The autist doctor said "Male" referring to the biological fact. Why did the other doctors deflect by going into the "gender" talk if the two things are different? If the patient is in the hospital for internal medicine then the biological status of a patient is the only relevant thing here.
Nice way to flip it back on the libs. Too bad they'll just ignore it and say, "Oh, he's so autistic! That's why he's calling her a he! He's just too autistic to tell otherwise! 🥰🥰🥰"
@Michael Hess It’s disrespectful to science and biology to not call him by his actual gender. It’s only a fact. If there is such a thing as gender dysphoria, then we should be telling them how it’s wrong, not encouraging their mental illness.
Those are doctors I NEVER want touching me Your taking thousands of years of evidence just to ignore it for someone emotions No give me the doctor thats there to do his or her job no consult my damn feelings
"Shaun, please, im about to call security. And pretending being transgender so you can say after this that I am 'transphobic' to Human Resources would let you at a worst situation."
@@angusdelaney905 we are far from the days of doctors abiding by science and logic. Healthcare’s mostly a sham of a business. Just ask the VA or Dr. Fauci
When it comes to medicine you need to know the biological sex of the patients to give them adeguate threatening, no serious surgeon would give a fuck in what they identify, it's not what they are.
True, just not in the way you think. The biological sex of trans people isn't cut and dry. Hormonal and phenotypic sex are far more important than chromosomal sex, which is practically irrelevant.
@@ashleigh.I don’t have the time to explain why that’s complete bunk. Males and females even have different absorption rates of some medicines depending on how they’re ingested.
@@jacksonconstantine5740 Source? I'm only aware of alcohol doing that, which is also dependent upon endocrine and phenotypic sex not chromosomal sex, I imagine such is the case with whatever you're referring to too.
I think the funniest part of this is every “medical expert” around him acting like he’s some idiot because he knows that men are men and women are women. The eye rolls, the condescension, the sighs, the corrections; it’s so obvious what kind of propaganda this is. C’mon Shaun, say the line. Do what the party says if you want to be a good doctor. You don’t want to be a bigot so you? A transphobe? I didn’t think so. Now pretend to ignore everything we know about human anatomy because a 12 year old is pretending his pole is a hole.
Okay, so I understand that the girl is actually transgender, but what I DON'T get however is that the doctor is CLEARLY autistic and yet all the other doctors treat him like an idiot because he has trouble comprehending a concept that's so alien to him. They talk him down for not understanding the idea of being transgender, while they themself don't understand how lost he might be feeling in this situation. The only thing I could think of hearing "Quinn has gender dysphoria. She's mismatched." was "Doctor 4chan here has autism. His idea of gender was mismatched."
Yeah you would think doctors would be familiair with the concept of autism and be able to deal with it the same way they can deal with a transgender patiënt. Might be a bit annoying if the autistic person is your colleague, but still, they should have skills to have more understanding and communicate better.
No he's wrong. Quinn had a female brain but a male body, so in order to alleviate their "gender dysphoria" you have to change the body to match the brain.
The fact that he has testicles proves Good Doctor is correct. And whoever say the patient is a she contradicts science. A medical procedure for a male person cannot be applied to a female simply because that woman has no testicles. if someone replies I'm not a doctor or a person who is an expert in biology then prove to the world females have testicles.
Gender=/=sex Biology vs. Psychology. Your argument does not even apply here because we all KNOW that trans people have the wrong parts. That's kinda why we're trans in the first place? And not cis? Also it doesn't contradict "science." Currently the best treatment for someone suffering from Dysphoria is acceptance and transitioning. And generally less bigotry like this in their lives. THIS is the real science, not the political nonsense people spew at a camera.
I think you may have missed the point of the scene, it was to show how silly that kind of thinking is. Colours and clothes don't equal gender, it's more complex than that. You can still be a tomboy woman, or a feminine man, but you can also be transgender. Some trans men are feminine, some trans women are masculine, just like people who aren't trans. People get so triggered over trans people because it makes them question their narrow-minded view of the world. It makes them think beyond the black or the white. And people seem to think science is this unmoving, unprogressive thing, which also annoys me because 100 years ago, we thought giving people lobotomies was a good idea. Things change, humans evolve, we can't just stay stagnant as a species or regress like so many of these comments seem to want
If this "be what you want to be" sht carries on. 40 year old men with start identifying and a 12 year old girl. Its a load of bollocks that people use for attention and it needs to stop.
