The Ven. Courtin is always a pleasure to listen to. The real strength in her talks, in my opinion, is the fact that she doesn't water down the conceptual explanation. She lays it out as she understands it. Some don't like her direct and rapid communication style, but it works very well for others. By the way, I don't think she was rude to the young woman at the end. She was trying to explain as she does, directly. That said, she works with prisoners and has access to a very wide array of human experience, including some that are brutal. It's possible that her teaching style has evolved to be practical no-nonsense because of that.
I like how she points out that negative thoughts are not to be denied, but they are also not what sits at the centre of who you are. Not to let ourselves be defined by them. Great.
I like her practical teaching, she seems real, and passionate. I like her vs. the xanax voice that most spiritual teachers feel that they need to project teachings.
Ha ha ha! I love 'Xanax voice'. I know what you mean. But one day if you follow the teachings, you might find your Xanax voice too! Buddhist practices can lead to calm that's better than Xanax. Try them!
@ 30:40 She blew me away...the reason why I fell apart when my sister died of cancer was due to my attachment to the idea that Sandy was going to go into remission....she simply could not die.
just because something is palpable it doesn't mean it is correct or right. there are many mental addictions and entertainments that even best therapist can't get you off of it.
I very much appreciate her frank manner and emphasis on using ones intelligence. She make me listen yet laugh a lot. She is the perfect one to work with inmates - lucky them and her
This was very introspective and enlightening. I sometimes wonder how the world would be as a whole if we were taught the ability to reduce the suffering that we bring onto ourselves at a young age instead of using material things to try to remedy them. It seems to me that this should be the basis of all teachings. This really makes one think about religion and how many congregations teach the opposite which raises the question, why would others want you to believe that you are not the controller of your own mind? To feel guilt or shame for simply existing? I feel fortunate to have reached a time in my life where many wonderful teachers are crossing my path.
Q..We are becoming materialistic... Explanation...because of buisness...they want to sell products..so they are CREATING..belief that things are connected to Happiness...by million dollar Adversiment...We are slowly programmed to believe this by showing advertisement every where.... CONTINUOUSly..
Beautifully delivered, very well delivered. I love the part how she speaks about the misconception of spirituality and judgement. Thankyou for putting the ancient teachings into plain english. 11:11
An absolutely brilliant teaching about looking at ourselves and ending our suffering!!! I love this woman's conviction and essence, she is pure truth!!!
Truly changes my relationship to these practices. I love the energy of this woman and what she does to break past the ideological assumptions we have in the west of what mindfulness is. So, so great.
I am trying to deal with depression and anxiety, and found what she said v useful. It took me a while to get used to how she was speaking, but so much of it made sense.
I nic mi nie mówiłaś... To jest źródło, z którego się dowiaduję o Twoich problemach po paru m-cach. Nie twierdzę, że umiałabym Ci pomóc lepiej niż ta jożka, bo przecież sama nie umiałam sobie pomóc throughout my life, ale smutno mi dowiadywać się, że nie umiałaś mi powiedzieć, wiedząc, że przecież mało kto zrozumie Cię lepiej, niż ja - mamy to, niestety, w genach, sweethart. I ten wpis był tuż przed Twoim przyjazdem do Polski. Nie mam żalu, ale czemu tak to jest? Ja nie mogłam nigdy zrozumieć, dlaczego nikt z moich bliskich nie wpadł na to, żeby zapytać mnie, kiedy byłam w koszmarnym dole, co właściwie dzieje się ze mną - chodzono wokół mnie na paluszkach i raczono cup of tea, kiedy trzeba było pagawarit' pa duszam (ruskie idiomatyczne powiedzonko, nie wiem, jak przetłumaczyć; chyba: "żeby dusze porozmawiały"?) By the way, dzwoniłam do Mariny i przyrzekłam, że na 100 % przyjeżdżamy w 2015 na białe noce (czerwiec). Powiedziała, że jest po prostu szczęśliwa, nareszcie!
Thank you Ven. Robina (and Google) for this presentation / talk video. The active, assertive tone of the speaker matches my tone for the day; and the subject matter was equally matched. Thus, it was beneficial to move quickly, candidly directly to the matter of: what is felt within you/your actions and what is you, the moment of recognition of these and where thinking "what can I do about this?" may bring you. (Now, to work on the underlying assumptions, the pace at which I can come to recognition, and the wisdom with which I decide what comes next!)
