@@LionelMeessi lol what. I agree it shouldn't just be milked for money. The desire to make profit over everything else ruins everything these days. Nobody makes things with a passion anymore. I just want more epic content, not all this fake CGI Disney bullshit. The Amazon series is dogshit. There's loads of lotr lore to be explored
The film is based on a story by J.R.R. Tolkien included in the appendices of “The Lord of the Rings.” EXCEPT THAT THEY CHANGED SO MUCH STUFF. FUCKING HELL WHEN DO THEY LEARN?
Yes The film is based on a story by J.R.R. Tolkien included in the appendices of “The Lord of the Rings.” EXCEPT THAT THEY CHANGED SO MUCH STUFF. FUCKING HELL WHEN DO THEY LEARN?
We don't know if it is good or bad, but it sounds like you made because someone's mommy actually believes in them. I will say, a lot of big names put their stamp of approval on it. Including the woman that co-wrote the LOTR and Hobbit movies people loved and which inspired this. Just saying.
@@elimartin5310the fact that you can only point to two instances of this in a 12 hour trilogy of stories filled with epic battles, where literally thousands of men die, is far more ironic than you realise. But okay lmao
Women should never be protagonists in action. It's so unbelievable that you can't watch it, more unbelievable than the fact that this is an animated film. Yes that unbelievable.
Something the LotR movies changed was Eowyn's character arc wasn't about overcoming sexism, but depression, her own inner demons. Part of the problem was the men around her revered her so much, it didn't occur to them that she was struggling so bad from Grima Wormtongue's mental poison. Killing Sauron's greatest warrior was just a stepping stone for her main triumph, her actual character arc culminating simultaneously in the Houses of Healing with Faramrir overcoming similar inner demons, a story beat completely left out of the movies.
Bruh no, This is ass, Tolkien wrote a backstory for a tree but the feminist director of this crap said she thinks "he overlooked" this dumb story about Helm Hammerhands tiny nameless daughter bodying 200 pound men. We are SO SICK of Hollywood taking liberties with Tolkiens work while promoting a dumb feminist doctrine. We DON'T WANT strong female characters, WE WANT strong Male characters who kick Orc ass. I genuinely believe we need to get rid of some rights women didn't earn.
Just having a female protag is “woke” now? (Yes I know of the criticisms of her replacing a male mc, this is about the people just complaining that an action protag is a woman at all) “Woke” is just the conservative version of the left’s vague “problematic”.
I think there's a lot of people who are too eager to discredit this. This looks great. They are telling a story that not often is considered and likely isn't known by most of the complainers before the trailer dropped. I think there are a couple of things that they could be doing way better, but I felt the same way about Lord of the rings too. I think a lot of people forget that Lord of the rings and the Hobbit both changed a bunch of stuff too. As long as the people who care about Lord of the rings keep working on it. It won't be an issue. The young woman they are presenting is the main character I think is a great choice, It gives off a almost mythical tone to the story which is right at home with middle earth. The art style does look a little off however, I am willing to wait and watch the movie to see how it all comes together.
@@darkhighwayman1757 okay. Do you get how much is changed in the the movies from the books for the live action Lord of the rings series? Have you considered that the person who has done the most faithful adaptations of jrr tolkien's work might have a reason to make the story follow this path over the frankly, very small amount that we're actually given about the conflict this is over. Rings of power was ass, But the people who made rings of power didn't understand the source material. The people who are making this have already proven that they understand the source material, sometimes they take larger creative liberties for ease of communicating it in film. One of the massive plot points in both Lord of the rings and Hobbit are overlooked, important characters are removed, different things are added. I'm willing to put Faith into someone who has shown faith in the material over just assuming and dissuading people from trying to be in better faith of the original content than what they have been
Yeah you can STFU, Tolkien wrote a backstory for a tree but the feminist director of this crap said she thinks "he overlooked" this dumb story about Helm Hammerhands tiny nameless daughter bodying 200 pound men. We are SO SICK of Hollywood taking liberties with Tolkiens work while promoting a dumb feminist doctrine. We DON'T WANT strong female characters, WE WANT strong Male characters who kick Orc ass. I genuinely believe we need to get rid of some rights women didn't earn.
