I wonder who was the moron who decided to use the music for the end credits... they used this scene as a teaser for the movie and guess what, it had the original music, but when I went to the cinema it suddenly had a different music
Movie barely even started and it already gave the audience massive blue balls. I mean, this song is literally PERFECT in every way for the intro, and they opted for some generic bullshit song. Look no further for proof of Hollywood being Hollywood than this.
OMG YES!! THIS should been the music they used for this sequence! I liked this music but they dropped the ball SO HARD on this one thing! I can only IMAGINE how my brain and heart would've exploded if this was in the actually movie! This intro is basically a combination of both intro songs use in the GITS and GITS 2. God I love this franchise tho...
Ghost in the Shell and Innocence were each once in a lifetime experiences and we got to experience them both in our lifetime. When I think about this, traffic jams are not so annoying.
I saw the original anime earlier this year and then watched this video the other day when I wanted to enjoy this epic soundtrack again. Now I've seen the live action one and was totally disappointed by the intro. I didn't knew this was a fancut :(
Ok here is the perspective of someone who didn't see the original until few minutes ago and just knew the 2017 adaption: When I was in the theatre I freaking loved the intro & the music, I think it is an amazing opening by itself BUT seeing the opening of the original few minutes ago kind of made me understand how people are feeling about it. The original score is a tremendous piece of art and conveys this strange religious larger than life feeling, its like witnessing human becoming god through their creation. Now seeing THIS gave me shivers. I can't understand why they didn't go with it. I still love the official 2017 version but this here is simply on another level. I also think that this movie really isn't the worst anime adaptation even though they could have made it something truely special if they dared to, but hollywood played it safe...
The hollywood movie was as a movie ok. The anime was a cornerstone in cyberpunk often mentioned as source of inspiration for dozens of books, comics or movies, the Matrix included. So yeah. I agree with you.
Had they done this, the movie would have gone from a 6/10 to a solid 8/10. It's a decent enough adaptation for what its worth, but the misuse of the classic GITS "chanting" theme was by far my biggest complaint. Why stick that in the end credits? Just... why?
Both sequences are incredible! Nothing beats the original but I found the film version to be quite inspiring and exceptional as well. The artists behind the live action film did such an incredible job. This film only suffered from writing. I wish they had given the writing to someone equally as passionate about this universe. Yet still, thoroughly enjoyed it.
@@alialtaf3412, she may have had a robotic endoskeleton, but she was still human. And by definition, a cyborg is an organism with any form of bionic/electronic augmentation. Why do you think the term "cybernetic organism" exists?
@@alialtaf3412 I did more research and it wasn't the whitewashing that ruined it. It was the overuse of Blade Runner references combined with poor casting. And if it really was her passion project, Scarlett could've been Assistant Director rather than the main character. She was also too short for the part. Officer Motoko Kusanagi/Mira Killan is 5' 6" (1.6764 m) tall.
@@jeremiahthornton7938 Personally i thought Scarlett was great casting and even Mamoru Oshi himself said so! i'm not too big on the original movie which i find overrated as it was stunning but hollow and lacks story or character development and humanity, i find films like Blade Runner 1 and 2, Robocop and Total Recall (1990) to be better films than the original anime movie and for anime movies i'll take Ninja Scroll, Akira, Ghibli, Vampire Hunter D 1 and 2, Fist of the North Star, etc over GITS 1 and 2 and part 1 i thought was ok but not that great but part 2 sucked ass as it was boring, pretentious and hollow. I like the live-action film the best out of the GITS films so far as it has great characterizations, stunning visuals with practical effects and stunt work and i get to know more about the Major and who is this Puppet Master.
From what I heard, this was essentially how the movie was in test screenings except a bit quieter, but it was replaced before general release. I suspect either Production I.G. slapped DreamWorks with a Cease and Desist or (more likely) an exec at Paramount ordered it removed for "not being American enough". 😓
I have no idea. I never got to see the actual movie myself, and this was the first time I heard the Robot Lady's voice! I have to admit though, this would hit home for nostalgia if they put the track in this way! :)
So bad, i found that video and started it, then i thought - shit i have to stop it to watch it in the movie, but then i read the comments .. and started the video again. So disappointing to read that its not in the movie as intro song. But now im gonna watch the movie and lemme surprise how the shell scene works with another music.. - thx for this video :)
I remembered nerding the f out when I heard this theme in the ending credits. They combined the original 1995 films theme with the opening theme to Ghost in the Shell 2 innocence which I thought was really awesome. Honestly I really enjoyed the movie. To hell with the haters.
