WATER propagation works FASTER than SOIL propagation for SUCCULENTS (an EXPERIMENT!)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 окт 2024
- EXPERIMENT on SOIL PROPAGATION vs. WATER PROPAGATION OF SUCCULENTS!
***
Hi guys!
It's been a while!
I have here an experiment of which succulent propagation technique will work faster and which way is easier. I have found out a lot with my experiment and it has been amazing! I have grown succulent babies through water and soil propagation and I have compared the two techniques.
I have been wondering about which one is easier and faster all this time and finally the answer has been handed!!! Watch the video for the answer.
TELL ME YOUR THOUGHTS IN THE COMMENT SECTION AND LET US INTERACT.
Happy planting and happy propagating!!!
Video Links:
Soil Mix Experiment: • How to Prepare SOIL MI...
Air Drying Succulents: • How to CLEAN and AIR D...
Propagation Techniques: • WATER propagation work...
Water Therapy for Succulents: • How to do WATER THERAP...
Succulents for Beginners: • SUCCULENTS for BEGINNE...
Repotting Succulents: • How to REPOT Cactus an...
🌟
email: aldouskenneth@gmail.com
instagram: kennoptionals
🌟
If you are interested in more of this video, join me!!! Thank you!
![CHILE vs. BRASIL [1-2] | RESUMEN | ELIMINATORIAS SUDAMERICANAS | FECHA 9](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5ObJt_71AYc/mqdefault.jpg)
Hey saw a lot of comments about the music being to loud and tho that is true I thought you might like to hear I really like your editing and appreciate the video :) working on my first propagation myself no success thus far but I’ll keep going!
Thank you so much, Mimi! Happy I found a good heart in the comment! Have a happy life ahead! Happy Planting! 🌱
@@aldouskenneth other people dont have bad heart brother , they also want you to improve , they are helping you by pointing out your mistakes
@@talhaayub4456 Got it Talha!!! Thank you so much for the concern 🥰
@@aldouskenneth you are much welcome brother ❤
Me too 💖👍👍😎
It's so kind of you to reply to practically all the questions asked! There's just a handful of you who do this. More power!
Thank you Cecile. I have noticed that the questions are also important, and to help, I responded on almost all of them. 👌
I tried this - put a couple of my succulent leaves in mud and let it dry and then transferred some of them to a plastic water bottle as you showed. The ones in the water bottle grew roots within couple of days. I noticed only one that I left on the mid had a tiny root after almost a week and the other one still nothing. I transferred them both to the plastic bottle with the rest.
The interesting thing is, the leaves I picked from the parent plant are not even healthy looking but each one of them did well in the water propogation. Amazing !!!
I am super excited that they are all growing roots now. Thank you so much.
The cool thing is when you go to Lowe’s to take the fallen leafs to propagate for free. There are some leafs that are already propagated
I just did this today! At Walmart! Felt like a rescue
I went to Home Depot yesterday and found a bunch of fallen leaves. Some already had roots on them which was an awesome feeling.
I do it all the time ..😆 absolutely 💯 ❤ 👌
Very true!!! Hahaha!
I do this from Lowe’s but how can I propagate it when it’s already like that
Thank you for your video. I've heard of water propagation, but I thought the leaves would rot in the water! But you say to suspend them just above the water, so not touching the water, actually. Wow now it all makes sense! I've learned a super good lesson today! Thank you!
Correct. Hope I helped! 😊
I don’t know which is easier-changing the water everyday or remembering to mist the soil propagations every 3 days....Thanks for doing the comparison. I had forgotten that water propagation was an option. Good video! Lots of great information. 😀
Hey Gigi!!! Thanks for the commendation 🔆
@@aldouskenneth
Why does this work to leave it in water? But if I water too much it dies?
@@xmo552 right? Lol.. I think when he's doing the water method, it's not actually in the water, but the moisture and humidity near the bottom of the leaf is the equivalent of being on top of moist soil, if it were actually in the water it would rot just like too much moisture in your soil will rot it
@@YourMajesty100 thats it bro, been doing this for a bit, and found that uou just let the roots grow into the water
Plants aside, your skin is ✨glowing✨
HAHAHAHA THANK YOU JANLEH! 😅😄✌
I think it would be better to show 2 time lapses first at 2 weeks and the second one at 6 weeks, maybe the soil one grow better once the root go deeper on soil 😜 by the way, great video 😄
I will try! Thank you!
salamat kuya! this helped so so much! I forgot to let the leaves sit out for a few days, thats probably why theyre taking longer than usual.
