You can tell that they really liked the story of Harry Potter, I mean others would not react to fan films. (There nothing wrong if others don't react to fan films)
fan films are so much fun especially for the marauders era characters because the harry potter movies/books give very limited information about each and every character (like the marauders and snape) that it’s so fun to see people’s interpretations
@@deya8329 No that isn't. When he transfigured, he was still pretty much a good person and a friend to the marauders. He didn't turn to voldemort's side until after they graduated from hogwarts
james actually never apologized for what he did to snape; he got away with everything and everyone was ready to forgive him (including lily and dambledore) because he was privliged rich kid; while they framed snape as a deatheater before he had even joined voldemort! james never felt sorry for tormenting snape and destroying his life; and snape was always damaged and hurt.. he never moved on with his life; i guess that's how bullying works..
Let's be honest this is torture not bullying. Bullying isn't using a marauders map to track every movement of your victim, or nearly getting someone killed by a werewolf
This was impressive beyond expectation :) I was seriously on Snape`s side. You watch this and add to your mind: Harry: "My father was a great man!!!" Snape: "Your father was a swine!" Snape`s childhood was extremely difficult, and along comes "Sunny Boy" James Potter and Co., and they have nothing better to do than bully him. No wonder, he ended up with Voldemort. Who else was there to bond with? I found the ending with Voldemort weird and too incorrect.
I’m just here to say Voldemort didn’t have a snake face until he was resurrected in goblet of fire. As he made more horcruxes, his face got less human, but he still had a nose and stuff haha!
Yes but that is the face that is famous. Nobody would recognize him otherwise. It just made it more definitive so people cant say well maybe it was or maybe not. You know how crazy people get online.
Yeah, that kind of bothered me but it was an overlookable detail. They did the make up and prosthetics really well- except for the nose could have been a tad flatter.
After years of torture, harassment and having James hide behind his larg group of marauders ambushing lone Slytherin. It is SUPER SATISFYING to to see JAMES conscious and have to watch his precious gang get taken down by Snape one at time Al the whole knowing he deserves this. Super satisfying. Finally, he gets his cumupance.
Please react to “Neville Longbottom and the Black Witch” it’s about what Bellatrix did to Neville’s parents and it’s absolutely amazing! The effects and the acting are seriously so sooo good!
This is interesting because, in Snape's Worst Memory, James disarms Severus immediately then proceeds to attack him, even while knowing that he couldn't defend himself.
Loved the reaction. If you're interested in watching more fan films I totally recommend "Neville Longbottom and the Black Witch" and "Sisters of House Black" they're amazing fan films and totally worth the watch.
I know this is not on your current list of fan films to react to, but I HIGHLY RECOMMEND another Broad Strokes Harry Potter Fan Film called "Dumbledore and Grindelwald - The Greater Good - Crimes of Grindelwald Prequel" This tells the story of an incident between a young Albus Dumbledore and Gellert Grindelwald which also involves Albus' brother Aberforth and their sister Ariana. The story is touched on briefly in the books and even more briefly in the movies. I very much like what they did with this fan film.
@@whitenoisereacts u should do the reaction to it.. you'll understand their relationship better & it's directly taken from Harry Potter books so it's not something new or something that fandom already doesn't know + it Directly shows the fight btw Grindelwald, Albus & aberforth & why Albus & Grindelwald seperated
Almost forgot how impressive this movie is. It captures the darkness of the books so incredibly well. Potterheads are a dedicated bunch❤️ EDIT: "I was a little bit shocked at how evil James was". I detest James Potter. Went to school with several of his kind (that includes girls) and their bullying turned me into the fucked up adult I am now (or, at least, contributed hugely) . In my HP- villain-top ten he ranks right after Umbridge - both of them are just so incredibly... real. People still underestimate the effect school bullying can have on an individual. That's also why I love Snape so much^^
Yeah. To be fair, kids are little shits when they are young and I feel that James may have regretted what he did in younger years. That doesn’t excuse it, but I do think there is some understanding to be thrown his way because of it.
Honestly, Snape started practicing dark magic and wasn't as good as you paint him to be, I'm not his fan at all and I think James was better person as he grew up, same as Sirius and Remus.
Guys don't get me wrong, I'm not saying he is an innocent little lamb who could do no wrong.^^ I simply consider him an incredibly well crafted literary character. Among other things he very realistically portrays the longtime effects multi-faceted trauma can have on someone who doesn't get any help and lacks any kind of support system.
@@whitenoisereacts I mean, Harry named his kids after James and Snape. Rowling did something good which was showing us the grey areas of so many characters. So many of her characters are so lifelike. Everyone knows a James Potter. That typical arrogant bullying popular high school jock. Everyone knows an Umbridge. That person who uses politics/religion/ or whatever else as a smokescreen to sadistic torture. The fact that we all hate Umbridge so much is probably a huge compliment to her actress, Imelda Staunton. Everyone knows a Snape even. That petty cruel high school teacher who seems to hate everyone and everything(including himself) for no apparent reason. The two biggest grey area characters in the fandom are Snape and Dumbledore, those two get debated on the most from what I've seen. Harry himself had to endure so much with the abuse he suffered at the Dursleys' and all the deaths he witnessed and loved ones he lost, as well as all the Voldemort shit he had to contend with. Yet throughout it all, he was still able to remain kind, humble, and a decent human being, showing just how much Harry takes after his mother instead of his father in terms of personality. Harry's kids names are: 1) James Sirius Potter (eldest son) 2) Albus Severus Potter (younger son) 3)Lily Luna Potter (youngest and only daughter) Rowling said Harry left Remus' name for Teddy to use, and George named his son after Fred, to honour his twin brother.
also this doesn’t show though that snape and james weren’t really attacking each other at hogwarts it was more or less like a prank war between the both of them. and lily stopped talking to snape when he called her a mud blood lol
@@elliemcnally1433 even in the books it was like this, james was such a coward and he takes 3 friends with him to bully snape; the mudblood incident alone is more then enough to explain what kind of creature james is, snape wanted to be powerfull that's why he joined the deatheaters; they were the only ones who protected him in this hell..
I only saw this now and WOW! The emotion that they got across in such a short space of time, was better than in the actual Harry Potter films, in my opinion. Well done to them! 👏👏👏
This was great! A few things not quite accurate, but for fan-made stuff I'm willing to let that slide, especially for the amazing quality that this was.
I'm still sad they had to leave and get on with their lives so soon, i was really hoping they would react to *Matilda 1996* or *Matilda the Musical.* 😢😞💔
That Fan Film was ABSOLUTELY amazing! I didn't expect anything and that Film was so fantastic. I wish I could see a whole film in the cinema. And the actors where so good. Thanks for reacting to that or I would have never seen that!
17:51 no, that's not how he got turned. he, and sirius and james were 3 unregistered animagi (wizards who could transform into an animal.. if you remember from the first film, mcgonagall, a registered animagi, had turned into a cat). they turned into animagi to keep remus company, since he was a werewolf..
Back then, Severus was already hanging out with death eaters to be, cursing others for fun, called Lily a mudblood (in the heat of an argument) and tried to get Remus kicked out of school.
Ok so i will correct you a little bit : If he hang with death eater its logic bc they were his fucking roomate. Snape never hex ppl for fun in fact its james and compagny Who did that " hexing ppl just bc you like it " -lily Idk out of what you invent that bullshit but shut up thats embarassing Also he treat lily a mudblood after the bullying so it cant be a reason of that bullying And for finish he never tried to fired Remus but he just tried to know what is Remus learn the diff
@@laurine____7543 First of all, why do you have to be rude just because you think I am wrong about a fictional character? Secondly , Andromeda Tonks was in Slytherin, came from a pureblood family and some of her family members including her own sister were some of the fiercest Voldemort supporters and yet she did not become anything close to a death eater. Neither did Sirius, having a similar, but of course not equally drastic background. So growing up in the vicinity of extremists is certainly a possible explanation, but no apology for becoming one yourself. Lily‘s even said that she knew of his wanting to become a death eater, which he I might add did not feel the need to correct. As for the hexing people for fun bit, James was undeniably a bully, a notion that I did not challenge at all. However Lupin‘s claim that Snape „never lost an opportunity to curse James“ (OotP) still stands uncontested. In my opinion „sneaking around trying to find out what we were up to … hoping he could get us expelled“ (book 3) is a good indication for his trying to get Lupin expelled. If you think that the assertion is too biased, „I think the loss of the Order of Merlin hit him hard. So he - er - accidentally let slip that I am a werewolf this morning at breakfast.“ should suffice as far as evidence that he at least displayed such intentions later on goes. In my opinion it shows his apparent urge to punish weaker group members in order to punish their friends. Yes, Snape cannot be envied for what he had to endure both at home and in school. But to pretend he was an innocent victim of circumstance would from my point of view be a misjudgment of his character.