I have been listening to Robina's talks for several years now. I always get something new from the talks each time. She is wonderful! I love her style of teaching, her straight forward, no nonsense approach! Plus, her sense of humor is fantastic!
Really enjoyed this. I didn't expect to finish it, but the direct delivery and relevant and truthful statements she made just drew me in. Absolutely loved it.
Wise words. For me it worked in any case. It's good to hear talks on this subject (in a way the most important one of all) from time to time and I find the variety in style and expression among teachers refreshing.
Great Video! I was a very harsh speaker and people used to hate me because of my speech. I am Hindu, one of my Buddhist friend introduced me to eight noble path and especially Right Speech. I loved the concept so much that, I started practicing it regularly and i used the "BuDhamma" mobile app to help me on this. Now, I speak gentle and my people are very happy with me. Lot of things I get easily done now!
This woman is incredible I've stumbled upon her seeking for truth and she clearly knows what she is talking about. I have watched this video already numerous times because she knows how to convey the message for those that are open minded enough to see past her manors. Wich I in particular have no problem with, infact it’s what makes her different and interesting. I on the other half listen to what she has to say and there are few out there that can say something that simple that direct without sugarcoating anything I love it. The only one time when she possibly said something wrong was when she called Sarah Palin authentic lol, but pff who cares about that. I am by no means new to Buddhism or it's concepts but she was somebody I was glad to stumble upon. There are more people out there worthy of listening to or checking out. For anybody serious about these topics go check out Sadhguru , this guy I come to have known only for a few weeks but is blowing my mind. Please fellow Buddhists , spiritual seekers or anybody willing to enhance their own life's and those of others check this Indian yogi named Sadhguru he is very very special and def not a fake guru! Peace❤
This is awesome! She is brilliant. Ive watched this more than once & every time I rewatch it I learn something new. Thank you Robina for sharing your wisdom!
This is a wonderful gift! This sister may not be your stereotype of a spiritually motivated person, but she strikes me as incredibly down-to-earth and real. This is an approach to wisdom and compassion that I can admire and desire to emulate. Namastẻ! Peace and Light!
I'm very happy I watched this talk a second time. When one does it one can see beyond her "hard talk" and really get the beautiful message delivered. Which is, to quote Ven. Robina, is hidden under a layer. Thx Robina and everybody who made it possible :-)
@Seikisho I completely agree with you. She's not trying to give off that "mystical" aura that others give off. She's relatable and approachable. I really appreciate the way she teaches and her sense of humor. She's an excellent teacher.
What a razor-sharp and analytical mind! But from the questions and comments, I still applaud what J Krishnarmurti said " Truth is a pathless land" and what in a reverse direction, what nowadays sage Tom Campbell said "Truth has numerous paths". We are always stuck with physical appearances and boxes, categorizations, hence most heinous wars are fought along these religions and idealism. We at the Aquarian Age should wake up now! And focus on what these sages are saying: the potentials, the humanity and the Evolution. There are levels of evolution but no hierarchies. Get rid of our shackles, ID and boxes and Cheers to evolution. LOL, LOL, LOL from LOL ( Lots of love, lots of laughs and lots of learning from this Little Old Lady)
This is an amazing talk. The woman has a personality do not mistake that for anger. This talk has helped me immensly. As someone who has done bucket loads of therapy this is the appropriate wake up call - it is time to be your own therapist, you have to do it in the end no one else but you can make you happy, still your mind....think I'll watch it again!!
So much great info here ... enjoyed Q&A section the most! Robina has a beautiful clear way of speaking it as it IS. The concept that 'All thought is creative' was highlighted MOST effectively ... EVERYTHING starts & ends in our mind ... the hidden patterns behind neurotic delusions causing our pain/fear/anger... and that our thoughts are locked into the feeling level of our awareness ~ luv it! I notice Separation Trauma (experienced at birth) is a powerful hidden element behind much suffering.
