Kip Thorne - Is Time Travel Possible?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 дек 2024

Комментарии • 793

  • @JohnJackson-mn4ts
    @JohnJackson-mn4ts 5 лет назад +182

    Was there any mention of Time Travel?...
    No, I didn’t think so.

    • @KenBowd
      @KenBowd 5 лет назад +20

      The guy that titled this used to write TV Adds.

    • @TheEdwardCage
      @TheEdwardCage 5 лет назад +9

      Dude, I'm thinking the exact same thing! *!!*

    • @razzle3993
      @razzle3993 5 лет назад +3

      John Jackson but in a way he did tho you think it’s gonna sound simple ?

    • @rickrobitaille8809
      @rickrobitaille8809 5 лет назад +1

      Are you fucking kidding me !

    • @rickrobitaille8809
      @rickrobitaille8809 5 лет назад +2

      Kip thorne

  • @darkmatter6714
    @darkmatter6714 4 года назад +60

    Plot twist:
    Time travel wasn’t discussed in this clip because it was answered in the future but this clip was before that.

  • @baronvonteuchter1412
    @baronvonteuchter1412 5 лет назад +104

    Kip Thorne is a legend! Long may he continue educating us

    • @rickrobitaille8809
      @rickrobitaille8809 5 лет назад +2

      This man won friendly bets with hawking on black hole mechanics

    • @thetimetravelerguy301
      @thetimetravelerguy301 5 лет назад

      no offense but this guy can't educate you with shit all these idiots that go and get these college degrees and practise Einstein quote and theories should know his most famous was imagination is more powerful than knowledge that's the reason why I'm a real time traveler and teaching people how to time travel

    • @karljobstreibitzer6842
      @karljobstreibitzer6842 5 лет назад +4

      @@thetimetravelerguy301that's awesome bro! I hope you topped up your flux capacitor fluid! Don't wanna wine up in your own past making out with your mother again.

    • @thetimetravelerguy301
      @thetimetravelerguy301 5 лет назад +1

      Karl Jobstreibitzer haha

    • @rickrobitaille8809
      @rickrobitaille8809 5 лет назад +1

      @@karljobstreibitzer6842
      Awesome

  • @markrubino5990
    @markrubino5990 4 года назад +26

    His monitors seem to be working just fine. Perhaps only consumers need constant updating.

    • @bakerr2520
      @bakerr2520 4 года назад

      Seems like labview running

    • @Lucarinho
      @Lucarinho 3 года назад

      So does my phone from 1999. Still prefer not to use it.

  • @wickedcoolname399
    @wickedcoolname399 4 года назад +115

    Is time travel possible? Tune in tomorrow and I'll let you know last week.

    • @richardnelson4112
      @richardnelson4112 4 года назад

      Answer is so simple. YES. The question should be, will anyone find a way to do it

    • @nahCmeR
      @nahCmeR 4 года назад

      Your message was posted a week ago, what’s the consensus?

    • @richardnelson4112
      @richardnelson4112 4 года назад

      @cass nortom explain

    • @aaronnbroussard3108
      @aaronnbroussard3108 4 года назад

      Nice one I like That 😁😄🙂😏👍✝️🙏🙋‍♂️

    • @oggody1409
      @oggody1409 4 года назад

      @cass nortomyyes youre right . people should do some research

  • @StanTheObserver-lo8rx
    @StanTheObserver-lo8rx 5 лет назад +36

    He says "We are as close to building a time machine as an amoeba is to building a rocketship"..that was hysterical.

    • @richardnelson4112
      @richardnelson4112 4 года назад

      Hysterical but true. And just because the idea to be able to travel in time is popular with almost everyone, doesn't mean that mankind will be able to achieve it even if it's possible. It might require that man is able to use more than 10% of the capacity of the mind before it can be made possible

  • @RobGravelle
    @RobGravelle 4 года назад +43

    I'm not the sharpest tool in the shed, but I love listening to people who are a lot smarter than me.

    • @magnusydhag035
      @magnusydhag035 4 года назад

      Do you understand what they talk about?

    • @jollyroger7624
      @jollyroger7624 4 года назад +1

      @@magnusydhag035 Could it be like an art critic rambling on in the esoteric language of art critics, off on their own vernacular tangents, but nodding approval from their fellow critics who have not a whit of a clue as to what they allude ?!

    • @RobGravelle
      @RobGravelle 4 года назад

      @@magnusydhag035 Not the details.

    • @magnusydhag035
      @magnusydhag035 4 года назад

      @@jollyroger7624 sth like that I suppose. Sounds plausible.

    • @magnusydhag035
      @magnusydhag035 4 года назад

      @@RobGravelle you don't miss much. It's all speculations anyway...

  • @adamrandall5163
    @adamrandall5163 4 года назад +7

    I have a new found appreciation for the word "whirling"

  • @Epoch11
    @Epoch11 5 лет назад +27

    Mr. Kuhn, can whoever puts these videos up also add the information about when it was recorded to give an idea of when these ideas are being discussed?

    • @necroleak
      @necroleak 5 лет назад

      Mark G listen to the podcasts, they are being posted in the correct order

    • @7grims
      @7grims 4 года назад +1

      i think they are somewhat old, seems for the last decade or more science has disregarded string theory

    • @JRLB38
      @JRLB38 4 года назад +1

      If those monitors are any indication I'd say about 2008

    • @Voltomess
      @Voltomess 3 года назад +1

      CRT monitors I would say it's from 90's

  • @ShaneIsAlways
    @ShaneIsAlways 4 года назад +3

    Love it that 6-years ago Kip accurately predicted the success of LIGO in detecting gravitational waves for the first time. Think it happened even sooner than he expected, which is pretty awesome!

