“$25” was the best. It actually look like an authentic pizza advertisement rather than doing too much in which it takes away the pizza aspect of the advertisement. Sometime simple is the best and better.
2-year update: 25 dollar guy went from 45 reviews to 553, and his standard package price went up to $100. He made you a commercial for $25, but your "commercial" for him was priceless! 👏
In a bunch of different ways too so that's more likely that you will see one that really clicks with you. And to top it off he's getting paid by fiverr to do this.
No the $500 guy is just did a bad edit, and it seems he has only basic editing skills, the key point of the $500 guys one was "Its in reverse", which doesn't even make sense
Although the 500$ guy is expensive - I like his style. He didn't just focus on editing but went ahead by incorporating a story so his style is so different and unique. Even without the voice over, as a viewer you would know the message he wants to give and showed it.
$25 might have been the lowest player, but he is the only one who put a piece of his soul in the commercial for every dollar he got. All hail $25 dollar guy.
25$ was great but 35$ guy imo was my top time favorite. Just the great music and it makes you feel hungry while watching with a "classy pizza with time and craft" feel kinda put into it i really like for upper middle pizza.
@T C but he has his own page on that website with his pricing policy that includes different packages, how does he suddenly change his prices so abruptly?
@@bastion5686 I thought it was good, except for the music, I think it did not combine very well, and it was very basic, I would not buy by watching that commercial
Daniel: The transitions were too abrupt and could’ve been way more smoother. Me (who has never edited a commercial in my life): Yeah totally agree, definitely not worth the price.
the sounds did not seem authentic, the pizza in the oven sounded like a close up camp fire (wood) and the sauce coming out of the bottle sounded like water boiling or peeing in a toilet bowl. other then the sound selection\design, it was great. worth wayy more then what was paid.
Professional editor and director here. I would say that all of this depends so much on the direction given to the editor. Most of the times the direction is incorporated into how the piece is going to be edited, so it's unusal to see first edits based on just the material and music alone without any direction. I like these kinds of experiments because it's a look into the creative process of the first edit, the actual one editors can do on their own before directors, producers and clients have their say. I think most of these were well done, but I don't think the price difference is really a justified comparison. Price can also be about how experienced the editor is working with directors and producers. There are many people really creative who never worked in a collaborative manner and that's where the price usually shows itself. The ability to consistently input creative quality for each and every iteration of feedback from others. So even though some high paid editors might be considered less good in these edits, they might be well worth it in a collaborative space. Since there's so much else going on in commercial editing, with target audiences, visions, company identity markers etc. it's very hard to actually know the direction just based of music and material. So I would say, all of these creative editors did a fine job. It's hard to value between them due to the factors above. But it's interesting to see how things like this plays out. It's just important to remember that editing is collaborative and that follow-up feedback run-throughs are just as much a part of the process as these first edit results.
I watched this video last year and I’m back to thank you for this video for inspiring me to work in Fiverr! Within the span of a year I became a top rated seller in tattoo design and it absolutely changed my life.
@@czarekpiast TBH the $500 edit had a great start but it kinda looked empty at the end but your $100 edit was on point. It was just amazing. Literally loved it. ♥️ You need to up your price 😂, you're skilled af.
The 500 dollar one just felt busy. Most of the other ones were kind of pleasing while the 500 dollar feels like the kind of add where I would instantly look for the "skip ad" button
One of the best cinematographer out there bro your fire 🔥🔥🔥I wonder what you would come up with? You guys should do a collaboration with DANIEL super pumped to see it actually give him your footage and he gives you his.... how about that?....
I understand everyone is setting their own price, but for 25$, that is seriously some amazing editing and I would be absolutely thrilled if I only paid 25 bucks to have my commercial like that. Some of the others were very good, but for the price, it's just amazing. 25$ hands down is the best one over all.
@@kdsingh5213 I'd imagine with few ratings it's very hard to get any jobs. Probably set his price low to start, and once he's gotten a number of reviews under his belt he'll be able to charge more.
Daniel, whenever I feel down and don't have inspiration and just wanna give up on videography, I just watch your videos and it all comes back. Thank you.
The $500 edit was the most unique, perhaps the most memorable for the customer: "oh it's pizza ad where they reverse the making of a pizza" i hated it at first look, but now i think it's kinda good
It’s still bad. Cheese coming OFF a pizza just didn‘t look appetizing. I would’ve glossed over it if I saw it on tv. Granted, I don‘t like how the b-roll was filmed in the first place, so that added on to the dislike. But the whole reverse thing with the ingredients just does not work well with cooking. People are trying to see the finished dish, not the dish being unmade, made, halfway completed, still being made, then random cheesy pizza at the end.
@@shadypalmtree2989 IMO, this is the costs more = better product fallacy at work. It was a strong, creative choice by the editor to use the reverse gimmick but it was ultimately one of the worst out of the bunch for the reasons you mentioned. It would have been better to blind taste test this rather than giving out the prices he paid for each before you saw them.
Or the type of guy underselling his services so he can rack a large clientele and then start upping his prices when he has enough visibility and the demand outpaces him.
In my opinion The $25 dollar guy was the best. Remember, you get what you pay for. Imagine if you tell him to make another video foy you. That you are willing to pay $150 . I'm sure he would do exceptional work. Money motivates us video editors. 😁.
@@frankyfrank8523 Yes! Absolutely! True.😍 It motivates me to do better. I'm a beginner video editor. Im still studying it for now. To improve my youtube channel, as well.
I think that’s why the $500 is getting a lot of hate, and a lot of love. After seeing some fantastic ads for $100 or less, theres no possible way the $500 one could differentiate enough to show $400+ worth of difference, it’s just not possible. I also think he loved the $500 so much partially because he felt he had to.
Total honesty, I love these videos. I am an amateur video editor & at first I get intimidated by the views you get & footage quality. But then watching the video I see how different all the edits can be & it is uplifting.
Same! I don’t know if these people really don’t have a refined experience with pizza or what, but the most appetising appearance of the pizza is when it is in the oven; not when sad and flat looking ingredients are being scooped from metal Subway containers. Cheese melting and forming bubbles, the fire cracking, the ingredients changing colour from the heat... that’s what makes someone’s mouth water. Pizza in Italy is a refined experience every single time, and that’s what every pizza commercial should be aiming.
