Perhaps the greatest and most beautiful song ever written about a broken heart and the unplugged version he sang perhaps the greatest live version of any song ever sung. Absolutely raw emotion and so so beautiful. This song always hits home and will always have a special place in my heart despite how incredibly sad it is but that's life and he let it all out and I just imagine so many people he reached from this song and helped let out all the pain as well.
Hands down it's the greatest love/breakup song of all time. From the music, the passion and emotion Eddie puts into it, to the lyrics cause those lyrics are not just pure art but absolutely brilliant.
@@sydpiris lol you've posted this on more than one comment. You aren't making us aware of some profound fact, we all know bud. Doesn't change the fact that he shows his powerful emotions.
Spencer Grady I was high while writing those commends more than once and yeah ofc he s got some emotions going on but I couldnt stop myself from seeing and sharing that how much high he looks :D
Esse vídeo deveria ser patrimônio da humanidade, uma das mais belas canções que eu tive o prazer de ouvir na vida. Obrigado, Pearl Jam! OBRIGADO, EDDIE!
If you find yourself listening to this in a loop... remember that everything will be okay. It may not look like that now, but it will be. Thank you Eddie for sharing this song to us.
@@loyduncan3728but it means, that you are not belonging to each other and you are not compatible. Just stop this and start something new. Don’t hurt your self and other person. Don’t stop in finding love
You can really hear the pain and the emotion in his voice when he sings Black live. Especially at the end. This song speaks to me and anyone else to lost someone they truly loved
This song goes through all the states of grief, of any grief, that is why we identify so much and we make catharsis again and again beautifully and powerfully. Saludos desde Argentina, bien al Sur 💜
Black... Uma linda e triste canção, para aqueles que tem o coração tatuado por alguém que ficará apenas nas lembranças. Obra prima do rock. Vou morrer escutando essa música.
I lost the love of my life to pancreatic cancer last November 13. She was my best friend my soulmate😢 and the mother of our only child, and I will never get over losing her and this song is heartbreaking and I listen to it repeatedly because it reminds me of just how much we were in love not just with each other but with the love of the life we had with our family. A truly heartfelt song for me. Keep on Rocking the world Eddie my friend.
The most heart breaking part of this song and gets me every time 😥 I know someday you'll have a beautiful life I know you'll be a star In somebody else's sky But why Why Why can't it be Why can't it be mine
Rick Grimes that was just a Vedder thing with his eyes. He does that quite often in a lot of his songs. Sometimes he only shows the whites of his eyes, he’s a man possessed by the depth of his talent.
Creio que essa seja uma das maiores apresentações que um palco já recebeu em todos os tempos. Os caras deixaram tudo de si ali, a gente assiste mil vezes e parece que é a primeira.
Eddie Vedder - one of the most beautiful men to ever live. Just sheer unparalleled beauty and talent. This is the ultimate heartbreak song. So many fans can't listen to the last two minutes without breaking down in tears. Just have no words for the ending...
Gawd I LOVED him...my favorite tee shirt sophomore year said "Mrs Eddie Vedder" 🤣🤣🤣 my dad HATED it 🤦...he was way too old for me but I would have runaway with him in a heartbeat lol.
+Sixcocheal Yeah but in the studio everyone plays their part separately and you get an infinite number of chances to get it the best you possibly can...Considering that, this live performance is unworldly!
+surgeyX It's called having talent. To be honest, most modern artists build up such high expectations in their album versions, and when you hear them live, they're shit. Most bands I like are completely raw, identical live and in their studio versions.
This is it, this is the passion and the genius required to be a star. This blows me away every single time. It’s like an out of body experience for me. Eddie Vedder is the best ever.
I can't stop with this version, I feel my heart and all myself turn into black, just wanna cry, and this song make me tears all drop away, thanks Eddie 4 one of the most beautyfull song ❤
3:46 - 4:12 is the most painful yet beautiful moment, the lyrics, the way that eddie stared and how eddie remove his hand from his chest, the emotion and the melody of the song are fits perfectly!
This particular performance, especially at 4:32 through the end, destroys me every time. So powerful and beautiful. I've been listening for Pearl Jam since '91 and there's just nothing like it. It's not even that I feel "sad", even though it could be called a sad song - I just feel moved by it. I don't stand a chance and I love it.
Eu te amo sabia disso não aguento mais estou Suando às mão trem o hospital clínica seåra é vc acho que este sentimento acho e verdadeiro fico aqui pensando como e relevante nação brasileira nós somos a irarquia tá todas pessoas no vive dizendo pra onde iremos fazer meu trabalho é combinado então galera curtir muito bom falar aqui não tem amizade preciso que minha receber informaçr tá bom beijo negocinho depilação tem estralan vou ganhar dinheiro pra pagar as contas reciclado meu irmão faleceu então não vamos reciclar maus hoje um mês fica olhando das CMF eu não tenho sonho estudar trabalho e ajudar os filho gêmeos trabalho filha sem trabalhar e o outro também muitas felicidades pra vocês também muitas o vai arrumar tá bom para caramba trave e está cansado de ficar quieta 5 terapia humana vcs estão achando que eu não tenho dinheiro pra pagar o banco mercantil eu recebi lá na conta do Abreu kkkk tudo vai se encaixar e ela sim que bom que eu iria fazer isso as vezes hospital clínica seåra Indaiatuba 5 tenho fé em deus que iremos aucansar os objetivos alcansar muito bem garoto vai descansar consigo só uma endireita de Lisboa e ela está estralando kkk doído fica com Deus lpas amor ,.
