I was very sceptical of a 20 year old becoming an MP, I didn't think it was right, but having listened to this speech I hold my hands up and admit how wrong I was. This girl is really something. As an Englishman, I feel thoroughly ashamed at how we are currently lagging so far behind our progressive Scottish neighbours. Good on you Mhairi, and the rest of the SNP members - you're putting the Labour Party to shame.
Martin Davies Martin, England can wake up too and do the same. It is already starting. Take courage and find some likeminded folk and start talking to people. Maybe join the Greens. Maybe campaign for Jeremy Corbyn. Maybe start a cross-party grassroots movement. Whatever you do, we'll be cheering you one every step of the way.
Annette Kupke Funny you should say that, I did support the Greens locally at the last election (despite not being a 'Greenie' - I am a disillusioned LibDem in fact) and I have signed up to support Corbyn's bid for leader. Small steps. ;-)
Nice thing to say martin. Its appreciated here from a scot. Up here we are really disillusioned with westminster treating normal people like shit hence the independence argument, but what annoys us just as much is the media trying to put a wedge between people like you and i. We just want a fairer place for all but our only option seems to be independence unfortunately .
Until I heard this speech, I had misgivings about someone aged 20 being able to represent a constituency. How wrong I was. Spoken with passion and direct experience to back it up. Clearly someone with future leadership potential.
Derek Williams I don't think we have so much to worry about with the kids these days. I see again and again shining examples. . . I think mine was the bad generation.
Derek Williams People of 20 are allowed to vote. Parliament is supposed to represent the people. Even if a 20 year old wasn't that articulate she should still be allowed to represent her constituency.
Andrew Wilson I completely agree - if they vote for her, that is the way it works, and as I already said, I believe the electorate made a great choice in this MP.
***** Even if every constituency in Scotland had voted labour it would still have been a tory government. "Nationalist fascists"? That's just laughable. Read Billy Bragg's post in the Guardian.
***** You're so wrong. The reason the Tories were voted in again was because Labour was not seen as a credible alternative. If the union does break up, it will due to in no small part to this existing Tory government. The Tories have no interest in Scotland, yet the UK has a Tory government. Don't complain about the SNP in Westminster. They have a right to be there.
Andrew Wilson in the words of our representatives 'hear, hear'! This isn't about Scotland Vs England or anything so archaic, its about the working people Vs Tories. (though that's just my opinion, I'm sure.)
***** But labour did nothing for us, why would we have voted for them again if it was going to be the same outcome. Even if all of Scotland voted labour it would still be conservative, we can't be responsible for the amount of scared, misled sheeple down there who voted conservative. As you know the SNP won nearly all seats... Does that not show how different our countries interests are?
From all the way across the Atlantic, I salute you Mhairi Black! Do not ever forget where you came from. Do not ever forget who you serve. While some of your elders have forgotten these things, you stand as a champion of the people. Use your power accordingly, and never allow it to corrupt you. :)
***** As long as you perceive "power" to be a responsiblity to others, as opposed to "power" over others. I don't think you'll be easily corrupted. To serve not to be served. ;)
I wish to add my voice to the chorus of admiration and praise for the maturity, passion and eloquence from this new MP. Scottish politics will typically not have much of an effect on my little bubble with me living south of the border in the North West of England, but it is always refreshing and heartening when somebody who clearly cares about democracy, fairness and the interests of her constituents can make me nod my head for eight minutes DESPITE me being a Tory supporter. We want to see real people in our elected house, not mercenary professional politicians just wanting to stick their snouts in the trough... I think my opinion of the SNP has just gone up about 50% thanks to this one speech
I really respect your comment, the fact that your political views are quite different but you took the time to watch and appreciate this speech warms my heart. We genuinely as a party want to reach out in friendship to our friends and neighbours down South, so there's a possibility that the SNP could affect your life in some way and I'd like to think it would be positive :-) x
MrP86 I've never believed that any one single party ticked ALL MY BOXES... you would have to be a cliche to follow any party on EVERY ONE of their policies... hence why there are divisions within all parties It is perfectly normal to have aspirations and a conscience at the same time If any one single party ever nails that then we would never need to have another election again Until then we just have to pick the party that covers most of the bases
TheComputec That is very magnanimous of you to say. Thank you. The SNP is made up of people from many different parties who are looking for change in the way the UK is run and the present leader, Nicola Sturgeon, while the welfare of Scotland is perhaps her prime concern, is also very concerned about the suffering of many ordinary people all over the UK.
