I really don’t agree with people who say that The Dangerous Gift messed up with Snowfall’s character development. Considering it’s length, it’s a lot better than most other WoF books in that regard! I also feel like the dragons were never as much anti scavenger as much as they were just,,, ignoring them or using them as prey. There didn’t have to be that big of a change, considering that 2 out of 7 Phyrrian tribes really had something against Scavengers to begin with.
Luckily Tui said that she would like to write about Umber in arc 4. It doesnt confirm at all that Umber will be protagonist but at the very least we know Tui wants it
I genuinely hope that when/if Tui returns to WoF to write a 4th arc, she takes a good hard look at why Legends Darkstalker is considered her best work by many. I also hope she returns to previous protags instead of just writing new ones. There is plenty of untapped potential in a lot of them, arc 2s cast especially. My biggest personal gripe with all of Arc 3 was that the prose and dialogue took a huge nosedive. It was almost impossible to take any of it seriously because even when it wanted to be serious, it crammed goofy comic relief nonsense or wacky silly prose into nearly every page, or forced the characters to speak like grade school children spouting memes on a playground, even if they were an adult. The previous books had some of that but nowhere near to the degree arc 3 had.
I was always reluctant to read WOF cause I tought it will be childish, it wasn't at all so far, reading escaping Peril, realy looking forward to read Darkstalker, and now my anticipation towards arc 3 turned into anxiety
i really liked dragonslayer :D it made me think abt how they basically humans and dragons just judged each other based on appearance, but in (i think) book 14, they all started to get along :) i can see how u dont like it though, i also didnt really like ivy and leaf's pov
In my opinion the 3rd book is usually the standout of the arc or the winglet. I think this might be because Tui no longer needs to set up the main story of the arc or wrap it up. We get more time for descriptions and world building which is personally one of my favorite things about WoF.
My critique of wof Darkstalker is that it could have been longer with more world building and generally a taste for the world 2,000 years ago also I feel like the intent was to have the trip (of Fathom and Indigo) be longer and the sudden friendship between Fathom and Darkstalker/Clearsight and trust seems weird
I enjoyed 14 a lot but it did feel kinda off in arc 3. I wish Snowfall had interacted with the rest of the protagonists more or had a bigger influence on the overall plot, but I loved her story and it was a very fun and emotional book to read :)
I know this is off-topic, but I like how you have Monster Hunter music in the background. My favourite book series and one of my favourite video games.
I do want arc 4 to happen, but I pray that Tui takes all this time away from Wings of Fire main books to get a strong idea for the whole arc that can surpass the best books in WoF. As much as I'd love another book with as much effort and dark themes as Legends Darkstalker, I fear we're past that era (I'd do anything for arc 4 to do something major).
I agree, I really hope that’s why she’s taking a while to announce it (if it happens). I would love more WOF but only if Tui is able to find an idea that she’s passionate about and fully flesh it out. I really don’t want it to become a series that Tui feels forced to keep writing, for her sake and the sake of the series.
@@frannie4310 I believe when she said she doesn't want to stop writing Wings of Fire, but I hope she takes her time. I know the first two arcs were written very quickly (2-3 years each + Winglets and Legends Darkstalker) while arc 3 took around 5 years, but I think she just needs a stronger foundation to keep the arc coherent. Since we don't have to establish too many new characters and no new settings I hope it's easier to have a concept ready to go.
