Stephen Hawking & Philosophy is Dead Jurisdiction - God's Not Dead movie

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024

Комментарии • 108

  • @ontmaskeraar6978
    @ontmaskeraar6978 6 лет назад +35

    steven hawking: philosophy is dead
    Philosophy: NO U

  • @hammeringhank5271
    @hammeringhank5271 7 лет назад +39

    So a philosophy professor made an appeal to authority. Lol. Wot?

  • @robtierney5653
    @robtierney5653 2 года назад +7

    "Philosophy is dead, " Is a common quote used by scientists to suggest that the discipline of philosophy is inferior to the modern scientific method. This doesn't imply that philosophy is useless. On the contrary, it helps expand the thinking box, but it doesn't always equate to designing the better box. If you want to become a chemical engineer, it doesn't hurt to take a philosophy course, but it's not enough to rise to the top of any field. It's just a tool.

    • @ShivamSharma-ob8ix
      @ShivamSharma-ob8ix 7 месяцев назад +1

      Philosophy can oftentimes make the individual question some fundamental truths which are a framework of thoughts developed over a long period of studying and practice; thus, instead of just relying upon them and getting scientific jobs done, it will induce unnecessary cognitive load and confusion.

  • @abigailc9062
    @abigailc9062 3 года назад +8

    God adds a day every day u don’t know if it will end tomorrow only god. So tomorrow is a extra day he adds on

  • @jessemeade9176
    @jessemeade9176 3 года назад +20

    God is awesome!!!

    • @riverc.820
      @riverc.820 2 года назад

      Sure, but this movie is Unholy. School is nothing like this...and lying like this is a Sin.

  • @simonriley8597
    @simonriley8597 5 лет назад +11

    You know if any of you is gonna comment about something
    Dont make as tho you are belittling the other party
    God gave us free wil so, so beat it
    Science said freedom is for every person so, so beat it
    Just respect each others opinions and dont offend them
    Then we can all live a very happy life

    • @I_am-satisfied.
      @I_am-satisfied. 3 года назад +2

      I couldn’t agree more, spot on🤗

    • @andrewmoreno3707
      @andrewmoreno3707 Год назад +1

      only Jesus can give u a TRUE happy life. Go to Him! He’s waiting for you! Before it’s too late! ❤

    • @andrewmoreno3707
      @andrewmoreno3707 Год назад +1

      @@I_am-satisfied. Only Jesus can give u a TRUE happy life. Go to Him! He’s waiting for you! Before it’s too late!

  • @SMALLENGINECAMS
    @SMALLENGINECAMS 4 года назад +5

    Jesus is alive beleve in the God that made you and the universe “he has no beginning or ending”

    • @thomasfuentes2913
      @thomasfuentes2913 Год назад +1

      @powerfulpower9 sometimes we dont need evidence to proof he exists we just need to have faith that he's there and does exists thata all he wants us to do is to trust and believe that he's real believe me i know cause i felt his presence and i cried so hard to know deep down he gave his life up for me on the to be free from the sins of the enemy and there has been no other love i ever felt before in my life for before i met God i had no social life i struggled with my autism growing up and didnt had any friends i grown up in Christian household but i never had a relationship with God cause with the struggles i was dealing growing up i even hated myself wondering why people bullied me cause i was different thank the Lord almighty ge brought me to him and put people in my life to help me through my struggles thanks to the Lord almighty he changed my life he gave me friends that used to bullied me and have gave themselves to him and they are the bestest friends i ever if itbwasnt for God i would be nothing thank to him he gave me a social life😊

  • @nemom225
    @nemom225 6 лет назад +11

    Steven Hawking was a brilliant and talented person in the field of science. Sadly he has passed away yesterday. I would just like to say that he has truly made an impact on this world and will be missed.

  • @allanwright5231
    @allanwright5231 4 года назад +5

    How can a universe create itself?

    • @josephsack4918
      @josephsack4918 4 года назад +2

      It can't. black holes inside the universe can create something, but it all leads back to a beginning.

    • @pierre0227
      @pierre0227 3 года назад +1

      And if it did create itself how would the process know when or where to stop?

    • @pierre0227
      @pierre0227 3 года назад +1

      @@rickydickydingdong7570 enough with the stupid comments.

