Not true at all. Peyton Manning is a top3 QB in the history of the NFL. He is NFL royalty... more like 1 Manning for every 1000 Jamarcus Russells. For every Kirk Cousins there are 4 Jamarcus Russells
Bringing this up is moronic. Russel was a lazy addict, and the only reason he was drafted as high as he was because the Raiders owner liked him. The red flags were BLATANT even at the time. It's true that most picks are busts, but the Russell comp is r*tarded. Russell was an obvious bust to begin with.
@@ProfKisuto , the number of QBs that make it to their second contract is about 1 in 3, let alone whether they live up to those contracts. Peyton and Jamarcus are probably a bit too extreme of examples, being the poplar ends of the spectrum but there are definitely more Carson Wentzes than there are Carson Palmers.
I like Kurt Warner’s honesty. He says it is virtually impossible to know how these qbs translate to the nfl because their college tape is so schematically different. Between the ears processing is paramount.
Well, Kurt’s latest break down of Caleb vs Washington there are a lot of concepts that will be at the next level. The NFL is now in more of a spread offence type but, playing it with different personnel. We will see a lot more spilt safety coverages this year and quarters looks to help with overhangs on the RPOs and being flat footed on run support and those intermediate throws. But yes, you never really know how any of these guys will translate physically and mentally
A lot of people like down Daniels because of his talented WR’s . Malik Nabers was projected to be a 1st rounder coming into the season, but Brian Thomas Jr. was not . Daniels play led to his receivers having a great season. IMO he is the best pocket passer and has the best deep ball placement of any QB in this class
Every defensive player that talked about Daniel’s mentioned his agility twitchiness and fluidity when running he’s very fast and smooth. He is not a pocket passer but nice try “who dat” I’m sure you rode his dingle ling since the moment he stepped in Baton Rouge😂
@@DairyHamilton just because they talked about his ability to run doesn’t mean he’s not a good pocket passer . Also I stated that it was my OPINION . But reading and comprehension clearly isn’t you’re strong suit
It’s funny how no one is talking about the bad stuff. Crying to his mom after losing on the sideline..Refusing to do press conferences after losing games the last 5-7 games of the season. The guy is immature and throws fits. He not a leader. But sports casters got to boost someone. But the bears should definitely trade the pick
One of the keys to being a successful NFL QB is mental toughness. Crying to mommy tells me he is anything but. He may have the physical tools but QB is as much about mental as it is physical toughness.
Lamar my fav qb but it’s honestly a guessing game at the end of the day because depending on what team they land on determines majority of their success or lack or lack thereof
I feel like some guys just have a ranking and dont actually properly watch the film. Simms clearly does and that is why he has probably the most accurate rankings. Yes he gets some wrong but, every single person has when rankings QBs.
This slighting of McMahon is shameful. Doesn’t the Vikings fan remember the 1985 Monday night game? Even former Bears like Dan Hampton later acknowledged that McMahon was the key.
If it weren't for Green Bay's Charles Martin's absolute cheap shot slamming McMahon to the ground, the 86' Bears would've repeated as SB Champs. McMahon wasn't elite or the best, but he was the leader and best for that team.
So what? Zach went 2nd overall and was clearly the top QB for most of the league after Lawrence. Yes he had a few ones that went wrong but so does the league miss on many. on the opposite side, he nailed a lot of them, like Mahomes, Allen, Lamar, Stroud, Jordan Love, Bortles, etc. He is one of the best qb Analysts the media has out there. Always gonna listen to his evaluations
5 stars, not just for this video but for all you do. You guys are like peas and carrots; like meat and potatoes; like Aichman and Buck. Hope to watch you for a long time !!
Yeah as Simms said people criticize Williams for trying to play hero ball too much but in his mind he probably had too to have a chance in games since his defense was lousy. Plus when you have his kind of talent it's easy to go for too much when you more often then not succeed at doing it. And I like that he mentioned Allen who's really the poster boy for hero ball. But that's what I love about Allen. It's part of what makes him great and it's also why they're never out of a game. I just hope the Bears don't try to change him. He definitely has to dial it back, but he also needs to be who he is which is making plays when things break down.
How insightful. What a well thought out perspective. I could not find this same perspective anywhere else. I really do believe that Chris really hit the tapes hard and really really and critically evaluated these prospects and not just copy and pasted what everyone else said. Yeah. I really believe that.
If we look at past "sure thing" #1 qbs of the recent past, were they worth it? Why isnt it easier to see future success at this position compared to others???
The only "sure thing" QBs were Elway, Peyton, Andrew Luck, and Trevor Lawrence (could be argued he wasn't a sure thing because there were some prospects scouts who felt he was a touch overrated).
@@thomaswelcomer8443 nope, he's always been overrated imo... Which is why I pointed out why you could argue he was not even a sure thing. Plenty of promenet scouts and talent evaluates (Simms is a good example), said people were over rating Trevor... if there are experts saying he isn't a sure thing then you could argue he didn't get the "sure thing" treatment that Luck got... I didn't hear anyone say that about Luck cause he was a sure thing.
@@thomaswelcomer8443Team is overrated. Had Meyer as a coach his first year. The team skipped over Hutchinson to take Walker. Thanks. (Lions fan) Trevor is good enough to take a team to the Superbowl. But a good team. Not carry the entire thing. Good enough to be top ten qb, and have a good year to fit in at 5 or 6.
