Sorry for the weird jumpiness at the beginning... I had plugged our online site and due to recent RUclips policy, I had to edit that part out, which you just hear the tail end of. It looks like botched editing but its the best I could do without deleting the video and re-uploading it. Thanks for watching!
The nDLC is a Nitride treatment and then a Diamond Like Coating (DLC) over the nitride, which makes for a very durable finish. Nitride goes on Clear. Tenifer, Melonite, is simply a Nitride treatment that's trademarked due to proprietary blend. Also, Nitride is usually QPQ which is a Quench, Polish and then Quench again to provide that super slick feel to it. Nitride actually bonds at a molecular level with the substrate (outer most layer) of the metal. Nitride is not a coating or plating per se. It's a metal treatment that fuses with the outer layer of the metal...creating a very strong hard case equaling about 68-72 RHc...which is extremely hard. Both DLC and Nitride have been around for quite some time. However both are relatively new to being used in the firearms industry. Most companies who use Nitride (infusion of Nitrogen and Carbon) will Black Oxide over the Nitride due to the treatment goes on clear. Hope this helps some of you out.
@@rokaine7334 the 40 caliber Glocks have an increased likelihood of jamming if you mount a flashlight on the Generation 3 also there are issues with the ejector many times on even the 9 mmm. Also extraction is terrible because it'll fling brass towards your head even if you don't limp wrist sometimes. They're also not as accurate as generation 5 Barrel.
Why? Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
First I must say I you are an amazing speaker and kept my interest throughout this entire video. Thank you for your excellent comparison and explanation of the Glock generations. My comments are regarding the number of pins on Glocks. Let me add now that I am a Glock Armorer. Many years ago Glock made it known that the single block pin models in calibers higher than the 9mm, we're experiencing "stress difficulties " while there were little or no problems in 9mm. With that I believe they decided to add the 2nd block pin. So here now it is my belief that you won't be seeing the generation 5 in any other calibers than 9mm. I haven't read other commentary here yet because I didn't want to lose my thoughts. So forgive me if another has already explained the reasoning. Maybe it would be safer to say no other model gen 5 than 17 or 19 at this time. This is my best guess at Glocks tactics. Thanks for your time.
Yes Mike, that is what I am seeing as well. As an armorer myself, I can't tell you how many Glocks I have had to repair for locking block rebound impact issues. It causes the top of the block to be peened over by the bottom of the slide, and eventually causes malfunctions. All of this is caused and directly related to the lightweight frame itself, and the inability of the human wrist to completely control the muzzle flip, no matter how big or strong you think you are. It's pure physics. You would think all those brilliant engineers at Glock that copied the Keltec design and named it Glock, would have sense enough to see this. If the Glock were made with a metal frame, it would be a nice weapon. I have fun getting a rise out of all the Glock fans at the range when they show me their pistols. I say, "Nice Keltec you have there." ...It sends them off into fits. Ha ha.
Awesome review right to the main points that people need to know! I already have a Glock 17 Gen 4 but was looking for a 19 and I've done all my research with features and what I would get for my money and decided to go with the 19 gen 3!
Why? Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
@@jaytay7989 Just my opinion, I'm not comfortable with the grip on most current Poly grip Guns. When this is the case I'll wrestle on a Houge grip an be careful the rubberized grip does not catch my clothing during a draw, which is almost never an issue. I always depend on a firm, tight grip and never want a slippery Gun. Glad you brought up the issue.
Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
Wow! Opposite of my concern. Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
Luke William , what did you do, that’s my concern. Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
Great video! Very well-delivered narration, you held my interest all the way through. I love my Glock 19 gen 4 - I see that there's a ton of love for the gen 3 though. I've never owned a gen 3 so I can't comment.
..btw ...before I was educated with the differences in the Gens ...I simply asked the guy working the counter , who btw is the best salesman I've encountered... knowledgeable , no salesman babble or high pressure talk ....handed me the Gen 3 .... cheers
Generation 5 to me and alot of others is the best. It's the best looking and it has the match grade barrel, plus flared magwell. I believe it's gonna be the most reliable as well now they only improve and to me get better
David & Elizabeth..I hate my gen3 19 i changed out the extractor, ejector and recoil spring and still get BTF with erratic ejection..my gen4 in my opinion is much better.
Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
They guy at my gun shop said glocks are the AK of the hand gun world I’m looking at my first Glock ever! 19 gen 4. But damn it they have a S&W 39-2 my favorite auto gun so I but it on layaway I probably don’t need 3 of them but damn it I love that gun. I’m just enjoying the all the great options we still have and hopefully will always have! Great video sir
You know how to get a lighter trigger pull?......How about going out and firing hundreds upon hundreds of rounds through it? I guarantee the stock trigger on my gen 4 is smoother than the 5 right out of the box, just from shooting it.
Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
Daryl Ragland Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
The new barrel will give you better accuracy than the previous generations. Sounds like new golf equipment, shoot straighter and further than before with this new club just like your previous club claimed!
