Is the hadith about music being Haram in Islam weak fatwa shopping
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 мар 2021
- #ASSIMALHAKEEM #ASKZAD #zad_tv #just_a_Layman
____________________________________________
Knowledge Base:
assimalhakeem.freshdesk.com
____________________________________________
Need One-to-One live Counseling with Sheikh Assim?:
www.assimalhakeem.net/announc...
_______________________________________________
Do you have a question:
www.assimalhakeem.net/ask-a-q...
_______________________________________________.
Comment where you are watching from - For RUclips algorithm so more people can hear this In Sha Allah🚀
Bangladesh
Indonesia
Afghanistan
Malaysia
India West Bengal
As a revert , this is one of the hardest things to try to give up, especially as an African American revert . Music was such a big part of our lives before Islam and for a lot of us we participated in singing for so long, so trying to find a balance between trying to be a proper Muslim and avoiding music has been my biggest struggle. May Allah make this easy upon us all Ameen
What part of Africa are you from or are you just black?
Music is like one of those things you feel like you can't live without if its part of your daily life, but when you gradually start keeping yourself from indulging it, you reach a point where you don't even feel the need for it. This rule applies to every type of harmful addiction or habit. You just need to always remember that you want to stop doing it.
If you leave it for the sake of Allah, then there is great reward. This life is temporary and if we give importance to afterlife which is Eternal in Heaven, insha Allah it will be easier for us to leave such habits.
May Allah make it easy for you . When you give up something for the sake of Allah then he replaces it with something better.
May Allah make the Haram hard for all of us and the Halal easy for all of us.
"Fatwa Shopping" is a great way to describe *following the desires of Nafs.*
I can feel the benefit after I have given up listening to music. All things that made haram are for our good.
He wasn't fatwa shopping, the young man was just asking a question shaykh.
one of the major things I noticed is that after I perform namaz, that music to me seems to lose its appeal. I no longer feel the "need" to listen to it. Namaz protects us from sin.
Subhannalah. Now im at the point where im past saying "is it *REALLY* haram???" instead Im saying "How can I stop it."
May allah place certainty in our faith.
I hope i stop listening to music... i need to get my life together and not be lazy
Hopefully being a good muslim becomes easy for me one day
Inshallah and ameen❤
Everyone is missing the point!! Music that we are hearing nowdays is Haram, look at the clips, listen to the text, look at the singers.
Everywhere where music is played you see only haram, look at concerts, look at disco's, look at bars, all about sex, drugs and alcohol.
if you watch a music channel you will understand that is forbidden, you are like these people who you are looking at, just be honest to youre self!
People are listing more music then that they are listen QURAN, and the they defend music, of course! because they are spending more time on music, the love it more than the quran! Addicted! why not addicted to reading and listening quran?????
*Sheikh may ALLAH سبحانه وتعالى bless you and your family.....love how you always hit the hammer on the nail by being straight forward with the truth and the Haq*
Thank you for clearing the doubt about music is haram. May Allah SWT guide us through the straight path. Ameen.
Exactly! It's dangerous for us to go online and look for Fatwah that fits with our desire. It is like taking a medicine whatever you want without a prescription from a doctor.
This Labib always calling 😂... May Allah protect him
😂😂
Ameen! Love labib!
So what? Hes a good brother. What's wrong with asking hes learning about the deen.
He wants to learn akhi.
Say this 3 times for 6 hours worth of reward: Subhan-Allahi Wa bihamdihi, ‘adada khalqihi, wa rida-a nafsihi, wa zinata ‘arshihi, wa midada kalimatihi(Glory and praise be to Allah, as many times as the number of His creatures, in accordance with His Good Pleasure, as much as the weight of His Throne, equal to the ink that may be used in recording the words (for His Praise).” (Muslim)
Bukhari is the second best book to get knowledge from after the holy Quran. Allāhu A'lam
Basically, whenever these kind of questions are asked the answer is always "who are you to judge/have thoughts about it" instead of giving real reasons why it may be haram. If you don't know the reason why it might be haram you high chance don't know what that hadid tells you. Even Allah wants us to ask questions and answer of course by it's right way it shows us to follow. But no, acceptence to anything without knowing why is popular in this age of history. Althought I agree with what he says in this video, you need to explain why to unknowers so they won't be distrackted by other false fatwas.
MashaAllah...very good reply sheikh. ..🌷
I agree with the sheikh but we should not assume that our brother Habib is doing fatwa shopping
One simple principle in Islam: it is free from fitna. If it causes fitna, it's haram. That's it.