This talk really works for me on many levels, and I lived in a Buddhist community for many years. Many of these precepts work and I have taken them with me as part of my life-long quest for truth and peace. A few things however do not add up. She touches on the "how" of Buddhism but not the "why". Buddhism believes that the conditions of our suffering are all tied to karma (cause and effect), which is easy to understand, except they believe in past lives which means we are suffering the effects of past misdeeds. In other words, if you are attacked, raped, disfigured, or victimized in any way in this life, then it's likely because of a past misdeed in a previous live that has "ripened". Their view of why good and bad things happen is very old world and in my opinion the karmic explanation is just another cop out from dealing with the fact that reality is capable of producing loveliness or harshness and often it is for no meaningful reason -- certainly not anything YOU did. The other thing is that pre-modern Buddhists explained thinks like physical deformities, autism, and basically any mental disability that prevents functional human interaction as a "lesser birth". This is because such individuals cannot receive the teachings of Dharma and the Buddha. It's true that a lot of our suffering is because of delusion, but there are some true cases where people are born different, or biochemical imbalances which cause their inability to maintain happiness. Schizophrenics, for example. In these cases, Buddhism's approach to their suffering might be frustrating because it implies that the solution is merely about debunking neuroses, when really there might be in-born problems that can't be debunked with mere analysis. Buddhism is NOT totally equivalent to the modern scientific method because they believe in things which cannot be empirically proven. Tibetan Buddhism in particular is a product of Indian Buddhism merged with local deity worship, so in any Tibetan temple you will see statues to all manner of entities. They are also into 'empowerment' ceremonies where you invoke these deities into you, which IMO is just adding more layers of delusion and not getting to core mind. They also believe in reincarnation, the wheel of life (i.e. when your karma is bad you come back with a lesser birth, like an animal, and if your karma is really good, you might come back as a demi-God), and there is a lot of pomp surrounding lineage rituals and proper ceremonies which again I do not believe really get to core mind. So, I have to disagree that Tibetan Buddhism (which the speaker practices) is free of contradictions. It has many of them, which is why Buddhism is a religion and not a pure science. But as she said, do what works for you. I took a great deal of useful wisdom away from my experiences with the Buddhists, and tossed the rest. IMO Zen Buddhism makes a lot more sense. It's no frills and doesn't have the Tibetan cultural hangups attached to it. If you stick just to the "how" and not the "why", Buddhism will make a lot of sense to you. For me it was not a complete system and I had to continue my search.
Your giving very valid points...but all you are giving for Buddhism..a religion..may it tibetian,Indian, Japanese..... Buddha never set a religion. He never claim to be god. He never asked to be workshiped.. So Buddha's Teaching are pure Scientific based... And Buddhism is a DISTORTION of his teaching..as religion... See Buddha's as Buddha ...a scientist.. He topic of research was to end of human Suffering... Buddha's only teaches four Truth.. 1)ABOUT the suffering 2)Cause of suffering 3)yes Suffering can be removed 4)The method...eight Fold path Rest is distortion... Buddha stated... Don't believe Anybody not Me...walk ,experiment on the Eightfold path...if it met with your wisdom accept it...if not reject it...
I've seen this video so many times that I know most parts by heart. It changed my life enormously and shaped my views, starting from my view of myself. Love it
Wonderful woman ! So amazing, interesting how we blame others for own self-centredness….this has really opened my eyes to how I can be more caring to others….thank you from me and everyone I meet….😅
This woman is outstanding. It's a very different approach than many of other teachers that say "be present, be happy". To my opinion, that's a very nihilistic point of view. What this woman here says is that the road is bumpy, is not nice to look at your self, but take responsibility. This point of view comes from the will of discipline and inner work. This is the balance to the other approach that says "sit, watch, observe and do nothing". The equilibrium is the wisdom of knowing them both.
Yes, it's amazing that we can make such a difference by choosing peace for a few minutes. Just imagine what would happen if feeling peace became our top priority.
Different teachers have different styles of teaching. And that applies to different tradition too. If you look at Zen Buddhism, even though the teaching is the same, their approach can be quite different. So, it's a task for everyone to seek out their teacher. Ven. Robina teaching method is fairly direct and is challenging one's ego directly.
Also, I feel she answered the last question, not with contempt but with compassion, selflessness and truth. She is very articulate and speaks with conviction which should not be mistaken as anger or the sort.