Bruh I actually remember hearing about this fan film on german news when it came out and If I remember correctly they at first had problems with Warner Brothers because a lot of people apparently thought this was legit because it looked and felt so accurate lol edit at least that’s what they said on the news
Even if you guys don't do a reaction video for it you should definitely check out A Very Potter Musical by Team Starkid. It's a hilarious parody musical from like 10-12 years ago. There's a playlist on RUclips of all the parts.
I really highly recommend Mischief Managed! It's filmed at Oxford university so it's on the same location that a lot of the actual film was shot at, it's super fun and silly and follows part of the marauders' school days
That was sick isn't it ? You guys should see The Sisters Of House Black too, this fan movie is as brilliant as this one. Male like female actors are stunning and they gives chills 🥰 bye guys, love your videos, kisses from France
I strongly recommend you to listen their audio-series that Broad Strokes made and which continues the story of Snape and the Marauders during the great war named The Great Wizarding War... it's still in progress cuz the episodes take a long time to be created. This is a freakin masterpiece. There aren't true canons cuz nothing was written by JK Rowling about this period. All we have is some informations about the first Order of the Phoenix in the 5th book of Harry Potter. There are so much interesting characters like the two brothers of Molly Weasley who died in hero (Fabian and Gideon same initials as Fred and Georges) or the Neville's parents and from what we learn in the Harry Potter books 4 and 5 is such interesting (all fights of Alastor Moody, the Ministery's cases with Bartemius Crouch etc...). But plz, u have to listen this serial audio, u won't regretted it. This is, by far, the darkest period of this universe that explains too why this fan-made is dark x)
yea it was such great work... i didn't like how lily was portrayed as an angel, and i didn't like how she gave snape an alternative but he chose the dark side anyway; apart from that it was such a great serie..
when I watched this I just couldn't with lily. James just flat out emitted to a 4 v 1 against Snape and Lilys like "I might forgive you but the people who just tried to kill you are fine by me"
Wow what a bitch, in the books she is quite dark yes severus did bad things and his obsession with the dark arts drove Lily away but Lily not forgiveing Severus and constantly witnessing him BEING ABUSED AND TOMENTED is just soo cruel. being sorted into two seperate houses is not an excuse for their their friendship to disolve after fifth year. yes one bad word and lily never knew severus's real truth about him his deep Love for her its just a tragity!
This movie paints Snape in too positive a light tbh. And I'm someone who actually really doesn't like James Potter, or Lily for that matter. Edit: 1) James matured in his 7th year. If anything, it's likely James would have approached Snape to make peace rather than fight again. 2) James and Snape would go at each other. It wasn't always one sided. 3) Fiendfyre is dark magic and the marauders, outside of Peter later in life, didn't partake. 4) Snape was friends with future death eaters since his first year. He was already planning on joining Voldemort after hogwarts by his 6th year. 5) James would never say, "Severus please." 6) Lily never spoke to Snape after he called her a mudblood. That's why he regrets that memory so much. He never got closure with Lily. She didn't row with Snape because he defended himself against James smh. 🤦🏽♂️ Well made movie in everything but the story and understanding of these characters. And also, the marauders, outside of Peter, were basically like popular Hermiones. They wouldn't have gotten their ass handed to them this easily
Idk about that. Sirius said he got better in his seventh year when he "stopped hexing people for the heck of it." But he also mentioned Snape was an exception and would "hex him right back." In this video they were both going for each other as well, though James did start it. James did mature to a degree but this was right after he left Hogwarts, its not too hard to believe he would do this. In addition the reason he was more anxious about Snape now was because he was with Lily and didn't want Snape anywhere near her, not just their usual rivalry, so it fits that he was more aggressive. As for James saying "Severus Please," it does make sense because like I said he has matured to a degree and cares more about his friends getting hurt than about Snape. Lupin was bleeding out, Sirius was hit by the Cruciatus Curse. Yes, Snape was friends with future Death Eaters but that doesnt mean anything. Technically, Sirius, Lupin and James were friends with a future Death Eater as well. Plus in their school years, the worst thing mentioned that Snape's friends did was enlarge somebody's head. Fred and George have done things at about that level (example: making sweets that turns people into canaries and possibly damaging Montague by shoving him into the broken Vanishing Cabinet). Meanwhile, Sirius pretty much tried to commit murder and get Snape killed. There's no evidence that Snape was planning on joining Voldemort while he was in school. The only thing that suggests so is Lily saying that to Snape when she is very angry at him, as thats what she believes, but its more than likely if "Snape's worst memory" had never occurred, things wouldve gone very differently. The last part I vehemently disagree with, its never inferred that the Marauders were popular Hermione's. Were they talented? Yes. But never like that. The only thing they had above what most graduating students did was more experience, animal transformation, and a slightly expanded knowledge of experimental curses. But there's nothing that suggests they were anywhere near as powerful as Snape. They weren't even a powerful as half the Order like Kingsley, Moody, or the Aurors, forget Snape. Hermione was better than the Marauders as in her 5th year, as she was able to modify/combine a jinx that nobody could reverse and that literally prevented someone from talking or else a bunch of spots would cover their face. Nobody was able to cure this jinx, not even the teachers of Hogwarts who are pretty powerful. At 17, she was able to constantly keep up protections and magical enhancements to hide from the entire world including the most powerful dark wizard of all time. The Marauders weren't at Hermione's level in their youth, so they were nowhere freaking near Snape's level. In the books its stated "Snape knew more curses when he arrived at school than most 6th and 7th years ever did." Snape literally created new spells, outsmarted the textbook makers for potions (who have to be pretty smart in their own right) and literally made potions better than any student ever and even rewrote the recipes for them to make them better, was extremely skilled in Occlumency, and went on to literally lie directly to the face of the most powerful dark wizard ever who was an unparalleled Legilmens and be one of the only two people who could fly without the use of brooms (the Death Eaters couldn't do that in the books). The Marauders dont stand a chance against Snape. Lily also still didnt forgive him hear, thought the same thing of him he did back then, and went off with James. Its still his worst memory.
This is my favourite fan film because it stays quite true to the personalities of Severus and James (though I'm hesitant of the personalities of Sirius and Remus, especially in the fight). This is always how I imagined the Marauders to be during school given what we know, and makes so much sense to how Severus becomes so messed after all those antagonistic years. People are always saying, 'no, it was a mutual rivalry!'.It's not a rivalry if is 1 vs 2-4...that's bullying. People like to say it's that so they can feel better about James and refuse to believe that yes, he was a bullying asshole. Severus only ever fought back in self-defence, and will never willfully attack them unless he was baited to it. It would go completely against Severus' character if he chose to attack them because he felt like it - he knew better if he knew he was outnumbered. Aside from that, I REALLY love the casting and the effects! Such an amazing fan film, for sure!
lets be realistic here now. It was clearly stated James and the rest of the marauders matured and left Snape alone. I do not like James enough to understand his actions, because he was an arrogant rich bratty boy, but he bullied Snape because Snape had and continued to have prejudice against muggleborns. You cannot deny the fact Snape was always a racist asshole, he never changed his ways, he was only nice to Lily because he became obsessed with her for years. Snape joined a terrorist group because he got rejected. James is the morally grey character here, Snape always remained a bad guy. He was bullied because of his beliefs, not because he was different. Are we really going to ignore the fact Snape was very similar to Voldemort? Snape created a nickname for himself to get rid of his muggle heritage, just like Voldemort did. Snape despises muggleborns and the fact he is not a pureblood like most of Slytherin. Snape bullies his students on multiple occasions, and he never done a good thing in his life. He only cared about Lily, and her safety. In the books he only asks Lily to be hidden, and in response, Dumbledore tells him he is disgusting. Snape did not become a double agent because his allegiance changed, and he realised he was on the wrong side the whole time. He did it because Dumbledore kept him in the loop by blackmailing him. Dumbledore cleared his name after Voldemort was defeated the first time, in favour of becoming a spy for him and whenever Snape did not want to do a certain thing, he would always be reminded of Lily by Dumbledore, to at least do it for her sake. I will always continue to despise Snape, he is not a morally grey character, he is a disgusting piece of shit. end of story.