a few months ago we got the announcement that tui is making an arc 4 and she's thinking about doing the younger generation yk auklet cliff all them so yall's know what that means
Before this video premieres, I’m just gonna guess the ranking (worst to best) Dragonslayer The Dangerous Gift The Hive Queen The Dark Secret The Flames of Hope The Lost Continent Prisoners Runaway The Lost Heir Winter Turning Darkness of Dragons The Dragonet Prophecy Talons of Power Moon Rising The Poison Jungle Assassin The Hidden Kingdom The Brightest Night Escaping Peril Deserter Darkstalker (obviously) Edit: Charcoal, please don’t make a video about the Moon x Winter x Qibli love triangle. There really isn’t much to talk about, because we don’t spend a lot of time with them. Seriously, I REALLY don’t get why Moonbli is so popular! I get why Winter likes Moon, but why Qibli! I reread Legends: Darkstalker recently. Those last few chapters solidified this book as the best book I’ve ever read Another edit: My personal ranking, except for Dragonslayer because I don’t have time to read a 496 page book that a lot of people hate: The Flames of Hope, The Hive Queen, The Dangerous Gift, The Dark Secret, Prisoners, Runaway, The Lost Heir, The Lost Continent, Winter Turning, Darkness of Dragons, Talons of Power, Moon Rising, The Poison Jungle, The Dragonet Prophecy, The Hidden Kingdom, Assassin, The Brightest Night, Deserter, Escaping Peril, Darkstalker
I'm gonna be real with you, I really liked Book 11. Not my favorite, but it is top 8 at least. It only had one real problem for me: Blue. Other than that, I adore Pantala's worldbuilding, and dystopian is my favorite story genre.
Now reading Escaping peril and having a realy good time, best one so far! And I hope arc 3 is not as bad as people say it is, I'm relatively easy to please and I realy want to like it cause the concept as a whole sounds great!
i mean, im only on book 14, but i personally think that the arc you like the best depends on your personal likings. My favourite is arc 1, because of the DoDs, the amazing well thought out plot, and ofc the ships (ripnami,glorybringer,clayril), but most people actually like arc 2. i liked arc 2 but the plot was a little messy. With arc 3, if you like worldbuilding, arc 3 is super good.
Prisoners very well did make me like Fierceteeth even more XD She's in my top 5 characters at least. The lost heir IS SO GOOD WHAT ALSO. I fully agree with Darkstalker though, I get chills just thinking about it
For me, it's 100% in my top 3. I don't think it was the best, (I personally think darkstalker was the best book), but it was awesome and very entertaining imo
I love how you ripp into dragonslayer early, seriesly Dragon Slayer missed the mark for introducing and having Sky play a crucial role in Arc 3 so badly, my preferred alternative would be Legands: Kestral with the first third finally ironing out Kestrel's story up until she flees from scarlet and the later two thirds being focused on Sky and Peril's separate stories before and for sky during the events of the first two arcs before Culminating in their meeting just prior to the events of the Dangerous Gift
Quoted Meme rating: Book 1: THAT’S WHY IT’S THE GOAT, THE GOOOAAAT! Book 2: Whoooo! Yea baby! Book 3: I mean… it’s alright like… Book 4: Boring. Book 5: It was perfect. Perfect. Everything. Down to the last minute details… Book 6: Whoooo! Yea baby! Book 7: I mean… it’s alright like… Book 8: THAT’S WHY IT’S THE GOAT! THE GOOOOAAAT! Book 9: Boring. Book 10: It’s enough to make a grown man cry… and that’s okay… Book 11: MIIIIID! Book 12: What is dis!? Book 13: It was perfect. Perfect. Everything. Down to the last minute details… Book 14: I mean… it’s alright like… Book 15: It’s the biggest piece of dogsh*t. Darkstalker Legends: It was perfect. Perfect. Everything. Down to the last minute details… Dragonslayer Legends: It’s the biggest piece of dogsh*t. Winglet #1: Prisoner: That is one big pile of sh*t… Winglet 2: Assassin: Hey, that’s pretty good! Winglet 3: Deserter: I like this one… Winglet 4: Runaway: It was perfect. Perfect. Everything. Down to the last minute details…
I love Dragon slayer,its just so good i dont know how you could hate it.i also love the flames of hope too,these two books are honestly my favorite books in the series,ya i know its not the most popular option but i just love both books so mutch!