É um som de perda/perca, independente da situação a qual você passe, não se entregue, ouça o som com sabedoria de entender o 'porquê' da situação, não use drogas, não tire sua vida, Deus te ama. Amanhã você vai ouvir esse som brilhante e recordar de tudo, e vai ser uma sensação boa.
Gente, sério mesmo! Essa música não é desse mundo! EU nunca ouvi outra música nessa nível. que consegue tirar de mim e taaantas pessoas, tantos sentimentos ao mesmo tempo, é SURREAL o poder dela!!! Consegue chegar no mais profundo, bem lá no íntimo de quem a escuta e mexe bastante. E Quando ele canta, JUSUUUUUUS! O que é isso? A gente consegue sentir exatamente o que ele tá cantando/ sentindo. E visceral mano!
A música da minha vida! E que interpretação hein? O cara vira a própria música. Da pra sentir daqui oq ele sente. Toca na alma! Simplesmente sensacional!!! Sem palavras.
Hey, oh Sheets of empty canvas Untouched sheets of clay Were laid spread out before me As her body once did All five horizons Revolved around her soul As the earth to the sun Now the air I tasted and breathed Has taken a turn Oh and all I taught her was everything Oh I know she gave me all that she wore And now my bitter hands Chafe beneath the clouds Of what was everything Oh the pictures have All been washed in black Tattooed everything I take a walk outside I'm surrounded by Some kids at play I can feel their laughter So why do I sear Oh, and twisted thoughts that spin Round my head I'm spinning Oh, I'm spinning How quick the sun can, drop away And now my bitter hands Cradle broken glass Of what was everything All the pictures had All been washed in black Tattooed everything All the love gone bad Turned my world to black Tattooed all I see All that I am All I'll be Yeah I know someday you'll have a beautiful life I know you'll be a star In somebody else's sky But why Why Why can't it be Why can't it be mine
Watch at 2:00 how his buddy checks if Eddy doesn´t break...this song comes from the deepest soul and is by far the best performance of Black and maybe one of the best live pop performances ever. I dare to say.
Jerry and Gavin are not Grunge gods, it's insulting to me for you to put them in their category. 1. Chris Cornell 2. Layne Staley 3. Eddie Vedder 4. Scott Weiland There ya go! Kurt was not on any of these guys level either, enough said.
I'm 60 so I'm really wondering that myself. Just found out I'm a grunge freak. I had a baby in 91 and missed Eddie Vedder until "Into the Wild". It's been a wild, wonderful trip watching the whole band grow from crazy-ass dancing, head-banging boys into good looking men. Their talent has only increased.
When you find it, let me know, I'll come search in your direction as well! OMG, I still find him the most handsome man that ever lived... and that voice... Nowadays I appreciate PJ's music so much more than I did back then, when I could only stare at Eddie... OK, I admit, I still stare at Eddie....
mark richards ha i can relate bro, turnjng 50 this year.. this feels like yesterday time flies... take care do al, u can nkw travel time with family friends hobbjes, jesus , hobbies etc etc
A música em si já é foda ,ai vem o fator ao vivo,interprete se emocionando ,banda botando pra fuder fica difícil se conter diante desta obra prima !!! Perfeição total !!!
Se o próprio vocalista se emociona cantando, tu acha mesmo que eu não vou chorar escutando essa obra de arte da minha tristeza? kkkkkkkkkkkkkkk claro que vou :/ #feels
i feel this is the only live version of black that almost captures the true emotion of the studio recording. most of the other live versions i've seen can't even come close to replicating the power of the original.
+Sam Ace Rothstein Agreed. I prefer this to the original. I was 18 when Ten came out. I always preferred Alice In Chains but, this song always called to me.
Stevesk0011 the unplugged version is definitely up there too. that was a great performance. Hampton AZ same here, i usually prefer alice in chains myself, but they really outdid themselves with ten.
Eu fiz uma promessa, deixei meu cabelo crescer e que nunca mais ia cortar, hj tá igual ao do Eddie de 1992, Rock sempre será meu estilo! Me identifico com ele desde pequeno, rapaz... que foda!!!
Not perhaps: it is the greatest performance of rock history of all time. Wedder's face at the top of the ecstasy is like the angeles' on Leonardo's paintings. Noting is greates in this genre. Thank you boys. I never cease to get back to it.
Anyone notice how at 2:09 the guitarist (forget the mans name) is starting at Eddie because he knows how emotional this is for him. Shows how close the band was
Yes, and Eddie put his thumbs up to sign he's ok. Such real emotions and passion!! The best song ever, my favorite is MTV unplugged version of course!! 😊✌️🤘❤️
Peggy Miller You must be deaf he h Ad no body and was gross still is The Ledgendary British band Def Leppard front man Joe Elliot was and still is gorgeous and granted they are a very different band they were unbelievable and very young when they started this song is very annoying the Grunge era was horrible style and clothes
There’s not many songs that are sang on pure emotion. Listen to Eddie at 4.34 man, jeez you feel it. I played this song on loop when going through divorce. Felt like Eddie was singing for me and all the words I wanted to say. Grunge saved me in that part of my life.
