Yeah it would be rubbish if it was a prequel. Like what is the point of showing so many events occurring and changes happening and the bloody possibility of life outside the train if nothing is going to change for another 11 years.
I find it so hard to understand why people cannot except that the TV show in the movie or its own separate things and not connected by story in anyway, but yet people still make of the most elaborate theories trying to connect both things
I understand. It totally this video makea it seem like they are the same but from the get go i thought they where deferent realities first none of that processed food the pepole in the back where forced to eat and the did not resort to eating other humans in the show but they did in the movie plus the revaluation was a victory where in the movie there where tones of revaluations but they all failed
It’s implied (but not fully explained) in the season finale too. Alice came from a different “maintenance” railway so it’s easy to imagine they were using a parallel railway all along, changing their speed and switching between railways to not cross paths with Snowpiercer 🤷♂️
Or you know read the books the first one is called "Snowpiercer the Escape" it's a very good read but you might get frustrated by them because they are different from the movie and the TV series, and they have their different takes on the story line.
@@dylankennedy453910 train in the novel and only 2 in the TV, 1 in the movie and juste the size dont match like a wagon of the TV show have the size of a building when the movie and novel have the size of regular train
I started watching Snowpiercer the TV series last night it was freaking amazing I can't wait to continue it. And yes David Diggs Jennifer Connelly and Ed Harris were the point where i said fine I'll give it a shot.
The books actually imply the existence of 10 trains, and the movie is confirmed as being in the same universe as the book because the two characters at the end are seen interacting with the characters from the book. So it's more likely the TV show just takes place in another one of these trains.
@@AlejandroLZuvic In the book there is a train called Snowpiercer and they mention the Snowpiercer from the movie as a different name. They all live independently so they don't ask need different names since in theory they weren't supposed to meet.
Although that doesn’t explain why there’s two Wilfords, and two pairs of Mr and Mrs Headwood, in the book, movie, and tv series. Unless they are some kind of family relatives??
@@strbournein the book Icebreaker aboard Olga (Snowpiercer) to contain the engine in a cargo bay because they take the oportunity to have a "second engine"
Don't forget the third train Icebreaker from the bande dessinée, i think there's 7 trains in total. Tailles will be mixed as trains merge and cars dropped. Snowpiercer isn't even close to replacing parts with kids yet. I think Leyton, Ruth and other main characters will end up in boxes.
Is confirmed the Tv and Movie are in different spaces. That means The TV has its own universe. And now the next season is about the rescue of snowpuercer in the hands of Wilford. Also the warm continents. So this means the show will end in about 3 seasons now that Netflix has the rights. Same as they did with Lucifer.
This video was done more than a year ago, so at that time, season 3 wasn't finished filming, let alone available for view. Edit to add: I'd like to see another video by the same person for an update of sorts here... even though they're completely unrelated.
Yea I know just poking a little fun at them 😂. I just finished watching the last ep 30 mins before I made the comment searching to see when the next season might come, sadly there isn’t anything yet
@@beafjerlky608 Yeah, I know. I don't know anyone personally, in my little world that watches the show... so this (RUclips) is where I go to chat about my shows that no one watches. 😂
Big Alice was hiding behind Piercer the whole time, waiting for its time to overtake the ark. Alice actually doesn’t know where Snowpiercer is the whole time, it was Ben who contacted with Alice
@@theinternetisnotarealplace4133 so your saying that no one else survived from the train? I’m sure that somewhere down the train there had to be someone still alive whose car just fell over
so you got that third screen rant video for me? yes sir I do excellent now I can make the same joke for the third time today being early to a Screen Rant video that isn't a Pitch meeting is super easy, barely an inconvenience
So if you listen deeply to conversation and watch carefully in the backgrounds of the new and old episodes it is told Wilford was not able to make it on so he presumably stayed in a bunker with other survivors until Big Alice was finished being built and only traveled on the Rocky Mountain route until it was time to take back Snowpiercer.
it isnt a circulatory track, and big alice can travel in both directions due to its duo-cockpit systsem. This means it would be easy to avoid snowpiercer.