One more comment... the gen3 magazine release was very positive and easy to use. In Gen4, they make a big paddle of a release button. If you do not hit that button in the right place it does not work... so effectively it is much worse than the smaller gen3 button.
I prefer the gen 3 as well. The dual action spring, and guide rod is not an improvement. I dislike the dimpled trigger bar, not sure why it's a thing. I change them out. The ambi slide release is stupid, and doubles your chance of riding it, causing the slide to not lock back. Take down levers should be extended from the factory for ease of use. I do appreciate the bigger may button, but I still change them out to a quality steel part.. If I had my way, slides on new gens would have a universal optics cut that would accept a wider range of dot, not just RMR. Eliminate the polymer trigger shoe, widen that safe action button. I believe it would be more durable. Lastly, no more polymer sights, or guide rods. Steel please.
Jody Felland how does an ambi slide release double your chance to ride it? If youre shooting right handed, how in the hell do you ride the release on the right side?
Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
It really depends on how you grip the gun. I have occasionally put upward pressure on extended slide lock, causing the gun to lock open. I no longer use that part to prevent it.
I found in my rental range day, that in 9mm I found no feeling of more recoil with the gen 4 or 5. Basically I feel like there is more creature comforts added which are nice but for someone who wanted a basic gun with some added night sights the gen 3 was better for me. It was cheaper, I added the medium backstrap on newer gens any how, and if I ever decide I want to change anything, there are tons more options for gen 3 guns at this point. All three however are very good!
If it was perfect we would all have gen 1s. Gen 3 is as close as they could get.....but they refused to remove the finger groves. How difficult could it be to make a removable front strap with finger groves?..... Thats right the thing is perfect; that is why we upgrade the trigger, change the sights, shave off the finger grooves, sand down the back strap, cut slide serration in the slide....did I forget anything? Oh extended slide locks, re stippled grips and shave memory indexes(gas pedals) into the polymer......PS. dont forget your but plug on the way out. LMAO perfect. Its a good gun true, but if it needs that much upgrading then it aint perfect. If she needs that much plastic surgery to be attractive.....Just get a blow up doll. Definition of perfect 1 a :being entirely without fault or defect :flawless a perfect diamond b :satisfying all requirements
Dude its really not that deep! "Perfection" is an opinion. I was simply voicing an opinion, playing on their motto "glock perfection"! Opinions are like ass-holes, everyone has one!
Perfection is a state of being....its perfect...not an opinion. An opinion is "I think it is perfect". All and all I know its marketing deigned to create hype and brand loyalty. My opinion is it is the perfect canvas. You know; kind of like the canvas the Mona lisa was painted on. It wouldn't be shit with out the paint....kinda like Glocks and upgrades. LMAO 2ez; Im just trolling Glock fanboys right now, but I think I forgot 80% poly lowers with the 1911 grip angle and under cut trigger guards for the "perfect" gun to be perfect-er. If there is a state of more perfecter. Personally I get Glock knuckle from shooting the perfect guns. I know knuckles are for pussies but still I get it.
You have way to much time on your hands. I simply don't care what you think of my comment. I have been carrying Glocks for 20 years both for personal protection, and occupationally. 90% of Indiana's law enforcement carry them, if its good enough for them its good enough for me.
And I've been carrying a 1911 since 1912....if it was good enough for the great wars by gosh its good enough for me. Glock fanboys are too easy to troll. You do know I stopped trying after my first post. And obviously you have the same amount of free time as I. Calm down you are #triggered. Carry your glock bro...its a good gun....just aint perfect.
Mark Homiak I remember clearing my throat in disagreement at my armorers class. The notion that the polygonal rifling is supurbly accurate is a stretch for sure. Its easy to clean, cheaper, and faster to produce. And plenty accurate for service standards. I got the side eye from our instructor. He fucked with me in class. I got the last laugh at the shot show that year when he remembered me. I set him straight. I think he misspelled my name on my certificate to spite me.
I measured barrel walls and it’s definitely thicker on gen 5 than gen 4. I assume it’s should hold higher pressures and hotter rounds and less prone to kabooms.
Nice demo. I’m all In for my new Gen 5. I got plus 2 mags which functions best for my hand size. The slide finish and no finger groove plus other updates are worthwhile improvements over my gen 4, in my opinion. Glockenspiel y all.
I own a glock 19 ..gen 3 ..gen4 and now gen5...and THERE IS A DIFFERENCE IN the GEN 5 TRIGGER..its better..smoother...have currently put 400 rounds through my gen 5...after I get to 500 rounds without any issues will make it my EDC
Thanks for your input! Just feeling the trigger out of the box, I could not notice any obvious difference. Then again, I have only had this one Glock 19 in my hands... Also, I have not fired it, so with a few 100 rounds down range, the trigger may loosen and may ease into a cleaner break. I will reevaluate the trigger when I get some time behind it at the range. Thanks again for commenting!
being in MA we can only buy used Gen2 Glocks from dealers... although there are ways around that now... decided it's time to retire my 32 year old Gen2, and trying to decide on the 3, 4, or 5 i like the 2 pin frame, but i also like the finger grooves...... dammit.... i mean, the Gen2 G19 is the best Glock ever made, but it's older than the last woman i dated....
