I love the way Maya raises her right hand high when she's going for those high notes (especially when Belting), instead of raising her head up. That's good vocal technique there. The raised hand opens up her ribcage and allows the lungs to give her solid breath support and she avoid tension in the throat
I always get chills hearing Maya's part. She had already left the group by the time I knew about this group, so I only knew her in this song. She really has a powerful voice. Almost similar to Keiko's.
@@MorioDaichi You're right about Hikaru depending on the throat a bit for belting power. Not singing from below. Just watch the posture in this song during the belting phases. Compare how Hikaru and Maya stood when belting the chorus passage.
I became a fan of Kalafina just recently and the first time I heard this song was during their 10th anniversary concert. I thought it was great but this, with Maya, holy shirt it was mind-blowing!!! I couldn't stop my goosebumps!!!
Next level right here. Their voices were all still young in this performance and Maya helped to complete the live harmonies much more fully. There was much less reliance on the recorded background vocals. There were a bunch of layered vocals and dual harmonies that she performed, providing a medium low range that freed Keiko to rest at times, and her belted section showed her power with a comparable tone to Hikaru's.
Huh, it's so crazy, a while back I was searching frantically for the old version of this song with Maya in it, and now it just pops up randomly in my auto queue! Thanks for the upload!
i was never into kalafina until after they disbanded, and i cant seem to find many performances with maya. as much as i love the three of them, there's just something about her belting voice that is just so magical (but like the same goes to all of them lmao)
We are in the same boat! I totally agree with you. I also discovered Kalafina post-disbanding, through a RUclips recommendation to their 10th Anniversary Budokan llve, and the mystical "Ring Your Bell" intro caught me and bound me (they sounded like angels) even though I could never imagine watching a 2-hour-plus RUclips video. I watched it all through! I have become partially obsessed with hearing Maya sing live from this period. Her tone and obviously punching below her maximum high pitch and power (it seemed oddly easy for her) belting the same chorus part as Hikaru, made me excited to hear more of her. What I even noticed is that Keiko amplified her volume for her harmony low notes when singing with Maya, to match the slightly higher power of Maya's belt compared to my favourite girl, Hikaru. I am interested in Maya's head voice, her highest pitch, her low notes, dynamics. I wish we had a documentary on just her.
If someone would post the Sprinter LIVE of this performance we would see Maya with her full potential, but anyway Maya's career is short to be honest due to personal reason for letting her finish college first but sadly she didn't came back after making that decision ):
@@catsinni I heard that she joined a dance group or something. It's similar to Kawashima Yuuka (founding member of Perfume) who left the group for school and then tried multiple times to come back into entertainment with series of relative failures, while the group went on to become one of the biggest in Japan .
Impossible for me to watch this legendary masterpiece without tears in my eyes... Hikaru's voice is just OMG ❤ Though I prefer Wakana's current voice, this is by far the best live version to ARIA 🥹
Watched this again and I have few wishes: 1. We could watch a high-res and full-width version of this live performance. 2. We could watch a rehearsal video for this performance with all four singers. 3. More vocal teacher/coach reaction channels listened and reacted to this. 4. Maya was active on social media so we could see her activities in music/dance/etc.
Which recorded version exactly? The very original one of the movie or the Aria Live from the 5th Anniversary disc? The Aria Live of the anniversary disc is awesome too. Everyone should listen to that version. It sounds way different than this one and the original.
It's so easy to confuse Maya and Hikaru sometimes (especially when they're belting). All this time, I thought 4:05 was sung by Hikaru... Then I took a glance at the screen lol.
Same! It’s just Maya’s doesn’t have the “metallic” element Hikaru’s voice has - it’s softer. I’d say her voice is like a mixture of Wakana’s and Hikaru’s.
They have similar tomes. I think she has just a teeny bit more power than Hikaru and a slightly richer low range, though Hikaru is my favorite. I saw this because she covered some mid-low notes (that gave Keiko rest at some points) and she holds her mike further away from her mouth almost all through the performance.