    • @ShaneIsAlways
      @ShaneIsAlways 4 года назад

      @Dirk Knight I remember those same things said around the time of Gravity ProbeB...better late than neverr I suppose, ha!

  • @KokoRicky
    @KokoRicky 2 года назад +1

    I kind of love that peculiar speech thing Kip Thorne does. This isn't sarcasm, I just think it adds to his personality and I enjoy listening to him explain things.

    • @GeorgeSmiley77
      @GeorgeSmiley77 Год назад

      You know the song _Freak Out_ by Chic? They got the opening _Aaaaaah_ from Kip. He has a writing credit on the song and still gets royalty cheques in the mail. Honest!

  • @chrisjoiner6877
    @chrisjoiner6877 3 года назад

    love it when youtube recommends something like this

  • @meows_and_woof
    @meows_and_woof 5 лет назад +37

    People need to stop making fun of his speech. It’s clear that he might have Tourette syndrome , when people repeat some sounds or movements involuntary.

    • @bushraduti6780
      @bushraduti6780 4 года назад +15

      Wow I thought he is a super smart guy. Was submerged by his speech. Very eloquent speaker. So I never thought he has any problem with his speech. Whoever makes fun of him must be real stupid people...

    • @jjt1881
      @jjt1881 4 года назад +7

      Touch Bionics Yes, but the amazing thing is that the sound he makes continuously corresponds exactly to the sound of gravitational waves so far discovered. It is as if the gods were playing tricks with the mind of a genius.

    • @7grims
      @7grims 4 года назад +2

      i was not expecting to hear those sounds, at some point it made me laugh, but at the same time i was angry to be laughing at such thing. i was so fascinated with what he was saying i finally stopped focusing on the sounds

    • @Dhw997
      @Dhw997 4 года назад

      Thank you!!!

    • @simesaid
      @simesaid 4 года назад

      @david wyn-jones hear hear!

  • @FredPlanatia
    @FredPlanatia Год назад

    what a bizarre choice of title for this video. But it matters not. The content of the video makes it worth my while. It delivers far more than the question i was asking. Awesome!

  • @rwarren58
    @rwarren58 4 года назад +6

    Clickbaited but listening to Kip Thorne speak about the potential for gravitational waves is like being there for Eddington to prove Einstein was correct about gravitational lensing. It's been a year, any update?

  • @72pod
    @72pod 4 года назад +3

    "As time comes into existence". My head hurts.

  • @jeffwads6158
    @jeffwads6158 5 лет назад +5

    Reading these comments cements my theory on how things got so screwed up in modern times.

  • @RahulGupta-lu6lj
    @RahulGupta-lu6lj 5 лет назад +44

    No talking about time travel...😫

    • @SunilKumar-on4rg
      @SunilKumar-on4rg 5 лет назад

      @Tukhan Yatim you have been tricked.

    • @kadalijo2806
      @kadalijo2806 5 лет назад +1

      He said earlier in the video, the time moves differently on the Earth surface or near the black hole, it's the fault of the interviewer didn't explore much further about this topic during this interview.

    • @Prashanthreddy-mh8lb
      @Prashanthreddy-mh8lb 5 лет назад

      @Tukhan Yatim if in future it is possible. Then the future people should come in our present. There are no people coming from our future then it means it cant possible and it will never going to be success. Its just simple to say that it cant possible

    • @doximanman
      @doximanman 5 лет назад

      ​@@Prashanthreddy-mh8lb Maybe time works in a way we don't know of yet, and maybe when you go back in time, the original timeline splits into 2 timelines, making our present, future, and past stay as is, while the other timeline, is the timeline which the time traveler from our future visited. There are no rules in quantum physics nor general relativity denying time travel to the past.

    • @WILLYLYNCH.
      @WILLYLYNCH. 5 лет назад

      @@Prashanthreddy-mh8lb Maybe you can't travel back before the time machine was built. Who knows, not you or me.

  • @privateprivate1865
    @privateprivate1865 3 года назад +1

    So Kip and Rico DID know what they were talking about

  • @beaconterraoneonline
    @beaconterraoneonline 4 года назад +1

    I listened to this next Thursday and found out the day before a month from now they answered the question of time travel last November before the question was posed yesterday.

  • @JonathanStephenHarris
    @JonathanStephenHarris 5 лет назад +2

    Travelling to the future is possible but going back is not.. So on that note what would be the point?

    • @julianoqueral8537
      @julianoqueral8537 4 года назад +1

      It is indeed possible. But only in a microscopic scale.

    • @swabhimanexplores
      @swabhimanexplores 2 года назад

      Excellent question. Travelling to the future will have next to no takers on Earth.
      But imagine a landing party of humans on an extraterrestrial planet which AI/simulations have predicted to be the next Earth in let's say a million years. (Assuming it is in the process of cooling down or warming up)
      Now those humans if have access to time travel can jump straight into million years into the future to enjoy Earth 2.0.
      Thus ensuring the survival of the human race.

    • @Parasmunt
      @Parasmunt Год назад

      Travelling to the future we do all the time.

  • @NEKORID
    @NEKORID 4 года назад +1

    This video must be old. Thorne, Weiss and Barish won the nobel prize for their contributions to the creation of the LIGO detector, which brought a clearer view on the string theory with the study of gravitational waves

  • @francismason8891
    @francismason8891 4 года назад +19

    Kip gave me a "D" in Ph236a, Special and General Relativity. in 1968; I deserved it. I did not take Ph236b...hahaha

    • @stevetproject
      @stevetproject 4 года назад +2

      Francis Mason no problem. Go back & try again!