MagicEve There's nothing wrong in being self-aware. I wish more people were. Especially politicians. Young achievers usually burn themselves out by thirty anyway.
As an Aussie I was invited to listen to Mhairi's speech and now am so glad I did. Why, oh why can't we have politicians of this calibre in Australia? She blew me away with her passion and determination for her country and it's people. All strength to your arm Mhairi and may you continue to be a signpost that is so urgently needed!
I'm a dual Scottish-Australian. We were until recently stuck with Scott Morrison. A more corrupt and useless pm I've never known. Turnbull was my favourite but thankfully Albanese is in power.
"..... One of the most unhealthy workplaces you could ever be in..."... And you would know this how Mahri? It is you first and only job.... Ya wee daftie!
Wow. Nicola Sturgeon has a successor waiting in the wings. How on Earth did the Scottish Labour Party miss her?! It's unbelievable. No wonder Scottish Labour fell apart. They should be ashamed. The SNP has managed to find a 'diamond'. I hope she is there for some time. I am listening to an eloquent lady who speaks with the reassurance of a veteran. If she were my daughter (I am nearly 47) I would have burst every button on my jacket with pride. Bravo Mhairi.
I thought you were being sarcastic with your comment. but ,no ,I'm mistaken i think it was your "she's a eloquent lady "( as eloquent has a kick in the nuts , me thinks).comment that had me
she is a diamond, when ever she back home she makes sure she speaks to my dad, and listen to his stories ( i been on the phone with him for 90 mins with his stories), they even exchange books about scotland. she is a Diamond and me and my family are proud of her.
An amazing performance, especially as it was Mhairi's maiden speech. This is one of the most impressive young women to enter politics in a very long time. We need far more like her.
If only we could put on the ballot paper an individuals name for PM, she would win hands down. Like many I thought her to be too young to be an MP even after such a great maiden speech-but no she has gone to be the only MP I would trust and vote for..Pity I dont live in Scotland. Well done and thank you for being such a great role model.
Pleased to see so many positive comments from so many English people. You need to know, understand and educate so many of your fellow countrymen who think that we hate you - we absolutely do not, as I'm sure most of you reading this will realise. Most of us have friends and family who are English, or friends or family who live in England. We don't wish any badness to befall you. We support pretty much all of your athletes competing internationally, apart of course from your football teams, we'd support Iraq playing against them. I've lived in England for a year or so, and worked in and out of England from Scotland about 50% of my working life. I've never had any problems there at all really, always found people to be professional and friendly. My son lived in England for years too, in York. I think he really liked the place. I found it pretty charming too, despite facing legal execution by bow & arrow. Mhairi Black's maiden speech was absolutely sensational. Words spoken with passion for the well-being and representation for so many people whose voices are utterly unheard and totally unrepresented and have been for decades. Words for people who are now finally being sacrificed to death by starvation, by some right-wing policy sell off French quango murderers called ATOS, which isn't being entirely ignored by the Tory party. Ian Duncan Smith is currently refusing to bow to a 1/4 million signatory or so petition to release figures of how may have died directly after having their "Benefits" (such as misnomer) sanctioned. This is surely the greatest scandal in recent British history? Is it hundreds? Is it thousands? Of British citizens basically starved to death/suicide!?!? We need to know the body count. We need to know who made the key decisions. We need to prosecute them to the full extent of the law. We don't need this to take as long as Hillsborough has taken to come close to a righteous and just ending. That this isn't the number one story in all of the newspapers, on TV, and the lips of every politician, all of the time smacks of a very nasty conspiracy indeed. Tony Blair stole the Labour Party and moved it centre-right and with catastrophic mismanagement, utterly destroyed the soul of the Labour Party, forever. As Tony Benn and Mhairi Black would put it "there are weather-cocks and signposts". Well Tony Blair was tumble-weed for the Labour Party. I think they need another total revolution, or better a new left-wing party to evolve to replace them and steal their (our) identity back. About time we had some real left-wing politicians, speaking with passion, and ripping into the proto-fascist state that Britain is becoming. And better still, engineer a way for Scotland's Independence to happen.