Nice, thanks for doing this! I actually had to pause after the intro of the 2017 version and look for this. The new intro music was a totally anti-climatic experience for me. It's kinda fixed now. Probably had to do with expectations. But everything else in the intro felt very respectful of the old, so why replace that very iconic music with that boring low-key, low-pitch stuff. Anyway, thanks again!
Not having this song play in the movie intro demonstrates the director's misunderstanding of the appeal of the anime's aesthetics to fans, even if the movie still looks good
Or it could’ve been the studio. Everything looked like it was right out of the anime. Maybe I’m more lenient with the live action movie is because there isn’t a definitive ghost in the shell. The first movie was darker than the original manga, and all GITS has their own interpretation, what is the live action one but just another interpretation. Besides, it’s not like Japan does better when they make a live action anime movie. Look at attack on Titan
@@tgiacin435 i know im getting into this convo late but i feel that movies today are just made to fast this would of been made within in 2 years i think if they had an extra year to polish the script experiment with diffrent techniques of music and filming we would of got a better movie if you look at star wars before it was bought by disney all the movies had at least 3 years now disney is pumping them out every 2 years and each film/tv show is getting worse in terms of story characters and filming
si me vi la peli ORIGINAL como 5 veses y ni soy fan de la saga...solo x entender de que hablaban todos....y la pelicula es la ostia cuando inicia el live action...uno se pregunta... Y EL BSO MEN????es como con the shining algo similar..x eso el descontento de los fans
Personally, speaking on behalf of someone (I) who bought the Bluray disc and the wall poster at the cinema, I would say that from 1:47 to 1:51 there is a level of art that approaches the anime. The other parts on the entire sequence are not enough to compete. It would cost much more to keep the same quality/pace as Oshii's animation.
This is live action or anime from the creators of Dragon Ball Evolution, Bleach & Attack On Titan comes the new chapter of the hit movie called “The Ghost In The Shell.”
Its so messed up how they obtained the brain for this to take place which you find out at the end of the movie that they basically kidnapped some poor girl that hardly anyone would probably miss than extracted her brain against her will to have it inserted into Scarlett Johannsson's character's body.... :O :O :'(
Something I've never figured out... both _Ghost in the Shell (2017)_ and _Terminator Salvation_ show the title *twice* in the opening credits. (Both of them near the start in plain text... then in a more stylized way at the end.) Why is that? Is it some legal thing?
Something that I did not like in this adaptation was the music for making of a cyborg (like many of us). In the animated movie its music is mostly vocals with ancient (to some) and natural instruments. It offset the very mechanical and cyber-aesthetic of the visuals of a mock birthing scene. I'd describe it as a celebration of a birth. A tribe elated at a new and healthy child. This one though... it just felt too mechanical, as well as generic (it has that baseline of every epic/ trailer for a sci fi setting ever). There are some strings for a more natural sound, and even a few seconds of quiet chanting. It makes it all seem way too generi and artifical for my liking. In a way it's too modern and "western" when it was a Japanese story written and made by Japanese people.
@Metroid2424 did you change anything or did you just dub the original theme? Because if this is a straight dub, it's clear to me Rupert wanted the original theme but some copyright or money problems happened. Because how could you NOT us this.
I looked for a couple different ways to sync the video and audio, and I settled on that big drum hit during the white covering flaking off. I didn't change the video or song. It really should have been like this!
Which version was used for this edit? I don't recognize the second half of the track, which sounds somewhat similar to one of the tracks from Innocence, yet different.
Why? Why the fucking FUCK did they not play this song with the 2017 movie? This intro would have (and did, in 1995) **made the movie**. Literally the only thing they had to do to make the film excellent but they were happy with good. ... I like the song :3
It was poor executed live action...so sad Why not stick on the original story? Instead, they (hollywood) generated typically lame made up story about Major...and made her so emotionally human...