I think 7 is just when they s*xually mature - kind of like how girls can get pregnant as earlier as 10 or 12. Adults are probably later, and Deathbringer might actually be considered a teen. Dragon ages are hard to actually compare as there is none put down. It's still weird, obviously. If they were both fully grown, I think it would be ok if there was an age gap, and they obviously don't have at least one child until they're older (as in Moonwatcher's vision), so there's that. But the ages they got together is still a bit wrong. He was probably around 6 or so when she was born. I wish their relationship had waited, or was at least a bit smaller. But who knows, maybe in the dragon world this actually isn't bad? Their age system might work differently. Like, for example, if morrowseer had a mate that was 20 it would probably be seen as weird. Or maybe more 12? And not because it would be a large gap - but because that's still "youth." Either way, Deathbringer is too old for glory at the time.
Lynx is my favorite character I think the Dangerous Gift was great Darkstalker is by far the best book in the series I hope ark 4 comes out to make up for ark3
Honestly, it'd be funny if instead of Sky being on the Secret Stealth Team it was Peril. I . . don't like Sky. No need for flamesilk, just send Peril into the othermind's heart and BOOM problem solved book ends early everyone gets to go home the end.
I never touched book 4 at all like at all. i liked the opening of jade mountain academy and the old nightwing kingdom and several other kingdoms like the seawing kingdom. my favorite book is honestly book 8 because of peril and the sky easter egg and scarlet I liked the sky palace. I'm just disgusted about the hivewings being related to one another and all the silkwings are the desandents of the beetlewings that didn't m8 with clearsight. pantala is kinda like the human world but with dragons instead
How did you place a book with legit NO story that serves to answer a question that can be solved using some simple inferring above the series finale (even if the pacing was a bit off). In my book "nothing" books should be closer to the bottom than "bad" books
Really hope arc 4 will have a mud wing main character and a hybrid one! I liked Sunny but you didn’t get much hybrid from her and more just defective and weak.
I also agree that the book is amazing, but it contradicts the whole point of wings of fire. After all, the series is about dragons, not humans, "Wings of fire"
Dragonslayer is very bad thing why not just make it very much something that you said a full book series of dragons should be central for this world and any human base character must have been built much better but not the biggest book to
Wings of Fire has the potential to be a phenomenal media franchise, but its numerous plot holes and flaws make leeway for filmmakers. For example, if I were a producer adapting the series into film or television, I would omit animus magic, Pantala and the Pantalan tribes from the story. Dragons can and are powerful, majestic and special without magic; Arc 3 shouldn't even exist in the first place, anyway.
Good list. I agree with most of your opinions, but I disagree with a lot of others. Dragonslayer for one. I'd put that one up a little higher. I personally thought it was marginally better than Flames of Hope because it at least consistent with the events of the first arc, and I feel that Ivy and Leaf are more interesting than given credit, especially considering how they interact with each other and get to the bottom of the conspiracy that befalls Ivy's home. Yea, the story was predictable except for Wren, but they at least contributed SOMETHING to the overall plot and we understood what was happening from their perspective which would have been impossible to write from a dragon's. The groundwork was there, but I do agree that it could have been handled better, but I don't think it's really as bad as everyone says it is. I personally think the negativity is more of a knee-jerk reaction because it's from a human's perspective and not a dragon's. I would have put Qibli's book a little higher on the list as well because Qibli's just such a lovable goofball, and at least the first two parts of his book give Qibli something to do while Turtle is off on his adventure. I love the dynamic he has with his "family" and I use that term loosely, and Winter coming along for the ride. Best of all it still has him worrying about Darkstalker and how much of a looming threat he still is. The plot doesn't forget about it and does everything it needs to to remind the readers that it's going on. I might put Assassin a little bit lower, but everything else is about where I would put them.
I really don’t agree with people who say that The Dangerous Gift messed up with Snowfall’s character development. Considering it’s length, it’s a lot better than most other WoF books in that regard! I also feel like the dragons were never as much anti scavenger as much as they were just,,, ignoring them or using them as prey. There didn’t have to be that big of a change, considering that 2 out of 7 Phyrrian tribes really had something against Scavengers to begin with.