MinceCFC I am English born but have lived in Scotland for 35 years. From my experience in Scotland the SNP do the most damage to Scots reputation regarding the English. A joke of a party that just blames Westminster for everything, Lies about Scotland's assets (Jimmy Krankie Sturgeon overestimated Scotlands Oil revenue by as much as £34 Billion pounds over 20 years. Thats £68000 per head of population . £3,400 per year. And she wants fiscal control of the Scottish economy! Are you kidding! I've nothing against this young girl. But I wouldn't trust the SNP to run a church fete, Let alone a country. A party of Liars, Bigots, Hypocrites. I despair that this shower could probably eventually win independance. If the Scottish people don't wake up and realise that a vote for the SNP is NOT a vote for Scotland. Unless your vision for Scotland is a highly taxed independant minnow country with no clout, nothing to bargain with and a leader who seems to have no clue about how an economy works I blame labour for being a shower of shit as well. That's how this has happened. No way Scotland would vote Tory. So the nationalists got all the votes from the void. So looks like we're stuck with the Tories in power, The only thing worse is SNP running Scotland
Philippe Coutinho Name me a political party in the UK that aren't liars, bigots or hypocrites? It doesn't matter to me who wins Independence for Scotland, just that it is won and we break free from Westminster, which is the biggest monster in the history of the entire world. They've ruled over the invasion of 90% of nations on this earth and killed tens of millions of people, now they are killing their own.
"Name me a political party in the UK that aren't liars, bigots or hypocrites? " -OK you got me there Talkin about the British Empire seems Moot to 2015, not sure where your going with that? "Westminster the biggest monster in the History of the world!" -Seriously mate? "now they are killing their own." ?? You've lost me
Philippe Coutinho Yes, seriously. The British Empire make the Nazis look like hippies. They've invaded 9 out of every 10 countries on earth. And 'killing their own' refers to both British soldiers and more importantly, to those sentenced to starve to death by "Benefit" Sanctions, who number in the thousands.
donna blues Or perhaps people who understand very little about politics or how the law works enjoy listening to her poorly informed rhetoric. Which is all this is.
She is from a drilled anti Anglo capitalist ideology, embroiled in over sensationalised and baseless nationalism.. and can clearly be seen consuming substances even during parliament sittings
Here is what the Uk needs, an MP in touch with her community, not an old grey man, in an old grey suit, from a family with money. Mhairi understands her peers, her parents generation and actually sees the people around her. This is inspiration! A brutally honest talk on the state of, but mainly, about the people that live in it, the people she represents! Mhairi hold fast, stay true, do not be sucked into the grey old man politics, keep it fresh and exciting!
So proud that someone so young has a command of the English Language and is able to display it so well. She rises above the baying herd of most M.P.s of all parties. I pray that she does not fall to the temptations of power and the corrupting influences of the "Establishment". She inspires, Johnson corrupts.
I can't put it any other way than I'm very proud of her. She hasn't just raised the bar but thrown it through the window. Inspirational stuff from a young woman talking from the heart. Her and Caroline Lucas are a force to be reckoned with.
It doesn't matter what party your from, this is seriously something. For a 20 year old to put her voice across in this way, in the most famous Parliament on earth says a hell of a lot.
Aye walking into the most famous Parliament in the World wearing a grubby old sports jacket and jeans this lesbian needs some lessons on etiquette Black is showing contempt for Authority .