This one is tough one with Daniels. You watch the arm and angles and it seems like he’s phenomenal. Then you watch for the progression….and like Fields in college, it just wasn’t exactly necessary. Especially with those legs and the WR can always just run downfield after the play broke down…and that’s not always the case in the NFL. Drake Maye reminds me of a Carson Wentz without the balls.
Mr Florio, I hate that you said Chicago won the Super Bowl because of the defense. What about Walter Payton? duh! The 85 Bears had the best rushing attack in the league and ranked 2nd in total offense......learn your facts.
The bears are looking at this as an easy decision The team is almost set to contend Reset the clock with Williams and give him a rookie salary for the next few years is a no brainier and even if his floor another Justin fields then they still think they can contend and the contract is cheaper Clearly he’s better than JF but it shows how easy an decision it is If it doesn’t work out they can look at free agent qb or draft another in a year or two At least the rest of the positions are setup for the future so it’s doesn’t need a huge overhaul and they are not stuck with a huge QB contract to offload
Where these guy’s go has a lot, and I mean a lot to do with if they succeed. I truly believe that some of the quarterbacks who failed, their careers would have been a complete 180 with another team.
More like 50% depends on what criteria you use. But more importantly only 5% of guys after the 1st round do - so any pick after the 1st is usually a waste of time (11 since 2000 have been at least OK)
@@brandondillman5841 lmao no he’s not. He’s had a few bad whiffs in his career but he certainly is much closer to really accurate than he is inaccurate. 65% percentage and adjusted it’s 77%.
@@JamesJDMoe idk. All the highlights I've seen on Maye he's consistently underthrowing the deep ball. There's a lot of tape out there of Maye missing easy throws several times a game.
Do we think the days of a Rex Grossman getting a team to the Super Bowl are over? Because I kind of do. The league has changed. You need at least a top 12 or so QB to even have a shot. Defense can still win championships, but you have to score points to get there.
Williams has mannerisms like Curt Warner & Marino. Bears problem offensive line and wide receivers. Is the best college player Williams or someone else? If so who?
The combine should be mandatory for any player entering the draft. Everything in the combine should be also. Caleb Williams declining the medical exams is ludicrous. It's a business with billions upon billions. The owners should all agree to make sure he's drafted last in the draft. Chicago trades for the last pick, and drafts him there. Then make him back up.
I want to see these so called sports experts talk about William's mental issues, his father issues and all the other stuff that is going to make him potentially a big pain for the organization that drafts him. Cause next year there is going to be another guy just like William's at the top of the draft. Could be Sanders, Ewers or someone else, but we'll be right back here with them regurgitating what they're saying now.
Lmao, no QB in last years draft was seen to be as good as Williams, same with the class before that. The last time a QB got this much hype was Trevor Lawrence and before that it was probably Andrew Luck.
If you've ever watched Simms you would know that he watches the tape, that's it. He's going by their football ability. It's up to the GM's and Coaches to figure that other stuff out.
@@yellowsnowman9157 nah he’s really similar scrambles around and looks to throw deep and does his best work off script if he was Mahomes size I’d get it I was telling ppl Mahomes was the best QB prospect in that 2017 classes Williams is top pick worthy but doesn’t check the height box and he’s not running at the combine or doing any agility testing so really can’t see if he’s a college athlete or he’s just freaky athlete
simms is tapped in and people respect his thoughts on QB. his best friend kyle shanahan talks football with him, why wouldnt a GM ask him? doesnt mean they’ll take his advice
How is this an analyzation of the qb class? Only two were talked about and everyone knows Caleb is the first pick. If this is it…man o man will it be a boring lead up to the draft. Sorry Pats…guess there are no qbs left at #3
Seems like he trying to hold his rankings until closer to draft. Plus this just one opinion , half say Drake is #2. As a Commanders fan I don’t care just give me who my staff trust.
@@terencebarnes7393 honestly…it’s about time the Commanders got a guy who can rally the fanbase. I hope they nail it or even move up to get Caleb a local guy. But I agree, Simms is still watching tape of the other guys. Just felt short changed with this discussion
@@jeffmetcalf1733 Yea I get it with Simms. Yea we need a guy bad. I be having debate with other Commanders fans wanting to trade back. Which I understand but if there is a QB you like/love draft him and figure out rest later.
Did Chris Sims say plagiarize his thoughts? 😂😂😂 He was in love with zach Wilson and kellen mond! 😂😂😂 he needs to hold his tongue cuz he's gonna say something stupid and needs to protect himself 😂😂😂 dudes hilarious 😂 😂😂
Well last year every analyst but Simms said Young was a tier above Stroud. But after a year, Stroud is clearly leagues better and only Simms ranked him #1. By your logic you can no longer trust any analyst as they all got it wrong, big time. Simms hits more often on QBs than anyone though. He also had hit on Maholme's, Allen, Herbert and Jackson when other analysts had people like Tua, Darnold, Rosen, etc above them. Also, he had Mond 4th in his rankings that year. If you're gonna cherry pick on his 4th rated QB you literally should trust no analyst ever. The draft is not an exact science or else you'd never have early round Busts and late round stars. That's why you have to go off hit rate. And in that metric, Simms gets QBs right more often than anyone else in the industry.