@@viktoriabuzas2001 It's really disappointing when people don't care to understand Snape's story, because those such as yourself, have these narrow-minded views when it's been indicated already by the author herself, that Severus Snape is indeed, a grey character. I suppose you've never suffered parential abuse, and bullying/harassment/ostracization/public humiliation by fellow peers for seven years? I don't suppose you have any idea what it's like to be attacked and singled out for being different? I don't suppose you understand the mindset of an abused child, and how isolated they can be, and are easily influenced by a side who can make a person feel safe? A child so severely ostracised by the people 'of good', that conveneing with the darker crowd seems far more appealing. The people of good, treated him like shit for no real reason, except they were bored. James is a douchebag who never changed. He flaunted his power with his gang, hexed other students, and bullied Severus 'because he exists'. Because James couldn't keep his mouth shut on the first train ride, in a private conversation Severus was having with Lily. James and co were power tripping. The whole 'James changed' is BS because we dont SEE him change, except for biased half-truths from his best mates who will never speak ill of him, and to appease his son. We dont see the change, or remorse for his actions, because he thought they were justified. Because what they did to Severus for 7 years, caused him severe PTSD, along with anxiety, and likely depression. Saying James suddenly changed is erasing him of all wrong doings, and is a slap in the face for people who did suffer in the way that he did. Severus on the other hand, lived longer, therefore we actually DO see his change. From joining the DE's, to defecting by choice less than 2 years later, approaching the enemy at risk of his own life. We see his loyalty to Dumbledore. We see him save students. We see him protect Harry numerous times. We see him saving Order members. We see him snap at Phineas when he calls Hermione a Mudblood. We see him swap the Sword of Gryffindor, keep it safe, and give it to Harry upon the right conditions. We see him do so much good already, and yet you fail to see any of it. Severus Snape had many opportunities to flee his post and save himself. At first it was about Lily - but it became so much more than that. Much of what he did had nothing to do with Lily, so this obsessive notion haters throw around is BS. Severus saw Lily when they finished from Hogwarts, and never saw her alive after that. Unlike James, Severus did not blackmail her in the middle of torturing her friend, and asked to date her. That is disgusting behaviour on James' part. James died for people who loved him. Severus died for people who hated him. Because at the end of it all, Severus had a hand in Voldemort's downfall - twice. Was he nice? Hell no. Did he bully some of his students. Of course he did. I'd rather have an asshole who saves your life without question, than a man like Tom Riddle who appears friendly and charming, but will not hesitate to kill you. Severus and Tom are absolutely nothing alike. If Severus was so evil as you think he is, Harry would have never named a kid after him. So go take your petty hate elsewhere.
@@MonotJin You are definitely confusing adult Severus, with young Severus. This is about young Severus - as a teenager, he was no bully. But he grew to become one as he was influenced by a bad crowd of Slytherins and ostracised/tormented by the supposed 'good guy' Gryffindors. Still doesn't give James and co a free pass for acting like douchebags.
Ya'll should also react to Neville Longbottom and the Black Witch (extremely sad!), Le Maitre de la Mort, and The Founders: The Ravenclaw Ghost. They are all extremely accurate to the canon.
I like this fan film, but it makes no sense that Voldemort looks like that. His inhumane appearance came from the body he created himself in the Goblet of Fire. When the marauders were at Hogwarts Voldemort was probably looking more or less humane. Have you guys seen Darth Maul: Apprentice? I know its not HP-related but since you‘ve seen the Star Wars movies and it is one of the best fan films EVER made... I recommend reacting to it :)
No thats not true. Voldemort's inhumane appearance came from splitting his soul. The more he did it, the more inhuman he looked. Voldemort has that same description of a gaunt inhuman grey face with red slits for pupils in Dumbledore's memory in the Half-Blood Prince, when Voldemort asked Dumbledore for a job at Hogwarts.
Fun thing about HP series, it has potential to tell a lot of stories in coming years... A film franchise with so much potential is rarely born in the world of film industry these days... but it all came from Rowlings mind when she drinked coffee at caffe "Elephant house" XD XD Amazing... and probably cant happen again XD
You guys should check Marotos: uma história (Marauders: a history). It's a brazilian independent webserie made by fans. Two episodes are up in RUclips with English subtitles!!
they made a whole radio series that continues the story through the Wizarding War. I didn't listen to all of it but if you want more with the same cast plus more, they did spend time making more of filling in the gap of this story before Harry Potter's story.
The only thing I dislike is how they showed Voldemort, because unless I'm mistaken, he didn't have that noseless appearance until after he was resurrected with Harry's blood. I might be wrong of course, but I could have sworn he didn't just look like that.
You should react to "The Great Wizarding War" which is basically a direct sequel to this fan film, and is kind of like an audiobook with multiple chapters. The Voice Actors there are awesome and it is just A M A Z I N G!
Will u PLEASE react to 'a very potter musical' and 'a very potter sequel' there is also a third one called 'a very potter senior year' but it's not as funny as the other two but it definitely completes the trilogy. Even if you're not a fan of musicals, TRUST ME, u don't watch it for the music. Its one of the funniest things I've ever seen and in some places, its even more accurate to the books than the films are
We are reacting to the first one only. Coming out tomorrow, but I’ll prbly watch the rest ;). Just don’t want to do too many reactions of these. Maybe on a livestream.
Even thought some fans don't want to admit it, the Marauders were bullys and even if they try to excuse their behavior saying "snape was bad he deserves it" "those were harmless pranks" "snape was annoying james" "he was into dark magic anyways" dude, they made his life a living hell even before that, it's sad but this also shows how even the nicest people have their dark side, i never liked him (james) but I don't like snape either (cause he is NOT the innocent character y'all think he is lol) and i have a hard time liking the rest of the Marauders too (coming from a victim of bullying) harry potter has a great world full of interesting stories and I'm soo happy y'all are enjoying it ❤️❤️
i find the marauders and snape storyline is so interesting because i think (personally) let’s take james and snape for example, two very morally grey characters (in different aspects of their lives) and it shows almost different outcomes of situations based on the people around them. both of them are so good and bad in many ways and I find it very cool how it shows almost the spectrum of morally grey characters in the series. idk if that made any sense ahahah
So glad you took time to react to fan-made Harry Potter films.. Also glad to hear you are reading the books :D.. Since you guys really liked Snape (RIP Alan Rickman), I would highly recommend watching Sweeney Todd. Alan Rickman as Judge Turpin is awesome.. Also Helena Bonham Carter (Bellatrix in HP) is incredible as Mrs. Lovett. The movie also nicely portrays how insanely talented Sacha Baron Cohen (better known probably as either 'Ali G' or 'Borat') actually is.. Also, on a whole other subject: I've said it before, I'll say it again: I would love love LOVE to see your reactions to The Walking Dead :D..Just saying;..
I haven't watched this one bc is made by a Snape fan and I'm too much of a James one to find this movie mildly entertaining. But wanted to say how fun it has been to watch the both of you become fans of the franchise. I hope you end up watching the musicals, they are truly amazing; funny, clever and more diverse in how people felt about canon.
How about Severus Snape Origins and many other more characters... But Severus is my favorite character/comfort character so i always recommend him but.. There's so many origins from Harry Potter characters so i suggest you guys should watch it.. So uhmm thanks for reacting to this😊😊😊
Broad Strokes also did "The greater Good". It is about what happened when Dumbledore's sister died. It was their first attempt so the effects aren't as good, but the story is.
Important to remember, this entire "encounter" is from Snape's pov. Told by Snape, so, not necessarily the most accurate recounting of events. Same with the scenes in the actual movies. The only times we see James are from Snape's memories.
I doubt it matters here. In these books the memories don't really have a "pov". They're realistic, detailed, have a lot of gravity. Considering that Dumbledore uses the memories as a source of information about Voldemort, horcruxes and other important stuff, means that they can be trusted. If the memory depended on someone's pov, it would be totally unreliable as it could be deformed by this person's emotions etc. So for Rowling showing a memory is just another way of storytelling.
@@Lucklaran Well, exactly- he tampered with it. Purposefully, to hide something. That was not the case with other memories that we've seen (Snape's among the others) right? I'm just saying that those memories were kind of a big point of the plot and their meaning was pretty much mulled over in the story. Trying to interpret them as character's "pov" (like...what, it looked different from someone else's perspective? How exactly?) is like splitting hair, as that's rather not what the author had in mind.
