alsenar2 make a movie about holocaust or how great america is, then see how many oscar even an uneducated film maker can get oscar with that bullshit movie , oscar is complete bullshit!
alsenar2 Just like video games, movie awards these days are popularity contests. Movies targeted for the masses and casual audience become more famous than the ones targeted for the ones who like complex storylines.
alsenar2 It didn't win because the plot doesn't make sense, it's full of plot holes and the dialogues are dumb (the love speech ugh). Oh, before you say anything... yes, I've understood the movie and I understand the science behind it, that's exactly the reason that makes me understand how dumb the plot is, expecially the ending. Special effects were incredible btw, well deserved oscar... but also the only one that this movie deserved.
He's a rock star within the Astrophysics community. He's been doing General Relativity dealing with blackholes, gravitational fields, etc. If you're a rock star, gotta dress like one
It wouldn't have been nominated because so many religious people don't like it plain and simple, especially in america everyone is so sensitive, not open-minded enough.
Rudi Leandro I agree. I enjoyed it, but it wasn't "Best picture" worthy. I've seen half of the nominees for Best picture this year, and Interstellar was not as good as any of them.
It is the greatest crime that Interstellar was not nominated for Best Picture at the Oscar's. Completely ridiculous. It was the best film of the year by a mile!
I love Chris Nolan's films. Every time I watch one it leaves me on the edge of my seat with my mouth hanging open questioning everything i've ever known
This movie was fantastic. It's pacing is so well done, it never felt almost a 3 hour movie. I was wanting for more actually at the end. SPOILERS : That 5 dimention scene was so heart pumping, i was like holy shit he is going into the black hole, HE IS GOING TO THE BLACK HOLE? That excitement was incredible for me. The visuals, the acting and the direction, all done masterfully. 9.8/10
Amazing, amazing movie. The story, the emotions, the acting, and the amazing science, my god, i'll watch this movie again sometime because there is a high probability that i lost some information that i'll get if i watch it again.
Felipe Frota Don't forget about the incredible music from Hans Zimmer which makes this movie at is best!! Really great performance of the director and cast!
Interstellar was marvelous. What Nolan lacked in plot, of which I felt like it was to more or less inspire the watcher to create his own theories and to leave out any spoon-feeding, he gave in the sheer sense of wonder, excitement and philosophy. Most grand scale and possibly meaningful movie i've seen, definitely this generations' 2001.
totally agree with you, mate ! a master piece !! a real piece of art, philosophy, spirituality... This scene, close to the end, where McConnaughey floating in the inter-dimensional tesserect, is one of the most wonderful and acute i ever saw... a pure piece of art !! ahp.li/6bb14613d3b14d04e61d.jpg
2001 has nothing to do with interstellar. 2001 is a movie about man's journey from primordial life into life in space BEFORE man set foot on the moon. Interstellar uses space travel to illustrate REHABITATION on planets outside our solar system.
KVPD It's 'strange' so many times how people could be so far on their visions or interpretations about a piece of art. Here, i have really no time for long explanations, discuss etc (and no desire), but it's difficult for me to imagine that someone couldn't see any 'connections' between 2001 and Interstellar ! for me, it's so obvious in so many parts, and not only, but specially about endings ! They're 2 different master pieces, but with so many brain and intellect junctions. ahp.li/899f40293f0002fa3530.jpg Cheers.
I disagree... Interstellar was great, no denying that, but it didn't leave anything for the watcher to think about. It spoon feeds you a twist that could've been seen from before he left Earth, and it's whole speech about love, although beautiful, wasn't very philosophical and it was straight up non sensical when brought up by Anne Hathaway's character. It doesn't reach 2001's brilliance in visual poetry and metaphor, and it's innovative approach to narrative. Aside from the ambitious scale and some of it's themes, it was a very straight up Nolan-esque blockbuster, just set in space
Nolan as a filmmaker is fascinating. He tells stories that are mind bending and are routed in such human warmth & feelings that it connects the mind and heart at equally fascinating measures. This is his SciFy masterpiece and a wonderful watch
I liked the movie, but there are many mistakes, starting of, with wormholes ( not observed, not proven), who would go to a planet only with water next to a black hole, how do they communicate, where do they all that oxygen, the hypersleep not explained at all, why is earth in such a bad shape..... etc. There are at least 15 more big mistakes
Giovanni Pezzino I feel like half those questions are answered with common sense. For example, there was only one promising system with 3 planets who activated their beacons. They were short on fuel, and since that planet was the closest (since they referenced approaching it soon after traveling through the blackhole) it seemed like the logical choice. They also were clearly not aware of that the planets had in store and focused on the information transmitted. The limit in oxygen was also referenced, for example when Brand said they were literally wasting their breath before going into hypersleep. And hyper sleep can simple be explained as going into a cryogenically frozen state, where cell activity is near null, which is why Dr Mann was cold and shivering when he was released from hyper sleep. I'm not too sure how the planet got into that state, although I think Professor Brand mentioned some organisms that breathed nitrogen (which I was also skeptical about), but I don't think this movie had nearly as many mistakes as people say it does, although I do accept that it has a few.