The Bears would be CRAZY to allow Fields to go to Atlanta. CRAZY! Sure, Caleb's better. But you put Fields behind the #4 offensive line in the competition with Bijan and Kyle Pitts and he's going to win games. Which is a problem. Because Caleb's going to be judged against the guy he's replaced. Like it or not. And I certainly don't trust the Bears to put him into a winning position.
At least tell the truth Caleb is terrible under pressure .My grandma throws a better Deeo ball holds the ball dosent throw on time run backwards instead of get yards
Caleb Williams looks like another failed USC quarterback to me. If the Bears are dumb enough to draft him, they deserve all of the suckery that falls on their heads. Learn from the Panthers mistake, and take Jayden instead.
Ok sir I am going to voice my opinion, I really do like to see everyone be successful offensively, but defensively what I do hate, is this folker spearing the receiver, and trying to hurt the receiver. And so help me God when you do that I’m going to be the guy that picks him up and then you will find out just how big you and I really are and power to the offense because I promise you the offense has the right to run right through the defense hit because you better brace your body for impact from the defense. And hang on to the ball no matter who you are because I’m sure the offense players are tired of his shit defensively too.
I’m a huge Chris Sims fan and I usually agree with everything that he says most of the time but this Caleb Williams shit is just absolutely ridiculous they’re acting like he’s the greatest coach football player to ever play and he’s just not at all I mean yeah, he’s got a good arm. I can’t wait to see how he does in the power level because I don’t think it’s gonna switch over as well as people think he is, not gonna go as far as to say he’s gonna be a bus, but I doubt he’s gonna be a top 10 quarterback in his first 2 to 3 years
I would draft a qb that played in pro style offense in college. I also would want high iq quarterback that can read a defense. These little qbs are a joke they get hurt.
I think Zach has grown a bit and could have a good if intriguing year. After all the Jets are not picking #1 for an organization that have minimal support in developing young quarterbacks.
Bla bla bla is all the shit that I hear because usually I can’t hear the tv from the music and most of the time the music sucks but then some of it is good but yes I agree to cut that shit off too because the music sucks and let me clean your soul with better music and stuff
If Fields is traded. Washington can offer their 2nd rounders for Fields and maybe another pick or two next year. Then they don't have to wait on a young qb to develop, otherwise JD.
Nah, Fields has the same issue they accused Howell of, he "holds the ball too long!" The difference is, Fields had the SIXTH BEST O-line in NFL at end of season ranking (!), and gave him a very good 2.66 seconds to throw and was rated VERY GOOD at picking up the blitz. That's TWO MAJOR things Howell didn't have. In fact when teams realized WFT was not good at picking up the blitz, they were attacked 28.8 percent of the time!!! Have you ever thought of gaining the FACTS about the issue, BEFORE commenting??!
@escaped1534 Your attempt to inform me about this team is quite unnecessary because I know the offensive issues and what Howell went through quite well and showed us what he capable of doing. My comment point was if they were targeting a quarterback with this pick and who is right there for the taking and with a slight trade down inside top ten they can start building the OL and gain back a 2nd round pick type scenario.
Hard pass. Anybody trading for Fields has to commit a lot of money to him too. He's not worth more than 1 2nd rounder and the Commies aren't a good fit.
A lot of draft pundits don't even bother looking at the schemes different teams run, they just put players on teams even when the fit isn't right. Much like so many pundits have had Justin Fields or Jayden Daniels to the Falcons, WTF? Neither fit Zac Robinson's scheme yet pundits time after time place these QB's with schemes they don't fit in. Most pundits are simply talking out their ass. They get so caught up i the numbers they end up not seeing the forest through the trees - most of the shit they spew is worthless.
Yup, the arm talent, quick release, sold me. If he can read defenses, his ability to throw and throw quickly is topshelf. He is my #1 pick, only reservation are his injuries.
Florio you’re one to talk about idea plagiarism. You steals Simms knowledge and takes ALL THE TIME. You can trace it all. I’m always so surprised that Simms lets you get away with it. Florio doesn’t watch any film at all. He doesn’t know shit and refuses to dedicate any of his “precious time” to doing his job and watching film. It’s far too easy to just steal for Simms and parade it all as his own thoughts
Sims has revised his evaluation of Jayden Daniels after actually watching game tape of him. Before, he criticized Daniels' throwing mechanics and ability, BUT NOW (after finally actually watching game tape!) he is reporting that Daniels' throwing mechanics and ability is Top Shelf. Better late than never, I guess!
Well if you actually listen to him talk he says he doesn't evaluate guys during the season and any opinions before the draft process are just based on casual observations here and there.
You act like every guy watches game tape for every single prospect on a weekly basis. Most of the noise all year long are just based on casual observations. There are very few people who do film breakdown after every single game, and most of those guys are NFL scouts. It's good when somebody can realize their initial observations were wrong rather than "stick to their guns" because they don't want to admit they made a mistake.
Marginal discrepancy in talent is not the deciding factor when it comes to success at the QB position. We have seen many elite College QB's, taken in the 1st round and yet fail in the NFL. Intelligence, leadership skills, moral foundation, focus/ commitment and 'heart' is what separates those who fail from those who become Elite QB's in the NFL.