We'll see. The rings of power had an unlikable girl boss on top of a story that made no sense. Plus, they might be playing up how much girl bossery there is.
Because of how popular the lord of the rings was so popular over the years, I think animators for this movie should animate the lord of the rings trilogy by tracing each frame after frame in the films, probably in the extended editions.
That would have been very expensive!! This new cell computer technique might save time but it looks like s****. I would rather it be more grainy like with Lodoss War or Legend of Arslan with updated frame by frame animation. This should p*** off even anime fans. As is a poor effort to say the least I think.
a character that is so unimportant to Tolkien he didn't even name her. So they're gonna base a show on her? Lot of girl bossing gonna be going on. I had such hopes.
Yeah they changed the original story...fuck. The film is based on a story by J.R.R. Tolkien included in the appendices of “The Lord of the Rings.” EXCEPT THAT THEY CHANGED SO MUCH STUFF. FUCKING HELL WHEN DO THEY LEARN?
I’m so glad they gone it in this style rather then awful cgi like the hobbits movies the cgi ruined the movies but this looks great! In fact it looks amazing I can’t wait to watch!
Nice animation and acting but im sorry what does this have to do with tolkiens work? I know its an adapdtion of one his lore but if it didnt have LOR in the title i wouldnt know.
It’s based on something in the Appendixs in LOTR, but that was only a couple paragraphs long iirc and they’re making a whole movie from it so I guess it’s both original and based on appendix.
The helm hammerhand story seems to be pretty lore accurate. If i remember but they've just added in his daughter as the saviour of the film because we can't have a strong white male save the day these days.
The film is based on a story by J.R.R. Tolkien included in the appendices of “The Lord of the Rings.” EXCEPT THAT THEY CHANGED SO MUCH STUFF. FUCKING HELL WHEN DO THEY LEARN?
It’s based on something in the Appendixs in LOTR, but that was only a couple of paragraphs from what I recall so it’ll be down to personal interpretation how original and how based on writings it is.
Tolkien wrote a backstory for a tree but the feminist director of this crap said she thinks "he overlooked" this dumb story about Helm Hammerhands tiny nameless daughter bodying 200 pound men. We are SO SICK of Hollywood taking liberties with Tolkiens work while promoting a dumb feminist doctrine. We DON'T WANT strong female characters, WE WANT strong Male characters who kick Orc ass. I genuinely believe we need to get rid of some rights women didn't earn.
Why are they going with the girl boss? Rohan did not let women fight as established in LotR. This woman being a good rider, I can see. Her beating multiple armed fighters, no. She would not have the experience or skill to do so. Otherwise it looks good. I just wish they would respect the lore.
Listen they changed the story from the original, a lot. I'm worried about this clip too. It looks fantastic but they changed the story of the original. The film is based on a story by J.R.R. Tolkien included in the appendices of “The Lord of the Rings.” But they changed it a lot.
can't they make anything new? why keep remaking old stuff over over and over again? when there's ton's of other fantasy book or comic book series that' hasn't been made into movie or animation yet? lotr are not the only popular fantasy story that exist for the past 20 years?? there are ton's of other popular fantasy book or comic book that could be animated???
Dont like this new computer cel generated animation technique. It makes everything look cheap & unfinished. If they were shooting for an anime style. At least base it off of a good material like Record Of Lodoss War. Which is about as close to Middle Earth as I have seen in an Anime. Although it is quite old now but this just look terrible. Typical Warner Brothers always going for the cheap way out!!
Gay zoomer hair noncanon girl power movie that's totally in the same vein as pre-Denny's Tolkien content. The names attached would have maybe meant something over a decade ago
Oh god they try to give fans a "untold warrior Eowin"-like story paired with a sexist animation style. I already hate it. This is not how I would want to watch and celebrate a female warrior character in a LOTR setting .....😵💫
well, this is the only remotely interesting thing I've seen out of middle earth since the return of the king. Worth giving it a shot. Also, I know Adaptations can sometimes change the heart of what worked about a story, but the Silmarillion was less of a story and more of a blueprint, just Tolkien's notes on things that happened. I think he would change plenty if he were to write this out as a full story, so treating it as a sacred text is pretty damn silly.