Giovanni Pezzino calm down. it’s a perfectly explained movie with perfect little details. nolan is a genius and he wouldn’t have missed those very important things you mentioned. besides there are millions of videos explaining the whole movie, it’s not real so it doesn’t need a HUGE explanation
Kallen the thing that amazed me was how the first person on that planet just got there an 1 hour before they did due to the time being slower from the closeness of the black hole i feel many people probably missed that detail
The Scientist Director, Christoper Nolan. Look at both those intellectuals talk. No stupid jokes, no childish humour, the way they talk and explain things, its just magnetic.
I still don't get how this was snubbed and Gravity won awards. I thought gravity was great, and then Interstellar came along and blew my mind - also made me cry. This movie, fore me personally, was the pinnacle of intellectually and emotionally stimulating content in cinema. How is a genius like Christopher Nolan not acknowledged at the awards?!
Please, ask Christopher Nolan about his parents, how they communicated when he was a child and later, did he feel any pressure from his parents, does he consider his parents his friends, did his parents choose what to do in life for him? And so on. I have a hypothesis that the less domestic violence, the higher the chances of becoming a happy and successful person. And there is a lot of research on the topic of Adverse childhood experiences.
his mother was from USA and father from UK. He joined British boarding school because his father wanted him to. He passed his childhood both in USA and UK but mostly UK. where as his younger brother jonathan passed his childhood mostly in USA. They are a very private family. it's hard to know. but i think they had a ok childhood. they stayed away too and lived together too.
"the universe when it (inaudible) expands faster than the speed of light. The distantly separated regions that communicate with each other, are moving faster than the speed of light, relative to each other and it is the speed limit that applies when you are in a region so small, that the warping of space and time isn't important" -Thorne. @3:11, the interviewer was like "WTF did he just say?"
Agent Smidt also worth noting that the expansion of the universe being faster than the speed of light isn't actually a breaking of the speed limit. The speed of light is the speed limit of anything traveling through the universe, not the universe itself.
Loved how Christopher Nolan deftly and savagely countered the interviewer's prompt about Physics and Cosmology being irrelevant to people's lives, what a very superficial perception it is. Physics is the most fundamental discipline and it never was, is, and will be irrelevant wherever you are in the cosmos. Without the laws of physics life (biology) and all its shenanigans (history, economics, humanities, technology, politics, etc) will not be possible.
It doesn't matter to the individual people on Earth how a black hole is formed, why galaxies exist and what dark matter is made of. Whether you get the right medicine, however, has immediate impact on everybody's lives, therefore knowing the human biology is both literally and figuratively "closer" to us than cosmology and astrophysics. I think that's what he was getting at.
I just wanted to say: I love to see a big Hollywood director an Producer like Christopher Nolan so interested in Phisics and into solving the fundamental mysterys of the universe 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🙌🙌🙌🙌👌👌👌👌
After watching the movie again for the second time(7th of January 2023) and somehow get a bit of understanding of its science based storyline, I would say that this film was carefully and artistically thought out. The movie is a masterpiece! I personally think that it is the greatest film that I've seen to date. It has the cliché plots of; choosing the lesser evil, family, love, betrayal and determination being told in a scientific based artistic perspective. Watching the film I was in awe at how Chris Nolans brain operates. Brilliance!
For the people who are saying Interstellar has a plot hole the hole is in your heads, the part that these people mainly talk about as a plot hole is that how the humans survived the extinction and helped the people on earth by sending them the black hole near saturn and building the tesseract for Cooper, will there is no explanation for it it's called a bootstrap paradox so for the people who liked the movie don't come up with theories to explain the movie because there is no explanation it's a paradox.
I think the people who saved the humans weren´t "us" in that sense. Cooper might be referring to humans or maybe a humanoid species from another dimension, who, for some reason, decided to help their fellow beings trough gravity and dimensions. But that´s just how i see it.