@@manwhatdoiputherea schizo might think they're being chased by the government. is it fine to let them live in delusional because their condition causes it?
@@manwhatdoiputherenot if that identity is a delusion. It’s a psychosis bro. Because a bunch of paid off shills in L.A. decided to rename it to something less offensive doesn’t make it healthy.
@@manwhatdoiputhere Millions of years of biological evolution and we have people out here thinking humans are some magical creatures whose self perception supercedes reality. I feel bad for thinking the religious people were the crazy ones for so many years.
@@manwhatdoiputhere Janet is a MtF transgender, if Janet have testicular or prostate cancer I can just say that "Janet have this" instead of "he have this". Don't expected other people to do the same though.
I know we're supposed to understand that because he's autistic he doesn't have the ability to deal with the trans concept but let's be honest, he is just stating facts. It's like this show is doing everything in reverse like how we are also supposed to side with him when he doesn't have the reason.
This exactly what I dont like about SOME members of this community and today's progress. For the most part for medical exams, they dont ask you whether you like dresses, pants or skirts no one should care about what you prefer but you, doctors ask for your biology because of dosage, screening and other anatomical reasons! It doesn't make sense to put any of this where is not due!
He is autistic, sometimes they are sometimes socially awkward.I found this on google, when i typed up autism."problems with social communication and interaction, and restricted or repetitive behaviors or interests".He is simply autistic, With an interest about that gender.Thinking "why does a boy think they're a girl.
Typically they don't luckily. Psychologists do look for signs like that but I know I wouldn't of come down with the trans as a child, didn't do girly stuff. It's mostly just socially transitioning without any medication as you wait to be seen professionally. Might start on hormone blockers but that's reversible if done for a relatively short time. It's all to give the child more time to decide
You should watch another episode where there's a girl who's on T, and has a male partner... And, that male partner intercourses with her vaginally and gets her pregnant... Yet, they say they're both gay! I stopped watching this series after that very episode. It's S4: E9....
I have the same opinion with the autistic doctor which the 'girl' should be classified as a male biologically. It's true that she has gender dysmorphia, but I personally dislike anything about misgendering. Except some cases when there are people born with both male and female reproduction systems.
Bro there is no such thing as people being born with woman’s and men’s body parts. Also, if you are classified as having XX chromosomes you are a girl. If you have XY chromosomes you are a guy. I thought they taught this in 6th grade science.
bro murphy isnt even wrong.. why tf are kids even into this stuff tho- they shouldnt even know what this is....correct me if im wrong but i know im correct
How could doctors assign gender? Do they come to a baby and say ''you must wear dresses and play with dolls'' or ''you must wear jeans and play with cars''?
@@majungasaurus6814, the second doctor said ''her assigned gender is not the one she identifies with'' so i wondered how on earth can doctors assign it
@@ВладСетонов your child has a penis, it's a male, your child has a vagina it's a woman, o wow your child is a hermaphrodite that's weird that's how they do It
@@ВладСетонов I get you vlad, why is the doctor assigning the sec? but sometimes when people are intersex the doctor really does choose, but yeah it's assigned by nature
@@SandwitchZebra transgender people can still be biologically their birth assigned sex, pretty sure the gender part is where the feelings come in…since it’s infinite lmfao
So much transphobia in the comments. Shaun was acting very unprofessional in this scene. Let me lay some things straight. Biological sex is important when discussing medical problems. So is mental health, as these two things are intrinsically connected. While it is reasonable to treat the patient with the knowledge of her being biologically male, it is also important to maintain respect and good rapport with your patient. Shaun went over the line by not referring to her correctly, and especially went over the line by asking questions that are by no means necessary for a diagnosis, and only necessary for his own gain. And though this curiosity does come from lack of understanding, it is also very unprofessional to push this onto your patient, and should instead be addressed later via research and discussion with peers or even your boss. His repeated disrespect of his patient's wishes is certainly warranted for discipline and in a real life setting, this would be means enough for a patient or her representatives to be talking to HR. Mental health is just as important as physical health. Gender dysphoria is a serious condition and should be treated with respect and delicacy, just as we do with physical illnesses like cancer or a broken leg. And before you mention him being autistic. Yes, this is a factor for social difficulty. I am also autistic. We can learn things too, it just takes time. And sometimes this takes discipline.