I trust Simms analysis more than any of the other talking heads. I only disagree with his opinion that Caleb Williams is a sure bet. I saw that boy cry after one of his college games: mental fortitude is a big part of success in the NFL.
@@yellowsnowman9157 That's what they said about Plunkett and Stabler and even that dude that played for New England.. Oh yeah and they hated Bradshaw in Pittsburgh almost cut him.
1:46 Mike should apply this to anything science related. As I did, he will eat a large slice of embarrassing humble pie after applying this way of thinking across every possible subject that one can have an opinion on.
for every Payton Manning there are 4 Jamarcus Russel's
I wouldn't go THAT far.
lol only luck, Lawrence, and Williams have been on this level coming oht
Not true at all. Peyton Manning is a top3 QB in the history of the NFL. He is NFL royalty... more like 1 Manning for every 1000 Jamarcus Russells. For every Kirk Cousins there are 4 Jamarcus Russells
Bringing this up is moronic.
Russel was a lazy addict, and the only reason he was drafted as high as he was because the Raiders owner liked him.
The red flags were BLATANT even at the time.
It's true that most picks are busts, but the Russell comp is r*tarded. Russell was an obvious bust to begin with.
@@ProfKisuto , the number of QBs that make it to their second contract is about 1 in 3, let alone whether they live up to those contracts. Peyton and Jamarcus are probably a bit too extreme of examples, being the poplar ends of the spectrum but there are definitely more Carson Wentzes than there are Carson Palmers.
I like Kurt Warner’s honesty. He says it is virtually impossible to know how these qbs translate to the nfl because their college tape is so schematically different. Between the ears processing is paramount.
Absolutely, we can never know until we see it.
Well, Kurt’s latest break down of Caleb vs Washington there are a lot of concepts that will be at the next level.
The NFL is now in more of a spread offence type but, playing it with different personnel.
We will see a lot more spilt safety coverages this year and quarters looks to help with overhangs on the RPOs and being flat footed on run support and those intermediate throws.
But yes, you never really know how any of these guys will translate physically and mentally
disagree
@@HM55-77 how
“Jayden Daniels is the Incredible Hulk compared to Bryce Young.” 😂😂😂
damn, simms spoiled the fun revealing his qb draft rankings
Curious to see how Chris's picks turn out, he's been pretty accurate with his takes on prospective QB's each year.
I really like Jayden Daniels, I hope he listen to his coaches and slides on runs. Its crazy how many big hits he took.
I hope he puts on 15 lbs or so of muscle/weight because he's gonna get cracked so hard running as high as he does
@@buddybarlow9604watch Daniels interview. He has no plans on doing that.
@@buddybarlow9604 Exactly.
Daniel’s is the best QB this draft
I was watching the Oklahoma game when he came in an took Spencer rattler's job. I was like this kid is special..crazy how things have come to fruition
A lot of people like down Daniels because of his talented WR’s . Malik Nabers was projected to be a 1st rounder coming into the season, but Brian Thomas Jr. was not . Daniels play led to his receivers having a great season. IMO he is the best pocket passer and has the best deep ball placement of any QB in this class
Brian thomas jr is a dawg too. You def can not say Daniel’s elevated their play
Every defensive player that talked about Daniel’s mentioned his agility twitchiness and fluidity when running he’s very fast and smooth. He is not a pocket passer but nice try “who dat” I’m sure you rode his dingle ling since the moment he stepped in Baton Rouge😂
@@ajkareem5685 Brian Thomas Jr had just over 350 receiving yards in 2022. So yes I can say Daniels elevated his play
@@DairyHamilton just because they talked about his ability to run doesn’t mean he’s not a good pocket passer . Also I stated that it was my OPINION . But reading and comprehension clearly isn’t you’re strong suit
This mofo just said “dingle ling” 😂. Kids man….
It’s funny how no one is talking about the bad stuff. Crying to his mom after losing on the sideline..Refusing to do press conferences after losing games the last 5-7 games of the season. The guy is immature and throws fits. He not a leader. But sports casters got to boost someone. But the bears should definitely trade the pick
One of the keys to being a successful NFL QB is mental toughness. Crying to mommy tells me he is anything but. He may have the physical tools but QB is as much about mental as it is physical toughness.
Bears need to trade the pick and load up.
Trade the pick, get picks, THEN draft a qb. There. Corrected. This is too good of a qb class to not pick one of them up.
Chris is worth listening to.
Hey! Jim McMahon has 2 Super Bowl Rings!
He was never elite even in 1985
Earl Morrall, a QB, has 3.
Simms said Lamar Jackson was the best qb in that draft when they was telling him too play receiver look it up
He also said Zach Wilson was the best qb in his class
Lamar my fav qb but it’s honestly a guessing game at the end of the day because depending on what team they land on determines majority of their success or lack or lack thereof
Please Chicago don't draft C W....
I feel like some guys just have a ranking and dont actually properly watch the film. Simms clearly does and that is why he has probably the most accurate rankings. Yes he gets some wrong but, every single person has when rankings QBs.