They did James dirty (both the movies and fan films). Sure, he had no right to bully anyone, but teenage Snape wasn't innocent either. They went to school during the First wizarding war and Snape was hanging out with the racist of the wizarding world aka blood-supremacists, all future Death Eaters. He practiced the Dark Arts which is illegal magic but the teachers and Dumbledore turned a blind eye to most things happening at Hogwarts (typical lol). James, as a "noble Gryffindor" as he probably prided himself to be, hated the Dark Arts and anyone who supported Voldemort, though, again, it doesn't give him the right to bully people of course. It's just that he wasn't a villain. Sirius was the same though, they were like brothers. And it's Snape's fault he lost Lily, James has nothing to do with it because it's all Lily's decision.
A bully is always a bully anyway. As much as Snape was he was still minding his own business. Nobody cares if He lost lily or not even if he did he was just looking out to say sorry. Meanwhile James and his angsty jealousy in everything makes him worse and he deserved his death by trusting a traitor like Peter more.
To be honest, Snape had massive plot armor in this. When Sirius joins in with James to attack Snape, both flanked him from opposite ends, which is a good strategy and allows the two to box him in and split his focus and attention. When Remus and Peter joins in, they all decide to attack him from the front, which makes no tactical sense besides director's clear bias and Snape's plot armor. The Marauders had a clear tactical advantage despite Snape literally being the better duelist than all four combined. Also, the fiendfyre looked good but then the effects after the attack landed looked disappointing and small.
We dont know actually, this is a fanmade this isn't a canon of the universe but Broad Strokes are extremely respectful of this universe as they showed when they create the audio-series The Great Wizarding War which is an unknown masterpiece which continues the events of this fanfilm
Since you're also doing fantastic beasts reaction, plz do Dumbledore & Grindelwald fanfilm reaction! You'll understand their history a lil bit more through it & it shows how Dumbledore's sister was killed & all..
Hi, I just stepped over your HP Playlist and I absolutly love your reactions. I love it even more, that you're also reacting to fanmade content. I would also like to recommend some CMVs (Cosplay Music Videos). For example Loubelle Cosplay - I'll be good They are a german group and this video fits this movie quite well. I dont know, if you've heard of the whole Story of J.K.Rowling against trans rights. But for many parts of the lgbtq comunity HP is a big thing, cause it's like symbolizing love and equality. So it was a huge shock. Counterwise to this there is a swedish Cosplay group named mischief Managers that made a whole series of skits about Tedy Lupin starting his own resistance group named Squad (Socerers queers united against discrimination) fighting against old and unneccesary rules. They also have several CMVs and skits in the marauders Era and the original Timeline. I can especialy recommend their cmv phoenix and the skits 1977, 1980 and 1981. Shockingly they will make you nearly like and understand Peter Pettigrew. Greetings from germany ( and sorry for all of the mistakes, i hope it is all understandable)
I personally don't like how they are showing James because it is sort of mistaking the purpose of why was he showed bullying Snape as 15 years old kid. It was because Harry needed to see all those people who he idolized as flawed humans because it is part of growing. So it happened with James, Sirius (but just in the books), Remus (also just in the books) and Dumbledore. Snape is much bigger bully throughout the books than James ever is shown but we see James through keyhole and Snape in full view. Apart of that I love the colors in this movie, they are so cinematic and the quality of it is really good, spells look great! It is also a bit like a horror movie and acting is fantastic, I love Lily. My favorite fan made movie is about Neville, it is so touching and true to the books.
The only issue I had with the entire film is Voldemort... he didn't receive his snake like look until AFTER his resurrection in the graveyard with the help of Wormtail
James and crew were awful in the books. Horrible bullies. And lily herself said they hexed everyone just because they could, especially James, not just to Snape.
CADÊ ANIMAIS FANTÁSTICOS? (Where is Fantastic Beasts?) Hahahahaha (yes, i'm brazilian and i follow you, because you, guys, are amazing, or "bons pra caralho". Thanks for your job here :) )
the james and snape situation is pretty debatable amongst hp fans. my stance is in the middle, but i waver towards defending james most times although i see both sides very clearly james was a privileged and talented prick in school who had a crush on lily, who hardly gave him the time of day. severus was not privileged in any sense but was talented In other areas, and he had lily as a friend. i think they were both jealous of each other in ways and they simply clashed. they were young, it happens. james and sirius picked on him without a doubt, and snape didn't lie down and take everything. still, james was a bully to other people as well. however, he seemed to grow up a lot. he was head boy his last year and people credit that as one of the reasons lily fell for him. his growth with that being said, severus went down a dark path. he called lily a mudblood, he was obsessed with the dark arts, he became a death eater. despite the fact that he changed sides and became a spy for the order, he was still not over the beef with james and especially not when lily and james got together. she clearly did not love him, or like him anymore because of who he had become. he could not get over her, to the point that he asked Dumbledore to keep her safe from Voldemort without a care for her husband or son when harry got to Hogwarts he hated snape, a lot of them hated professor snape because he was a bully to them. he picked on harry on his first day and never really stopped. he bullied neville so hard that he became the kids worst fear in boggart form..... so james was a bully in high school and grew out of it, but snape bullied his students and never grew out of that. he saw harry in school and he was a spitting image of the boy who bullied him all of those years ago, with the eyes of the girl he loved his whole life. and he did save harry in multiple ways, so he is a wonderful grey character, both good and bad. i just think lily would be furious to see how snape treated harry to his face and i think james would punch him lol
It isnt canon. Bc Snape had already buddy with Lucius Malfoy when they're at school and he loves research about the Dark Art. I guess at first the Death Eater bunch just seem like a club of wizard to perform and study "real magic" unrestrictedly to the Nerdy Snape.
You can tell that they really liked the story of Harry Potter, I mean others would not react to fan films.
(There nothing wrong if others don't react to fan films)
fan films are so much fun especially for the marauders era characters because the harry potter movies/books give very limited information about each and every character (like the marauders and snape) that it’s so fun to see people’s interpretations
Snape didn’t turn Peter into a rat, he was already able to transfigure himself
I think he ment that's how Peter turned to the dark side
Yeah
@@deya8329 nah I think Peter became bad cuz he always wanted to be with the popular/powerful ppl and in this case was Voldy n gang
@@deya8329 No that isn't. When he transfigured, he was still pretty much a good person and a friend to the marauders. He didn't turn to voldemort's side until after they graduated from hogwarts
@@lapplandkun9273 they did just graduate it's more after they all went their separate ways
james actually never apologized for what he did to snape; he got away with everything and everyone was ready to forgive him (including lily and dambledore) because he was privliged rich kid; while they framed snape as a deatheater before he had even joined voldemort! james never felt sorry for tormenting snape and destroying his life; and snape was always damaged and hurt.. he never moved on with his life; i guess that's how bullying works..
Let's be honest this is torture not bullying. Bullying isn't using a marauders map to track every movement of your victim, or nearly getting someone killed by a werewolf
please also react to Sisters of House Black :D it's about Bellatrix and her sisters
Coming out Friday 😂
@@whitenoisereacts react to mischief managed, it’s another one about the marauders
@@whitenoisereacts is this still coming?!
@@whitenoisereacts it never came out do u ever plan on actually uploading it
This was impressive beyond expectation :)
I was seriously on Snape`s side.
You watch this and add to your mind:
Harry: "My father was a great man!!!"
Snape: "Your father was a swine!"
Snape`s childhood was extremely difficult, and along comes "Sunny Boy" James Potter and Co., and they have nothing better to do than bully him.
No wonder, he ended up with Voldemort. Who else was there to bond with?
I found the ending with Voldemort weird and too incorrect.
" she's not some prise to be won " severus my love..
went through your entire harry potter playlist and it was just a wholesome moment! so glad to see you guys enjoyed it
Dude. HARRY POTTER is the best!!
I do have to say that they need to cast this guy as young Severus Snape in a full movie immediately.
I always thought the same thing, but now Mick Ignis is Morgana Ignis, so I think this is never going to happen...
I’m just here to say Voldemort didn’t have a snake face until he was resurrected in goblet of fire. As he made more horcruxes, his face got less human, but he still had a nose and stuff haha!
Oh... oops
Yes but that is the face that is famous. Nobody would recognize him otherwise. It just made it more definitive so people cant say well maybe it was or maybe not. You know how crazy people get online.
@@zackstoner4523 yeah, I totally understand why they did it!
@@zackstoner4523 Doesn't make sense lore nor continuity wise. Sorry
Yeah, that kind of bothered me but it was an overlookable detail. They did the make up and prosthetics really well- except for the nose could have been a tad flatter.
That made me tear up... that Hug with Lily and Snape especially
There is a video of these actors reacting to this video for the first time, seeing it with the special effects added, and they go absolutely crazy.