Nice video. One correction though, the use of lead bullets will not decrease your barrel life, in any gun, as opposed to full metal jacket or copper. Well done, thx.
I’m going to buy a glock my dealer has a gen 3 for 499 is that a good deal or should I buy the gen 5 wich one is better and will preform better see should I want till the come out with a new one? Like I’m confused 499 is cheap and I have that in cash and want to buy it but i don’t want to buy it and find out the game out with a better one are the gen 5 was way worth it
The first Glock 26s had a single guide rod = Gen 2.5, Also the 2nd locking block pin was for 40 S&W/357 SIG, So far the 5th gens are 9mm only = G17/G19,Finger grooves suck.. The larger magazine release is also fugly.. waiting for the Gen6
I have a full size Gen 3 ( as all my glocks are ) Mod 37 45-GAP, it has an odd finish, darker then all of my other gen 3's, also has that rounder nose that you usually see in the smaller glocks
Thanks for the video, I was looking for this. Also is the mag release the same size between the gen 4 and 5? The two pin system was originally meant for 9mm. They shifted to a three pin system to better handle the stress of .40 and .45. The M series FBI pistols which were the precursor to the gen 5 were built for solely for 9mm. The 19 MHS submission was for 9mm and .40 and they only used a two pin system so maybe they felt it wasn't necessary on their newer designs. As we all know everything we read on the internet is always true.
5:48... When those sights are off it sure is noticeable. I don't know anybody that leaves these plastic sights on. Everybody seems to change these first.
Yes, the GEN5 uses the same holster as the Gen5... lol, I think you may have meant to specify a different Gen glock, and unless you update that we can not answer your question.
I like the beveled mag well and the bevels on the front of the slide on the Gen 5, but man I could never get over how ugly that grip is. Gen 3 is so much better.
Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
@@jaytay7989 I have a Gen 3 19. I have handed it with wet and sweaty hands. The texture that is on it isn't a problem. Unless you are have a seizer while holding your gun, you'll be fine. I have put about 250 rounds though it, never had a problem of ejection issues. But, if you have then, you can change the extractor pretty easily. You can disassemble and re-assemble the entire slide in about 5 minutes
Can you put the Gen 4 spring in the Gen 3? At the 10 minute mark you said that you can put the Gen 5 spring in the Gen 4 but can you also switch it out with the Gen 3?
Ok so heres what Ive determined about who favors what generation of glock...if your from Commifornia, Gen 3 is the absolute best, If you like finger grooves, Iron sights, and crappy triggers but have mostly compatible parts with older generations, your a Gen 4 guy....If you Like Optic ready, DLC coated, front slide serrations and beveled slide for reholstering, with some new and improved parts and a pretty decent factory trigger your a Gen 5 advocate. Me personally? Im a generation 43x/ 48x MOS guy.... all other glocks are obsolete.....
Great video kris, answered a lot of questions but I do have one question I'm unsure of, maybe you or some viewers can also help. I have an opportunity to get a GEN 3 In excellent condition almost looks new. My question is should I hold out for a GEN 4 or a GEN 5?
John Sparks , why is a Gen 3 better? Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
The New guide rod spring are different from each other between the gen 5 and gen 4. he Gen 5 is a tad longer and has a different weight spring. Not backward compatible either. The trigger is improved at many points a total redesign. Check it out in detail you will discover a total new trigger.
At this point, I would buy gen3 or gen 4 and leave the five alone until it gets more time under its belt. I do think 2 pins are better then 1. I guess time will tell
Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
@@jaytay7989 no it’s not more reliable i have 2 Glock 19 gen 5’s and never once had a problem with jamming a lot of people say “gen3” because in the state they live in gen 3’s are the only Glocks allowed for multiple reasons
I shot today with a G17 Gen 5 and a G19 Gen 3, disregarding the length of the stock, I felt that the grip of the Gen 5 is a little smaller than the Gen 3, is that correct?
I'm currenty in the market for a G19. Thanks for this info. I tried a gen 4 and so, since I do not like the stippling on the gen 4 and 5, I'm going to need to find a gen 3. Are there any other options, since I don't like the needle feel of the gen 4/5? Thanks.
Wow, opposite of my concern. Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
@@jaytay7989 I do like the Hogue grips. I wound up buying a used G22 that I like. The glock grip is just on the edge of being too big/brick feeling for me, but the gun is solid. Shoots well. Almost as tight a group as my p320. I don't know about reliability or superior of the g19 or g22. I just know, for me, the gen 4/5 grips are like trying to grip a porcupine. I do really well with the gen 3 grips. If I could find an aftermarket grip for my g22 that was slightly smaller in the grip, I'd be one happy customer! Thanks!