    • @greasycheese8095
      @greasycheese8095 3 года назад

      @@pierre0227 the universe is eternal, despite their studies, yes the expansion of the universe implies a point of beginning, but lately we have noticed the speed of expansion slowing down, to the point that in billions and billions of years the universe will collapse onto itself, the resulting explosion will launch itself into a new "big bang" and start again

  • @princesslulu5795
    @princesslulu5795 6 лет назад +7

    I would suggest to anyone who doesn’t buy this argument rewatch the movie with subtitles take some notes from the debates in particular, then review the sources on your own and make your own decision. Don’t be so quick to dismiss an argument based on preconceived notions

    • @myvidaloka
      @myvidaloka 3 года назад +2

      There’s evidence everywhere that there’s a creator. It’s like we’re living in a box. And God is outside that box.

    • @riverc.820
      @riverc.820 2 года назад +1

      These arguments are dishonest though. The entire film is dishonest. Yes, this means we can ignore the arguments.

    • @None-if3mo
      @None-if3mo Год назад +1

      ​​@@riverc.820what do you mean dishonest? What define dishonest or not? Dismissing others argument just because you don't like it is basically the same as confirmation bias. Philosophy is about thought, question. If anything you can't really consider arguments as dishonest just because you don't like it. If the arguments are wrong then prove it, don't just label it as "dishonest" because that's basically againts the core of philosophy and science. Philosophy and Science are about finding answer through research, discussion.

  • @karlthomson7194
    @karlthomson7194 7 лет назад +18

    atheists got butthurt

    • @acemachine26
      @acemachine26 7 лет назад +19

      Funny and ironic coming from a christian. I thought altar boys were the ones that were butthurt after the priests were done with them.

    • @hammeringhank5271
      @hammeringhank5271 7 лет назад +3

      All the Christian comments in here would suggest the opposite, unless butthurt is code of "making arguments I can't handle, so I'm just going to insult them." In that case you might have a point

    • @TheHealthConscounist
      @TheHealthConscounist 6 лет назад

      Karl Thomson not a tiny bit. I actually get encouraged when I'm faced with challenging thoughts of my beliefs, while with theists, it is a completely different story

    • @craxnor
      @craxnor 6 лет назад +1

      Atheist facepalm from the stupidity

    • @mr.g3642
      @mr.g3642 5 лет назад +1

      Im athiest and i just laugh at your stupidty of your imaginary friend lol

  • @ShivamSharma-ob8ix
    @ShivamSharma-ob8ix 7 месяцев назад

    Universe needed to exists? Does universe have personal values and feelings like us? I believe the mapping of thoughts to the existence or formation of the universe is inconsistent as the gentleman is thinking as per human instincts.

  • @craxnor
    @craxnor 6 лет назад +5

    You can't disprove science and then use science as proof.

    • @craxnor
      @craxnor 6 лет назад

      Anthony Gold their belief in any theism holds no basis to their actual work. I won’t deny that fact that theist did bring forth the great leaps in science, Newton to name one.
      No belief is beholden to the existence of science. Science and it’s laws are indomitable with or without a deity. As long as individuals and scientist research and discover new realities of existence, as long as they are not looking to prove they are right, then that is enough.

    • @craxnor
      @craxnor 6 лет назад +1

      Anthony Gold 1. Stephen hawking, formerly smartest man on the planet, whose breakthrough with black holes allowed for the general acceptance of the Big Bang theory
      2. Alan Turing. Founder of computer science and the artificial intelligence
      3. Rosalind Franklin who discovered DNA and the double helix structure
      4. Neil degrasse Tyson who revamped our measurement of the universe
      5. Thomas Edison, though that credit goes more towards Nikolai Tesla, but both were atheist who made breakthroughs with electricity.
      And again faith in any being does not relate to scientific achievement. It just so happens that those affiliated with the church at those time were gravity and the Big Bang theory were theorized, those with connection to the church had the funding and reading material they needed to do so.
      Also I once saw this experiment where they made a vacuum and nothing filled it because it was a vacuum and. Next time you make an example give the link or name of the experiment.
      The universe makes itself, thank you Stephen hawking, and there is no proof no matter how much you show how neat everything in the universe is that there is a higher power. The only source of reference besides, hey this looks too neat, is a book written hundreds of years ago by people who thought the sky was a bowl.