Thanks Janiya. Yes, that's a critical part of doing this. Thanks!!! Happy Planting. 🍃
Thank you for the info! Clear and to the point without any fancy jargon, perfect for the plant beginner. Music was cute but like others have said - hard to hear you over it. Overall still a 10/10
These are nice words! Thank you!
Thanks for sharing
I agree , the music to loud, which makes it difficult to hear you.
Thanks for taking the time to do this and sharing the results.
Thanks Andrea!
My water props rooted faster than my soil props, but the roots on both look equally great.
Great, Yolanda. I learned as I went through that as long aa you propagate, it means a lot! Happy to hear from a lot of you!!!
I couldn’t hear in the video, do the leaves have to touch the water or be above?
@@gracemoss9477 I don’t know if it’s too late but in case anyone else is wondering the leaves should be just above the water but not touching!
I've had two succulent plants living on a raft on my aquarium, with the roots hanging down in the aquarium water, for the past month. So far, both plants are doing very well.
Perfect!!!! Hope it still grows.
Thanks for sharing this. Will surely try this system soon bcz everytime i buy a succulent plant it doesn't live long.
Keep safe!
Thank you! I hope you can propagate successfully! Happy Planting!!!
Just quit loving it so much and it will live sooo long !!! The less attention you give it the more it’ll try to please you . We tend to love our plants to death , go easy on watering ..
Thank you so much for your time in creating this informative and creative way! Love the graphics. I have hear another way to explain why we DO NOT let the ends touch the water.
Basically it will work harder to get to the water to survive, creating roots. Like a baby, when learning to walk you can’t hold its hand always you must allow the toddler to come TO you in order for it to be strong 💪. Also, would you be willing to add your own subtitles? The time just before ‘experiment time’ is hard to understand.
Thank you so much for the comment, and for the additional information! I would consider adding subtitles on my next video especially when the volume might be too low. Thank you for watching the video! 😊🍃
The ACTUAL reason you don't let the end touch the water is because it will ROT... the humidity in the jar is what makes it grow... But if left in there too long it would still rot.
good tip
I am going to try this technique, sounds easy, thank you for sharing
Go Mafu and share the good news! Haha! Don't ever be afraid of experimenting! Happy Planting!
kumusta
did it work?
did it work??
I tried before with the soil propagation but I failed
Thanks to Allah I found cool video like this
by the way I like the music it"s really relaxing
all respect كل الاحترام
Thanks you so much!
You're welcome man
I rewatched it today pretty cool video@@aldouskenneth
Interesting! I just started on the fun of propagation. But seems like the leaves / cuttings are rotting when using water propagation... will try more! Thank you :)
Thank you so much!!!
Try to make sure the leaves do not touch the water and that the water is changed if it’s milky or dirty
i have also heard that you should let the cutting/leaf callous over as sometimes if there is no callous and the cutting is touching the water, it will just rot. I have been through that many times lol
What a cute tiny water container for the 1 leaf. I need!
Haha just look anywhere a perfume cap can work
It looked like a cannister for camera films lol
I found this so helpful thank u for comparing the 2 methods!
Thank you so much. I hope you appreciate the other videos!
Thanks for this thorough explanation.. I’m trying now the water propagation 😊
I truly enjoy warching the way you propagate into the water , another I learned from you and thank you .
Thank you Maya! Wishing you the best in life. Have a great day!
Thanks , great info, I had to keep changing the volume because of the music. No music would be nice.👍🏻
ฉันกำลังปลูกต้นแบบนี้อยู่เลย ฉันสนใจมากๆ ไม่ทรสบจะชำและปลูกอย่างไรให้ถูกวิธี 🙏🌵🪴 ขอบคุณคะ
Very nice video! But please make sure next time the music is not 10x louder than the speech. I had too keep adjusting the volume and hurting my ears :p
Thank you!!! Hated the insane music and the volume was almost harrasment!😬
Take your earbuds out sometimes
Thank you for sharing the comparison! I'll try water
No worries. Serena!