Simms does the work, no doubt (educated opinions)
Glad to see Bo Nix getting some love. I have rated number 2
Production and tape don't say #2 overall
@@justinevans182agreed I have Penix over Nix, although I understand how past injuries can be a downside for him.
Too high...Williams/Maye/Daniels at minimum will go higher (possibly the first three picks)
You’ve got to be kidding
This guy rode the bench his whole career all three of these guys will be great go pats
The only thing with Daniel's is, do you completely ignore the ASU tape?
Same reasoning with Williams @Oklahoma. Gotta take it all in.
Washington has receivers.
This slighting of McMahon is shameful. Doesn’t the Vikings fan remember the 1985 Monday night game? Even former Bears like Dan Hampton later acknowledged that McMahon was the key.
If it weren't for Green Bay's Charles Martin's absolute cheap shot slamming McMahon to the ground, the 86' Bears would've repeated as SB Champs. McMahon wasn't elite or the best, but he was the leader and best for that team.
The Bears haven't had a great QB since Sid Luckman in the 1940's. lol
It was one of the first Thursday night games actually. I was at my favorite neighborhood bar watching it.
Simms thought Zach Wilson was top QB in that draft class hahaha
He also got Mahomes and recently CJ spot on. You win some you lose some.
So what? Zach went 2nd overall and was clearly the top QB for most of the league after Lawrence.
Yes he had a few ones that went wrong but so does the league miss on many.
on the opposite side, he nailed a lot of them, like Mahomes, Allen, Lamar, Stroud, Jordan Love, Bortles, etc.
He is one of the best qb Analysts the media has out there. Always gonna listen to his evaluations
Jets are a broken franchise. They break QBs
He did go to the jets
So you think Maye is better than Daniels then? lol
Cale Williams, Drake Maye, Michael Pinx, JJ, Daniels is 5th. He has above average arm. Not great, small frame can he throw in tight windows????
5 stars, not just for this video but for all you do. You guys are like peas and carrots; like meat and potatoes; like Aichman and Buck. Hope to watch you for a long time !!
"5 stars, not just for this video"
I feel like it's been at least 10 years since stars existed on RUclips videos.
Yeah as Simms said people criticize Williams for trying to play hero ball too much but in his mind he probably had too to have a chance in games since his defense was lousy. Plus when you have his kind of talent it's easy to go for too much when you more often then not succeed at doing it.
And I like that he mentioned Allen who's really the poster boy for hero ball. But that's what I love about Allen. It's part of what makes him great and it's also why they're never out of a game. I just hope the Bears don't try to change him. He definitely has to dial it back, but he also needs to be who he is which is making plays when things break down.
The diamond in the haystack. 😂
Anyway, I knew Chris would come around eventually.
There are more intangibles that effect success than physical talent!
How insightful. What a well thought out perspective. I could not find this same perspective anywhere else. I really do believe that Chris really hit the tapes hard and really really and critically evaluated these prospects and not just copy and pasted what everyone else said. Yeah. I really believe that.
Simms doesn't comment,that after 4 of the 5 losses of USC ,Caleb Williams, didn't do a post game interview.Shows his immaturity.
in college you aren’t obligated to do post game. nobody also knew that there were games they won this year and he didnt do post game
Whatever Chris Simms says to do, do the opposite.
Williams reminds me more of Bryce Young than Patrick Mahomes
You must not have watched him much.
If we look at past "sure thing" #1 qbs of the recent past, were they worth it? Why isnt it easier to see future success at this position compared to others???
Speed of the game. Some guys can adjust, and some can't...
The only "sure thing" QBs were Elway, Peyton, Andrew Luck, and Trevor Lawrence (could be argued he wasn't a sure thing because there were some prospects scouts who felt he was a touch overrated).
@@keenannash2947 would you say, after a few years in the league, Trevor is worthy of a top pick?
@@thomaswelcomer8443 nope, he's always been overrated imo... Which is why I pointed out why you could argue he was not even a sure thing. Plenty of promenet scouts and talent evaluates (Simms is a good example), said people were over rating Trevor... if there are experts saying he isn't a sure thing then you could argue he didn't get the "sure thing" treatment that Luck got... I didn't hear anyone say that about Luck cause he was a sure thing.
@@thomaswelcomer8443Team is overrated. Had Meyer as a coach his first year. The team skipped over Hutchinson to take Walker. Thanks. (Lions fan) Trevor is good enough to take a team to the Superbowl. But a good team. Not carry the entire thing. Good enough to be top ten qb, and have a good year to fit in at 5 or 6.
😂its funny how know one talks about caleb williams wobbley deep ball
Simms knows all.... just ask him. Lol
This one is tough one with Daniels. You watch the arm and angles and it seems like he’s phenomenal. Then you watch for the progression….and like Fields in college, it just wasn’t exactly necessary. Especially with those legs and the WR can always just run downfield after the play broke down…and that’s not always the case in the NFL.
Drake Maye reminds me of a Carson Wentz without the balls.
Maye is not better than Sam Howell despite being bigger and faster.
@@cperkins5050Drake Maye is Zach Wilson 2.0
The edge Daniel's have is playing in the SEC against many players who will make NFL rosters.