Cooper doesn´t have to know it all, he´s just kind of guessing, that paradox thing seems unlikely, i don´t believe Christopher Nolan would let a crucial plot point so ambiguous, i´m going for another dimension humanoids.
pfl95 It absolutely is a deus ex machina, despite fans insisting it cant be because the beings a referenced from the first 20 minutes of the film. It's very cleverly camouflaged, but it absolutely is- the characters have a huge number of problems with their situation- the gravity equation, accumulation and delivery of data, fuel, time, imminent death from a black hole- and boom Tesseract magically solves everything- even plops Cooper back near saturn at a survivable local to be picked up (generous considering the future beings were happy to let everyone else die) just so the audience could have a happy ending (a cooper sacrifice would have been 100X more impactful- and yet people are saying it's not a deus ex machina?! IT'S THE LITERAL DEFINITION OF THE TERM for Christs sake - higher beings descending and magically solving everyone's problems. It was lazy and boring, i hoped Nolan(s) had more balls as writers.
It was such a well done movie. The beauty was not lost on me as a physics student, as not only could I appreciate what I was seeing, I understood it. It was such a beautiful film.
Nolan’s films are just out of the Oscar’s league. Simple as that. I think for him to win an Oscar would almost be an insult. He’s better than that crap.
The question Christopher Nolan raised about economics and physics is actually incredibly important. I wish the interviewer picked up on that. Nolan remarked on how economics studies things that are so important to our day-to-day lives, yet is always wrong and actually causes crisis after crisis, while astrophysics is as far removed from day-to-day as it gets, yet makes huge improvements like the GPS to our lives. The difference is empirical veritability. Science, by its method of always trying to disprove itself, ensures that over time nothing nonsensical remains. Economics (and a few other "fields" I shall not mention) do not use the scientifical methods. Human nature (e.g. selective memory) ensures they're always wrong. Until other fields start to use the scientific method, they'll continue to sound reasonable until they destroy us in moments of madness.
Christopher Nolan makes the best movies. And interstellar is his best movie. It's as epic in scope as it is dazzling in visuals as it is heart breaking. A new definition of epic movie making.
True. In this universe of billions of things and humans, if Chris left the world, it would be the saddest day for me or anyone with the level of perception to even understand 1% of him.
Thank you, Chris, Kip, Jeff and thespian bro. Mathew, I love what you have done with the book and I hope to do some very serious partying with you soon, peace and love, Doug.
nolan, every film is a monster film daniel day lewis , every film is a monster film i would like to see a nolan film with main actor daniel day lewis, and ost by hans zimmer to me, daniel day lewis and henry fonda are the best drama actors i have ever seen
What this movie depicts and stands for is amazing. It stands for human curiosity and human spirit. I hate that the fact people hate Nolan is because his movies are "blockbusters" like not every movie has to be a "Birdman" or a "Budapest Hotel" to be a award winning film.... I hate that bullshit of Nolan always getting thrown under the bus just because he has a bigger budget.
I wonder what part of the movie Nolan wanted faster-than-light travel for. Also, I think the interest in cosmological matters comes from our deepest yearnings for meaning, connecting to the universe, the infinite, whatever. Kind of like a modern-day replacement for religion.
believe me when i say that, i know people that are not moved by all these concepts, they dont care about existential and cosmological questions.and i know they had zero stimuli during their childhood. sometimes i get frustrated at how a person cannot be moved by all this
tonyvice6661616 Oh, I know there are people like that...it makes me think that is why Lawrence Krauss didn't like the movie, because of its existential themes. Because atheism has no answer for people dealing with these questions, it sometimes tries to pretend they don't exist. And then there are other people who just plain aren't interested. Sometimes I envy them, as I have struggled with these questions since I was a kid and all it has done is provoked a huge amount of anxiety and angst in me. I wish every day that our tools for investigating the mind were as effective as the ones that allow us to see far-off galaxies.
I get confused on the scenes with matt damon. Seriously, I got so confused on whether it is the martian or intersteller that had a person pushed down the hill..
5:54 "It can't just be the calculus it has to be the feeling"... Kip was nodding in agreement and I am laughing here that he did agree to that. That's so funny. I am sure he will watch this later and regret it lol.
Not going to even relatively hint at my viewpoint on Interstellar, based on some of the other comments on this video I don't want that much flak, but Christopher Nolan is 100% my favorite director of the past 2 decades. Inception is close to flawless, The Dark Knight is one of (if not the) best super hero movies out there, even his first films are great, i.e. Doodlebug & Following. Let's just hope that this "Dunkirk" movie rumor comes to be true!
nolan looks likes a physics professor, while kip looks like a biker!
