For those questioning why I didn’t wear “professional” headphones for this challenge: I did that on purpose because I was more interested in the accuracy of the sounds and how they matched with the visuals, rather than the quality. I wore generic headphones to level the playing field and while I understand that the quality is a big part of what you pay for, I wanted to make the challenge more difficult for myself.
I focused more on the sound they did when the smoothie was poured in the glass. Some were too unrealistic as it sounded more "watery"/"flowy" which isn't exactly the sound of a smoothie. So C became my fave bet, it really captured the sort of thickness/chunkiness sound of a smoothie when you pour it.
I noticed that C was the 1000$ one, because he was the only one who used a different sound for pouring in the smoothie. Everyone else recycled their water pourling sound.
After hearing the "C", it was basically game over for me. No one but Jonas actually cared about how the independent sounds compare to one another in a volume perspective, that was top notch!
I love that these videos are a confidence boost for the lower priced sellers. If you can't tell the difference between $1000 and $400 products, then they should definitely raise their prices!
You can also take it as you don't really have to go for expensive artists all the time. For videos like this $400 or even $80 artist can get the job done perfectly.
I prefered A since the begining, I'm very glad it's cheapest (40 dollars). The quality/price is great. For 400 dollars I expect a song. For 1000 dollars I expect an amazing song. I have a poor-middle class mentality.
@@branlan895 I didn't find too much difference and I think most people on Earth focus more on music and words when watching commercials. I like A the most because it values "low notes"(bass sound? I don't how to explain it). My problem with C and D is the fact that some sounds aren't pleasurable in my ears, they have great quality but, some sounds irritated me.
As a sound design student: if someone is using too much reverb it means they have bad quality samples and want to cover it, I know because I was doing that in my first year haha
i’m considering a career in sound design. do you know what kind of jobs would be available if i did that and a salary i could expect. and also what college you’re studying at? thank you!!
Not only that but what also stuck out to me was the pitch of how full the cup was since in the video the smoothie cup was nearly full and you could hear the cup of water that was recorded wasn't
The title cut off at smoothie so I thought it said “I paid a stranger $1000 to finish my smoothie”. This is not what I had in mind, but I am not disappointed.
Id say it's probably intentionally omitted, there is no visual cue for the straw hitting the bottom of the cup, if they added it more people would be weirded out
C was definitely my favorite. The attention to detail was great and it sounded the most realistic to me. They did a great job at accentuating the details and grabbing my attention. E.g the knife sharpening sound added to the shot of the blade was a great way to add sound and make the shot seem necessary. The others kind of ignored it which made the shot itself feel out of place to me. I’m not an expert, that was just my thought when listening to it. I wasn’t expecting it to be the so high up but honestly it makes sense.
What I learnt here is that, you can hire a $40 artist and it doesn't really sound too different from a $1000 artist. Remember that the advert you're making is for untrained ears
That $1000 did sound significantly better than everybody else (idk why he put E on the $1000), but it's not such a big difference to varrant the price difference (the price itself though isn't that bad if it's a real ad, a short film, etc.)
You may be making an advert for untrained ears however, that extra quality could possibly catch the right person's ear and get you another gig down the line.
you're right, for the untrained ear it's not a big difference... but going the extra mile always pays off in a very round end product as a whole, even you don't notice the details
I really liked the 40$ one best, especially the zipper sound?!?! It is SO original!! And he even added some cool background sounds too which you mentioned as "almost scary". I'm totally in love with that!!
Watermelon season runs throughout the summer, that's why a product like frozen watermelon exists, because depends on what part of the planet you are, you might not be able to get it fresh
me: doesn't understand anything about commercials. learned the word foley 15 minutes ago. also me agreeing to everything he says: yes my thoughts exactly.
They all sound the same to me lol, this is like that scene in american psycho where they're comparing business cards but they all basically look the same
"you don't need a bag with already chopped carrots, if you want to have carrots you just buy a carrot, I was so confused" says the guy who asked to sound a video with a girl opening a BAG OF ALREADY CHOPPED WATERMELON! What?
Glad to see the idea I suggested some months ago on the 25$ edit pizza comparison happened! Not seeing the price before the analyses makes a huge difference =)
The comments above me are delusional.. Especially those two.. And this comment is irrefutable and is not telling a lie.. And is basically invincible. That's it.
Issue I had with all of them was the blender sound was 'real time' but the visual was 'slowed down' so it just didn't sync together. Needed to be lower in pitch to get the feeling of slow mo blending.
I felt this the whole video! I was confused why he was so impressed although in each video I found extremely obvious flaws , still a great video tho for sure
For me was also the smooth switching from sound to sound. Like there's a really nice air sound with each switch that makes it dramatic but not overly? Not sure but i said yes that's high quality
I guessed E as the last one 😅 the smoothie sound was a bit off, but everything was good to me. I thought that too. E had all the sounds for everything, like the metal straw hitting the glass and the droplet at the end. And the sounds were brighter, seemed to transition better and fit a smoothie commercial more. That’s what made me thought it was the most expensive 🤷🏻♀️
Am I crazy? Out of the five, as a customer watching an advert, I enjoyed A the most, would buy the product. The juice and straw sound is the most satisfying.