It's not very clear if she left for school, yes, but it is confirmed that Maya's decision was at the behest of her father. He wanted his daughter to have a different career. In Japan, parents, especially fathers, have a lot of say in their children's lives. It's highly unlikely that Maya will ever perform with Kalafina again.
I dont know about her father, but its confirmed that she has return to her hometown, has finished her school and now she's in some dancing group, married and with a child too.
maya gave a reason in twitter,she said that because she was lack of strength。But i think it's a euphemism and the truth is she was eliminated by corporation。
I wish Hikaru's voice could have a chance to heal. I feel like there is a problem now. Maybe nodes? That would be so sad :( I love Hikaru and want the best for her just as much as the other members.
I don't think Hikaru's voice will come back. But it's really not a problem, I already get used to it. Her vocal cord is changing while she is getting older, therefore she has to change her way to sing. And so does Wakana. Besides, Kalafina has TOO MUCH work for lives, if Hikaru is still using her previous way to sing, it will hurt more.
What exactly happened to her voice? I mean, I know she sounds quite different now, if not worse. Did she hurt her throat or something? Is it because of the extensive live shows, so much that it exhausted her voice, or anything?
I think it's a combination of neverending live shows and work (especially from 2014-on as they become more popular) and Hikaru's vocal cords changing as she gets older, as the person below said. In addition, Hikaru has frequently been required to strain her voice in songs by singing to the top of her range (like in this song) or, more frequently, by lowering it just barely above breakage (a la Magia)... It may just be that her voice isn't meant to do that all the time, even if it sounds really cool. She also has said that it takes a lot for her to take care of her voice, she takes a lot of steps to protect it.
honestly I think Hikaru's voice sounds fine despite changes. It's Wakana's loss of breath and difficulty in singing that worries me recently. I always hear her gasping/hiccup sound both in live & recorded.
I don’t think that there’s nearly as much to worry about with Hikaru, or Wakana, at this point in comparison to when you all posted this. Vocally Hikaru has changed pretty drastically - my personally most audible times hearing this would include sitting down on the 9+ONE and 10th Anni concert videos and focusing only on drastic requirements, like her falsettos in the 9+1 Oblivious and the 10th Anni’s Lirica. However, I don’t think anyone yet knows if Hikaru got what’s often labeled “the singer’s surgery” as Wakana has. (I will say the surgery helped her a nice amount but oh my God she STILL CANNOT BREATHE. It’s just too much of a habit at this point although it’s noticeably better in comparison to, say, Red Moon era.)
I'm with you. There would have been more variety and energy in their voices, and maybe Hikaru and Wakana wouldn't have had to strain their voices so much since the load would have been shared.
Her voice was so powerful and more just a bit more resonant than Hikaru's. The way she holds her microphone away from her face shows that she had enough vocal power to project to the mike! She was really missed as a force in Kalafina.
OK, just listened to this again and Maya was awesome: 1. Her voice is powerful, loud, rich and piercing. 2. She can obviously out-dance everyone else. Does anyone know her social media - Twitter, etc.? Does she have a website?
Luego de verlo varias veces me fijé en lo similar que es el Belting de Maya al de Hikaru, pero en su voz más central hay un punto intermedio entre Hikaru y Keiko demasiado increíble. Le da una llenura preciosa a la canción.
Yes! Maya is sorely missed. I can imagine how much fulness she could have given to other songs we know, since she covered high, middle/lead, and low parts in this song. A really versatile singer. And her mix belt was balanced and powerful (she also had stronger head voice than Hikaru and could match Wakana to my ears).
Good question. Overuse of her voice in too many live singing arrangements and being written a lot of music in her higher range. Probably not having a consistent vocal coach to help keep her voice healthy through the rigors of a decade. Also age changed her voice...
@@TRal55 If we feel like this, I imagine how she feels knowing in her memory and mind that she can "hit" some notes but her body/voice won't do what she wants it to. And she experienced the deterioration/change firsthand.
@@TheSeeking2know Definitely. It's upsetting to know that that can even happen. I never knew someone's vocal power could change like that. I definitely feel for her.