![[AMV] - Ghost in the Shell 1995/攻殼機動隊1995 (Puppet Ⅰ & Inner Universe)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gmFeHj3or60/mqdefault.jpg)
![[AMV] - Ghost in the Shell 1995/攻殼機動隊1995 (Puppet Ⅰ & Inner Universe)](/img/tr.png)
the makers of this sequence had ONE JOB!
Real-life footage of how Scarlett Johansson was created
It's how they make Hollywood stars, now
Colourised XD
@@arsnakehert lmfao
Literal perfection
As Major
I wonder who was the moron who decided to use the music for the end credits... they used this scene as a teaser for the movie and guess what, it had the original music, but when I went to the cinema it suddenly had a different music
Movie barely even started and it already gave the audience massive blue balls. I mean, this song is literally PERFECT in every way for the intro, and they opted for some generic bullshit song. Look no further for proof of Hollywood being Hollywood than this.
@@gracecalis5421
That was very sad 😯😲😨😞
Yes this was a huge disappointment for me 😢
@@gracecalis5421 and by music it lost a lot of meaning...in the original it was an actual birth...in hollywood adaptation was more like an assembling
@@efes47198 The Japanese and American mindsets for you.
When the fans make a better opening sequence than Hollywood.....
Same happens in videogames, and shorts.
he didnt make anything lol, he just put music made by someone else and an intro sequence made by someone else together
sorry Kenji Kawai made this song for the film but was never used in the live action film.
@Кирилл КО That doesn't save the movie.
@@dannypenfold9301 its in the credits
OMG YES!! THIS should been the music they used for this sequence! I liked this music but they dropped the ball SO HARD on this one thing! I can only IMAGINE how my brain and heart would've exploded if this was in the actually movie! This intro is basically a combination of both intro songs use in the GITS and GITS 2. God I love this franchise tho...
Ghost in the Shell and Innocence were each once in a lifetime experiences and we got to experience them both in our lifetime. When I think about this, traffic jams are not so annoying.
a shame they didn't put it like this in the movie
This was my biggest disappointment
I saw the original anime earlier this year and then watched this video the other day when I wanted to enjoy this epic soundtrack again. Now I've seen the live action one and was totally disappointed by the intro. I didn't knew this was a fancut :(
And only because the original anime isn't free to watch anymore with any of my streaming services
Is it so hard to buy the dvd ?
@@adriencalvary556 it’s so easy to download an hdr copy
ケンジ・カワイの「謡」が国際的にも非常に評価されていることが解っただけでも私は満足です。
Ok here is the perspective of someone who didn't see the original until few minutes ago and just knew the 2017 adaption:
When I was in the theatre I freaking loved the intro & the music, I think it is an amazing opening by itself BUT seeing the opening of the original few minutes ago kind of made me understand how people are feeling about it. The original score is a tremendous piece of art and conveys this strange religious larger than life feeling, its like witnessing human becoming god through their creation.
Now seeing THIS gave me shivers. I can't understand why they didn't go with it. I still love the official 2017 version but this here is simply on another level.
I also think that this movie really isn't the worst anime adaptation even though they could have made it something truely special if they dared to, but hollywood played it safe...
The hollywood movie was as a movie ok. The anime was a cornerstone in cyberpunk often mentioned as source of inspiration for dozens of books, comics or movies, the Matrix included. So yeah. I agree with you.
So good with the original music
It's not the original music. It's a song specifically made for the movie and wasted on the credits.
Arthur Wild This is the original music from the animate
@@KaPowProductionwtf no it sounds worse
@@GodHandAct For you its worst, for me the original lives.
This was what we wanted. Just a scene by scene rendition would have been phenomenal.
What’s the point so ?
The original is enough 🤦🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
It would change peoples complaints from: why is it shit? To: whats the point? Which is a good improvement @@adriencalvary556
exactly right. they had ONE job
Just watch the original then
Had they done this, the movie would have gone from a 6/10 to a solid 8/10. It's a decent enough adaptation for what its worth, but the misuse of the classic GITS "chanting" theme was by far my biggest complaint. Why stick that in the end credits? Just... why?
Same, while I like the movie as its own interpretation, this should’ve been in the opening
it felt like an insult to me
It actually was. I was at the theatrical release but they removed it in dvd for some reason
@@keniaTheYuriar Are you sure? I saw this movie in theaters as well but the original Kenji Kawai theme wasn't used in the shelling sequence.