Sheets of empty canvas, untouched sheets of clay Were laid spread out before me as her body once did. All five horizons revolved around her soul as the earth to the sun Now the air I tasted and breathed has taken a turn Ooh, and all I taught her was everything Ooh, I know she gave me all that she wore And now my bitter hands chafe beneath the clouds of what was everything. Oh, the pictures have all been washed in black, tattooed everything... I take a walk outside, I'm surrounded by some kids at play I can feel their laughter, so why do I sear? Oh, and twisted thoughts that spin round my head, I'm spinning, oh, I'm spinning, how quick the sun can drop away And now my bitter hands cradle broken glass of what was everything All the pictures have all been washed in black, tattooed everything... All the love gone bad turned my world to black Tattooed all I see, all that I am, all I'll be... yeah... Uh huh... uh huh... ooh... I know someday you'll have a beautiful life, I know you'll be a star in somebody else's sky, But why, why, why can't it be, can't it be mine? Aah... uuh.. Too doo doo too, too doo doo
I cannot believe this was recorded 28yrs ago....aside from the two combat tours I spent in Iraq, the years since 1992 have sped by so fast they're just a blur....now, after having just turned 46yrs old, I wish I would've taken the time to slow down and enjoy life much more than I did.....
Cada vez que la escucho y veo su interpretacion, me enamoro, esta cancion llega al alma, quien cuando joven no se sintio asi, da nostalgia, y te dan ganas de botar toda la tristeza que sientes en esos momentos, te lleva a otros tiempos.. y si la puedo escuchar 10 veces al dia y aun asi, siento lo mismo al escucharlo y eso me enamora de la interpretacion y de su sentir.
I was 12 years old. The only teenager in my JHS wearing a Pearl Jam t-shirt that I got from one of my older brothers. Meh! I thought I was the coolest kid... what am I saying. I was!!! I had the hugest crush on Eddie... that hair!!! I still do!
Nunca había escuchado este concierto, como suena esta gran banda, esa guitarra esa batería, el bajo y por supuesto el gran Eddie Vedder que sentimiento por Dios!!!! El temazo black para mi pasa a la historia de la música como obra de arte
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
Pearl Jam at its peak. Eddie's voice, the rawness of the band, the drummer, Vedder's looks, the gig, the crowd. This is beyond music, this theatre...
Amen!!
"this theatre"
I totally agree eh 👍
"theatre"... that word might be a bit too theatrical
I was 4 in 92 but I sure do wish I could've attended this. It's beautiful.
Perhaps the greatest and most beautiful song ever written about a broken heart and the unplugged version he sang perhaps the greatest live version of any song ever sung. Absolutely raw emotion and so so beautiful. This song always hits home and will always have a special place in my heart despite how incredibly sad it is but that's life and he let it all out and I just imagine so many people he reached from this song and helped let out all the pain as well.
Aggred but Eddie fucks up the lyrics in the MTV unplugged version. Therefore I never liked it that much. But still…
No question bout it!!!🤟🤟🤟
Well Said
Emotion, put in to music. It immortalized his pain, but allows us all to feel something, forever.
Hands down it's the greatest love/breakup song of all time. From the music, the passion and emotion Eddie puts into it, to the lyrics cause those lyrics are not just pure art but absolutely brilliant.
If this song means nothing to you, you’re really lucky !
Facts lol
Yujiro Hanma well said
or not
Ikr!
Oh yesss.....
Sadly humans no longer make this kind of music. Good thing we have these videos.
You must not be looking too hard
@@elijahcourtney9901yeah, these kinds of comments always make me somewhat upset
check Klone band
They do, they're just not 'popular' these days. Keep looking.
you should listen to ants from up there from the band black country, new road!
One of the greatest live performances of all time.
One of hell.....THE GREATEST PWRIOD!!!!
Agreed, and I'm not the biggest of Pearl Jam fans. It's absolutely fantastic!
Воистину
Muy de acuerdo, eso si es sentimiento al cantar
Have you watched all live permormances?
Drumming and smoking like a boss
Fifi Fornow ... Like a boss... Facts...
This is true rock
Like a boss is so 2017.......that’s a rocker.
Nick Buakaew Its 2012 actually
drank himself out of a job lol
You can clearly see him visualizing the moments, memories and pain.....wow this song is SO Powerful!!
aaaand he is high...
@@sydpiris and?
And so much emotion 🥰
@@sydpiris lol you've posted this on more than one comment. You aren't making us aware of some profound fact, we all know bud. Doesn't change the fact that he shows his powerful emotions.
Spencer Grady I was high while writing those commends more than once and yeah ofc he s got some emotions going on but I couldnt stop myself from seeing and sharing that how much high he looks :D
I was there !....best gig i've ever been and shall be ! 🤘That song still rips my heart open everytime !
Lucky! And yeah, me too
@@piratejen77 I saw them a little over a month earlier. Day on the Hill at KU
@@piratejen77 ...It should, or the love wasn't real ❤🩹
@@ericschneider4976 I STILL haven’t seen them 😭 I’m jealous
@@johnadams3365 so true
This is the most intensely passionate and sad song,I cry every time I hear it
Same. I don’t think I’ve ever not cried listening to this version.
@@catherinemotl7156 same here
This kills me…
“I know someday you'll have a beautiful life
I know you'll be a star
In somebody else's sky”
Me too 😔
Same
how i feel, my husband loved this song, he passed recently, covid, tears
Stay strong 🙌❤️
All my Condolences bro.. she is in Heaven watching you from there
I'm so sorry
@@ThalesBernardo1996 its the other way around dude. The husband died.
I am sorry 😞
Esse vídeo deveria ser patrimônio da humanidade, uma das mais belas canções que eu tive o prazer de ouvir na vida. Obrigado, Pearl Jam! OBRIGADO, EDDIE!
