I know everyone talks about how amazing Liam Neeson was in this scene and he was! But Sir Ben Kingsley was also incredible, in a very subtle but powerful way
Cinebinge's reaction to this scene was very satisfying because they spent so much of the movie saying what a bad person Schindler was, and it was here that he finally drops his uncaring facade and shows his true soul to everyone.
This is the only movie that I absolutely cannot watch again. It's too overwhelming. It would be one thing if it was fictional, but the fact that this really happened is soul-crushing.
I don't cry often at the movies ... but this scene gets me, when he collapses in anguish because he feels like he could've gotten ONE MORE... 1100 people... and it wasn't enough
Schindler's List is a phenomenal movie, I myself, was like everyone else reacting to this movie, I cried my eyes out too. And Liam Neeson deserved his Oscar as Schindler. This movie should be shown in schools all over the world.
I've never seen the last reaction channel in this line up, Mjoy4 Fun, but his comment at the very end, "they don't have the courage to celebrate, but they have joy in their hearts," absolutely broke me!! What a beautiful description!
A powerful scene, the part that always makes me break down is when Schindler’s heart shatters because he blames himself for not doing enough and he begins openly weeping, the reactions of everyone around him are so touching, his heart is breaking and all they want to do is console him and thank him in their own way for all that he did for them, he was an angel in human form for what he did and the lives he saved. RIP Herr Schindler you’ve earned your place in heaven.😢😢
Tom Hanks was just as amazing in Philadelphia as Liam Neeson was in this movie and I think these two deserved to share the Academy Award for their roles. Oskar Schindler was actually credited for saving 1200 lives. This movie is listed as a movie that you have to watch once but can't watch again but I'll watch it if it is on because the acting is so good and it is one of those parts of history that people can't forget.
"I couldn't" is terrible, but "I could have, but I DIDN'T" is a tragic self-condemnation. I wish we could all see the HUMAN value of our decisions and actions.
Perhaps, it would be unbearable to see EVERY action we participated in that contributed to the HUMAN VALUE of our decisions. Maybe that's God's job in the fullest sense of the problem and morality. ( EX: How much has a person enabled greater injustices in other parts of our society, let alone world, through purchases we make? Are we guilty of each and EVERY purchase? Depends, doesn't it? Are we absolutely guilty for such decisions/actions? ) And for every way that a person could have said something good, true or right, spoken up and out, defended another from undue pain or harm, done the right thing, but did not, then comes to a point of understanding and accountability, one must find forgiveness. At least from God, perhaps others who one didn't help or actually hurt, and ultimately from oneself. Otherwise, it can be become a curse and bondage of the soul.
@@machtnichtsseimann You ask if we are guilty of every (purchase) consequence of every action we take. If by GUILTY you mean RESPONSIBLE., then I say absolutely, YES. We are always responsible for our actions, and for the consequences of those actions. Our entire legal system is based on that understanding. But Guilt only attaches when one becomes aware of those consequences, or the potential likelihood of those consequences. If you hand a child a gun that you believe is unloaded, and the child harms the dog, you are not guilty of shooting the dog, but responsible for its death. If knowing the human cost of your actions is "unbearable" you need to change what you are doing, not close your eyes to the consequences of your deeds.
You have such a sympathetic and kind heart for making these videos - You are really wonderful for helping people to share their experiences. thank you for your kindness
This film is tough to sit through - but i encourage everyone to view it at least once. Powerful, depressing, and very sad Spielberg created a masterpiece of a film here - few films leave a mark on you like this one does.
The same Talmud passage is also in the Quran. God put it there for a reason. God know that they will rule the world and commit atrocities in the name of their religion.
I would highly recommend that you look up Sir Nicholas Winton. He was a British stockbroker who saved 669 children in Czechoslovakia from being sent to concentration camps. The thing that makes it more amazing is that he didn’t tell anyone about it. The only reason it came out was because his wife found a scrapbook in their attic with detailed info on all the kids.
To have such a moving and beautiful ending after all the horror witnessed throughout the entire film is a testament to Mr Spielberg's ability as a filmmaker. And also to leave us with the knowledge that amidst all the evil we perceive in this world, there will always be Good people to stand against it.
AMONG SOOO MUCH PAIN AND SUFFERING AND EVIL, GOD SENDS AN ANGEL TO GIVE A LITLE RELIEVE. YES HE STARTET BEING JUST GREED BUT HE COULDN'T STAND THE BARBARIC ACTS FROM THE NAZZ AND HAD A WONDERFUL DEVELOPMENT ENDING WITH THIS BEAUTIFUL SCENE WITCH ALWAYS GETS ME IN TEARS. REGARDS AND BLESSINGS FROM MEXICO TO JEWISH PEOPLE AND TO YOU ALL.
