Ranking $4000 of Creed Cologne (11 BEST & WORST Fragrances!)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 июл 2024
- Our definitive ranking and comparison of different Creed Fragrances: gentl.mn/creed-cologne-fragra...
#creed #colognes #notsponsored
SHOP THE VIDEO:
→ Moss Green Pocket Square with Printed Geometric Medallions: gentl.mn/green-geometric-meda...
→ Black & White Solid Socks: gentl.mn/black-white-two-tone...
GUIDES YOU DON'T WANT TO MISS:
→ Creed Fragrances - Is It Worth It?: gentl.mn/creed-fragrances
→ Moncler Jackets - Is It Worth It?: gentl.mn/moncler-jackets1
→ Canada Goose Jackets - Is It Worth It?: gentl.mn/canada-goose-jackets1
VIDEO CREDITS:
→ Script: Jack Collins & Teresa C. Schneider
→ Camera: Chris Dummer
→ Editing: Jonathan Oster
→ Visual Supervision: Preston Schlueter & Jack Collins
FRAGRANCE TESTING:
→ Kyle Thibodeaux
→ Teresa C. Schneider
→ Nathan Price
→ Chris Dummer
→ Preston Schlueter
→ Sven Raphael Schneider
Want to see more videos? Subscribe to our channel!
→ gentl.mn/youtube
Become a part of the Gentleman's Gazette community - support us on Patreon!
gentl.mn/patron
__________________________________________________________
Gentleman's Gazette
gentl.mn/gg-home-website1
gentl.mn/shop-fortbelvedere
Facebook: / gentlemansgazette
Gentleman Quiz: gentl.mn/quiz-gentlemansgazette
00:00 Creed’s Fragrances Ranking Introduction
We were lucky enough to receive Creed’s now sold-out “Collector’s Coffret” which contains 15 sample sizes of some of Creed’s most iconic and famous scents. That being said, Creed has not sponsored us for this video.
Overall, we do think that Creed makes great colognes but once we compare them, how will the classics stand up to the newer and more unique scents in their lineup? Our HQ team of 6 ranked and compared all 11 scents.
Rather than going with letter grades as we have in our other ranking videos, we’re just going in simple order from least favorite to most favorite.
01:37 11. Viking
02:59 10. Original Vetiver
04:09 9. Spice & Wood
05:15 8. Original Santal
06:30 7. Silver Mountain Water
07:21 6. Virgin Island Water
08:55 5. Royal Oud
10:00 4. Aventus
11:00 3. Millesime Imperial
12:27 2. Aventus Cologne
13:37 1. Green Irish Tweed
In the end, it turns out that famous colognes are famous for a reason! These really are some of the best scents out there. What did you think of our ranking? Have you sampled any of Creed’s scents before? Or perhaps you own a couple and would rank things differently?
Even though the “Collector’s Coffret” is sold out, you can still create your own customizable sampler of 3 scents on Creed’s website for $39: creedboutique.com/products/cu...
It’s undoubtedly pricey for a few samples, but then again it’s probably worth it before spending $300 to $400 on a bottle of cologne.
15:27 Outfit Rundown 
Хобби
Ayo I just realized that Kyle looks like Matt from wii sports
Lol
I won't unsee that.
For me personally Aventus and Green Irish Tweed are tied for first place mainly because these are my two favorite niche fragrances in my collection and I wear them the most of my Creeds.
Great video! Thanks. I have yet to sample any creed frags but do have a couple clones
I knew even before I saw this Green Irish Tweed would be number 1. I was not disappointed.
The less known Erolfa and Neroli Sauvage are my favourite, but I rarely see them mentioned when people talk about Creed.
Although there are six particular Creed fragrances that I enjoy wearing out of the fourteen that I've tried, I always return to wearing Aventus (two or three times per week), and Green Irish Tweed (once per week on average) after "giving them a break" (which isn't very long - for two or three weeks, typically). These two scents get the most positive response from friends and strangers, though I'm really wearing it because I enjoy the creations, themselves. Of course, I "like" that it pleases others along with what I may be wearing at the time, especially since I see fragrances as a fashionable accessory to set or reaffirm a tone.