    • @francismason8891
      @francismason8891 4 года назад +7

      @@stevetproject well sort of....after Kip almost failed me, I regrouped, graduated with a BS Physics, with my class in 06/69, and went to Graduate School UC Santa Cruz...Dept. of Astronomy and Astrophysics. In my Admission Essay, I recall writing that 'much exciting stuff was happening in the Cosmos, discovery of Black holes and Quasars'. Seemed like a good place to be, intellectually.
      Of course, the Viet Nam War was raging, too, UC Santa Cruz was a hippie colony, I got a big number (315) in the first draft lottery...and left college.
      "Two roads diverged in a yellow wood..."

    • @donaldsmith3926
      @donaldsmith3926 4 года назад +2

      @@francismason8891 I spent 6/68 to 6/69 in RVN; we both got an education.

  • @280zjammer
    @280zjammer 4 года назад

    You have to ask the question correctly.
    Does ambient spacial tension change under a local effect? Can that differential be small enough to encapsulate you from the environment with which you wish to alter your temporal relationship?
    I seriously doubt you can reverse it. You can only alter the passing rate because it’s not directional. It’s the eternal becoming.

    • @sacr3
      @sacr3 2 года назад

      Who knows, I'd assume not, regardless of what happens there always seems to be some form of interconnectivity that cannot be severed.

  • @johansenphotography
    @johansenphotography 4 года назад +1

    Nice gear; electronics and CRT monitors in the background. =]

  • @mscir
    @mscir 4 года назад +1

    Frame dragging still blows my mind.

  • @denniswhite7736
    @denniswhite7736 4 года назад

    Time travel forward is nothing like traveling back. If we can't start there then how can we discuss this?

  • @unkle_Enkil
    @unkle_Enkil 4 года назад +2

    I have time travelled for the last 49 years. I propell myself forward into the future at the rate of 1second per second. My biological travel device is powered by a matter to energy converter. Matter goes in, then is broken down for nutritional goodness, which is then converted to energy..

  • @harkiranonline
    @harkiranonline 4 года назад

    I think the whole idea of statement that the time started with the big bang is just a crutch used to avoid having to answer what happened before big bang.

  • @FEARisCOLD
    @FEARisCOLD 5 лет назад +8

    What if we're all just recordings playing over and over again

    • @Matthew-ve7uv
      @Matthew-ve7uv 5 лет назад +6

      What if we’re all just recordings playing over and over again

    • @migueg.r.2088
      @migueg.r.2088 5 лет назад +5

      What if we're all just recordings playing over and over again

    • @aniladaisi3257
      @aniladaisi3257 5 лет назад +5

      What if we're all just recordings playing over and over again

    • @user-se8nh3yu1e
      @user-se8nh3yu1e 5 лет назад +1

      What if I’m different and I create a new recording

    • @johansalvador7289
      @johansalvador7289 4 года назад

      The thought has crossed my mind.

  • @alijassim7015
    @alijassim7015 5 лет назад +1

    at 12:13 and beyond. You can feel the excitement in their voices.

  • @thor2012
    @thor2012 5 лет назад

    This makes me think that the beginning of the universe somewhat mirrors power coming on. Almost like an “on/off” switch, there was no energies before the birth of the universe, then the switch was flipped and gravitational waves, etcetera pour out into the universe like electricity through a cord.

    • @DeliciousFood69420
      @DeliciousFood69420 5 лет назад

      Or it's just the other side of a blackhole spewing out everything in it and theres billions of universes

  • @stevetproject
    @stevetproject 4 года назад +3

    Time travel IS possible!
    You can move forwards to the end NOW, thus saving 12m55s & learn the same amount about time travel as if you hadn't....

  • @2010sunshine
    @2010sunshine 4 года назад

    Wonderful discussion. Why did 208 people dislike this video?

  • @Unknown-sg4tv
    @Unknown-sg4tv 5 лет назад +2

    Safety Time Machine Key Points
    1. Automatic door lock. To prevent time travellers from changing history.
    2. Goes invisible. So people in the 1950s can't see it.
    3. Moves objects over it. To prevent the airplanes of the 1950s from hitting it.
    4. Has camera/TV inside so the time travellers can only observe history.
    5. Can stand extreme weather.
    6. Has solar panels.
    7. Has rocket fuel.
    8. Rocket fuel fades extremely fast in the sky. So the environment is not effected.
    9. Automatic probability control so history doesn't change on it's own.
    10. Uses wormholes to time travel.

  • @billnorris5318
    @billnorris5318 5 лет назад +5

    Engaging to the end! Well done. I've heard Kip talk about the possibility of time travel in more detail, well worth looking into.. if it IS possible to travel into the past, AND ANY affect the Chrononauts cause there creates a time shift dimensionally ( As suggested in this series ) separating them from their ORIGINAL timeline, then it seems to follow, from our perspective, that we send them out, and NONE return..hmmm.

  • @rohitmundra7158
    @rohitmundra7158 5 лет назад +1

    Absolute legend in the field.. GOAT....

  • @rogjerr
    @rogjerr 4 года назад +8

    It's possible because we travel into the future every day from the present. We're all time travelers, but the challenge is going backwards.

    • @2dudesanerd738
      @2dudesanerd738 4 года назад +1

      Einstein kinda said that its impossible. because he said to do that u need to travel faster then light.. but then he said its not possible to go faster than light... anyways check this time travel video reaction : ruclips.net/video/7Xi4_TpL4hA/видео.html
      subscribe if you like :)

    • @richardnelson4112
      @richardnelson4112 4 года назад

      The present is what keeps the past and future from interfering with each other. To travel to either one, the present MUST be removed. The present is where we are trapped. I believe that's where the solution lies. The present is what defines the past and the future and keeps us from going either direction This cannot be a coincidence

    • @2dudesanerd738
      @2dudesanerd738 4 года назад

      @@richardnelson4112 well that took a turn to philosophy 0_0 ...
      But dude einstine proved that traveling to the future is possible.. so technically were not trapped in the present

    • @richardnelson4112
      @richardnelson4112 4 года назад

      @@2dudesanerd738 it always comes down to that Mr Einstein. He's wasn't God, but some wild dude with wild ideas

    • @2dudesanerd738
      @2dudesanerd738 4 года назад

      @@richardnelson4112 but here is the point he actually Proved his wild ideas... And he said that traveling to the past U need to move faster than light.. which makes it really X 100000 times hard ... But if you bring God into this then traveling to the past is impossible.. but still traveling to the future is possible.. through relativity.. it's been proven..