@@ShadowOfTheVoid yeah definitely, idk about you. I saw it in Phoenix AZ though. Dunno if that makes a difference.
I saw the premiere in AZ and it had this song in the opening sequence. Absolutely no clue why they removed it
Both sequences are incredible! Nothing beats the original but I found the film version to be quite inspiring and exceptional as well. The artists behind the live action film did such an incredible job. This film only suffered from writing. I wish they had given the writing to someone equally as passionate about this universe. Yet still, thoroughly enjoyed it.
Even though I've never watched either one before,you're right. Hovever,that's not the only thing. The other thing that ruined it was the whitewashing.
Jeremiah Thornton protagonist race didn't matter because she is not human.
@@alialtaf3412, she may have had a robotic endoskeleton, but she was still human. And by definition, a cyborg is an organism with any form of bionic/electronic augmentation. Why do you think the term "cybernetic organism" exists?
@@alialtaf3412 I did more research and it wasn't the whitewashing that ruined it. It was the overuse of Blade Runner references combined with poor casting. And if it really was her passion project, Scarlett could've been Assistant Director rather than the main character. She was also too short for the part. Officer Motoko Kusanagi/Mira Killan is 5' 6" (1.6764 m) tall.
@@jeremiahthornton7938
Personally i thought Scarlett was great casting and even Mamoru Oshi himself said so! i'm not too big on the original movie which i find overrated as it was stunning but hollow and lacks story or character development and humanity, i find films like Blade Runner 1 and 2, Robocop and Total Recall (1990) to be better films than the original anime movie and for anime movies i'll take Ninja Scroll, Akira, Ghibli, Vampire Hunter D 1 and 2, Fist of the North Star, etc over GITS 1 and 2 and part 1 i thought was ok but not that great but part 2 sucked ass as it was boring, pretentious and hollow.
I like the live-action film the best out of the GITS films so far as it has great characterizations, stunning visuals with practical effects and stunt work and i get to know more about the Major and who is this Puppet Master.
Look how effing in sync this is.. FUCKING GOLD
From what I remember that's what the had planned all along. Preview Footage of this scene had this song.
@@arthurwild6563 why did they change it??
From what I heard, this was essentially how the movie was in test screenings except a bit quieter, but it was replaced before general release. I suspect either Production I.G. slapped DreamWorks with a Cease and Desist or (more likely) an exec at Paramount ordered it removed for "not being American enough". 😓
They used it in the END credits. So they still used it, just not where it was supposed to be.
@@wileecoyote837 guess it were execs/producers interference then, a fucking shame
If this was the intro, I would've watched the movie in the theater
Great oportunity lost right there!!!!!!!!!!!
Im glad Im not the only one who feels they should have kept the original opening theme
Wow I knew it was going to be better, I didn't realise it was going to be that much better
why put this score at the end instead of here where it belongs???
Tristan Sighe
This is the beginning!
what? yes this is the beggining and this song should be used
eduardo arce
Ohhh my bad
I have no idea. I never got to see the actual movie myself, and this was the first time I heard the Robot Lady's voice! I have to admit though, this would hit home for nostalgia if they put the track in this way! :)
This will become a reality,one day.
Sure👋🏻.
Not a matter of if, just when.
@@alexlun4464 hey so elon musk is doing nerualinks its kind of similar to this but without the casing , it’s a chip installed in ur brain
Not really.
It has begun......... 😌
This movie it's not what we wanted, but we must admit that this scene was so well-made
This is what happens when Japanese and Bulgarian folklores clash. What a masterpiece.
So bad, i found that video and started it, then i thought - shit i have to stop it to watch it in the movie, but then i read the comments .. and started the video again. So disappointing to read that its not in the movie as intro song. But now im gonna watch the movie and lemme surprise how the shell scene works with another music.. - thx for this video :)
Thank you so much for uploading such content! This will be perfect for the transhumanism and ciberculture speech I will have in one week. ^^
It's a different movie with the original soundtrack
I remembered nerding the f out when I heard this theme in the ending credits. They combined the original 1995 films theme with the opening theme to Ghost in the Shell 2 innocence which I thought was really awesome. Honestly I really enjoyed the movie. To hell with the haters.