I've started noticing this more as I get older, but man is it distracting when people in historical dramas/post-apocalypse, have perfect white teeth/veneers.. Especially when we know they've only been eating bug bricks for years
The biggest continuity issue if the movie train and the TV train are the same is Gilliam. They could fix that by having him show up and be a minor character now and gradually become a major character, but not being there at all is an issue.
In regards to cinematography, the movie reminds me of the movie12 Monkeys, and the show reminds me of the show 12 Monkeys. They got rid of the French style of cinematography, like City of lost children.
Interesting breakdown, good insights into the trains ... Im not liking the prequel slant cause now I'm less interested in the fate of the tailies now, knowing that the revolution changes nothing and what about the earth getting warmer in their lifetimes ?!
I believe that the show is not set in the same universe and do not affect the story of the movie. I believe that if the uprising of Leyton happened in the movie canon, it would have to be mentioned, since Tailies wouldn't just forgotten about the time they ruled the train. Also, there are some difrences in the backstories, for example how they stoped cannibalism in the back of the train, with layton defeating canibal group in a first months of the travel while movie Tailes would do that difrently. Let's also mention the that train designs are difrent and there's the whole Big Alice that we don't see a trace of nowhere in the movie.
I've always assumed they're not and that's made it much more enjoyable, just the same concept taken and retold as a different story. More like a reboot
@@ZETH_27 well I believe they're different eternal engines as this one seems to do a large circuit around the us. But we all deserve our own opinion as it's up to interpretation; much like the SCP cannon.
@@jackbrunato8960 It really isn't. The TV show is officially a reboot which means that there is no way for the worlds to be connected. You can still believe they are, but it wouldn't be an interpretation, it'd just wrong.
It’s got it’s highs and lows. It’s hard to ride (hehe get it?) on such an unbelievable plot for 10+ episodes without breaking the illusion so I’d say the showrunners are doing a fine job, but don’t expect the best TV series in the world.
One of the main differences is everyone dies in the movie literally everyone you could say, but the kids get out. No that is a polar bear. They only eat meat with the state the world was left in that thing extra hungry
I think this story takes place at the beginning of snow piercer and the movie takes place at the end, just like humanity there have been many revolutions and extinctions and eventually it has to start again!
so basically the show is a prequel to the actual movie? no i don't think so, they're totally different universes witht he same base, i chose the show over the film.
yeah thanks for putting the graphic novels title in the description or a pinned comment... if anyone has it, could you please? i'm not that good with french spelling.
@@MasterChief-nk5lc so far only snow piercer and big Alice are canon, MAYBE there will be more, as suggested by the Band dessinè but it was not confirmed yet
I liked the movie but I hate Curtis decision at the end SPOILER ALERT we see that the world is warming a few more years and the earth could recover more but Curtis instead condensed humanity in a split second decision. If they had survived on the train and endured its tyranny humanity would have survived and Curtis made the wrong decision
So are u saying that the one from the movie is the one from the show because wilfred seid that all the times they tried to take the train failed and where is that old guy who gave his leg so they did not eat the kid ?
I don’t really know, but the logical conclusion says it’s its own thing. I can’t really imagine being a prequel no matter how hard some people want to believe that.
I don't know why almost everyone is on the Tails side and they're complaining about not being treated right and having no freedom. they should have brought a passenger ticket or worked as a crew in order to stay in the Snowpiercer but instead they broke through the Train by Brute Force. and they have the audacity to Riot while everyone is being generous enough to let them stay in the train. well that's just my point of view and how I was mad throughout the series. they should know their place.
I completely understand where you're coming from but u should understand the train has limited space, so it can only have enough workers and as we see in season 3 most of them have to go through wilford first !! Also buying a ticket is like telling a homeless man to get a house, i mean the price and demand for the tickets must have been insane also when u consider the society inside snowpiercer it was very hierarchical not by gender or race but by class now image if it was equal they could ahev fit a lot more people in one of the gigantic carts of the 1st class!! I understand that the first class probably payed millions but we're not talking about a 1 month vacation in the bahams in the first class private jet but were talking human survival !! the more people they could fit in the train the more they could ensure the survival of human being !!
