He Went Vegan And His Cholesterol Got WORSE! - Doctor Reacts

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 дек 2024

Комментарии • 86

  • @justin333eb
    @justin333eb Час назад +64

    I question everything, especially advice from government health organizations after reading 'Health and Beauty Mastery' by Julian Bannett, this book exposes so many shocking truths about the health industry. I completely changed my habits.

  • @KCallaAK
    @KCallaAK 16 часов назад +11

    I was keto (20T carbs) for 3 years... went whole food plant based (no oil sugar or salt) for 6 years..... cholesterol started going up. Doc told me at my age 68, I needed more protein... SOOOO I went back to keto with meat, Dr. Westman's page 4 and guess what... my cholesterol went down a little... BUT, my triglycerides went way down and HDL went up, and my doc said, I don't need statins! I'm now 69!

  • @wgterry73ify
    @wgterry73ify День назад +11

    Love Nick's channel

  • @christiroseify
    @christiroseify День назад +8

    I would love to hear you review Dr. Peter Rogers discussing humans as "starchivores". That we are to eat more starches & fiber and less protein and fat.

    • @masterchiefburgess
      @masterchiefburgess 22 часа назад +9

      Having seen his debate with Bart Kay, I wouldn't trust ANYTHING Peter has to say!

    • @christiroseify
      @christiroseify 22 часа назад +4

      @@masterchiefburgess I cracked up laughing when I heard him say, "starchivores"...

    • @masterchiefburgess
      @masterchiefburgess 16 часов назад +3

      @@christiroseify If you haven't watched his debate with Prof. Bart Kay, it's certainly worth a watch. Bart kept insisting that science is litigated through experiment, and that we CANNOT extract causality from weak epidemiogical studies and Peter replying "well it's the best we've got and we have to work with what we've got". Bart's reply, as always, was "Fine; but do not imply causality and use words like 'risk', because the connection just isn't there!". It embodied the whole problem with the pseudo-scientific community: they're willing to sacrifice PROPER scientific rigour in order to make inappropriate cause-and-effect statements to support their ideology/theology. BTW, Bart broke the discussion into half a dozen shorts. He made Peter look a complete fool, but of course Peter claims on his own channel that he won the debate. You be the judge.

    • @christiroseify
      @christiroseify 16 часов назад +2

      @@masterchiefburgess I only had to listen to Peter once to hear how credible he was.

    • @masterchiefburgess
      @masterchiefburgess 16 часов назад +2

      @@christiroseify 🤣🤣🤣

  • @nickbaffa3582
    @nickbaffa3582 14 часов назад +2

    Recently, my 14-year-old daughter had blood work done and they informed her parents that her LDL was 400. I think she fits into the lean mass hyper responder she’s 107 pounds and and she’s 5’1” and she’s very low carb. She learned somewhere that she could clear up her complexion by not eating so much sugar which it has worked but her pediatrician wants us to see a specialist. Yay my wife and I are not on the same page.

  • @aurapopescu1875
    @aurapopescu1875 День назад +3

    Love Nick Norwitz and his channel ❤

  • @ptbwinland146
    @ptbwinland146 День назад +11

    I thought the comments were interesting because people were accusing him of lying

    • @SpikeFastingRacing
      @SpikeFastingRacing 23 часа назад +1

      He was lying

    • @Clammy69
      @Clammy69 23 часа назад

      @@SpikeFastingRacing prove he was lying. Just because his results don't fit your indoctrination doesn't mean they're false.

    • @amyfarrell8799
      @amyfarrell8799 23 часа назад

      ​@@SpikeFastingRacing how do you know that? You just are vegan and don't like the results. Temper tantrum

    • @michaelstephens9852
      @michaelstephens9852 22 часа назад +3

      ​@@SpikeFastingRacinghow? He laid out what he ate.

    • @firstchoicefarm7767
      @firstchoicefarm7767 22 часа назад +4

      @@SpikeFastingRacing Do you always accuse people of lying when they say something that conflicts with your ideology, or do you have evidence of lying? I assume you believe a team of doctors from coast to coast are also lying?

  • @MsLeenite
    @MsLeenite 13 часов назад

    Thank you, Dr Westman and Dr Nick.

  • @charlestoast4051
    @charlestoast4051 18 часов назад +2

    When you consider that humans lost 5 inches in height and about 15% of their brain size with the advent of agriculture, I think you might reconsider your view that many diets can be healthy. Jawlines got narrower, and tooth crowding became an issue. Such crowding was not seen in the remains of pre-agricultural humans, who enjoyed far better dental health than modern people. Before the agricultural revolution, stable isotope testing of long bones reveals that humans and their predecessors consumed a diet comprising 80% animal products. Humans are obligate carnivores, with stomach acidity greater than lions.