+Kim Jong Fun If you didn't who was who, one would probably mistake Kip for Nolan :P
+Kim Jong Fun Exactly!
kip is cool
Kip is like one badass who makes meth in his garage
and noble winner "thorne"
That Interstellar didn't won anything at the Oscars is just one more Proof that the Oscars are a completely Joke.
alsenar2 make a movie about holocaust or how great america is, then see how many oscar even an uneducated film maker can get oscar with that bullshit movie , oscar is complete bullshit!
alsenar2 Just like video games, movie awards these days are popularity contests. Movies targeted for the masses and casual audience become more famous than the ones targeted for the ones who like complex storylines.
alsenar2 Interstellar won the oscar for visual effects
alsenar2 It did win an Oscar. Probably the most important one for the movie...
alsenar2 It didn't win because the plot doesn't make sense, it's full of plot holes and the dialogues are dumb (the love speech ugh).
Oh, before you say anything... yes, I've understood the movie and I understand the science behind it, that's exactly the reason that makes me understand how dumb the plot is, expecially the ending.
Special effects were incredible btw, well deserved oscar... but also the only one that this movie deserved.
I have never in my life had a more emotional reaction to a film. This was a true masterpiece.
Profile picture checks out haha
same !
SAME. The Hans Zimmer scores just made it even more so for me.
Me too😭 It gutted me
@@TheReutter85 except for the physics and the logic
Fun fact: as of 2017, Dr Kip Thorne is a Nobel Laureate of Physics.
Yet some people say this movie was not based on real science. 🤷♂️
Thats great
@Anshuman Singh Maybe rather than being idiots, probably stubborn 'smar-tasses'.
FACT.
@@grec. the climax is just a theory , even scientists don't know what's inside wormhole. They told Nolan to proceed with theory
That leather jacket though.
He's a rock star within the Astrophysics community. He's been doing General Relativity dealing with blackholes, gravitational fields, etc. If you're a rock star, gotta dress like one
That 2 colored beard, though.
ey , that's Kip fuckin Thorne . Show some cotdam respect.
The jacket? Those socks.
starfox I like how you took the time to edit your post, and yet it's still an incoherent mess.
Oscars are not good enough for this film.
Yeah
i mean oscar are only given to black actors and black directors
@@sethxtekken You’re a simple person, to me that is obvious with such a shallow comment.
Chris got ripped. Interstellar should have been nominated for Best Picture.
voteFORpedro28 Because It's not a very good film...
Rudi Leandro says who?
I think it was fantastic.
gregory steve It's an extremely flawed film in many ways... The special effects were amazing though.
It wouldn't have been nominated because so many religious people don't like it plain and simple, especially in america everyone is so sensitive, not open-minded enough.
Rudi Leandro I agree. I enjoyed it, but it wasn't "Best picture" worthy. I've seen half of the nominees for Best picture this year, and Interstellar was not as good as any of them.
It is the greatest crime that Interstellar was not nominated for Best Picture at the Oscar's. Completely ridiculous. It was the best film of the year by a mile!
True hello i mean wow you commented 8 years ago
congrats to Prof Kip Thorne for winning Nobel prize in Physics - the most prestigious even in Nobel prize categories
I love Chris Nolan's films. Every time I watch one it leaves me on the edge of my seat with my mouth hanging open questioning everything i've ever known
+Gabrielle Henderson Yup. BTW, Are Cobs in his dreams or in reality? And Momento? You have to find the answers online
Questioning our very existence
This movie was fantastic. It's pacing is so well done, it never felt almost a 3 hour movie. I was wanting for more actually at the end. SPOILERS : That 5 dimention scene was so heart pumping, i was like holy shit he is going into the black hole, HE IS GOING TO THE BLACK HOLE? That excitement was incredible for me. The visuals, the acting and the direction, all done masterfully. 9.8/10
Amazing, amazing movie. The story, the emotions, the acting, and the amazing science, my god, i'll watch this movie again sometime because there is a high probability that i lost some information that i'll get if i watch it again.
I wished the sequence of him falling into the black hole was longer.
Felipe Frota Don't forget about the incredible music from Hans Zimmer which makes this movie at is best!! Really great performance of the director and cast!
+Mau Jo *wormhole
AbhiShake you didn't get it. He never went into the black hole. "THEY" saved him from falling into the black hole.
Wait a min... The Director looks like A Physicist and Visa versa.
they had opposite day lol
Have you ever even stepped foot on a college/university campus?...
I don't think you'll ever see Chris in a leather jacket lol.
all hail VISA!