I love the show and enjoyed the move, years ago!! Interesting video for sure but If I'm being honest this seemed rather lazy on your part haha 🤷♂️ This was the best you could do?? Lol
It really is, I watched the tv show first and the film after. Honestly, I liked more the tv show because the film seems too rushed copared to a 10h tv show. I suggest you to watch it and make your opinion :)
I suggest you to watch it. I watched the film after the tv show and I honestly didnt like it very much. The tv show is much more deep, intriguing, a lot of twists and a lot to think about.
They have different appeal. The movie is very self contained with one strong message. The show is much more concerned with worldbuilding and character development. I also like that the show looks at what happens after the revolution. It definitely adds to the discussion
They are different timelines they are not in the same universe the snow piercer movie and TV show are different continuities
Oh ok i thought he was saying that they where the same train i thought it was a parallel dimension cause the storys definitely did not match up
Finally, the answer I was looking for.
In the TV series, it's A LOT colder. EDIT: And the cars are much wider and taller.
Yeah it would be rubbish if it was a prequel. Like what is the point of showing so many events occurring and changes happening and the bloody possibility of life outside the train if nothing is going to change for another 11 years.
I find it so hard to understand why people cannot except that the TV show in the movie or its own separate things and not connected by story in anyway, but yet people still make of the most elaborate theories trying to connect both things
I don’t understand it either. It’s a reboot, or a remake or something like that. End of story.
I understand. It totally this video makea it seem like they are the same but from the get go i thought they where deferent realities first none of that processed food the pepole in the back where forced to eat and the did not resort to eating other humans in the show but they did in the movie plus the revaluation was a victory where in the movie there where tones of revaluations but they all failed
They can easily just be on different Trains, So what’s wrong with them being connected?
@@user-td4fe5ng6u 🙄🙄 it ain’t in the same universe
@@ncrxghost8075 why can’t it be?
If you want to know where big Alice came from watch the first couple of episodes from season 2
My toughts too, it got explained, but this is probely made weeks/months ago. This is when you got this errors in video's like this.
It’s implied (but not fully explained) in the season finale too. Alice came from a different “maintenance” railway so it’s easy to imagine they were using a parallel railway all along, changing their speed and switching between railways to not cross paths with Snowpiercer 🤷♂️
Thanks. I was almost gonna dislike but must be an old video
Or all of it
Or you know read the books the first one is called "Snowpiercer the Escape" it's a very good read but you might get frustrated by them because they are different from the movie and the TV series, and they have their different takes on the story line.
Having sean bean is a spoiler in itself. We know what's gonna happen to him.
I'm happy I wasn't the only one who thought thay
What do you mean?
@@ByAllAccounts Sean beans character dies in 90% of the projects he plays in
In 2019 he said he won't sign roles where he dies anymore
Well he is still living even after the season 2 finally lol
The track isn't circular. There are several tracks. Tracks that come into play as the plot needs, but they are there.
Yeah but the mainline is circular
I love the show, truly underrated. tnt needs to do more work marketing their content
In the UK it's on Netflix and certainly with season 2 it's consistently in the top ten list with each new episode.
@@kevinh96 cool to know, that's dope
It’s on Netflix originals now aswell so it’s very much advertised on Netflix uk
2:49 it’s not a curricular track it is the complete opposite with sheds sidings loops warehouses and much more
How does someone have a massive RUclips channel dedicated to movies and shows and still not realize that the show and movie are completely unrelated.
Theres 6 trains
@@dylankennedy4539 maybe, that does not change the fact that the movie and the show are separate
@@dylankennedy453910 train in the novel and only 2 in the TV, 1 in the movie and juste the size dont match like a wagon of the TV show have the size of a building when the movie and novel have the size of regular train
I started watching Snowpiercer the TV series last night it was freaking amazing I can't wait to continue it. And yes David Diggs Jennifer Connelly and Ed Harris were the point where i said fine I'll give it a shot.
it’s daveed. D A V E E D. not david.
Loving both. Buuut I love tv show a bit better. There is more story and answers that movie didn't answer.
The books actually imply the existence of 10 trains, and the movie is confirmed as being in the same universe as the book because the two characters at the end are seen interacting with the characters from the book. So it's more likely the TV show just takes place in another one of these trains.
How? Each train has its own name and both the train of the TV show and the movie are called Snowpiercer.