People are truly more worried about what people think about themselves than having self-respect, Boo Hoo someone called me she instead of he, I couldn't give any less shits if someone else called me a tractor because I like how I am.
Why is this posted like it's a new episode? It's not. At the end of the episode Shaun sees her as a girl (as it should be). Odd that this wasn't that long ago and feels outdated
Imagine the doctor consulting the parents by saying:
“I’m sorry, but your daughter has testicular cancer.”
Omg she’s so brave to be the first girl with testicular cancer so proud of her
“But how can it be? BIOLOGY ISN’T REAL”
It comical how some people can’t see how ridiculous that sounds
“Maam you have testicular cancer”
I’m a cat. I am the strongest, biggest, smartest cat
@@YzzamiI've typed enough in other comments but we (as trans people) do see the ridiculousness of it. It can happen though 🤷♀️
I love how the writers try and make him look like a bad guy but in the end they can’t even say he’s wrong.
Because he is not lmao
Fr
Or why they think he's wrong 😂
@@emma_luce_1123 “he has testicle cancer”
“She…”
Like they can’t not sound ridiculous…
Kkkkkk
Always disliked this show, but after this scene and the “i am surgeon” meme, I truly believe this series is a masterpiece
😐
@@PigsHealthcare yup people are going back to reality my friend
@@drbubonic4942 🤓
But that's just a meme
@@PigsHealthcare
✡️
"She has testicular cancer"
Probably the first time somebody has ever said that.
House said it first
I'm learning that transphobes are more stupid than hateful lol this happens all the time
@@coilinkeegan8640 you’re calling them stupid when you think it’s possible to change genders 😂
@@coilinkeegan8640 This comment wasn't related to the comment you're replying to. Did you reply to the wrong one?
@@coilinkeegan8640 ✡️
the good doctor? more like the based doctor, amiright boys?
Right
Your goddamn right🗿
Transgender BS
Hell yeah. Idk how people argue that u can change ur gender
what in tarnation
I AM BASED!
I AM BASED!
I AM BASED, DOCTOR HAN! I AM BASED!
damn bro go outside💀
@@pazkal61 Huh?
Damn, do you not attend biology
@@niks7921 the kid is a boy 💀
@@ash_11117 no *SHE* is a girl
The last seconds of this clip made me laugh so hard 😂😂😂
The autist doctor said "Male" referring to the biological fact. Why did the other doctors deflect by going into the "gender" talk if the two things are different? If the patient is in the hospital for internal medicine then the biological status of a patient is the only relevant thing here.
Nice way to flip it back on the libs. Too bad they'll just ignore it and say, "Oh, he's so autistic! That's why he's calling her a he! He's just too autistic to tell otherwise! 🥰🥰🥰"
@Michael Hess It’s disrespectful to science and biology to not call him by his actual gender. It’s only a fact. If there is such a thing as gender dysphoria, then we should be telling them how it’s wrong, not encouraging their mental illness.
@Michael Hess is it disrespectful to tell the truth?
@Michael Hess it’s also stupid to lie to your doctor about an important medical fact
@@_Code_3 these days is disrespectful to tell a fat girl she is fat😂 or an ugly perosn they are ugly
Paging doctor based
Literally lol'ed at the end when the doctor guy sighed and said she
Those are doctors I NEVER want touching me
Your taking thousands of years of evidence just to ignore it for someone emotions
No give me the doctor thats there to do his or her job no consult my damn feelings
I am a SHE
I am...a SHE
I AM
I AM A SHEE, IIIIIII AM A SHEEEE, DOCTOR
"Shaun, please, im about to call security. And pretending being transgender so you can say after this that I am 'transphobic' to Human Resources would let you at a worst situation."
"Grr society has stereotypes about women"
"If you vaguely feel like the stereotype of a woman that means you are one"
Same person
Yes, they are two sides of the same coin, and the coin flips everytime one side gets exposed as sinister or manipulative
"gender is a social construct"
Same person: "let's do surgery to have your body match the social construct"
Try to understand the difference between femininity and harmful stereotypes challenge: Impossible
Those doctor just scared of sued or cancelled..
Doctor must abided by science and biology, if they can't do that then show them the door.