@@martincosgrove5961 No she is showing that scotlands future generation needs to be respected, but to mention what she wears !!!! shows you do not understand what she saying, so go away and look back and then come back and say sorry.
@@martincosgrove5961 perhaps you should concentrate more on what she is saying rather than what she is dressed in or her sexuality which is actually not your concern
I'm actually a wee bit chocked-up after listening to this speech. Much wisdom, passion and compassion in someone so young, or any age for that matter. Well done. It's good to know Scotland has this calibre of woman working for us.
😂😂😂😂😂😂 what !!!! HIGHEST DRUG DEATH RATE IN Europe!!!! NHS in shambles , police Scotland is in a shambles ! Scotland is fkd due to the SNP ! Not West minister ! She watched them decline because the SNP steel so so much money and put 0 back into The community! Cut the rehab budget ! But yeah they really do care huh !!!!
Being a Norwegian I have only a limited knowledge of UK politics but this MP heartbreaking story about the man really got to me and shows the human costs of political descisions. The district Mhairi is representing is lucky to have her, we need more like her in this country as well.
Mhairi is already distinguishing herself as a "hall of fame"-class leader. She is 100% PM material. Such an inspiring leader. And a person of true moral quality.
What I am going to say may sound a bit exaggerated but whenever I see this Awesome Scottish political figure on Screen I think of Oscar(hint: French Revolution). What a powerful talk. May Allah and his pathetic killer Muhammad, kiss your hands and shoes for this Gorgeous speech. Be blessed sister.
I am absolutely overwhelmed with admiration for the courage and honesty with which this young woman speaks the truth. I wish i had watched it before. I have commanded my children to watch it, to be inspired by a young person who cares about others
A genuine and moving speech identifying the hope in us all for a better future. Don't ever lose sight of your direction Mhairi - don't let them corrupt you! May the almighty give you strength and guidance - god bless
incredible... and i would do anything for mhairi black to help her. i think she is, one day, going to be our leader. she is that unique strong but connecting character. i have absolutely no doubt. just watch over the years. thankyou for your heart mhairi.
Mhairi you moved me first time at the Nats conference, wondered who you were, Never forgot the speech. Then the election result caused me to cry and you do it again today. Thank you for being a voice for the forgotten ones that the elect try to demonize.
Mesmerising and probably the best speech I’ve heard from an MP. Refreshing oratory from such a young woman with an incredible passion, you are the future Mhairi
This young woman is the sort of person we need in government... someone who tells it like it is, and is not afraid of exposing the rotten truth about the never ending degradation of the welfare state... I hope you go far in your chosen political path Mhairi. Good on you girl!!!
You would be very welcome in Scotland William, as I replied to another of friends and neighbours down South, don't feel bad Scotland was almost shaken and forced to wake up to politics because of the referendum, things will balance themselves out, thanks for the lovely comment
More real people with good hearts like this need to take over the world. She has her head and her heart in the right place and could teach the leaders of this world where their priorities should lie.
Earth Suit Real people, really, so what has this 'real person' actually done in her life, what's her life experience, could that 'good heart' just be naivety. One thing is for sure, the society that prioritises the bottom 10% is a society that is going nowhere.
Reading your comment suggests to me you would like to see this young woman give up on her efforts for a better society, she has grown up in a poverty stricken area, I think you are the one who hasn't had any life experience
Earth Suit For crying out loud, she's just a trumpet blaring out the party line like all other SNP MP's. The SNP, like any other nationalist party throughout history will promise the world but deliver nothing but misery. 'The hand of friendship', LOLZ
What a wonderful young woman to be able to speak out for the neglect of support for young adults and others in need. Not all young adults have family support and there is such suffering today. All praise to Mhairi for expressing the real problems that exist out especially the dreadful sanctions for claimants, Food banks should no longer be tolerated in a civilised society. I take issue that they are now a necessity for families and individuals - this is appalling in our society. Well done Mhairi, you have a great future.
