I always find it interesting how some languages, mainly in Russia, have different names based on geography. I've seen it in Hill/Meadow Mari, Forest/Tundra Enets, and a few others
I had the pleasure of coming into contact with this language and I even recognize one voice and I want to say that this is my favorite Samoyedic language --- pä bai enets --- it is beautiful sincere thanks to the author of the channel
Hello. One more language of Krasnoyarsk region that you introduced in your channel. Thank you for your great job. I hope to see a video about Dolgan language, probably the most northern turkic language in the world
Totally support Enets people! Save your language! I'm Izhorian, and our both languages are endangered. Enens is an incredible language! Not intelligable, but nice to hear.
Interesting that the numbers are completely different from Finnish and Hungarian - not a single one is similar. And that's usually one of the most visible commonalities between related languages!
There is a very limited amount of cognate words with systematical sound correspondences. I haven't ever studied it more deeply, but what I have seen, the sound changes may have made surface level comparison often impossible in a way like in Finno-Ugric languages that there is at least some resemblance with cognate words. In numbers here I checked 7, which somewhat looks like Finnish *seitsemän* and Estonian *seitse* . According to Eesti etümoloogiasõnaraamat (Estonian etymological word book) Finnic word can be Uralic or then Indo-European loan, and word in Samoyedic languages may be parallel loan from Tocharian branch. So, it is like a puzzle with few tiny pieces, but there are also grammatical similarities besides vocabulary.
@@javindhillon6294 languages have sounds and feelings which require no evidence. I was stating subjective fact which do not require you “judgey” objectivity. Thank you for you comment.
@javindhillon6294 hit me back when you comprehend bigboy English. Every comment is made up in the fly. Subjectively. That means you can't do it for me. Objectively mean I can't do it for you. Do you actually know the history of ancient and surviving languages and the migrations of those who spoke them?
@@davidfryer9359 Alright, we've crossed the realm of ad-hominems. But you do have a “point”. Could you clarify what “stating subjective fact” means though?
This sounds like the Lakota / Sioux I heard in Dances With Wolves. I'm Hungarian Uralist (I'm also studying Finnish) but as much fascinated as I am with the Samoyeds and keen to claim them as family, I hear no linguistic similarity. Can someone smarter than me explain?
You hear no linguistic similarity because the samoyedic languages split away from the Finno-Ugric languages about 10000 years ago, and of course time does it’s job well changing how the language sounds. Another thing is that since the proto-Uralic language broke away so long ago, there weren’t many words even existing in the language. Humans really needed words for only very simple things such as numbers 1-10, some names of plant and animal species, some natural features exct. However those words that I mentioned tend to be similar across many Uralic languages. One thing that I can also think of is loaning. Almost all Finno-Ugric languages have gotten large amounts of Influence from other languages such as Indo-European and Turkic languages. When ever someone has invented some new cool invention, has the invention’s name been loaned to the language from outside. However that’s not the case with the samoyedic languages because the samoyeds have lived through out the history so north and in so isolated places that they simply haven’t gotten influenced by other languages much in the course of thousands of years. That means that they have had to literally make words out of thin air for many things.
I do not like how the Russian government care so much about Ukraine's territory, but does not care about language preservation and many other political problems. 😒
@@ja.michael That is not what I meant. You cannot find a country who has no endangered language but we can see many politician or a group of politicians who atrive there efforts to revive or preserve their language. Stop generalizing all politicians and demonizing them. That is too judgemental!
Славяне - это одна из крупнейших групп народов Евразии, которая включает в себя множество этнических подгрупп, таких как горане, гурали, полещуки, поморы, русины, и другие Они имеют богатую историю и культуру, и их присутствие можно найти в разных частях мира Одним из таких мест является и Сибирь Источники свидетельствуют о том, что славяне действительно жили в Сибири до прихода русских и казаков под предводительством Ермака в 16 веке Однако, этот факт не был широко известен в исторической науке, и был открыт только в последние десятилетия благодаря новым исследованиям и археологическим находкам Известно, что славянские народы населяли Сибирь еще задолго до нашей эры Славяне жили в разных частях Сибири, включая Западную Сибирь, Кузбасс и другие регионы Изучение археологических находок показало, что славяне в Сибири имели свои собственные общественные и культурные центры, такие как городища и курганы Они занимались различными промыслами, включая металлообработку, производство кожаных изделий, изготовление орудий труда и так далее Однако, со временем, славянские народы Сибири стали подвергаться воздействию других культур, таких как тюркские народы и монголы, которые вторглись в Сибирь в 13 веке Это привело к смешению культур и образованию новых этнических групп, таких как сибирские татары и другие Таким образом, можно сделать вывод, что славяне действительно жили в Сибири до прихода Ермака, и оставили свой след в истории и культуре этого региона Однако, с течением времени, их культура и язык были заменены другими культурами и языками, и сегодня славяне Сибири представлены только в виде небольших этнических групп
I always find it interesting how some languages, mainly in Russia, have different names based on geography. I've seen it in Hill/Meadow Mari, Forest/Tundra Enets, and a few others
It is true of indigenous languages in Canada as well (e.g. Plains/Tundra/Swampy/Rocky Cree)
I had the pleasure of coming into contact with this language and
I even recognize one voice and I
want to say that this is my favorite Samoyedic language --- pä bai enets --- it is beautiful
sincere thanks to the author of the channel
Siberia is such an interesting place with interesting people
they're intriguing
It is very fascinating to discover about Siberian languages.
Hello. One more language of Krasnoyarsk region that you introduced in your channel. Thank you for your great job. I hope to see a video about Dolgan language, probably the most northern turkic language in the world
Totally support Enets people! Save your language! I'm Izhorian, and our both languages are endangered.
