@@stephensocolow Definitely worth it. It's a completely different experience. Just keep an eye out, some cinemas do specials every few years where they show 'classics".
Ahora, con el Coronavirus, es aún más claro que la ciencia y tecnología son importantes para ayudar a la humanidad contra catástrofes mundiales. Espero que esto sirva como una lección a la humanidad para dejar atrás el pensamiento mágico y acercarse al científico.
The ship design is one of the most plausible I've seen for a movie like this. Well, not the gravity engines, but the Rangers. Nuclear powered generators that produce a plasma to heat the air with no fuel, and then using metallic hydrogen with nuclear heat to power the main engines, bypass to rcs for all control surfaces, etc. Like, the science was so realistic
I was hoping for the explanation on how a human being can survive inside a black hole. I have always believed such amount of gravity would rip anything apart.
future human technology, warping spacetime to allow cooper to enter the black hole where time and space are reversed and also where most of the fiction lies in the movie
I believe Neil deGrassi Tyson explained this one in a video, IIRC gravity would indeed rip you apart if you were in the center of the black hole however if you had a trajectory that avoided the center that might not happen.
With Time, I am fading with all other movies but this movie is keep on growing. I watched this movie twice in 2 different cities with 2 different set of friends and even in 2nd watch it was as fresh as it was in first time watching. I want to forget this movie, so that next time If I watch it will be like my first watch. That may not be possible but whenever time will permit I will watch this movie again and again. All Nolan's movie are linked with time. Even his latest Oppenheimer teaser gives you timer.
No one is more excited about this movie and the science and technology behind it than me. I have read Mr. Thorne's book about the movie as well as other books about great scientists and astrophysicists like Carl Sagan and Einstein. I once sat in at a lecture by Mr. Sagan at Cornell. Although I greatly admire these scientists and appreciate what the human race has learned and accomplished with regards to space and the universe, I am saddened by the lack of acknowledgment given to God about these things. I believe that God has made the Universe and that the vastness of space and time is a testament to his greatness. Even Einstein believed in an intelligent design of our universe...he felt that the universe has so much beauty and order and that the physical laws that govern it are so perfect that they could not have been randomly created...something to think about.
"We need technology to save humanity from disaster." Even the "intelligent" scientists are lost about life, this realm, and what we are all doing here. How can such a mass of people become so disconnected from who they are? All of culture/society is utterly insane.
Well, the funny thing is that most of the disasters we face (climate change, species extinction, nuclear disaster) come from the power of science and technology itself, so we need even more science and technology to escape from these same problems. Not sure this is the best path.
Cooper is the protagonist of the movie...he AND the women and other men who chose to take the dangerous likely one way trip through the wormhole are the heroes of the movie
If Miller's planet had a one hour to 7 years time shift it would have to be so close to the black hole that it would be torn apart and sucked into the black hole!
When Cooper and co arrive at Miller's planet near Gargantua where 1 hr equals to 7 years on earth, why is it that gravity on that planet seem to be similar to that on Earth? Amelia and Doyle move around in the lake how one would in lakes on Earth. Shouldn't the gravity there be enormously higher than that of Earth and earthlings would find walking next to impossible? Could anyone shed some science behind this?
Manjit Mohan The warping of space time that causes the difference between time on Miller’s planet and Earth is due to the gravity well created by Gargantua. Amelia and Doyle are under the influence of gravity on the planet. In the scene you can see them struggling slightly to move around, and I believe they mention the increased gravity compared to earth while in the water. I believe that could be due to the size of the planet or its position in orbit around a spinning black hole, but it’s not really made clear in the film.
@@calvin010 Thank you for your reply. Thinking more on the subject, it could be working this way: The time dialation (1hr vs 7yrs) happens because of the difference in the relative speeds of both planets (earth vs Miller's planet). However since they are already on Miller's planet they do not feel the speed of the planet, just like we on earth do not feel the speed at which earth is moving through the universe. But then the question is, how were they able to reach Miller's planet?; since for that amount of time dialation, Miller's planet should be traveling at the speed of 0.9999999998% speed of light.
Manjit Mohan Just as time can slow due to an object approaching the speed of light, it can also slow due to increased gravity, a force that bends space time. For instance, satellites that orbit earth actually have to account for general relativity when transmitting data due to Earth’s time being “slower” because of the planet’s gravity relative to the satellite in orbit. I think you’re still correct in that the speed of the planet could play a role as well, but we just don’t know.