  • @Darkyahweh
    @Darkyahweh 4 года назад

    Calling it now 10 years early. Time does not move slower near a black hole... the distance remains the same and the rate of travel remains constant. The only change that occurs within gravity is the appearence of space is shrinking when it and anything in it is simply condensing at an equal rate.

  • @secreto1910
    @secreto1910 4 года назад

    Comments say: there's no talk about time travel... funny... they are taking us back to the beginning of time

  • @tommyjames2755
    @tommyjames2755 2 года назад

    Absolutely Fascinating!

  • @1p6t1gms
    @1p6t1gms 5 лет назад +2

    I think the sciences will always be on the verge of new discoveries, always for as long as humans are here in existence or perhaps always, I think we'll get there one day.

  • @shmookins
    @shmookins 2 года назад

    LISA - Laser Interferometer Space Antenna, is planned for 2037. It's a space detector of gravitational waves.
    Wild times.

  • @dougieh9676
    @dougieh9676 2 года назад

    Reverse time travel goes against entropy’s relentless arrow of time. Entropy always increases unless work is put into the system, which in turn increases the overall entropy of the universe. The 2nd Law of Thermodynamics is a cruel mistress. To rewind time is asking entropy to reset. I don’t believe there is any known physics that can overcome this fact. To me it’s startling, disturbing.
    The British astrophysicist Arthur Eddington had a stern warning to would-be theoretical physicists in 1915. “If your theory is found to be against the Second Law of Thermodynamics I can give you no hope; there is nothing for it but to collapse in deepest humiliation,” he wrote.

  • @jamiegoldenseal3826
    @jamiegoldenseal3826 4 года назад +1

    bless this man Kip true inspiration

  • @danarrington2224
    @danarrington2224 4 года назад

    Time travel cannot be possible without the existence of multiple universes. You can never travel to the past of your reality but you could
    travel to the past of another reality. And I love the new word he has created "generelativity".

    • @danarrington2224
      @danarrington2224 4 года назад

      @Dirk Knight I am a believer of the "Many Worlds" theory. There are an infinite number of worlds that represent every possible
      "fork in the road" since the beginning of time. In at least 1 of these worlds the length of a second is slightly longer than in our world.
      Therefore if we simply move from this world to that world we have gone back in time sort of. If you don't understand that I can't help you.

    • @danarrington2224
      @danarrington2224 4 года назад

      @Dirk Knight You are joking right?!?! If I knew how the machine worked I wouldn't be on YT right now.

    • @danarrington2224
      @danarrington2224 4 года назад

      @Dirk Knight Many Worlds is not a religious belief. It is simply a hypothesis of the nature of the universe. The idea that any and everything
      is possible. How can you argue with that?

  • @andrew12bravo21
    @andrew12bravo21 4 года назад +2

    I always wondered, so much happened in the first second after the Big Bang but was that second a traditional second or did that second take millions if not billions of years to pass due the massive amount of energy and mass in that close of a proximity.

    • @richardnelson4112
      @richardnelson4112 4 года назад

      And you can still wonder what happened in that hypothetical 1 second. You won't be alone because they sure as hell don't know themselves

    • @sacr3
      @sacr3 2 года назад

      What is the speed of time?
      We process time at the rate we do due to our brains processing power, speed, etc. So our time is 1 second per second. But to a fly they experience 4 seconds per "1" of our seconds.
      So if all animals experience time at slightly different rates, what if no life exists, how fast does time travel?
      We experience and catalogue time at our rate, but without a brain or something to process and experience time, the universe can fly by VERY fast or VERY slowly through time. We dont know.

  • @KuljitIssar
    @KuljitIssar 7 месяцев назад

    is time travel to past future really possible and how please tell can u help me out to do

  • @allen2879
    @allen2879 3 года назад

    Kip always gets off topic but still good stuff lol

  • @godgoodtheknight3060
    @godgoodtheknight3060 4 года назад

    i will understand this in the future

  • @1invag
    @1invag 4 года назад +10

    Aaaaiiii. Hard to not notice how often he actually does that noise when your not watching but only listening haha

    • @jezebulls
      @jezebulls 4 года назад +2

      Combed Autumn lmao. At first I thought it was a stutter, but I think it’s more of a condition like Tourette’s...

    • @Dan-u3d
      @Dan-u3d 4 года назад +1

      ALL THESE DUDES HAVE ASPERGERS OR BORDERLINE SOMETHING....SO THEY ARE SUPER INTELILGENT …BUT THEIR SPEECH PATTERNS ARE SCREWED UP … LISTEN TO ELON MUSK …THE MORE NERVOUS THE WORSE IT GETS..NOT FUN BEING THEM..BRAIN NEVER SWITCHES OFF...BETTET TO BE A LINEAL HOOLIGAN ..JUST BEER MATE AND HEAD KICKING...LOL

    • @LikeablePuppet
      @LikeablePuppet 4 года назад

      @4:51

    • @gladesoutfitters
      @gladesoutfitters 4 года назад

      I searched comments to see this...did not have to look far...Aaaaii

    • @kiarash7604
      @kiarash7604 4 года назад +1

      That's not a problem

  • @Skankhunt420.
    @Skankhunt420. 5 лет назад +6

    Is this a recent video or a repeat cos those computers look about 100 years old?