    • @craxnor
      @craxnor 6 лет назад +1

      Anthony Gold even with all of that you still don’t provide proof that there is an originator. Your own argument refutes itself. What created everything? The creator. Who created him? Nothing. Then how did a creator come from nothing if the universe itself didn’t? If the house wasn’t built without the builder then who made the builder in the first place?
      Also Lennox didn’t debunk anything. He made a caltrop argument that didn’t address the question and dismissed it. And when asked to defend his point he argues that he doesn’t have to.
      Never argued that Christians made great strides into science. I said that their faith didn’t matter to science as a whole. Also black holes are a visible and real thing. That you say that nobody has proven that they exist is actually really weird.
      Another quick note the laws of the universe is simply a title that we gave in order to better understand the parts of the universe that are seen over and over again. We didn’t make or give the laws the universe itself developed and the laws are a byproduct of the universe in function.

    • @craxnor
      @craxnor 6 лет назад +1

      Anthony Gold besides the fact that astronomers have been observing them for decades. They are a paradoxical existence because the theory of relativity claims that their existence is impossible but it still exist.
      They go against everything we know but since we can see and quantify them they exist.
      blackholes.stardate.org/objects/type-supermassive.html

  • @tnvol2011
    @tnvol2011 6 месяцев назад +1

    “Philosophy is dead and if Philosophy is dead, then there is no need for this class!” One of the greatest comebacks ever spoken by a freshman haha

  • @rileyclements5139
    @rileyclements5139 4 года назад +8

    The flaw in Josh’s logic is Stephen Hawking is an authority on Physics, but not Philosophy. I don’t go to my neurologist asking about stomach cramps. You can disagree with one argument, and agree with
    another argument. If someone says “vegetarianism is good for the environment, because we need farting cows” I can agree with the conclusion but disagree with the reasoning

  • @Patrick-jm3sp
    @Patrick-jm3sp 6 лет назад +1

    You all need to go see Dr. Strange, immediately. The main character? That's you.

  • @BeatleLoverification
    @BeatleLoverification 3 года назад +1

    Oh snap!!

  • @Patrick-jm3sp
    @Patrick-jm3sp 6 лет назад

    Everything that makes tangible things attractive is intangible - think about it. Let's say you go rent a movie - are you mathematically satisfied because you found a disc that is 3.5 inches in diameter that allows you to store replayable video footage in a scientifically "efficient" manner or are you simply "psyched" that you get to see Iron Man kick some ass or something? Are the atheist or the religious trying to proove their point because that is the mathematically correct thing to do or are they doing it because they WANT to do it? In other words, because they WANT God to exist or WANT the big bang theory to be accurate. Since we're oh so convinced that the big bang theory is not a theory, why is it called a theory? Show me the proof.

    • @Daniel-cz7kd
      @Daniel-cz7kd 4 года назад

      Hello 👋 Patrik Craine, interesting reply and logic. You are right, the average person will get excited or as you put it “psyched” when they see an action of bodily injury performed by two or more actors on a plastic disc meant to replay images on a machine aka t.v. 🖥, more than they would to understand the mathematics 🧮 and the engineering that it took to actually make all these things capable for them to actually watch them in the first place. As for the theist and atheist, the atheist either wants the Big Bang to be true or just there to be no god, religious is just another word for many of the beliefs god or no god, so actually the theist wants to prove with evidence the existence of God.

  • @toxendon
    @toxendon 7 лет назад +1

    Sean Carroll.

  • @Patrick-jm3sp
    @Patrick-jm3sp 6 лет назад

    If I was God I'm just saying, if I was using MY image for my earthly creation I would've used all of my bells and whistles on THAT one, I wouldn't have made us a species hypothesized to only have been able to evolve because of the extinction of dinosaurs which are well-documented to have existed based on THE GIANT SKELETONS WE HOUSE IN MUSEUMS that were completely left out of the bible, by the way. That seems like a rather large arc in the history of the earth for God to have decided it was filler or something and was unnecessary to include in his biography.

    • @josephsack4918
      @josephsack4918 4 года назад

      @Doomer The neet gloomer allah was a moon god. Muhammad just stole the name and lied to some arabs. The quran supports the torah, and then contradicts it. Same with the gospel

  • @Mechaghostman2
    @Mechaghostman2 8 лет назад +1

    Reporting for misleading video. This is the film God's Not Dead. This has nothing to do with Stephen Hawking and him saying philosophy is dead.

    • @myvidaloka
      @myvidaloka 3 года назад +2

      They reference him in it. Therefore not clickbait.

  • @pierre0227
    @pierre0227 3 года назад +3

    This part made me realize that scientists may be very smart but mathematics majors can be even smarter.