Concordo, uma performance épica!
Isso é MÚSICA!!
Amo
todo dia eu tenho que ver esse vídeo, é uma terapia
Amo e não canso de ouvir❤
If you find yourself listening to this in a loop... remember that everything will be okay. It may not look like that now, but it will be.
Thank you Eddie for sharing this song to us.
Thank you for this comment
Sometimes not, Gabriel. Well, maybe for guys. Sometimes you can spend years trying to put that crushed heart together and it just won't fix.
thanks for that
@@loyduncan3728but it means, that you are not belonging to each other and you are not compatible. Just stop this and start something new. Don’t hurt your self and other person. Don’t stop in finding love
❤idem ❤ Gracias ❤ 🇦🇷 tatuado angel en mi mano ❤
I want to thank the girl who broke his heart for this song!
i think its about her moving away
@Jesus Hong i read something about it being about eddies first true love and her family had to move away.
Lucky her! 😍🥰
@@weeeeoooow lucky you , hi
I think he might have actually broken her heart. That’s what it appears to me. That he screwed up. He knows it and regrets it and she moved on.
Hands down the best breakup song ever.
Angie. Nuff said ...
I suppose if your the one being broken up with then yeah 😅
A different take on the legendary outro: ruclips.net/video/hByLb_W_y7Y/видео.html
You can really hear the pain and the emotion in his voice when he sings Black live. Especially at the end. This song speaks to me and anyone else to lost someone they truly loved
Agree, that's art, turn the pain in a masterpiece
This song goes through all the states of grief, of any grief, that is why we identify so much and we make catharsis again and again beautifully and powerfully.
Saludos desde Argentina, bien al Sur 💜
Alternate rock. Alternative rock. The 90s. What a time to be growing up.
Eddie Vedder wrote this song about an ex girlfriend.. he will often cry while performing this song. How beautiful.
I'm pretty sure Gossard wrote the lyrics but the beauty is in it's universality. We all live it., even Eddy
@@enorbet2 no Eddie Vedder wrote all the lyrics on ten including black. Stone Gossard wrote the music for black.
Which girlfriend? Does anyone know?
Which girlfriend? Does anyone know?
@@Josh-cw8by how do u know
Black... Uma linda e triste canção, para aqueles que tem o coração tatuado por alguém que ficará apenas nas lembranças. Obra prima do rock. Vou morrer escutando essa música.
Menina !! eu tirei um print dessa teu pensamento; Bateu na minha alma , é o que estou passando . . . Dói demais !!!!!
Uma verdadeira obra prima. Ouço todos os dias.
@@cacasantos123 Eu também amo demais essa música, a sensação é como se eu ouvisse pela primeira vez
Minha música favorita desde sempre!! Pena que agora eu me identifico com ela kkkkkk
@@gustavoteisen É amigo nós nos identificamos com essa música 💕 Ele diz tudo sobre mim...
This right here is the best version of this song
JahJah agreeed
Pearl Jam performing "Black" from their 1992 MTV Unplugged concert in New York City is better.
@@kimeiriklarsen7499 I agree Kim. Way better.
@@lilflower25 It's actually one of my favorite live recordings ever. Just incredible performance, especially by Eddie.
@@kimeiriklarsen7499 Mine too Kim. Beyond awesomeness.
2025!! This sounds as epic as the day it was made! August 27th 1991 ..! Who is still with me…!
One of the greatest rock songs of all time in my opinion.
One of the greatest songs period.
Alguém mais em março de 2021, curtindo esse som maravilhoso?!!
opa
@@space...cowboy hehehe
Opa
Opa!!!
Casa CMG!
The depth and beauty of this man in this performance are overpowering.
Agreed! 👏👌
I lost the love of my life to pancreatic cancer last November 13. She was my best friend my soulmate😢 and the mother of our only child, and I will never get over losing her and this song is heartbreaking and I listen to it repeatedly because it reminds me of just how much we were in love not just with each other but with the love of the life we had with our family. A truly heartfelt song for me. Keep on Rocking the world Eddie my friend.
Esta canção e interpretação é das melhores de Pearl Jam❤❤
U keep going as well with the same energy it took to express that!
So very sorry😢
Deepest sympathies to you... She is still with you, just on a different plane no longer in pain...
'I Want to Eat Your Pancreas', watch it.
The most heart breaking part of this song and gets me every time 😥
I know someday you'll have a beautiful life
I know you'll be a star
In somebody else's sky
But why
Why
Why can't it be
Why can't it be mine
I hear you...it kills me.
Love it too❤
*WHHHHYYYYYYYYYY* 💛
That keyboard kills me more it's perfect
It is perfect...
4:21 you can litrerally see him holding back tears
I know for sure I'm not holding mine
Rick Grimes that was just a Vedder thing with his eyes. He does that quite often in a lot of his songs. Sometimes he only shows the whites of his eyes, he’s a man possessed by the depth of his talent.
I'm alone in my room. Crying my heart out.
You can also see the guitarist walking up an making sure he,s ok,if this doesn’t move u yer not human!
@@rivertrubia2710 you're definitely reaching
Creio que essa seja uma das maiores apresentações que um palco já recebeu em todos os tempos. Os caras deixaram tudo de si ali, a gente assiste mil vezes e parece que é a primeira.
É ótima,só perde para queen no rock in rio 😉
Todos os brasileiros de excelente gosto em 2020
🙋
eu
🙋♀️
Show!
