;)

    • @edgarroberts8740
      @edgarroberts8740 4 года назад

      @Miasma A L I T T L E T R A P I N F L U E N C E

  • @DeadEndFolliesTube
    @DeadEndFolliesTube 5 лет назад +1

    Super interesting vid, guys. It’s important to draw the line between genuine criticism and product reviews in the age of Amazon review and you guys highlighted very precisely how Anthony does it.

  • @nextl3v3l99
    @nextl3v3l99 5 лет назад +6

    While I don’t think musicians should be aiming to get 10/10 or any sort of approval from melonhead. I do like that this video provides a basic template for upcoming musicians on how to make quality music. I think if anything as an artist you should be striving for excellence none the less, loved this video PBS :)

  • @katsuura8179
    @katsuura8179 5 лет назад +2

    I love how all the videos on the side when you show some of Fantano's videos are all Sound Field.

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +2

      Yeah that’s the agreement we made for this collab. He has to feature all of our videos on his videos.

  • @Aquatarkus96
    @Aquatarkus96 5 лет назад +3

    Your song reminded me almost of 70s jazz fusion or something in that vein. Stupendous!

  • @mania.archive
    @mania.archive 4 года назад +6

    Anthony: they need to be precise, meticulous, and cohesive
    Death Grips: get get get get got got got got blood rush to head lit hot lock

  • @amoscaul3264
    @amoscaul3264 5 лет назад +4

    Woah, how did I miss the PBS logo until they started jamming.

  • @cjthibeau4843
    @cjthibeau4843 5 лет назад +2

    And yall made ANOTHER DOPE TRACK!!! Who woulda thought???

  • @hsmoscout
    @hsmoscout 5 лет назад +39

    don't emo-splain him, Sound Field

    • @nekozombie
      @nekozombie 4 года назад

      i love people like you

  • @TundrahSounds
    @TundrahSounds 5 лет назад +3

    I love me some of that Fantano! But i always look at the reviews he’s doing as emotionally connected to who he is and what he cares about, packaged with a way above average music knowledge and communication skills. It’s easy to get either convinced he’s right, or the entire opposite. I usually learn more about the albums when just paying attention to his detailed descriptions here and there, than his scores. But they are very entertaining!

  • @sophiebosio8171
    @sophiebosio8171 5 лет назад +3

    Nahre is so cute at the end when she does the Fantano outro

  • @adamyohan
    @adamyohan 4 года назад +2

    I'm no music critic. I however think that the music you guys made is incredible. I wish I could download it or stream it. It's REALLY cool.

  • @justinfromwfr
    @justinfromwfr 5 лет назад +12

    Just make an album called "You Don't Get To Pimp Kind Kids Seeing Ghosts At The Money Store"

  • @tcbvgames
    @tcbvgames 4 года назад +1

    Dig that jazz trio finale! 9.5/10 would jam again.

  • @blizzmuzic
    @blizzmuzic 4 года назад +3

    I found something that all of the 10/10 albums have in common. From my understanding they are all albums.

  • @MaxRaldin
    @MaxRaldin 5 лет назад +1

    Every artist is taking notes

  • @RetrogradeBeats
    @RetrogradeBeats 5 лет назад +19

    This video comment section is going to be lit tf up once this video drops.

  • @aboutsoundandvision
    @aboutsoundandvision 5 лет назад +10

    The song reminds me of something Traffic would've put out in the early 70s, I'm thinking a light to decent 8

    • @ralstonwithanr
      @ralstonwithanr 5 лет назад

      What Traffic stuff? I only know The Low Spark of High Heeled Boys, which I’m not sure reminds me of this. Looking for a recommendation please!

  • @JMartinJ
    @JMartinJ 5 лет назад +12

    I think the song was a 7. Just like DAMN.

  • @donfillinger3571
    @donfillinger3571 5 лет назад +2

    Awesome concept for a RUclips video. Keep it up dudes.

  • @KaisTestKitchen1
    @KaisTestKitchen1 5 лет назад +3

    Man never thought I'd like a PBS medium as an adult

  • @itzlucaaa6789
    @itzlucaaa6789 5 лет назад +2

    Yo I haven’t seen PBS since the early 2010’s but this channel is actually kinda cool.

  • @jayiguess6735
    @jayiguess6735 5 лет назад +4

    quality content! we're feeling a light to decent 9!

  • @sebastiandevida4685
    @sebastiandevida4685 4 года назад

    I really like this combo of hosts

  • @creathechiboi
    @creathechiboi 5 лет назад +17

    This is the equivalent of taking every little scenario and tweaking it just for a high school grade.

  • @DDDoily
    @DDDoily 5 лет назад +1

    We love Sound Field

  • @kriskenard
    @kriskenard 5 лет назад +3

    WE LOVE YOU, MELON!!!!

  • @wordviruses
    @wordviruses 5 лет назад +1

    Anthony playing bass is my spirit animal

  • @shinyt9003
    @shinyt9003 5 лет назад +9

    i'm feeling a strong 10 to a light 11 on this song. TRAN-

  • @cjthibeau4843
    @cjthibeau4843 5 лет назад +1

    So sad that I wasn't here to ask yall some questions. But after watching this, and never really being a fan of Anthony, I think I'm going to try watching his stuff again. Thanks guys! Also would LOVE to see a video one day breaking down Death Grips, and can't wait for the music criticism video!!!

  • @Jack-eu5vu
    @Jack-eu5vu 5 лет назад +7

    sounds like that one song from napoleon dynamite, 10/10

  • @teowalcott6320
    @teowalcott6320 5 лет назад +2

    Ayyyyy the song goes real hard for real! Nicely done guys 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @kaphizmey6229
    @kaphizmey6229 5 лет назад +28

    first adam neely, now anthony fantano? you guys really love youtube bassists... i’m calling it, y’all are gonna have davie504 on next. 😆

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +9

      We love davie504! How can we get his attention ?

    • @SoundFieldPBS
      @SoundFieldPBS  5 лет назад +7

      @Salim Sivaad hahahah but we can't slapp the bass nearly as good as davie

    • @RobertHalvarsson
      @RobertHalvarsson 5 лет назад +1

      I endorse this message 👏

  • @andersonwang1746
    @andersonwang1746 5 лет назад

    Fantano used to work for PBS, this is a nice come back home coming collaboration

  • @jorgecandeias
    @jorgecandeias 5 лет назад +155

    "What did you think of our song?"
    It's a bit Doorsy, innit?

    • @SROnivera1
      @SROnivera1 5 лет назад

      @FriedIcecreamIsAReality Same! Like definitely feeling that tone more than anything.

    • @AnthonyFlack
      @AnthonyFlack 4 года назад +3

      @FriedIcecreamIsAReality- like the Headhunters, but terrible instead of fantastic. I actually am starting to kind of love the way these guys analyse music to death and then produce something soulless and dreadful at the end. I don't want to be mean, I probably shouldn't say anything, but I think I'm gonna have to put on the actual Headhunters now to take the taste away.

    • @kibrika
      @kibrika 4 года назад

      I was thinking The Doors too! And that I love Nahre's composing basically in any genre, probably because she does so many.

    • @mrsteinbergenson7348
      @mrsteinbergenson7348 4 года назад

      Jorge Candeias - it can never be TOO Doorsy.

  • @bedcadet
    @bedcadet 5 лет назад +1

    Love the jam at the end