Spartan and Pudgy, the lest feeling of the lot. Congrats. Actually, Natalie Gold might take the top spot. Why doesn't that surprise me. I hate her shit.
@@griechland awww bless, you think it actually started on Oct 7th, Palestinians have been getting slaughtered by Israel since 1948 and by Britain since 1800s, go read a book ffs.
@@the-smelly-hippie Muslims have been slaughtering Jews since Mohamed wiped out the Qurayza. Move up ahead to the period of this film and you had the The Grand Mufti, founder of the Palestinian movement, a strong ally of Hitler and ardent Nazi who recruited SS units in the Balkans. That Nazi impress has never left the Palestinians who had former Reich officers advising their militias in 1948. And you wonder why things got so bad?! As long as the people of Gaza hate the Jews more than they love themselves, including before the IDF coasted Gaza in 1967, they will be always be shackled by their self-destructive choices.
@@the-smelly-hippieit’s actually very easy to cry because these people have nothing to do with what their grandchildren are doing now and what their grandchildren are doing doesn’t change the fact that the holocaust was evil and inhumane. Learn to differentiate between your crimes against humanity.
Beautifully harrowing. A masterpiece, I've seen it dozens of times and it still chokes me up. The ending, bringing in the generations in colour is the work of genius. One of the greatest movies of all time
If they had the expression “I can’t hang with this!” then… That’s probably what he could have felt seeing genocide of human beings!… “No!… I can’t hang with this!… I MUST do something!”
I also love they kept the blooper of dropping the ring, but Liam and Ben stayed in character so it worked to show Oskar holding it together by his fignertips.
Every Single Performance In This Masterpiece Of Steven Spielberg,Is Oscar Worthy.I Seen This Brilliant Movie Well Over 20 Times.And In Case Anyone Was Wondering And Still Didn't Know,That's Liam Neeson At the End Standing By Oskar Schindler's Grave...
This one scene was one of the biggest departures from historical fact. But I think either Steven or Liam thought it so important to include. I can also guess a conversation like this happened around the decision of Israel to declare Oskar Schindler as Righteous Among the Nations.
Brilliant film but he was asking the wrong question… the question shouldn’t have been why didn’t I get more, it should’ve been why weren’t there more like me?
That would be deflection..he felt the weight of guilt because he had the wealth to save many more then 1100 possible triple or more..but he used it on other things and wasted a lot of his wealth so when he realized he was running low he started late on buying workers
This would have been one of my most favorite movies of all time (top 5 for sure), except for Spielberg's "sense of humor". It took away the illusion and just rubbed me the wrong way. Technically very good movie, very good acting but it just reeked of Spielberg in some parts.
Natalie Gold’s reaction was so weird. She cries and sobs uncontrollably at the dumbest shit but her reaction to this scene was indistinguishable from if she was watching a minor league baseball game.
I know everyone talks about how amazing Liam Neeson was in this scene and he was! But Sir Ben Kingsley was also incredible, in a very subtle but powerful way
Sir Ben Kingsley was and is amazing
I can sit through most of the film but this scene never lets me off the hook. Breaks my heart every time.
I would love to see Liam Neeson and Ben Kingsley talk about filming this scene.
Cinebinge's reaction to this scene was very satisfying because they spent so much of the movie saying what a bad person Schindler was, and it was here that he finally drops his uncaring facade and shows his true soul to everyone.
This is the only movie that I absolutely cannot watch again. It's too overwhelming. It would be one thing if it was fictional, but the fact that this really happened is soul-crushing.
No matter how many times i watch this scene, i will always shed a tear. Steven Spielberg has created an enduring and masterful film.
The fact that Liam Neeson didn’t win best actor for this should be a crime.
He didn't get an Oskar, but he was Oskar..
Itzhak Perlman's violin doesn't make the scene any easier to bare... just tears flowing.
the most haunting and beautiful soundtrack I know. That violin cuts through me like a blazing sword through butter..
I don't cry often at the movies ... but this scene gets me, when he collapses in anguish because he feels like he could've gotten ONE MORE... 1100 people... and it wasn't enough
Truly good people don't pat themselves on the back for what they did well, they are haunted by the good they couldn't accomplish.
Schindler's List is a phenomenal movie, I myself, was like everyone else reacting to this movie, I cried my eyes out too. And Liam Neeson deserved his Oscar as Schindler. This movie should be shown in schools all over the world.
If saving 1 life is a miracle, think of 1100 lives saved 😢😊😢
I've never seen the last reaction channel in this line up, Mjoy4 Fun, but his comment at the very end, "they don't have the courage to celebrate, but they have joy in their hearts," absolutely broke me!! What a beautiful description!