@@angusdelaney905 Biology says there are two genders.
@@angusdelaney905 we are far from the days of doctors abiding by science and logic. Healthcare’s mostly a sham of a business. Just ask the VA or Dr. Fauci
@@angusdelaney905 its funny how science is stretched thin thanks to mental people nowadays
@@cesruhf2605yeah but it’s a hospital not a therapist session room so obviously the doctors will refer to the patient’s sex and not gender
When it comes to medicine you need to know the biological sex of the patients to give them adeguate threatening, no serious surgeon would give a fuck in what they identify, it's not what they are.
True, just not in the way you think. The biological sex of trans people isn't cut and dry. Hormonal and phenotypic sex are far more important than chromosomal sex, which is practically irrelevant.
@@ashleigh.I don’t have the time to explain why that’s complete bunk. Males and females even have different absorption rates of some medicines depending on how they’re ingested.
@@jacksonconstantine5740 Source? I'm only aware of alcohol doing that, which is also dependent upon endocrine and phenotypic sex not chromosomal sex, I imagine such is the case with whatever you're referring to too.
I think the funniest part of this is every “medical expert” around him acting like he’s some idiot because he knows that men are men and women are women. The eye rolls, the condescension, the sighs, the corrections; it’s so obvious what kind of propaganda this is.
C’mon Shaun, say the line. Do what the party says if you want to be a good doctor. You don’t want to be a bigot so you? A transphobe? I didn’t think so. Now pretend to ignore everything we know about human anatomy because a 12 year old is pretending his pole is a hole.
have you even watched the show? He literally has temper tantrums over the smallest things. He acts like a 5 year old.
@@kathleenoconnell-yf7ls you're going to dismiss his opinion because he has autism?
Pretty abelist of you, no?
@@kathleenoconnell-yf7ls bro just compared autism to act like a child.
Okay, so I understand that the girl is actually transgender, but what I DON'T get however is that the doctor is CLEARLY autistic and yet all the other doctors treat him like an idiot because he has trouble comprehending a concept that's so alien to him.
They talk him down for not understanding the idea of being transgender, while they themself don't understand how lost he might be feeling in this situation.
The only thing I could think of hearing "Quinn has gender dysphoria. She's mismatched." was "Doctor 4chan here has autism. His idea of gender was mismatched."
Like the true doctor said, he has testicular cancer
Yeah you would think doctors would be familiair with the concept of autism and be able to deal with it the same way they can deal with a transgender patiënt. Might be a bit annoying if the autistic person is your colleague, but still, they should have skills to have more understanding and communicate better.
bro went through a decade of medical school. he should be able to get stuff, no matter how retarded he is
Also people seem to forget the boy is a minor
Children can’t consent
He might be autistic, but he's the smartest one out of the two
Science and reality can be a real pain in the testicles. 😏😎
there has GOT to be a writer operating behind the scenes sliding based scenes like this in.
I get that it's meabt to be a "haha, autistic guy doesn't get it lol" moment. But he's literally right
No he's wrong. Quinn had a female brain but a male body, so in order to alleviate their "gender dysphoria" you have to change the body to match the brain.
@@ninjrax No, it;s a sickness. You have to treat the sickness so the brain matches the body.
@@ninjrax >have to change your body
get real lol
@@vvvega58 ?
@@ninjrax he’s saying YWNBAW
The fact that he has testicles proves Good Doctor is correct. And whoever say the patient is a she contradicts science. A medical procedure for a male person cannot be applied to a female simply because that woman has no testicles. if someone replies I'm not a doctor or a person who is an expert in biology then prove to the world females have testicles.
Gender=/=sex
Biology vs. Psychology. Your argument does not even apply here because we all KNOW that trans people have the wrong parts. That's kinda why we're trans in the first place? And not cis?
Also it doesn't contradict "science." Currently the best treatment for someone suffering from Dysphoria is acceptance and transitioning. And generally less bigotry like this in their lives. THIS is the real science, not the political nonsense people spew at a camera.
@@wolfman-zd1ed good luck with that.
Imagine going to medical school for 10 years just to say "Ma'am you have testicular cancer"
It's crazy how we went from "It's ok for boys to play with dolls and like pink" to "playing will dolls and liking pink means you're a girl".