[As a side note, I typically dress in darker colored clothing and prefer sweeter and/or textured scents with them, whereas, when I'm wearing something brighter - especially with a white shirt - I'll tend towards something with a prominent citrus. I do have synesthesia, however - so, it probably has much to do with it, and comes along with my senses as a musician, as well.]
And, because I prefer colder, cloudier weather, as opposed to hot and sunny (I might as well mention that I happen to be photophobic as well - ha), there are some other Creed fragrances that I only wear in a cooler climate (or, indoors though air conditioning, though I keep my car like an icebox on wheels, throughout the year); namely: Viking and Royal Oud. The various spices work so well in general, but best with colder temperatures and low humidity.
Himalaya is also worth mentioning, since I found it to be very interesting for something natural that reads as sharp but not abrasive in the area of cedar (though, it reminds me of smoke and honeysuckle accents), and is great in warmer weather, along with Millésime Impérial, which I was surprised to find a reminder of GIT within.
Royal Mayfair, on the other hand, was simply "impossible" for me to get through an hour of wearing, due to the eucalyptus which was like a burnt rubber medicinal chemical made for an eccentric older woman from the eighteenth century. It was a case of my wanting to like the scent for the story more than the story being that I didn't like the scent.
One fragrance that I'm surprised was missing from this lineup, though, is Bois du Portugal. It's amazing. If this hasn't been reviewed on the Gentleman's Gazette as of yet, I highly suspect that it will be appreciated for the lavender, vetiver and ambergris (among other wood notes).
Once I tried it, I was immediately impressed with how much of a class act it exuded. It has longevity, but didn't overstay its welcome, so to speak, and is so well crafted with an array of gentlemanly accords that I tend to believe the story of how it was, supposedly, Frank Sinatra's favorite scent to wear.
There is one last thing that I do feel compelled to mention about this episode, though. It's that I've heard and read that it's best not to rub a cologne or perfume into the skin when applying. It can, inadvertently, destroy certain molecules within the top notes, especially, and compromise the integrity of the fragrance as a whole. There will, most likely, be those who will disagree with my saying that (which is fine), but this is what I've learned from a number of perfumers over the years.
I would think that people are accustomed to rubbing them in because of also doing so with aftershave lotions and such, but I would advise against it for safety's sake.
With that said, thank you for reading my comment (I didn't actually "intend" on writing a book), and thanks as always for the entertaining and informative channel. I greatly appreciate it!
For which season ist Green Irish Tweed the best? Is it a summer scent?
Viking did not follow aventus, Royal oud was in between them in 2011
Good to know, thank you! We used Creed's own website for the research behind this video, but certainly appreciate your addition :)
@@gentlemansgazette wouldn't be the first time Creed have lied to everyone. Read the "The Ghost Perfumer" written by Gabe Oppenheim, pretty shocking.
@@gentlemansgazette also, thanks for your reply 🙏🏻 🫂
Technically both Royal Oud and Royal Mayfair (I realize this was a re-release of Winsor) were between Aventus and Viking
I'd like to see what you guys think of Bois du Portugal. It's one of my favorites.
I wear Green Irish Tweed just about every day. Such a wonderful fragrance!
Hey boys, I highly recommend ordering samples on top of using a video like this! I ordered samples of green irish tweed and viking and ended up liking viking more!!! Remember it's not just about what others think, you should like how you smell too!!!
Wow, I would’ve expected Original Vetiver to be higher
I've used a good number of those scents in a shaving soap from many different vendors. I'm not overly a big cologne person but do enjoy some of those Creed scents
Excellent transition to tall, dark and handsome 4:13
What can we say? "If the shoe fits!" ;)
I can only afford one of these every other year or so, so I go with Green Irish Tweed 9 times outta 10. The one time I’ll deviate, it’ll be Himalaya 🧉🦄👍🏽
unicorn emoji??? whats the meaning
here in europe you can find the bottles for quite cheap. you can always just buy decants tho
@@burritodog3634he’s a fruit cup
Loved the video! Indeed, very rare to have all of these together.