This guy: “you’re gonna buy carrots, just buy a carrot, don’t get a bag of chopped carrots. That’s just kinda silly” Also this guy: uses a bag of chopped watermelon in the video
i could tell that c was the more expensive due to the sound of the smoothie when it was poured. the others sounded too liquid for the consistency of the smoothie
Also the pouring of the smoothy was the best one because smoothies are more viscous than juice or water and it sounded heavier and more dense which fits way better to pouring a smoothie
@@lukasmargesin5756 they're actually not super popular here in the States. So I always look like a hero when I introduce the uninitiated into what is a Moka Pot.
Is that a coffee grinder lol? The manual ones? Most of us Americans use instant pour overs. I personally have drip brew, grinder and pour over. I never thought about getting manual grinder lol. I think even traditional cafes use grind machines
@@ICeyCeR3Al u put coffee and water in it, then put it on the stove and it makes espresso coffee, it’s an espresso machine to be exact because it can only make espresso coffe, the part he was grinding in the video is the part where it opens and u put the water then it has a filter like thing on top of the water to put the coffee
The C sounded the best any ways because it’s not only that it feels correct and real it also does not exaggerate reverb and also control how loud some noises sounds like versus others so it is still enjoyable to the ear and sound “aesthetic” enough. Idk I’m not a pro
That contraption you wondered about in the video from #E is a Bialetti Moka Stovetop Espresso maker. They work by using the pressure from boiling water to push the water through a filter with coffee grinds. They make excellent Espresso and all you need is a heating plate.
My uncle is a foley artist... The thing about real life is that real life sounds aren't as rich as the replacements they use. If they used the real sounds the movies would be very disappointing.
Quality does not always cost the most. Which speaks so much for humanity as a whole. There are so many people who do such amazing things, but don't get the credit they deserve and then there's people who are less good and get too much credit. It's really unfair a lot of times.
as a sounddesigner I can say that one could hear that C was the best. How? Super tight low end (=low frequencies) + perfect layering of sounds. I'm also shocked that some didn't put sounds on the animated white drop thing in the intro. Like what? I literally wouldn't pay someone if they did not include such an important sound
Thanks for sharing! After filming this I finally listened with proper headphones and all I could say is WOW I noticed a difference. Can definitely hear the difference in depth and EQ in C.
A few of them missed the droplets at the intro and end, as well as the straw clinking against the glass! So I dismissed those as the higher-tier ones immediately.
This video taught me that liquid foley detail really separates good foley from great. You can tell so easily when the artist is pouring into an empty cup. I would have just bought the frozen watermelon and recorded myself making the smoothie lol
It's the sharpness of your audio ability thingamajig I guess. I notice that those artists who stand out are sharper than an average person on an aspect
For me, they all sound different. I could guess instantly that C was $1000. I guess 9 years listening to ASMR makes my ears easily differentiate the quality of sounds that are almost the same.
As a Marketing major final year student, your videos teach a lot about the actual production process of a commercial... I also want to be in the advertisement market and your videos inspire me even more... love love your videos!! :) :)
Hello ,🎂🍰we have much videos about cooking and cake 🍰🎂🥀🌷all welcome 🎂watch please and tell us 🥧🍑🥀🌷🥐🍩the comments important for us 🌷🍊😉🙂merci 🥐🍯thank you🍓🙂🍕
I actually think that E sounded the best, especially with the blending, the sound matched the liquidy texture much better, and also transitioned between clips better, in my opinion,,,, not an audio engineer, but I do a lot of recording as a vocal performance major and when getting sound samples I use in producing songs
The first time I watch one of your videos, I was in the parking lot of Chick-fil-A and I was eating a deluxe. I turn on your video by accident and couldn’t put it down. Great video! Great work!👍🏽
Thanks RUclips, I've never shown an interest in this or anything like this and I dont know which this channel is but you got me to watch the whole thing and like it, ARE YOU HAPPY?