@@AlejandroLZuvic In the book there is a train called Snowpiercer and they mention the Snowpiercer from the movie as a different name. They all live independently so they don't ask need different names since in theory they weren't supposed to meet.
Although that doesn’t explain why there’s two Wilfords, and two pairs of Mr and Mrs Headwood, in the book, movie, and tv series. Unless they are some kind of family relatives??
@@strbournein the book Icebreaker aboard Olga (Snowpiercer) to contain the engine in a cargo bay because they take the oportunity to have a "second engine"
Watching this after season 3 hurts
Don't forget the third train Icebreaker from the bande dessinée, i think there's 7 trains in total. Tailles will be mixed as trains merge and cars dropped. Snowpiercer isn't even close to replacing parts with kids yet. I think Leyton, Ruth and other main characters will end up in boxes.
Is confirmed the Tv and Movie are in different spaces. That means The TV has its own universe. And now the next season is about the rescue of snowpuercer in the hands of Wilford. Also the warm continents. So this means the show will end in about 3 seasons now that Netflix has the rights. Same as they did with Lucifer.
Wrong they are doing the season 4
Love the show! I'm having so much fun watching it during this TV dry spell.
Damn guess they haven’t seen season 3
This video was done more than a year ago, so at that time, season 3 wasn't finished filming, let alone available for view.
Edit to add: I'd like to see another video by the same person for an update of sorts here... even though they're completely unrelated.
Yea I know just poking a little fun at them 😂. I just finished watching the last ep 30 mins before I made the comment searching to see when the next season might come, sadly there isn’t anything yet
@@beafjerlky608 Yeah, I know. I don't know anyone personally, in my little world that watches the show... so this (RUclips) is where I go to chat about my shows that no one watches. 😂
Big Alice was hiding behind Piercer the whole time, waiting for its time to overtake the ark. Alice actually doesn’t know where Snowpiercer is the whole time, it was Ben who contacted with Alice
It literally said on the show it was on a different track
It's too late to fix anything
Now that everything has gone wrong
Its been Big Alice All Along
I just hope the show doesn’t end of replacing the moving and that we can still get a sequel to Snowpiercer and the aftermath of the train derailing
The only survivors were the little balck kid and the asian girl
@@theinternetisnotarealplace4133 so your saying that no one else survived from the train? I’m sure that somewhere down the train there had to be someone still alive whose car just fell over
@@TheCosmicViewer no one survived because will Ford planted bombs on the train you forgot
@@TheCosmicViewer and even if there wasnt they would die from the extreme cold
so you got that third screen rant video for me?
yes sir I do
excellent now I can make the same joke for the third time today
being early to a Screen Rant video that isn't a Pitch meeting is super easy, barely an inconvenience
Telling same jokes is tight
I always believed the TV show and movie were their own thing. The TV show is a remake if you will, not a prequel. Am I wrong?
Yeah they are different timelines
So if you listen deeply to conversation and watch carefully in the backgrounds of the new and old episodes it is told Wilford was not able to make it on so he presumably stayed in a bunker with other survivors until Big Alice was finished being built and only traveled on the Rocky Mountain route until it was time to take back Snowpiercer.
From what I understand Big Alice was the prototype and was on a side track.
it isnt a circulatory track, and big alice can travel in both directions due to its duo-cockpit systsem. This means it would be easy to avoid snowpiercer.
actually both are different universe, there's no link between TV show and 2013 movie
@@philchao that's what I read on reddit
@@philchao its been offically confirmed not be the same thing
@@simen30 it is unofficial because there different gauges of track, Snowpiercer is close to say 26 feet wide and ice breaker is mainline
@@philchao wrong
@@locker07 stay off reddit un less to see leak nudes
I've started noticing this more as I get older, but man is it distracting when people in historical dramas/post-apocalypse, have perfect white teeth/veneers.. Especially when we know they've only been eating bug bricks for years
The biggest continuity issue if the movie train and the TV train are the same is Gilliam. They could fix that by having him show up and be a minor character now and gradually become a major character, but not being there at all is an issue.
Yeah Ivan kind of filled that role
It's a different universe
In regards to cinematography, the movie reminds me of the movie12 Monkeys, and the show reminds me of the show 12 Monkeys. They got rid of the French style of cinematography, like City of lost children.
in my own head cannon, the video for Snap's 'World in my Hands' happened on this train
Cam we just have the two be in either different timeliness or the TV show as a remake?