+Mai Nem Jesus fucking Christ. The SNP are ruining the UK from their couches in Scotland, do you really want those delusional, law breaking cunts in Downing Street!?
These haggis-fed women (Mhairi and Nicola) are intellectually sharp and humane. They want to help everyone lead happy lives - which is anathema to Westminster.
Absolutely brilliant speech, it makes me weep to think how much this country has been destroyed by the tories and no real opposition from liebour, I'm Welsh so couldn't vote for this young lady but I agree with every word she said.
Everyone has been talking about this speech today. . . It has been all over the radio and TV, even here in London. Labour turned it's back not just on Scotland, but on all it's core supporters. Worse it gave them the finger as it turned. Even with Corbyn, Labour can hope only to regain England, Scotland were betrayed. My fear is that a real socialist will never be at the helm of Labour again.
Labour just isnt what it should be anymore. There used to be a clear distinction between them and the Conservatives but they are seriously just red tories now. Scotland doesnt want them, thats for sure! Have you seen Ed Miliband arriving in Glasgow? Its brilliant!
I tell ya, when Labour finally get kicked out of the north you're going to see 50 years worth of cover-ups and corruption brought to light. It'll make Rochdale and Hillsborough look like Ed's bacon butty. Labour and the unions control the press in the north, they're shit scared to say a thing against them, but even so they can't stop people posting pro-UKIP stuff in the comments sections and the numbers are a growing...
After listening to your Maiden speech in the Commons, I have to say, you have a maturity that belies your years. You have the makings of being a wonderful constituency member of parliament, one that Scotland can be proud of.I wish you all the very best in your continued good offices.
What a blinding speech! I wish that I could vote for her, but I live in a tiny red spot in the south of tory England (Soton Test) and cannot do so. I just hope that she sticks to the principles expressed in her speech, and is not corrupted by the cess pit that is Westminster. She, and her party are the best hope for clipping the tories wings...the Labour party are currently not in a position to defend the NHS etc.
Ngl she gave a brilliant speech, but why would you want to vote for a party who's only agenda are to only help Scotland?? Considering you live in England.
Phumelela Mavundla "She, and her party are the best hope for clipping the tories wings...the Labour party are currently not in a position to defend the NHS etc." - because of that.
Sheechiibii Fox and why would the tories need thier wings clipped? You must be looking at Athens and feeling envious of their awesomeness. How would you sort out our deficit? Incase you dont know, that means that our country is spending more every year that we collect. Its unsustainable and something has to be done or we go bankrupt. So, what is the great socialist plan you believe in that will save us?? Spend and borrow? Take from the driven and give to the lazy?? Or do we stand up to the lazy and say "no, in this country you earn your way and everyone has a use"
smcg i wouldn't take from people who need help, who have worked and paid taxes their whole lives and deserve help when they need it. I hope you never become disabled or are unable to find work, because then you'll be one of the 'lazy' people who are starving to death thanks to the tories. How would i sort out the deficit? I'd start by giving less money to people who won't die without it. Taxes are meant to go towards helping society, not lining the pockets of tories and their banker friends.
smcg so why must the poorest bare the brunt of the deficit they didn't cause it bsnkers did, what a society that blames the poor fot being poor, trust me Scotland will be independent within 10 years, will do well & england can wallow in austerity & stop comparing the "UK" with Greece its ridiculous tory spin (ie lies)
AMFCEO1 He might not be twenty years old, but Bernie Sanders is by a mile the best candidate for President. Exactly the kind of man the world needs to be President.
Yes your right actually I'm all the over here in California , and they don't give Mr.Sanders any TV time . Till now I heard his name twice . But I did my reasearch and Mr.Sanders for president !
What a remarkable young woman. Intelligent. articulate, witty and incredibly self possessed. She's passionate and honest as well. Our young people need more role models like this instead of vapid celebrities. What she said was totally spot on, it's so long since we've heard honesty like this in parliament.