Enens is an incredible language! Not intelligable, but nice to hear.
Interesting that the numbers are completely different from Finnish and Hungarian - not a single one is similar. And that's usually one of the most visible commonalities between related languages!
Ооо! Адтҍ урал не̄дтӭль лӣ! Шӯрр па̄ссьпэ о̄дт вӣдьесьт!
I love how Translate failed to translate many of the characters
@@JaredtheRabbit Google translate is too close-minded for the overwhelming power of Kildin Sami...
Быдт тэ̄нн уһцэ! Ёарркэй пэре ке̄һпьнэ лӣ
The Samoyedic languages seem to be very different from Finno-Ugric. How was the relationship even proven?
There is a very limited amount of cognate words with systematical sound correspondences. I haven't ever studied it more deeply, but what I have seen, the sound changes may have made surface level comparison often impossible in a way like in Finno-Ugric languages that there is at least some resemblance with cognate words. In numbers here I checked 7, which somewhat looks like Finnish *seitsemän* and Estonian *seitse* . According to Eesti etümoloogiasõnaraamat (Estonian etymological word book) Finnic word can be Uralic or then Indo-European loan, and word in Samoyedic languages may be parallel loan from Tocharian branch. So, it is like a puzzle with few tiny pieces, but there are also grammatical similarities besides vocabulary.
Sounds like Native American languages. There must be a connection.
Ah yes, “sounds like”, absolutely irrefutable evidence
@@javindhillon6294 languages have sounds and feelings which require no evidence. I was stating subjective fact which do not require you “judgey” objectivity. Thank you for you comment.
@@davidfryer9359 That sounds like you just made it up
@javindhillon6294 hit me back when you comprehend bigboy English. Every comment is made up in the fly. Subjectively. That means you can't do it for me. Objectively mean I can't do it for you. Do you actually know the history of ancient and surviving languages and the migrations of those who spoke them?
@@davidfryer9359 Alright, we've crossed the realm of ad-hominems. But you do have a “point”. Could you clarify what “stating subjective fact” means though?
Nice video ❤️❤️💪
Sad but glade you did them.
What is "the Russian Republic"? 0:15
Enets 2(çize) and 4(tet) sounds like Proto Turkic 2(iγe) and 4(töt).
It's sounds a little like Gaelic and Japanese, turkic which is obviously since they are paleo Siberians.
This sounds like the Lakota / Sioux I heard in Dances With Wolves. I'm Hungarian Uralist (I'm also studying Finnish) but as much fascinated as I am with the Samoyeds and keen to claim them as family, I hear no linguistic similarity. Can someone smarter than me explain?
You hear no linguistic similarity because the samoyedic languages split away from the Finno-Ugric languages about 10000 years ago, and of course time does it’s job well changing how the language sounds.
Another thing is that since the proto-Uralic language broke away so long ago, there weren’t many words even existing in the language. Humans really needed words for only very simple things such as numbers 1-10, some names of plant and animal species, some natural features exct. However those words that I mentioned tend to be similar across many Uralic languages.
One thing that I can also think of is loaning. Almost all Finno-Ugric languages have gotten large amounts of Influence from other languages such as Indo-European and Turkic languages. When ever someone has invented some new cool invention, has the invention’s name been loaned to the language from outside. However that’s not the case with the samoyedic languages because the samoyeds have lived through out the history so north and in so isolated places that they simply haven’t gotten influenced by other languages much in the course of thousands of years. That means that they have had to literally make words out of thin air for many things.
samoyedic gang rise up
Дарова
😇
The distant cousin of Finns and Hungarians
I do not like how the Russian government care so much about Ukraine's territory, but does not care about language preservation and many other political problems. 😒
You can say this for any country
Russian government just wants more people to oppress, to show them how superior they are.
@@ja.michael
that's not always true
@@dalubwikaan161 uhm, name at least one country where there is no endangered language
@@ja.michael
That is not what I meant.
You cannot find a country who has no endangered language but we can see many politician or a group of politicians who atrive there efforts to revive or preserve their language.
Stop generalizing all politicians and demonizing them. That is too judgemental!
2
Славяне - это одна из крупнейших групп народов Евразии, которая включает в себя множество этнических подгрупп, таких как горане, гурали, полещуки, поморы, русины, и другие
Они имеют богатую историю и культуру, и их присутствие можно найти в разных частях мира
Одним из таких мест является и Сибирь
Источники свидетельствуют о том, что славяне действительно жили в Сибири до прихода русских и казаков под предводительством Ермака в 16 веке
Однако, этот факт не был широко известен в исторической науке, и был открыт только в последние десятилетия благодаря новым исследованиям и археологическим находкам
Известно, что славянские народы населяли Сибирь еще задолго до нашей эры
Славяне жили в разных частях Сибири, включая Западную Сибирь, Кузбасс и другие регионы
Изучение археологических находок показало, что славяне в Сибири имели свои собственные общественные и культурные центры, такие как городища и курганы
Они занимались различными промыслами, включая металлообработку, производство кожаных изделий, изготовление орудий труда и так далее
Однако, со временем, славянские народы Сибири стали подвергаться воздействию других культур, таких как тюркские народы и монголы, которые вторглись в Сибирь в 13 веке
Это привело к смешению культур и образованию новых этнических групп, таких как сибирские татары и другие
Таким образом, можно сделать вывод, что славяне действительно жили в Сибири до прихода Ермака, и оставили свой след в истории и культуре этого региона
Однако, с течением времени, их культура и язык были заменены другими культурами и языками, и сегодня славяне Сибири представлены только в виде небольших этнических групп
1