I feel bad because, everyone is saying how they love the mouth sounds guy but, I thought it was really bad 😅 Edit: I also agree with what you guys are saying about it being good as mouth sounds, but bad as like, professional commercial sounds.
so basically the guy who asked $ 40 does such a great job that he could raise the prices. And that at 13:35 is a moka. In Italy we use it to make espresso coffee xD
@@Enroxxx what are you talking about? "caffè espresso" is a type of coffee that we have in italy 🤨 a very very short coffee (look on the internet). And a moka do espresso coffee. EDIT: at home we are using moka to do espresso because we don't have those fancy coffee machine that you find in a bar
@@Enroxxx I know they are two different things, but very often we use the term espresso vulgarly even when we make a ristretto coffee with the moka. If you don't live here you can't understand our customs
@@BimbaElis sorry but that is just blasphemy!!! Espresso refers to the process, you can do a "ristretto", a "lungo" etc with an espresso maker, it doesn't describe the "quantity", it describes the process. With a moka, you cannot do an "espresso", is like saying "ho fatto l'arrosto con la padella sul gas" 😂
For those questioning why I didn’t wear “professional” headphones for this challenge: I did that on purpose because I was more interested in the accuracy of the sounds and how they matched with the visuals, rather than the quality. I wore generic headphones to level the playing field and while I understand that the quality is a big part of what you pay for, I wanted to make the challenge more difficult for myself.
Great brother
Great my dear friend 🙏
@@lolgaming7251 tanks
Love from India Daniel😁😘
End user of the product isn't using 'professional' headphones either, crappy phone or tv speakers. Accuracy and overall vibe is way more important.
I focused more on the sound they did when the smoothie was poured in the glass. Some were too unrealistic as it sounded more "watery"/"flowy" which isn't exactly the sound of a smoothie. So C became my fave bet, it really captured the sort of thickness/chunkiness sound of a smoothie when you pour it.
Exactly! Was looking for this comment. Same here🙋♂️
YES! I was annoyed by how it was too ‘liquid’ too... it needed to be ‘thicker’
Right? Same and was looking for this comment
SAME!!!
Soo trueee❤
This guy just made us watch 14 mins ads.
That's another level of advertising
😂😂😂😂
What about vat19 lol
@@MrJ.N lol
And it contains multiple ads, for his watermelon brand, for fiver, and for the fiverr sellers😅
Looool
My problem is that everyone made the smoothie sound like a soda
except C, they actually made it sound proper
DarkValorWolf Yes
Ikrrr that’s why I kinda liked the 8:40 one cause it still sounded “chunky” a little bit
Agree
I’m your 1000th like
“That was absolutely fucking terrible.” - Me
“THOUSAND DOLLAR FOLEY.” - Him
E or D
that was my exact thought lol
the heck is wrong with u 🤣 that sounded pretty good like a actually tv commercial
Haha, I thought they all sucked.
Ikr, the best was definitely the C one
I noticed that C was the 1000$ one, because he was the only one who used a different sound for pouring in the smoothie. Everyone else recycled their water pourling sound.
And the sound of the blending was more clear than the E one
Yup. Do people know smoothies have stuff in them, they're like..thick..unlike water?
The mixer sound was pretty shitty...i would't have paid 1k for that..scam
Comment below me is trash
wow that really hurts me
That guy really did make those noises with his mouth 😂😂😂
Hi John!
I heard better beatboxers
It was pretty funny and cool
Which guy did that?
😂😂😂
After hearing the "C", it was basically game over for me. No one but Jonas actually cared about how the independent sounds compare to one another in a volume perspective, that was top notch!
Facts, Jonas was by far the best one
I shouldn't have read this Before watching the whole video 😭😭😂
And that's why it cost 1k
Right for me c was better than e
Same here
I love that these videos are a confidence boost for the lower priced sellers. If you can't tell the difference between $1000 and $400 products, then they should definitely raise their prices!
You can also take it as you don't really have to go for expensive artists all the time. For videos like this $400 or even $80 artist can get the job done perfectly.
Or the other guys should lower theirs..
diminishing returns. you can easily tell the difference between say 20$ vs 200$, but its harder to tell the difference between say 500$ to 1000$.
I prefered A since the begining, I'm very glad it's cheapest (40 dollars). The quality/price is great.
For 400 dollars I expect a song.
For 1000 dollars I expect an amazing song.
I have a poor-middle class mentality.
@@branlan895 I didn't find too much difference and I think most people on Earth focus more on music and words when watching commercials.
I like A the most because it values "low notes"(bass sound? I don't how to explain it).
My problem with C and D is the fact that some sounds aren't pleasurable in my ears, they have great quality but, some sounds irritated me.
As a sound design student: if someone is using too much reverb it means they have bad quality samples and want to cover it, I know because I was doing that in my first year haha
Lol i still like that one above all other
It’s like using grain in photoshop to correct all the other mistakes during edits. It still has its charm, I guess
Lool interesting that you watched Golden Boy.. so few people looked it
i’m considering a career in sound design. do you know what kind of jobs would be available if i did that and a salary i could expect. and also what college you’re studying at? thank you!!
@@lizziem2912 o that’s cool!
He was trying so hard not to laugh during the mouth one lololol
lmfao if it was me i would also be trying not to laugh too💀💀
Is it one of the A-E or different video ?