I AGREE! THAT BOOK WAS ONE OF MY FAVES IDK WHY PEOPLE HATE IT :(
I don't know why but dangerous gift was my least favorite book 😭😭
Best part of Flames of Hope was the Secret Stealth Team. (Qibli!) BUT YOU NEVER SEE HALF OF THEM FOR 90% OF THE BOOK!
It's cause they so stealthy
I hope there is an arc 4 with a MudWing protagonist, THESE GUYS NEED MORE PAGE TIME
FR
A LOT MORE
Luckily Tui said that she would like to write about Umber in arc 4. It doesnt confirm at all that Umber will be protagonist but at the very least we know Tui wants it
Always felt bad Clay kinda got sidelined most of the books and then we never get another big Mudwing character
I genuinely hope that when/if Tui returns to WoF to write a 4th arc, she takes a good hard look at why Legends Darkstalker is considered her best work by many. I also hope she returns to previous protags instead of just writing new ones. There is plenty of untapped potential in a lot of them, arc 2s cast especially.
My biggest personal gripe with all of Arc 3 was that the prose and dialogue took a huge nosedive. It was almost impossible to take any of it seriously because even when it wanted to be serious, it crammed goofy comic relief nonsense or wacky silly prose into nearly every page, or forced the characters to speak like grade school children spouting memes on a playground, even if they were an adult. The previous books had some of that but nowhere near to the degree arc 3 had.
I was always reluctant to read WOF cause I tought it will be childish, it wasn't at all so far, reading escaping Peril, realy looking forward to read Darkstalker, and now my anticipation towards arc 3 turned into anxiety
i really liked dragonslayer :D it made me think abt how they basically humans and dragons just judged each other based on appearance, but in (i think) book 14, they all started to get along :) i can see how u dont like it though, i also didnt really like ivy and leaf's pov
Darkstalker will always be one of my favorite books of all time
Are suggesting darkstalker is a book
😂😂😂
@art-cooki they're talking about the book not his actual character
In my opinion the 3rd book is usually the standout of the arc or the winglet. I think this might be because Tui no longer needs to set up the main story of the arc or wrap it up. We get more time for descriptions and world building which is personally one of my favorite things about WoF.
My critique of wof Darkstalker is that it could have been longer with more world building and generally a taste for the world 2,000 years ago also I feel like the intent was to have the trip (of Fathom and Indigo) be longer and the sudden friendship between Fathom and Darkstalker/Clearsight and trust seems weird
hottake: I don't care for darkstalker legends it was alright I actually enjoyed book 4 and 14 more
I 100% don’t agree with you but respect for sharing that
fair@@Eclipse210
I enjoyed 14 a lot but it did feel kinda off in arc 3. I wish Snowfall had interacted with the rest of the protagonists more or had a bigger influence on the overall plot, but I loved her story and it was a very fun and emotional book to read :)
@@Eclipse210same here
Dude, you put Lost Continent over Winter Turning!?💀
I know this is off-topic, but I like how you have Monster Hunter music in the background. My favourite book series and one of my favourite video games.
I LOVED Snowfall's Character Arc of learning empathy. It was SO enjoyable and such a cool way to give us, the reader, information
I do want arc 4 to happen, but I pray that Tui takes all this time away from Wings of Fire main books to get a strong idea for the whole arc that can surpass the best books in WoF.
As much as I'd love another book with as much effort and dark themes as Legends Darkstalker, I fear we're past that era (I'd do anything for arc 4 to do something major).
I agree, I really hope that’s why she’s taking a while to announce it (if it happens). I would love more WOF but only if Tui is able to find an idea that she’s passionate about and fully flesh it out. I really don’t want it to become a series that Tui feels forced to keep writing, for her sake and the sake of the series.
@@frannie4310 I believe when she said she doesn't want to stop writing Wings of Fire, but I hope she takes her time.