Preach it Sheikh Assim!! May Allah reward you for standing by the haq! May Allah reward the uploader of these videos!! 👍🏼 👍🏼 👍🏼
A website could also be created by enemies of islam or mushrik.
Dont make aram as halal or halal as haram
“Fatwa Shopping” is the best term for this
Thank you for this video-this is a very important issue!
Great clarification provided by Sh. Asim. May Allah (swt) gives us towfeek to follow the right path.
Wallah I love this sheikh! May Allah reward him in this life and the hereafter
Subhan Allah ×10
Allahu Akbar ×10
Astagfirullah ×10
Alhamdulillah ×10
Subhan Allah wa bi hamdihi Subhana Allah al adheem ×10
LA ilaha ha ilalla ×10
Good deeds for you and me🌷✨
( don't hesitate to SHARE this)
جزاكم الله خيرا
For the clarification
Jazakallah khair Sheikh
The irony is that the people who try to falsify the hadeeth could be the exact people spoken of in the hadeeth - people from the ummah who would try to make musical instruments halaal.
ربنا آتنا في الدنيا حسنة وفي الآخرة حسنة وقنا عذاب النار
Rabbanā ātinā fīd-dunyā ḥasanatan wa-fīl-ākhirati ḥasanatan wa-qinā ʿadhāban-nār
Our Lord, grant us good in this world, and good in the Hereafter, and protect us from the torment of the Fire
JazakAllahu Khairan Katheeran!
May Allah guide us to the straight path. Ameen.
Bismillah thank you may you and those around you be blessed, Amin.
May ALMIGHTY ALLAH SAVE US FROM SINS AMEEN
Thank you
SubhanAllah
Fatwa Shopping is like eating at buffet, you eat what you like only. We need to take the whole package.
I am convinced and for a lifetime.
As Salam alaikum, true Word for me . May Allah protect all Our Umma .
Asalaamualaikum. We are living at a time where time is ticking fast. Music can lead to addiction. With that being said, it can then be very time consuming. And then you got sports broadcasted on television which is another time consumer. And then you got soaps, movies, media, gaming platforms, paying a visit to your friends, time spent at work, etc. My question is, how much time do we have remaining for our Deen?
جزاك الله خيراً
my frnd kaludi listen to song everyday may allah guide him 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Jazakallahu Khairan akhi ☺️
واياكم خير الجزاء
Thank you so much. I love how you simplify. I’m having these discussions with my children and in this world time and age the only way Islam is being challenged is by putting doubts. I am proud to be a Muslim and I’m learning to listen and not challenge . Allah. Said it end of story I don’t have to go find out why he’s my maker the creator, the one and only thank you so much I love listening to you getting to the point love you 100% for the sake of Allah.
I love this Sheikh
I think I know what website Labib was talking about bcuz I typed the whole same question on Google and came across this article. I also kinda relate to this young man bcuz I wasn’t exactly ‘fatwa shopping’ upon weakening belief but an encounter on YT chat confused me. The other person on the opposite claimed that music wasn’t totally haraam, i.e. we can listen to it as long as it does not have absurdities. The website later did not help the matter at all. But the sheikh clearing it up erased those doubts so jkh
Definitely be careful about taking fatwas from randoms on RUclips, it is better to stick to the actual scholars.
Yes sheikh we dont have the knowledge, it's the people with knowledge who confuse us.
Fantastic reply
JAZAKALLAH KHAIR
During end times they will claim haram as halal
Sports are the recommended Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad SM. Prophet Muhammad SM practiced archery and horse racing along with eating healthy.
The end of the time ahadeeth refers to the unlawful type of music, the popular music which has sinful content, activities, lyrics, manners and extravagance.
Not all music is haram! We have proof from the Ahadeeth -people playing percussion instrumental music when it's not associated with sinful activities, content, lyrics and sinful manner and prophet (saw) allowing them.
Hadith on Songs: People of Medina sing, play drums for the Prophet
Anas ibn Malik reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, passed by some of the girls of Medina and they were playing their drums and singing the words, “Muhammad is an excellent neighbor! We are neighbors from the tribe of Najjar!” The Prophet said, “Verily, Allah knows that you are dear to me.”
Source: Sunan Ibn Majah 1899
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
Hadith on playing drums on the wedding
Al-Rubayyi’ bint Mu’awwidh reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, came to me after performing our marriage and he sat on my bed. *Some young girls were playing the drums and singing in lamentation of my father*, who had been killed at the battle of Badr. Then, one of the girls said, “There is a prophet among us who knows what will happen tomorrow.” The Prophet said, “Do not say this, but continue saying what you had said before.”