I've sampled most of these myself (not sure if all of them though) and my favorite so far is Royal Oud. There are Creed scents that suffer from poor performance (like Millesime Imperiale and Silver Mountain Water), but Royal Oud smells fantastic and performs very well for me too. Aventus is one that I like as well and wear often, but it's a bit more mass appealing and more pedestrian than Royal Oud. Erolfa I also enjoy, but it's a bit less versatile than the other 2 I mentioned. A bit more of a summer scent.
Green Irish Tweed is one that I really don't enjoy. The opening is really nice, but for me, it dries down into what I can only describe as freshly chopped parsley. While I love some parsely for garnish on my food, I don't really fancy smelling like it all day 😅
Where can i get the samples?
I've tried many niche fragrances over the past few months. It all started when i heard from y'all about how great Green Irish tweed was. That one didn't become a staple for me, but Creed became one of my favorite brands with Roja tied for first. They are relatively easy to wear and generally very high quality and natural smelling. Never pay full price, never buy a batch of Aventus without seeing reviews for that batch (terrible batch variation.)
Aventus Cologne is my daily driver- fresh and clean, sporty and and with the right amount of a designer vibe. Original aventus is loud and fruity in a masculine way, i wear it when i want to be more socially galvanized and come across more friendly.
Always sample before you buy. Never rely on anyone else's review. And when you sample wear it multiple times- some things i dont like at first become a favorite and vice a versa.
Some great Creed fragrance tips, thank you!
Creed Spice and Wood is my absolutely favorite fragrance of all time!
3:43 ho hoooo! Bad form there, dude!
Rubbing in the scent. Great way to destroy the top notes 👌
I own and wear Green Irish Tweed but it is far from my favorite. If I had to pick a favorite Creed it would be Viking, hands down.
You, sir, have exquisite taste. Viking is an underrated king.
I didnt watch the video but the top 3 for sure are 1. Aventus 2. Green Irish Tweed 3. Silver Mountain Water. It's the most designer fragrance from a niche brand. And all 3 can be had with MB Explorer, Davidoff Cool Water and Armaf Club de Nuit Silage. Combine under 100 usd. The moral of the story is dont buy Creed. Buy MFK, Amouage or Parfam De Marly. Ok now I'll see if my pick was correct(Well I'm 2 out of 3 on this one)
I love Original Santal❣️
Great video. Is that how vetiver is pronounced - vet-e-vay?
in french, yes.
@@memedecade5805 but why aren’t any of the other notes pronounced in French? Doesn’t make sense to me
It doesnt make much sense that he went out of his way to use the proper french pronounciation for vetiver, yet pronounced ambergris as amber-griss, when the french pronounciation would be ambergree
I only tried Silver Mountain and Aventus and they're great
aventus for summer
silver mountain for winter
but i'll try green irish tweed
SMW is great for the spring and summer too. Refreshing and clean. Give it a try. I’m not a fan of it in the winter I prefer the sweeter, heavier scents.
I think that Green Irish Tweed is a bit disappointing. It smells a lot like Davidoff's Cool water with a little bit more dimension to it... but not enough dimension to make it cost 10-20 times the price.
I bought 10 creed samples on EBay. One that wasn't on this video was Bois Du Portugal, which was also pretty good. I would put it about midway among the fragrances in this video.
Great, thanks, Bill! Is it more of a day or night fragrance to you?
I would also like to know the seasonal profile of this as well!
I've tried six Creeds so far and ranking goes something like: GIT, Himalaya, Aventus, Royal Oud, MI, Viking. Next on my list to check out would be Original Vetiver, SMW, and maybe Erolfa or Aventus Cologne. I think I like my Creed's "brisk" for lack of a better word, hence my top two picks.
Another one for Himalaya 🧉🦄👍🏽
Aventus is my #1 by far. Especially during spring/summer/mild fall. GIT is much like Cool Water and is more "night out" than an everyday.
Royal Oud and Green Irish Tweed are compliment magnets
Usually wear Imperial, however, my girlfriend prefers I go with Versace Eros more often. She feels that the Imperial is too strong.
I feel you brah. It hurts when the ladies love the cheapies more than the heirlooms.