    • @actuallynph
      @actuallynph 5 лет назад

      Recent. He discusses LIGO measuring gravitational waves.

    • @autofocus4556
      @autofocus4556 5 лет назад +1

      McConaughey is poking from in between the monitors

  • @priyabratadash381
    @priyabratadash381 3 года назад

    Love & respect to Kip Throne...

  • @nostalgia63
    @nostalgia63 3 года назад +1

    Good video. Philochrony is the theory that describes the nature of time and demonstrates its existence. Time is magnitive: objective, Imperceptible (intervals) and measurable.

  • @leaettahyer9175
    @leaettahyer9175 4 года назад

    Watch the monitor with the green in the lower right corner at 11:31 ! ! They could not have planned that.
    IMYLF

    • @sturpdog
      @sturpdog 4 года назад

      What did I miss??

  • @stevejobs6396
    @stevejobs6396 4 года назад +1

    One Of The Few Humble Folks Who Admit To Not Understanding Einstein’s Laws Completely!

    • @Dan-u3d
      @Dan-u3d 4 года назад

      HE DIDNT UNDERSTAND HIMSELF WITH SPOOKY ACTIONS

    • @richardnelson4112
      @richardnelson4112 4 года назад

      Einstein's laws are not the laws of existence. So ultimately his so called laws are irrelevant

    • @richardnelson4112
      @richardnelson4112 4 года назад

      @@Dan-u3d what he called spooky action at a distance, is proof that he was not as intelligent as he's made out to be. Entangled particles are misunderstood simply because the assumption is made that only the KNOWN dimensions are involved. It's more likely that no distance exists between them. An example of this happens when you try to project a 3 dimensional object onto a 2 dimensional surface. Drawing a box on a piece of paper will appear to be a box, but in reality isn't one. Until more dimensions can be confirmed, alot of theories will remain just that. Alot of things just don't make sense when dealing with quantum physics, simply because alot is missing. There is a limit to what humans can understand and comprehend. Try explaining to your dog what mathematics is and how it works. Good luck on that ! Humans are arrogant in the belief they will find the answers to any and everything. Where they got this idea is the biggest mystery over all other mysteries

  • @danielthompson7690
    @danielthompson7690 4 года назад +1

    If an object travels in a cycle fast enough it can pass itself. This is called a WARP or compressed time
    signature.

    • @richardnelson4112
      @richardnelson4112 4 года назад

      To pass itself would require it has an exact replica of itself. What you are saying is that it no longer is in the place where it can pass itself because it is now involved in a fast cycle which removed it from it's original location, leaving it unable to pass itself since it no longer is there. A cat cannot catch it's tail

  • @pastabilities2116
    @pastabilities2116 5 лет назад +5

    when was this filmed?

  • @McCatshot
    @McCatshot 4 года назад

    Why so many hung up on the wrong title thing. So what? It was a mistake. These were brilliantly lucid explanations by Kip Thorne. I enjoyed it. Time travel is a thing of the past anyway.

    • @2dudesanerd738
      @2dudesanerd738 4 года назад

      its a thing of the future... its a thing of every generation :D
      check this time travel video reaction : ruclips.net/video/7Xi4_TpL4hA/видео.html
      subscribe if you like :)

  • @chrisc1257
    @chrisc1257 5 лет назад +1

    You're only a spectator while engaged in the field of (backward)"time travel"; The imagination transforms and sculpts the future/present in that permanent field (wave function).

    • @Epoch11
      @Epoch11 5 лет назад

      I always thought so....................ahem..............

    • @chrisc1257
      @chrisc1257 5 лет назад

      @@Epoch11I think therefore I think?

    • @Useaname
      @Useaname 5 лет назад +1

      @@chrisc1257 that's a really interesting theory. Is there any other information on reverse time travel. It would make sense that you would only be able to travel back in time as a spectator, therefore not affecting past history and events, as this affectation is the main argument against such travel.

  • @felipaguzman488
    @felipaguzman488 4 года назад

    If density of a gas makes gravity then why not use hard water in order to make gravity on the ship in order to make the pull of magnets work so you can have and use an impossible amounts of push or inertia ( moment of this thought 7/23/20
    10:52-11:00 a.m) or use an even dencer gas like Tungsten Hexafluoride to make the gravity pull and just put magnets on top and the bottom of the ship in order to stop the inertia from killing the people inside the ship as the push thrust the ship throughout the cosmos .A way we could send the dencer gas could be with lasers to the ship one gram or particle at a time till you the accumulationcomments of enough to creat gravity and make the magnets work in space. by Erick Guzman Garcia
    If you don't believe I came up with this on my own just look at the date when I first put this comment on you tube under this profile.

  • @priyabratadash381
    @priyabratadash381 3 года назад

    Love & respect to Kim Throne...

  • @richardnelson4112
    @richardnelson4112 4 года назад

    Even if time travel was possible, and it seems more people would be interested traveling into the past rather than into the future, you would have a problem XY but not necessarily one about paradoxes. The biggest problem I see is that we are given a certain number of years to be alive. They say the universe is around 13.6 billion years old. If you are lucky depending on your view of living to 100 years, there is no way you could experience all the years that have pasted since the universe has existed. Now you decide to go back to a time you have already experienced, but no matter what point in that time you have already experienced you decide to go to, you will always be older than when you were there before, and probably not be able to be part of what you are seeing since it has already happened. Now you have wasted more of your remaining years just watching what you already went through. At the same time you are doing this, you have created no new experiences in your life, and your end time clock keeps on ticking away. This would be no different than watching the same movie over and over again. The only way traveling in time would be worth doing, is if time was added to your overall time to exist.