🤔
Except it doesn't
And how we went from tomboys being a thing to, "I'm non-binary/genderqueer".
@@briang3598 fr why cant girls just accept them being tomboys man 😒
@@AlisonL520 Silence man with long hair.
I think you may have missed the point of the scene, it was to show how silly that kind of thinking is. Colours and clothes don't equal gender, it's more complex than that. You can still be a tomboy woman, or a feminine man, but you can also be transgender. Some trans men are feminine, some trans women are masculine, just like people who aren't trans. People get so triggered over trans people because it makes them question their narrow-minded view of the world. It makes them think beyond the black or the white. And people seem to think science is this unmoving, unprogressive thing, which also annoys me because 100 years ago, we thought giving people lobotomies was a good idea. Things change, humans evolve, we can't just stay stagnant as a species or regress like so many of these comments seem to want
If this "be what you want to be" sht carries on. 40 year old men with start identifying and a 12 year old girl. Its a load of bollocks that people use for attention and it needs to stop.
Oh it's a girl, we can rule out testicular cancer, prostate, and haemophilia. Oh wait, biological sex is relevant to medical diagnosis?!
Yes, nobody's saying that we should rule out biological sex in medical diagnoses for trans people. We can do that yet still respect their identity.
@@manwhatdoiputherea schizo might think they're being chased by the government. is it fine to let them live in delusional because their condition causes it?
@@manwhatdoiputherenot if that identity is a delusion. It’s a psychosis bro. Because a bunch of paid off shills in L.A. decided to rename it to something less offensive doesn’t make it healthy.
@@manwhatdoiputhere Millions of years of biological evolution and we have people out here thinking humans are some magical creatures whose self perception supercedes reality.
I feel bad for thinking the religious people were the crazy ones for so many years.
@@manwhatdoiputhere Janet is a MtF transgender, if Janet have testicular or prostate cancer I can just say that "Janet have this" instead of "he have this".
Don't expected other people to do the same though.
Chad Surgeon vs Cringe LGBT protester
of course the lbgt supporter is a person of colour. makes our race look bad 😂
He’s just a confused little boy lol
@@cajunking5987 how the doctor telling the truth or the patient that can’t figure itself out
@@Omega101-13 the patient is a confused little boy
You are definitely under the age of 12.
"She has a testicular cancer" 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
Lmao its unreal, its so ridiculous we really live in a period.
-he- she doesn’t get periods
We live in a period where biological fact is denied
I know we're supposed to understand that because he's autistic he doesn't have the ability to deal with the trans concept but let's be honest, he is just stating facts.
It's like this show is doing everything in reverse like how we are also supposed to side with him when he doesn't have the reason.
"She, has testicular cancer" 😂 what a time to be alive.
Trans people have always existed. Always.
@@UnknownButterflies1312you have no testosterone
@UnknownButterflies1312 except they always were male and female before our retraded times.
This is probably the only reason I know why he should continue being a surgeon
He also identifies as a surgeon, he IS a surgeon
💀💀💀testicular cancer
Bet he lurks pol
The based Doctor.
sigma
"20 questions are up"
"I only asked four"
Man that had to be so cathartic for the actors
Someone get this king a crown already 😤
erm.. 💀
this is the rare exception where dr han would side with dr murphy.
This exactly what I dont like about SOME members of this community and today's progress. For the most part for medical exams, they dont ask you whether you like dresses, pants or skirts no one should care about what you prefer but you, doctors ask for your biology because of dosage, screening and other anatomical reasons! It doesn't make sense to put any of this where is not due!
He is autistic, sometimes they are sometimes socially awkward.I found this on google, when i typed up autism."problems with social communication and interaction, and restricted or repetitive behaviors or interests".He is simply autistic, With an interest about that gender.Thinking "why does a boy think they're a girl.
Typically they don't luckily. Psychologists do look for signs like that but I know I wouldn't of come down with the trans as a child, didn't do girly stuff. It's mostly just socially transitioning without any medication as you wait to be seen professionally. Might start on hormone blockers but that's reversible if done for a relatively short time. It's all to give the child more time to decide
@@rubencasey he found a sickness, and he's trying to treat it. Like a doctor should.