So agree with you! It was refreshing to see her approach to buddhism. Reinforces why I love Buddhism so much, because of how flexible the practice is.:)
i dont think ive gathered more wisdom in 1 hour before this video. she's a smart lady. and i love the way she talks fast and has effortless humour haha.
No, we do not necessarily suffer when we receive things, you are correct. But, the main point is that all negative emotions (anger, jealousy, depression) have an overwhelming sense of "I" or "mine" involved in them. Therefore it is this sense of "I", the ego, that is the source of all these emotional problems. So if you give and receive things with out ego and w/o expectations, you will be genuinely happy. The ego is the enemy, not any external phenomena. This is true realization.
Wonderful! I am in love with Robina. What a wonderful, honest, fearless woman. Thank you for posting this lovely speech. I have learned again what is necessary.
Sounds like Buddha was a good student of Albert Ellis, founder of rational emotive cognitive behavioral therapy. Anyway. Their approaches seems to dovetail very nicely. (On the other hand, Albert Ellis said himself that CBT wasn't something he created at all but derived directly from a few ancient Greek thinkers.) Thanks for this outstanding discussion.
ha ha ha somehow i managed to listen to her all the way thru...although at times i felt like she was being a little abrupt...overall i think it is a good talk...very lively...
It is true the sense of I is at the core of our suffering. It is the grasping (Upadana)of the I and I related phenomena that creates dis ease.The total freedom comes from letting go, but this isn't suppression or annihilation.Until things cease, if we can develop a space around things through mindfulness and abide there, instead of grasping and becoming we are at peace.The desire to get more and more can be enslaving and doing things free of self, bring peace. Keep letting go if it feels good.
I'm smiling at your comment because I was almost clenching my fists when she would call people "sweetheart", "darling", "honey", etc. I find these terms directed at strangers to be very offensive, as if one is talking down to someone. Now, I have to check myself. I think she´s brilliant.
Those were common words of warmth and terms of endearment coming from parents, Aunties and uncles etc in the part of Australia where I grew up in the 90s. I had to learn to shed them (for a male, they can now be problematic at work, with strangers etc), but yeah to me it makes her sound a like family/a mates mum.
The Ven. Courtin is always a pleasure to listen to. The real strength in her talks, in my opinion, is the fact that she doesn't water down the conceptual explanation. She lays it out as she understands it. Some don't like her direct and rapid communication style, but it works very well for others. By the way, I don't think she was rude to the young woman at the end. She was trying to explain as she does, directly. That said, she works with prisoners and has access to a very wide array of human experience, including some that are brutal. It's possible that her teaching style has evolved to be practical no-nonsense because of that.
I like how she points out that negative thoughts are not to be denied, but they are also not what sits at the centre of who you are. Not to let ourselves be defined by them.
Great.
I like her practical teaching, she seems real, and passionate. I like her vs. the xanax voice that most spiritual teachers feel that they need to project teachings.
Ha ha ha! I love 'Xanax voice'. I know what you mean. But one day if you follow the teachings, you might find your Xanax voice too! Buddhist practices can lead to calm that's better than Xanax. Try them!
@ 30:40 She blew me away...the reason why I fell apart when my sister died of cancer was due to my attachment to the idea that Sandy was going to go into remission....she simply could not die.
I am impressed in how she counters the many passive aggressives and victim positions in the audience.
Her straightforwardness is challenging & refreshing, the passion for the truth is papable!! thx for upload!!!
oops palpable =- )
just because something is palpable it doesn't mean it is correct or right. there are many mental addictions and entertainments that even best therapist can't get you off of it.
I very much appreciate her frank manner and emphasis on using ones intelligence. She make me listen yet laugh a lot.
She is the perfect one to work with inmates - lucky them and her
This was very introspective and enlightening. I sometimes wonder how the world would be as a whole if we were taught the ability to reduce the suffering that we bring onto ourselves at a young age instead of using material things to try to remedy them. It seems to me that this should be the basis of all teachings. This really makes one think about religion and how many congregations teach the opposite which raises the question, why would others want you to believe that you are not the controller of your own mind? To feel guilt or shame for simply existing? I feel fortunate to have reached a time in my life where many wonderful teachers are crossing my path.
Q..We are becoming materialistic...