After years of torture, harassment and having James hide behind his larg group of marauders ambushing lone Slytherin. It is SUPER SATISFYING to to see JAMES conscious and have to watch his precious gang get taken down by Snape one at time Al the whole knowing he deserves this. Super satisfying. Finally, he gets his cumupance.
Please react to “Neville Longbottom and the Black Witch” it’s about what Bellatrix did to Neville’s parents and it’s absolutely amazing! The effects and the acting are seriously so sooo good!
That's my favorite one!
Yeah, that's an awesome fan film plus you are damn hot evil🔥
@@aradsstates9584tf
You have to respect that when Snape disarmed James. He did not use his wand against him a unarmed man.
This is interesting because, in Snape's Worst Memory, James disarms Severus immediately then proceeds to attack him, even while knowing that he couldn't defend himself.
@@Inferno90 what makes it worse is this is canon
@@shyfoxfeatherhere6446 The fan film is canon ?
@@proushapourrostami9893no
Loved the reaction. If you're interested in watching more fan films I totally recommend "Neville Longbottom and the Black Witch" and "Sisters of House Black" they're amazing fan films and totally worth the watch.
I already watched both and they are really good like they should actually be movies
Also "dumbledore and grindelward - For the greater good - secrets of dumbledore"
This is so cool!!! I love that you guys are watching these
Two more coming!!!
I know this is not on your current list of fan films to react to, but I HIGHLY RECOMMEND another Broad Strokes Harry Potter Fan Film called "Dumbledore and Grindelwald - The Greater Good - Crimes of Grindelwald Prequel" This tells the story of an incident between a young Albus Dumbledore and Gellert Grindelwald which also involves Albus' brother Aberforth and their sister Ariana. The story is touched on briefly in the books and even more briefly in the movies. I very much like what they did with this fan film.
I’ll watch it, just not sure we can do a reaction to it
@@whitenoisereacts u should do the reaction to it.. you'll understand their relationship better & it's directly taken from Harry Potter books so it's not something new or something that fandom already doesn't know + it Directly shows the fight btw Grindelwald, Albus & aberforth & why Albus & Grindelwald seperated
I wasn't expecting this at all!! So great!
Almost forgot how impressive this movie is. It captures the darkness of the books so incredibly well. Potterheads are a dedicated bunch❤️ EDIT: "I was a little bit shocked at how evil James was". I detest James Potter. Went to school with several of his kind (that includes girls) and their bullying turned me into the fucked up adult I am now (or, at least, contributed hugely) . In my HP- villain-top ten he ranks right after Umbridge - both of them are just so incredibly... real. People still underestimate the effect school bullying can have on an individual. That's also why I love Snape so much^^
Yeah. To be fair, kids are little shits when they are young and I feel that James may have regretted what he did in younger years. That doesn’t excuse it, but I do think there is some understanding to be thrown his way because of it.
I actually don't like Lily or James Potter as characters, but you're painting Snape in too positive a light
Honestly, Snape started practicing dark magic and wasn't as good as you paint him to be, I'm not his fan at all and I think James was better person as he grew up, same as Sirius and Remus.
Guys don't get me wrong, I'm not saying he is an innocent little lamb who could do no wrong.^^ I simply consider him an incredibly well crafted literary character. Among other things he very realistically portrays the longtime effects multi-faceted trauma can have on someone who doesn't get any help and lacks any kind of support system.
@@whitenoisereacts I mean, Harry named his kids after James and Snape. Rowling did something good which was showing us the grey areas of so many characters. So many of her characters are so lifelike.
Everyone knows a James Potter. That typical arrogant bullying popular high school jock. Everyone knows an Umbridge. That person who uses politics/religion/ or whatever else as a smokescreen to sadistic torture. The fact that we all hate Umbridge so much is probably a huge compliment to her actress, Imelda Staunton. Everyone knows a Snape even. That petty cruel high school teacher who seems to hate everyone and everything(including himself) for no apparent reason. The two biggest grey area characters in the fandom are Snape and Dumbledore, those two get debated on the most from what I've seen. Harry himself had to endure so much with the abuse he suffered at the Dursleys' and all the deaths he witnessed and loved ones he lost, as well as all the Voldemort shit he had to contend with. Yet throughout it all, he was still able to remain kind, humble, and a decent human being, showing just how much Harry takes after his mother instead of his father in terms of personality. Harry's kids names are:
1) James Sirius Potter (eldest son)
2) Albus Severus Potter (younger son)
3)Lily Luna Potter (youngest and only daughter)
Rowling said Harry left Remus' name for Teddy to use, and George named his son after Fred, to honour his twin brother.
also this doesn’t show though that snape and james weren’t really attacking each other at hogwarts it was more or less like a prank war between the both of them. and lily stopped talking to snape when he called her a mud blood lol
It was still an interesting take IMO
@@whitenoisereacts yeah i really enjoyed it!
bullying is not school pranks, it was littraly 4 against 1!
@@ramosestos5205 i wasn’t talking about in the fan film lol /lh
@@elliemcnally1433 even in the books it was like this, james was such a coward and he takes 3 friends with him to bully snape; the mudblood incident alone is more then enough to explain what kind of creature james is, snape wanted to be powerfull that's why he joined the deatheaters; they were the only ones who protected him in this hell..
I wish the canon films had put this much effort into the choreography and special effects in most of their fights.
I only saw this now and WOW! The emotion that they got across in such a short space of time, was better than in the actual Harry Potter films, in my opinion. Well done to them! 👏👏👏
OH MY GOSHHHH, Im so friggen happy you guys watched this! I was wishing from the start of your harry potter adventures that you would
Yes, those were their patronuses
James: Stag, Sirius: Dog Remus, Wolf, and Peter: Rat.
I absolutely love this fan film, it’s SO good!
This was great! A few things not quite accurate, but for fan-made stuff I'm willing to let that slide, especially for the amazing quality that this was.
I'm still sad they had to leave and get on with their lives so soon, i was really hoping they would react to *Matilda 1996* or *Matilda the Musical.* 😢😞💔
I need to check out more of these fan films some good stuff 👌
That Fan Film was ABSOLUTELY amazing! I didn't expect anything and that Film was so fantastic. I wish I could see a whole film in the cinema. And the actors where so good. Thanks for reacting to that or I would have never seen that!
17:51 no, that's not how he got turned. he, and sirius and james were 3 unregistered animagi (wizards who could transform into an animal.. if you remember from the first film, mcgonagall, a registered animagi, had turned into a cat). they turned into animagi to keep remus company, since he was a werewolf..
Lol, did they read the books?
Back then, Severus was already hanging out with death eaters to be, cursing others for fun, called Lily a mudblood (in the heat of an argument) and tried to get Remus kicked out of school.
he was never a good person, and i dont get why people try to defend him.
@@viktoriabuzas2001 Exactly! The fact that other people mistreated him does not make him a good person.
Ok so i will correct you a little bit :
If he hang with death eater its logic bc they were his fucking roomate.
Snape never hex ppl for fun in fact its james and compagny Who did that
" hexing ppl just bc you like it " -lily
Idk out of what you invent that bullshit but shut up thats embarassing
Also he treat lily a mudblood after the bullying so it cant be a reason of that bullying
And for finish he never tried to fired Remus but he just tried to know what is Remus learn the diff
@@laurine____7543 First of all, why do you have to be rude just because you think I am wrong about a fictional character?
Secondly , Andromeda Tonks was in Slytherin, came from a pureblood family and some of her family members including her own sister were some of the fiercest Voldemort supporters and yet she did not become anything close to a death eater. Neither did Sirius, having a similar, but of course not equally drastic background. So growing up in the vicinity of extremists is certainly a possible explanation, but no apology for becoming one yourself. Lily‘s even said that she knew of his wanting to become a death eater, which he I might add did not feel the need to correct.
As for the hexing people for fun bit, James was undeniably a bully, a notion that I did not challenge at all. However Lupin‘s claim that Snape „never lost an opportunity to curse James“ (OotP) still stands uncontested.
In my opinion „sneaking around trying to find out what we were up to … hoping he could get us expelled“ (book 3) is a good indication for his trying to get Lupin expelled. If you think that the assertion is too biased, „I think the loss of the Order of Merlin hit him hard. So he - er - accidentally let slip that I am a werewolf this morning at breakfast.“ should suffice as far as evidence that he at least displayed such intentions later on goes.
In my opinion it shows his apparent urge to punish weaker group members in order to punish their friends.