Mr Florio, I hate that you said Chicago won the Super Bowl because of the defense. What about Walter Payton? duh! The 85 Bears had the best rushing attack in the league and ranked 2nd in total offense......learn your facts.
The bears are looking at this as an easy decision
The team is almost set to contend
Reset the clock with Williams and give him a rookie salary for the next few years is a no brainier and even if his floor another Justin fields then they still think they can contend and the contract is cheaper
Clearly he’s better than JF but it shows how easy an decision it is
If it doesn’t work out they can look at free agent qb or draft another in a year or two
At least the rest of the positions are setup for the future so it’s doesn’t need a huge overhaul and they are not stuck with a huge QB contract to offload
Zach Wilson had no line, ran for his life.
Where these guy’s go has a lot, and I mean a lot to do with if they succeed. I truly believe that some of the quarterbacks who failed, their careers would have been a complete 180 with another team.
If Mahomes had gone to the Broncos or Raiders crappy coaching, his career would look completely different. He got the ultimate QB Guru in Andy Reid...
Thank you! Can you please explain that to all the Vikings fans who are willing to trade Jefferson and several years of draft picks just to get a QB
Where you go is 70% of the equation.
Well then Get ready to be shocked Chris Simms.
I don’t see it with Nix
Historically only 1/3 of 1st round QBs pan out. That means only 2 of the top 6 this year.
More like 50% depends on what criteria you use. But more importantly only 5% of guys after the 1st round do - so any pick after the 1st is usually a waste of time (11 since 2000 have been at least OK)
Obv Daniels is number 2 - don't even know why Maye is on the list
I think Williams is just overhyped, and in my opinion, NFL defenses are going to chew him up
Drake Maye is better than Jayden Daniels. People will see soon enough
😂😂
Maye is too inaccurate
@@brandondillman5841 lmao no he’s not. He’s had a few bad whiffs in his career but he certainly is much closer to really accurate than he is inaccurate. 65% percentage and adjusted it’s 77%.
@@KingPolo985 my reaction when ppl say Daniels is QB1
@@JamesJDMoe idk. All the highlights I've seen on Maye he's consistently underthrowing the deep ball. There's a lot of tape out there of Maye missing easy throws several times a game.
Do we think the days of a Rex Grossman getting a team to the Super Bowl are over? Because I kind of do. The league has changed. You need at least a top 12 or so QB to even have a shot. Defense can still win championships, but you have to score points to get there.
The 49ers made it with Jimmy G. a few years ago.
Simms once said Zach Wilson might be worth the #1 pick over Trevor Lawrence.
Would Jaden Daniels be worth Chicago trading there first for Washington's first and second this year and next year?
Why would Washington do that? Caleb has too many red flags to trade up for.
With all due respect, you have lost your mind.
I still believe that Bo Nix is going to be the best QB from this draft, hands down. Mark my words.
"Plagiarize my thoughts???" The guy who manloved Zach Wilson so much that the kid still has the drool on him?
Williams has mannerisms like Curt Warner & Marino. Bears problem offensive line and wide receivers. Is the best college player Williams or someone else? If so who?
They spent most on 1 qb and not the QB (s) class
It's not the on field we have to worry about with Caleb. I would take Daniels at 1.
How much of the Kool Aid have you drank?
@@JohnAC4 you will see when he goes pro. He reminds me of rg-lll.
Antony Richardson!!! Please don't compare any other running QB to him!
Richardson isn't as fast as Daniels. He's huge and powerful with good speed, but he's not as fast.
The combine should be mandatory for any player entering the draft. Everything in the combine should be also. Caleb Williams declining the medical exams is ludicrous. It's a business with billions upon billions. The owners should all agree to make sure he's drafted last in the draft. Chicago trades for the last pick, and drafts him there. Then make him back up.
I want to see these so called sports experts talk about William's mental issues, his father issues and all the other stuff that is going to make him potentially a big pain for the organization that drafts him. Cause next year there is going to be another guy just like William's at the top of the draft. Could be Sanders, Ewers or someone else, but we'll be right back here with them regurgitating what they're saying now.
Lmao, no QB in last years draft was seen to be as good as Williams, same with the class before that. The last time a QB got this much hype was Trevor Lawrence and before that it was probably Andrew Luck.
Seeing as none of these guys are mental health experts that would be kind of silly.
If you've ever watched Simms you would know that he watches the tape, that's it. He's going by their football ability. It's up to the GM's and Coaches to figure that other stuff out.
Caleb reminds me a lot of Fran Tarkington.
He’s bigger stronger better passing lesser runner Kyler Murray
Fran was the first one I thought of a couple years ago too funnily enough. I was hoping to see someone else mention it
@@isaiahh4108so he's completely different than Kyler.... Congrats on the awful comparison
@@yellowsnowman9157 nah he’s really similar scrambles around and looks to throw deep and does his best work off script if he was Mahomes size I’d get it I was telling ppl Mahomes was the best QB prospect in that 2017 classes Williams is top pick worthy but doesn’t check the height box and he’s not running at the combine or doing any agility testing so really can’t see if he’s a college athlete or he’s just freaky athlete
2:50 LOL, ain't no GM asking Chris Simms who to take at QB. Clown.
simms is tapped in and people respect his thoughts on QB. his best friend kyle shanahan talks football with him, why wouldnt a GM ask him? doesnt mean they’ll take his advice
Not a better arm than Penix.