Lol true😂😂
@@isolated.4722 It was not on the list, it's just a bonus or something
@@viktortoth7104 thx~
Do people not realize that smoothies don’t sound like water?
ikr
Not only that but what also stuck out to me was the pitch of how full the cup was since in the video the smoothie cup was nearly full and you could hear the cup of water that was recorded wasn't
Fun fact:
Did you know you can hear the difference between hot and cold water getting poured.
@@noskillnokill_7371 really?? I'm gonna have to go try this one now lolll
That's what was bugging me the whole time!!
That $1,000 foley sounded so good, but honestly, the dude who did it with his voice was super fun and my personal favorite!
That one would also be more popular and catch more attention. Its something unique. Maybe could refine a bit more in some parts and its good to go
The title cut off at smoothie so I thought it said “I paid a stranger $1000 to finish my smoothie”. This is not what I had in mind, but I am not disappointed.
I SAW THE SAME BUT IT WAS STREAMER INSTEAD OF STRANGER
That's what I read lol
But you clicked on that anyways 💀
@@chloegribble3037 bc I thought it'd be funny
Plot twist: the smoothie was poisoned
It really bugged me on the ones where they didn't add sound of the metal straw hitting the glass
I thought i was the only one 🥲 and they maybe should‘ve added a sound when the straw hits the bottom of the glass
@@maatje4ever ikr
The last one did around 8:45 ish
me to
5:51 made it very satisfying
The mouth one made me lol for real 🤣🤣🤣 super talented dude though! Awesome, fun video my dude!
Glad you enjoyed :)
🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂😂🤣😂🤣🤣🤣😂
Same man, lol
Reminds me of Peter Mckinnon doing his own sound effects hehe 😂
My god that was hilarious
The mouth noise one would work really well in a commercial with a kid describing how a smoothie is made.
When they didn’t add the sound of the straw hitting the bottom of the glass, I was frustrated
IKR
Id say it's probably intentionally omitted, there is no visual cue for the straw hitting the bottom of the cup, if they added it more people would be weirded out
or the straw going through the smoothie, though it would really happen that way in real life i think it wouldve been better.
I think straws aren't made of iron. It doesn't make that much of a noise imo.
@@zinetx it's a metal straw
me: wow that was really good
Daniel: "I don't think that was as good as-"
me: IT WAS TRASH
E was trash 😂
@@guupie1 e was the best
ITS SO SATISFYING TO THE 1000TH LIKE lol
@@guupie1 yes it was bad
Ngl in *my opinion* e was the best of all of them..
Me: *this sucks...*
Daniel: “This is the $1000 foley”
Me: definitely the best one, hands down.
LMAOOO SAME
I liked the $400 one best
Exactlyyy
SAMEEEE the $400 one was definitely the best 😭😭.
SAMEEEEE
C was definitely my favorite. The attention to detail was great and it sounded the most realistic to me. They did a great job at accentuating the details and grabbing my attention. E.g the knife sharpening sound added to the shot of the blade was a great way to add sound and make the shot seem necessary. The others kind of ignored it which made the shot itself feel out of place to me. I’m not an expert, that was just my thought when listening to it. I wasn’t expecting it to be the so high up but honestly it makes sense.
The CRISPNESS of the smoothie pour is what made C the best, it's the sound when you pour a liquid over ice and they ever so slightly crackle.
And it sounded thick, not like water
YES!
also the straw hit the glass and it has sound
What I learnt here is that, you can hire a $40 artist and it doesn't really sound too different from a $1000 artist. Remember that the advert you're making is for untrained ears
but theres a bunch of things as an untrained audience that just sounds wrong when you watch it, like when a plastic bag sounds like zipper
That $1000 did sound significantly better than everybody else (idk why he put E on the $1000), but it's not such a big difference to varrant the price difference (the price itself though isn't that bad if it's a real ad, a short film, etc.)
You may be making an advert for untrained ears however, that extra quality could possibly catch the right person's ear and get you another gig down the line.
you're right, for the untrained ear it's not a big difference... but going the extra mile always pays off in a very round end product as a whole, even you don't notice the details
@@NoName-uy2hr do you honestly think the one charging $1000 is 25 times better than the one charging $40?
Welcome to another session of “why is this in my recommendation?”
me too lol, but this was pretty fun
well ain't complaining tho
True 😂😂😂 the video is interesting though
I wonder why too
lol 😂
I really liked the 40$ one best, especially the zipper sound?!?! It is SO original!! And he even added some cool background sounds too which you mentioned as "almost scary". I'm totally in love with that!!
Daniel: If you are gon'a buy carrot just buy a carrot, don't get a bag of chopped carrots
Also Daniel: Buys a bag of chopped watermelon
Lmaoo
Delete this comment.