Brilliant! Mhari Black indeed is far more mature and poised than many twice(3 times!) her age. Bless you lass. Bless you. This gives me hope for the future. She sure seems like future Prime MInister material.
Great stuff Mhairi!...Gaun yersel hen! Reminiscent of another young woman MPs. maiden speech to the house. Also spoken with great passion and conviction. Bernadette Devlin! back in the 70s.
Mhairi leaving her role is understandable, entirely, yet it is still terribly depressing. Integrity is rare, except with this one, seaping from every pore. This speech is beautifully articulate, funny, emotional, deep, meaningful. I hope Mhairi can recover, recuperate and come back swinging once more. The strength of conviction in her character is extremely moving and motivating. It hurts to know the system wore her down so thoroughly, though likely because she is capable of actual feeling; empathetic paralysis ❤
For me she is one of the finest MP's to have walked through the doors of the Palace of Westminster in my 61 years. She is the type of MP not only Scotland, but Britain needs.
"Show your appreciation vociferously, just don't clap." You cut off the deputy speakers response to the outburst of spontaneous applause to Mhairi Black's wonderful speech. Far better to instinctively applaud than bray like an 18th century aristocrat yelling at peasants to get off their land...
What a fantastic MP and what a tribute to both Scotland and to Britain. If this is what she's like as a newbie - watch this space for what we'll see in a few years time.
Well done Mhairi Black. What a confident, caring young woman. Caring enough to point out how unfair it is for the paid for by taxpayers 2nd homes of these money grabbing MPs. She made me sit up and take notice and I'll wager no one in the benches fell asleep while she was speaking. Keep it up.
Brilliant speech, regardless of party. It's good to hear someone talking from the heart and not totally driven by party politics and petty oneupmanship comments. More politicians need to realise that if they talk like 'normal people' that the 'normal people' will sit up and listen.
if you are so "virtuous" why don't you spend your own money on the poor and jobless? Its easy to virtue signal and say "we need to do more for the poor" when you are spending SOMEONE ELSES MONEY
We have a government that we all pay taxes to whose job it is to provide services and benefits to maintain a certain standard of living for every citizen in our society. We ALL benefit from government systems in one way or another. We ALL benefit from “someone else’s money” in one way or another. This argument fundamentally comes from a place of selfishness and greed. We can not afford to live in a society where so many people who work so hard live in squalor while the ultra-wealthy live like kings. It. Is. Not. Right.
Brilliant maiden speech, so right about you not leaving the Labour Party but the Labour party leaving you. Those sentiments are felt and agreed with by so many people across the UK. Just hope Labour gets the message but I very much doubt it.
There 650 members of parliament and only 56 of them come from the SNP. Everytime I watch the chamber these days it is packed with SNP though and the other benches are sparse. This is despite the SNP MPs having to travel from constituencies many times the distance than most of the UK party MPs. Shows exactly why the SNP are dominating these days. They actually care.
Ooh, she'll go far! Outstanding, this lady has a genuine calling for politics. Eloquent, heartfelt and informed. We could do with more like her here in the south. Da iawn!
Absolutely brilliant lass. As a still burning, well just anyway at my age, socialist firebrand I hope you can live up to your rhetoric and help the labour party rediscover the reason for their existence. I have voted labour my whole life but the next time I will be voting SNP as they are the only genuinely left wing radical party left in Scotland. Superb performance Mhairi. Get stuck into the Tory bastards!!!!
ian mcdowell Scotland always had a voice in Westminster, except now we are only represented by one party. You are aware I presume that Scotland is no more represented in terms of seats as it was before?. SNP Scotland
Mhairi Black should be proud of herself. This was spoken with truth, passion and is simply a breath of fresh air to British Politics. Outstanding and finally a politician that I can actually relate to instead of the dinosaurs that sit in Westminster
as an englishman she would get my vote (even though i cant vote for her) a sensible person with powerful convictions, that appears to genuinely care about those who elected her - well done Mhairi
I was very sceptical of a 20 year old becoming an MP, I didn't think it was right, but having listened to this speech I hold my hands up and admit how wrong I was. This girl is really something. As an Englishman, I feel thoroughly ashamed at how we are currently lagging so far behind our progressive Scottish neighbours. Good on you Mhairi, and the rest of the SNP members - you're putting the Labour Party to shame.