YouKnowImRightHanded lol he should definitely meet my physics professor. rides goldstar 500 to school everyday
Kip looks like heisenberg from breaking bad season 20
+Ramraj G I would say he looks more like Mike....
oh, yeah, i forgot abt him!
Ramraj G lovechild of Walter White and Mike Ehrmantraut
Nah, like Mike Ehrmantraut 😂
I could listen to Nolan talk for hours.
Kip Thorne's no slouch in the interview department either.
neonatalpenguin i couldn’t .. but just because it isn’t my mother tongue :(
Me too
So that's why the broken robot with Matt Damon was named KIP...
Just an Easter egg or tribute.. I guess
Interstellar was piece of art greatness my goodness great work Nolan
Interstellar was marvelous. What Nolan lacked in plot, of which I felt like it was to more or less inspire the watcher to create his own theories and to leave out any spoon-feeding, he gave in the sheer sense of wonder, excitement and philosophy. Most grand scale and possibly meaningful movie i've seen, definitely this generations' 2001.
totally agree with you, mate ! a master piece !! a real piece of art, philosophy, spirituality...
This scene, close to the end, where McConnaughey floating in the inter-dimensional tesserect, is one of the most wonderful and acute i ever saw... a pure piece of art !!
ahp.li/6bb14613d3b14d04e61d.jpg
2001 has nothing to do with interstellar. 2001 is a movie about man's journey from primordial life into life in space BEFORE man set foot on the moon.
Interstellar uses space travel to illustrate REHABITATION on planets outside our solar system.
KVPD
It's 'strange' so many times how people could be so far on their visions or interpretations about a piece of art.
Here, i have really no time for long explanations, discuss etc (and no desire), but it's difficult for me to imagine that someone couldn't see any 'connections' between 2001 and Interstellar ! for me, it's so obvious in so many parts, and not only, but specially about endings !
They're 2 different master pieces, but with so many brain and intellect junctions.
ahp.li/899f40293f0002fa3530.jpg
Cheers.
KVPD I mean the comparison in the sense of being a great space movie
I disagree... Interstellar was great, no denying that, but it didn't leave anything for the watcher to think about. It spoon feeds you a twist that could've been seen from before he left Earth, and it's whole speech about love, although beautiful, wasn't very philosophical and it was straight up non sensical when brought up by Anne Hathaway's character. It doesn't reach 2001's brilliance in visual poetry and metaphor, and it's innovative approach to narrative. Aside from the ambitious scale and some of it's themes, it was a very straight up Nolan-esque blockbuster, just set in space
Cgristopher Nolan is my all time favorite director. He truly is an inspiration to me.
Him working with Hans zimmer = perfection
Jack Richard agreed never took school serious but now I like to teach myself about space
Thank you for giving this movie to all of us Mr. Nolan and Professor Thorne. This is my favorite movie ever
Nolan as a filmmaker is fascinating. He tells stories that are mind bending and are routed in such human warmth & feelings that it connects the mind and heart at equally fascinating measures. This is his SciFy masterpiece and a wonderful watch
Jeffrey Kluger is fantastic. Great voice. Great questions. Great back and forth with the two. Made for a great discussion.
How the hell Gravity WON best picture back in 2013, while this film was not even nominated for 2015 Oscars, remains a mystery.
If I'm not mistaken, Interstellar was nominated for four Oscars and won the Oscar for best visuals? Yeah. That happened.
mdJRICK he meant not nominated for best picture?
@@f3-faithfitnessfinance gravity didnt won best picture
@@ignaciopazgarcia5370 it won 7 academy awards
There is some sort of intuition in Nolan that I can't quite put my finger on. Maybe he is some sort of creative genius.
Captain Obvious thanks ,captain obvious!
My favourite movie 😍.I was literally crying the whole movie.
The science behind interstellar by kip thorne. I suggest everyone to read it. So educational
Can you share the downloadable link here please.
I really loved Interstellar. It will get its recognition in due time.
i have even more respect for nolan after watching this interview such a great director and overall person. We can expect more amazing work from him
It must be silly socks day for Nolan!
that's the first thing I noticed!
BAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAAHHA I LOVE HIM
Interstellar was a fantastic movie, probably the best of this decade! People are just not willing to admit the genius writing.
Brief message in this video is;
"DO NOT JUDGE BY APPEARANCE"
I think most people arent smart enough to understand the time concepts in the movie so they say plot holes.