Wish they'd just give Peter Jackson a massive budget to make more LOTR. Been nothing like it since 😢
Just re watch the trilogy. Get stoned. It never gets old
there is no neee for any more LOTR smh.... the books were done, stop milking stuff just for money
@@LionelMeessi lol what. I agree it shouldn't just be milked for money. The desire to make profit over everything else ruins everything these days. Nobody makes things with a passion anymore. I just want more epic content, not all this fake CGI Disney bullshit. The Amazon series is dogshit. There's loads of lotr lore to be explored
💯
Never seen any of it, is it any good
The film is based on a story by J.R.R. Tolkien included in the appendices of “The Lord of the Rings.” EXCEPT THAT THEY CHANGED SO MUCH STUFF. FUCKING HELL WHEN DO THEY LEARN?
When they run out of money.
So disappointed I thought this had a chance to be good.
Never.
They can be bleeding from debt and will come back as the undead to desecrate his work more
shut up nerd
The "source material" is like 2 paragraphs, there's not much to change but rather to fill in the gaps..
They woked it up with female protagonist.
Aragorn didn't kick the helmet and break his toe foot for that...
Evil is not able to create anything new, it can only distort and destroy what has been invented or made by the forces of good.
This sentence is PERFECT for this situation... and only a few will understand it
Damn, well said, dude
Repeating The Rings of Power's mistakes I see
Yes The film is based on a story by J.R.R. Tolkien included in the appendices of “The Lord of the Rings.” EXCEPT THAT THEY CHANGED SO MUCH STUFF. FUCKING HELL WHEN DO THEY LEARN?
@@lawrencefrost9063you already said that
That isn't it's most glaring problem here. It looks Ai made and looks like crap!!
Nay, i see warrioress fighting for her kingdom against loyal son and monsters. There is no ugliness, just beauty.
Jeff Bezos says : "Fk me"
why girl boss there are so many characters that can be made main
We all know Helm's nephew killed Wulf
ikrrrrrr they are changing so much already
Girl boss movie
She wants to be Leader not be married! Strong and independent woman
You can be a girl boss and be married
@@EXKALIBER555sadly some people don't know that. or maybe they don't wanna know
@@EXKALIBER555 Luthien: overpowered Middle-Earth's Satan with song and convinced God's court to give her back her dead beloved
Yeah cause I really wanna watch a movie about a wedding wtf is wrong with u people
@@randomgeekcrap who said we wanted this movie to be about a wedding. Read properly before u comment
again with the girl boss...they even redid the galadriel wall climb....when will they fukhin learn...
Oh, how sweet. Rich and powerful mama producer helping her daughter's LOTR fanfiction become a high budget anime.
Lmao
We don't know if it is good or bad, but it sounds like you made because someone's mommy actually believes in them. I will say, a lot of big names put their stamp of approval on it. Including the woman that co-wrote the LOTR and Hobbit movies people loved and which inspired this. Just saying.
Nepotism destroys art
@@righteousgreek2161 Stan Lee was hired to Marvel due to nepotism
Much better than the tv show.
💀 they're both trash
I actually don’t like the artwork. Too shiny for LOTR.
Record of Lodoss War would have been a better template. This looks like some cheap Ai generator s**** not worth anyone's time.
"You got knocked the fuck oouut!"
Looks awesome but i dont know why do they keep trying to make the woman beat men up all the time now
Rewatch the Arwen and Eowyn scenes of LoTR
@@elimartin5310the fact that you can only point to two instances of this in a 12 hour trilogy of stories filled with epic battles, where literally thousands of men die, is far more ironic than you realise. But okay lmao
@@akielstraker
That’s mainly because there were literally no other women around lol.
Who else are they going to beat up?
Women should never be protagonists in action. It's so unbelievable that you can't watch it, more unbelievable than the fact that this is an animated film. Yes that unbelievable.
Something the LotR movies changed was Eowyn's character arc wasn't about overcoming sexism, but depression, her own inner demons.
Part of the problem was the men around her revered her so much, it didn't occur to them that she was struggling so bad from Grima Wormtongue's mental poison.
Killing Sauron's greatest warrior was just a stepping stone for her main triumph, her actual character arc culminating simultaneously in the Houses of Healing with Faramrir overcoming similar inner demons, a story beat completely left out of the movies.