With the $500 edit, that is somebody who took your footage and did something outside the box with it rather than just putting it in a sequence. You can tell that is somebody who's done some freelance work and knows how to put a creative spin on it, I loved it!
That's what I loved so much about it- I was so caught up in how "different" it was from the rest that I didn't even notice that there was no sound design! I think with some extra polishing that would make for an amazing commercial.
I actually disagree. I feel like as an advertising, there should still be a bit of a narrative and he kind of took that away. It was more of a music video tbh
The 25$ was my favorite! He's the only one who let the finished pizza have it's moment. I love watching the whole process, but if I can barely see the end result, it's not going to do much for me as a customer.
I feel the same. I don't care what they say in voiceover, or creative video editing with beats. The smoking hot fresh out of oven pizza is what gooooood.
The last one started out great, but I thought he kind of over did the boomerang effect... I think it would have been better if he had done it one or two fewer times.
th super expensive one by the israeli chick was way better but the canadian market would be weirded out by how it goes backwards then forwards really quick.
Yes, at the start i did think that this would get boring. But hey here i am. Finished the entire video. Commented my top 3. And looking for some interesting comments.
Ik everyone's talking about the $500, $25, and $100 video edits but can we appreciate the voice overs?? I mean those were epic especially the first one.
Don’t know if has already been suggested, would have been better not knowing how much each cost until the end. Removes the unconscious bias. Pretty cool to see the difference in approach though.
You mean conscious bias, not unconscious bias because the term you’re looking for is anchoring once a price has been given before the value has been shown.
@@Montoya2005 yeah you might be right. I was having this conversation with my friends the other day of what the difference in biases are. Though I still question if the assessment on quality is intentional or not; that we assign quality based on price knowingly or not - I'm still on the fence.
The difference between the $500 edit and the $25 one is that, although the most expensive one has the best transitions, it makes the viewer a bit sick because of all the reverse shots while the $25 edit lets you pay more attention to the product (which is the whole purpose of an add) and it even makes you HUNGRYwith those shots and, specially, those sound effects of the pizza being cooked. He really needs to rise his prize!
Oh come on. The $500 one was the most creative and appealing for me. The guy that charged $25 should charge more of course, but it was nowhere near the $500 one.
Agreed. There is something to be said about just letting the viewer see the hot, steaming, moist food. 500 dollar is certainly the best edited, but the goal isn't to win an editing competition, it's to sell pizza.
What!? That 25$ edit is insane man! The 500$ one started of insanely good but lost me at the midpoint though. The 100$ was great and has to be my favourite along with Gregs voice over. Awesome video!
The 500$ one might be the most video-technically unique, however from a marketing standpoint I would prefer the 25$ one. Edit: Wow, I guess a lot of people agree. Thanks for boosting my self esteem:) Now I guess it's time for the shameless plug: I try my best to create videos that are both effective and video-technically unique, so if you're interested I'd highly appreciate if you took the time to check some of them out!
Trygve Hals Butenschøn came here to say exactly this. Great display of skill for a reel, but won’t sell more pizzas. I’d go with the Lukas voiceover one, if it was my store.
This was actually really intriguing video idea. I have always edited things for a very specific niche, but seeing how all there people made this footage work was amazing. That fact that he would pay $500 for that top one really forces me to take a second look at “silly YT stuff”
When i saw the 25$ one i couldnt imagine how good the rest could become, but at the end they werent that impressive, its just that the 25$ guy is way too cheap for his quality
The 25$ Commercial made the pizza look really fresh and appetizing. I thought it might just be because it was the first one that I watched so I had to rewatch it again afterwards but I got to say that from a consumer perspective, the 25$ commercial looked the most appealing to me. The other ones were... Too flashy, idk. I don't want to see a pizza being disassembled, rofl. I'm surprised you ranked the 25$ so low. I Dont know about editing but I Dont care. The objective was to make the best commercial ad right? The best edited video would be the most appealing one rather than the most flashy one in this case.
not really true trust me ive been used by many companies be their go-to boy to call in when they need someone and always get complimented on the work then soon as I ask for more Im cut loose
@@Skylance87 I'd say it's more easily misunderstood. Don't be the cheap option, but you always want to beat expectations. Good enough isn't good enough to be anybody.
But at what point would you say he should had stopped it since the concept for that one was deconstructing it and quickly adding it all back together for the end.
You should've, somehow, done more of a blind reveal. So you rank them without know who's is who's. Someone else should've received and renamed the files so that you had to guess which one was what. I would've loved for you to try and guess to see which one was worth $500. Also, this would've allowed all the viewers to play along. We too could've determined which video was worth what. AND when you give the big reveal at the end, it would've encouraged us to go back and review (which would increase your RUclips watchtime). Great video, nonetheless.
Good idea! This could be done in a future video, that would be nice. Also thoughtful for the "viewers to play along", it's efficient for sure, I'm someone who does go back to check and compare with my opinions.
Yeah, when you buy something expensive, you're stigmatized to feel you've made the right choice. Because the alternative is grief over lost benefits, a feeling one wouldn't want to impose on themselves.
I feel like a more telling challenge would be to ask these editors what they can do with footage that is NOT that good. That footage is very nice. It didn't take a lot to make it look that good, and it was all shot in a way that already begged for pretty specific ramps and fast cuts. But if you're an editor on here you know the real challenge is when a client gives you bizzare, disjointed crap, random frame rates and requests a bunch of text and cuts from terrible interviews, etc. A good editor can kill it with good OR bad footage.
@@kingprone7846 Defiantly shows that the video sponsor wants the higher tier editors to be perceived as worth the price tag, when the video actually demonstrated the underpaid editors do solid work.
@@CoriStrell On the other hand, it seems that in pure effort time, the $500 one spent most hours on the editing, so it would warrant the highest price tag. However, if you spent twice as much time on a video edit as others to add extra effects it doesn't mean you're the best at editing of course. But you're right, there's so many fiverr review vids out there, it's a definite pattern ;-)
Nope he does its also a business strategy you offer a service for cheap so you get two things experience and customers Experience goes a long way which in his case hes delivering more than hes paid for and getting better reviews for it he'll be the one not available for less than 500 in coming years
how do you know the $25 one wasn't some 14 year old kid's side hustle? or someone in the global south where $25usd is a LOT of money for 0.5-2 hours of simple yet mentally engaging desk work. just because YOU find good value in something doesn't mean it's produced by "that poor guy who doesn't know his value".