Khajiit Is Innocent so many times i have heard people say this movie makes no sense ...it's infuriating
I liked the movie, but there are many mistakes, starting of, with wormholes ( not observed, not proven), who would go to a planet only with water next to a black hole, how do they communicate, where do they all that oxygen, the hypersleep not explained at all, why is earth in such a bad shape..... etc. There are at least 15 more big mistakes
Giovanni Pezzino I feel like half those questions are answered with common sense. For example, there was only one promising system with 3 planets who activated their beacons. They were short on fuel, and since that planet was the closest (since they referenced approaching it soon after traveling through the blackhole) it seemed like the logical choice. They also were clearly not aware of that the planets had in store and focused on the information transmitted. The limit in oxygen was also referenced, for example when Brand said they were literally wasting their breath before going into hypersleep. And hyper sleep can simple be explained as going into a cryogenically frozen state, where cell activity is near null, which is why Dr Mann was cold and shivering when he was released from hyper sleep. I'm not too sure how the planet got into that state, although I think Professor Brand mentioned some organisms that breathed nitrogen (which I was also skeptical about), but I don't think this movie had nearly as many mistakes as people say it does, although I do accept that it has a few.
Giovanni Pezzino calm down. it’s a perfectly explained movie with perfect little details. nolan is a genius and he wouldn’t have missed those very important things you mentioned. besides there are millions of videos explaining the whole movie, it’s not real so it doesn’t need a HUGE explanation
Kallen the thing that amazed me was how the first person on that planet just got there an 1 hour before they did due to the time being slower from the closeness of the black hole i feel many people probably missed that detail
Nolan would be a great Bond villain. Has that look haha.
thegnarcs just need a scar on his face and all good to go
The Scientist Director, Christoper Nolan. Look at both those intellectuals talk. No stupid jokes, no childish humour, the way they talk and explain things, its just magnetic.
I still don't get how this was snubbed and Gravity won awards. I thought gravity was great, and then Interstellar came along and blew my mind - also made me cry. This movie, fore me personally, was the pinnacle of intellectually and emotionally stimulating content in cinema. How is a genius like Christopher Nolan not acknowledged at the awards?!
gravity was terrible imo. the storyline was just... i don't know, kind of boring?
I watched gravity after interstellar and I couldn't even sit halfway through it
It's all a popularity contest
gravity is a very forgettable movie lol
And... This year Dr. Thorne was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics.
Please, ask Christopher Nolan about his parents, how they communicated when he was a child and later, did he feel any pressure from his parents, does he consider his parents his friends, did his parents choose what to do in life for him? And so on. I have a hypothesis that the less domestic violence, the higher the chances of becoming a happy and successful person. And there is a lot of research on the topic of Adverse childhood experiences.
his mother was from USA and father from UK. He joined British boarding school because his father wanted him to. He passed his childhood both in USA and UK but mostly UK. where as his younger brother jonathan passed his childhood mostly in USA. They are a very private family. it's hard to know. but i think they had a ok childhood. they stayed away too and lived together too.
@@yasmin9473 Thanks, but I know it, it is well-known info. I would like to know more.
"the universe when it (inaudible) expands faster than the speed of light. The distantly separated regions that communicate with each other, are moving faster than the speed of light, relative to each other and it is the speed limit that applies when you are in a region so small, that the warping of space and time isn't important" -Thorne. @3:11, the interviewer was like "WTF did he just say?"
Yeah I was wondering that too XD like whatt??
Agent Smidt also worth noting that the expansion of the universe being faster than the speed of light isn't actually a breaking of the speed limit. The speed of light is the speed limit of anything traveling through the universe, not the universe itself.
Harry Plinkett as a side note, all the universe would be black, as light would not be able to reach anything
Loved how Christopher Nolan deftly and savagely countered the interviewer's prompt about Physics and Cosmology being irrelevant to people's lives, what a very superficial perception it is. Physics is the most fundamental discipline and it never was, is, and will be irrelevant wherever you are in the cosmos. Without the laws of physics life (biology) and all its shenanigans (history, economics, humanities, technology, politics, etc) will not be possible.
It doesn't matter to the individual people on Earth how a black hole is formed, why galaxies exist and what dark matter is made of. Whether you get the right medicine, however, has immediate impact on everybody's lives, therefore knowing the human biology is both literally and figuratively "closer" to us than cosmology and astrophysics. I think that's what he was getting at.
Rose Angelique Santos I mean, that’s not what even happened but okau
The bomber jacket though..genius Kip Throne.
Interstellar is one of the best movies ever made. It will stand as a classic of our time.
I dig Nolan's socks
Sierra M lol
Sierra M i haven't spotted them yet but since you're a girl I'll say ME TOO 😉
The interviewer asks some very good questions....