Explanation...because of buisness...they want to sell products..so they are CREATING..belief that things are connected to Happiness...by million dollar Adversiment...We are slowly programmed to believe this by showing advertisement every where.... CONTINUOUSly..
Beautifully delivered, very well delivered. I love the part how she speaks about the misconception of spirituality and judgement. Thankyou for putting the ancient teachings into plain english. 11:11
Personally I simply do LOVE Ven. Robina Courtins approach to this topic. Becoming your own therapist! It is down to earth and full of wisdom...
An absolutely brilliant teaching about looking at ourselves and ending our suffering!!!
I love this woman's conviction and essence, she is pure truth!!!
Sometimes it takes a strong voice to get the message across.
Truly changes my relationship to these practices. I love the energy of this woman and what she does to break past the ideological assumptions we have in the west of what mindfulness is. So, so great.
I am trying to deal with depression and anxiety, and found what she said v useful.
It took me a while to get used to how she was speaking, but so much of it made sense.
I nic mi nie mówiłaś... To jest źródło, z którego się dowiaduję o Twoich problemach po paru m-cach. Nie twierdzę, że umiałabym Ci pomóc lepiej niż ta jożka, bo przecież sama nie umiałam sobie pomóc throughout my life, ale smutno mi dowiadywać się, że nie umiałaś mi powiedzieć, wiedząc, że przecież mało kto zrozumie Cię lepiej, niż ja - mamy to, niestety, w genach, sweethart. I ten wpis był tuż przed Twoim przyjazdem do Polski. Nie mam żalu, ale czemu tak to jest? Ja nie mogłam nigdy zrozumieć, dlaczego nikt z moich bliskich nie wpadł na to, żeby zapytać mnie, kiedy byłam w koszmarnym dole, co właściwie dzieje się ze mną - chodzono wokół mnie na paluszkach i raczono cup of tea, kiedy trzeba było pagawarit' pa duszam (ruskie idiomatyczne powiedzonko, nie wiem, jak przetłumaczyć; chyba: "żeby dusze porozmawiały"?)
By the way, dzwoniłam do Mariny i przyrzekłam, że na 100 % przyjeżdżamy w 2015 na białe noce (czerwiec). Powiedziała, że jest po prostu szczęśliwa, nareszcie!
Been watching this video when I need it (and her other talks) for nearly a decade now!
"What can I do about it" very good simple point instead of paying for negative actions with guilt.
Love her! Boom - so real, so straight up. Brilliant! Thank you!
Thank you Ven. Robina (and Google) for this presentation / talk video. The active, assertive tone of the speaker matches my tone for the day; and the subject matter was equally matched. Thus, it was beneficial to move quickly, candidly directly to the matter of: what is felt within you/your actions and what is you, the moment of recognition of these and where thinking "what can I do about this?" may bring you. (Now, to work on the underlying assumptions, the pace at which I can come to recognition, and the wisdom with which I decide what comes next!)
I have been listening to Robina's talks for several years now. I always get something new from the talks each time. She is wonderful! I love her style of teaching, her straight forward, no nonsense approach! Plus, her sense of humor is fantastic!
This is such a brilliant talk teeming with lots and lots of wisdom.
I listen to a lot of talks on Buddhism and THIS is by far one of the most amazing.
Clear, concise advice without the essoterical nonsense, love her.
Amazing! She is so right about many things. Her comment about depression and people thinking their situation will never end really hits the mark.
This is one of the best explanations of Buddhism and psychology I've ever heard. Brilliant.
What a fantastic talk, that is the real essence of Buddhism!
I know Robina, and she's pure gold. Very open hearted and kind. I love her dearly and love her style.
Really enjoyed this. I didn't expect to finish it, but the direct delivery and relevant and truthful statements she made just drew me in. Absolutely loved it.
Wise words. For me it worked in any case. It's good to hear talks on this subject (in a way the most important one of all) from time to time and I find the variety in style and expression among teachers refreshing.
ruthlessly authentic, witty and humorous!! thank you Ven. Robina!
this was refreshing up front talk i would love to study buddhism with a teacher like Robina Courtin
Thank you for your clarity and directness.
Great Video!
I was a very harsh speaker and people used to hate me because of my speech.
I am Hindu, one of my Buddhist friend introduced me to eight noble path and especially Right Speech.