@@Tenakin if you click the three ellipses, you can delete your own comments, true story
Watermelon season runs throughout the summer, that's why a product like frozen watermelon exists, because depends on what part of the planet you are, you might not be able to get it fresh
@@mateodillon9412 Yeah, but don't judge to one who bought chopped carrots.
me: doesn't understand anything about commercials. learned the word foley 15 minutes ago.
also me agreeing to everything he says: yes my thoughts exactly.
Lmao 😂
Literally same
its ok. that's how we learn
A was obviously the cheapest, the zipper sound threw me off immediately
yeah zipper and paper doesnt closely sound the same
Besides the zipper I liked it the most. I thought the muffledness was a good touch-
@Gshi _ at least dude got sponsored and the view that his content. But for regular people it does sound silly to spend that amount of money.
I thought the zipper sounded the coolest
I noticed it was a zipper and not actually plastic but it still sounded better in my opinion
I saw the title as "I paid a Stranger $1000 to finish my smoothie" and I was wondering why he couldn't just drink the rest of it
My mind: Haha that's the $40 one
Daniel: -definitely the $1000 one
E was the worst
I was thinking the exact same thing
Leon agreed
Yep, and A was the best. Clearly bought and paid for review.
Yeeeesss! In my oppinion it sounds so numb and doesnt have a full sound. That really bothered me
Non of the foley artists made a sound for the straw hitting the bottom of the cup before hitting the side of the cup, it drove me nuts!
agreed! the straw is much longer than the cup
OH MY GOD I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE!!! i was losing my MINDDDD
Yes, I was expecting it to. It's not like the base of the cup is soft or something.
The sound could be muffled by the smoothie
YES SAME!!! I also missed that noise😂
They all sound the same to me lol, this is like that scene in american psycho where they're comparing business cards but they all basically look the same
Wear earphones or something the difference is night and day on some lmao
The accuracy tho hehe---is what matters in this industry,u know that hehe
Ikr
No no, those cards are not the same - and I say that as a graphic designer
"you don't need a bag with already chopped carrots, if you want to have carrots you just buy a carrot, I was so confused" says the guy who asked to sound a video with a girl opening a BAG OF ALREADY CHOPPED WATERMELON! What?
to be fair, watermelon is a pain in the ass to cut unlike carrot which easier besides, i think that watermelon cut specially for juice.
@João Alves maybe idk never seen those before lol
What bothers me the most is that it’s a smoothie, not water. Smoothies DO NOT sound like that when poured.
Yep, they sound like glup glup glup glup
It’s driving me crazy
C did gud, also bothers me this guy prefer E as 1000 foley
Lew Kang I know!! E sounded so bad compared to c. C was the only one that actually killed it
omg same, texture matter !! hahah that is why i believed in C the most
I just didn't like how the thick smoothie sounded so watery in them
E nailed it I thought it was the 1k one
Yeah I was gonna say the main thing is none of those sounded like a smoothie, they sounded like a soft drink…
C and E both got the thicker liquid sound pretty well.
C sounded thick
fax bro
Glad to see the idea I suggested some months ago on the 25$ edit pizza comparison happened!
Not seeing the price before the analyses makes a huge difference =)
I remember that video it lives rent free in my head tbh
Comment below me is trash
@ThatRandomLady ＨＡＨＡ NO U DIDNT HAHAHHAHA
The comments above me are delusional.. Especially those two.. And this comment is irrefutable and is not telling a lie.. And is basically invincible. That's it.
The 4th guy's name above me is so damn creative yet so unoriginal
C was definitely my absolute favourite. Full bodied and complex layering.
Issue I had with all of them was the blender sound was 'real time' but the visual was 'slowed down' so it just didn't sync together. Needed to be lower in pitch to get the feeling of slow mo blending.
I felt this the whole video! I was confused why he was so impressed although in each video I found extremely obvious flaws , still a great video tho for sure
Agreee. I think D had a slow blade tho the squeak was good
@@jicksle thats why it takes quite a bit of time and to be invested in the project. idk how the deadline tho but yea some revision is key
I guessed DABEC. What really separates recording C from the rest, is the smoothie sound itself. Most of them sound way to watery.
I felt the same way, like the liquid being poured wasn't viscous enough. Overall I loved C the mostm
It was the straw hitting the glass for me as it was the only one that sounded realistic to me.
For me was also the smooth switching from sound to sound. Like there's a really nice air sound with each switch that makes it dramatic but not overly? Not sure but i said yes that's high quality
I guessed E as the last one 😅 the smoothie sound was a bit off, but everything was good to me. I thought that too. E had all the sounds for everything, like the metal straw hitting the glass and the droplet at the end. And the sounds were brighter, seemed to transition better and fit a smoothie commercial more. That’s what made me thought it was the most expensive 🤷🏻♀️
@@potatocat2445 Same! The way the sounds blended seamlessly into each other was very professional.
9:50
“Either Seller C or Seller E is the $1000 Foley.”