+Delian Jay yup. unlike Wakana and Keiko, she has an average Japanese typical voice. Wakana and Keiko are taking their level out of Japanese typical singer. If you know what I mean.
![[Vietsub - Kara] Oblivious - TypeMoon Fes 10th anniversary](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/X-OnvAR_AhY/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG SUB] FictionJunction - Kimi ga Ita Monogatari (2014 elemental tour live)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/h5kphpt9bgA/mqdefault.jpg)
やっぱりこの頃のARIAに戻ってきてしまう。 大サビのMAYAのガツンと来る感じだったり4人だからこその重なり、当時のいい意味での粗削りなとこ、すべてが完璧に重なってる気がする。。。
何度も聴きたくなるARIA。MAYAの声はHIKARUの声よりも高くはないんだろうけど空間を穿つような広がり方が凄いなと思う。これだけの声量でもまだ余裕がありそうな。フルパワーでだしたらどれだけ出るんだろう。
一方でHIKARUの声もこの時期は金属的な響きでなおかつ声量が凄いからこの四人の中でも支配的なボーカル。恐らくはこの頃のKalafinaの時代が最強なのかな。
3人で歌っているのも好きだけど、4人で歌うARIAは音の厚みがすごい😭
4人いるからこその声の重なりや迫力もあるのだろうけど、ARIAはこの4人のこのライブの時が一番良いと思う^ ^
ヒカルの声はほんとに素晴らしい✨
これを超えるARIAはないな
mayaさんのサビは本当にしびれました
I love the way Maya raises her right hand high when she's going for those high notes (especially when Belting), instead of raising her head up.
That's good vocal technique there. The raised hand opens up her ribcage and allows the lungs to give her solid breath support and she avoid tension in the throat
Will always learn lots from you!
@@LegendoftheGalacticHero Oh thank you!
このARIAでMayaの歌声に度肝を抜かれた人間なので、もっとMayaのいるKalafinaの歌も聴いてみたかったな…
4人でsprinter歌ってほしかった
She was at least on par with Hikaru.
They did sing. In this show, they also sang sprinter and oblivious, but it wa never released.
mayaの声質ってhikaruに似てるとこあるのに、低音もしっかり出せてるのがすごい！
Maya is a slightly more versatile singer it seems.
この頃が1番上手いというか響くな
今が悪いという訳では決してないけど、この頃が一番いい
👍
まだ最近ファンになったばっかだけどMayaがいた方が個人的にすごく好き。
カラフィナのライブは完成度常に高いけど、このライブ完成度高すぎる！音源以上じゃないすか！！？
これ聞いちゃうと他のアーティストのライブが聴けない笑
神曲過ぎる... 何回聴いてるかわからない
このＬｉｖｅの「ＡＲＩＡ」が一番好きです。😋😋
Me too. This is the original with fuller live vocals.
I always get chills hearing Maya's part. She had already left the group by the time I knew about this group, so I only knew her in this song. She really has a powerful voice. Almost similar to Keiko's.
The tone sounded just like Hikaru at the belting duet but has a richer low end than Hikaru's.
Yo siendo su voz muy similar a la de Hikaru, me costó bastante identificarla. Pero que buena voz
i remember there was a video of her singing sprinter at karaoke but i can’t find it anymore:(
she's also part of the recording for sprinter, but as far as live performances go then yea this is prob the closest you'll get
HIKARUさんの声は歌唱力だけでなく、＋アルファの癒やしがある。心地がよい。
Best Kalafina's song ever :3
One of my favorites (and I like a lot of songs from them!)! I've listened to this a couple of times already on the same day lol
やっぱこの頃のHikaruさんの声素晴らしいな。
Kalafina時代晩年はかなり苦しそうで伸びも悪くなっていたし。
声というのは難しいな。
この頃のひかるちゃん最高ですよね。
声の出し方とかライブやり過ぎとか色々あったと思いますが…特に後半は見てて辛かったです
もともとHikaruさんの歌い方が喉を酷使するような感じだったのと、「Destination unknown」のような迫力を求める曲にHikaruさんがメインボーカルに採用される事が多かったので、声帯の負担が激しいものになっていたからだと思います。
80年台のスーパーアイドルの松田聖子さんもやはり同じような感じで、デビュー時の歌い方が途中でできなくなり、いわゆる「キャンディーボイス」の歌い方に変えていったのと被るような気がします。
でも最後のLIVEの「oblivious」は声楽的な歌い方に切り替えて、綺麗な声を出せるようになれて良かったと思います。
個人的にはMagiaあたりで声破壊されたと思っている
@@MorioDaichi You're right about Hikaru depending on the throat a bit for belting power. Not singing from below. Just watch the posture in this song during the belting phases. Compare how Hikaru and Maya stood when belting the chorus passage.