@@AlisonL520 psychologists do more harm than good
That’s why blud is confused, his balls fell off 💀
He he he
his balls committed suicide after all the bull he was saying 💀
Bro 💀
@@cesruhf2605Oml your joke was so funny I forgot to laugh 😐
@@purpleducck okay mr/mrs/ms/theythem oonga boonga
it's biology, simple
Nuh-uh
@@PigsHealthcare ye
Aye biology determines sex, not gender
@@manwhatdoiputhere google says gender is a synonyme of sex
@@manwhatdoiputhere Gender dysphoria is a mental disorder and should be treated accordingly.
Can’t “she” identify as someone without cancer? Done, problemo solved.
No one thinks like this.
@@wolfman-zd1edI mean people kind of do to a certain extent
Doctors: We're sorry, but your daughter has testicular cancer.
Parents: 😭😭
Girl: 😮😀
Women don't get testicular cancer! This episode a WOKE EPISODE!☹️
You should watch another episode where there's a girl who's on T, and has a male partner... And, that male partner intercourses with her vaginally and gets her pregnant... Yet, they say they're both gay! I stopped watching this series after that very episode.
It's S4: E9....
She is a woman
bro forgot to ask why dont your parents love you
I have the same opinion with the autistic doctor which the 'girl' should be classified as a male biologically. It's true that she has gender dysmorphia, but I personally dislike anything about misgendering. Except some cases when there are people born with both male and female reproduction systems.
Bro there is no such thing as people being born with woman’s and men’s body parts. Also, if you are classified as having XX chromosomes you are a girl. If you have XY chromosomes you are a guy. I thought they taught this in 6th grade science.
Vagina = girl
Penis = boy
"She has testicular cancer" 😆😂🤣
Logically, medically, biologically doesnt make sense
People say “biologically” like its the only factor.
If they have testicular cancer, thats a guy.
So here's the thing
MALE - boy (grows up to be a man)
FEMALE - girl (grows up to be a woman)
It's so simple
Yeah but they can’t hear or read that 😂
100% females are females and males are males
😂😂😂😂 he keep saying she till the very end got me dead
It’s disgusting how the older and more experienced doctors are encouraging his delusion.
based dexter
This works more as an antiwoke message lol
DAMMIT SHAUN YOU MADE HER DO 41%!
😐
@@PigsHealthcare more like 💀, at least a 41% chance
one of the most misconstrued statistics in modern political discourse and making fun of suicide, good one bro
@@rafael502 why are you making fun of suicide victims?
@@PigsHealthcare 41% 42% 43%
Based 🧐
no?
This is absolutely hilarious!
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I don't know why they looking at him like he crazy? He's nailing it. He is a boy!
Cuz they are scared to get Sued, cuz this world or Society are Corrupted
Why are we debating over a FICTIONAL show?? None of us are going to win this debate, bc it doesn’t exist. This. isn’t. Real.
The dude is a surgeon, he knows everything. Don't question him.
I swear when this dude acts he's pretending to be an Alexa AI.
Why are there not one but TWO doctors in the control panel watching as the scan is performed, that is not how that works lmao
I’m sorry is it physically impossible for two people to watch a screen?
@@cajunking5987 I’ve never had a doctor in the scan room with me when performing scans, we as techs handle everything
bro murphy isnt even wrong.. why tf are kids even into this stuff tho- they shouldnt even know what this is....correct me if im wrong but i know im correct
You are correct.
This clip underscores and highlights just about everything wrong with the movement.
This is hilarious lmfao
why does he sound like he inhaled helium and then was hit on the head during this scene
Cancer does not care about your pronouns.
Dr. Based
>she
lmao
How could doctors assign gender? Do they come to a baby and say ''you must wear dresses and play with dolls'' or ''you must wear jeans and play with cars''?
I dont get this comment doctors have nothing to do with gender
@@majungasaurus6814, the second doctor said ''her assigned gender is not the one she identifies with'' so i wondered how on earth can doctors assign it
@@ВладСетонов assigned gender is referring to the sex? Male or female or intersex
@@ВладСетонов your child has a penis, it's a male, your child has a vagina it's a woman, o wow your child is a hermaphrodite that's weird that's how they do It
@@ВладСетонов I get you vlad, why is the doctor assigning the sec? but sometimes when people are intersex the doctor really does choose, but yeah it's assigned by nature
Common Dr Shawn Murphy W
What a fucking timeline we live in. 🤣🤣🤣
Tell me about it
Presenting facts to someone who lives in a fairytale. Sounds familiar
Funny how they picked a biological female for this role instead of a biological male.