This video is so clear! Thanks so much! If you have other videos coming up, could you please lower the music just a bit? It overlaps with your voice and it’s hard to hear you sometimes 😔 anyway, thanks for the video, I’ve been trying to grow succulents for my studio 😊
Thanks Daniela 😊
Thanks so much for sharing. I didn’t know the leaf isn’t supposed to touch the water.
Yep. It should not :)
I learned so much! I'm starting my own plantita journey lol
I never have luck with the soil. Going to try the water way! Thanks for the info!!
You are welcome. Happy to hear this.
Thanks for the great info! I have tried several times to Soil propagate my succulents; however, no luck. I’m not sure what I’m doing wrong! Glad to know these can be water propagated! I’m going to give this a try.
Good luck! 🌞
Did it work
did it work??
Place the clean cut leaves on a napkin on your window sill. Do not water or spray. Within a week you will begin to see small tiny roots begin to form. You may place them on soil to begin flowering. Do no Do this in direct sunlight.
@@AnnaBella510 does this work?
Thanks for showing me the right way to do this
Thank you Cynthia!!!
I bought a beautiful plant from the store about a week ago and it’s the only one out of all my plants to die :( it’s so beautiful. It’s about 99% dead at this point so I was trying to save the live leaves that I accidentally pulled off, but comparing what I have to what you have, I think they may be too far gone to save. I wasn’t ready to be a plant mom yet like I thought 😔
Hey blazereh. No one was born ready to be a plant parent. Me, too, I've killed my first succulent - and that pushed me to buy more and research about it more. So, that's why I am making videos to help every aspiring plant parent out there to know more. So I hope you learn something in our videos. You can also watch our videos regarding soil mix, cleaning succulents and air drying succulent if you want, to help you out. Remember that being a plant parent needs patience and willingness - no GREEN thumb needed! So, I recommend you to buy another one, search for care tips and never give up!!! HAPPY PLANTING! God bless!
Thanks so much for the video! I’m gonna try water 💦
After 2 weeks should we plant in soil mix?!
How was it Jessica? 😊
Great Video! And a question, when i do the water propagation do I just have to put it in soil after 2 weeks so it can grow Into a full grown succulent?
Hi Kenan. I wait for the roots to be long enough so that it can stabiloze in soil. If it does not grow roots and only leaves, I leave the leaf together with the parent leaf in the soil. Have the best luck! 🔆
Well Young Man. What You think is what I think too. Well done Young & Hansom. Good Luck in Your Guarding.
Thanks Nabil! Appreciate it!
Im doing propagation too.. do we e
Really have to change the water frequently?
Yep if you think na may nagbubuild ng molds :)
Love it. I do the same water propagation. Thanks for sharing.
Thank you so much. Good luck! 🔆
When this is done, how deep do you place it in the soil? - Cover the whole thing, or let the small new baby stick up?
Just leave it at top of the soil and the roots will crawl itself.
That’s really interesting, I’m going to try propagation for the first time
Thank you for helping us with my/our beautiful succulents! And showing how to do propagation, step by step techniques 👍🏼. 👈🏼. Green Thumb 😁beauties too Can’t wait to start! 👏🏼👏🏼 🤗🌱🤗. Thanks again. Subscribed!!
Stay safe. Stay kind!
These were sweet words Rhonda. Thank you so much 💚
Tamang-tama! May gan'tong halaman kapitbahay namin! Ita-try kong bumunot doon nang hindi nila nalalaman kundi paktay ako NYAHAHAHAHA
HAHAHAHA Grabe yun! Pwede naman. Ipaalam mo nalang 😂 Mura lang din yan sa Garden Center. 25 pesos isang buong halaman na makulay, meron ka na :)
Thank youuu!!! 🎉 You said it doesn’t touch the water thank you!
Aldous Kenneth Ligutan. wow your a real horticulturist water propagation works faster than soil propagation for succulents
THANK YOU!
Thanks dude! This tutorial really helps me out!
Sure! Happy Planting!!!
I’ve had way more success with water!!! Then transferring to soil after roots are formed! Love the video! Subscribing!
Thank you thank you Nicholas. 😊😊😊
I finally propagated my first leaf thru soil but im open to giving the water method a try I have a beautiful blue succulent and the leaves just don't do well in soil with misting.
Let's do it!!!