この編成でSprinterできなくなったのは悲劇だろってくらいこのARIA良い
kuma segawa
まさに伝説のARIA
The original
この頃のヒカル。。声量ハンパないな。。。
素晴らしいコーラスだと思います。
アニメに疎いのですが、曲に惚れ込んでしまいました。
This song is hauntingly beautiful..
I became a fan of Kalafina just recently and the first time I heard this song was during their 10th anniversary concert. I thought it was great but this, with Maya, holy shirt it was mind-blowing!!! I couldn't stop my goosebumps!!!
Next level right here. Their voices were all still young in this performance and Maya helped to complete the live harmonies much more fully. There was much less reliance on the recorded background vocals. There were a bunch of layered vocals and dual harmonies that she performed, providing a medium low range that freed Keiko to rest at times, and her belted section showed her power with a comparable tone to Hikaru's.
Maya is like hibrid of Hikaru and Keiko
@@greenady Exactly. With a little bit of Wakana in terms of head voice. She also replaced high part for Wakana at a point in the song!
Maya's voice is so good and yeah this is one of my favorite song of their group❤️😍👌
I miss Hikaru and Wakana's 2008-2010 voice. Keiko was consistent and did better in her control as the years went by.
Speechless. This has gotten me all kinds of emotional.
maya chan's voice is amazing :D and more with keiko
MAYAがいた頃も充分素敵だけど、今も透明感とか落ち着きのあるかんじがあって好きだな(❁´ω`❁)
I love their harmonizations
This is some extraordinary stuff done by kalafina.
mayaうまいじゃん！
I really love how consistent keiko sing her alto part what a great singer!
Huh, it's so crazy, a while back I was searching frantically for the old version of this song with Maya in it, and now it just pops up randomly in my auto queue!
Thanks for the upload!
いつでも見てもmasterpieceです
ここに戻ってきてしまう。私の原点。
Love this version the best
Очень красиво, прекрасные голоса.
I really love this song 💖💖
gosh I miss them guys I so miss them singing again!! >
何回きいてもステキだ❤
Powerful. No more words, just Powerful
もしMayaが最後までいたらサビは全部彼女が担当してたかもね。
Hikaruが声変わりしてからのARIAは喉壊しそうでヒヤヒヤしてたし…
Very possible.
Best Aria live
Me encanta Kalafina espero con ansias su visita a Mexico en Febrero ☺
Aaagh que envidia :3 Jamás vendrán a Puerto Rico T.T PORQUÉ NO SOY MEXICANA?!?! Primero VAMPS y ahora Kalafina (VAMPS es una banda japonesa)
2020 and I am here ❤️❤️
Ikr
2020 and I've been stanning this group for a year 🙂
(I miss them so much😭)
2021 :(
2021 :(
2021 here
아리아가 최고다 진짜👍👍👍
This is still the best aria
i was never into kalafina until after they disbanded, and i cant seem to find many performances with maya. as much as i love the three of them, there's just something about her belting voice that is just so magical (but like the same goes to all of them lmao)
We are in the same boat! I totally agree with you.
I also discovered Kalafina post-disbanding, through a RUclips recommendation to their 10th Anniversary Budokan llve, and the mystical "Ring Your Bell" intro caught me and bound me (they sounded like angels) even though I could never imagine watching a 2-hour-plus RUclips video. I watched it all through!