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 3779
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Bukhari
Hadith on Vows: The Prophet tells a woman to carry out her vows by playing the drum
Abdullah ibn Amr reported: A woman came to the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, and she said, “O Messenger of Allah, I have made a vow I will play the drum for you.” The Prophet said, “Fulfill your vow.” She said, “I have made a vow to sacrifice at a certain place where they slaughtered in the time of ignorance.” The Prophet said, “For an idol?” She said no. The Prophet said, “For an image?” She said no. The Prophet said, “Fulfill your vow.”
Source: Sunan Abī Dāwūd 3312
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
Hadith about entertainment on Eid:
Aisha reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, came to my house when two girls were beside me singing songs of Bu’ath. The Prophet laid down and turned his face to the other side. Then, Abu Bakr came in and spoke to me harshly, saying, “Musical instruments of Satan near the Prophet?” The Prophet turned his face toward him and he said, “Leave them alone.” When Abu Bakr became inattentive, I signaled to the girls and they left. It was the day of Eid and the Abyssinians were playing with shields and spears. Either I asked the Prophet or he asked me whether I would like to watch and I said yes. Then the Prophet made me stand behind him while my cheek was touching his cheek and the Prophet was saying, “Carry on, O tribe of Arfidah.” I became tired and the Prophet asked me, “Are you satisfied?” I said yes, so I left.
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 907, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 892
Grade: Muttafaqun Alayhi (authenticity agreed upon) according to Al-Bukhari and Muslim
@@faysalahmed9157 SubhanAllah at least stop creating fitna for others. For anyone who will believe that comment: please listen to actual scholars and don't take fatwas about the halal and the haram from random people on RUclips.
May Allah be pleased with you sheikh
Allah ﷻ guide us more.
I wish the Sheikh had elaborated on the specific Hadith.
you are right .
One of the things that are helping me on my process to give up music is listening to Nasheeds!
If something is is not clear to you wether it is haram or not just ask yourself 2 question.
Can you imagine muhammad SAW and the sahaba doing it?
Would you do it in front of the prophet SAW?
Jazak Allah Khayr
واياكم خير الجزاء
Stoping music lead me to reflect and relfection lead me to search for the truth. then searching for truth lead me to islam.
Masha Allah
Jazakah allahu khairan
May allah guide us
Assalamu alikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu ya Sheikh! I would really like to know the hadith that speaks about the music 🎵 because just as you have just said people are just trying to drive the Muslims on the wrong way through their marketing website
I told my family music is haram but they don't believe it i showed the hedith to my brother and he rejected it what should i do?.
Great answer
When I was younger I used to love music a lot and the type of music I used to listen to was Video game music or cartoon music but I listened to other stuff and some of them had to do with inappropriate songs about girls or sex. When I heard it was haram it took me a while to actually quit and I was thinking I couldn't live without it but I quit when I was 15 and it was an awesome decision like today its hard to find songs that don't have sex drug or alcohol references so it's not worth it.
what about maher zain and sami yusuf?
@@prod.by.rifqyy if your talking about Nasheed artists I’m not mentioning them i meant mainly songs that the Kuffar make that has haram content. For nasheed artists they don’t have that haram content but it really depends on whether or not they have instruments or only vocals. It is haram to listen to them if they use instruments because its literally music but if it they just have vocals and the lyrics they use doesn’t mock the deen or dont contain haram then it shouldn’t be an issue
I saw am Ex DJ/Musician (Now a muslim) saying that, "Music is Haram because the frequency is capable of controlling human psychology. And Devils taught him how to match the tones so thet the crowd vibes with it"
3:23 DAMN! bro really said "WHO?"
perfect response
That really good reason
I can confirm the thing he said about ocd. Ive been suffering from ocd even before reverting to islam but ever since i learned you can go blind by looking at the sky during salah, i compulsively pray an extra sujood asking allah to not make me blind even if ilooked up by accident or not at all
That is total nonsense. You won't go blind, but your salaah will break
Music was a big part of my life but since I started getting closer to ALLAH and start performing Salah I find no longer songs I need I now listen Quran reciting.
Mashaa Allah
Is Music a major or minor sin? There's too much confusion on this, no clear answer 😮
You could really see how he was agitated the sheikh. I may not be the most knowledgeable but I can at least search up a hadith and find out if it's sahih or not. Do you due diligence.
The fact that no matter what the words are in the music is saying, evil words can be said but the beat moves you whether you agree with the words or not, is a clear sign its haram! Then of course the prophet SAW says so, we hear and obey!
exactly 1,000%
هذا العالم ملعون من الله إلا الإسلام.
Musical scoring, Music is Haraam even An-Nasheed.