@@calvin010 yes, absolutely. I am assuming the dilation is from the velocity of the planet since the gravity on the planet didn't seem drastically different from that on Earth. Thank you. 🙏🏽👍🏽🙂
They were looking for planets for humanity to live on, so gravity had to be similar to that of earth's. Miller's planet is still a planet with it's own gravity: this gravity can be affected by other planets/celestial objects in the same system (think of the tides affected by the moon on earth) as they all pull on eachother and hold eachother in a certain way. But the further an object, in this case a planet, is from another object= another planet, the less impact their gravity has on eachother. Quite certain I remember this correctly but I may be wrong or misunderstood the bigger picture.
He visto la película varias veces y la verdad no recuerdo que mencionen seres alienígenas ("Bulk") ni como los conocieron o se comunicaron con ellos; tampoco recuerdo nada relacionado con "disminuir la gravedad de la Tierra" y naves cilíndricas. En fin, tendré que verla otra vez.
When they used slingshot around the black hole (Penrose process to be precise), then the dilation happened significantly. We have to assume that Cooper falling down to black hole to his return to Solar system- this happened relatively much more quickly in the first place so not much long time has passed by even far away from the hole. May be few months or few years but not decades.
Because time is relative. They are in different places/planets, moving at different velocity in the universe. For all we know the planet Brand is on, is one where an hour equals the same as 7 years on earth
@@maserjeees5670 Considering how many things happened after Cooper was rescued, he would have been dead before he even reached her if that was the case. Besides, where did you get that from?
Dr brand did age just like Cooper did and so when Cooper went back he was seeing his granddaughter who was very old while Dr brand was the same age as Cooper. Cooper fell into a black hole which added some years but after he crossed the event horizon the time effectively paused so the bulk beings ended up returning him to his solar system pretty much after he crossed the event horizon
So magical space aliens built a path out of the black hole that crosses eons of time and billions of lightyears to his daughter's bedroom? I sure hope Thorne marked this part with an S for Speculative. When it comes to scientific plausibility this movie rates up there with Harry Potter. Shame on Kip Thorne.
dude is a black hole, science doesnt know yet what happens when you reach a black hole past the event horizon, its believed the laws of physics as we know it are completely subjective there and make non-sense. the movie took advantage of that to give themselves artistic freedom and do whatever they want with the little information we have of it, so practically, no speculation is entirely impossible
He said in the lecture that a lot of the science was theoretical, but the bulk beings in the movie turn out to be humans in the future that have learned to master the fourth and fifth dimensions, and are able to manipulate gravity across time the same way Cooper did at the end. Weird that you think Kip Thorne is just making all this up.
It is a movie and it becomes relatable due to characters that we care about. Science still checks out even if you consider the instruments of it (i.e. the characters and the plot) implausible. And it isn't even that implausible, given that Murph is intelligent enough to become a theoretical physicist, and Cooper is the best pilot NASA can have at that situation.
@@pyridonfaltis9761 Nope. The movie throws scientific accuracy out the window as soon as he crosses the event horizon. The excuse: We don't know what goes on inside a black hole so anything goes.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
I saw Interstellar for my 8th time in cinema last week. Best movie ever made.
It's in theaters again? 😲
@@MagicWuf ye lots of movie theatres were showing it again because no new movies are coming out becuast of covid19.
HOLY CRAP is it in IMAX? my biggest regret in life is not seeing this in IMAX.
@@stephensocolow Definitely worth it. It's a completely different experience. Just keep an eye out, some cinemas do specials every few years where they show 'classics".
I rank it up there with 2001 a Space Odyssey
Idk if I ever cried so much during a movie as I did with this one. I can say honestly, it is the greatest movie I've ever seen.
Deadass. Got me looking at shit like it's a sign from another dimension
Thanks for uploading mate. No other relevant Kip Thorne explaining Interstellar videos out there.
Rapidly evolving pathogens. Well, that proved itself 5 years later.
I know right lol
Foreshadowing
Plandemic
Rabid? Naturally? It's conflicting as I type
Rapidly engineered for widespread distribution
He also knows selling.
On the strange point he mentions at end he doesnt ecplain it and "i explain it in my book"
What an awesome video this guy deserves so much much more
Qué genial, ahora todo es mucho más claro, gracias Kip Thorne por explicarnos. 💕
my favorite movie of all the time i wish it showed us more of Edmond's planet
Bravo 👌 por todo. La explicación , el tema , la película en fin gracias señor kip ojalá pueda encontrar las respuestas que tanto ha buscado .
science, technology AND LOVE!
My mom:
You're watching Interstellar again? I bet it's your 20th time!
Me: I can do this all my lifetime !
I do thing I went to the cinema to see Interstellar but if it ever plays in 70mm at the science museum then I'm DEFINITELY going to watch it.
Ahora, con el Coronavirus, es aún más claro que la ciencia y tecnología son importantes para ayudar a la humanidad contra catástrofes mundiales. Espero que esto sirva como una lección a la humanidad para dejar atrás el pensamiento mágico y acercarse al científico.