Both this movie and the original 1995 movie hit different now because of the passing of Atsuko Tanaka, who voiced Motoko Kusanagi/ Mira Killian.
Too bad that they use it for the credit score 😖
yes men....bad very bad...
CUBETechie you’re talking about the beginning credits or the ending ones ?
@@camillepotter8166
When I watched the movie making of cyborg was used in end credits
perfect
Great opening alot better then original live action movie version.
music is next level .. amazing ...
Perfect
Someone did it!!
Nice, thanks for doing this! I actually had to pause after the intro of the 2017 version and look for this. The new intro music was a totally anti-climatic experience for me. It's kinda fixed now. Probably had to do with expectations. But everything else in the intro felt very respectful of the old, so why replace that very iconic music with that boring low-key, low-pitch stuff. Anyway, thanks again!
Сцена сразу же стала выглядеть лучше))
Not having this song play in the movie intro demonstrates the director's misunderstanding of the appeal of the anime's aesthetics to fans, even if the movie still looks good
Then again, all these Hollywood people are too self-absorbed to respect any art that isn't their own
Or it could’ve been the studio. Everything looked like it was right out of the anime. Maybe I’m more lenient with the live action movie is because there isn’t a definitive ghost in the shell. The first movie was darker than the original manga, and all GITS has their own interpretation, what is the live action one but just another interpretation. Besides, it’s not like Japan does better when they make a live action anime movie. Look at attack on Titan
@@tgiacin435 i know im getting into this convo late but i feel that movies today are just made to fast this would of been made within in 2 years i think if they had an extra year to polish the script experiment with diffrent techniques of music and filming we would of got a better movie if you look at star wars before it was bought by disney all the movies had at least 3 years now disney is pumping them out every 2 years and each film/tv show is getting worse in terms of story characters and filming
@@steffanoboin5060 yeah, it needed more time, but for what it is, it’s decent as an anime adaptation
@@tgiacin435 oh definately im not shitting on the movie i just think if they had that extra year they could of polished it a bit more
Awesome 😎 movie
Asi quedaba sublime, con esta musica especialmente hecha para esta apertura. Espero que la justicia investigue este homicidio de soundtrack
si me vi la peli ORIGINAL como 5 veses y ni soy fan de la saga...solo x entender de que hablaban todos....y la pelicula es la ostia cuando inicia el live action...uno se pregunta... Y EL BSO MEN????es como con the shining algo similar..x eso el descontento de los fans
segun lei, a un productor idiota le parecia que la cancion incomodara a los espectadores al no enter la letra
@@cerono9169 BAhahahahha no puede ser verdad.
Que horrible.
Personally, speaking on behalf of someone (I) who bought the Bluray disc and the wall poster at the cinema, I would say that from 1:47 to 1:51 there is a level of art that approaches the anime. The other parts on the entire sequence are not enough to compete. It would cost much more to keep the same quality/pace as Oshii's animation.
Robot get consciousness isn't about...but is something else...white light boost.
I saw this in the theater and I could’ve sworn it actually had this song in the intro. Why the fuck did they remove it for the home release?
Why they don´t put this in the original Version of the Movie??? O_o Such a smal change and such a large differenc xD
I like this song it’s way better then the original 1995 one
I wish it was done this way. And a different actress would fit Ms. Kusanagi's character. Scarlet's fine, as B.Widow. But not as the lieutenant.
The mayor
The Major
johanson was perfect as the major!
This is live action or anime from the creators of Dragon Ball Evolution, Bleach & Attack On Titan comes the new chapter of the hit movie called “The Ghost In The Shell.”
Its so messed up how they obtained the brain for this to take place which you find out at the end of the movie that they basically kidnapped some poor girl that hardly anyone would probably miss than extracted her brain against her will to have it inserted into Scarlett Johannsson's character's body.... :O :O :'(
So thats How Hollywood creating they dolls wow even with Epic music:)
Bravo👏
Don't know why they didn't put this in the movie.
Copyrights. If the director had his way, the words "fan made" wouldnt be here
Something I've never figured out... both _Ghost in the Shell (2017)_ and _Terminator Salvation_ show the title *twice* in the opening credits. (Both of them near the start in plain text... then in a more stylized way at the end.) Why is that? Is it some legal thing?