WUT. The technical skill and creativity for the $500 video was worth that much, but it was confusing af as a pizza commercial. It's disorienting to see a product being unmade for almost a full 30 second commercial. It's fine as a fun creative flair for one shot, but confusing when the whole commercial is like that. Oh and the second VO was fucking fantastic.
Bruh that $500 take was fresh af boi, it gave me the illusion of feeling and smelling how fresh the produce looked and being put together quickly to be cooked then served is the big idea of a fast food like pizza.
Yeah bro when you hear the catching sound you are like... sh@t another annoying add... because the amount of add you hear daily.. so the music play a role in the people who are annoyed with the adds when they want to watch something....... only to clarify.... FACEBOOK=ANNOYING
“$25” was the best. It actually look like an authentic pizza advertisement rather than doing too much in which it takes away the pizza aspect of the advertisement. Sometime simple is the best and better.
jeremy lar I agree
agreed that last one if that came on as an ad or on tv... I would just shut my t.v off lol
Ryan Mattei LOOOL
I liked the $275 one the most
$25 one is definitely 2nd for me though
I get why you're saying this but from creative standpoints, the last guy definitely tops the list. He would place solid 2nd tho.
25$ is underselling his skills too much.... I felt sad :( He's easily one of the most worth in this episode.
Some Fivers who are just getting started will start with low pricing to get clients and receive top ratings. Then they can start to up their price!
yeaaaah!!! :( he should be a 100$ + option... easy... :(
Bro yes, the first and the second guy were the best
So true
That always happens to a really talented people, cuz we're all humble af
this guy just finessed us into watching an ad for 10 minutes
now that is big brain advertising
Lmao
😂😂😂
He used 100% of his brain to advertise a video
turtleyanddoggy the same ad*
😂😂😂😂
2-year update: 25 dollar guy went from 45 reviews to 553, and his standard package price went up to $100. He made you a commercial for $25, but your "commercial" for him was priceless! 👏
Oh, that's exactly what I was hoping to find in the comments. I'm absolutely happy for this guy
Nice info bro
Im so happy for the guy
Nice observation bro way to bring something to the table we actually want to see 👍 updates are great 😊
Wow
When a 25$ stranger does better than a high prestige advertising company.
@Harry Sachs someone hurt u or something?
vigtak what’s your profile picture I forgot it
Imagine being named Hairy Sacks, you'd be butthurt too lmao
@@wasreallygoodnikka I shouldn't have laughed at this
@@unusedaccount7358 a stormtrooper from star wars
me: *skips a 20 second ad that could actually be useful*
also me: *willingly watches a 13 minute video of a pizza ad*
Dchan2005 you win for best comment lol
@@jellybean1528 HAHAHA true
No youtube ad ever helped me tbh
Dchan2005 LMAOO ME
A vídeo of a pizza commercial where You see the actual comercial and the autor gets money for the views
This guy is a genious, he found out how to make people watch your commercial over and over for 13 minutes.
underrated comment, I genuinely want to try this pizza
Somehow his pizza ad is more interesting than any actual youtube ad i watched
And I still don't remember the name of it lol
In a bunch of different ways too so that's more likely that you will see one that really clicks with you. And to top it off he's getting paid by fiverr to do this.
He he got paid twice for the video. Once from Fiverr and again from RUclips.
Him: they gave me the edits quite fast huh
Them probably: free creative direction with good quality footage???!!!! *drops every other project*
Can't agree more xD
Haha, surely this would have happened.
ruclips.net/video/0Gp_BHTK8VM/видео.html
That's exactly it!
This would be an absolute dream for me 😅
The $25 guy undervalued himself soo much that people hating on the $500 guy.
The $500 one was confusing, though.
@@socrattt yeah
No the $500 guy is just did a bad edit, and it seems he has only basic editing skills, the key point of the $500 guys one was "Its in reverse", which doesn't even make sense
Although the 500$ guy is expensive - I like his style. He didn't just focus on editing but went ahead by incorporating a story so his style is so different and unique. Even without the voice over, as a viewer you would know the message he wants to give and showed it.
Yeah 25 is too less for that
$25 might have been the lowest player, but he is the only one who put a piece of his soul in the commercial for every dollar he got.
All hail $25 dollar guy.
25$ was great but 35$ guy imo was my top time favorite. Just the great music and it makes you feel hungry while watching with a "classy pizza with time and craft" feel kinda put into it i really like for upper middle pizza.
I know that guy from school he used to be in the class above me. A mate just now showed me the video
@T C but he has his own page on that website with his pricing policy that includes different packages, how does he suddenly change his prices so abruptly?
@@bastion5686 I thought it was good, except for the music, I think it did not combine very well, and it was very basic, I would not buy by watching that commercial
@@bastion5686 You do realize he had to remove the original music the editor actually put there, for copyright reasons.
Daniel: The transitions were too abrupt and could’ve been way more smoother.
Me (who has never edited a commercial in my life): Yeah totally agree, definitely not worth the price.
Me at the end: I want pizza
Khajiit has wares hi i have hot pockets pepperoni + a microwavable pizza and im planning to order dominos
Aldo when you don't like a dance in dancing with stars and then the judges says "i give it a 10" and then you say "yes the best dance ever"
@@khajiithaswares4147 me at the end: I am pretty enoyed by the songs but I would like some pizza
hahahah
When you see the 25$ guy’s ending, then all the rest become worthless
💚Jesus lived the life we couldn't live and died the death we deserve. Repent of your sins and trust in Him💙
only the 100$ czarekpiast one can compete
@@Rubiecat I agree
@Daughter of the King
Fuck Jesus. Cry
@@ngirlsdiary wtf
The $25 guy needs to up his price.
all of them!
the best one in my opinion
Yup, I agree absolutely, especially after this endorsement.
also the 35 bucks
Definitely Tho He Needs to Upgrade through Different Aspects tho he is Good 🙌
When you realize you just got tricked into watching 13 minutes of PI CO ads...