Brilliant! Thanks, Aldous! Also, excellent zoom and much appreciation for the still shot of the zoom! Short, sweet tutorial! And don't worry about the music. "Perfect", manufactured VLOG content just looks fake. I want to see what REAL explorers are REALLY doing and REAL explorers who are REALLY "doing" REAL stuff don't have the time or the wherewithal to worry about such things. THEY'RE TOO BUSY EXPLORING!! Keep it real! Subscribed!
Kudos for doing this experiment for those na gusto magpropagate like me. I'd try the water propagation technique, thank you
I hope you'll grow your succulents healthy! Happy Planting!
Will new leaves grow from where we picked leaves from the bottom?
It may 😊
No I don’t think so
Not in all, only in certain kind of succulents
It may grow a shoot depending on the plant type
Hello friend thanks for sharing your great information on propagation for succulents new subscribers watching from California
My succulent is dying so thank you!! ✨☺️🌿🌸
Always welcome. Hope they'll be alive
@Mariana Sottile No they're just saying that since their succulent is dying, this video is helpful for them haha ❤️✨
Hi your propgation method is amazing I've tried the water method it took 3months to propagate will definitely try it again soon
One other thing can you tell me what do I add to the potting for the soil propagation can must i add any compost to the potting mix
Hi. I have another vlog for the soil mix. Another experiment video for that one. Hope it helps. But I prefer 80-90% inorganic and 10-20% organic. 😊
how many hours/days do I have to air dry? thank you.
Overnight po, okay na as long as tuyo na yung end ng leaf 😊
Спасибо вам за видео , попробую сделать это у себя 😊
So the leaves DONT touch the water, correct?
Yuuup! Correct
It’s like being trapped in my Wii menu screen watching this video
Hahaha! Was that a great experience?
Good video, i'd never though of water propagation. Just a suggestion, please turn the music down. I turn the volume up so i can hear you then my ears get blasted because its too loud. Best wishes.
Sure, Marie. Will do that. Thank you! 😊
OMG You really need to turn down the volume of the music. Content was informative.
ขำวิธีนี้ต้องีดน้ำทุกวันไหมคะ ฉันทำแล้วรากไม้งอกเลยคะ
Cheers for more plants waiting ahead!!!
I love propagating too!
So much support! Thank you, Hapoy greens!!!
This is a great video! How long do I do water propagation until I place them in the soil?
Until the roots are long enough to stabilize in small pot. 🌞
Thank you!! you are so sweet and this video helped me so much! I've also been experimenting both methods and I also find water prop my preferred way! cheers my friend
💕🍁
Cheers Emily. Thank you so much!
After I bought my first succulent, I just can't stop buying again lol.
Hahaha it happens 🙇♂️
Same.. I bout 14.. and now I'm scared and over whelmed !😅
Oh wow... I thought you had to put the end of the succulent in the water, much like you would a pothos or philodendron.
Great Ibiza 😊 Happy Planting!
I use baby food jars to root mine I asked my mom friends to save the for me 😊 Thank for the video..
Welcome, Jennifer 😊
I once tried one of the succulents multiply with a plastic bottle and water but it wilted ...
Do not stop trying!!! 😊
The very top of my sedum stonecrop plant has a leaf that is turning brown. I tried some propogations but none survived yet. Can you suggest me what should I do now?
It’s great, it’s cool 👍👍💗💗
Thank you so much! 😊
I have 2 spiraling succulents, stonecrop raym. Hamet. They have pointed green leaves. I only have moisture retention soil. Is this bad? I have a bag of volcanic rock though.
Will it not be over watered?????
It won't. That's why you call it water propagation. It gets the nutrients from water alone. Mushy leaves are natural but that leaf would be useless after getting the babies, after all. :) So go, do not worry about over watering!
Thank you
Do I have to dry the leaves before water propagation?
Should the leaf not touch water while putting it in any container?
You do not need to dry the leaves before water propagation. But it should NOT touch the water while putting it on the container. Hope you'll have q successful one!
I see lots of comments on your music ... it is too loud ... your Voice is soft , you need to correct this ... I love your information .... you do an excellent job ....
Thanks dave. I appreciate this. Thank you! 🇵🇭
First time viewer ..... love your work mate ..... subscribed
Thank you Frank!!! 😍
Thank you for this! We are trying water propagation right now! This experiment was very helpful!
Thank you Meredith!!!
What happens when the roots come out?Do I just let it be? Or do I have to put them in soil?