Suck It, Amazon!
Reminds me a bit of the animated LOTR and Hobbit by Rakin/Bass and Ralph Bakshi. Perhaps even better.
The lord of the rings in anime looks so incredible
hopefully this isn't lame like Rings of Power or overdone like The Hobbit
Hey I love the Hobbit.
its gonna be bad. She's gonna be soooo powerful and they will make Helm not even a part of his own F'ing story
Master piece is back in anime 🔥🔥
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Bruh no, This is ass, Tolkien wrote a backstory for a tree but the feminist director of this crap said she thinks "he overlooked" this dumb story about Helm Hammerhands tiny nameless daughter bodying 200 pound men.
We are SO SICK of Hollywood taking liberties with Tolkiens work while promoting a dumb feminist doctrine. We DON'T WANT strong female characters, WE WANT strong Male characters who kick Orc ass.
I genuinely believe we need to get rid of some rights women didn't earn.
Just having a female protag is “woke” now? (Yes I know of the criticisms of her replacing a male mc, this is about the people just complaining that an action protag is a woman at all) “Woke” is just the conservative version of the left’s vague “problematic”.
Yay another girl boss that didn't exist climbing a ice mountain with daggers 😂.
2:10 I got goosebumps
I think there's a lot of people who are too eager to discredit this. This looks great. They are telling a story that not often is considered and likely isn't known by most of the complainers before the trailer dropped. I think there are a couple of things that they could be doing way better, but I felt the same way about Lord of the rings too.
I think a lot of people forget that Lord of the rings and the Hobbit both changed a bunch of stuff too. As long as the people who care about Lord of the rings keep working on it. It won't be an issue.
The young woman they are presenting is the main character I think is a great choice, It gives off a almost mythical tone to the story which is right at home with middle earth. The art style does look a little off however, I am willing to wait and watch the movie to see how it all comes together.
its terrible, she gets barely a sentence in the book. Just tell Helm's story. Do they have to have a girl boss in every GD show?
@@darkhighwayman1757 okay. Do you get how much is changed in the the movies from the books for the live action Lord of the rings series? Have you considered that the person who has done the most faithful adaptations of jrr tolkien's work might have a reason to make the story follow this path over the frankly, very small amount that we're actually given about the conflict this is over.
Rings of power was ass, But the people who made rings of power didn't understand the source material. The people who are making this have already proven that they understand the source material, sometimes they take larger creative liberties for ease of communicating it in film. One of the massive plot points in both Lord of the rings and Hobbit are overlooked, important characters are removed, different things are added.
I'm willing to put Faith into someone who has shown faith in the material over just assuming and dissuading people from trying to be in better faith of the original content than what they have been
@@darkhighwayman1757i agreee they arent followikg the source material
Yeah you can STFU, Tolkien wrote a backstory for a tree but the feminist director of this crap said she thinks "he overlooked" this dumb story about Helm Hammerhands tiny nameless daughter bodying 200 pound men.
We are SO SICK of Hollywood taking liberties with Tolkiens work while promoting a dumb feminist doctrine. We DON'T WANT strong female characters, WE WANT strong Male characters who kick Orc ass.
I genuinely believe we need to get rid of some rights women didn't earn.
Takes me back 20 years when I saw the trilogies back when the movie theater was still a thing
New Animated movies for middle earth whelp time to hope for a first age movie of the battle of dragons vs great eagles!!!!!!!!!
Finally, something we’ve all been waiting for, Girl Boss interpretation of LOTR! If only they have had a similar approach on Rings of Power, oh wait…
We'll see. The rings of power had an unlikable girl boss on top of a story that made no sense.
Plus, they might be playing up how much girl bossery there is.
😂
In fairness Jackson's LoTR trilogy changed the story to add girlboss Arwen.
It's a Japanese anime, don't worry about western propaganda being shoved into it.
@@elimartin5310 There's a difference between a strong or powerful woman and a girl boss
Because of how popular the lord of the rings was so popular over the years, I think animators for this movie should animate the lord of the rings trilogy by tracing each frame after frame in the films, probably in the extended editions.