Yes, Snape cannot be envied for what he had to endure both at home and in school. But to pretend he was an innocent victim of circumstance would from my point of view be a misjudgment of his character.
Bruh I actually remember hearing about this fan film on german news when it came out and If I remember correctly they at first had problems with Warner Brothers because a lot of people apparently thought this was legit because it looked and felt so accurate lol
edit
at least that’s what they said on the news
Even if you guys don't do a reaction video for it you should definitely check out A Very Potter Musical by Team Starkid. It's a hilarious parody musical from like 10-12 years ago. There's a playlist on RUclips of all the parts.
I really highly recommend Mischief Managed! It's filmed at Oxford university so it's on the same location that a lot of the actual film was shot at, it's super fun and silly and follows part of the marauders' school days
Neville Longbottom and the Black Witch is another great one, one of my favorites!
That was sick isn't it ? You guys should see The Sisters Of House Black too, this fan movie is as brilliant as this one. Male like female actors are stunning and they gives chills 🥰 bye guys, love your videos, kisses from France
The greater good is also a great one, going into the relationship between Dumbledore, Grindelwald and Dumbeldore's sister
I strongly recommend you to listen their audio-series that Broad Strokes made and which continues the story of Snape and the Marauders during the great war named The Great Wizarding War... it's still in progress cuz the episodes take a long time to be created. This is a freakin masterpiece. There aren't true canons cuz nothing was written by JK Rowling about this period. All we have is some informations about the first Order of the Phoenix in the 5th book of Harry Potter. There are so much interesting characters like the two brothers of Molly Weasley who died in hero (Fabian and Gideon same initials as Fred and Georges) or the Neville's parents and from what we learn in the Harry Potter books 4 and 5 is such interesting (all fights of Alastor Moody, the Ministery's cases with Bartemius Crouch etc...). But plz, u have to listen this serial audio, u won't regretted it. This is, by far, the darkest period of this universe that explains too why this fan-made is dark x)
yea it was such great work... i didn't like how lily was portrayed as an angel, and i didn't like how she gave snape an alternative but he chose the dark side anyway; apart from that it was such a great serie..
when I watched this I just couldn't with lily. James just flat out emitted to a 4 v 1 against Snape and Lilys like "I might forgive you but the people who just tried to kill you are fine by me"
Wow what a bitch, in the books she is quite dark yes severus did bad things and his obsession with the dark arts drove Lily away but Lily not forgiveing Severus and constantly witnessing him BEING ABUSED AND TOMENTED is just soo cruel. being sorted into two seperate houses is not an excuse for their their friendship to disolve after fifth year. yes one bad word and lily never knew severus's real truth about him his deep Love for her its just a tragity!
This movie paints Snape in too positive a light tbh. And I'm someone who actually really doesn't like James Potter, or Lily for that matter.
Edit:
1) James matured in his 7th year. If anything, it's likely James would have approached Snape to make peace rather than fight again. 2) James and Snape would go at each other. It wasn't always one sided. 3) Fiendfyre is dark magic and the marauders, outside of Peter later in life, didn't partake. 4) Snape was friends with future death eaters since his first year. He was already planning on joining Voldemort after hogwarts by his 6th year. 5) James would never say, "Severus please." 6) Lily never spoke to Snape after he called her a mudblood. That's why he regrets that memory so much. He never got closure with Lily. She didn't row with Snape because he defended himself against James smh. 🤦🏽♂️
Well made movie in everything but the story and understanding of these characters.
And also, the marauders, outside of Peter, were basically like popular Hermiones. They wouldn't have gotten their ass handed to them this easily
Still pretty cool tho
@@whitenoisereacts super well made, but I have opinions and want them heard! 🤣
Idk about that. Sirius said he got better in his seventh year when he "stopped hexing people for the heck of it." But he also mentioned Snape was an exception and would "hex him right back." In this video they were both going for each other as well, though James did start it. James did mature to a degree but this was right after he left Hogwarts, its not too hard to believe he would do this. In addition the reason he was more anxious about Snape now was because he was with Lily and didn't want Snape anywhere near her, not just their usual rivalry, so it fits that he was more aggressive. As for James saying "Severus Please," it does make sense because like I said he has matured to a degree and cares more about his friends getting hurt than about Snape. Lupin was bleeding out, Sirius was hit by the Cruciatus Curse. Yes, Snape was friends with future Death Eaters but that doesnt mean anything. Technically, Sirius, Lupin and James were friends with a future Death Eater as well. Plus in their school years, the worst thing mentioned that Snape's friends did was enlarge somebody's head. Fred and George have done things at about that level (example: making sweets that turns people into canaries and possibly damaging Montague by shoving him into the broken Vanishing Cabinet). Meanwhile, Sirius pretty much tried to commit murder and get Snape killed. There's no evidence that Snape was planning on joining Voldemort while he was in school. The only thing that suggests so is Lily saying that to Snape when she is very angry at him, as thats what she believes, but its more than likely if "Snape's worst memory" had never occurred, things wouldve gone very differently. The last part I vehemently disagree with, its never inferred that the Marauders were popular Hermione's. Were they talented? Yes. But never like that. The only thing they had above what most graduating students did was more experience, animal transformation, and a slightly expanded knowledge of experimental curses. But there's nothing that suggests they were anywhere near as powerful as Snape. They weren't even a powerful as half the Order like Kingsley, Moody, or the Aurors, forget Snape. Hermione was better than the Marauders as in her 5th year, as she was able to modify/combine a jinx that nobody could reverse and that literally prevented someone from talking or else a bunch of spots would cover their face. Nobody was able to cure this jinx, not even the teachers of Hogwarts who are pretty powerful. At 17, she was able to constantly keep up protections and magical enhancements to hide from the entire world including the most powerful dark wizard of all time. The Marauders weren't at Hermione's level in their youth, so they were nowhere freaking near Snape's level. In the books its stated "Snape knew more curses when he arrived at school than most 6th and 7th years ever did." Snape literally created new spells, outsmarted the textbook makers for potions (who have to be pretty smart in their own right) and literally made potions better than any student ever and even rewrote the recipes for them to make them better, was extremely skilled in Occlumency, and went on to literally lie directly to the face of the most powerful dark wizard ever who was an unparalleled Legilmens and be one of the only two people who could fly without the use of brooms (the Death Eaters couldn't do that in the books). The Marauders dont stand a chance against Snape.
Lily also still didnt forgive him hear, thought the same thing of him he did back then, and went off with James. Its still his worst memory.
This is my favourite fan film because it stays quite true to the personalities of Severus and James (though I'm hesitant of the personalities of Sirius and Remus, especially in the fight). This is always how I imagined the Marauders to be during school given what we know, and makes so much sense to how Severus becomes so messed after all those antagonistic years. People are always saying, 'no, it was a mutual rivalry!'.It's not a rivalry if is 1 vs 2-4...that's bullying. People like to say it's that so they can feel better about James and refuse to believe that yes, he was a bullying asshole. Severus only ever fought back in self-defence, and will never willfully attack them unless he was baited to it. It would go completely against Severus' character if he chose to attack them because he felt like it - he knew better if he knew he was outnumbered.
Aside from that, I REALLY love the casting and the effects! Such an amazing fan film, for sure!
very well said;
lets be realistic here now. It was clearly stated James and the rest of the marauders matured and left Snape alone. I do not like James enough to understand his actions, because he was an arrogant rich bratty boy, but he bullied Snape because Snape had and continued to have prejudice against muggleborns. You cannot deny the fact Snape was always a racist asshole, he never changed his ways, he was only nice to Lily because he became obsessed with her for years. Snape joined a terrorist group because he got rejected. James is the morally grey character here, Snape always remained a bad guy. He was bullied because of his beliefs, not because he was different. Are we really going to ignore the fact Snape was very similar to Voldemort? Snape created a nickname for himself to get rid of his muggle heritage, just like Voldemort did. Snape despises muggleborns and the fact he is not a pureblood like most of Slytherin. Snape bullies his students on multiple occasions, and he never done a good thing in his life. He only cared about Lily, and her safety. In the books he only asks Lily to be hidden, and in response, Dumbledore tells him he is disgusting. Snape did not become a double agent because his allegiance changed, and he realised he was on the wrong side the whole time. He did it because Dumbledore kept him in the loop by blackmailing him. Dumbledore cleared his name after Voldemort was defeated the first time, in favour of becoming a spy for him and whenever Snape did not want to do a certain thing, he would always be reminded of Lily by Dumbledore, to at least do it for her sake. I will always continue to despise Snape, he is not a morally grey character, he is a disgusting piece of shit. end of story.