Sheikh Uthaymeen [رحمه الله]: "If you see your brother debating and disputing when the truth is clear and he does not want to follow it, you should flee from him in the same way as you flee from a lion. Tell him that you have nothing more than that to say to him, and let him be." [Sharh Hilyah Talib-ul-‘Ilm, Page 28]
Ibn al-Uthaymîn: "Nasheed is an innovation. It imitates what the Sufis innovated in the religion." [Tandheem Al-Ikhwaani al-Muslimeen, Page 139]
Imām ash-Shafi'ī [رحمه الله] said: "Whosoever listens to music, then he is an idiot (سفيه) whose testimony is to be rejected." [الأم للشافعي (٦\٢٠٩)]
Imām Shāfi'ī [رحمه الله] said: "Thagbīr (Anāshīd) were created by heretics to distance people away from the Qur`ān." [مجموع الفتاوى لإبن تيمية ١١\٥٣٢]
Imam Ahmed Bin Hanbal [رحمه الله] was asked about ghinaa’ (singing/music). So, he said: "Music causes hypocrisy to sprout/grow in the heart" [Al-Mughni of Ibn Qudaamah, (12/42)]
Shaykh al-Fawzān حفظه الله: "Nasheeds are not Islamic. They are like music. They should be shunned and not sold." [Al-Khutab Al-Mimbariyyah 3/184]
Shaykh Sālih al-Fawzān حفظه الله: "Nasheeds are from the signs of the Soofis and Hizbis." [Fatawaa Ala Hawaa - 05/05/34]
Sh. Sālih al-Fawzān حفظه الله said: "There's no such thing as 'islamic nashīd', this is the innovation of sūfīs, it is not permissible to promote them." [مجلة الدعوة (١٦٣٢)]
Shaykh al-Albanî [رحمه الله]: "Nasheeds may be performed in the manner of songs & performed like the customs of western music." [Tahreem Alaat al-Tarb] < #Foresightedness of a Scholar!
Shaykh al-Albanî [رحمه الله]: "This is a new mistake, and imitation of the non-muslims and immoral people." [Ibid]
Ibnul Qayyim رحمه الله said: “Singing [and music] is worse and more harmful than stories of emperors, because it directs [one] to adultery and fornication and it is the fountainhead of hypocrisy. It is the snare of the Shaytaan, and it intoxicates the intellect, Its obstructing (people) from the Qur’aan is worse than any way in which other types of phony speech blocks them, because the souls of people lean towards [sounds like this] and have the desire to listen to it.”
[Ighaathatul-Lahfaan’,1/258-259]
Ibn Rajaab said: "People started singing about alcohol & other sinful activities therefore the sahaba took a firm stance against music." [Fat-h, Volume: 6, Page: 77]
Ibn Mas'ūd رضي الله عنه said: "Music breeds hypocrisy in the heart just as water causes vegetation." [Igātha al-Lahfān 1/225-268]
Shaykh 'Abdul Muhsin al-'Abbaad said, "A person should spend his time with what will give him good in return in this life and the life after this. Let him occupy himself with remembrance of Allaah, read the Qur'aan and beneficial books. Moreover, it is also fine to listen to beneficial poetry which urges to noble character and good adab. But as for these Anasheed which are listened to in these times, and which are sung in choirs to thereafter be recorded and sold, one should neither listen to them nor care about them (i.e one should ignore them)." [al-Qawl al-Mufeed fee Hukm-il-Anaasheed, Page 70]
May Allah accept our prayers, May Allah accept our deeds, May Allah protect our families, May Allah make it easy for us, May Allah grant us His paradise, May Allah love our brothers & sisters in need, May Allah grant shifa' to all the sick, May Allah forgive us. Summa Ameen.
النوتة الموسيقية والموسيقى حرام حتى النشيد.
قال الشيخ عثيمين (رحمه الله): إذا رأيت أخاك يتجادل ويتجادل والحقيقة واضحة ولا يريد أن يتبعها فعليك أن تهرب منه كما تهرب من أسد. ليس عنده أكثر من ذلك ليقوله له وليكن ". [شرح حلية طالب العلم ، صفحة 28]
قال ابن العثيمين: "النشيد بدعة. إنه يشبه ما ابتدعه الصوفيون في الدين". [تنديم الإخواني المسلمين ص 139].
قال الإمام الشافعي (رحمه الله): "من سمع للموسيقى فهو أحمق تنكر شهادته". [الأم للشافعي (٦ \ ٢٠٩)]
قال الإمام الشافعي (رحمه الله): "الثغبر (الأناشيد) خلقهم الزنادقة لإبعاد الناس عن القرآن". [مجموع الفتاوى لإبن تيمية ١١ \ ٥٣٢].