Gen 3 .40 cals jam once you attach a flashlight. And Gen 3. 9mm's are known to throw brass at your face EVEN if you don't limp wrist. It'll require a modified ejector or extractor. So the 19 and 23 are ripe with issues in Gen 3. FAR from perfection. Gen 5 is the LEAST plagued with issues edition Glock on the market right now. They don't have these issues. Gen 3 sucks. Plus they ain't as accurate without that Marksman barrel. I've tested it to know myself.
so basically a new black color and no finger grooves, Perfection. nobody says on any review its more accurate,has a better trigger,lighter, nothing? i guess that why they didnt get the military contract because they handed them a off the shelf gun painted it tan
What about the G45? A consortium, generally made of gen 3,gen 4, and gen 5, parts, with a little bit of sugar and spice, luck, and scraps left after cleaning up the floors!! I'm still considering the G43... Or the 43x... Or the 48... If I can remember which frame and which slide combination works together!! Oh....never mind! I'm gonna stick with the M&P...SHIELD...2.0??? Do they use Glock mags, too?? Now, I'm confused!! In gonna have to spend my gun budget, on psychotherapy!!
Sorry for the weird jumpiness at the beginning... I had plugged our online site and due to recent RUclips policy, I had to edit that part out, which you just hear the tail end of. It looks like botched editing but its the best I could do without deleting the video and re-uploading it. Thanks for watching!
...no worries ...great informative video 👍
great vid. fuck youtube
The nDLC is a Nitride treatment and then a Diamond Like Coating (DLC) over the nitride, which makes for a very durable finish. Nitride goes on Clear. Tenifer, Melonite, is simply a Nitride treatment that's trademarked due to proprietary blend. Also, Nitride is usually QPQ which is a Quench, Polish and then Quench again to provide that super slick feel to it. Nitride actually bonds at a molecular level with the substrate (outer most layer) of the metal. Nitride is not a coating or plating per se. It's a metal treatment that fuses with the outer layer of the metal...creating a very strong hard case equaling about 68-72 RHc...which is extremely hard. Both DLC and Nitride have been around for quite some time. However both are relatively new to being used in the firearms industry. Most companies who use Nitride (infusion of Nitrogen and Carbon) will Black Oxide over the Nitride due to the treatment goes on clear. Hope this helps some of you out.
This comment is for my Gen 3 lovers only! Glock Gen 3 all day EVERY day!!!
Gen 3 has the most issues out of them all.
@@InfuzeDcyphR first time ever hearing that claim
Gen 3 is the best they dont make em like that no more I love my g19 gen 3 more then any other one of my guns
@@InfuzeDcyphR are you a downy ?
@@rokaine7334 the 40 caliber Glocks have an increased likelihood of jamming if you mount a flashlight on the Generation 3 also there are issues with the ejector many times on even the 9 mmm. Also extraction is terrible because it'll fling brass towards your head even if you don't limp wrist sometimes. They're also not as accurate as generation 5 Barrel.
Gen 3 is and probably will allways be my favorite
Why? Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
Still carry my GEN 2 G17 daily. Added a SS guide rod, but other than that...all stock and still 100%.
First I must say I you are an amazing speaker and kept my interest throughout this entire video. Thank you for your excellent comparison and explanation of the Glock generations.
My comments are regarding the number of pins on Glocks. Let me add now that I am a Glock Armorer. Many years ago Glock made it known that the single block pin models in calibers higher than the 9mm, we're experiencing "stress difficulties " while there were little or no problems in 9mm. With that I believe they decided to add the 2nd block pin. So here now it is my belief that you won't be seeing the generation 5 in any other calibers than 9mm. I haven't read other commentary here yet because I didn't want to lose my thoughts. So forgive me if another has already explained the reasoning. Maybe it would be safer to say no other model gen 5 than 17 or 19 at this time. This is my best guess at Glocks tactics. Thanks for your time.
Yes Mike, that is what I am seeing as well. As an armorer myself, I can't tell you how many Glocks I have had to repair for locking block rebound impact issues. It causes the top of the block to be peened over by the bottom of the slide, and eventually causes malfunctions. All of this is caused and directly related to the lightweight frame itself, and the inability of the human wrist to completely control the muzzle flip, no matter how big or strong you think you are. It's pure physics. You would think all those brilliant engineers at Glock that copied the Keltec design and named it Glock, would have sense enough to see this. If the Glock were made with a metal frame, it would be a nice weapon. I have fun getting a rise out of all the Glock fans at the range when they show me their pistols. I say, "Nice Keltec you have there." ...It sends them off into fits. Ha ha.
I'd be interested to hear your thoughts now that the Gen 5 is offered in other calibers.
My friend has a Sigmatism and I have Glockoma.
W
this comment deserves sm more likes 😂
Fascinating
I see what you did there... 🤭
Oh and my favorite Glock...hands down...Larry vickers glock 19 FDE GEN 3!!
Awesome review right to the main points that people need to know! I already have a Glock 17 Gen 4 but was looking for a 19 and I've done all my research with features and what I would get for my money and decided to go with the 19 gen 3!