I have become partially obsessed with hearing Maya sing live from this period. Her tone and obviously punching below her maximum high pitch and power (it seemed oddly easy for her) belting the same chorus part as Hikaru, made me excited to hear more of her.
What I even noticed is that Keiko amplified her volume for her harmony low notes when singing with Maya, to match the slightly higher power of Maya's belt compared to my favourite girl, Hikaru.
I am interested in Maya's head voice, her highest pitch, her low notes, dynamics. I wish we had a documentary on just her.
U can see maya in other video singing Kizuato. She only doing kajiurago harmony
it's a shame that there doesn't seem to be a live video available of her singing sprinter, a song in which she has lines
If someone would post the Sprinter LIVE of this performance we would see Maya with her full potential, but anyway Maya's career is short to be honest due to personal reason for letting her finish college first but sadly she didn't came back after making that decision ):
@@catsinni I heard that she joined a dance group or something. It's similar to Kawashima Yuuka (founding member of Perfume) who left the group for school and then tried multiple times to come back into entertainment with series of relative failures, while the group went on to become one of the biggest in Japan
.
これは良い素晴らしい厚みがあって圧倒される
衣装が斬新素敵で見てしまう。
Hikaru back then was an absolute unit of a singer.
Hikaru's voice is brilliant！！
She's my favorite.
Impossible for me to watch this legendary masterpiece without tears in my eyes...
Hikaru's voice is just OMG ❤
Though I prefer Wakana's current voice, this is by far the best live version to ARIA 🥹
Kalafina 너무좋아요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 제가 앨범같은거 안사는데 꼭살거에요
they're so pretty
2020 this song always remeber me in diana and claud from who made me a princesse
Watched this again and I have few wishes:
1. We could watch a high-res and full-width version of this live performance.
2. We could watch a rehearsal video for this performance with all four singers.
3. More vocal teacher/coach reaction channels listened and reacted to this.
4. Maya was active on social media so we could see her activities in music/dance/etc.
@c h Oh thanks.
@c h She made such an impact in such a little time, especially in this "Aria" live.
MAYAは外すべきでなかった
もっと上のレベルのグループになれたのに・・・
I also feel like Maya was removed for some reason. I still don't fully buy the "schooling" excuse.
最初とかの梶浦語が好き。
Is it me or is it really better than recoded ver
Most of their lives are better than their recorded versions, you're not wrong
It's significantly better
Which recorded version exactly?
The very original one of the movie or the Aria Live from the 5th Anniversary disc?
The Aria Live of the anniversary disc is awesome too. Everyone should listen to that version. It sounds way different than this one and the original.
Keiko and Maya would be unstoppable. 💖
Exactly! They were powerful together.
It's so easy to confuse Maya and Hikaru sometimes (especially when they're belting). All this time, I thought 4:05 was sung by Hikaru... Then I took a glance at the screen lol.
Josheb Dayrit
omg I thought its Hikaru too omg Maya so great ;-;
Me too... I also thought it was Hikaru... anyway, they both are powerful!
Same! It’s just Maya’s doesn’t have the “metallic” element Hikaru’s voice has - it’s softer. I’d say her voice is like a mixture of Wakana’s and Hikaru’s.
They have similar tomes. I think she has just a teeny bit more power than Hikaru and a slightly richer low range, though Hikaru is my favorite. I saw this because she covered some mid-low notes (that gave Keiko rest at some points) and she holds her mike further away from her mouth almost all through the performance.
That might be because Hikaru took that part after Maya left?
2022 and I still here for this master piece
私もです😊
Honestly Maya has such a nice range like she can be on par with Hikaru and Keiko, I don't know why she left 8((
If I remember, she left for school. I think her voice is gorgeous and powerful too.
I hope she comes back ;-; but she probably won't and it makes me sad ;-;
It's not very clear if she left for school, yes, but it is confirmed that Maya's decision was at the behest of her father. He wanted his daughter to have a different career. In Japan, parents, especially fathers, have a lot of say in their children's lives. It's highly unlikely that Maya will ever perform with Kalafina again.