@@viktoriabuzas2001 It's really disappointing when people don't care to understand Snape's story, because those such as yourself, have these narrow-minded views when it's been indicated already by the author herself, that Severus Snape is indeed, a grey character. I suppose you've never suffered parential abuse, and bullying/harassment/ostracization/public humiliation by fellow peers for seven years? I don't suppose you have any idea what it's like to be attacked and singled out for being different? I don't suppose you understand the mindset of an abused child, and how isolated they can be, and are easily influenced by a side who can make a person feel safe? A child so severely ostracised by the people 'of good', that conveneing with the darker crowd seems far more appealing. The people of good, treated him like shit for no real reason, except they were bored.
James is a douchebag who never changed. He flaunted his power with his gang, hexed other students, and bullied Severus 'because he exists'. Because James couldn't keep his mouth shut on the first train ride, in a private conversation Severus was having with Lily. James and co were power tripping. The whole 'James changed' is BS because we dont SEE him change, except for biased half-truths from his best mates who will never speak ill of him, and to appease his son. We dont see the change, or remorse for his actions, because he thought they were justified. Because what they did to Severus for 7 years, caused him severe PTSD, along with anxiety, and likely depression. Saying James suddenly changed is erasing him of all wrong doings, and is a slap in the face for people who did suffer in the way that he did.
Severus on the other hand, lived longer, therefore we actually DO see his change. From joining the DE's, to defecting by choice less than 2 years later, approaching the enemy at risk of his own life. We see his loyalty to Dumbledore. We see him save students. We see him protect Harry numerous times. We see him saving Order members. We see him snap at Phineas when he calls Hermione a Mudblood. We see him swap the Sword of Gryffindor, keep it safe, and give it to Harry upon the right conditions. We see him do so much good already, and yet you fail to see any of it.
Severus Snape had many opportunities to flee his post and save himself. At first it was about Lily - but it became so much more than that. Much of what he did had nothing to do with Lily, so this obsessive notion haters throw around is BS. Severus saw Lily when they finished from Hogwarts, and never saw her alive after that. Unlike James, Severus did not blackmail her in the middle of torturing her friend, and asked to date her. That is disgusting behaviour on James' part.
James died for people who loved him. Severus died for people who hated him. Because at the end of it all, Severus had a hand in Voldemort's downfall - twice. Was he nice? Hell no. Did he bully some of his students. Of course he did.
I'd rather have an asshole who saves your life without question, than a man like Tom Riddle who appears friendly and charming, but will not hesitate to kill you. Severus and Tom are absolutely nothing alike.
If Severus was so evil as you think he is, Harry would have never named a kid after him.
So go take your petty hate elsewhere.
"It would go completely against Severus' character if he chose to attack them because he felt like it"
I don't know the guy bullies children.
@@MonotJin You are definitely confusing adult Severus, with young Severus. This is about young Severus - as a teenager, he was no bully. But he grew to become one as he was influenced by a bad crowd of Slytherins and ostracised/tormented by the supposed 'good guy' Gryffindors. Still doesn't give James and co a free pass for acting like douchebags.
Ya'll should also react to Neville Longbottom and the Black Witch (extremely sad!), Le Maitre de la Mort, and The Founders: The Ravenclaw Ghost. They are all extremely accurate to the canon.
I’ve never seen this, how violent! I’d hate to think the marauders’ beef was anything more than just school pranks
snape is one of the best !
I like this fan film, but it makes no sense that Voldemort looks like that. His inhumane appearance came from the body he created himself in the Goblet of Fire. When the marauders were at Hogwarts Voldemort was probably looking more or less humane.
Have you guys seen Darth Maul: Apprentice? I know its not HP-related but since you‘ve seen the Star Wars movies and it is one of the best fan films EVER made... I recommend reacting to it :)
No thats not true. Voldemort's inhumane appearance came from splitting his soul. The more he did it, the more inhuman he looked. Voldemort has that same description of a gaunt inhuman grey face with red slits for pupils in Dumbledore's memory in the Half-Blood Prince, when Voldemort asked Dumbledore for a job at Hogwarts.
Fun thing about HP series, it has potential to tell a lot of stories in coming years... A film franchise with so much potential is rarely born in the world of film industry these days... but it all came from Rowlings mind when she drinked coffee at caffe "Elephant house" XD XD Amazing... and probably cant happen again XD
You guys should check Marotos: uma história (Marauders: a history). It's a brazilian independent webserie made by fans. Two episodes are up in RUclips with English subtitles!!
its almost like those martial arts movies where the master has to fight bullies which is more than 2 people and snape is the master
they made a whole radio series that continues the story through the Wizarding War. I didn't listen to all of it but if you want more with the same cast plus more, they did spend time making more of filling in the gap of this story before Harry Potter's story.
The only thing I dislike is how they showed Voldemort, because unless I'm mistaken, he didn't have that noseless appearance until after he was resurrected with Harry's blood. I might be wrong of course, but I could have sworn he didn't just look like that.
You should react to "The Great Wizarding War" which is basically a direct sequel to this fan film, and is kind of like an audiobook with multiple chapters. The Voice Actors there are awesome and it is just A M A Z I N G!
I wrote a comment in other video suggesting this without knowing you watched it already xD
Please react to the sisters of house black , it's a fan film and you get more detail on bellatrix, the black family and the malfoys
Glad you guys enjoyed it
This was a good fanfilm I'm so ready for you to react to the sister house of black
I wish they would make a series of the marauders!!
Will u PLEASE react to 'a very potter musical' and 'a very potter sequel' there is also a third one called 'a very potter senior year' but it's not as funny as the other two but it definitely completes the trilogy. Even if you're not a fan of musicals, TRUST ME, u don't watch it for the music. Its one of the funniest things I've ever seen and in some places, its even more accurate to the books than the films are
We are reacting to the first one only. Coming out tomorrow, but I’ll prbly watch the rest ;). Just don’t want to do too many reactions of these. Maybe on a livestream.
Even thought some fans don't want to admit it, the Marauders were bullys and even if they try to excuse their behavior saying "snape was bad he deserves it" "those were harmless pranks" "snape was annoying james" "he was into dark magic anyways" dude, they made his life a living hell even before that, it's sad but this also shows how even the nicest people have their dark side, i never liked him (james) but I don't like snape either (cause he is NOT the innocent character y'all think he is lol) and i have a hard time liking the rest of the Marauders too (coming from a victim of bullying) harry potter has a great world full of interesting stories and I'm soo happy y'all are enjoying it ❤️❤️
i find the marauders and snape storyline is so interesting because i think (personally) let’s take james and snape for example, two very morally grey characters (in different aspects of their lives) and it shows almost different outcomes of situations based on the people around them. both of them are so good and bad in many ways and I find it very cool how it shows almost the spectrum of morally grey characters in the series. idk if that made any sense ahahah
Chills at the end
I genuinely skip I thought it was uploaded.. Nope it was live LMAO
So glad you took time to react to fan-made Harry Potter films.. Also glad to hear you are reading the books :D.. Since you guys really liked Snape (RIP Alan Rickman), I would highly recommend watching Sweeney Todd. Alan Rickman as Judge Turpin is awesome.. Also Helena Bonham Carter (Bellatrix in HP) is incredible as Mrs. Lovett. The movie also nicely portrays how insanely talented Sacha Baron Cohen (better known probably as either 'Ali G' or 'Borat') actually is.. Also, on a whole other subject: I've said it before, I'll say it again: I would love love LOVE to see your reactions to The Walking Dead :D..Just saying;..
I haven't watched this one bc is made by a Snape fan and I'm too much of a James one to find this movie mildly entertaining. But wanted to say how fun it has been to watch the both of you become fans of the franchise. I hope you end up watching the musicals, they are truly amazing; funny, clever and more diverse in how people felt about canon.
After reading All the young dudes it fet weird to see a different story line, but it was really good!!!
they also made a dumbledore one i believe
damn ive made some starwars fan films but now i wanna do harry potter lol
How about Severus Snape Origins and many other more characters... But Severus is my favorite character/comfort character so i always recommend him but.. There's so many origins from Harry Potter characters so i suggest you guys should watch it.. So uhmm thanks for reacting to this😊😊😊
Oh good I'm not alone in finding Severus a comfort character
@@Phantom_Fireside Yesssss
Broad Strokes also did "The greater Good". It is about what happened when Dumbledore's sister died. It was their first attempt so the effects aren't as good, but the story is.
IM AGAIN TOO LATE FOR THE LIVE.