The original lotr movies was animated back in late 70s they are very dated now but it be awesome to see a newer fresher version like this
@@kitkat88816 I know, I remembered taking a look at it back when I was a kid, I liked the animated Hobbit more with Orson Bean as Bilbo Baggins.
That would have been very expensive!! This new cell computer technique might save time but it looks like s****. I would rather it be more grainy like with Lodoss War or Legend of Arslan with updated frame by frame animation. This should p*** off even anime fans. As is a poor effort to say the least I think.
Guy with greyish hair next to the prince, hunch he's an instigator and servant of sauron.
Tolkien fought in the world war and now they turned his stuff into anime lmao
Yay......girl boss.
Cancer
Looks well done, looking forward to this.
Is this made by the same studio that made Castlevania? The artstyle is pretty similar
They ran out of money with Rings of Power, so they had to make a cartoon
Different studio
a character that is so unimportant to Tolkien he didn't even name her. So they're gonna base a show on her? Lot of girl bossing gonna be going on. I had such hopes.
LOTR if made by Disney in a fusion of "Brave"... To bad because of Rohan is my favorite faction in Tolkien's world and I like anime but this...
This isn't even anime but a cheap Computer cel generated knockoff.
Why don’t they just do Beren and Luthien, The Children of Hurin and The Fall of Gondolin?
The Tolkien estate hold onto the Silmarillion like its the one ring.
@@darkhighwayman1757frankly I don’t blame them considering how ROP has not endeared itself to the general public.
Peter just wrote his name on it.... ?!
Old age...foolish decision. He has to have alzeimhers or something to do such a stupid thing as to write his name on a project like this?
My thoughts exactly or perhaps his talent is all used up?
No thanks. I like my Tolkien to be more Tolkien.
Yeah they changed the original story...fuck. The film is based on a story by J.R.R. Tolkien included in the appendices of “The Lord of the Rings.” EXCEPT THAT THEY CHANGED SO MUCH STUFF. FUCKING HELL WHEN DO THEY LEARN?
poor John Ronald Reuel Tolkien is turning in his grave now...after hobbitts and rings of the power, he thought that it couldn't be worse...
I’m so glad they gone it in this style rather then awful cgi like the hobbits movies the cgi ruined the movies but this looks great! In fact it looks amazing I can’t wait to watch!
0:03 what music is this?
The anime style isn't getting me giddy and is a missed opportunity, hope I'm wrong.
yeah i agree. Like it's alright but it looks a bit too crisp and clean
Woke DoA
Absolutely DOA, woke turns everything into DOA.
Is this the low frame rate version?
😊
Nice animation and acting but im sorry what does this have to do with tolkiens work?
I know its an adapdtion of one his lore but if it didnt have LOR in the title i wouldnt know.
It is based on two paragraphs in the Lord of the Rings appendix. A civil war in Rohan that occurred 200 years before the War of the Ring.
@@davidricart1395 she's not even given a name in the story.
so dope
Please be better than the Hobbit trilogy
It won't 💀
LotR Strong Woman: Anime Edition.
Yo wtf is this
Can they stop with girl bosses? I am so tired of girl bosses.
This looks cool but it doesn’t feel like LOTR movies, this could have been its own thing but they want the embedded audience (those that still exist).
Old man punched his $hit right out !
Eomar and his sister in..?
Wow! They are going to show how a woman can be a strong lead without Identity politics! Brilliant!
What book or story is this based on?
I think it's an original
An original fake 💀 she wasn't named. She didn't do anything, her father did, but you know Strong and Independent 💀
It’s based on something in the Appendixs in LOTR, but that was only a couple paragraphs long iirc and they’re making a whole movie from it so I guess it’s both original and based on appendix.
Woke
Berge Meadow
Yay another girl boss
"You could rule the world." The whole point of Tolkien is that isnt a good thing. This looks like another girl power fantasy. Bad times.
I've never read the books, can anyone tell if this is canon or not.
The helm hammerhand story seems to be pretty lore accurate. If i remember but they've just added in his daughter as the saviour of the film because we
can't have a strong white male save the day these days.
@@jayc5555cry more white man🤡
@@jayc5555
We have plenty of them. But crybabies only focus on the small percentage on women.
The film is based on a story by J.R.R. Tolkien included in the appendices of “The Lord of the Rings.” EXCEPT THAT THEY CHANGED SO MUCH STUFF. FUCKING HELL WHEN DO THEY LEARN?