Oh wait, Did I just watch A lot of Ads for 13mins straight after skipping an Ad?
Modern problem need modern solution.
NATESOR this RUclips video is the best pico pizza ad
and now i'm sad i cant go to pi co
Dammmm i just realize
The first voiceover guy sounds more like he should be narrating documentaries
I know right. He’s almost as good as David Attenborough
timmy Turner
he sounds like he’s tryna give me the Wabbajack
I wonder if that's why the video literally showed a scene from documentary he narrated... and said he's clearly good at what he does.
He sounds like the narrator from “The Stanley Parable”
You know it’s good when Daniel rips the score paper 😂
PRICELESS!!!
Yep
2222
The first one you could hear a crackling fire at the oven, that is the one thing that sold me. First video was the best. That was an excellent touch.
funny I thought that was so cheesy and didnt fit
I think the fire was great but the water sound was not neccessary
@Egan314 Yeah, if it was a little bit more subtle, that'd be even better
@@daltonkackerman cheesy is the point. It's a pizza ad.
the sounds did not seem authentic, the pizza in the oven sounded like a close up camp fire (wood) and the sauce coming out of the bottle sounded like water boiling or peeing in a toilet bowl. other then the sound selection\design, it was great. worth wayy more then what was paid.
When you realize this guy got you to watch the same ad 25 times
Yea
Wow🤣
LMAO.
@AgestaDesu that’s so funny, almost everyone on RUclips can’t wait to skip 5 second ads but we can watch a 10 minutes video of ads 😂😂😂
RUclips: you have to watch this 30 second ad
Me: wow how annoying
RUclips: here’s the same ad for 10 minutes
Me: hell yea I’ll watch that
Bruh 😂
Plot Twist: It actually is a RUclips ad.
Jazmin Lopez underrated comment 😂
well played bait.
Ooh man😂😂
Professional editor and director here. I would say that all of this depends so much on the direction given to the editor. Most of the times the direction is incorporated into how the piece is going to be edited, so it's unusal to see first edits based on just the material and music alone without any direction. I like these kinds of experiments because it's a look into the creative process of the first edit, the actual one editors can do on their own before directors, producers and clients have their say. I think most of these were well done, but I don't think the price difference is really a justified comparison. Price can also be about how experienced the editor is working with directors and producers. There are many people really creative who never worked in a collaborative manner and that's where the price usually shows itself. The ability to consistently input creative quality for each and every iteration of feedback from others. So even though some high paid editors might be considered less good in these edits, they might be well worth it in a collaborative space. Since there's so much else going on in commercial editing, with target audiences, visions, company identity markers etc. it's very hard to actually know the direction just based of music and material.
So I would say, all of these creative editors did a fine job. It's hard to value between them due to the factors above. But it's interesting to see how things like this plays out. It's just important to remember that editing is collaborative and that follow-up feedback run-throughs are just as much a part of the process as these first edit results.
I guess the only one who is bad here is the one who didn't respect the 30 seconds requirement then
is your last name Nolan 😲
Insolvo is netter than Fiverr
The $25 guy needs to charge more and not undervalue himself. I enjoyed his the most.
I thought that one was one of the best too
He proved that you can get professional level work done at cheap prices
Some charge very low rates in the beginning to get their reputation up, and then when they have a high reputation, they can raise their rates later.
@@ElijahLynn Smart thinking
I agree
I’m surprised I just watched the ‘same’ commercial for 12 minutes.
Right? I’m even more surprised I was having a blast
Right? Was the video sponsored by Fiverr or by PI Co?
its ok..i..,was...watching you the last 12h..
btw PETER how breakfast? looked yummy
eatpeople420 Then what did i get for breakfast?
wow quarantine really out here got me watching pizza commercials lmfao
it really be like that dough
Haha!
Same lmao
Iamoo same
Im laughing so hard cause of this, thanks dude
I watched this video last year and I’m back to thank you for this video for inspiring me to work in Fiverr! Within the span of a year I became a top rated seller in tattoo design and it absolutely changed my life.
Congratulations
The 25$ guy needs to up his prices and the 500$ guy needs an uppercut
I swear, he got finessed so hard I feel bad for him 💀
I wish I looked like that when I walk into a room.
Thank you. The $500 video was garbage.
500 is an insult
this made me laugh harder then it should have lol
The 100$ czarekpiast is the best for me, and the 25$ guy needs to raise their price
aye! yeah I vote for the $100 guy he nailed it! 500 was next level, 25 needs to charge more XD
Your words.. my emotions!! 😁
I agree with ur point
CzarekPiast. He is probably from my Country :D
Yes thats right
Super happy that you like my edit! The $500 is so damn impressive though.
Did you know this was a challenge all along??????
@@danielschiffer I was not quite sure, to be honest!
@@czarekpiast TBH the $500 edit had a great start but it kinda looked empty at the end but your $100 edit was on point. It was just amazing. Literally loved it. ♥️ You need to up your price 😂, you're skilled af.
nice
Your's is the best value!
“This is the best I’ve seen so far” my dude they are all so strikingly similar.
The 500 dollar one just felt busy. Most of the other ones were kind of pleasing while the 500 dollar feels like the kind of add where I would instantly look for the "skip ad" button
too much of the same effects for 500$, he used the same effect like 8-9 times xD
Yeaah. The only thing that i liked about that one was the use of the logo at the beginning. But... that´s it.
Yea I agree. Did not like the $500 one.
same he just spammed the reverse... did not like it
the 500 bucks video had a weak outro and weird concept but that intro was fire and probably the best one.
That Greg Johnson guy has a chance in the voice over community. He just has that voice that you can picture on any commercial.
gEiCo
He sounds exactly like the youtuber "Behind The Speakers"
He sounds just like the voiceover from the training videos at my job
Infographics Show much
Yeah, it's awful. Milquetoast
I feel like the $500 one was trying to sell his own editing skills more than the pizza itself
I definitely agree!