Caleb has the better arm, but Penix has the better touch. Having seen both multiple times in person, Both are going to do well in the NFL.
How is this an analyzation of the qb class? Only two were talked about and everyone knows Caleb is the first pick. If this is it…man o man will it be a boring lead up to the draft. Sorry Pats…guess there are no qbs left at #3
Seems like he trying to hold his rankings until closer to draft. Plus this just one opinion , half say Drake is #2. As a Commanders fan I don’t care just give me who my staff trust.
@@terencebarnes7393 honestly…it’s about time the Commanders got a guy who can rally the fanbase. I hope they nail it or even move up to get Caleb a local guy. But I agree, Simms is still watching tape of the other guys. Just felt short changed with this discussion
@@jeffmetcalf1733 Yea I get it with Simms. Yea we need a guy bad. I be having debate with other Commanders fans wanting to trade back. Which I understand but if there is a QB you like/love draft him and figure out rest later.
Simms said that kellen mond was good 🤣👎
Isn't this what you guys said last year about Young, how'd that work out?
Arm strength was never mentioned with Young. Doing too much to win was never mentioned with Young.
Did Chris Sims say plagiarize his thoughts? 😂😂😂 He was in love with zach Wilson and kellen mond! 😂😂😂 he needs to hold his tongue cuz he's gonna say something stupid and needs to protect himself 😂😂😂 dudes hilarious 😂 😂😂
Jayden Daniels = RG3 2.0
If RG3 could have stayed healthy with the Shanahan's he would have had a great career. Can't predict injury.
Mess me up Faja Topher
Florio and his agent spiel…
Simms was adamant that Kellen Mond could be a starter in this league. His opinions on the position can be safely discarded.
So every analyst should be 100% right?
@@RLZ01 You can be a little off. Being *THAT* wrong? Nah bruh.
Well last year every analyst but Simms said Young was a tier above Stroud. But after a year, Stroud is clearly leagues better and only Simms ranked him #1. By your logic you can no longer trust any analyst as they all got it wrong, big time.
Simms hits more often on QBs than anyone though. He also had hit on Maholme's, Allen, Herbert and Jackson when other analysts had people like Tua, Darnold, Rosen, etc above them.
Also, he had Mond 4th in his rankings that year. If you're gonna cherry pick on his 4th rated QB you literally should trust no analyst ever. The draft is not an exact science or else you'd never have early round Busts and late round stars. That's why you have to go off hit rate. And in that metric, Simms gets QBs right more often than anyone else in the industry.
Daniels is not as good a runner as A Richardson. 😅
Lol you must be high. He’s a better runner just not as powerful . Check the stats
Daniels is faster, Richardson is more of a Cam Newton type of power runner.
Daniels at 1
chris simms one of the best out there
I think Caleb is a awesome quarterback but the mechanics in the pocket are there
The Bears would be CRAZY to allow Fields to go to Atlanta. CRAZY! Sure, Caleb's better. But you put Fields behind the #4 offensive line in the competition with Bijan and Kyle Pitts and he's going to win games. Which is a problem. Because Caleb's going to be judged against the guy he's replaced. Like it or not. And I certainly don't trust the Bears to put him into a winning position.
You forgot drake london, but it's also overstated how and rhe bears' oline is and the weapons fields' had. A lot of those sacks fields caused himself
Ummm! You might want to Check Sid's Stats.... Not a Franchise QB!
I don’t care florio is friggin annoying as hell
I’m pretty confident that Simms does as much or more film study than most draft experts. Consequently, he’s been more accurate than most.
At least tell the truth Caleb is terrible under pressure .My grandma throws a better Deeo ball holds the ball dosent throw on time run backwards instead of get yards
Caleb Williams looks like another failed USC quarterback to me. If the Bears are dumb enough to draft him, they deserve all of the suckery that falls on their heads. Learn from the Panthers mistake, and take Jayden instead.
Ok sir I am going to voice my opinion, I really do like to see everyone be successful offensively, but defensively what I do hate, is this folker spearing the receiver, and trying to hurt the receiver. And so help me God when you do that I’m going to be the guy that picks him up and then you will find out just how big you and I really are and power to the offense because I promise you the offense has the right to run right through the defense hit because you better brace your body for impact from the defense. And hang on to the ball no matter who you are because I’m sure the offense players are tired of his shit defensively too.
I’m a huge Chris Sims fan and I usually agree with everything that he says most of the time but this Caleb Williams shit is just absolutely ridiculous they’re acting like he’s the greatest coach football player to ever play and he’s just not at all I mean yeah, he’s got a good arm. I can’t wait to see how he does in the power level because I don’t think it’s gonna switch over as well as people think he is, not gonna go as far as to say he’s gonna be a bus, but I doubt he’s gonna be a top 10 quarterback in his first 2 to 3 years
I’m curious who the last rated qb on this list is. Because that will be the best quarterback from this class
Bears = Daniels # 1.
you know they're gonna screw up and take that diva Caleb.
A barely Average Sims, analyzes QBs, just don't get this dude.
A barely average human analyzes guys who played in the nfl
I would draft a qb that played in pro style offense in college. I also would want high iq quarterback that can read a defense. These little qbs are a joke they get hurt.