I LOVE YOUR REACTIONS BTW! ❤️❤️❤️
Join us for the live tonight:)
@@whitenoisereacts okay❤️
Important to remember, this entire "encounter" is from Snape's pov. Told by Snape, so, not necessarily the most accurate recounting of events. Same with the scenes in the actual movies. The only times we see James are from Snape's memories.
I doubt it matters here. In these books the memories don't really have a "pov". They're realistic, detailed, have a lot of gravity. Considering that Dumbledore uses the memories as a source of information about Voldemort, horcruxes and other important stuff, means that they can be trusted. If the memory depended on someone's pov, it would be totally unreliable as it could be deformed by this person's emotions etc. So for Rowling showing a memory is just another way of storytelling.
@@leno_o17 Except that Slughorn tampered with his memory, so, no, they are clearly not that reliable.
@@Lucklaran Well, exactly- he tampered with it. Purposefully, to hide something. That was not the case with other memories that we've seen (Snape's among the others) right? I'm just saying that those memories were kind of a big point of the plot and their meaning was pretty much mulled over in the story. Trying to interpret them as character's "pov" (like...what, it looked different from someone else's perspective? How exactly?) is like splitting hair, as that's rather not what the author had in mind.
Such a brilliant idea to react to this
They did James dirty (both the movies and fan films).
Sure, he had no right to bully anyone, but teenage Snape wasn't innocent either. They went to school during the First wizarding war and Snape was hanging out with the racist of the wizarding world aka blood-supremacists, all future Death Eaters. He practiced the Dark Arts which is illegal magic but the teachers and Dumbledore turned a blind eye to most things happening at Hogwarts (typical lol).
James, as a "noble Gryffindor" as he probably prided himself to be, hated the Dark Arts and anyone who supported Voldemort, though, again, it doesn't give him the right to bully people of course. It's just that he wasn't a villain. Sirius was the same though, they were like brothers.
And it's Snape's fault he lost Lily, James has nothing to do with it because it's all Lily's decision.
A bully is always a bully anyway. As much as Snape was he was still minding his own business. Nobody cares if He lost lily or not even if he did he was just looking out to say sorry. Meanwhile James and his angsty jealousy in everything makes him worse and he deserved his death by trusting a traitor like Peter more.
To be honest, Snape had massive plot armor in this. When Sirius joins in with James to attack Snape, both flanked him from opposite ends, which is a good strategy and allows the two to box him in and split his focus and attention. When Remus and Peter joins in, they all decide to attack him from the front, which makes no tactical sense besides director's clear bias and Snape's plot armor. The Marauders had a clear tactical advantage despite Snape literally being the better duelist than all four combined.
Also, the fiendfyre looked good but then the effects after the attack landed looked disappointing and small.
oh my god you guys should watch neville longbottom and the black witch. it's amazing.
Plese someone tell me if I'm wrong, I dont remember that Lily ever forgive Severus because he call her Mudblood, did she???
We dont know actually, this is a fanmade this isn't a canon of the universe but Broad Strokes are extremely respectful of this universe as they showed when they create the audio-series The Great Wizarding War which is an unknown masterpiece which continues the events of this fanfilm
She didn't
I don't remember this story from the book? Any references guys? Is it only the story from fan theories?
You should check out Star Wars: The Foretelling - A Jedi Fallen Order Story!!
Do you think you can react to Dark on Netflix in the future? Amazing show, only 3 seasons for the whole series
Possibly, we are going to start doing more tv soon, and when we do, I’ll look at that.
@@whitenoisereacts great! You won't regret it
For next time, I would recommend you to watch Harry Potter: How it should have ended....
Since you're also doing fantastic beasts reaction, plz do Dumbledore & Grindelwald fanfilm reaction! You'll understand their history a lil bit more through it & it shows how Dumbledore's sister was killed & all..
I’m curious how Lily figured out where they were
Hi, I just stepped over your HP Playlist and I absolutly love your reactions.
I love it even more, that you're also reacting to fanmade content.
I would also like to recommend some CMVs (Cosplay Music Videos). For example Loubelle Cosplay - I'll be good
They are a german group and this video fits this movie quite well.
I dont know, if you've heard of the whole Story of J.K.Rowling against trans rights. But for many parts of the lgbtq comunity HP is a big thing, cause it's like symbolizing love and equality. So it was a huge shock. Counterwise to this there is a swedish Cosplay group named mischief Managers that made a whole series of skits about Tedy Lupin starting his own resistance group named Squad (Socerers queers united against discrimination) fighting against old and unneccesary rules. They also have several CMVs and skits in the marauders Era and the original Timeline. I can especialy recommend their cmv phoenix and the skits 1977, 1980 and 1981.
Shockingly they will make you nearly like and understand Peter Pettigrew.
Greetings from germany
( and sorry for all of the mistakes, i hope it is all understandable)
Please react to "Voldemort: Orgins of the Heir" I personally think that it's well made and a good story.
*Watch "Dubledore vs Grindwald: greater good" fan film.*
React to Sisters of House of Black. It came out last year. Quite well made
How many hp fan films you are doing as reaction....and which one??
Sister Black and A Very Potter Musical, that’s it for now, any others we will do later or just watch for enjoyment
I personally don't like how they are showing James because it is sort of mistaking the purpose of why was he showed bullying Snape as 15 years old kid. It was because Harry needed to see all those people who he idolized as flawed humans because it is part of growing. So it happened with James, Sirius (but just in the books), Remus (also just in the books) and Dumbledore. Snape is much bigger bully throughout the books than James ever is shown but we see James through keyhole and Snape in full view. Apart of that I love the colors in this movie, they are so cinematic and the quality of it is really good, spells look great! It is also a bit like a horror movie and acting is fantastic, I love Lily.
My favorite fan made movie is about Neville, it is so touching and true to the books.
Whoot! First in line! 😍🙏🏽👑🌹
The only issue I had with the entire film is Voldemort... he didn't receive his snake like look until AFTER his resurrection in the graveyard with the help of Wormtail
watch sisters of house black too!
Check out Studio C on RUclips, they have some "oh Snape" videos. So much fun! Snape and Voldemort conversations 🤣 keep up the good work!
James and crew were awful in the books. Horrible bullies. And lily herself said they hexed everyone just because they could, especially James, not just to Snape.
Please do the greater good!!!! It's by the same people
Yes then!!! The best fan film there is, react to mischief managed
CADÊ ANIMAIS FANTÁSTICOS? (Where is Fantastic Beasts?)
Hahahahaha
(yes, i'm brazilian and i follow you, because you, guys, are amazing, or "bons pra caralho". Thanks for your job here :) )
Sisters of house black?
you should react to voldemort: origins of the heir !!
Damn u really hate james when you see that xD
no WAY omg yesss
the james and snape situation is pretty debatable amongst hp fans. my stance is in the middle, but i waver towards defending james most times although i see both sides very clearly
james was a privileged and talented prick in school who had a crush on lily, who hardly gave him the time of day. severus was not privileged in any sense but was talented In other areas, and he had lily as a friend. i think they were both jealous of each other in ways and they simply clashed. they were young, it happens. james and sirius picked on him without a doubt, and snape didn't lie down and take everything. still, james was a bully to other people as well. however, he seemed to grow up a lot. he was head boy his last year and people credit that as one of the reasons lily fell for him. his growth
with that being said, severus went down a dark path. he called lily a mudblood, he was obsessed with the dark arts, he became a death eater. despite the fact that he changed sides and became a spy for the order, he was still not over the beef with james and especially not when lily and james got together. she clearly did not love him, or like him anymore because of who he had become. he could not get over her, to the point that he asked Dumbledore to keep her safe from Voldemort without a care for her husband or son
when harry got to Hogwarts he hated snape, a lot of them hated professor snape because he was a bully to them. he picked on harry on his first day and never really stopped. he bullied neville so hard that he became the kids worst fear in boggart form.....
so james was a bully in high school and grew out of it, but snape bullied his students and never grew out of that. he saw harry in school and he was a spitting image of the boy who bullied him all of those years ago, with the eyes of the girl he loved his whole life. and he did save harry in multiple ways, so he is a wonderful grey character, both good and bad. i just think lily would be furious to see how snape treated harry to his face and i think james would punch him lol
is that the begining of him becoming a death eater?
Yes
It isnt canon. Bc Snape had already buddy with Lucius Malfoy when they're at school and he loves research about the Dark Art. I guess at first the Death Eater bunch just seem like a club of wizard to perform and study "real magic" unrestrictedly to the Nerdy Snape.