LOL so true
Lol
I didn’t like it tbh. There was just too much happening
Exactly how it feels
this is the reason why do not underestimate art (as a hobby and as a work), to all artist there, RAISE YOUR PRICES... you deserve it!!
Sending all my RUclips videos to that $25 guy, I’m killing my self for no reason lmao
You're killing yourself to give us great awesome videos YC! don't underestimate you. You rock!
One of the best cinematographer out there bro your fire 🔥🔥🔥I wonder what you would come up with? You guys should do a collaboration with DANIEL super pumped to see it actually give him your footage and he gives you his.... how about that?....
YCImaging ikrrrr😭😭😭
Well I do photography, you could try me
Love u YC
I understand everyone is setting their own price, but for 25$, that is seriously some amazing editing and I would be absolutely thrilled if I only paid 25 bucks to have my commercial like that. Some of the others were very good, but for the price, it's just amazing. 25$ hands down is the best one over all.
So on point!
I second that
@@kdsingh5213 I'd imagine with few ratings it's very hard to get any jobs. Probably set his price low to start, and once he's gotten a number of reviews under his belt he'll be able to charge more.
@@clanginator yeah he is trying to get as many ratings and jobs as possible
agree
500 ad is professional and intersting to watch, but the 25$ ad is the most tastiest one. It just feels very tasty to see that ad.
Hey how does this not have any comments yet lol
@ZeroSeven ??
It’s deffinetly the ASMR part
Daniel, whenever I feel down and don't have inspiration and just wanna give up on videography, I just watch your videos and it all comes back. Thank you.
The second voice actor sounds like the spotify ads.
What if it really is him
Lil Comedown ooOooOooOooOoooooOoooOo
𝘞𝘈𝘕𝘛 𝘈 𝘉𝘙𝘌𝘈𝘒 𝘍𝘙𝘖𝘔 𝘛𝘏𝘌 𝘈𝘋𝘚?
I knew it sounded familiar
dude come on, don`t torture yourself with that free version
You didn't search for this but it was recommended to you
Yup
😅😅😅
Hahaha hit me to the point
Yes ... but how and why 😅
Nah overused comment
The $500 edit was the most unique, perhaps the most memorable for the customer: "oh it's pizza ad where they reverse the making of a pizza"
i hated it at first look, but now i think it's kinda good
It’s still bad. Cheese coming OFF a pizza just didn‘t look appetizing. I would’ve glossed over it if I saw it on tv. Granted, I don‘t like how the b-roll was filmed in the first place, so that added on to the dislike. But the whole reverse thing with the ingredients just does not work well with cooking. People are trying to see the finished dish, not the dish being unmade, made, halfway completed, still being made, then random cheesy pizza at the end.
@@shadypalmtree2989 slow mow cool
you small pp = small brain
@@shadypalmtree2989 IMO, this is the costs more = better product fallacy at work. It was a strong, creative choice by the editor to use the reverse gimmick but it was ultimately one of the worst out of the bunch for the reasons you mentioned. It would have been better to blind taste test this rather than giving out the prices he paid for each before you saw them.
The reverse video is very common, I saw it used tens of times. Very well edited, but not really innovative... and kinda weird in some parts.
100$ is the best
Timestamps of all the editors just in case it's helpful
2:51 SheppardMedia $25
3:51 LiamDixon $35
4:35 ChrisaxWorthy $65
4:53 RiotaFoya $75
5:40 GisMoxan $85
6:06 Czarekpiast $100
7:01 Elapero $100
7:43 Matteo505 $120
8:30 IamMacmClean $125
9:29 GregJohnsonVoic $160
10:37 LucasSachs $275
11:38 FeldmanRonny $500
THANK U
The $25 guy is the kind of person who thinks his work isn't good enought. I hope he saw this video and up his price. I really loved it!
Or the type of guy underselling his services so he can rack a large clientele and then start upping his prices when he has enough visibility and the demand outpaces him.
@@avrgegmer1396 it’s hard to get there my guy. People get pigeon holed into low pricing unless they move or never lowball in the first place
In my opinion The $25 dollar guy was the best. Remember, you get what you pay for. Imagine if you tell him to make another video foy you. That you are willing to pay $150 . I'm sure he would do exceptional work. Money motivates us video editors. 😁.
Yes! I agree, it really catches my attention. Excellent video.editing $25 guy. 😀💪😍💪
@@frankyfrank8523 Yes! Absolutely! True.😍 It motivates me to do better. I'm a beginner video editor. Im still studying it for now. To improve my youtube channel, as well.
Next time, rate all the videos without seeing the price tags and then reveal the prices for each of them
I think that’s why the $500 is getting a lot of hate, and a lot of love. After seeing some fantastic ads for $100 or less, theres no possible way the $500 one could differentiate enough to show $400+ worth of difference, it’s just not possible. I also think he loved the $500 so much partially because he felt he had to.
@@mileschicken1 people is kinda biased towards the 500 one. I know it's overpriced, but despite of that saying it's the worst is a bit over the top.
Exactly this. Blind test or no test.
@@mileschicken1 its not possible to show that much extra value because of the law if diminishing returns
If anyone knows the $25 guy, tell him to up his price ! He’s better than most of them.
Jasmine Faith cap
he's called sheppardmedia in fiverr
exactly 😝
Nah the 35$ one was best
Guys they all stole the video from a guy he made a review of his shots
Total honesty, I love these videos. I am an amateur video editor & at first I get intimidated by the views you get & footage quality. But then watching the video I see how different all the edits can be & it is uplifting.
$25 Needs a raise...
- Sound effects
- Color Grading
- Visual Effects
- Transitions
I would say his worth around 75 or over
@David Amaya i hope that was a joke
David Amaya yeh you wish
EXACTLY
Gelo agree. Still like his vid the most lol !
yup
is no one talking about how well the greg voice over was synced with the commercial????
Read the comments. That's all anyone is talking about
He probably sent the commercial for them to VO over it.
@@idontthink He gave them the text, so...
for real tho
Just didn't like how he said "Pizza"
The crackling fire on the $25 woulda sold me immediately.
True!