Why? Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
@@jaytay7989 Just my opinion, I'm not comfortable with the grip on most current Poly grip Guns. When this is the case I'll wrestle on a Houge grip an be careful the rubberized grip does not catch my clothing during a draw, which is almost never an issue. I always depend on a firm, tight grip and never want a slippery Gun. Glad you brought up the issue.
Being a southpaw, I like the ambi slide release on the gen5. I'm looking at the MOS.
I'm thinking of getting the Gen 5 since I'm a lefty, what do you guys think? since I see a lot of Gen 3 fans
Kosem72 I just realized I can't get a gen 4 or 5 in California, unless I buy it from an officer. I might just go with a Gen 3
Thanks to you I know what Gen my Glock 19 is. Mine didn't say gen on the slide. My Glock 19 9mm is a Generation 3. Woohoo! Thanks!
Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
I have a gen 3, love, love, love this gun!!!!!
Your best video yet. Great job on the trigger comparison. Keep up the great work
Glock 19s = Toyota Tacoma’s = reliable
This was more informative and helpful than I thought it would be. Great stuff!!
The aggressive texturing the on gen 4s killed glocks for me. They need to offer a smoother frame option like the gen 2. I’m happy with my gen 3.
Why do you want a slippery grip? I only have a Gen 3 but it is too slippery for me.
I don't like how the gen 3 grip looks. I prefer the grip of the gen 4/5's
Wow! Opposite of my concern. Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
Luke William , what did you do, that’s my concern. Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
Great video! Very well-delivered narration, you held my interest all the way through. I love my Glock 19 gen 4 - I see that there's a ton of love for the gen 3 though. I've never owned a gen 3 so I can't comment.
Too many problems with the gn4 they discontinued it
..btw ...before I was educated with the differences in the Gens ...I simply asked the guy working the counter , who btw is the best salesman I've encountered... knowledgeable , no salesman babble or high pressure talk ....handed me the Gen 3 .... cheers
The follower doesn't really help as the brass shows through the witness holes on the mag anyway
they dont always line up. so at quick glance the orange is easier to know for sure.
Generation 5 to me and alot of others is the best. It's the best looking and it has the match grade barrel, plus flared magwell. I believe it's gonna be the most reliable as well now they only improve and to me get better
He got the first made Gen 5 19 the slides different from the one's now the slides now have the lines front and back!
@@corythegoat2745slide serrations.
Well done, sir! Gen 3 for life.
David & Elizabeth YES!
David & Elizabeth..I hate my gen3 19 i changed out the extractor, ejector and recoil spring and still get BTF with erratic ejection..my gen4 in my opinion is much better.
Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
@@jaytay7989 if you can find a Gen5 trust me get the Gen 5 it's literally better in every way.
BigBossCSM , thank you. When I get stationed in Texas again, I’ll get a Gen 5.
The squareness of the older glocks is a lot more appealing. The less wide 5th gen isn't as good looking.
They guy at my gun shop said glocks are the AK of the hand gun world
I’m looking at my first Glock ever! 19 gen 4.
But damn it they have a S&W 39-2 my favorite auto gun so I but it on layaway I probably don’t need 3 of them but damn it I love that gun.
I’m just enjoying the all the great options we still have and hopefully will always have!
Great video sir
I have G19s in Gen2, Gen3-RTF2, & Gen5-MOS w/RMR. Great guns. Very informative video. Thank you
My local firearm dealer told me that the Gen 3’s typically sell more than the Gen 5’s.
I agree; the Gen 1-3 are the ones that put Glock on the map...
You know how to get a lighter trigger pull?......How about going out and firing hundreds upon hundreds of rounds through it? I guarantee the stock trigger on my gen 4 is smoother than the 5 right out of the box, just from shooting it.
Gen 5 when back to a gen 2 grip....using the gen 3 trigger and a gen 4 recoil spring....gen 3 is king of glocks....
Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
Daryl Ragland Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
Glock 3 groves feel so grippy in my hands back kinda hippy but I’ll take it for front grip recoil I’m thinking for wide back
The new barrel will give you better accuracy than the previous generations. Sounds like new golf equipment, shoot straighter and further than before with this new club just like your previous club claimed!
I still roll with the gen3
I have a G17 gen 1 that I've had for 25 years. I LOVE the thing. I saw no reason to buy any other.
If you really have a gen 1 Glock, you can sell it and buy like 20 new glocks
Gen 3 is my preference the grip and the aiming pointe is excellent
One more comment... the gen3 magazine release was very positive and easy to use. In Gen4, they make a big paddle of a release button. If you do not hit that button in the right place it does not work... so effectively it is much worse than the smaller gen3 button.
Why does your Gen 5 not have the serrations on the front of the barrel? I’ve never seen it without those in stores???
I prefer the gen 3 as well. The dual action spring, and guide rod is not an improvement. I dislike the dimpled trigger bar, not sure why it's a thing. I change them out. The ambi slide release is stupid, and doubles your chance of riding it, causing the slide to not lock back. Take down levers should be extended from the factory for ease of use. I do appreciate the bigger may button, but I still change them out to a quality steel part..