*_proceeds to show the other three sellers spelling out “B A D”_*
Lol didn't notice that one
In my class there was a angle BAD (in a triangle)
😂😂😂
Lol
yeah i noticed it too 😂
Am I crazy? Out of the five, as a customer watching an advert, I enjoyed A the most, would buy the product. The juice and straw sound is the most satisfying.
To each their own. I personally enjoyed E the most. I will say the beatboxing one was enjoyable also😂
the sounds sounded too much like ambience to me
This guy: “you’re gonna buy carrots, just buy a carrot, don’t get a bag of chopped carrots. That’s just kinda silly”
Also this guy: uses a bag of chopped watermelon in the video
@ then just buy a water melon and freeze it lol
@@sherryp3452 genius, that actually made me laugh
@ you can also freeze your own chopped watermelon
@@khoado2060 it is harder to cut than say, an apple right lol? I'm not really comparing it to a durian
True
i could tell that c was the more expensive due to the sound of the smoothie when it was poured. the others sounded too liquid for the consistency of the smoothie
Hey thats me 🤣😂🙏 This was fun to work on!! I tried my best!🤷♂️ #Beatbox
Ayee you did great! When I filmed this I was going on about how cool it was but I had to cut my reaction down to make the whole video shorter haha
o
lmao great
In my opinion your Foley was the best lol
Esh?
The fact that the 3 lowest ranked spell out the word "BAD."
WHY IS THIS THE ONLY COMMENT TALKING ABOUT THAT
marco? where tf is marco im italian and im dying but overall is a good video
Damnn
If A was at the 3rd place the top 3 would have been "ACE".
• cool •
I had a feeling C was the 1000 dollar one, the noise of the watermelons hitting the table was too realistic
Yup, the blender was great too
Plus the smoothie actually sounded thick and not watery
Yep I thought the C was so much better, couldn't believe he was hesitating.
Also the pouring of the smoothy was the best one because smoothies are more viscous than juice or water and it sounded heavier and more dense which fits way better to pouring a smoothie
Me: wow that was shit!
Him: that was increíble! Def the 1000$ one.
HAHA ikr
For that one, the bag rip did not sit well with me, it sounded like paper imo
Lol same reaction
I felt the very same way mehn.. Lol
same
13:33
Daniel: "im not entirely sure what that contrapion is..."
Me: *laughs in italian while drinking my caffè italiano*
I was looking for this comment before I posted my response lol
@@woodypaul_ haha i was like "does he really not know what that is? he gotta be kidding" lol
Same 😂
@@lukasmargesin5756 they're actually not super popular here in the States. So I always look like a hero when I introduce the uninitiated into what is a Moka Pot.
Haha the only reason I knew it was a moka pot was because my Italian friend has one
Him: *hands in face*
Me: yep it sucks
Him: Oh my gooosh. This has to be the 1000$ foley
Me: yep I knew it
“I’m not entirely sure what that contraption is” literally a coffee machine hahahah
🤣🤣 I laughed so hard when he called it a contraption🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Is that a coffee grinder lol? The manual ones? Most of us Americans use instant pour overs. I personally have drip brew, grinder and pour over. I never thought about getting manual grinder lol. I think even traditional cafes use grind machines
@@ICeyCeR3Al no no, it's a moka! It's used to brew coffee using grinded coffee beens (that you can buy at the store)
@@ICeyCeR3Al u put coffee and water in it, then put it on the stove and it makes espresso coffee, it’s an espresso machine to be exact because it can only make espresso coffe, the part he was grinding in the video is the part where it opens and u put the water then it has a filter like thing on top of the water to put the coffee
Solo un italiano poteva usare una moka per simulare il rumore AHAHA
The C sounded the best any ways because it’s not only that it feels correct and real it also does not exaggerate reverb and also control how loud some noises sounds like versus others so it is still enjoyable to the ear and sound “aesthetic” enough. Idk I’m not a pro
Agree
yeah! and the way that we heard the sounds fading in before we would see what was making them, like with the blender.
Agree
D and E in my opinion were elite
I agree I knew C and A were for sure the best and worst.
'D' was the best output . If you listen closely he even edited Environment Ambience for the last shot with birds chirping. I would vote him the best.
and the rusty blade part! It kinda squeaked when blades started to rotate. I really liked that.
I taugh he was the 1000$ one. My favorite too, super realistic.
But I didn’t like that the smoothie sounded like water so liquid
I agree. I thought it’d be the most expensive.
Plus the lemonade sounds? So good
That contraption you wondered about in the video from #E is a Bialetti Moka Stovetop Espresso maker. They work by using the pressure from boiling water to push the water through a filter with coffee grinds. They make excellent Espresso and all you need is a heating plate.
I'm amazed that you got them all wrong 😂
spoiler much?
This is why I need to stop going in the comments
@@golly5941 ikr
@@BulkBlitzz damn i JUST clicked on the video lmaooo
@@BulkBlitzz what do you think gonna happen when you go to the comments
Why the heck couldn't they just literally make a smoothie and record the actual sounds?