I would take Daniel's number 1. He has a great all around game and can make all the throws.
He’s older than Caleb Maye and JJ
@@isaiahh4108this is a fair point since people love to bring it up about bo even tho him and Daniels are the same age
Drake Maye has Zach Wilson written all over him...
I think Zach has grown a bit and could have a good if intriguing year. After all the Jets are not picking #1 for an organization that have minimal support in developing young quarterbacks.
Bla bla bla is all the shit that I hear because usually I can’t hear the tv from the music and most of the time the music sucks but then some of it is good but yes I agree to cut that shit off too because the music sucks and let me clean your soul with better music and stuff
If Fields is traded. Washington can offer their 2nd rounders for Fields and maybe another pick or two next year. Then they don't have to wait on a young qb to develop, otherwise JD.
Nah, Fields has the same issue they accused Howell of, he "holds the ball too long!"
The difference is, Fields had the SIXTH BEST O-line in NFL at end of season ranking (!), and gave him a very good 2.66 seconds to throw and was rated VERY GOOD at picking up the blitz. That's TWO MAJOR things Howell didn't have. In fact when teams realized WFT was not good at picking up the blitz, they were attacked 28.8 percent of the time!!!
Have you ever thought of gaining the FACTS about the issue, BEFORE commenting??!
@escaped1534 Your attempt to inform me about this team is quite unnecessary because I know the offensive issues and what Howell went through quite well and showed us what he capable of doing. My comment point was if they were targeting a quarterback with this pick and who is right there for the taking and with a slight trade down inside top ten they can start building the OL and gain back a 2nd round pick type scenario.
Hard pass. Anybody trading for Fields has to commit a lot of money to him too. He's not worth more than 1 2nd rounder and the Commies aren't a good fit.
Come on now a failed NFL QB who was less than average and only has a job due to nepotism. Your thoughts whatever no one cares.
No little 6'1" QB is going to be successful in today's game. Williams has bust written all over him.
A lot of draft pundits don't even bother looking at the schemes different teams run, they just put players on teams even when the fit isn't right. Much like so many pundits have had Justin Fields or Jayden Daniels to the Falcons, WTF? Neither fit Zac Robinson's scheme yet pundits time after time place these QB's with schemes they don't fit in. Most pundits are simply talking out their ass. They get so caught up i the numbers they end up not seeing the forest through the trees - most of the shit they spew is worthless.
At the end of the day yhe whole process is just a massive guessing game thats what makes it so fun
They call it a game of imperfect information
Simms never liked Fields, he only pretended too. Multiple times last year he said he was a Huge JF fan and JF needs help. 😅
You mean special like Zach Wilson was Chris?
Penix is going to put to sleep all these quarterbacks and several GMs fired
He’s my dark horse for sure
Yup, the arm talent, quick release, sold me. If he can read defenses, his ability to throw and throw quickly is topshelf. He is my #1 pick, only reservation are his injuries.
SKOL !! He does look good in purple.
Ha ha ha , like he did vs a pro style defense like Michigan .
Or he's just going to get injured again.
Florio you’re one to talk about idea plagiarism. You steals Simms knowledge and takes ALL THE TIME. You can trace it all. I’m always so surprised that Simms lets you get away with it. Florio doesn’t watch any film at all. He doesn’t know shit and refuses to dedicate any of his “precious time” to doing his job and watching film. It’s far too easy to just steal for Simms and parade it all as his own thoughts
Sims has revised his evaluation of Jayden Daniels after actually watching game tape of him. Before, he criticized Daniels' throwing mechanics and ability, BUT NOW (after finally actually watching game tape!) he is reporting that Daniels' throwing mechanics and ability is Top Shelf.
Better late than never, I guess!
Relax
Well if you actually listen to him talk he says he doesn't evaluate guys during the season and any opinions before the draft process are just based on casual observations here and there.
You act like every guy watches game tape for every single prospect on a weekly basis. Most of the noise all year long are just based on casual observations. There are very few people who do film breakdown after every single game, and most of those guys are NFL scouts.
It's good when somebody can realize their initial observations were wrong rather than "stick to their guns" because they don't want to admit they made a mistake.
Marginal discrepancy in talent is not the deciding factor when it comes to success at the QB position. We have seen many elite College QB's, taken in the 1st round and yet fail in the NFL. Intelligence, leadership skills, moral foundation, focus/ commitment and 'heart' is what separates those who fail from those who become Elite QB's in the NFL.
I trust Simms analysis more than any of the other talking heads. I only disagree with his opinion that Caleb Williams is a sure bet. I saw that boy cry after one of his college games: mental fortitude is a big part of success in the NFL.
I stopped watching after 3 minutes cause I never knew you could say so many words without saying anything.
Jayden Daniels better than Caleb easy
We'll take Justin Fields.
Signed, the Raiders
You guys love bad QBs
@@yellowsnowman9157 That's what they said about Plunkett and Stabler and even that dude that played for New England..
Oh yeah and they hated Bradshaw in Pittsburgh almost cut him.
1:46 Mike should apply this to anything science related.
As I did, he will eat a large slice of embarrassing humble pie after applying this way of thinking across every possible subject that one can have an opinion on.