Yes they are amazing, I’m subbed to them and they are such a treasure 💖
A powerful scene, the part that always makes me break down is when Schindler’s heart shatters because he blames himself for not doing enough and he begins openly weeping, the reactions of everyone around him are so touching, his heart is breaking and all they want to do is console him and thank him in their own way for all that he did for them, he was an angel in human form for what he did and the lives he saved. RIP Herr Schindler you’ve earned your place in heaven.😢😢
If this movie doesn't make you cry, nothing will.
How he got here doesn't matter. He saved so many in the end. We may never know how many people we save with even one act of kindness
Liam Neeson was robbed of his oscar award by the academy that year. Looking back I'm still dumbfounded by how could the academy get it so wrong !!! 💯😤
Tom Hanks was just as amazing in Philadelphia as Liam Neeson was in this movie and I think these two deserved to share the Academy Award for their roles. Oskar Schindler was actually credited for saving 1200 lives. This movie is listed as a movie that you have to watch once but can't watch again but I'll watch it if it is on because the acting is so good and it is one of those parts of history that people can't forget.
"I couldn't" is terrible, but "I could have, but I DIDN'T" is a tragic self-condemnation. I wish we could all see the HUMAN value of our decisions and actions.
And such a dark and dangerous hole to spiral down into.
Perhaps, it would be unbearable to see EVERY action we participated in that contributed to the HUMAN VALUE of our decisions. Maybe that's God's job in the fullest sense of the problem and morality. ( EX: How much has a person enabled greater injustices in other parts of our society, let alone world, through purchases we make? Are we guilty of each and EVERY purchase? Depends, doesn't it? Are we absolutely guilty for such decisions/actions? ) And for every way that a person could have said something good, true or right, spoken up and out, defended another from undue pain or harm, done the right thing, but did not, then comes to a point of understanding and accountability, one must find forgiveness. At least from God, perhaps others who one didn't help or actually hurt, and ultimately from oneself. Otherwise, it can be become a curse and bondage of the soul.
@@machtnichtsseimann You ask if we are guilty of every (purchase) consequence of every action we take. If by GUILTY you mean RESPONSIBLE., then I say absolutely, YES. We are always responsible for our actions, and for the consequences of those actions. Our entire legal system is based on that understanding. But Guilt only attaches when one becomes aware of those consequences, or the potential likelihood of those consequences. If you hand a child a gun that you believe is unloaded, and the child harms the dog, you are not guilty of shooting the dog, but responsible for its death. If knowing the human cost of your actions is "unbearable" you need to change what you are doing, not close your eyes to the consequences of your deeds.
I dont often cry in movies but when I do, I prefer Dos Equis
The scene that gets me every single time even more than this one is the fade to color with the REAL Schindler Jews.
Destroyed me the first time seeing the actual survivors
And those real people being escorted by the actors who played them.
I'm a guy. Saw this in a theater and not ashamed to say I was crying like a baby towards the end.
You have such a sympathetic and kind heart for making these videos - You are really wonderful for helping people to share their experiences. thank you for your kindness
Liam neeson my country man. Such a fine actor💚💚💚☘️☘️
This film is tough to sit through - but i encourage everyone to view it at least once. Powerful, depressing, and very sad Spielberg created a masterpiece of a film here - few films leave a mark on you like this one does.
I saw it in theaters. It was the only movie I've ever cried during, when leaving the theater and driving home. We can never forget.
@@shannanigansisme definitely 😥
The amazing thing is that Kevin Costner attempted to buy the rights to this story. He was to portray Oscar Schindler.
I was only able to watch this once, because it absolutely destroyed me. Everyone gave brilliant performances. 😪
The same Talmud passage is also in the Quran. God put it there for a reason. God know that they will rule the world and commit atrocities in the name of their religion.
Maybe all he saw in his mind was that little girl in red. 😞
I would highly recommend that you look up Sir Nicholas Winton. He was a British stockbroker who saved 669 children in Czechoslovakia from being sent to concentration camps. The thing that makes it more amazing is that he didn’t tell anyone about it. The only reason it came out was because his wife found a scrapbook in their attic with detailed info on all the kids.
The strongest people are given the greatest burdens
To have such a moving and beautiful ending after all the horror witnessed throughout the entire film is a testament to Mr Spielberg's ability as a filmmaker. And also to leave us with the knowledge that amidst all the evil we perceive in this world, there will always be Good people to stand against it.
Liam Neeson at his absolute best👌🙏
Women are amazing (at crying on camera)
AMONG SOOO MUCH PAIN AND SUFFERING AND EVIL, GOD SENDS AN ANGEL TO GIVE A LITLE RELIEVE. YES HE STARTET BEING JUST GREED BUT HE COULDN'T STAND THE BARBARIC ACTS FROM THE NAZZ AND HAD A WONDERFUL DEVELOPMENT ENDING WITH THIS BEAUTIFUL SCENE WITCH ALWAYS GETS ME IN TEARS. REGARDS AND BLESSINGS FROM MEXICO TO JEWISH PEOPLE AND TO YOU ALL.