@@JSn00py You understand my pain!
Spice and Wood is my all time favorite.
You got to give Erolfa a try, it's so good!
Please, tell us about Bois du Portugal
I first bought GIT back in 2006, when it was only $125 for the large bottle. Once it was bought by Saks and it got bumped to $450, it fell off. Still my favorite cologne of all time, but it only lasts an hour or two now, rather then all day. They cheapened it while making it beyond expensive
Which would be a top unisex creed
How about ranking TOM FORD fragrances next? amazing video by the way!
Thank you! Do you have a favourite Tom Ford fragrance?
Try Tom Ford Noir Extreme, it is a fantastic and long lasting scent.
I guess it mustn't have come in the box, but I think you guys would give Erolfa a pretty high score. It's kind of like a greener, classier version of Millesime Imperial.
Aventus has changed over the years. I wore it daily since it’s premier in 2010. I noticed about 5 or six years ago the after notes that I loved about it were no longer present. Been looking for an alternative ever since I noticed the difference. Maybe it’s just me.
Viking is in my collection that I bought recently and I think it is best with business and formal Attire
I have 6 Creed. Royal Oud has to be my #1. Aventus a close 2nd. GIT is top notch, along with Viking. SMW is the freshest of my group. Days where I wanna feel mature, old school, manly, I pick Bois Du Portugal.
I was waiting for Tabarome to be the numero UNO fragrance for your countdown, but then I always tend to overrate people's tastes, you turkeys! Tabarome is AWESOME.
Green irish tweed is probably my favorite fragrance of all time🔥 seriosuly so good and good longevity
Team Aventus 💪
MY top 4 in no order: GIT, Aventus Cologne, SMW, Viking
Can't wait to try these out myself.
Royal Water never gets mentioned. It's perfect for Summer if you're attending a wedding, garden party or any event with a summer chic dress code.
I have 4 creed fragrances I order them as such Original Santal,Aventus cologne, Aventus, Milinese imperial
What about creed himalaya
Creed MI is an amazing summer scent. But yes, longevity is an issue. I want to see if Erolfa is truly the competitor to this scent
1. Aventus
2. Silver Mountain Water
3. Green Irish Tweed
White suede by tom Ford is interesting . Not talked about much . A good one to layer with others .
The green Irish one smells like a country side no lie. I just smelled them 5 minutes ago😊
Personally I like the sents from Floris and Penhaligons a lot more
Creed is overpriced
Jack, the Englishman on our team is a big fan of these scents, too!
Viking reminds me of Old Spice
Im not too big on Creed anymore, but millesime imperial and royal oud are still decant worthy to me
Man, the "sülzomat" was running hot at Creeds. Raphael has to translate it.
GIT is by far the best, everything else is just marketing baloney. I have a hard time with anything marketed as unisex.
Viking is only one wich you can't get cheap analogs. Its number one for me. One note is GreenIrishTweed, although i like it.
Por favor traducir el vídeo a espańol .Gracias
A shame Bois de Portugal is omitted from the scent. Classic gentleman’s fougere.
While many Creed fragrances are great, PDM’s Layton and Herod are the greatest fragrances created by the hand of man (with Creed’s Green Irish Tweed and Silver Mountain Water coming in next).
I agree with you on Layton and Herod, not a huge Creed fan overall though.
My favourite is Buois du Portugal, which isn't on the list!
Olivier Creed is not a master perfumer and created exactly zero of those scents 😂 Read a book called The Ghost Perfumer. Most of the credit should go to Pierre Bourdon. I think Aventus was Herault though.
Millesime Imperial for the win... for me!
Veti-vay 🙊😜
Edit: Please don’t rub the fragrance. It breaks up the molecules and kills the top notes.
As good as some of the Creeds are, due to their misinformation about their heritage I can’t get myself to give the company my money. That said, Green Irish Tweed, Erolfa and Silver Mountain Water are some of their best!
Is this just my impression or is the perfume descriptions the biggest BS in the world of marketing gibberish? It even trumps the gibberish describing expensive wine.
For example: "the scent is meant to evoke an endless sunshine that bathes the legendary landscapes on the south of France in summer "- what drugs do they use in order to come up with something like that?...