    • @pierre0227
      @pierre0227 3 года назад +1

      @@rickydickydingdong7570 don’t be. I’m an agnostic.

    • @riverc.820
      @riverc.820 2 года назад +1

      Mathematics...is part of Science.

    • @pierre0227
      @pierre0227 2 года назад

      @@riverc.820 true but I think math is more problem solving. Science is something else.

    • @riverc.820
      @riverc.820 2 года назад

      @@pierre0227 This is science & math. Hard sciences. What we think or want it to be...doesn't count. We can rearrange things in our head how we like it....but it will be wrong.

    • @pierre0227
      @pierre0227 2 года назад

      @@riverc.820 what did I say that was wrong??

  • @harrynguyen2503
    @harrynguyen2503 6 лет назад +1

    Who's god

    • @harrynguyen2503
      @harrynguyen2503 6 лет назад

      Anthony Gold based on what evidence

    • @amordoc6168
      @amordoc6168 6 лет назад +2

      God is the end and the beginning,Our creator go read bible

    • @harrynguyen2503
      @harrynguyen2503 6 лет назад

      amor doc I know who god is dumbshit. That was me being sarcastic

    • @amordoc6168
      @amordoc6168 6 лет назад +1

      Harry Nguyen "i know who god is" maybe you meant i know who God is.

    • @harrynguyen2503
      @harrynguyen2503 6 лет назад

      amor doc gOD

  • @YOSUP315
    @YOSUP315 7 лет назад +1

    0:57 chick's like, I'm actually paying for this shit?

  • @jowildcat40
    @jowildcat40 4 года назад +1

    Theists claim God exists, and atheists respond with 'Until you prove to me your God exists, I don't believe you.'
    From what I've seen so far, this movie tries to pass on the burden of proof while utilizing the argument of ignorance to paint a nasty light on those who question God.
    But if you really want to question your average Christian, why do they accept a collection of stories to which they pick and choose particular chapters as truth, meanwhile if you actually read the Bible, Jesus had no idea about what are bacteria and diseases, he had a boyfriend who he cuddled with on numerous occasions, God specifically said no God's other than me, then Jesus came along and said he was God too, Jesus is basically a parallel to Moses, where multiple stories were copied from Moses (Greek scholars made sure to change the stories enough to not make them exact).
    I can go on, such as how Revelations was written to be relevant with the current events that took place during the time it was written, or that we do not know the real authors of some of the books of the main disciples who describe the resurrection.
    With all that said, along with Exodus 21 where it's okay to own slaves and beat them as long as you don't kill them and to provide a loophole for keeping slaves for their entire lives.... with all that said, apparently this archaic book of fables is more scientifically accurate than our own current philosophies and sciences.
    "Let there be light" is more explainable than there is no beginning and that matter could have very much existed before the expansion of our universe. People can understand what infinity is but they can't grasp it, therefore God is the solution. Wishful thinking doesn't bring us closer to the truth, instead it hides the fact that religion has more blood on the hands of the believers than any other motive for genocide. Hell, Christian God had murdered more people than the devil has, as written in the Bible. Nowhere does it say that the serpent in the garden was the devil.
    I'm fed up with people claiming that christianity is a good religion when 99% of it's followers have never read the entire Bible. The ones that did mostly became atheists because of the contradictions and the ones that stayed probably have a strong motive to want to cling to religion as a means to cope with difficult stresses in life and to feel accepted with a like-minded community.
    If you are a devout Christian, show me in the Bible where Jesus says it's wrong to own another human being. Show me where God says it's wrong to own another human being. Show me where you can prove that Jesus has saved people from damnation, brought on to them by God if they don't believe. If you can do that for me, I will believe. If not, I can show you where in history Jesus was just a copy of many other religious figures that predate Christianity.

    • @myvidaloka
      @myvidaloka 3 года назад +4

      It all comes down to free will. You choose to do wrong no one else. Because you will give an account on EVERYTHING you’ve done in your life. All those people owning slaves n stuff is wrong. Those people will have to give their account on that and be judged on it. And just like here we get punished for it. You have consequences. That’s how it’ll be in the end with our lives for eternity. It’s corrupt people. Just like today in age. Slavery is wrong. God wouldn’t like for it to happen, but it falls on OUR choices because we chose not to listen to Him. Our purpose in life is to find Jesus our Lord n Savior, to come to him so that we may be saved and go live with our father. And that wasn’t God that brought them slavery. Be VERY careful of what you say bout God. And it’s funny you say that last part because in other religions the VERY thing that Jesus said he was, other religions said, “I don’t know the meaning of life.” When Jesus himself said, “I am the way the truth AND the LIFE, no one gets to father except through me.”