Yeps! Just make sure that the cuts or wounds, if any, are calloused. 😊
You can do either! Do your own experiment and let us know which way works best for you :)
@@aldouskenneth Hi po. After po ba macut yung leaves, pwede na po ba sya i-propogate sa water? Or need pa po bang intayin ng mga ilang days bago po sya i-propogate?
GRACIAS MAGNIFICA IDEA
Thanks Ruth!!!
If plants could talk, we’d hear a faint “OUCH” as you tore off her Leaf. 🍃
I'm so sorry, plants 🥺
I have never thought of this! Thank you!
Welcome!!!
hey bro, great video but the music is way to loud. i normally look past it but yours is insane. otherwise the video was amazing
Thanks for the concern Sebastian. I'll improve this one 😊👍
Just Wondering If The Leaves You Pull Off Succulent Will Leaves Grow Back From That Spot Agian?
It will... :)
Naka tip or naka dikit po ba yung dulo ng dahon sa tubig or hindi?
Hi Brian! It should not touch the water po. 😊
Thanks for sharing, how many times a week does the water need to changed?
I usually do change every other day. However, if it is not affected by molds, you may not change it. 🌞
this video is so cute, thanks!
Thank you!!!
i got my first succulent about a week ago. its doing pretty ok and i got some leaves off of it and im trying to see what works for me with propogation
Great!!!
Perfect
Thank youuu
I am doing so well with a bit of rooting hormone on the Succulent after letting it dry for a few days. My roots are huge I have it in a glass jar with plastic wrap and they have amazing pups. What is the best way to transplant these into soil and can succulents that are propagated in water work in a terrarium setting ?
Airdry it. Then transfer it. Do not transfer it while it is wet, it might be damaged.
Video Links:
Soil Mix Experiment: ruclips.net/video/H1hmi2nuozE/видео.html
Air Drying Succulents: ruclips.net/video/Lunhj4iqzRc/видео.html
Water and Soil Propagation Techniques: ruclips.net/video/mKHJnxxFtT0/видео.html
Water Therapy for Succulents: ruclips.net/video/nqXokU1sUIM/видео.html
Succulents for Beginners: ruclips.net/video/khp159zAYls/видео.html
Repotting Succulents: ruclips.net/video/okWJy4ZeDVU/видео.html
Nahatid ko na po gift ko
@@bellafadz ano po?
dinidiligan ba sya pag sa soil propagation?
Can you make a video of how to propagation of hawarthia limifolia frm seeds ?
I would try. Thank you! 😊
How long do you wait for roots in soil.? How long should The water roots be before you plant in soil.
I subbed because of your cute funny animations keep it up!
Haha! Thank you so much 🌵😊
Awesome video and
Thank you!!!
I accidentally watched this vlog, may I know what's the title of the song you've used in 2:18?
I also do not know :( But I think I saw it when I searched background vlogs for coffee shops non copyright.
I couldn't tell if you said the leaf should or should not touch the water. Can someone tell me? Thanks.
Hi Lisa. Thank you for letting me clarify! 😊But the leaves should NOT touch the water. Thank you!
Thank you! Very helpful!
You're welcome Linnyluvzya 🍃😊
I really appreciate the video and all of your knowledge. Thank you for that.
Next time try to watch the volume on your music and the ding noises. I had to turn my volume to the max to hear you speaking (which is most important) then the music or sings chime in & blow out my ears/speakers.
Appreciate the feedback Robin! Have a good day!
Very informative! 😊
Tulog ka na nga 😂😂😂😂
Tebrikler çok güzel bir anlatım olmuş her ne kadar dilini anlamasamda anlatmak istediğini anlamak güzel.....
Why suddenly my succulent plants leafe falling
Hi Uma. That's normal as long as they are from the bottom part. Do not be frustrated. They can be normal 😊
thanks for your concern.
Awesome video ! Do you have to air dry the leaves before water propagation?
Surely! :)
helped me a lot! thank you! 💚
This is my objective. Thank you so much! 😊
It would help to know when to take the plantlet out of the water or soil and plant them in a pot, How big should the new plant be?
It is not in the new plant. The roots should be long enough to be stable in the soil when you move it. But be sure to airdry it :)
Thank you for sharing.
You are welcome 😊
What’s a bright shaded area mean? I use indoor plant lights.
It’s bright but without direct sunlight.