Himalaya is my favorite Creed fragrance. It didn't even make the list...
Royal Oud
You cannot do a fragrance video then do what youre doing at 6:07. You know nothing about fragrances.
I worked in a lumberyard for a few years, smelling of pine, cedar and sweat every day, with no complaint from my ex-girlfriend. 😁
1:07 👀Raphael stop rubbing it in man 🤦🏿♂️
Discovered Creed the 1990's and I agree with this top 5. Back then, this stuff made you a king. Now it's at Dillard's.
GIT is a masterpiece. Aventus smelled significantly different from it's initial release than it does today (its been improved). MI has changed a lot also and used to be much stronger and left a trail. Every time I wear it I wish I had gone with GIT instead. Royal Mayfair belongs on the list somewhere. VIW and SMW smell cheap and toxic. Don't care about the others except maybe Viking.
Nicely done video.
Fragrance = rank. For me. 😱
And the saga of mispronouncing vetiver continus
If anyone wants cheap but very close copies:
Aventus: Armaf Club De Nuit Intense Man
Green Irish Tweed: Davidoff Cool Water (No they're not the same but they're certainly similar enough that the average person won't notice the difference without putting their nose to your skin)
Millesime Imperial: Christian Audigier Love and Luck
Silver Mountain Water: Armaf Club De Nuit Sillage
CW has very similar DNA to Green Irish Tweed (I own both) but it’s a great exaggeration to say that no one would notice the difference. Cool water has a synthetic smell to it that is just inescapable. To someone who knows what GIT smells like, the likelihood of mistaking it for cool water is low.
@@jaycowper I think that's true for people who care enough about fragrances to spend $400 on a bottle, or even know what the brand Creed is. But I don't think the average person would notice the difference
@@BenjaminGoude Not to parse words, but what you said was no one would notice the difference. Categorically untrue. Do you own or have extensively sampled the clones vs the originals? I own two "inspired by" fragrances. Montblanc Explorer and Davidoff Cool Water. The way I like to look at it, it's like eating steak. One that came from a fine steakhouse, and the other coming from a sizzler. It's the same thing, but one is just remarkably better than the other.
bois du portugal, where art thou? 😉
Nice to see someone in this comment section who knows what they're talking about
No question about it🤨❗️ HÉRMES “ROCOBAR” IS THE BOMB😉❗️❗️❗️🇺🇦
My problem with Aventus is how it’s become a go-to for cloning, and smells like what your Uber driver wears
If you can’t differentiate between the original and a clone, you should stick to mall fragrances… 🙄
@@herbtube7824 My point is more that Aventus has become a victim of its own success, and less that there are some unconvincing clones out there (*cough cough* Armaf). I mean, we could argue the merits of whether something like Hacivat is a clone, or its own thing, but I guarantee that almost nobody discovered Hacivat without Googling "Aventus but less expensive"
@@jmgerraughty Just as an aside, I don't like Nishane Hacivat. It's not an Aventus clone, but opens like it. Hacivat is overrated imo.
Could you maybe consider the brand Xerjoff? In my honest opinion they are far superior than Creed.
🎩🥃
Buying a Creed fragrance is akin to buying a solid gold spoon. It does the job just as well as a cheap spoon, but at a much higher pricepoint. At least with a solid gold spoon, the cost to manufacture somewhat justifies the price. I suppose it's more like buying a regular spoon with a cool logo on it and paying the price of a solid gold spoon.
Creed... 😒
Instant like, typical of us notification squad members !
Creed has some great fragrances but I feel itherr nothing unique about the brand anymore as I feel those who dotn know about fragrances buy Creed for the clout.
There's so many other great fragrance houses out there like Parfums de Marly, Maison Francis Kurkdjian, and more!
The most expensive colognes in the +1000 a bottle range smell like absolute garbage. It’s like they are just distinct. You’re the only person on the continent who smells like that when you’re wearing it.
You know what smells better than Creed cologne doctor squats soap + shampoo and conditioner plus deodorants + toothpaste + cologne
Original Vetiver is the best fragrance in the line🤌