    • @flynnrider2871
      @flynnrider2871 2 года назад +3

      Jesus said you must love your neighbor as yourself. In other words do onto others that you would have done to you. Do you wanna be a slave? Of course not. So don’t make someone a slave.

    • @andrewmoreno3707
      @andrewmoreno3707 Год назад +2

      Acts 22 1-30

  • @elmo_eman2867
    @elmo_eman2867 3 года назад

    Ofcourse God’s Not dead,Only things that Exist die.

  • @nemom225
    @nemom225 6 лет назад +2

    As expected I don't agree with this moive and think that Steven Hawkings work can't be summarized in one sentence just like if I pick out an embarrassing sentence in the Bible and said this is what it represents. Furthermore he did not give any context into what was truly said so in short a middle schooler is smarter then that character.

    • @LaniakeaLeathercrafts
      @LaniakeaLeathercrafts 6 лет назад +4

      What's the context of his statement, then? It seems pretty independent on its own.

    • @josephsack4918
      @josephsack4918 4 года назад +1

      @@LaniakeaLeathercrafts "something made something from nothing" 6th grade logic hawking...😕

  • @ForeverBleedinGreen
    @ForeverBleedinGreen Год назад

    The only problem I have with this Christian movie franchise is not once, in all 4 movies, is evolution ever mentioned, when it is in fact the main problem with this country, and world for that matter today. It is literally stealing the souls of our kids in the same way as a burglar would in the dark of night, yet these Christian-based movies never even speak a single word about this voodoo science that's based on nothing but 163 years (and counting) of viscous lies, deception and deceit.
    And the worst part about "evilution," as it's so frequently pronounced across the pond, is being taught to most of our kids today. By allowing this, we are simply teaching them to spit on the graves of our fallen war war heroes who fought and died fighting against Darwinism and evolutionism in Nazi Germany. Now, if you tell an evolutionist that Hitler, his cronies, and the entire Nazi nation, that they fully condoned and embraced evolutionary theory, and they'll call you a liar, and tell you that Hitler was a "Catholic."
    This is true, but only because his mother was a staunch Roman-Catholic and FORCED Hitler to go to her church, but after leaving his family home, he never stepped into a one of any kind ever again for the purpose of "worship," which is something he fully admits he admits to not doing even when there, because he hated religion, and especially Jesus. The truth of the matter is Hitler and the Nazis not only wanted to burn down every church in Nazi Germany, but murdered any priest who did not promptly do their bidding.
    The Nazis also used Darwinism, and its sick and evil step-sister evolutionism, as a convenient excuse to murder 6 to 8 million innocent men, woman, and children on an industrial scale, yet here we Americans are, teaching that same insidious and sick ideology that I thought we defeated, to our own kids. To me, this is just as sick as Hitler and the Nazis were - maybe more so considering how many kids whose faith was destroyed, and did I mention Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot - who all were also evolutionists and murdered millions of their own people as well.
    Evolutionists also just love to bring up all that is bad about the Roman-Catholic church throughout history, but when you bring up the modern-day atrocities of this aforementioned group of monsters, they do what evolutionists do best - they lie to themselves. This is called "cognitive dissonance," and is by far THE worst mental illness that exists in the world today, that has been, and will continue to be by far, THE most destructive ideology in the entire history of mankind. Thank you Charlie Darwin.
    Lies and deceit - that's the very foundation of evolutionary theory - and kids by the millions are being indoctrinated into this horrific philosophy every day. So, with this comment, I hope to get other people to help get a message across to the producers of the God's Not Dead franchise, to make a movie denouncing Darwin and his horrible idea as it needs to be, since it is THE biggest problem with not only science (by holding back all of humanity), but the entire world's evolution as well - because the ONLY thing that actually "evolves" is human innovation and the things and concepts it has created with the God-Given intelligence we've been handed.
    This has to stop, but it most likely won't - until the day Jesus returns - and evilution will no doubt be the number one cause for his return unless we act now before it's too late - if it isn't already that is.

  • @videoestres
    @videoestres 2 года назад

    this movie sucks

    • @andrewmoreno3707
      @andrewmoreno3707 Год назад +2

      That’s just your opinion, but God is the truth