And Lorne Bolf oh so they wanted that
AH, thats better
ほんとにアニメ版を実写で忠実に再現しただけなのね。
ふうんさすがハリウッドだねCGスゴいね、
…で？
って感じかな。
川井さんの曲も若干テンポ速めなのかな。
Animators: Thank You For Putting In The Song
my god.. I surrender my soul take me..
Something that I did not like in this adaptation was the music for making of a cyborg (like many of us).
In the animated movie its music is mostly vocals with ancient (to some) and natural instruments. It offset the very mechanical and cyber-aesthetic of the visuals of a mock birthing scene. I'd describe it as a celebration of a birth. A tribe elated at a new and healthy child.
This one though... it just felt too mechanical, as well as generic (it has that baseline of every epic/ trailer for a sci fi setting ever). There are some strings for a more natural sound, and even a few seconds of quiet chanting. It makes it all seem way too generi and artifical for my liking. In a way it's too modern and "western" when it was a Japanese story written and made by Japanese people.
@Metroid2424 did you change anything or did you just dub the original theme? Because if this is a straight dub, it's clear to me Rupert wanted the original theme but some copyright or money problems happened. Because how could you NOT us this.
I looked for a couple different ways to sync the video and audio, and I settled on that big drum hit during the white covering flaking off. I didn't change the video or song. It really should have been like this!
Actually the only thing I did edit was extending the title screen at the very end of the video.
Really dumb that they didn’t put this song in the opening making cyborg scene before releasing it in theaters…
Would’ve been perfect
Which version was used for this edit? I don't recognize the second half of the track, which sounds somewhat similar to one of the tracks from Innocence, yet different.
Scarlett Johansson lore:
I can't find the intro... 😑
❤
Era pra ser assim no filme
Ne
映画館で初めて寝た映画
そういう意味では記念すべき一昨ではある
Cuánto épica le faltó al nacimiento del Cyborg 😠 un verdadero desperdicio
Congratulations to the person who thought it was a good idea changing the song.
Where's the link to the original one?
Why? Why the fucking FUCK did they not play this song with the 2017 movie? This intro would have (and did, in 1995) **made the movie**. Literally the only thing they had to do to make the film excellent but they were happy with good.
...
I like the song :3
Nice fan-made movie, except some fancy gfx in the end. And the actor is not ideal. Anyway nice work :P
It aint fan made.
why didn’t they use this version with original soundtrack?
Bad choice
This seems to be a great film,
please someone give me a honest review
How it should be. Great movie though.
Epilepsy warning ffs dude.
"waiting for brain insertion" is kinda bad.
Just say "ready", no ones waiting.
They had one F* job, put this song in the intro and they screwed it up and some youtube had to fix the mistake. Hollywood do better.
How was this movie bad?
It wasnt. Its just a bunch of butthurt fanboys and people who think the film was Whitewashing... which it really wasnt.
I actually preferred the Clint Mansell and Lorne Balfe score over Kenji Kawai's tbh...
Naah, it's so deffrent.
I can't gettin used with it
😍😍😍😍😍
А это сделали фанаты
Ghost in the Shell FanFilm
ruclips.net/video/SwLhFoyyvQ0/видео.html
Too easy to understand...
Comment section full of edgelords.
Sorry but that was painful to watch.
if you want to do something good for yourself, then you look at the original and not this more than bad copy...
UNA FALTA DE RESPETO AL ORIGUNAL....¡¡¡¡
Anime fan be like : why this movies can't end before starting.
素材を台無しにしたクソ映画
映像自体はいいと思ったが、内容が薄っぺらいのなんの
原作は問題提起だけして、判断を見てる人に委ねるからこそ奥深さが生まれる良作なのに、この映画は作中で「○○は△△だ」って言いきっちゃうんだよね。それがホントくそ。監督の思考（倫理観）の押し付けとか、マジでいらねーんだよ。
I prefer the new score tbh
It was poor executed live action...so sad
Why not stick on the original story? Instead, they (hollywood) generated typically lame made up story about Major...and made her so emotionally human...
Nah, in my opinion, i liked some of the changes, especially the change to make major more human.