I also loved the guzzle noise of the sauce bottle
Should have been leveled a little better panned slightly and had some eq
Same! I don’t know if these people really don’t have a refined experience with pizza or what, but the most appetising appearance of the pizza is when it is in the oven; not when sad and flat looking ingredients are being scooped from metal Subway containers. Cheese melting and forming bubbles, the fire cracking, the ingredients changing colour from the heat... that’s what makes someone’s mouth water. Pizza in Italy is a refined experience every single time, and that’s what every pizza commercial should be aiming.
That audio is from a fireplace tho..it sounded slightly off to my ears. Idk if anybody else agrees.
The 25$ bucks one deserves top 1 in my opinion. The 500$ is very good, at is at least second, but the 25$ one is by far the most effective
"What can I get for $500?"
"I can reverse your footage."
😂 I thought the same
He was watching Jojo while making the ad
lmfaooooo
the daniel guy know nothing about commercial or editing :)
*reverses footage* OMG BEST THING I'VE EVER SEEN.
With the $500 edit, that is somebody who took your footage and did something outside the box with it rather than just putting it in a sequence. You can tell that is somebody who's done some freelance work and knows how to put a creative spin on it, I loved it!
That's what I loved so much about it- I was so caught up in how "different" it was from the rest that I didn't even notice that there was no sound design! I think with some extra polishing that would make for an amazing commercial.
spot on!
@@danielschiffer at some point the video lost the magical touch.. I don't know why exactly, but that's how it felt like, look at Peters reply
I actually disagree. I feel like as an advertising, there should still be a bit of a narrative and he kind of took that away. It was more of a music video tbh
@@niijosiah just needed to be shorter. The deconstruction part was a tad too long
RUclips: here’s a random 20 second commercial
Me: no way! Skip
RUclips: here’s 10 30 second pizza commercials
Me: Don’t mind if I do
and with the same footage*
Damn you're so right hahaha, i just feel so stupid now because of you😂😂
So true! That's what a worldwide lock down does to the brain...
I sometimes just listen to the music
But if there's voice-over it's an instant skip,
So I just kinda zoned out like that.
Even better, you watched a 10:30 pizza commercial that was actually a 10:30 commercial for Fivver. INCEPTION!
Everybody worrying about the 25 $ guy.
Me : I just want a pizza now.
Nope, its for 100$ guy , was the best editing.
@@sasmalprasanjit2764 We're here talking about Pizza. Eating it.
I reckon I could swallow a pizza rn
@@lvcasvarela I’m with you on that one
FOOD. PIZZA . HEAVEN
that's all I gotta say for this comment bro
The 25$ was my favorite! He's the only one who let the finished pizza have it's moment. I love watching the whole process, but if I can barely see the end result, it's not going to do much for me as a customer.
I feel the same. I don't care what they say in voiceover, or creative video editing with beats. The smoking hot fresh out of oven pizza is what gooooood.
Let it breathe!
I agree. The $25 was my favorite. Should've been $250 at least.
As an avid pizza eater (not video editor), I'd say the $500 one was worth $25 and the $25 one was worth $500.
Same lmao
Those little fire crackle sounds in the $25 were so nice!
Agreed I think the deconstruction part and the too many transitions were overkill, 25 dollars was way better
Dusin Bonnema truuue
Same
I really love your videos, Daniel😊. The way you appreciate the editors for their work while respectfully explaining any minor errors is just amazing👏👏
The $500 ad was “un-making” a pizza.
True
Agreee🤣
My exact first thought. Lol.
It was more like someone who just learned how to reverse a video and spammed it
@@aidanfundora1641 HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHA DAMN BROO
Did I search for this: no
Did I watch till the end: yes
Did I enjoy: extremely yes
Same
That's literally the point of the algorithm.
Same
Did I asked: no!!
@@harshaljamdade2733 yeah but 100+ people did and by commenting to this, it shows that u actually care
25$ guy needs to get serious about his life and finances.
his probably some indian guy who charges cheap
@@dareko988 lol.......dont think so
He's been burnt by too many "friends" who need a "favor" that he doesn't know his worth.
Nah, I think he deserves $10 for having no ambition.
He probably spent an hour on this.
6:06 That was my favorite one. Awesome use of split screen and also going back in time in one of the shots.
The logo in the ending part of the $25 guy was extremely good. Only that ending is worth $25.
True
TRUE
And the sound effects!
That's soo true
What's the name of this guy I want to use him haha
All the guys : Start to finish
The last guy : Reverse -Uno-
Last guy wins.
Underrated comment!
The last one started out great, but I thought he kind of over did the boomerang effect... I think it would have been better if he had done it one or two fewer times.
AStoeckle fr like at first it was impressive but then it just dragged on lol
@@misoasoda340 I don't think it's worth 500. At first, it was stunning, however, putting a video in reverse isn't too difficult.
Cowmilla
Me: Ew that was horrible!
Daniel: That was amazing!
Me: Amazing! Wonderful.
HAHAHAHAHAHA
which one lol i liked them all exepct for the 1st voiceover one
Hahahhahahhahahahah
Yea - man I did not get why he said the $275 guy was good - I did not like his music choice....
Yea - man I did not get why he said the $275 guy was good - I did not like his music choice....
I have never taken an interest in editing like this before this video. Wow thanks :)
Plot Twist: He edited all this himself and didn't spent a single buck on the site.
You mean plot twist?
@@someone_random1049 same thing
MF Ver.02 pro No, not the same thing. Fun fact is a truth. Plot twist can be considered a joke and is the complete opposite.
@@anniembus6488 oh... thanks for information.
I fixed it now again thanks
Lul
Imagine if 25$ dollar guy was getting paid 500 instead
@• ganja Jesus loves you
@@S_u_n_Flower_ yes
God's Girl amen
@God's Girl hallelujah
25$ guy cant even color granding clip tbh...
9:47 to 10:11 is absolutely phenomenal, that’s the ad, I would’ve bought a pizza.
th super expensive one by the israeli chick was way better but the canadian market would be weirded out by how it goes backwards then forwards really quick.
Insulting to professional editors and basically a 10 minute ad like Seto says. He's lucky he found an editor who undersells themselves.
*Next video: WITHOUT seeing the price, try to guess how much you paid for each.* - as always, great video Daniel!
Dope idea 👌
Yep
e nada de video né?