  • @SPACEDOUT19
    @SPACEDOUT19 День назад +4

    cholesterol is important. the high cholesterol is a sign of something else, body uses cholesterol as a building block to hormones and an antioxidant

    • @SpikeFastingRacing
      @SpikeFastingRacing 23 часа назад

      Carnivore causes high cholesterol not good then

    • @amyfarrell8799
      @amyfarrell8799 23 часа назад

      He is not saying cholesterol is bad. That is not the point of this video

  • @DrAJ_LatinAmerica
    @DrAJ_LatinAmerica День назад +19

    Vegan is a religion. But YES, have had many patients go from Standard American Diet to Vegetarian and have been vegetarian for 5+ yrs. They all lost weight, reversed their diabetes, improvement in all blood markers and reduced plaque. Now hoping at some point to get them to join my other patients go keto / carnivore. Of course, patients are the boss, their body, their choice.

    • @paulhailey2537
      @paulhailey2537 20 часов назад +8

      I WAS 455 POUND VEGETARIAN AND ALWAYS STARVING TO DEATH ☠️ AND NOW I'M A 200 POUND CARNIVORE AND NEVER HUNGRY

    • @DrAJ_LatinAmerica
      @DrAJ_LatinAmerica 19 часов назад +4

      @paulhailey2537 awesome!!! Everyone is different. Sometimes it is the type of food, sometimes the timing, other times it is the preparation, and other cases based on the health of the person. I was never hungry on vegetarian diet but just don't like veggies. Carnivore / keto works for me. However with patients, must meet them in the middle. I can only recommend, they have to decide. It is the same with a medication or treatment. Provide full disclosure and let the patient decide what they want and what they can consistently follow based on their living situation, job, location, economic status, health,.....

    • @herbbowler2461
      @herbbowler2461 13 часов назад

      So you are against people being healthy?

    • @truthmatters8241
      @truthmatters8241 12 часов назад +2

      @@DrAJ_LatinAmerica I Iike your approach, very reasonabIe. Thanks for sharing your perspective Dr.AJ

    • @DrAJ_LatinAmerica
      @DrAJ_LatinAmerica 12 часов назад +1

      @@herbbowler2461 why would I be against people being healthy? It is my job, career, and responsibility to help people with their journey to reach their health goals. Their goals. Not my goals for them. Many roads can lead to the same place. Their goals under their timeline. The patient is always the boss.

  • @Alecmcq
    @Alecmcq 21 час назад +3

    Incorrect title: higher cholesterol is not “worse”

  • @dacisky
    @dacisky 20 часов назад +1

    I do hflc to keep my IBS in remission. Last year something strange happened and my gp thought I had cancer,I was also seeing a rheumatologist and got sort of a diagnosis of scardosis,started loosing weight and my ldl shot up. Doctors went nuts,I refused statins due to past experience...It was horrible as lymph nodes swelled up,got uveitis, and such.Then it all went away.Still doing hflc,
    and am beloe the magic number you stated ,so triglycerides are way down,LDL is still up but not quite as high. Anyway,I'm really curious to find out more info on lmhr and understand what's going on,so this was a wonderful program!

  • @tuyendo7409
    @tuyendo7409 2 часа назад

    Thank you dr Westman for giving us a second opinion

  • @robyn3349
    @robyn3349 День назад +1

    Thank you!

  • @joeh1687
    @joeh1687 11 часов назад +2

    Not really sure what he is trying to prove... eating only 29 grams of carbs is not even close to what someone would be eating on a typical vegan diet... some of them are eating 500 grams or more.

  • @Elvin6669
    @Elvin6669 8 часов назад

    Cool experiments.

  • @MuscleControlCenter54
    @MuscleControlCenter54 4 часа назад

    i went meat based about 10 years ago. 55 now, take zero medications and every year i get faster, stronger and healthier(well, not according to every single doctor when they see my cholesterol)

  • @peterbedford2610
    @peterbedford2610 12 часов назад

    I'm very low carb. Lots of leafy vegetables, nuts, dairy and various fish. Doesn't have to be carnivore.

  • @homomorphic
    @homomorphic 59 минут назад

    Net carbs is the technically correct measurement. The carbs that aren't included are indigestible and therefore are irrelevant wrt serum glucose.