She's literally trans lmao
Except they didn’t, Sophia Giannamore is transgender, but congratulations on proving you can’t “always tell”
@@SandwitchZebra That happens when you give children hormone blockers, which is broadly seen as morally reprehensible...
LMAOOOOO she’s not, hold the L
@@SandwitchZebra transgender people can still be biologically their birth assigned sex, pretty sure the gender part is where the feelings come in…since it’s infinite lmfao
Movie name
dr han saw him denying her trans identity and denied his vocational identity 💪😤💪😤🔥🔥
🔥
Ofc you troons would simp for the CCP guy lmao
@@sekaiyoru01 ?
RAHHHHHHH
@@sekaiyoru01 asian man = CCP?
“Guys, we’re not racist, I swear”
So much transphobia in the comments.
Shaun was acting very unprofessional in this scene.
Let me lay some things straight. Biological sex is important when discussing medical problems. So is mental health, as these two things are intrinsically connected.
While it is reasonable to treat the patient with the knowledge of her being biologically male, it is also important to maintain respect and good rapport with your patient. Shaun went over the line by not referring to her correctly, and especially went over the line by asking questions that are by no means necessary for a diagnosis, and only necessary for his own gain. And though this curiosity does come from lack of understanding, it is also very unprofessional to push this onto your patient, and should instead be addressed later via research and discussion with peers or even your boss.
His repeated disrespect of his patient's wishes is certainly warranted for discipline and in a real life setting, this would be means enough for a patient or her representatives to be talking to HR. Mental health is just as important as physical health. Gender dysphoria is a serious condition and should be treated with respect and delicacy, just as we do with physical illnesses like cancer or a broken leg.
And before you mention him being autistic. Yes, this is a factor for social difficulty. I am also autistic. We can learn things too, it just takes time. And sometimes this takes discipline.
Docter me fr
The thing that struck me the most about this storyline was how much of a spoiled brat that kid actually is written to be when mom and dad are around.
The Chad Doctor 🗿
Poor fellas just a bit confused
I am not a boy i am not a girl
I am a surgion
Now THIS is 100% Kosher Certified Slopaganda!
People are truly more worried about what people think about themselves than having self-respect, Boo Hoo someone called me she instead of he, I couldn't give any less shits if someone else called me a tractor because I like how I am.
Trans women aren't women
that sentence contradicts itself
@@williamplayzgames8 women don't have XY chromosomes
@@williamplayzgames8 no it doesnt, trans means fake
@@Hangedman11911 you missed my point "Trans *women* " (by saying trans women you are calling them women)
@@williamplayzgames8 this is an argument based off of semantics and proves nothing. u know what op was saying, ur just trying to make a "gotcha" lmao
Mam your balls are good sir
I am no longer on team Dr. Han.
What is the episode??
YWNBAW
his stomach was hurting, maybe he was having his period, not long then he is gonna ovulate and ready to have a baby... oh wait...
Based af
I’m going to play this scene at a gay bar
The best doctor
I thought it was She. But then I forgot they were trans. So it is He because they were born male.. but the actor looks FEMALE. so they are female.
Science says YWNBAW
This dude be like: I AM TRANSPHOBIC I AM TRANSPHOBIC DR HAN
Science doesn’t care about their feelings 🍷🗿
if science is 'transphobic' then imma be a transphobe
aint no way these comments where did i drop
@@thesnickerskittle you were expecting people from your echo chamber of delusion? You arent entitled to people agreeing with you.
It's the fact, which you deny
1:28 boom chackmate
Is this AI generated?
yes
wtf i love the good doctor now
Why is this posted like it's a new episode? It's not. At the end of the episode Shaun sees her as a girl (as it should be). Odd that this wasn't that long ago and feels outdated
no he's a guy, he has testicular cancer.
@@storm3rdsfg She has testicular cancer. Says in the episode
He can call himself whatever he wants while getting treatment for his balls cancer.
You mean he has testicular cancer 😂
@AlisonL520 he has testicular cancer, only men get testicular cancer. If you believe men can be woman, you must be smoking alot of pot
1:24 competition? Since when did it become a competition? Good doctor should take you to a mental institution.