That's such a nice comment, don't feel bad my friend, Scotland was kind of forced to wake up and take a look at politics because of the referendum
Martin Davies Martin, England can wake up too and do the same. It is already starting. Take courage and find some likeminded folk and start talking to people. Maybe join the Greens. Maybe campaign for Jeremy Corbyn. Maybe start a cross-party grassroots movement. Whatever you do, we'll be cheering you one every step of the way.
Martin Davies There is a proud father out there in Scotland somewhere.
Annette Kupke Funny you should say that, I did support the Greens locally at the last election (despite not being a 'Greenie' - I am a disillusioned LibDem in fact) and I have signed up to support Corbyn's bid for leader. Small steps. ;-)
Nice thing to say martin. Its appreciated here from a scot. Up here we are really disillusioned with westminster treating normal people like shit hence the independence argument, but what annoys us just as much is the media trying to put a wedge between people like you and i. We just want a fairer place for all but our only option seems to be independence unfortunately .
Watching this in 2022, 2015 feels like "The good ol' days".
Until I heard this speech, I had misgivings about someone aged 20 being able to represent a constituency. How wrong I was. Spoken with passion and direct experience to back it up. Clearly someone with future leadership potential.
Derek Williams I don't think we have so much to worry about with the kids these days. I see again and again shining examples. . . I think mine was the bad generation.
Derek Williams People of 20 are allowed to vote. Parliament is supposed to represent the people. Even if a 20 year old wasn't that articulate she should still be allowed to represent her constituency.
Andrew Wilson There's a difference between being 'allowed' and being 'able'.
Andrew Wilson I completely agree - if they vote for her, that is the way it works, and as I already said, I believe the electorate made a great choice in this MP.
Totally agree
Outstanding speech from a very talented young Politician, quite inspirational!
***** Absolutely. There's nothing like a sanctimonious lefty for gorging themselves on state money. She will prove no different.
vordman unfortunately this is probably true
Sanctimonious? You mean, speaking from a place of generosity and social responsibility?
These are the politics that Billy Bragg was talking about when he said English socialists should be supporting the SNP.
anti pioneer Is there any reason a millionaire can't be a socialist?:
He writes good songs. People want to buy his music.
***** Even if every constituency in Scotland had voted labour it would still have been a tory government.
"Nationalist fascists"?
That's just laughable.
Read Billy Bragg's post in the Guardian.
*****
You're so wrong. The reason the Tories were voted in again was because Labour was not seen as a credible alternative. If the union does break up, it will due to in no small part to this existing Tory government.
The Tories have no interest in Scotland, yet the UK has a Tory government. Don't complain about the SNP in Westminster. They have a right to be there.
Andrew Wilson in the words of our representatives 'hear, hear'!
This isn't about Scotland Vs England or anything so archaic, its about the working people Vs Tories. (though that's just my opinion, I'm sure.)
***** But labour did nothing for us, why would we have voted for them again if it was going to be the same outcome. Even if all of Scotland voted labour it would still be conservative, we can't be responsible for the amount of scared, misled sheeple down there who voted conservative. As you know the SNP won nearly all seats... Does that not show how different our countries interests are?
From all the way across the Atlantic, I salute you Mhairi Black! Do not ever forget where you came from. Do not ever forget who you serve. While some of your elders have forgotten these things, you stand as a champion of the people. Use your power accordingly, and never allow it to corrupt you. :)
We are so proud of her Hans thank you for your lovely comment
Matthew Bull genius.
***** As long as you perceive "power" to be a responsiblity to others, as opposed to "power" over others. I don't think you'll be easily corrupted.