I know the first two arcs were written very quickly (2-3 years each + Winglets and Legends Darkstalker) while arc 3 took around 5 years, but I think she just needs a stronger foundation to keep the arc coherent.
Since we don't have to establish too many new characters and no new settings I hope it's easier to have a concept ready to go.
Yeah definitely
a few months ago we got the announcement that tui is making an arc 4 and she's thinking about doing the younger generation yk auklet cliff all them so yall's know what that means
But she doesn't have a strong idea for it but this is a possibility
Before this video premieres, I’m just gonna guess the ranking (worst to best)
Dragonslayer
The Dangerous Gift
The Hive Queen
The Dark Secret
The Flames of Hope
The Lost Continent
Prisoners
Runaway
The Lost Heir
Winter Turning
Darkness of Dragons
The Dragonet Prophecy
Talons of Power
Moon Rising
The Poison Jungle
Assassin
The Hidden Kingdom
The Brightest Night
Escaping Peril
Deserter
Darkstalker (obviously)
Edit: Charcoal, please don’t make a video about the Moon x Winter x Qibli love triangle. There really isn’t much to talk about, because we don’t spend a lot of time with them. Seriously, I REALLY don’t get why Moonbli is so popular! I get why Winter likes Moon, but why Qibli!
I reread Legends: Darkstalker recently. Those last few chapters solidified this book as the best book I’ve ever read
Another edit:
My personal ranking, except for Dragonslayer because I don’t have time to read a 496 page book that a lot of people hate:
The Flames of Hope, The Hive Queen, The Dangerous Gift, The Dark Secret, Prisoners, Runaway, The Lost Heir, The Lost Continent, Winter Turning, Darkness of Dragons, Talons of Power, Moon Rising, The Poison Jungle, The Dragonet Prophecy, The Hidden Kingdom, Assassin, The Brightest Night, Deserter, Escaping Peril, Darkstalker
Dont understand why moon rising is so high, and dark secret is so low
@@juststrahyk5377 It’s based on my guess of how Charcoal is gonna rank the books
@@Eclipse210 ok
You were pretty close
Hm, The Flames of Hope is right before The Dangerous Gift
I'm gonna be real with you, I really liked Book 11. Not my favorite, but it is top 8 at least. It only had one real problem for me: Blue. Other than that, I adore Pantala's worldbuilding, and dystopian is my favorite story genre.
Now reading Escaping peril and having a realy good time, best one so far! And I hope arc 3 is not as bad as people say it is, I'm relatively easy to please and I realy want to like it cause the concept as a whole sounds great!
i mean, im only on book 14, but i personally think that the arc you like the best depends on your personal likings. My favourite is arc 1, because of the DoDs, the amazing well thought out plot, and ofc the ships (ripnami,glorybringer,clayril), but most people actually like arc 2. i liked arc 2 but the plot was a little messy. With arc 3, if you like worldbuilding, arc 3 is super good.
Winter and Qibli bounce off each other like Quickdeath’s spear bounces off Darkstalker’s scales
Prisoners very well did make me like Fierceteeth even more XD She's in my top 5 characters at least. The lost heir IS SO GOOD WHAT ALSO. I fully agree with Darkstalker though, I get chills just thinking about it
dragonslayer did do a lot of explaining cause yknow, we needed explaining
Here after the premiere! Another awesome video Charcoal :))
I was really really excited for a scavenger POV book, but I never could get through dragonslayer...