I dont know about her father, but its confirmed that she has return to her hometown, has finished her school and now she's in some dancing group, married and with a child too.
maya gave a reason in twitter,she said that because she
was lack of strength。But i think it's a euphemism and the truth is she was eliminated by corporation。
Watching this live always makes me feel so sad that Maya left. She probably has the most powerful voice in the group.
You could tell she wasn't outputting at 100% yet, whether in terms of power or range.
MAYAがいる。初期のkalafina😊
아니 미쳤나 노래 진짜 좋네
2021-02-24 i love you its teme.
Kalafina my heart is for you
Jesus, the nostalgia
I wish Hikaru's voice could have a chance to heal. I feel like there is a problem now. Maybe nodes? That would be so sad :( I love Hikaru and want the best for her just as much as the other members.
I don't think Hikaru's voice will come back. But it's really not a problem, I already get used to it. Her vocal cord is changing while she is getting older, therefore she has to change her way to sing. And so does Wakana. Besides, Kalafina has TOO MUCH work for lives, if Hikaru is still using her previous way to sing, it will hurt more.
What exactly happened to her voice? I mean, I know she sounds quite different now, if not worse. Did she hurt her throat or something? Is it because of the extensive live shows, so much that it exhausted her
voice, or anything?
I think it's a combination of neverending live shows and work (especially from 2014-on as they become more popular) and Hikaru's vocal cords changing as she gets older, as the person below said. In addition, Hikaru has frequently been required to strain her voice in songs by singing to the top of her range (like in this song) or, more frequently, by lowering it just barely above breakage (a la Magia)... It may just be that her voice isn't meant to do that all the time, even if it sounds really cool. She also has said that it takes a lot for her to take care of her voice, she takes a lot of steps to protect it.
honestly I think Hikaru's voice sounds fine despite changes. It's Wakana's loss of breath and difficulty in singing that worries me recently. I always hear her gasping/hiccup sound both in live & recorded.
I don’t think that there’s nearly as much to worry about with Hikaru, or Wakana, at this point in comparison to when you all posted this. Vocally Hikaru has changed pretty drastically - my personally most audible times hearing this would include sitting down on the 9+ONE and 10th Anni concert videos and focusing only on drastic requirements, like her falsettos in the 9+1 Oblivious and the 10th Anni’s Lirica.
However, I don’t think anyone yet knows if Hikaru got what’s often labeled “the singer’s surgery” as Wakana has. (I will say the surgery helped her a nice amount but oh my God she STILL CANNOT BREATHE. It’s just too much of a habit at this point although it’s noticeably better in comparison to, say, Red Moon era.)
4人でのARIAを聴いちゃうと3人のは残念過ぎる😖⤵️mayaの声が素敵過ぎて他の曲も4人で聴きたかったな(>_
Mayaの声って帯域が広いし奥深い
もっと表舞台に出てきても良いと思う
ただこの動画を見てて思ったけれど
ビジュアル的になんかMayaにだけ悪意を感じる
@@Houri_Tatsunari その通りですね(>_
@@Houri_Tatsunari
この頃には脱退が決まってたから、なるべく映さなかったのでは？
権利関係とか色々あるだろうし。
I'm with you. There would have been more variety and energy in their voices, and maybe Hikaru and Wakana wouldn't have had to strain their voices so much since the load would have been shared.
when I heard the first 13 seconds, I was reminded of Deliora from FT. The soundtrack used was the same with the melody😊
OMG they really do have similarities OMG
2021 April here ♥️😍
2021 ❤😁
my fav part is 4:03 Maya!!!
Her voice was so powerful and more just a bit more resonant than Hikaru's. The way she holds her microphone away from her face shows that she had enough vocal power to project to the mike! She was really missed as a force in Kalafina.
2021✨
OK, just listened to this again and Maya was awesome:
1. Her voice is powerful, loud, rich and piercing.
2. She can obviously out-dance everyone else.
Does anyone know her social media - Twitter, etc.? Does she have a website?
Nope she doesn't has any
Only Instagram
@@Bessywap Do you know her Instagram handle?