  • @julienfroidevaux1143
    @julienfroidevaux1143 Час назад

    What essential nutrients cant be found from ethical sources?

  • @frugalprepper
    @frugalprepper 21 час назад

    Oh I though you were saying it got lower when it got worse. Higher is better.

  • @lasellbartlett7719
    @lasellbartlett7719 57 минут назад

    Is the high ldl research taking new subjects?

  • @Aminah6623
    @Aminah6623 День назад +3

    Is vegan keto a thing? How?

    • @amyfarrell8799
      @amyfarrell8799 23 часа назад +1

      Low carb no animal foods . Still in ketosis

    • @Vineyardedge
      @Vineyardedge 20 часов назад

      I did it for a year. Same foods daily... romaine, arugula, avocado, black olives, hemp seed, nutritional yeast, with ACV/black olive juice/extra virgin olive oil/stevia dressing. Pecans, walnuts, pistachios, almonds, and macadamia nuts. Coconut cream (TJs), brain octane oil, bulletproof coffee. A few blueberries, strawberries, broccoli and cauliflower. I tested my blood for ketones and was usually around 2.3 mmol. Lost all of my extra weight and was full of energy, no issues.

    • @leemanwrong
      @leemanwrong 10 часов назад +1

      Eat a ton of avocados I guess 😂

    • @amyfarrell8799
      @amyfarrell8799 10 часов назад

      @@leemanwrong tofu too

  • @happyapple4269
    @happyapple4269 18 часов назад +2

    Is cholesterol trying to fix the damage veganism is doing?

  • @markkozlowski6776
    @markkozlowski6776 19 часов назад +1

    Actually after one week are you going to get any reading that are any good? 🤔🙄

  • @amyfarrell8799
    @amyfarrell8799 23 часа назад +2

    Dr westman nick said 21 grams of fiber not carbs

    • @lloydhlavac6807
      @lloydhlavac6807 20 часов назад

      Fiber is a type of indigestible carbohydrate.

    • @amyfarrell8799
      @amyfarrell8799 19 часов назад

      @lloydhlavac6807 I'm just saying what Dr Westman said. I know what fiber is. There is soluble and insoluble

    • @Echidna7095
      @Echidna7095 19 часов назад

      Fibre is carbs.

    • @Echidna7095
      @Echidna7095 19 часов назад

      Yes but maybe. This is the "accepted" model . But there is some evidence that it might do actually work that way in the body

  • @SpikeFastingRacing
    @SpikeFastingRacing 23 часа назад +2

    If Vegan diet raises cholesterol then that’s good and it means it’s more nutrient dense.

    • @Clammy69
      @Clammy69 23 часа назад

      You, and your cult are delusional. 🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @amyfarrell8799
      @amyfarrell8799 23 часа назад

      That is not the point of this video
      He never says its bad or good

    • @amyfarrell8799
      @amyfarrell8799 22 часа назад +2

      Just having higher cholesterol in itself does not mean it's healthier. It doesn't mean your diets more nutritionally dense either. It's the ratio of your triglycerides to HDL and the size of the LDL particles that determines how healthy the cholesterol is. Did you actually listen to what he said? If you are overweight can you eat the same amount as a person who is normal weight your cholesterol will be lower. If you stay on the same diet and lose weight your cholesterol will go up

    • @amyfarrell8799
      @amyfarrell8799 22 часа назад

      Great video nick!

  • @williamcreech1505
    @williamcreech1505 19 часов назад

    Partical size

  • @alejandrosaez1772
    @alejandrosaez1772 День назад +1

    Ok, so n=1. Big deal!

    • @firstchoicefarm7767
      @firstchoicefarm7767 День назад +1

      Dave Feldman did similar. It is a big deal as the LEM has not been broken yet.

    • @amyfarrell8799
      @amyfarrell8799 23 часа назад +2

      It disputes the plant based propaganda

  • @josephsantus881
    @josephsantus881 22 часа назад +2

    Westman is running out of content, so he's looking at these maniacs with anecdotal information and he's trying to dissect it like he's on the committee for a student defending their dissertation at an ivy league school. This is a bunch of bullshit. This is when RUclips influencers become old and stale and they're just doing it for whatever monetary value they can get from these lame videos....

    • @RobBanks14
      @RobBanks14 22 часа назад +8

      Is this the first time you have seen Nick Norwitz or heard of LMHR?

    • @paulhailey2537
      @paulhailey2537 20 часов назад

      YOU'RE OBVIOUSLY A LITTLE BIT OF A S L O W THINKER