If I had my way, slides on new gens would have a universal optics cut that would accept a wider range of dot, not just RMR. Eliminate the polymer trigger shoe, widen that safe action button. I believe it would be more durable. Lastly, no more polymer sights, or guide rods. Steel please.
Jody Felland how does an ambi slide release double your chance to ride it? If youre shooting right handed, how in the hell do you ride the release on the right side?
Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
It really depends on how you grip the gun. I have occasionally put upward pressure on extended slide lock, causing the gun to lock open. I no longer use that part to prevent it.
@@jaytay7989 gen5 are still good. Just not an improvement as such. Your mileage may vary.
I found in my rental range day, that in 9mm I found no feeling of more recoil with the gen 4 or 5. Basically I feel like there is more creature comforts added which are nice but for someone who wanted a basic gun with some added night sights the gen 3 was better for me. It was cheaper, I added the medium backstrap on newer gens any how, and if I ever decide I want to change anything, there are tons more options for gen 3 guns at this point. All three however are very good!
We aren’t allowed to have Gen 4 and Gen 5 here in California so the only Glock that I am familiar with is the GEN 3. I love my Gen 3 G19.
I thought California was America….?
HEHEHEHEHEHEHE 🇺🇲 🇺🇲 🇺🇲 🇺🇲 🇺🇲. OLE COMMIEFORNIA
Why no drastic change between the generations? It is simply not possible to improve on perfection!
If it was perfect we would all have gen 1s. Gen 3 is as close as they could get.....but they refused to remove the finger groves. How difficult could it be to make a removable front strap with finger groves?.....
Thats right the thing is perfect; that is why we upgrade the trigger, change the sights, shave off the finger grooves, sand down the back strap, cut slide serration in the slide....did I forget anything? Oh extended slide locks, re stippled grips and shave memory indexes(gas pedals) into the polymer......PS. dont forget your but plug on the way out. LMAO perfect.
Its a good gun true, but if it needs that much upgrading then it aint perfect. If she needs that much plastic surgery to be attractive.....Just get a blow up doll.
Definition of perfect
1 a :being entirely without fault or defect :flawless a perfect diamond
b :satisfying all requirements
Dude its really not that deep! "Perfection" is an opinion. I was simply voicing an opinion, playing on their motto "glock perfection"! Opinions are like ass-holes, everyone has one!
Perfection is a state of being....its perfect...not an opinion. An opinion is "I think it is perfect". All and all I know its marketing deigned to create hype and brand loyalty. My opinion is it is the perfect canvas. You know; kind of like the canvas the Mona lisa was painted on. It wouldn't be shit with out the paint....kinda like Glocks and upgrades.
LMAO 2ez; Im just trolling Glock fanboys right now, but I think I forgot 80% poly lowers with the 1911 grip angle and under cut trigger guards for the "perfect" gun to be perfect-er. If there is a state of more perfecter. Personally I get Glock knuckle from shooting the perfect guns. I know knuckles are for pussies but still I get it.
You have way to much time on your hands. I simply don't care what you think of my comment. I have been carrying Glocks for 20 years both for personal protection, and occupationally. 90% of Indiana's law enforcement carry them, if its good enough for them its good enough for me.
And I've been carrying a 1911 since 1912....if it was good enough for the great wars by gosh its good enough for me. Glock fanboys are too easy to troll. You do know I stopped trying after my first post. And obviously you have the same amount of free time as I. Calm down you are #triggered. Carry your glock bro...its a good gun....just aint perfect.
DLC is in fact an ion bond. I use to a company that does this type of coating.
Man, Glock really has consumers snowballed. A hexagon IS a polygon! 😂🤣
Mark Homiak I remember clearing my throat in disagreement at my armorers class. The notion that the polygonal rifling is supurbly accurate is a stretch for sure. Its easy to clean, cheaper, and faster to produce. And plenty accurate for service standards. I got the side eye from our instructor. He fucked with me in class. I got the last laugh at the shot show that year when he remembered me. I set him straight. I think he misspelled my name on my certificate to spite me.
They should say lands and grooves
Great job . Well done . Keeps up the good work . Thanks a lot. SC vet.
Thanks for this great comparison!!
This Week I Go to buy 2 gun,the Glock 19 gen 4 and the Sig Sauer p365 9mm color gray and like coyote color,I can't wait for it!
I measured barrel walls and it’s definitely thicker on gen 5 than gen 4. I assume it’s should hold higher pressures and hotter rounds and less prone to kabooms.
Nice demo. I’m all In for my new Gen 5. I got plus 2 mags which functions best for my hand size.
The slide finish and no finger groove plus other updates are worthwhile improvements over my gen 4, in my opinion.
Glockenspiel y all.