Essa música é um hino vey
this is literally the best version of this song. his intensity is just clear. nothing beats this.
Eddie Vedder - one of the most beautiful men to ever live. Just sheer unparalleled beauty and talent. This is the ultimate heartbreak song. So many fans can't listen to the last two minutes without breaking down in tears. Just have no words for the ending...
He really was gorgeous as a younger guy. He keeps himself in good shape still. I wish he would grow back his hair again😁
Gawd I LOVED him...my favorite tee shirt sophomore year said "Mrs Eddie Vedder" 🤣🤣🤣 my dad HATED it 🤦...he was way too old for me but I would have runaway with him in a heartbeat lol.
Más que hermoso, me enamoré de él desde la primera vez que lo vi de niña 😍🖤
This song and version really helps with my depression. I could play it 100x in a row
Stay strong homie
I've had it on repeat for the last few months 😢
Hang in there friend. There's always light at the end of the tunnel.
for me too, music helps me so much. how are you doing now?
are you sure it is 'helping' - i mean the question with the best of intentions and best wishes for you.
How the fuck does this sound so good? This sounds better than the fucking album version...
+surgeyX most of Peral Jam's music sounds better live rather then studio. At least in my opinion.
+surgeyX Absolutely
+Sixcocheal
Yeah but in the studio everyone plays their part separately and you get an infinite number of chances to get it the best you possibly can...Considering that, this live performance is unworldly!
+surgeyX It's called having talent. To be honest, most modern artists build up such high expectations in their album versions, and when you hear them live, they're shit. Most bands I like are completely raw, identical live and in their studio versions.
I didn't really become a huge Pearl Jam fan and appreciate them until I saw them live. Their energy and performances are amazing live.
This is it, this is the passion and the genius required to be a star. This blows me away every single time. It’s like an out of body experience for me. Eddie Vedder is the best ever.
But why cant it be mine?
I already watched this like 10000 times , it never gets boring
Me too!
I can't stop with this version, I feel my heart and all myself turn into black, just wanna cry, and this song make me tears all drop away, thanks Eddie 4 one of the most beautyfull song ❤
2020 e eu aqui, curtindo uma música de verdade !!
... é nooois
Tamo junto
ok boomer
Somos nós 👏👏
*Idem*
Quando queremos aumentar o volume e não tem mais.😭
Isso...rasga minha alma 💔❤😔😭
Turn Down For What - Deal with it muito bem kkkkkk
Falou tudo !
verdade 👍🏼✌🏼🤟🏻🙌🏻
Um hino desse merece ser escultado no último volume 🤘
Eddie's gaze during "I know someday you'll have a beautiful life..." really shows the emotion behind this song. Ugh.
I’m 59yo now and this song still does something to me. I hope it always will!
The fact he didn’t want this song to be as popular as it became and still did for the fans despite it being very personal is amazing
3:46 - 4:12 is the most painful yet beautiful moment, the lyrics, the way that eddie stared and how eddie remove his hand from his chest, the emotion and the melody of the song are fits perfectly!
Aqui, em 2021, matando a saudade de música de qualidade.
de qualidade e de verdade !
WE LOVE YOU PEARL JAM
This particular performance, especially at 4:32 through the end, destroys me every time. So powerful and beautiful. I've been listening for Pearl Jam since '91 and there's just nothing like it. It's not even that I feel "sad", even though it could be called a sad song - I just feel moved by it. I don't stand a chance and I love it.
2019!!! Alguém além de me.
Oi
✌✋
2020
Eu sempre
Pra sempre...
Alguém aqui já escutou essa musica pela milésima vez e ainda continua escutando? kkkkk
Eu....
Música boa não se enjoa
Sempreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
EU NA VIDA
e sem enjoar? facil !!
Best version of this song.....the emotion is almost too much to handle
I think the best version is MTV Unplugged but to each their own
Boa 2tardemusica para vcs TBM não eu não acabou só restou emoção fala verdade e linda chance 2
Eu te amo sabia disso não aguento mais estou Suando às mão trem o hospital clínica seåra é vc acho que este sentimento acho e verdadeiro fico aqui pensando como e relevante nação brasileira nós somos a irarquia tá todas pessoas no vive dizendo pra onde iremos fazer meu trabalho é combinado então galera curtir muito bom falar aqui não tem amizade preciso que minha receber informaçr tá bom beijo negocinho depilação tem estralan vou ganhar dinheiro pra pagar as contas reciclado meu irmão faleceu então não vamos reciclar maus hoje um mês fica olhando das CMF eu não tenho sonho estudar trabalho e ajudar os filho gêmeos trabalho filha sem trabalhar e o outro também muitas felicidades pra vocês também muitas o vai arrumar tá bom para caramba trave e está cansado de ficar quieta 5 terapia humana vcs estão achando que eu não tenho dinheiro pra pagar o banco mercantil eu recebi lá na conta do Abreu kkkk tudo vai se encaixar e ela sim que bom que eu iria fazer isso as vezes hospital clínica seåra Indaiatuba 5 tenho fé em deus que iremos aucansar os objetivos alcansar muito bem garoto vai descansar consigo só uma endireita de Lisboa e ela está estralando kkk doído fica com Deus lpas amor
,.
I think that MTV's is The Best One 2.