I loved the concept so much that, I started practicing it regularly and i used the "BuDhamma" mobile app to help me on this.
Now, I speak gentle and my people are very happy with me.
Lot of things I get easily done now!
Thank you so much for delivering wonderful, informative and deep knowledge of Budhsim..
She is such a brilliant speaker; her details quenched the questions that raised in my mind while she spoke.
I come to this video every time I feel lost. Thank you for sharing this ❤️
Love this nun's talk & they way she explains things! Love how she answered the 'why have a teacher' question! More please! :)
I really enjoyed listening to her lecture. she won't make you feel like she's grandma, but she will make you listen.
The great Robina! Love her - she has changed my life.
This woman is incredible I've stumbled upon her seeking for truth and she clearly knows what she is talking about. I have watched this video already numerous times because she knows how to convey the message for those that are open minded enough to see past her manors. Wich I in particular have no problem with, infact it’s what makes her different and interesting. I on the other half listen to what she has to say and there are few out there that can say something that simple that direct without sugarcoating anything I love it. The only one time when she possibly said something wrong was when she called Sarah Palin authentic lol, but pff who cares about that. I am by no means new to Buddhism or it's concepts but she was somebody I was glad to stumble upon. There are more people out there worthy of listening to or checking out. For anybody serious about these topics go check out Sadhguru , this guy I come to have known only for a few weeks but is blowing my mind. Please fellow Buddhists , spiritual seekers or anybody willing to enhance their own life's and those of others check this Indian yogi named Sadhguru he is very very special and def not a fake guru! Peace❤
she is exceptionally beneficial and kind I am so glad to have found her ! infinite gratitude!
This is awesome! She is brilliant. Ive watched this more than once & every time I rewatch it I learn something new. Thank you Robina for sharing your wisdom!
Buddha is a very fascinating historical figure
He is only a scientist...great scientist...
This is a wonderful gift! This sister may not be your stereotype of a spiritually motivated person, but she strikes me as incredibly down-to-earth and real. This is an approach to wisdom and compassion that I can admire and desire to emulate. Namastẻ! Peace and Light!
Ever best Buddhist talk from a westerner. Truly remarkable.
What a pertinent talk !
One of the few times I hear a good explanation of spirituality.
Spirituality takes balls !
I'm very happy I watched this talk a second time. When one does it one can see beyond her "hard talk" and really get the beautiful message delivered. Which is, to quote Ven. Robina, is hidden under a layer. Thx Robina and everybody who made it possible :-)
I am amazed to listen to your courageous speech of truth. I feel that you don’t have any fear or restriction in your expressions. I am amazed 🙂👍.
Great great great teacher RobinaCourtin
She throws out so many brilliant concepts so fast! I love her so much!
we are here to learn and teach each other no matter who and what we are tag as.
@Seikisho
I completely agree with you. She's not trying to give off that "mystical" aura that others give off. She's relatable and approachable. I really appreciate the way she teaches and her sense of humor. She's an excellent teacher.
What a razor-sharp and analytical mind! But from the questions and comments, I still applaud what J Krishnarmurti said " Truth is a pathless land" and what in a reverse direction, what nowadays sage Tom Campbell said "Truth has numerous paths". We are always stuck with physical appearances and boxes, categorizations, hence most heinous wars are fought along these religions and idealism. We at the Aquarian Age should wake up now! And focus on what these sages are saying: the potentials, the humanity and the Evolution. There are levels of evolution but no hierarchies. Get rid of our shackles, ID and boxes and Cheers to evolution. LOL, LOL, LOL from LOL ( Lots of love, lots of laughs and lots of learning from this Little Old Lady)
I actually like the way she talks. It's interesting and it seems real and personable.
This woman is amazing! So down to earth and really makes good sense of the questions raised...take it or leave it :)
Great message to high learning
Wonderful clarity, thank you so much!
This is an amazing talk. The woman has a personality do not mistake that for anger. This talk has helped me immensly. As someone who has done bucket loads of therapy this is the appropriate wake up call - it is time to be your own therapist, you have to do it in the end no one else but you can make you happy, still your mind....think I'll watch it again!!
So much great info here ... enjoyed Q&A section the most!
Robina has a beautiful clear way of speaking it as it IS.