    • @sacr3
      @sacr3 2 года назад +1

      Only way I can see people going back in time is to reverse physics itself, but you can't separate your physical physics based body from our universe, so you would also be reversed, thus all knowledge you gained to reverse physics would disappear and you would be unaware you reversed time as everything repeats itself.
      Other than reversing physics, the past is gone. The universe would have to keep in memory how things were "XXX" Yeara ago, which it seems it doesn't do, so there is nothing to go too in the past.
      IF we could, I am a fan of the idea that by going in the past you are still you, you can visit your younger self and even kill him/her, it won't affect you because you left your time line, you already don't exist there this new past is your new timeline, if you travel back forward it'll be based off the timeline you're currently in, your original timeline is gone forever.
      Every time you go in the past you enter a new timeline that changes based on your presence, as your original timeline continues without you, folks there would never see you return.

  • @absencetube
    @absencetube 5 лет назад

    you mean how they decreased entropy in a closed system in a laboratory a couple months ago

  • @Ken-wc7po
    @Ken-wc7po 4 года назад +1

    Great interview.. This guy is Awesome ... 🌎

  • @jlsxs
    @jlsxs 4 года назад +1

    is impossivel to make two journeys at the same time, be here on presente time and in another time

    • @2dudesanerd738
      @2dudesanerd738 4 года назад

      its possible dude... electrons can exist at 2 places at once... is proven...
      anyways check this time travel video reaction : ruclips.net/video/7Xi4_TpL4hA/видео.html
      subscribe if you like :)

    • @sneekmatrix
      @sneekmatrix 4 года назад

      Entanglement

  • @billyjohn9192
    @billyjohn9192 5 лет назад +2

    We don't have to go faster than light, we just have to slow down the speed of light.

    • @shkotayd9749
      @shkotayd9749 5 лет назад +2

      That can be done already. Just add mediums and some special conditions. Cerenkov radiation is all about something being able to go faster than the speed of light in a medium.

    • @Doppe1ganger
      @Doppe1ganger 5 лет назад

      Erm no, increasing your speed simply makes time around you pass faster, not slower. To travel back in time you'd have to go slower than not moving at all, or less than absolute zero, which is not possible. The only way to move through time is forward, whether it be slow (standing still) or fast (speed of light).

    • @richardnelson4112
      @richardnelson4112 4 года назад

      The speed of light or of a turtle has nothing to do with traveling into time

    • @billyjohn9192
      @billyjohn9192 4 года назад

      @@richardnelson4112 Sure it doesn't.

  • @ritchtaylor3831
    @ritchtaylor3831 5 лет назад

    Relativity is the "rules" for large objects. Quantum theory is the "rules" for things that are small. What is the threshold where things are too large for quantum or too small for relativity?

    • @MichiganUSASingaporeSEAsia
      @MichiganUSASingaporeSEAsia 5 лет назад +1

      Ritch Taylor but How to explain the time losses and disappearances in the “Lake Michigan Triangle” see proof? Any theories anyone? ruclips.net/video/FAKpBtZmRr0/видео.html

    • @xspotbox4400
      @xspotbox4400 5 лет назад

      Maybe an ordinary glass, where photon streams pass near atomic nuclei. If quantum gravity follow same law of distance squared, than same time dilation must occur where photons lens around glass particles mass and refracted picture is basically, at least partially echo from the past.
      Interesting thing is, it depends from observer what part of passing light we observe trough the glass, just a small patch in the center or entire light cone stretching over the glass edges. This would imply light can travel in different paths for each observer, reflecting slightly different moments in time.
      This would be easy to test, just project atomic clock with last few decimal values over small piece of glass and record results from different angles, spread apart at various distances from glass. It would be interesting to see if they can record different clocks, for same moment in time, depends on observer angle, not only relative distance from glass.

    • @MichiganUSASingaporeSEAsia
      @MichiganUSASingaporeSEAsia 5 лет назад

      @@xspotbox4400 Thanks for trying. I like your theories but not sure if you watched the video that I posted that explains the crazy things happening over the Great Lakes. Yes, Michigan is worse in the world. More so than the Bermuda Triangle, which many don't know. Did you know that? ?

    • @xspotbox4400
      @xspotbox4400 5 лет назад

      @@MichiganUSASingaporeSEAsia Interesting story, so i Googled for "great lakes triangle mystery explained" and found some good ideas on Skeptoid's site.

  • @Elrond_Hubbard_1
    @Elrond_Hubbard_1 4 года назад +5

    I feel lucky sometimes.
    I did half of a Bachelor of Sc at university and dropped out, but I was paying attention and I still have a strong interest, so I do consider myself scientifically literate.
    I tried explaining LIGO to my dad a while ago, and he' a clever guy but there was just too much stuff that he hadn't learnt and didn't know, so that my explanation of it was poor at best.
    Even though I dropped out of uni (I'm only 32, so maybe I'll go back and finish) the fact I did learn how to think scientifically, I'm very grateful that I did it. I've come to realise most people don't know nearly any of this stuff, only people who've gone through technical education of some kind. Even just trying to explain what EM radiation is and how light propagates, to most people, is a futile task. So trying to explain LIGO is just impossible.

    • @oldblinddarby2498
      @oldblinddarby2498 4 года назад

      I encourage you to pursue your degree. I originally dropped out half way through, then I returned and have worked as a scientist for several years. Working with science will teach you far far more than you can ever learn from a few classes, it did me, and i thought I had a very firm grasp after attending uni, but my knowledge base and critical thinking of scientific matters had been exponentially increased from applying it.
      Also what better use of your time could there be than to educate yourself. If I could, I would go to school for the rest of my life. It's difficult in older ages, but you can do it, one class at a time if needed.