Idk how anyone could listen and not feel it. Before the days of autotune
Who's still here on 2024?! ❤❤❤
I'll listen to this as long as i'm alive ❤
First time listening to this specific performance
Me
Am still listening. So heartbreaking❤
👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽 🇧🇷
Can you feel his pain in this song?
oh yeah
I can feel his pain as well as my pain...fuck
Yea
Елизавета Деркач I can feel his pain because like Eddie I lost my wife who I loved thank God we have 2 kids but don't have her. That's life u know
I’m there with you guys , I’m there with you ....
Será que o Eddie tem consciência que a gente tem mini-infartos assistindo esse vídeo?
musica linda acalma todo mundo...
Kkkkkkkk exatamente
Bem isso mesmo
Eu acho quê tem viu, mano as expressões dele nesse vídeo mostrar o quanto ele cantou com a alma. Arrepiante.
Ele sabe sim!!!
É um som de perda/perca, independente da situação a qual você passe, não se entregue, ouça o som com sabedoria de entender o 'porquê' da situação, não use drogas, não tire sua vida, Deus te ama. Amanhã você vai ouvir esse som brilhante e recordar de tudo, e vai ser uma sensação boa.
É verdade! 😔
Foda irmão
Assim Seja!
Me fez chorar 🥹
Tô contigo, cara. É isso aí.
Gente, sério mesmo!
Essa música não é desse mundo! EU nunca ouvi outra música nessa nível. que consegue tirar de mim e taaantas pessoas, tantos sentimentos ao mesmo tempo, é SURREAL o poder dela!!!
Consegue chegar no mais profundo, bem lá no íntimo de quem a escuta e mexe bastante.
E Quando ele canta, JUSUUUUUUS! O que é isso? A gente consegue sentir exatamente o que ele tá cantando/ sentindo. E visceral mano!
Pra quem é novinho essa Banda de rock, foi por diversas vezes eleita a melhor Banda de Rock do Mundo...
essa é a melhor banda de rock de todos os tempos.
Deveria ser de TODOS os tempos...
Pink Floyd mandou abraços
Pink floyd eh considerada a melhor banda de rock que ja existiu nessa terr
@@mariaantoniadalvino2189 acho q depende mt,tem bandas melhores e até mais importantes q Pink Floyd
Who would break his heart in first place? This man is so handsome, sensible, talented, deep, he has the voice of an angel, he's just so perfect omg.
He’s an alcoholic so she left
Took me 30 years to see the pain in his face from about 3:00 to 3:45 . Crazy when younger, I missed it.
Melissa vc é linda magnifica maravilhosa uma bela mulher ta de parabéns perfeita 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😍😍😍😍😍
I love him
She probably drive him to drink
That hair!!!!!!!! And those beautiful hands. He was gorgeous.
He was he still Is 🥰🥰🥰🥰
Gemma Benitez agreed
Beautiful hands hahah, u got me with this one
A música da minha vida! E que interpretação hein? O cara vira a própria música. Da pra sentir daqui oq ele sente. Toca na alma! Simplesmente sensacional!!!
Sem palavras.
O tema dessa música é pesado. Eu entendo ele raramente querer cantar ela.
Hey, oh
Sheets of empty canvas
Untouched sheets of clay
Were laid spread out before me
As her body once did
All five horizons
Revolved around her soul
As the earth to the sun
Now the air I tasted and breathed
Has taken a turn
Oh and all I taught her was everything
Oh I know she gave me all that she wore
And now my bitter hands
Chafe beneath the clouds
Of what was everything
Oh the pictures have
All been washed in black
Tattooed everything
I take a walk outside
I'm surrounded by
Some kids at play
I can feel their laughter
So why do I sear
Oh, and twisted thoughts that spin
Round my head
I'm spinning
Oh, I'm spinning
How quick the sun can, drop away
And now my bitter hands
Cradle broken glass
Of what was everything
All the pictures had
All been washed in black
Tattooed everything
All the love gone bad
Turned my world to black
Tattooed all I see
All that I am
All I'll be
Yeah
I know someday you'll have a beautiful life
I know you'll be a star
In somebody else's sky
But why
Why
Why can't it be
Why can't it be mine
We
We
We
We
We belong together
Together
Together
We
We
We belong together
Karyson Pheliphe de Souza' THANK YOU..
Vedder is the only human being who could sing these lyrics the way he did. Magic
SUN not star.
Thanks
Watch at 2:00 how his buddy checks if Eddy doesn´t break...this song comes from the deepest soul and is by far the best performance of Black and maybe one of the best live pop performances ever. I dare to say.
Ed’s subtle thumbs up too
Totally checking on him. You can feel it in the look
2:10 Are you ok bro?
Amazing moment. Eddie's anguish showed, plus they knew this song had special personal meaning and pain
Stone Gossard
A moment of absolute rock perfection .
32 years ago. I remember this. Fxck time flies so bad
Os músicos se entregam de verdade! Nunca encontrei essa versão em nenhum lugar. E sem dúvidas a melhor versão de Black.
The last King of grunge left. This still my shit and it's still good music. Long live grunge forever.
Jerry Cantrell
Heck yes! Wanna live back in 90's grunge forever.
chris simpson bush still around
Jerry and Gavin are not Grunge gods, it's insulting to me for you to put them in their category.
1. Chris Cornell
2. Layne Staley
3. Eddie Vedder
4. Scott Weiland
There ya go! Kurt was not on any of these guys level either, enough said.
@@RapFan54 Not Grunge!
Fevereiro/2023. Esse som nunca morrerá.
Essa é minha versão favorita 😍 não canso de ouvir
Minha também
Pra mim tb!!!!