The concept that 'All thought is creative' was highlighted MOST effectively ... EVERYTHING starts & ends in our mind ... the hidden patterns behind neurotic delusions causing our pain/fear/anger... and that our thoughts are locked into the feeling level of our awareness ~ luv it!
I notice Separation Trauma (experienced at birth) is a powerful hidden element behind much suffering.
Bring the pure mind to everything you do - including your job.
This talk really works for me on many levels, and I lived in a Buddhist community for many years. Many of these precepts work and I have taken them with me as part of my life-long quest for truth and peace.
A few things however do not add up. She touches on the "how" of Buddhism but not the "why". Buddhism believes that the conditions of our suffering are all tied to karma (cause and effect), which is easy to understand, except they believe in past lives which means we are suffering the effects of past misdeeds. In other words, if you are attacked, raped, disfigured, or victimized in any way in this life, then it's likely because of a past misdeed in a previous live that has "ripened". Their view of why good and bad things happen is very old world and in my opinion the karmic explanation is just another cop out from dealing with the fact that reality is capable of producing loveliness or harshness and often it is for no meaningful reason -- certainly not anything YOU did.
The other thing is that pre-modern Buddhists explained thinks like physical deformities, autism, and basically any mental disability that prevents functional human interaction as a "lesser birth". This is because such individuals cannot receive the teachings of Dharma and the Buddha. It's true that a lot of our suffering is because of delusion, but there are some true cases where people are born different, or biochemical imbalances which cause their inability to maintain happiness. Schizophrenics, for example. In these cases, Buddhism's approach to their suffering might be frustrating because it implies that the solution is merely about debunking neuroses, when really there might be in-born problems that can't be debunked with mere analysis.
Buddhism is NOT totally equivalent to the modern scientific method because they believe in things which cannot be empirically proven. Tibetan Buddhism in particular is a product of Indian Buddhism merged with local deity worship, so in any Tibetan temple you will see statues to all manner of entities. They are also into 'empowerment' ceremonies where you invoke these deities into you, which IMO is just adding more layers of delusion and not getting to core mind. They also believe in reincarnation, the wheel of life (i.e. when your karma is bad you come back with a lesser birth, like an animal, and if your karma is really good, you might come back as a demi-God), and there is a lot of pomp surrounding lineage rituals and proper ceremonies which again I do not believe really get to core mind.
So, I have to disagree that Tibetan Buddhism (which the speaker practices) is free of contradictions. It has many of them, which is why Buddhism is a religion and not a pure science. But as she said, do what works for you. I took a great deal of useful wisdom away from my experiences with the Buddhists, and tossed the rest. IMO Zen Buddhism makes a lot more sense. It's no frills and doesn't have the Tibetan cultural hangups attached to it. If you stick just to the "how" and not the "why", Buddhism will make a lot of sense to you. For me it was not a complete system and I had to continue my search.
Your giving very valid points...but all you are giving for Buddhism..a religion..may it tibetian,Indian, Japanese.....
Buddha never set a religion.
He never claim to be god.
He never asked to be workshiped..
So Buddha's Teaching are pure Scientific based...
And Buddhism is a DISTORTION of his teaching..as religion...
See Buddha's as Buddha ...a scientist..
He topic of research was to end of human Suffering...
Buddha's only teaches four Truth..
1)ABOUT the suffering
2)Cause of suffering
3)yes Suffering can be removed
4)The method...eight Fold path
Rest is distortion...
Buddha stated...
Don't believe Anybody not Me...walk ,experiment on the Eightfold path...if it met with your wisdom accept it...if not reject it...
I've seen this video so many times that I know most parts by heart. It changed my life enormously and shaped my views, starting from my view of myself. Love it
this lady is the real deal... she is "there"
I am so glad to have watched this.
It's always very enjoyable to listen to that woman :)
amazing,talk about mind. thanking your Venerable Robina.
Incredibly good talk. Something like this should be incorporated into our education systems.
I found this speaker to speak so much common sense and it is very obvious she is a very well read person, I want to listen to some more!
Best talk ever! (So far.)
Brillant in her clarity and humor on this complex concept
Wonderful woman ! So amazing, interesting how we blame others for own self-centredness….this has really opened my eyes to how I can be more caring to others….thank you from me and everyone I meet….😅
Namaste.