She has twitter but currently her acc is being locked tho
@@rena8621 That's a little sad. I hope she's doing well and has an outlet for her creative talent, even if it's only private.
진짜 정말 ㅈㄴ 잘부른다
ㄹㅇ
Hikaru 3> 3> such an angelic voice
And it’s better than the recorded
2021 hehehhe
Majestic
ヒカル美しい
😊
Luego de verlo varias veces me fijé en lo similar que es el Belting de Maya al de Hikaru, pero en su voz más central hay un punto intermedio entre Hikaru y Keiko demasiado increíble. Le da una llenura preciosa a la canción.
Yes! Maya is sorely missed. I can imagine how much fulness she could have given to other songs we know, since she covered high, middle/lead, and low parts in this song. A really versatile singer. And her mix belt was balanced and powerful (she also had stronger head voice than Hikaru and could match Wakana to my ears).
結論︰Kalafinaは最高である
前の方が～って言ってる人もいるけど、私は今のKalafinaが大好きだし、凄く努力してる3人だからこそ今の梶浦さんの曲を歌えてる訳で...
嫌なら過去にすがればいい
努力してるから許されるとか
どんな甘ちゃんやねんｗ
結果が全てだろ
Mayaが居てるからこその圧巻のコーラスなのに
そうでなくなったら努力してるから云々
馬鹿なの？
どちらにしても解散してしまった今となって願うのは、3人でも4人でも歌うところが見たいということです😢
2019
カメラワークに悪意がある😢
Wow it's too bad Kalafina wasn't able to retain this kind of vocal power, otherwise I would have been a much bigger fan
04:05
Они лучшие
Were they a group of 4 before? Had no idea!
Hikaruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
4:04
自分用
I can't believe Hikaru used to have this kind of vocal power. How did it change??
Good question. Overuse of her voice in too many live singing arrangements and being written a lot of music in her higher range. Probably not having a consistent vocal coach to help keep her voice healthy through the rigors of a decade. Also age changed her voice...
@@TheSeeking2know That's so sad!
@@TRal55 If we feel like this, I imagine how she feels knowing in her memory and mind that she can "hit" some notes but her body/voice won't do what she wants it to. And she experienced the deterioration/change firsthand.
@@TheSeeking2know Definitely. It's upsetting to know that that can even happen. I never knew someone's vocal power could change like that. I definitely feel for her.
@@TRal55 👍🏾
My personal best vocal rank:
1. Maya
2. Hikaru
3. Keiko
4. Wakana
For this song, I agree with the order. 👍🏾👍🏾
I'm not a huge fan of this song, but this probably one of their best live performances.
0:34 Plus, I dont really like this member's voice :/ Out of the these 3 girls, she's third for me.
+Delian Jay yup. unlike Wakana and Keiko, she has an average Japanese typical voice. Wakana and Keiko are taking their level out of Japanese typical singer. If you know what I mean.
+Monica Su Kajiura would disagree with you about Hikaru having an average Japanese voice.
+Deepika Govind I know. she must be had her reason for choosing Hikaru. but then again, this is my opinion.
+Monica Su I think Kajiura said that she chose Hikaru because of her voice sounding similar to a reed or wind instrument
Mayaさんビジュアルだけが残念なのは自分が一番分かってたんやろうね。
Hikaruはこの時代の伸びやかな歌い方が一番好き。今はうまく歌おうとしすぎて力んでるように感じてならない。
極論でいえば別にバックコーラスみたいに
横に控える形でも良かったと思うんですよねぇ
それでも存在感は示せたと思うんですけどねぇ・・・
私はMayaさんは可愛らしいと思って聞いてましたよ〜。
声が良いのは言うまでもナシ、でしたねぇ(全員良かったですが)。
これをいつかKAORIさんYurikoKaedaさん、そしてKEIKOさん、Joelleさん、HIKARUさんとの5人でカバーするかも(又はしたのかも)しれないんですよね、YukiKajiuraLiveで💦
03:16～のMayaとHikaru良いわ～(*´∀`)♪。
Mayaの声上手く聞き分けられないや😭