Essa e uma mais recente, que ele canta no Chile. Sensacional.
pra mim também linda!
It's hard to believe this was nearly 25 years ago. Where in the hell has my life gone!
exactly... :(
I'm 60 so I'm really wondering that myself.
Just found out I'm a grunge freak. I had a baby in 91 and missed
Eddie Vedder until "Into the Wild".
It's been a wild, wonderful trip watching the whole band grow from crazy-ass dancing, head-banging boys into good looking men.
Their talent has only increased.
When you find it, let me know, I'll come search in your direction as well! OMG, I still find him the most handsome man that ever lived... and that voice... Nowadays I appreciate PJ's music so much more than I did back then, when I could only stare at Eddie... OK, I admit, I still stare at Eddie....
mark richards ha i can relate bro, turnjng 50 this year.. this feels like yesterday time flies... take care do al, u can nkw travel time with family friends hobbjes, jesus , hobbies etc etc
We where patiently awaiting youtube red so we could download this performance and listen to it till we are all washed in black
I wish I could like this a billion times
Watched this live here in Australia last night ! WOW
A música em si já é foda ,ai vem o fator ao vivo,interprete se emocionando ,banda botando pra fuder fica difícil se conter diante desta obra prima !!!
Perfeição total !!!
el es alto...
Se o próprio vocalista se emociona cantando, tu acha mesmo que eu não vou chorar escutando essa obra de arte da minha tristeza? kkkkkkkkkkkkkkk claro que vou :/ #feels
Shou
Não sei se é mais lindo ele ou a música
Continuam firmes e fortes
Kkkk me acabei de rir agora kkkkkkkk essa música é perfeita ..
Né kkkk
His emotion in this performance is amazing.
he is high
Que voz maravilhosa!! E essa música??? PERFEITA!!!!
Barítono 😊❤
this is the only song I listen to on youtube rather than spotify, the live version is just that much better.
Dedicó esta canción a mi querida esposa R.I.P ROSA 🌹 FLORES 💐 🎶
😭😭😭😭🙏🙏🙏🙏
Es irreparable la pérdida de tu compañera, ojalá tu tiempo con ella haya sido muy bueno
@@dcrespin100 19 años inolvidables en las buenas y en las malas
⚘Para ella
i feel this is the only live version of black that almost captures the true emotion of the studio recording. most of the other live versions i've seen can't even come close to replicating the power of the original.
Oh this is by far Pearl Jams best concert
+Sam Ace Rothstein The unplugged version is just as powerful, if not better.
+Stevesk0011 yeah man, that unplugged version gave me chills. When Eddie is singing at the end 'we belong together'.. Almost brings a tear to my eye.
+Sam Ace Rothstein Agreed. I prefer this to the original. I was 18 when Ten came out. I always preferred Alice In Chains but, this song always called to me.
Stevesk0011 the unplugged version is definitely up there too. that was a great performance.
Hampton AZ same here, i usually prefer alice in chains myself, but they really outdid themselves with ten.
At . 37 the emotion he had shown were so heart felt and this was so touching as a teenager and even now!! Beautiful song and beautiful man and band!
Eu fiz uma promessa, deixei meu cabelo crescer e que nunca mais ia cortar, hj tá igual ao do Eddie de 1992, Rock sempre será meu estilo! Me identifico com ele desde pequeno, rapaz... que foda!!!
Cara também foi a minha inspiração pra deixar crescer .e TMB tá igual mas bem maior
@@viniciussoares6663 aí siiiim irmão!!!! o seu deve ta bem topzeira 🤘🤘✌
I always get shivers down my spine when I hear Mike McCready do that crazy bend at 4:15 - 4:30. Just so much emotion. One of the best guitarists
Damn dude never really heard that like i just did
Amo, amo, não me canso de ouvir. Voz perfeita do Eddie e um arranjo musical magnífico. Além desse rosto e cabelo maravilhosos. Perfeito roqueiro
Truly a masterpiece...one hell of a song!!!
Thanks *Eddie & Crew* for this beautiful song...long live *Pearl Jam...!!!*
Curtindo Eddie - Pearl Jam em março de 2021 e a boa música se eterniza. Quem mais curte dá um joinha ai
Sai daí mulambos
hahahhaah
a MÚSICA em migos
É , teve um tempo onde as coisas eram bem diferentes..
abril de 2021 #PJ🖤
Maio 2021!
Alguém mais em agosto/2021, curtindo esta maravilha. Este anjo em forma de homem, com uma voz belissima.
This song breaks me every time. "I know you will be a star in somebody else's sky"
But why, why, why can’t it be, why can’t it be mine
Not perhaps: it is the greatest performance of rock history of all time. Wedder's face at the top of the ecstasy is like the angeles' on Leonardo's paintings. Noting is greates in this genre. Thank you boys. I never cease to get back to it.
Não me canso de ver esse vídeo. O Pearl Jam esbanja charme, deeeemaaiisss !!
Jaydna Rocha 😍
Resposta errado ☺
Jaydna Rocha ainnnn pensamos o msm!!!! É mto charmeee! Amoooo!
Outro mundo
My fav PJ song... very personally relatable when it came out, too. I had the pleasure of seeing these guys, front row, in 1994... awesome memory.
yup, saw them at pinkpop 1992. Bloody amazing
Na alegria, na tristeza, Black é sempre a pedida. Linda demais😻💜
Sempre
Listening to this song in 2023 still takes my breath away
Anyone notice how at 2:09 the guitarist (forget the mans name) is starting at Eddie because he knows how emotional this is for him. Shows how close the band was
So powerfully emotional. Glad you caught that.