IMO moon rising (book 6) is the best book
For me, it's 100% in my top 3. I don't think it was the best, (I personally think darkstalker was the best book), but it was awesome and very entertaining imo
Not to me lol, I did not enjoy it
I love how you ripp into dragonslayer early, seriesly Dragon Slayer missed the mark for introducing and having Sky play a crucial role in Arc 3 so badly, my preferred alternative would be Legands: Kestral with the first third finally ironing out Kestrel's story up until she flees from scarlet and the later two thirds being focused on Sky and Peril's separate stories before and for sky during the events of the first two arcs before Culminating in their meeting just prior to the events of the Dangerous Gift
Tui taking all that time to make Dragonslayer: dang 😭
I honestly liked TDS, I hate what they did to Starflight but yeah it could have been better
i started wof with darkstalker, and man it was so difficult to get through some of the other books after seeing how amazing tui t's writing can be
Charcoal, you should do a video where you rank every WoF protagonist
if he is who I think he is Qibli would be at the top
@@BananaSoup-ju3rz He already made a Top 5 Favorite Character list. Fathom was at the top
Quoted Meme rating:
Book 1:
THAT’S WHY IT’S THE GOAT, THE GOOOAAAT!
Book 2:
Whoooo! Yea baby!
Book 3:
I mean… it’s alright like…
Book 4:
Boring.
Book 5:
It was perfect. Perfect. Everything. Down to the last minute details…
Book 6:
Whoooo! Yea baby!
Book 7:
I mean… it’s alright like…
Book 8:
THAT’S WHY IT’S THE GOAT! THE GOOOOAAAT!
Book 9:
Boring.
Book 10:
It’s enough to make a grown man cry… and that’s okay…
Book 11:
MIIIIID!
Book 12:
What is dis!?
Book 13:
It was perfect. Perfect. Everything. Down to the last minute details…
Book 14:
I mean… it’s alright like…
Book 15:
It’s the biggest piece of dogsh*t.
Darkstalker Legends:
It was perfect. Perfect. Everything. Down to the last minute details…
Dragonslayer Legends:
It’s the biggest piece of dogsh*t.
Winglet #1: Prisoner:
That is one big pile of sh*t…
Winglet 2: Assassin:
Hey, that’s pretty good!
Winglet 3: Deserter:
I like this one…
Winglet 4: Runaway:
It was perfect. Perfect. Everything. Down to the last minute details…
22:20 I guess you were having *The Brightest Night* 😂😂😂
30:13 I just realized darkstalker is looking into our soul
Make a ranking on the biggest events in wings of fire
I love Dragon slayer,its just so good i dont know how you could hate it.i also love the flames of hope too,these two books are honestly my favorite books in the series,ya i know its not the most popular option but i just love both books so mutch!
"It's too short"
WINGLETS ARE SUPPOSED TO BE SHORT
I think 7 is just when they s*xually mature - kind of like how girls can get pregnant as earlier as 10 or 12. Adults are probably later, and Deathbringer might actually be considered a teen. Dragon ages are hard to actually compare as there is none put down. It's still weird, obviously. If they were both fully grown, I think it would be ok if there was an age gap, and they obviously don't have at least one child until they're older (as in Moonwatcher's vision), so there's that. But the ages they got together is still a bit wrong. He was probably around 6 or so when she was born. I wish their relationship had waited, or was at least a bit smaller. But who knows, maybe in the dragon world this actually isn't bad? Their age system might work differently. Like, for example, if morrowseer had a mate that was 20 it would probably be seen as weird. Or maybe more 12? And not because it would be a large gap - but because that's still "youth." Either way, Deathbringer is too old for glory at the time.
Seemed like The Lost Heir had a grand mystery ideas but not enough page space so it crammed all the ideas together
I’m on book three, I’m exited but I’m trying my best to avoid spoilers
i read wings of fire at 3 am too
My favorite ships are moonbli ceril sunlow and (my brain just went to static while i was thinking of a ship name for fathom and indigo)
To be honest Dragonslayer is my favorite but I like wrens plot the best
Lynx is my favorite character I think the Dangerous Gift was great Darkstalker is by far the best book in the series I hope ark 4 comes out to make up for ark3
I agree with everything but I haven’t got to arc 3 almost tho
Placing Darkness of Dragons in number 12 is a crime
Should been top 5
Why does everybody hate the dark secret Is honestly a good book I don't get why so many people hate it
So funny how he roasts the books and puts myn favourites low! 🤣
Honestly, it'd be funny if instead of Sky being on the Secret Stealth Team it was Peril. I . . don't like Sky.