وسئل الإمام أحمد بن حنبل رحمه الله عن الغناء. فقال: "الموسيقى تنبت النفاق / تنبت في القلب" [المغني ابن قدامة (12/42)].
قال الشيخ الفوزان حفظه الله: "الأناشيد ليست إسلامية ، فهي مثل الموسيقى ، يجب نبذها وعدم بيعها". [الخطاب الميمبرية 3/184]
الشيخ صالح الفوزان حفظه الله: "الأناشيد من آيات الصوفي والحزبيين". [فتاوى على حواء - 05/05/34]
ش. قال صالح الفوزان حفظه الله: "ما من نَشَيد إسلامي ، فهذا بدعة الصفوف ، ولا يجوز ترقيتها". [مجلة الدعوة (١٦٣٢)]
الشيخ الألباني [رحمه الله]: "يجوز أن تؤدى الأناشيد بأسلوب الترانيم وتقليد الموسيقى الغربية". [تحرير الآت الطرب]
MashaAllah...
Alhamdulillah
Music is indeed haram, but some music is even shrik. That destroys persons Emannn. Avoid learning to any type of music. May Allah almighty bless us Muslims
I stopped listening to it but I have a question is it okay to put music to dance (when I’m alone btw) I take dancing as a sport I do to stay active and some people do it to lose weight plus it’s fun thereoit gives me energy and I learned that it’s haram if I’m dancing alone by myself with no one around and if there’s there’s there’s an include anything inappropriate so it’s okay to dance, but can I put music?
Ave also been in the misic industry where by idroped some of my own songs bt Alhandulillah iwas removed from that n blv mi brothers n ccters,its nt easy bt Allah whome he wills Alhamdulillah today ican drive while listening to my Quran n nt misic anymore
Music is haram? Then i ask you. Are you there bare witness when allah make music haram? Allah only can make a thing haram. And i dont see in quran allah make music haram. Or in a hadits. One thing clearly haram is that you said allah make a thing haram with no proof but your assuming
Robbi inni limaa anzalta ilayya min qairan faqeer
fallible. not infallible. but we understood what shaykh meant
That website that says "Bukhari has weakness" itself is weak. What in the world? I remember sura Al-Kafirun about that weird website.
Bangladesh 🇧🇩 ❤️❤️❤️❤️
can someone drop a link to videos going through that specific hadith that goes into music.
But what is the difference between poetry and music. I’m my country a lot of the poetry could be deemed as music. People sing it and harmonise and clap. I was under the presumption that the kinda of music that is haram uses instruments and discuss foul things.
nauman ali khan is also spreading the same doubts about this topic and spreading that about that hadith
Do you wish to die while listening to music or songs?
No one wish that that’s mean it’s wrong
I realized I have no reading skills lol. I read the thumbnail as ”is the Hadith about weak, music?” 😂😂
Why would music be haram? All music for that matter. Should it not be based on the content?
Assalamualykum shiekh,
I am from Bangladesh.
In our country some people say,Wife of Mohammad sa: is mother of ummah,so our prophet Mohammad sa : is father of ummah. Other say, A Muslim is brother to a muslim, so Mohammad sa: brother to a muslim. What is right?
What counts as music and what not?
Sheikh sahib did not answer the question.. Is music haraam or not? Can someone give straightforward answer in Yes or NO?
Its clearly haram as stated in the hadith
Whether is it Haram or not. No one can deny that it truly does hardens the heart
I realize people now a days learn from Mufti GOOGLE 😢SAD TO SAY THEY rather not STUDY OR RESEARCH TO AHADIT.. THEY ONLY COMPARE FATWA TO GET THE EASY ONE
Listen to music do what you want i do not care, but if you hear the prayer. shut it off, pray then continue your music. Do not Play it while the prayer is happening.
Instead of music, try listening to ambient sounds like the ocean and rainfall.
Even though sheikh summed it up beautifully as fatwa shopping i think he should have made this a small and comprehensive reply to why music is haram! And yes there are alot of people trying to carve ways out of the hadiths and trying to manipulate people into thinking that some things are not really haram while they actually are ... Yhats why we should always put down these liberal muslims and they should become real muslims... Jazak Allah khair
I am from Bangladesh
I am a bangladeshi and I know the people those who don't know Arabic accurately and started to tahqiq hadith.
They are mostly school and College going people (Age around 15-19). They don't have any academic study on this sector of tahqiq a hadis.
They openly spread the mazhab of ibn hazam andalusi (rah).
If you are reading this, I hope you feel loved and safe at all times.