  • @AndyGraumann1
    @AndyGraumann1 4 года назад +1

    Why does he have a CRT monitor.
    Old school.

    • @anderslarsen4100
      @anderslarsen4100 4 года назад +1

      They travelled back to 1995 to make the video.

  • @fghgffgvbgh
    @fghgffgvbgh 4 года назад

    Future time travel can be interpreted as slow aging for someone in a relative motion. So more you travel near light speed the more time slows for you and you. So one hour of travelling at high speed may result in 1000 years for someone observing you at reference. Same law apply at heavy mass object the time slows more. When we reach light speed time stops for us. I can't imagine our state here. For observer it may look normal. So we can reach 100 light years distance with zero aging that is instant transmission. But for observer 100 years have passed. Now the crazy notion of crossing light speed. In that case the time dilation will reverse. It's s crazy idea what we would feel at that speed. For observer too we may be out of sight coz we are crossing limit and and he can't obseve us. It would be interesting if someone come up with an intution for this case

    • @fghgffgvbgh
      @fghgffgvbgh 4 года назад

      fynes leigh which part you are referring

  • @KevinMurphy0403
    @KevinMurphy0403 4 года назад

    Fascinating video but the title is very misleading.

  • @TheGreatAlan75
    @TheGreatAlan75 4 года назад

    This was sooooo interesting 🙂

  • @heyfitzpablum
    @heyfitzpablum 4 года назад

    You travel in time every time you move away from a stationary position. Einstein's Special Theory of Relativity postulated that the passage of time changes with velocity. When you move YOUR passage of time slows down with respect to a person standing still. If you travel faster, like in a rocket ship to the moon, the difference is much greater-fractions of a second difference. But, we only seem to be able to change the passage of time in one direction, towards the future. That's the paradox.

  • @3949zxcvbnm
    @3949zxcvbnm 5 лет назад

    I believe as you enter into the center or side of a black hole. Space time speeds up around you, and ultimately spirals back into the big bang theory, exploding again outward, then contracting again.... endless cycle

  • @AlsCollectibles
    @AlsCollectibles 4 года назад

    Interesting! Thanks for sharing

  • @cesarordaz139
    @cesarordaz139 4 года назад

    Absolutely fascinating

  • @raystaar
    @raystaar 4 года назад +5

    I should have read the comments before watching the video. Time travel? Who would have thought that a channel called 'Closer To Truth' would stoop to click baiting?

    • @2dudesanerd738
      @2dudesanerd738 4 года назад

      ahahahaha... Click bait is also seeking the truth ... the truth is that the thing ur looking for is not here ahahaha
      anyways check this time travel video reaction : ruclips.net/video/7Xi4_TpL4hA/видео.html
      subscribe if you like :)

  • @vincentsimon4037
    @vincentsimon4037 4 года назад

    What about a device placed outside of Earth's orbit that can warp space and therefore create a space jump for interstellar travel. Forget about time travel. Even though time is impacted by the warping of space, it does not effect past events or the future.

  • @AliAbraham51
    @AliAbraham51 5 лет назад +1

    If one star is brighter than another than surely one black hole has more power of caving in than the other. The one with more - n etc would take in the one with the lesser of.

  • @sectionone2247
    @sectionone2247 4 года назад

    How do I travel to the past?

    • @angelaparaski
      @angelaparaski 3 года назад

      Only when do you thinking about what was past situations time ago. For a Wille. Tomorrow is the future....,

  • @christopherbako
    @christopherbako 3 года назад

    Sid Haig lives forever.

  • @matthewclaflin6568
    @matthewclaflin6568 4 года назад +3

    This is all Interesting but I can’t keep my eyes off those ancient monitors

  • @theoryofthemobius
    @theoryofthemobius 4 года назад +1

    Super computers? Is this from 2019 or 1999? Who uses a CRT monitor anymore? And the OS looks like Windows 95.

    • @billycasper3351
      @billycasper3351 4 года назад

      Yeah. The interview is from 2013 as far as I know. But still, up till that time, there was enough advancement in technology. I don't know why he's using outdated computers. Doesn't make sense.

  • @michaelwarthog8258
    @michaelwarthog8258 4 года назад

    Time travel is possible both forwards in time and backwards. Just not from a stationary point. If you could travel at the speed of light or very close to it? Your destination? You would be traveling into its past and as you return home? You would be traveling into the future.

    • @michaelwarthog8258
      @michaelwarthog8258 4 года назад

      Oh and by the way there Kip, Black holes are not singularities, and infinite gravity does not exist. A more appropriate name would be super-massive Dark Stars. Comprised of extremely heavy elements so far down the Periodic Table it would make your head spin and if we had infinite gravity? the Universe would not exist.

  • @laurenth7187
    @laurenth7187 4 года назад

    Yeah how do a black hole "spin rapidly" when the mass has slow down time to appreciatively halt ?

    • @sneekmatrix
      @sneekmatrix 4 года назад

      Its called time dilation, fast moving objects travel further in space and less in time. At so called relativistic speeds ( close to the speed of light ) time slows to a halt almost. Particles then have to lose mass but gain energy. The adjuctant is also true particles gain mass and lose energy. Behind the event horizon time does not exist. At this point the particles fall into the singularity and all mass is condensed ( zero volume) but the energy remains and can be felt gravitationally. The solutions for a non spinning black hole merging are known ( Kerr solutions ) a spinning black hole has no solutions and may not form a naked singularity instead it will form a ring singularity. The warping of space is permitted because the time element is reduced sufficiently to allow particles to coalesce and become entangled. The interior of a black hole is an energy condensate and is extremely cold. In fact it so cold that an atom if this temperature us enough to boil all the oceans of all the planets and all the galaxies. This is called a negative temperature ( not minus ) the temperature is negative in the sense that it precludes heat absorption.