He worked on Ghost in a shell and Eden of the East 2 classics, I’m excited for this story
Don't be 💀
GET IN! I'm so happy all my favourite I.P's are now getting the animation treatment, this is how you save a dying franchise
Another wake 🤮
What is this thing?
Where, in JRRT's writings does it appear or, like ROTK, is it all made up?
It’s based on something in the Appendixs in LOTR, but that was only a couple of paragraphs from what I recall so it’ll be down to personal interpretation how original and how based on writings it is.
Lord of the rings anime looks good I can't wait for this movie 🔥🔥🔥
lets give it a chance folks
Tolkien wrote a backstory for a tree but the feminist director of this crap said she thinks "he overlooked" this dumb story about Helm Hammerhands tiny nameless daughter bodying 200 pound men.
We are SO SICK of Hollywood taking liberties with Tolkiens work while promoting a dumb feminist doctrine. We DON'T WANT strong female characters, WE WANT strong Male characters who kick Orc ass.
I genuinely believe we need to get rid of some rights women didn't earn.
Manga??
Were is frodo bilbo.
The Day on restuns king movie retuns heroes
...Oh no...This is...Oh no...
Robinson Betty Lewis Christopher Harris Christopher
Anime version
LOOKS GOOD, cant wait.
Ah the blind can type now
Why are they going with the girl boss? Rohan did not let women fight as established in LotR. This woman being a good rider, I can see. Her beating multiple armed fighters, no. She would not have the experience or skill to do so.
Otherwise it looks good. I just wish they would respect the lore.
they just cant and I don't know why?
Never in this woke world will be those great movies again!
Arab is caming
Doesn't feel like LOTR, big skip.
😕
I got fucking chills. Jesus Christ.
PROMETE
meh
Wow looks da@@ good ! Better then the crap Ring of Power !
is the movie show watchable? is thi sany good.
Holy fuck this looks good
Listen they changed the story from the original, a lot. I'm worried about this clip too. It looks fantastic but they changed the story of the original. The film is based on a story by J.R.R. Tolkien included in the appendices of “The Lord of the Rings.” But they changed it a lot.
can't they make anything new? why keep remaking old stuff over over and over again? when there's ton's of other fantasy book or comic book series that' hasn't been made into movie or animation yet? lotr are not the only popular fantasy story that exist for the past 20 years?? there are ton's of other popular fantasy book or comic book that could be animated???
Feminism strikes again 🥱
looks god awful. this trailer gave me cancer
Bahhhhhhh! Anime was better back in my day. Record of Lodoss War OVA looks way better than this.
Did they know that the orcs are inspired by the Peruvians?
Ahhhh what?
Dont like this new computer cel generated animation technique. It makes everything look cheap & unfinished. If they were shooting for an anime style.
At least base it off of a good material like Record Of Lodoss War. Which is about as close to Middle Earth as I have seen in an Anime.
Although it is quite old now but this just look terrible. Typical Warner Brothers always going for the cheap way out!!
Gay zoomer hair noncanon girl power movie that's totally in the same vein as pre-Denny's Tolkien content.
The names attached would have maybe meant something over a decade ago
Oh god they try to give fans a "untold warrior Eowin"-like story paired with a sexist animation style. I already hate it. This is not how I would want to watch and celebrate a female warrior character in a LOTR setting .....😵💫
Boring boring 🥱🥱
Apart from the story looking bad the voice acting omg it’s so trash
No Hobbit?? no Gandalf?? no dwarf?? no elf?? no troll?? no uruk-hai?? no gollum?? then how the fuck am i supposed to watch this like LOTR??
well, this is the only remotely interesting thing I've seen out of middle earth since the return of the king. Worth giving it a shot.
Also, I know Adaptations can sometimes change the heart of what worked about a story, but the Silmarillion was less of a story and more of a blueprint, just Tolkien's notes on things that happened. I think he would change plenty if he were to write this out as a full story, so treating it as a sacred text is pretty damn silly.
because it's LOTR people will overlook the bad story and woke injections.
that s what amazon believes
no they wont.. its gonna bomb just like rings of power
mmmmmm....no