Ikr
That’s what I was thinking this whole time
My uncle is a foley artist... The thing about real life is that real life sounds aren't as rich as the replacements they use. If they used the real sounds the movies would be very disappointing.
@@oromis995 Yeah. *Imagine the pain doing it for fight scenes...* lol.
@@oromis995 yhea but in this case just a thick fluid would be better because liquid is definetely not a good idea imo
I recognized the $1000 one from its amount of detail and variety of sounds
This person made me watch 14 minutes of ads😐
Why did you watch it then -
@@fahmida791 cuz its so good....
Yes
@@fahmida791 it was a joke ;-;
@@fahmida791 the whole vid is an ad
Quality does not always cost the most. Which speaks so much for humanity as a whole. There are so many people who do such amazing things, but don't get the credit they deserve and then there's people who are less good and get too much credit. It's really unfair a lot of times.
Daniel seeing a moka: "I'm not really sure what that contraption is"
Every Italian alive: Dies of shock
First reaction: shock
Il commento di cui avevo bisogno ma non pensavo di trovare
molto fiero dell'artista italiano
I thought I was the only one. I kept yelling it makes coffee!
A moka? It looks like a percolator to me.
this guy just finessed us into watching an ad for 10 minutes
now that is big brain advertising
as a sounddesigner I can say that one could hear that C was the best. How? Super tight low end (=low frequencies) + perfect layering of sounds. I'm also shocked that some didn't put sounds on the animated white drop thing in the intro. Like what? I literally wouldn't pay someone if they did not include such an important sound
Thanks for sharing! After filming this I finally listened with proper headphones and all I could say is WOW I noticed a difference. Can definitely hear the difference in depth and EQ in C.
Especially with the added reverb to every audio clip. It really makes the sounds flow into each other
May i know which one is the animated white drop thing in the intro? Is it the glass rolling
@@nuramanina7224 yeah I think so
A few of them missed the droplets at the intro and end, as well as the straw clinking against the glass! So I dismissed those as the higher-tier ones immediately.
Hire an ASMR girl on RUclips, she know what she's doing
Lol yep
Lol
and a he, right?
@@mariahranard5988 yeah
I know a certain girl from Korea who’s good with these SFX
This video taught me that liquid foley detail really separates good foley from great. You can tell so easily when the artist is pouring into an empty cup. I would have just bought the frozen watermelon and recorded myself making the smoothie lol
Yes, but you have to be careful doing foley cus often times the actual thing doesn't make the sound you want, even if that sounds odd 😂
I liked B the most! (wormholesound) the epic thud when the bag hits the table, and the only one that chose to leave the straw silent. great vid btw!
Higher price doesn’t always mean higher quality
Yes
yup!
Me who knows nothing about sounds: no you’re wrong C is definitely $1000 and E $400
Honestly though, E just sounds better overall and especially for the price point. But jokes on us, this video was just an ad in disguise.
Something is wrong with me: they all sound almost identical
Innit lmao
It's the sharpness of your audio ability thingamajig I guess. I notice that those artists who stand out are sharper than an average person on an aspect
yeah
Except the 4 th one
For me, they all sound different. I could guess instantly that C was $1000.
I guess 9 years listening to ASMR makes my ears easily differentiate the quality of sounds that are almost the same.
The “weird construption” Marko used for that sound is a “Moka” and that’s a thing used in Italy to make coffee
As an Italian, the fact that the Italian artist used a moka for his foley makes me proud
E il fatto che non sapesse fosse una moka👁️👄👁️
@@infiresbaby2859 è stato un colpo al cuore
Stavo giusto lasciando un commento scrivendogli cosa fosse quell’oggetto misterioso
Pizza spaghetti pasta man
@@infiresbaby2859 lol mi ha intristito anche a me
C was definitely 1000 it was the only one that sounded like a smoothie and not water
okay but the smoothie commercial looks really good, like I haven’t gotten bored of watching it over and over again, and now I want a smoothie
same lmao
As a Marketing major final year student, your videos teach a lot about the actual production process of a commercial...
I also want to be in the advertisement market and your videos inspire me even more... love love your videos!! :) :)
Hello ,🎂🍰we have much videos about cooking and cake 🍰🎂🥀🌷all welcome 🎂watch please and tell us 🥧🍑🥀🌷🥐🍩the comments important for us 🌷🍊😉🙂merci 🥐🍯thank you🍓🙂🍕
Good luck
@@Paul_Bateman Thank you!! :) :)
Honestly the mouth noises is soooo original i LOVE IT and I would literally watch it if it comes in TV
I like color grading you did in this video with zooming 😌😌 any way evrything in this video is cool as always 💪
Wat
Wat
Ok
FITNESSARAB it’s distracting as hell. Get off his junk
I actually think that E sounded the best, especially with the blending, the sound matched the liquidy texture much better, and also transitioned between clips better, in my opinion,,,, not an audio engineer, but I do a lot of recording as a vocal performance major and when getting sound samples I use in producing songs
My main takeaway from this is that buying chopped carrots is a silly thing to do
😂😂 You made me laugh so I checked out your channel and I’m actually very impressed. Subbed!