  • @magnusydhag035
    @magnusydhag035 4 года назад +8

    ABBA won the Eurovision in 1974.
    That's got nothing to do with time travel.
    Neither has this video.

  • @glennmillerfan
    @glennmillerfan 2 года назад

    I recently lost the chance to marry a close friend of mine who I’ve known for 10 years and have been desperately in love in since 2012 (she is an extremely attractive Iranian American woman). Her fiancé’s parents met in the Summer of 1980 and were married in 1983, so would it be theoretically possible for me to go back to late 1979 or early 1980 to prevent them from meeting, or would it result in major time paradoxes? If it helps, her fiancé is non Iranian (Sicilian mostly) and I am non Iranian as well (mixed heritage, mostly European).

    • @swabhimanexplores
      @swabhimanexplores 2 года назад

      Would it soothe your heart to know that in countless universes you are happily married to her?

  • @ellierfromthebronx4531
    @ellierfromthebronx4531 4 года назад +16

    Um...he's got a funny way of saying uh...
    And he didn't answer the question.

    • @robert2948
      @robert2948 4 года назад +1

      Moron

    • @krzykris
      @krzykris 4 года назад +1

      I was listening and not watching. At first I thought the audio was bad. Then I wondered if he has tourettes.

    • @MrBendybruce
      @MrBendybruce 4 года назад

      You mean the question that he was never actually asked?!?

    • @MrBendybruce
      @MrBendybruce 4 года назад +4

      @@krzykris He has a speech impediment. But the man won the Nobel Prize and has been a leader in Theoretical Physics for decades, and I appreciate the bravery of the man that he does not let a social issue like that prevent him from communicating verbally, in spite of the endless childish comments (like yours) it inevitably provokes..

    • @krzykris
      @krzykris 4 года назад

      @@MrBendybruce I wasn't making fun. I was just curiuos as it was a bit unusual and I've never encountered it in my lifetime. He's brilliant and brave. I understand. As I once heard someone say, "there was only one perfect person in the world and they nailed him to a tree."

  • @holgerjrgensen2166
    @holgerjrgensen2166 4 года назад +1

    Well, Time is the result/effect of travel/motion, there fore we cannot travel in time.
    De ja vue is a spontanious experience of realizing some thing from past, but not under control of the will.
    In future by the development, the 'Ablity of sensing in time' gradually going to be a permanent ability under control by the will. The ability of sensing in time is to realize some thing from past or future.
    The Ability of sensing in Space, is to realize some thing synchron in a location some where else in space, this will also be a permanent ability in future.
    Travel at the physical level depends of speed and distance, but Thought-travel is a matter of purpose an Ability/condition.
    Time only exists in our consciousness.

    • @paulsuffridge8611
      @paulsuffridge8611 4 года назад

      Time is the polarizing medium of consciousness. It has no substance or dimension.

  • @laurenth7187
    @laurenth7187 4 года назад

    Yeah collide black holes, while there is no time for that. Nothing can ever fall into a black hole. And btw, what do warped space mean.

  • @gilbertlujan1220
    @gilbertlujan1220 4 года назад

    There is really much that we know or sure of !

  • @eriks2686
    @eriks2686 5 лет назад +1

    You guys making fun of him..i dont see you on here explaining these things

  • @jasonsmith-lv5my
    @jasonsmith-lv5my 5 лет назад +1

    Dude looks like Odin quincannon from the preacher series.

  • @pltatman1
    @pltatman1 5 лет назад

    It's interesting that there is a presupposition that time exists. I'm not sure why this is. Is there any evidence for the existence of time?

    • @manoo422
      @manoo422 5 лет назад

      The fact that you are asking the question means you wouldnt understand the answer.

    • @pltatman1
      @pltatman1 5 лет назад

      @@manoo422 Allow me to rephrase. Is there any evidence to suggest that time is more than a system of measurement that exists solely as a conceptual construct of our consciousness?

    • @manoo422
      @manoo422 5 лет назад

      @@pltatman1 No less so than light, gravity, energy, pressure, length....

    • @pltatman1
      @pltatman1 4 года назад

      @Newtube I would assert that time is a system of measurement which enables us to make sense of relative motion. Everything is simply moving and changing, and we have noticed that some things move a longer distance or change to a greater degree than other things. Our mind needs a way to make sense of this, and so we created time. I lack the necessary evidence to believe that it exists as something other than a mental construct.

    • @pltatman1
      @pltatman1 4 года назад

      @Newtube Can it be demonstrated empirically? Even an impartially understood force like gravity can be demonstrated to exist because of its interaction with matter. If time does not do anything, or interact with anything, and I can't detect it with my senses or with instruments, then what is my evidential basis for its existence? After all, everything that time describes can also be described through relative motion and interaction. For example, the second hand on my watch moves as a quartz crystal oscillates. Day becomes night as the earth revolves relative to the sun. Even my own internal sense of 'time' is relative to my own internal processes.

  • @rv706
    @rv706 4 года назад

    From what year is this video?

  • @kanghsu2466
    @kanghsu2466 4 года назад

    First answer is time possible?

  • @raptorman48
    @raptorman48 4 года назад

    I think the reason we can't find dark matter is because it's in another dimension affecting this dimension from that dimension like it could be in the spirit dimension but then again there could be so many other dimensions!

  • @seanmcguire7974
    @seanmcguire7974 5 лет назад +1

    If you speed it up ots like the kid on transformers when he writes on the blackboard

  • @greywolf271
    @greywolf271 4 года назад

    Was there a ripple in the fabric of time at 4:51 - 4:52 ?