Exactly what I was thinking. My jr.high science classes had an entire unit on bias and how to avoid it and no one ever seems to consider that.
Bro yee
RUclips should hire this guy, he just brainwashed us into watching a same ad 12 times and that also with interest...😂
Lol I agree 😂
this 😂😂😂
Yes, at the start i did think that this would get boring.
But hey here i am.
Finished the entire video.
Commented my top 3.
And looking for some interesting comments.
Epic advertisement
now i want the damn pizza
y’all realize how we always skip ads but we rewatched the same pizza commercial over and over but enjoyed it😳😳
If it's good, it's good:)
you my friend are an intellectual
This comment is what im looking for
I have AdBlock so I never get ads.
Yes, but nowadays all ads are just shitty and mind numbingly bad animated mobile game ads. And csgo roll.
Ik everyone's talking about the $500, $25, and $100 video edits but can we appreciate the voice overs?? I mean those were epic especially the first one.
The pizza restaurant: wait, we're selling more than we should
Wait, thats ilegal
@@RRivera10 totally illegal!
PICO getting the most free advertising ever... I'm sure they're happy with their purchase eh? 😂
you right :D
Where I'm at we have similar restaurants. Blaze is the main one, I love them and really want to try PICO now!
i wanna try pico
Seth Young blaze is so good
plot twist: they paid him to do this
rich people: buying house, cars...
*actually rich people: paying 25$ to a guy who only charges 10$ on fiver*
But Fiverr payed him for all of this so...
?
tom
*M R. B E A S T. I N T E N S I F I E S.*
tom
The funny thing is that the first clip was from he guy who started the charge for $10, and honestly that’s very good
@@robertbath3122 that's a thing called "joke"
Greg Johnsons voice over clip made me wanna cry it was so good :)
Don’t know if has already been suggested, would have been better not knowing how much each cost until the end. Removes the unconscious bias. Pretty cool to see the difference in approach though.
right on
You mean conscious bias, not unconscious bias because the term you’re looking for is anchoring once a price has been given before the value has been shown.
@@Montoya2005 you actually mean subconscious bias
Great idea for the next video. Hopefully he does one of these again..
@@Montoya2005 yeah you might be right. I was having this conversation with my friends the other day of what the difference in biases are. Though I still question if the assessment on quality is intentional or not; that we assign quality based on price knowingly or not - I'm still on the fence.
The difference between the $500 edit and the $25 one is that, although the most expensive one has the best transitions, it makes the viewer a bit sick because of all the reverse shots while the $25 edit lets you pay more attention to the product (which is the whole purpose of an add) and it even makes you HUNGRYwith those shots and, specially, those sound effects of the pizza being cooked. He really needs to rise his prize!
Totally! I feel like the £500 one was amazing for like a hiphop music video but definitely not an ad
Oh come on. The $500 one was the most creative and appealing for me. The guy that charged $25 should charge more of course, but it was nowhere near the $500 one.
The $500 was amazing, got me chills with a pizza commercial and now I am hungry
Funny because for me the 25$ gives me a bit of motion sickness with the rapid zooms and turns. He definitely needs to raise his price tho.
Agreed. There is something to be said about just letting the viewer see the hot, steaming, moist food. 500 dollar is certainly the best edited, but the goal isn't to win an editing competition, it's to sell pizza.
"plays the whole stuff backwards"
"yep, this 500$ was definitely worth it"
I agree with that
the 500$ one was weird... xD
It was really good doe
it was the skill,the creativity,the smoothness and that CC WAS OFF THE HOOK
It was cool but to much.
Besides the ultra professional $500 one, i thought the $35 ad was it. Loved the movement and the way it flowed with beat. Super nice.
What!? That 25$ edit is insane man!
The 500$ one started of insanely good but lost me at the midpoint though.
The 100$ was great and has to be my favourite along with Gregs voice over.
Awesome video!
hello peter!!!!! nice to see you here!!
I wonder how will you do it, your edits are just insane 🤯
hey peter! i thought the same
Totally agree, Peter. I'm already looking over my client list to find a project where I can use Greg or Mac
yeah the pacing of the $500 one was not good
The 500$ one might be the most video-technically unique, however from a marketing standpoint I would prefer the 25$ one.
Edit: Wow, I guess a lot of people agree. Thanks for boosting my self esteem:)
Now I guess it's time for the shameless plug: I try my best to create videos that are both effective and video-technically unique, so if you're interested I'd highly appreciate if you took the time to check some of them out!
I agree with Trygve. The $500 one was pyrotechnics. The $25 one sold pizza.
Yass
No the oil noise at 3:14 is cringe
Trygve Hals Butenschøn came here to say exactly this. Great display of skill for a reel, but won’t sell more pizzas. I’d go with the Lukas voiceover one, if it was my store.
Yeah. It was way too complicated which kind of makes you focus on the editing rather than the product.
I watched so many fast transition effects that I finally got sick!
Someone verified with 0 likes :o
second reply
Transition makes u sick😉
The $500 guy ; *Looks Like He is A 7 Years Old Kid who Learned To Use Reverse Transition Just a Moment ago for the First Time*
@@s_.4if hahaha
This was actually really intriguing video idea. I have always edited things for a very specific niche, but seeing how all there people made this footage work was amazing. That fact that he would pay $500 for that top one really forces me to take a second look at “silly YT stuff”
When i saw the 25$ one i couldnt imagine how good the rest could become, but at the end they werent that impressive, its just that the 25$ guy is way too cheap for his quality
it actually was a $75 edit he just put in the video it was $25
@@entxtyvisuals797 the guy might have upped his price after this video
@@schwanzkopf400 good for him
@@lunecker it is but in my mind that propably the reason why its more expensive now than stated in this video
The 25$ Commercial made the pizza look really fresh and appetizing.
I thought it might just be because it was the first one that I watched so I had to rewatch it again afterwards but I got to say that from a consumer perspective, the 25$ commercial looked the most appealing to me.
The other ones were... Too flashy, idk. I don't want to see a pizza being disassembled, rofl. I'm surprised you ranked the 25$ so low.
I Dont know about editing but I Dont care. The objective was to make the best commercial ad right?