Omg Diego I love your videos 💕
@@daisytheboston7721 Lmao I appreciate it a lot : )
@@mckennaparker4593 Thank you Mckenna 💛
My main takeaway is that your channel is fire, you just earned a new subscriber my friend
The person with the mouth has a lot of talent
I undoubtedly knew C was the $1000 dollar one , everything was so crisp and clear
The first time I watch one of your videos, I was in the parking lot of Chick-fil-A and I was eating a deluxe. I turn on your video by accident and couldn’t put it down. Great video! Great work!👍🏽
Other than the zipper sound, A was my favorite. It felt realistic without being too much
Yeah the zipper was the only downside
same
yes!!
Yeah i really liked A and C
13:34
"i'm not entirely sure what that contraption is"
*cries in italian*
I feel you
Well what is it then?
A pepper thingy?
@@blueyes5277 It's called a Moka. It's used to brew coffee
@@blueyes5277 coffee maker, i call it "moca"
ah I c
Seller C’s straw clink was euphoric
Reminds me of the sound when you open up Euro Truck Sim 2
Really enjoyed this. I’m just getting started and had no idea there were sound effect artists for hire.
The straw doesn't exactly need a noise for hitting the bottom but ya'll aren't ready to have that conversation yet.
exactlt some poeple didnt learn density or force and its very obvious in some of these people comments
was it a metallic straw? or a plastic one?
@@emmanuelebole325 metal*
Facts
@@sexyanonymous4962 i def now get it. but the bias of foley in that. it does not hit the bottom of the glass.
Thanks RUclips, I've never shown an interest in this or anything like this and I dont know which this channel is but you got me to watch the whole thing and like it, ARE YOU HAPPY?
Pays $1720 for audio.
Judges with Apple earbuds.
Artists: 0___0
This actually perfect because most of your listeners not using speakers will most likely be using Apple earbuds
This was way more entertaining than I expected. Well done and thanks for the video!
I feel bad because, everyone is saying how they love the mouth sounds guy but, I thought it was really bad 😅
Edit: I also agree with what you guys are saying about it being good as mouth sounds, but bad as like, professional commercial sounds.
i cringed
@@snacktime66 me too
Same
I mean, they are good for a mouth but they are bad
Same
This guys presentation is so good that I could listen to it for 10 hours straight
lol did that guy make those sounds with his mouth. OMG LOL
JAJAJAJA LOL
The fact that you listened to everyone's work with Apple earphones and not even decent headphones says how much you know about audio
so basically the guy who asked $ 40 does such a great job that he could raise the prices. And that at 13:35 is a moka. In Italy we use it to make espresso coffee xD
To be precise, "espresso" is a term used specifically for a coffee machine that uses pressurized air.
So a "moka" is not making espresso coffee.
@@Enroxxx what are you talking about? "caffè espresso" is a type of coffee that we have in italy 🤨 a very very short coffee (look on the internet). And a moka do espresso coffee. EDIT: at home we are using moka to do espresso because we don't have those fancy coffee machine that you find in a bar
@@BimbaElis you cannot do an "espresso" with a moka, you are a disgrace as an Italian if you don't know that 😂
@@Enroxxx I know they are two different things, but very often we use the term espresso vulgarly even when we make a ristretto coffee with the moka. If you don't live here you can't understand our customs
@@BimbaElis sorry but that is just blasphemy!!!
Espresso refers to the process, you can do a "ristretto", a "lungo" etc with an espresso maker, it doesn't describe the "quantity", it describes the process.
With a moka, you cannot do an "espresso", is like saying "ho fatto l'arrosto con la padella sul gas" 😂
This is the one guy who would actually prefer watching the commercials than the show
Me: oh that was definitely the $40 dollars one
Daniel: wow that has to be the $1000
Me:😶😶😶
Lmao same
I thought this to. Not sure why
@@Ender_Wiggin they used a proper sound for the slushie. and its calming.
Me too 😳✋
I thought it was trashy
Omg I was so happy that I got the $1000 one right
I probably wouldn’t skip RUclips ads so frequently if they were as entertaining as this video.
The Italian engineer using a moka to create the sound is so... Italian.
Bro kindo is a freaking beast when it comes to beatboxing. Didn’t even think that he’d be doing this stuff
C sounded so godamn great that I just knew it was the most expensive one.
Yes, it was like asmr to me
it was shit
As a sound editor and designer, the best sound is not always the most realistic one