“Space is proper big” - Kip Thorne
The ship design is one of the most plausible I've seen for a movie like this.
Well, not the gravity engines, but the Rangers. Nuclear powered generators that produce a plasma to heat the air with no fuel, and then using metallic hydrogen with nuclear heat to power the main engines, bypass to rcs for all control surfaces, etc. Like, the science was so realistic
i always wondered what fuel they used
@@alonsovm2880 Metallic hydrogen superheated.
@@pilotavery does that info come from the book by Kipp?
@@JDMKEV yeah
Incredible 👍
I was hoping for the explanation on how a human being can survive inside a black hole. I have always believed such amount of gravity would rip anything apart.
not all of the things in the movie is real sadly, its a science FICTION movie so yeah theres science in it but theres fiction too :]]]
future human technology, warping spacetime to allow cooper to enter the black hole where time and space are reversed and also where most of the fiction lies in the movie
I believe Neil deGrassi Tyson explained this one in a video, IIRC gravity would indeed rip you apart if you were in the center of the black hole however if you had a trajectory that avoided the center that might not happen.
Like he said, theres a gentile singularity that allows him to survive. The others planted it there to save him.
This seems to me to be highly speculative and is not explained at all within the movie. In the movie it's presented more as a Deus ex machina.
With Time, I am fading with all other movies but this movie is keep on growing.
I watched this movie twice in 2 different cities with 2 different set of friends and even in 2nd watch it was as fresh as it was in first time watching.
I want to forget this movie, so that next time If I watch it will be like my first watch.
That may not be possible but whenever time will permit I will watch this movie again and again.
All Nolan's movie are linked with time.
Even his latest Oppenheimer teaser gives you timer.
Esto es una forma de llamar la atención de la gente para que empiece a tener mas interés sobre la ciencia, y funciona
La verdad que si
Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.
No one is more excited about this movie and the science and technology behind it than me. I have read Mr. Thorne's book about the movie as well as other books about great scientists and astrophysicists like Carl Sagan and Einstein. I once sat in at a lecture by Mr. Sagan at Cornell. Although I greatly admire these scientists and appreciate what the human race has learned and
accomplished with regards to space and the universe, I am saddened by the lack of acknowledgment given to God about these things. I believe that God has made the Universe and that the vastness of space and time is a testament to his greatness. Even Einstein believed in an intelligent design of our universe...he felt that the universe has so much beauty and order and that the physical laws that govern it are so perfect that they could not have been randomly created...something to think about.
This man is a god damn genius
That is what i call science fiction! It is a fiction, but it is a science one.
13:50s Shouldn’t that be 7 different bedrooms? Did Kip make a mistake? A hypercube has 8 cells
Mas clarito donde? Excelnte el.profe Thorne
"We need technology to save humanity from disaster." Even the "intelligent" scientists are lost about life, this realm, and what we are all doing here. How can such a mass of people become so disconnected from who they are? All of culture/society is utterly insane.
Now I need a video explaining this in simpler terms 😭
I kinda got it the first time ❤
Well, the funny thing is that most of the disasters we face (climate change, species extinction, nuclear disaster) come from the power of science and technology itself, so we need even more science and technology to escape from these same problems. Not sure this is the best path.
I still don't understand
Becoming interplanetary doesn't matter if humanity's greatest enemy is itself!
Crossing the oceans mattered
4:42 I am not smart enough to correct Kip Thorne, but he should have put a T there...
All this incredible trip only to get the data to fit a model. That's interstellar.
What
Cooper is the protagonist of the movie...he AND the women and other men who chose to take the dangerous likely one way trip through the wormhole are the heroes of the movie
I think you don't quite get what protagonist mean... It has nothing to do with who is more heroic.
I guess those are just victim of prof brand's lie for his theory or stuff, the real hero of the movie is his daughter, Murph!😀
License
Could have called get inside
Threats of Army they will expose
France debts Dancing rev
Megaworld having more money and still Alone
Of what they hear of what Police Siren's change
If Miller's planet had a one hour to 7 years time shift it would have to be so close to the black hole that it would be torn apart and sucked into the black hole!
The real Walter White
When Cooper and co arrive at Miller's planet near Gargantua where 1 hr equals to 7 years on earth, why is it that gravity on that planet seem to be similar to that on Earth? Amelia and Doyle move around in the lake how one would in lakes on Earth. Shouldn't the gravity there be enormously higher than that of Earth and earthlings would find walking next to impossible? Could anyone shed some science behind this?
Manjit Mohan The warping of space time that causes the difference between time on Miller’s planet and Earth is due to the gravity well created by Gargantua. Amelia and Doyle are under the influence of gravity on the planet. In the scene you can see them struggling slightly to move around, and I believe they mention the increased gravity compared to earth while in the water. I believe that could be due to the size of the planet or its position in orbit around a spinning black hole, but it’s not really made clear in the film.