This part made me cry so much.
Spartan and Pudgy, the lest feeling of the lot. Congrats. Actually, Natalie Gold might take the top spot. Why doesn't that surprise me. I hate her shit.
I cry at this bit every single time. Even after visiting the camp on a holiday to Poland, I stood and cried to myself
This movie is a fucking MASTERPIECE
Masterpiece about the best and worst of the human being. About light in times of darkness. The horror of World War II never must be repeated. NEVER.
Thank you for this amazing compilation.
When the movie came out everyone was talking about it. A somber reminder of the hell of war and yhe human lives taken so callously..
Almost universally on every list of top 10, often top 5, of best films in history. Rightfully so. A triumph in every category
if you aren't crying by the end of this movie i'd have questions
It's a bit hard to cry when their grandchildren are now the ones killing innocent children.
@@the-smelly-hippie October 7
@@griechland awww bless, you think it actually started on Oct 7th, Palestinians have been getting slaughtered by Israel since 1948 and by Britain since 1800s, go read a book ffs.
@@the-smelly-hippie Muslims have been slaughtering Jews since Mohamed wiped out the Qurayza. Move up ahead to the period of this film and you had the The Grand Mufti, founder of the Palestinian movement, a strong ally of Hitler and ardent Nazi who recruited SS units in the Balkans. That Nazi impress has never left the Palestinians who had former Reich
officers advising their militias in 1948. And you wonder why things got so bad?! As long as the people of Gaza hate the Jews more than they love themselves, including before the IDF coasted Gaza in 1967, they will be always be shackled by their self-destructive choices.
@@the-smelly-hippieit’s actually very easy to cry because these people have nothing to do with what their grandchildren are doing now and what their grandchildren are doing doesn’t change the fact that the holocaust was evil and inhumane. Learn to differentiate between your crimes against humanity.
Beautifully harrowing.
A masterpiece, I've seen it dozens of times and it still chokes me up. The ending, bringing in the generations in colour is the work of genius.
One of the greatest movies of all time
The reason he was leaving was he wanted to surrender to the Americans and Brits rather than to the Soviets.
Try not to cry challenge
If they had the expression “I can’t hang with this!” then… That’s probably what he could have felt seeing genocide of human beings!… “No!… I can’t hang with this!… I MUST do something!”
This scene always strikes a chord with me…
I also love they kept the blooper of dropping the ring, but Liam and Ben stayed in character so it worked to show Oskar holding it together by his fignertips.
If any movie could pour a river of tears, it's this one.
The way he moves when he drops the ring.😢
Every Single Performance In This Masterpiece Of Steven Spielberg,Is Oscar Worthy.I Seen This Brilliant Movie Well Over 20 Times.And In Case Anyone Was Wondering And Still Didn't Know,That's Liam Neeson At the End Standing By Oskar Schindler's Grave...
Such an amazing movie. Great acting from all and a story that is amazing (no matter the creative license)
This one scene was one of the biggest departures from historical fact. But I think either Steven or Liam thought it so important to include. I can also guess a conversation like this happened around the decision of Israel to declare Oskar Schindler as Righteous Among the Nations.
"They need some water!! Get the Seinfelds some water!! They'll get dehydrated on the plane!!!"
Brilliant film but he was asking the wrong question… the question shouldn’t have been why didn’t I get more, it should’ve been why weren’t there more like me?
That would be deflection..he felt the weight of guilt because he had the wealth to save many more then 1100 possible triple or more..but he used it on other things and wasted a lot of his wealth so when he realized he was running low he started late on buying workers
This would have been one of my most favorite movies of all time (top 5 for sure), except for Spielberg's "sense of humor". It took away the illusion and just rubbed me the wrong way.
Technically very good movie, very good acting but it just reeked of Spielberg in some parts.
Who told her to start here? No knowledge of Kirk and Spock and you thot this was best?
This scene is quite the eye cleaning moment, very emotional movie, shocking. The multiple reaction fantastic.
And then when they surivive they conquered someone else land, and killed them. Irony
Nonsense
that's a lot of tears for a nothing burger.
Natalie Gold’s reaction was so weird. She cries and sobs uncontrollably at the dumbest shit but her reaction to this scene was indistinguishable from if she was watching a minor league baseball game.
And she's Jewish!!
I own this movie, I dont care had I paid 50 100 500$ for it. This is a true masterpiece.
"I didn't do enough."
"Oscar...you did more than most." 😪