The TV show is a reboot; the same concept and universe but done in a different way.
So... no mention of the original source, the book Le Transperceneige by Lob & Rochette?
Interesting breakdown, good insights into the trains ... Im not liking the prequel slant cause now I'm less interested in the fate of the tailies now, knowing that the revolution changes nothing and what about the earth getting warmer in their lifetimes ?!
I believe that the show is not set in the same universe and do not affect the story of the movie. I believe that if the uprising of Leyton happened in the movie canon, it would have to be mentioned, since Tailies wouldn't just forgotten about the time they ruled the train. Also, there are some difrences in the backstories, for example how they stoped cannibalism in the back of the train, with layton defeating canibal group in a first months of the travel while movie Tailes would do that difrently. Let's also mention the that train designs are difrent and there's the whole Big Alice that we don't see a trace of nowhere in the movie.
Is it even confirm that the movie and tv show are connected?
I've always assumed they're not and that's made it much more enjoyable, just the same concept taken and retold as a different story. More like a reboot
I don't believe that the movie is the same eternal engine as the tv show
it isn't. The Show is a reboot, meaning it's an alternate take on the same universe. so no, they aren't the same and never have been.
@@ZETH_27 well I believe they're different eternal engines as this one seems to do a large circuit around the us. But we all deserve our own opinion as it's up to interpretation; much like the SCP cannon.
@@jackbrunato8960 It really isn't. The TV show is officially a reboot which means that there is no way for the worlds to be connected. You can still believe they are, but it wouldn't be an interpretation, it'd just wrong.
I’m watching the series right now, and personally it’s amazing.
Made it ASAP when I saw the title
Big Alice could have had to have a sevice. Secret Resupply bass would exist even in a real apocalypse.
It didn't. It was just circling an alternate test track until it received a distress signal from Snowpiercer at the end of S1 of the TV show.
Does it actually hold its own?? Looks cheesey
It’s got it’s highs and lows. It’s hard to ride (hehe get it?) on such an unbelievable plot for 10+ episodes without breaking the illusion so I’d say the showrunners are doing a fine job, but don’t expect the best TV series in the world.
the tv show is just inspired by the books, its separate from the movie just a re-adaptation
I went to snowpiercer for daveed Diggs but then stayed for snowpiercer
I only knew him as Leyton, looked him up on RUclips and didn't even know he could sing!
@@annabarr1304 Hamilton is just life for me lol
One of the main differences is everyone dies in the movie literally everyone you could say, but the kids get out. No that is a polar bear. They only eat meat with the state the world was left in that thing extra hungry
Love this deep dive
Please do a Pitch Meeting on the movie
How do they compare to the original source material?
I think this story takes place at the beginning of snow piercer and the movie takes place at the end, just like humanity there have been many revolutions and extinctions and eventually it has to start again!
Too many inconsistencies...
They're 2 different iterations.
It literally says that TV Snowpiercer is a REBOOT.
Once they killed the cows, they stopped being the same timeline
Thats what im thinking
First : the train Is different
so basically the show is a prequel to the actual movie? no i don't think so, they're totally different universes witht he same base, i chose the show over the film.
6:04 the train secrets arent as WHAT? 🤣🤣 “sinifinant”? Tf is that lol
So in the movie they mentioned an attempt to take the train was made before, so theory wise this is the before.
yeah thanks for putting the graphic novels title in the description or a pinned comment... if anyone has it, could you please? i'm not that good with french spelling.
Le transperceneige
SPLITTERS!
LoL!
you know that there are probably multiple trains, right?
No
Yes as seen with big Alice
@@MasterChief-nk5lc so far only snow piercer and big Alice are canon, MAYBE there will be more, as suggested by the Band dessinè but it was not confirmed yet
I love the videos
Long trip to nowhere
Good vid 👍
Thanks for subbin bro 😏
@@SonicBoy145 your welcome
They only get rid of 7 cars lmao
anyone else wondering why the music is so distracting
You shouldn't call theovie the original snowpiercer.... Since the comic came first lol
But the comic wasn't Snowpiercer, it was Le Transperceneige. Calling it Snowpiercer would just yield unnecessary confusion. It's just not practical.