@@calvin010 Thank you for your reply. Thinking more on the subject, it could be working this way: The time dialation (1hr vs 7yrs) happens because of the difference in the relative speeds of both planets (earth vs Miller's planet). However since they are already on Miller's planet they do not feel the speed of the planet, just like we on earth do not feel the speed at which earth is moving through the universe. But then the question is, how were they able to reach Miller's planet?; since for that amount of time dialation, Miller's planet should be traveling at the speed of 0.9999999998% speed of light.
Manjit Mohan Just as time can slow due to an object approaching the speed of light, it can also slow due to increased gravity, a force that bends space time. For instance, satellites that orbit earth actually have to account for general relativity when transmitting data due to Earth’s time being “slower” because of the planet’s gravity relative to the satellite in orbit. I think you’re still correct in that the speed of the planet could play a role as well, but we just don’t know.
@@calvin010 yes, absolutely. I am assuming the dilation is from the velocity of the planet since the gravity on the planet didn't seem drastically different from that on Earth. Thank you. 🙏🏽👍🏽🙂
They were looking for planets for humanity to live on, so gravity had to be similar to that of earth's. Miller's planet is still a planet with it's own gravity: this gravity can be affected by other planets/celestial objects in the same system (think of the tides affected by the moon on earth) as they all pull on eachother and hold eachother in a certain way. But the further an object, in this case a planet, is from another object= another planet, the less impact their gravity has on eachother. Quite certain I remember this correctly but I may be wrong or misunderstood the bigger picture.
Unknown future threats- watching this in 2020 covid 19, now it's making sense. So here the "ghost" is us, the movie.wepl, haha
8:04
9:08
He visto la película varias veces y la verdad no recuerdo que mencionen seres alienígenas ("Bulk") ni como los conocieron o se comunicaron con ellos; tampoco recuerdo nada relacionado con "disminuir la gravedad de la Tierra" y naves cilíndricas. En fin, tendré que verla otra vez.
But why the hell Brand didn't get older when Cooper went into the black hole? That part doesn't make sense.
she did, they just dont show that on camera.
When they used slingshot around the black hole (Penrose process to be precise), then the dilation happened significantly. We have to assume that Cooper falling down to black hole to his return to Solar system- this happened relatively much more quickly in the first place so not much long time has passed by even far away from the hole. May be few months or few years but not decades.
Because time is relative. They are in different places/planets, moving at different velocity in the universe. For all we know the planet Brand is on, is one where an hour equals the same as 7 years on earth
@@maserjeees5670
Considering how many things happened after Cooper was rescued, he would have been dead before he even reached her if that was the case.
Besides, where did you get that from?
Dr brand did age just like Cooper did and so when Cooper went back he was seeing his granddaughter who was very old while Dr brand was the same age as Cooper. Cooper fell into a black hole which added some years but after he crossed the event horizon the time effectively paused so the bulk beings ended up returning him to his solar system pretty much after he crossed the event horizon
message to the story is that we need to sacrifice Mathew mecchonaughey to the black hole gods.
More realistic than Tenet it is
ostia es walter blanco
What's Walter White yappin about?
Puff.
So magical space aliens built a path out of the black hole that crosses eons of time and billions of lightyears to his daughter's bedroom? I sure hope Thorne marked this part with an S for Speculative.
When it comes to scientific plausibility this movie rates up there with Harry Potter. Shame on Kip Thorne.
Shut up, non scientist can proove anything in this movie is impossible. In haryy Potter? Hell yeah
dude is a black hole, science doesnt know yet what happens when you reach a black hole past the event horizon, its believed the laws of physics as we know it are completely subjective there and make non-sense. the movie took advantage of that to give themselves artistic freedom and do whatever they want with the little information we have of it, so practically, no speculation is entirely impossible
He said in the lecture that a lot of the science was theoretical, but the bulk beings in the movie turn out to be humans in the future that have learned to master the fourth and fifth dimensions, and are able to manipulate gravity across time the same way Cooper did at the end. Weird that you think Kip Thorne is just making all this up.
It is a movie and it becomes relatable due to characters that we care about. Science still checks out even if you consider the instruments of it (i.e. the characters and the plot) implausible. And it isn't even that implausible, given that Murph is intelligent enough to become a theoretical physicist, and Cooper is the best pilot NASA can have at that situation.
@@pyridonfaltis9761 Nope. The movie throws scientific accuracy out the window as soon as he crosses the event horizon. The excuse: We don't know what goes on inside a black hole so anything goes.
?????????? literally expaning nonsense and then skip over time dilation like wtf ?