Ionbond is a brand, dlc is diamond like coating. As far as i understand. What the N stands for idk yet
I own a glock 19 ..gen 3 ..gen4 and now gen5...and THERE IS A DIFFERENCE IN the GEN 5 TRIGGER..its better..smoother...have currently put 400 rounds through my gen 5...after I get to 500 rounds without any issues will make it my EDC
Thanks for your input! Just feeling the trigger out of the box, I could not notice any obvious difference. Then again, I have only had this one Glock 19 in my hands... Also, I have not fired it, so with a few 100 rounds down range, the trigger may loosen and may ease into a cleaner break. I will reevaluate the trigger when I get some time behind it at the range. Thanks again for commenting!
MarksmanTV new trigger lighter but squishy and no wall.
being in MA we can only buy used Gen2 Glocks from dealers... although there are ways around that now...
decided it's time to retire my 32 year old Gen2, and trying to decide on the 3, 4, or 5
i like the 2 pin frame, but i also like the finger grooves...... dammit....
i mean, the Gen2 G19 is the best Glock ever made, but it's older than the last woman i dated....
Didn't mention the round cut out in the bottom of the grip below your pinky finger in the front section of a Magwell. What's that about.
Nice video. One correction though, the use of lead bullets will not decrease your barrel life, in any gun, as opposed to full metal jacket or copper. Well done, thx.
Best GLOCK gens 1.2.3! Best Glock ever glock 22 gen 3 hands down!
I like how you named the 22 when its a Lil son compared to the 10mm
I’m going to buy a glock my dealer has a gen 3 for 499 is that a good deal or should I buy the gen 5 wich one is better and will preform better see should I want till the come out with a new one? Like I’m confused 499 is cheap and I have that in cash and want to buy it but i don’t want to buy it and find out the game out with a better one are the gen 5 was way worth it
Looking into buying my first gun.. this was a great video, thank you.. definitely had to subscribe
Thanks for watching and subbing. I am glad this video helped you out!
The first Glock 26s had a single guide rod = Gen 2.5, Also the 2nd locking block pin was for 40 S&W/357 SIG, So far the 5th gens are 9mm only = G17/G19,Finger grooves suck.. The larger magazine release is also fugly.. waiting for the Gen6
Ridiculous thought process
I have a full size Gen 3 ( as all my glocks are ) Mod 37 45-GAP, it has an odd finish, darker then all of my other gen 3's, also has that rounder nose that you usually see in the smaller glocks
Gen 3. Discussion complete. Return to duty.
Thanks for the video, I was looking for this. Also is the mag release the same size between the gen 4 and 5? The two pin system was originally meant for 9mm. They shifted to a three pin system to better handle the stress of .40 and .45. The M series FBI pistols which were the precursor to the gen 5 were built for solely for 9mm. The 19 MHS submission was for 9mm and .40 and they only used a two pin system so maybe they felt it wasn't necessary on their newer designs. As we all know everything we read on the internet is always true.
I would love a gen 4 lower and a gen 5 slide and I would be stoked
Great video easy to watch
I hear the new Gen 6 will come with a virus protection mask in the grip
For Gen 6 we’re gonna need Gen 4 features plus the angled front slide and ambi slide release of the Gen 5
Smiley Sixguns I
5:48... When those sights are off it sure is noticeable. I don't know anybody that leaves these plastic sights on. Everybody seems to change these first.
Thank you for the video quick question does the GEN5 use the same holster as the Gen5?
Yes, the GEN5 uses the same holster as the Gen5... lol, I think you may have meant to specify a different Gen glock, and unless you update that we can not answer your question.
I like the beveled mag well and the bevels on the front of the slide on the Gen 5, but man I could never get over how ugly that grip is. Gen 3 is so much better.
Gen3!!!
Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
@@jaytay7989 I have a Gen 3 19. I have handed it with wet and sweaty hands. The texture that is on it isn't a problem. Unless you are have a seizer while holding your gun, you'll be fine. I have put about 250 rounds though it, never had a problem of ejection issues. But, if you have then, you can change the extractor pretty easily. You can disassemble and re-assemble the entire slide in about 5 minutes
My glock 19 gen 5 came with front and rear slide serrations and ameriglo agen night sights.
DLC is diamond like carbon
I wanted to know if mine was a gen 3 or gen 2; not much help because it was about gen 4 and gen 5. Put that as your title and save us time; thanks.
Can you put the Gen 4 spring in the Gen 3? At the 10 minute mark you said that you can put the Gen 5 spring in the Gen 4 but can you also switch it out with the Gen 3?
Ok so heres what Ive determined about who favors what generation of glock...if your from Commifornia, Gen 3 is the absolute best, If you like finger grooves, Iron sights, and crappy triggers but have mostly compatible parts with older generations, your a Gen 4 guy....If you Like Optic ready, DLC coated, front slide serrations and beveled slide for reholstering, with some new and improved parts and a pretty decent factory trigger your a Gen 5 advocate. Me personally? Im a generation 43x/ 48x MOS guy.... all other glocks are obsolete.....
Two-thirds of your comment is correct but I'm a 26 and a 19 person myself. Comment was spot on tho lol
Great video kris, answered a lot of questions but I do have one question I'm unsure of, maybe you or some viewers can also help. I have an opportunity to get a GEN 3 In excellent condition almost looks new. My question is should I hold out for a GEN 4 or a GEN 5?