No need for flamesilk, just send Peril into the othermind's heart and BOOM problem solved book ends early everyone gets to go home the end.
I never touched book 4 at all like at all. i liked the opening of jade mountain academy and the old nightwing kingdom and several other kingdoms like the seawing kingdom. my favorite book is honestly book 8 because of peril and the sky easter egg and scarlet I liked the sky palace. I'm just disgusted about the hivewings being related to one another and all the silkwings are the desandents of the beetlewings that didn't m8 with clearsight. pantala is kinda like the human world but with dragons instead
How did you place a book with legit NO story that serves to answer a question that can be solved using some simple inferring above the series finale (even if the pacing was a bit off). In my book "nothing" books should be closer to the bottom than "bad" books
Your right dark$talker is the best book but the worst one art is the end
Really hope arc 4 will have a mud wing main character and a hybrid one! I liked Sunny but you didn’t get much hybrid from her and more just defective and weak.
All I know is Darkstalkers book is my favorite
DRAGONSLAYER IS SO GOOD THOUGH 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I also agree that the book is amazing, but it contradicts the whole point of wings of fire. After all, the series is about dragons, not humans,
"Wings of fire"
putting the highest main book in 3rd is wild
or atleast it would be in any other book series
I literally enjoy the darkstalker.
I only read wrens part in dragonslayer 😭
I gotta say, Darkstalker is the single best character in Wof
JMA (if you don't know him watch his vids)be like after seeing this comment : QIBlE
SOMBODY help me. Is willow a boy or girl.
Willow is a girl, she and Sundew are lesbians
Thank you so much
This video made me sooooooooooooooo mad. I love it
I agree with a decent amount of these books but some of the great ones are ranked so bad like huh??
Dragonslayer is very bad thing why not just make it very much something that you said a full book series of dragons should be central for this world and any human base character must have been built much better but not the biggest book to
You hate all the most of the books I love
Hot take: book 2 is the worst (or least good) besides dragonslayer
I think hive queen is the worst
31:54
Winter turning is pretty boring
My only reasoning for liking it is because the cover art is hella pretty and how the Ice Kingdom was fleshed out
@@Littlefox1213 yep
I only found the first part boring, the rest was great
Na bro just hates arc 3
I'm surprised book 10 is as high as it is LMAO
Wings of Fire has the potential to be a phenomenal media franchise, but its numerous plot holes and flaws make leeway for filmmakers. For example, if I were a producer adapting the series into film or television, I would omit animus magic, Pantala and the Pantalan tribes from the story. Dragons can and are powerful, majestic and special without magic; Arc 3 shouldn't even exist in the first place, anyway.
Good list. I agree with most of your opinions, but I disagree with a lot of others. Dragonslayer for one. I'd put that one up a little higher. I personally thought it was marginally better than Flames of Hope because it at least consistent with the events of the first arc, and I feel that Ivy and Leaf are more interesting than given credit, especially considering how they interact with each other and get to the bottom of the conspiracy that befalls Ivy's home. Yea, the story was predictable except for Wren, but they at least contributed SOMETHING to the overall plot and we understood what was happening from their perspective which would have been impossible to write from a dragon's. The groundwork was there, but I do agree that it could have been handled better, but I don't think it's really as bad as everyone says it is. I personally think the negativity is more of a knee-jerk reaction because it's from a human's perspective and not a dragon's.
I would have put Qibli's book a little higher on the list as well because Qibli's just such a lovable goofball, and at least the first two parts of his book give Qibli something to do while Turtle is off on his adventure. I love the dynamic he has with his "family" and I use that term loosely, and Winter coming along for the ride. Best of all it still has him worrying about Darkstalker and how much of a looming threat he still is. The plot doesn't forget about it and does everything it needs to to remind the readers that it's going on.
I might put Assassin a little bit lower, but everything else is about where I would put them.
Yesss