I agree with you so much, journalists nowadays don't have brains to ask right questions.
Oscar administration should go to collect "Nolan" award from Christopher Nolan, may be they can get....
I just wanted to say: I love to see a big Hollywood director an Producer like Christopher Nolan so interested in Phisics and into solving the fundamental mysterys of the universe 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🙌🙌🙌🙌👌👌👌👌
After watching the movie again for the second time(7th of January 2023) and somehow get a bit of understanding of its science based storyline, I would say that this film was carefully and artistically thought out. The movie is a masterpiece! I personally think that it is the greatest film that I've seen to date. It has the cliché plots of; choosing the lesser evil, family, love, betrayal and determination being told in a scientific based artistic perspective. Watching the film I was in awe at how Chris Nolans brain operates. Brilliance!
For the people who are saying Interstellar has a plot hole the hole is in your heads, the part that these people mainly talk about as a plot hole is that how the humans survived the extinction and helped the people on earth by sending them the black hole near saturn and building the tesseract for Cooper, will there is no explanation for it it's called a bootstrap paradox so for the people who liked the movie don't come up with theories to explain the movie because there is no explanation it's a paradox.
I think the people who saved the humans weren´t "us" in that sense. Cooper might be referring to humans or maybe a humanoid species from another dimension, who, for some reason, decided to help their fellow beings trough gravity and dimensions.
But that´s just how i see it.
I'm pretty sure he was talking about humans because he said that in the future we will be able to create wormholes
Cooper doesn´t have to know it all, he´s just kind of guessing, that paradox thing seems unlikely, i don´t believe Christopher Nolan would let a crucial plot point so ambiguous, i´m going for another dimension humanoids.
Juan Carlos Orellana I see is as the "intervention from the gods" deux ex machina is it?
pfl95 It absolutely is a deus ex machina, despite fans insisting it cant be because the beings a referenced from the first 20 minutes of the film. It's very cleverly camouflaged, but it absolutely is- the characters have a huge number of problems with their situation- the gravity equation, accumulation and delivery of data, fuel, time, imminent death from a black hole- and boom Tesseract magically solves everything- even plops Cooper back near saturn at a survivable local to be picked up (generous considering the future beings were happy to let everyone else die) just so the audience could have a happy ending (a cooper sacrifice would have been 100X more impactful- and yet people are saying it's not a deus ex machina?! IT'S THE LITERAL DEFINITION OF THE TERM for Christs sake - higher beings descending and magically solving everyone's problems. It was lazy and boring, i hoped Nolan(s) had more balls as writers.
It was such a well done movie. The beauty was not lost on me as a physics student, as not only could I appreciate what I was seeing, I understood it.
It was such a beautiful film.
Nolan’s films are just out of the Oscar’s league. Simple as that. I think for him to win an Oscar would almost be an insult. He’s better than that crap.
The irony that this was for Time magazine and the movie is based upon time
The film is 11 out of 10 it is just absolutely f***ing amazing :)
Best movie I've seen in a looong time, words can't explain how good is this movie, so shocking !!
Congratulations, Mr. Kip Thorne! You're the first physicist with familiar face, who won Nobel
Christopher Nolan you are the greatest artist of our generation
The question Christopher Nolan raised about economics and physics is actually incredibly important. I wish the interviewer picked up on that. Nolan remarked on how economics studies things that are so important to our day-to-day lives, yet is always wrong and actually causes crisis after crisis, while astrophysics is as far removed from day-to-day as it gets, yet makes huge improvements like the GPS to our lives.
The difference is empirical veritability. Science, by its method of always trying to disprove itself, ensures that over time nothing nonsensical remains. Economics (and a few other "fields" I shall not mention) do not use the scientifical methods. Human nature (e.g. selective memory) ensures they're always wrong. Until other fields start to use the scientific method, they'll continue to sound reasonable until they destroy us in moments of madness.
Christopher Nolan makes the best movies. And interstellar is his best movie. It's as epic in scope as it is dazzling in visuals as it is heart breaking. A new definition of epic movie making.
You have to give it to Christopher nolan, he truly had made some amazing contributions to human kind.
If i would wake up one morning and turn on the news to see that Nolan died from a car accident or something. I would lose my mind.
True. In this universe of billions of things and humans, if Chris left the world, it would be the saddest day for me or anyone with the level of perception to even understand 1% of him.
Chris Nolan, your daughter called and said quit wearing her socks.