The best edited video would be the most appealing one rather than the most flashy one in this case.
"The man who does more than he is paid for will soon be paid for more than he does." -Napoleon Hill
“That’s a STEAL!”
-Daniel shcipher
not really true trust me ive been used by many companies be their go-to boy to call in when they need someone and always get complimented on the work then soon as I ask for more Im cut loose
@@Skylance87 I'd say it's more easily misunderstood.
Don't be the cheap option, but you always want to beat expectations. Good enough isn't good enough to be anybody.
@@seigeengine nah philosophers are the scums of the earth, next to journalist
ALLAH equality. there is no god but he.
25$ Guy did his best smoothly done as Peter Lindgren said Well "Done is better than Perfect"
who is peter lindgren?
me doing my school project back in highschool:
@@painandmisery8971 I always feel like I can do so much better on some of my HW's but hey, it's done
$25*
@@myrabbitispink en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Lindgren_(musician)
the beginning of the 500 bucks was absolutely sick, caught my attention instantly which is in a commercial probably the best thing
The $500 one had way too much reversing for me to like it. If he held off on so much reversing then it would have easily been the best imo
Hi afrogum
But at what point would you say he should had stopped it since the concept for that one was deconstructing it and quickly adding it all back together for the end.
@@twistiicuber1055 hey fellow cubers
Yeah, I actually felt similarly. Just felt odd to me having the pizza being *de*constructed lol
yeah i was like just give me the pizza already lol
You should've, somehow, done more of a blind reveal. So you rank them without know who's is who's. Someone else should've received and renamed the files so that you had to guess which one was what. I would've loved for you to try and guess to see which one was worth $500.
Also, this would've allowed all the viewers to play along. We too could've determined which video was worth what.
AND when you give the big reveal at the end, it would've encouraged us to go back and review (which would increase your RUclips watchtime).
Great video, nonetheless.
Good idea! This could be done in a future video, that would be nice. Also thoughtful for the "viewers to play along", it's efficient for sure, I'm someone who does go back to check and compare with my opinions.
and very good opinion and comment.
Agreed!!
agreed!
Yeah, when you buy something expensive, you're stigmatized to feel you've made the right choice. Because the alternative is grief over lost benefits, a feeling one wouldn't want to impose on themselves.
I feel like a more telling challenge would be to ask these editors what they can do with footage that is NOT that good. That footage is very nice. It didn't take a lot to make it look that good, and it was all shot in a way that already begged for pretty specific ramps and fast cuts. But if you're an editor on here you know the real challenge is when a client gives you bizzare, disjointed crap, random frame rates and requests a bunch of text and cuts from terrible interviews, etc. A good editor can kill it with good OR bad footage.
Yes, the footage from clients, are never good.
I feel like that's all I've ever worked with, so you're giving me hope that when I DO get some good footage, I'll knock it out of the park.
Bro the way at 11:47 the cheese being put on syncs with the music, sooooo good
$500 edit: it’s either “why is everything in reverse??” OR “the buildup of the commercial’s plot leads to the foundation of the pizza.”
Worst Shot of the video tbh
I feel like if that editor found a way to make the reverse more subtle, it would definitely be good.
the 500 dollar one completely missed the point and sucked.
@@kingprone7846 Defiantly shows that the video sponsor wants the higher tier editors to be perceived as worth the price tag, when the video actually demonstrated the underpaid editors do solid work.
@@CoriStrell On the other hand, it seems that in pure effort time, the $500 one spent most hours on the editing, so it would warrant the highest price tag. However, if you spent twice as much time on a video edit as others to add extra effects it doesn't mean you're the best at editing of course. But you're right, there's so many fiverr review vids out there, it's a definite pattern ;-)
$25 he is the mhan not the $500 one , we vote that poor guy who doesn’t know his value
Nope he does its also a business strategy you offer a service for cheap so you get two things experience and customers
Experience goes a long way which in his case hes delivering more than hes paid for and getting better reviews for it he'll be the one not available for less than 500 in coming years
how do you know the $25 one wasn't some 14 year old kid's side hustle? or someone in the global south where $25usd is a LOT of money for 0.5-2 hours of simple yet mentally engaging desk work. just because YOU find good value in something doesn't mean it's produced by "that poor guy who doesn't know his value".
No one:
The ad skip button: I'm about to end this whole man's career
Yunoza v2 this comment needs more likes
Yunoza v2
Unless it force us to actually watch the ad...
But if it was a good ad than it’s not a lost...
God this meme never gets old
It's not fast food, it's not fine din-
Im the 1000 like hahahah
For $500 you’re not paying for technical ability you’re paying for vision and execution
If you see vision and execution from the $500 edit, don’t be an editor. That was the wackiest edit ever
Dude with the $500 is on a totally different level than anybody else. But I could go with that $25 too! 😁
I agree but the boomerang effect is kinda bruh on some part.
That was the worst one though. Reversing the video? WOW SO CREATIVE!
@@pawesomepal7827 jeez
True!!!
it's a woman from israel not a dude.
WUT. The technical skill and creativity for the $500 video was worth that much, but it was confusing af as a pizza commercial. It's disorienting to see a product being unmade for almost a full 30 second commercial. It's fine as a fun creative flair for one shot, but confusing when the whole commercial is like that. Oh and the second VO was fucking fantastic.
"ooh this is the voice-over, ok I'm pumped to hear this" cuts to ad "let's play raid shadow legends!"
VikingNOR Gaming i got a dominos pizza ad lmao
I got the same ad lol
@@Xenquility mine was one of those cringey MLBB skit ads
Same dude 😂😂😂
Bruh that $500 take was fresh af boi, it gave me the illusion of feeling and smelling how fresh the produce looked and being put together quickly to be cooked then served is the big idea of a fast food like pizza.
the 500$ one is something id skip in a heartbeat.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yeah bro when you hear the catching sound you are like... sh@t another annoying add... because the amount of add you hear daily.. so the music play a role in the people who are annoyed with the adds when they want to watch something....... only to clarify.... FACEBOOK=ANNOYING
@@magicalwizard9539 o5uy
HAHA RUclips PREMIUM DONT GET NO ADS BEST MONEY SPENT
@@deez7217 just get ad block lol