@@ZETH_27 semantics... Transperceneige is still the original source material and the movie is not the original telling of this story.
Um aksualy big Alice is based off ice breaker in the comics
The orange will live
I liked the movie but I hate Curtis decision at the end SPOILER ALERT we see that the world is warming a few more years and the earth could recover more but Curtis instead condensed humanity in a split second decision. If they had survived on the train and endured its tyranny humanity would have survived and Curtis made the wrong decision
Main difference: the movie was actually good
So is the tv show!
So at least they both don't suck!!
All the Tailees would be dead if it wasn't for the train!!!!!!All Hail Mr. Wolford!!!!!!
So are u saying that the one from the movie is the one from the show because wilfred seid that all the times they tried to take the train failed and where is that old guy who gave his leg so they did not eat the kid ?
Do we know that the series is a canon-prequel, and won’t run its own story as if the film never happened??
@@philchao read the first three words
@@philchao I don’t know, grammar structure and the question mark seem to indicate that yes, it is a question indeed. Lol.
I don’t really know, but the logical conclusion says it’s its own thing. I can’t really imagine being a prequel no matter how hard some people want to believe that.
I don't know why almost everyone is on the Tails side and they're complaining about not being treated right and having no freedom.
they should have brought a passenger ticket or worked as a crew in order to stay in the Snowpiercer but instead they broke through the Train by Brute Force.
and they have the audacity to Riot while everyone is being generous enough to let them stay in the train.
well that's just my point of view and how I was mad throughout the series.
they should know their place.
They didnt pay for the train, the train costs money to build, so I agree with you
I completely understand where you're coming from but u should understand the train has limited space, so it can only have enough workers and as we see in season 3 most of them have to go through wilford first !! Also buying a ticket is like telling a homeless man to get a house, i mean the price and demand for the tickets must have been insane also when u consider the society inside snowpiercer it was very hierarchical not by gender or race but by class now image if it was equal they could ahev fit a lot more people in one of the gigantic carts of the 1st class!! I understand that the first class probably payed millions but we're not talking about a 1 month vacation in the bahams in the first class private jet but were talking human survival !! the more people they could fit in the train the more they could ensure the survival of human being !!
More pitch meetings
There on different trains, this is pretty damn Obvious
Officially confirmed the 2 are not correlated in any way
It's kind sad that no one cares about these two masterpieces.... but I see that no one likes the apocalyptic genre
People dont like class analysis in their media.
Tailers? Not Tailies?
the TV show is better. I love bong joon hos work though
i love the movie but honestly i think the tnt show is better
So which one has the chocolate factory in it with the Ula Lumpas ‘n all?
I didn't like where they decoupled some of the cars
The TV series is better. At least old Ivan didn't sell out the tail to mr wilford like Gilliam
Well the show is 4 to 5 times better than the movie, theres that
Wait I’m confused so this is 7 years before the movie right?
They aren’t even the same universe.
@@kfallon862 oh there not I thought they were lol
It’s a reboot ffs
I love the show and enjoyed the move, years ago!! Interesting video for sure but If I'm being honest this seemed rather lazy on your part haha 🤷♂️ This was the best you could do?? Lol
I hope the people really do understand the government work for the rich and vice versa
cool
SPOILERS
14th
Time travel on the train. Would explain some of these different premise.
the brilliant movie and mediocre series
Is this show even good?
It really is, I watched the tv show first and the film after. Honestly, I liked more the tv show because the film seems too rushed copared to a 10h tv show. I suggest you to watch it and make your opinion :)
I hate the movie so much. I won't be watching the show
I suggest you to watch it. I watched the film after the tv show and I honestly didnt like it very much. The tv show is much more deep, intriguing, a lot of twists and a lot to think about.
K0O1
The movie sucked...
The difference is the shows mediocre and the movies a masterpiece
Nah they are both good
They have different appeal. The movie is very self contained with one strong message. The show is much more concerned with worldbuilding and character development.
I also like that the show looks at what happens after the revolution. It definitely adds to the discussion
2
Fun fact: Everytime someone watches one of my videos a lion gives birth
Are the oompa loompas still extinct?
2ent