Judi Grace StoryCorps.
Thank you for sharing, Ye shall know the truth when it is spoken! I think you are awesome1
"Wish for Truth" ....as she said ...
Resonates deeply with me.
This woman is outstanding. It's a very different approach than many of other teachers that say "be present, be happy". To my opinion, that's a very nihilistic point of view. What this woman here says is that the road is bumpy, is not nice to look at your self, but take responsibility. This point of view comes from the will of discipline and inner work. This is the balance to the other approach that says "sit, watch, observe and do nothing". The equilibrium is the wisdom of knowing them both.
Loved it. Her speech is so precise and logical.
Yes, it's amazing that we can make such a difference by choosing peace for a few minutes. Just imagine what would happen if feeling peace became our top priority.
Yes, it has changed mine too. I had been searching for it all my life and it offers the most profound peace.
Thank you for your inspiration and this amazing talk!
Metta, Martin
Different teachers have different styles of teaching. And that applies to different tradition too. If you look at Zen Buddhism, even though the teaching is the same, their approach can be quite different.
So, it's a task for everyone to seek out their teacher. Ven. Robina teaching method is fairly direct and is challenging one's ego directly.
What an excellent talk..what buddhism is truly about!
thanks for kind speech
I just love this woman !
Also, I feel she answered the last question, not with contempt but with compassion, selflessness and truth. She is very articulate and speaks with conviction which should not be mistaken as anger or the sort.
So agree with you! It was refreshing to see her approach to buddhism. Reinforces why I love Buddhism so much, because of how flexible the practice is.:)
i dont think ive gathered more wisdom in 1 hour before this video.
she's a smart lady. and i love the way she talks fast and has effortless humour haha.
so much stuff there that I have known for so long, good to hear it expurgated so intelligently, eruditely
No, we do not necessarily suffer when we receive things, you are correct. But, the main point is that all negative emotions (anger, jealousy, depression) have an overwhelming sense of "I" or "mine" involved in them. Therefore it is this sense of "I", the ego, that is the source of all these emotional problems. So if you give and receive things with out ego and w/o expectations, you will be genuinely happy. The ego is the enemy, not any external phenomena. This is true realization.
Wonderful! I am in love with Robina. What a wonderful, honest, fearless woman.
Thank you for posting this lovely speech. I have learned again what is necessary.
Thank you, I enjoy your talk a lot and learn some more:)
Sounds like Buddha was a good student of Albert Ellis, founder of rational emotive cognitive behavioral therapy. Anyway. Their approaches seems to dovetail very nicely. (On the other hand, Albert Ellis said himself that CBT wasn't something he created at all but derived directly from a few ancient Greek thinkers.) Thanks for this outstanding discussion.
"Sounds like Buddha was a good student of Albert Ellis" LOL. Do you know when Buddha was born?
+Charles W Buddha was born 500 years BC.
This girl is smart, huge respect.
This video is so powerful and made me look at my life as a whole. I feel empowered!!!!!!
ha ha ha somehow i managed to listen to her all the way thru...although at times i felt like she was being a little abrupt...overall i think it is a good talk...very lively...
I'm very impressed by this video. This woman is extremely smart and talented.
It is true the sense of I is at the core of our suffering. It is the grasping (Upadana)of the I and I related phenomena that creates dis ease.The total freedom comes from letting go, but this isn't suppression or annihilation.Until things cease, if we can develop a space around things through mindfulness and abide there, instead of grasping and becoming we are at peace.The desire to get more and more can be enslaving and doing things free of self, bring peace. Keep letting go if it feels good.
She's awesome.
real natural talk with real meaning
Brillant!
I'm smiling at your comment because I was almost clenching my fists when she would call people "sweetheart", "darling", "honey", etc. I find these terms directed at strangers to be very offensive, as if one is talking down to someone. Now, I have to check myself. I think she´s brilliant.
Those were common words of warmth and terms of endearment coming from parents, Aunties and uncles etc in the part of Australia where I grew up in the 90s. I had to learn to shed them (for a male, they can now be problematic at work, with strangers etc), but yeah to me it makes her sound a like family/a mates mum.
thanks for ur teaching. it's really awsome teaching keep going.
Thank you for this Amazing Video