Thank you, Chris, Kip, Jeff and thespian bro. Mathew, I love what you have done with the book and I hope to do some very serious partying with you soon, peace and love, Doug.
this movie is perfect, in all senses all the stories combined
s/o to nolans socks
Nolan is that physics teacher who just loves directing movies
This conversation is deep af. Why would anyone dislike the video?
Hi all, what is the name of the soundtrack in the beginning with the piano?
If i didnt know what Nolan looked like i would think hes the guy with the leather jacket and the scientist with a suit.
I didn't know Rorschach was a scientist!
Attempt but nah
bbkingzor HAHAHAHAHAHAH
What a comment!!!
so underrated
this video is good and also the bit about zimmers music
congrats to kip thorne for winning the nobel prize for physics this year
tnx nolan for all the movies you made.
this is not how i imagine how "kip the scientist" looks like.
just WOW, sir you amazed me.. this is so cool to see
I love kip and chris
nolan, every film is a monster film
daniel day lewis , every film is a monster film
i would like to see a nolan film with main actor daniel day lewis, and ost by hans zimmer
to me, daniel day lewis and henry fonda are the best drama actors i have ever seen
"Take a field like economics. It can't predict anything. It's always wrong."
Christopher Nolan discovers Austrian economics.
What this movie depicts and stands for is amazing. It stands for human curiosity and human spirit. I hate that the fact people hate Nolan is because his movies are "blockbusters" like not every movie has to be a "Birdman" or a "Budapest Hotel" to be a award winning film.... I hate that bullshit of Nolan always getting thrown under the bus just because he has a bigger budget.
I wonder what part of the movie Nolan wanted faster-than-light travel for.
Also, I think the interest in cosmological matters comes from our deepest yearnings for meaning, connecting to the universe, the infinite, whatever. Kind of like a modern-day replacement for religion.
believe me when i say that, i know people that are not moved by all these concepts, they dont care about existential and cosmological questions.and i know they had zero stimuli during their childhood. sometimes i get frustrated at how a person cannot be moved by all this
tonyvice6661616
Oh, I know there are people like that...it makes me think that is why Lawrence Krauss didn't like the movie, because of its existential themes. Because atheism has no answer for people dealing with these questions, it sometimes tries to pretend they don't exist.
And then there are other people who just plain aren't interested. Sometimes I envy them, as I have struggled with these questions since I was a kid and all it has done is provoked a huge amount of anxiety and angst in me. I wish every day that our tools for investigating the mind were as effective as the ones that allow us to see far-off galaxies.
His socks are fabulous
What a legend
I get confused on the scenes with matt damon. Seriously, I got so confused on whether it is the martian or intersteller that had a person pushed down the hill..
Oscar's don't deserve Christopher Nolan...
Question kept getting stupider but the answers kept getting wiser.
Saw Kip's photo with Stephen Hawking in Hawking's autobiography, he was a handsome dude. Idk why I was expecting a much younger Kip! Anyways, Kudos!
Kip Thorne Noble prize winner 2017..yayayay
4:30, where the brilliant Kip Thorne calls Jonah Nolan stupid. Rightly so too.
Why rightly so?
imagine you make a scientist go back home and rethink about it just showed how ambitious and the willingness of Chris Nolan is.
haha Nolan socks is so hilarious!!
Amazing Christopher Nolan Is My Favourite Director 😍🎬
Thanks To Christopher Nolan, Scientist and Producer
5:54 "It can't just be the calculus it has to be the feeling"... Kip was nodding in agreement and I am laughing here that he did agree to that. That's so funny. I am sure he will watch this later and regret it lol.
Well said Paulo.
Best movie i have ever seen ! Respect nolan and thanks nolan to give such experience.!
I love you Chris I can’t wait 🤍💒😘
The way they are dressed you would think that Kip's the artist and Nolen's the scientist lol
Not going to even relatively hint at my viewpoint on Interstellar, based on some of the other comments on this video I don't want that much flak, but Christopher Nolan is 100% my favorite director of the past 2 decades. Inception is close to flawless, The Dark Knight is one of (if not the) best super hero movies out there, even his first films are great, i.e. Doodlebug & Following. Let's just hope that this "Dunkirk" movie rumor comes to be true!
This movie made me a huge Kip Thorne fan..................and that leather Jacket
Time interviews a movie based on time!
2023 anyone ?😁😁😁
🙋♀️
He won the Nobel prize
Damn.. cool jacket Kip! Nolan you're the best, can't wait for another movie you got in store for us.
my volume is on max and i barely hear chris talking
you are genius Chris I’m so proud of you I love all your movies I can’t wait to be with you ❤ Ruby Nolan
Is this the Kip Thorne behind LIGO?