Get the Gen 3. It's better and saves you money.
John Sparks , why is a Gen 3 better? Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
@@jaytay7989 lmaooooo why is this comment every where 🤣
The New guide rod spring are different from each other between the gen 5 and gen 4. he Gen 5 is a tad longer and has a different weight spring. Not backward compatible either. The trigger is improved at many points a total redesign. Check it out in detail you will discover a total new trigger.
ALBERT E MOOTS JR I hear it's same for Glock 19 4 and 5 but different for 17 gen 4 and 5. Can u confirm this please?
ALBERT E MOOTS JR How about barrels? Are Gen3 G19 barrels compatible with gen5?
At this point, I would buy gen3 or gen 4 and leave the five alone until it gets more time under its belt. I do think 2 pins are better then 1. I guess time will tell
Dick Trickle I think 3 pins is better than 2
Why that slide different because they upgraded the Gen 5 from the one in video the upgrade is Gen 5 fs way better than the one in video!
Only gen 3 while mess with perfection.
Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
@@jaytay7989 no it’s not more reliable i have 2 Glock 19 gen 5’s and never once had a problem with jamming a lot of people say “gen3” because in the state they live in gen 3’s are the only Glocks allowed for multiple reasons
Excelent video, thanks
I shot today with a G17 Gen 5 and a G19 Gen 3, disregarding the length of the stock, I felt that the grip of the Gen 5 is a little smaller than the Gen 3, is that correct?
I'm currenty in the market for a G19. Thanks for this info. I tried a gen 4 and so, since I do not like the stippling on the gen 4 and 5, I'm going to need to find a gen 3. Are there any other options, since I don't like the needle feel of the gen 4/5? Thanks.
Wow, opposite of my concern. Is the Gen 3, more reliable or more superior? My ONLY concern with the Gen 3 is the grip and lack of texture that the Gen 4s have. I refuse to use talon grips. I’ll have to use as is or with a Hogue grip. I’m not worried about a dual recoil spring for a 9mm. I’ve never heard of ejection issues with a Gen 3.
@@jaytay7989 I do like the Hogue grips. I wound up buying a used G22 that I like. The glock grip is just on the edge of being too big/brick feeling for me, but the gun is solid. Shoots well. Almost as tight a group as my p320. I don't know about reliability or superior of the g19 or g22. I just know, for me, the gen 4/5 grips are like trying to grip a porcupine. I do really well with the gen 3 grips. If I could find an aftermarket grip for my g22 that was slightly smaller in the grip, I'd be one happy customer! Thanks!
Just bought a gen 3.
Would love the beaver tailed Gen 4 back straps on my Gen 3
Will the gen 5 barrel fit in a gen 3 slide and frame?
The barrel will but the spring isnt interchangeable. I asked the same question at the gun store last week and the dude tried it for me.
Is there a difference in the color and finish between the Gen 4 and Gen 5? Tell me again because you only mentioned it 1000 times.
Are the dual guide rods steel? I know the older single were plastic. I broke one
No still polymer
Gen 3 .40 cals jam once you attach a flashlight. And Gen 3. 9mm's are known to throw brass at your face EVEN if you don't limp wrist. It'll require a modified ejector or extractor. So the 19 and 23 are ripe with issues in Gen 3. FAR from perfection. Gen 5 is the LEAST plagued with issues edition Glock on the market right now. They don't have these issues. Gen 3 sucks. Plus they ain't as accurate without that Marksman barrel. I've tested it to know myself.
G34gen5, changed slide lock spring. That's only part I find I don't like. Perfer the gen3 slide lock spring.
My question is, do some of these interchangeable between the models
GEN 3 IS KING
My G30 has the finger grips of the Gen 3, but doesn't have the rail. What's up with that?
Love my gen 4
Of course sir
Are the gen 4 & 5 back straps identical?
...WELL DONE!!!
Thanks for watching!
There is no beating Gen2, yes I wish it had rail but it wasn't invented yet.
i have been looking for a gen 2 22c for forever... im beginning to lose hope.
Gen 4 & 3 Grips are better.
I live in Indiana whats the price for a gen 5
Barrel also has a crown on it.
So I bought a brand new gen 3 in 2021
Great choice
so basically a new black color and no finger grooves, Perfection. nobody says on any review its more accurate,has a better trigger,lighter, nothing? i guess that why they didnt get the military contract because they handed them a off the shelf gun painted it tan
Are they happy with Sig. No
Hey, you should put your website in the about section of your channel
why that Ggen 5 doesn't have serrations
What about the G45? A consortium, generally made of gen 3,gen 4, and gen 5, parts, with a little bit of sugar and spice, luck, and scraps left after cleaning up the floors!!
I'm still considering the G43... Or the 43x... Or the 48... If I can remember which frame and which slide combination works together!! Oh....never mind! I'm gonna stick with the M&P...SHIELD...2.0??? Do they use Glock mags, too??
Now, I'm confused!! In gonna have to spend my gun budget, on psychotherapy!!