Stone Gossard
Same thought
Yes, and Eddie put his thumbs up to sign he's ok. Such real emotions and passion!! The best song ever, my favorite is MTV unplugged version of course!! 😊✌️🤘❤️
I was about to comment that,I was shocked..totally agree with you.
Revendo esse clássico em 2022! "Lendas nunca morrem " legends "Never die " E para vc que leu meu comentário um grande abraço tudo de melhor sempre !
Pra mim, melhor música do mundo!
@@robertinhaquidute ♥️
17/09/22 Tmj
Namastê meu caro, apenas true da true, happiness sempre preserva-se ao redor da composição magnífica, muita paz e tmj, apenas alegria em tuas palavras
Fui no show no Maracanã e quando tocou essa música amigo, não sobrou Rafael kkkk
Eddie has the most amazing voice I've ever heard.
Peggy Miller Don't forget Chris Cornell, he was a legend too
Peggy Miller You must be deaf he h
Ad no body and was gross still is The Ledgendary British band Def Leppard front man Joe Elliot was and still is gorgeous and granted they are a very different band they were unbelievable and very young when they started this song is very annoying the Grunge era was horrible style and clothes
Freddie Mercury
The YARL!!!
There’s not many songs that are sang on pure emotion. Listen to Eddie at 4.34 man, jeez you feel it. I played this song on loop when going through divorce. Felt like Eddie was singing for me and all the words I wanted to say. Grunge saved me in that part of my life.
Sheets of empty canvas, untouched sheets of clay
Were laid spread out before me as her body once did.
All five horizons revolved around her soul as the earth to the sun
Now the air I tasted and breathed has taken a turn
Ooh, and all I taught her was everything
Ooh, I know she gave me all that she wore
And now my bitter hands chafe beneath the clouds of what was everything.
Oh, the pictures have all been washed in black, tattooed everything...
I take a walk outside, I'm surrounded by some kids at play
I can feel their laughter, so why do I sear?
Oh, and twisted thoughts that spin round my head, I'm spinning, oh,
I'm spinning, how quick the sun can drop away
And now my bitter hands cradle broken glass of what was everything
All the pictures have all been washed in black, tattooed everything...
All the love gone bad turned my world to black
Tattooed all I see, all that I am, all I'll be... yeah...
Uh huh... uh huh... ooh...
I know someday you'll have a beautiful life,
I know you'll be a star in somebody else's sky,
But why, why, why can't it be, can't it be mine?
Aah... uuh..
Too doo doo too, too doo doo
MissVariabile we... We... We belong together, we...we belong together, together :"(
MissV ariabile
Thank You Miss 4 The Lyrics!!! :)
im probs wrong but i thought it was 'why do i see her' not 'why do i sear'?
We
We
We belong together
Together
eddie vedder ta sentindo todas as palavras da musica, incorporou demais, lenda!!
I cannot believe this was recorded 28yrs ago....aside from the two combat tours I spent in Iraq, the years since 1992 have sped by so fast they're just a blur....now, after having just turned 46yrs old, I wish I would've taken the time to slow down and enjoy life much more than I did.....
You are always in time to enjoy life.
You still can my man you have a life ahead of you :)
First off, thanks for your service!!!!
Secondly, time freaking fly by!!! You and I are same age. Ahhhhh the good ole days
Much love man, I feel the exact same way. Just turned 41 and wondering where the last 20 years went?!?!
Same here my dude..
stones solo with the wah wah at 4:17 while eddie is screaming gives me chills its so good
Mike mcready ia lead guitar in this song not stone gissaard
Cada vez que la escucho y veo su interpretacion, me enamoro, esta cancion llega al alma, quien cuando joven no se sintio asi, da nostalgia, y te dan ganas de botar toda la tristeza que sientes en esos momentos, te lleva a otros tiempos.. y si la puedo escuchar 10 veces al dia y aun asi, siento lo mismo al escucharlo y eso me enamora de la interpretacion y de su sentir.
Bha!!! Paola garrido perez, tb sinto muito muita nostalgia, eu muita muita sensação de etsa jovem outra vez, isso é muito bommm !!!
Tiempos de incomprendido cuando no sabes que será de tú futuro
I was 12 years old. The only teenager in my JHS wearing a Pearl Jam t-shirt that I got from one of my older brothers. Meh! I thought I was the coolest kid... what am I saying. I was!!! I had the hugest crush on Eddie... that hair!!! I still do!
Liz Ariana Handsome Eddie *-* ♥
+Liz Ariana when he says Mhhm lol oh dear!
+Liz Ariana when he says Mhhm lol oh dear!
+Liz Ariana I was 2 years old ^^
old days
I was there in '92... Most legandary concert ever ❤️
1992 eu nasci...cresci ouvindo...e até hoje escuto essa música. Não me canso de ouvir! Beautiful music!
Nunca había escuchado este concierto, como suena esta gran banda, esa guitarra esa batería, el bajo y por supuesto el gran Eddie Vedder que sentimiento por Dios!!!! El temazo black para mi pasa a la historia de la música como obra de arte
Algo surreal não dá nem para dizer que você é muito foda cara cheia arrepiar
Já escutei milhões vezes não não canso de escutar essa música
This is simply the most beautiful version ever. I do love PJ. Facing this pandemic situation, listening to PJ calms me down