To serve not to be served. ;)
***** That woman is brilliant already with 20. She does not need to be told anything!!!
Hildegard Maier Nothing wrong with a little encouragement :D
I wish to add my voice to the chorus of admiration and praise for the maturity, passion and eloquence from this new MP. Scottish politics will typically not have much of an effect on my little bubble with me living south of the border in the North West of England, but it is always refreshing and heartening when somebody who clearly cares about democracy, fairness and the interests of her constituents can make me nod my head for eight minutes DESPITE me being a Tory supporter. We want to see real people in our elected house, not mercenary professional politicians just wanting to stick their snouts in the trough... I think my opinion of the SNP has just gone up about 50% thanks to this one speech
I really respect your comment, the fact that your political views are quite different but you took the time to watch and appreciate this speech warms my heart. We genuinely as a party want to reach out in friendship to our friends and neighbours down South, so there's a possibility that the SNP could affect your life in some way and I'd like to think it would be positive :-) x
TheComputec if thats true then why the hell did you vote tory
MrP86 I've never believed that any one single party ticked ALL MY BOXES... you would have to be a cliche to follow any party on EVERY ONE of their policies... hence why there are divisions within all parties
It is perfectly normal to have aspirations and a conscience at the same time
If any one single party ever nails that then we would never need to have another election again
Until then we just have to pick the party that covers most of the bases
TheComputec That is very magnanimous of you to say. Thank you. The SNP is made up of people from many different parties who are looking for change in the way the UK is run and the present leader, Nicola Sturgeon, while the welfare of Scotland is perhaps her prime concern, is also very concerned about the suffering of many ordinary people all over the UK.
Brother Charles Utter Drivel
how the fuck can we be the same age? i feel so unaccomplished im going to eat an entire cheesecake and cry myself into a vodka induced sleep
MagicEve I have a glass of wine here with me. It comforts until tomorrow when I wake up.
MagicEve me too
MagicEve Cheesecake is good though..
You can volunteer at a community centre or a garden project. Help the people she's referring to AND get free salad to go with that vodka. Good luck.
MagicEve There's nothing wrong in being self-aware. I wish more people were. Especially politicians. Young achievers usually burn themselves out by thirty anyway.
Now that’s what you call a speech! Fantastic.
Mhairi Black is a living legend. Power, strength and majesty ✌🏾🔥🔥🔥
She speaks with the gravity and maturity of a woman twice her age. Very impressive indeed, and a credit to her country.
Mhairi Black for Prime Minister
Without a doubt one of the most honest speeches I have heard and truly identify with. Well done and very well said.
As an Aussie I was invited to listen to Mhairi's speech and now am so glad I did. Why, oh why can't we have politicians of this calibre in Australia? She blew me away with her passion and determination for her country and it's people. All strength to your arm Mhairi and may you continue to be a signpost that is so urgently needed!
I'm a dual Scottish-Australian. We were until recently stuck with Scott Morrison. A more corrupt and useless pm I've never known. Turnbull was my favourite but thankfully Albanese is in power.
"... My mum would have loved fur me to have went to Oxford".
If you had gone to school more mhairi you would know how to speak properly 😜🤕
"..... One of the most unhealthy workplaces you could ever be in..."... And you would know this how Mahri? It is you first and only job.... Ya wee daftie!
Wow. Nicola Sturgeon has a successor waiting in the wings. How on Earth did the Scottish Labour Party miss her?! It's unbelievable. No wonder Scottish Labour fell apart. They should be ashamed. The SNP has managed to find a 'diamond'. I hope she is there for some time. I am listening to an eloquent lady who speaks with the reassurance of a veteran. If she were my daughter (I am nearly 47) I would have burst every button on my jacket with pride. Bravo Mhairi.
I thought you were being sarcastic with your comment. but ,no ,I'm mistaken i think it was your "she's a eloquent lady "( as eloquent has a kick in the nuts , me thinks).comment that had me
Probably there till she finds a girl friend in the Parliament,Young lezy .
Mhairi Black’s Gorbals act doesn’t convince. She’s from a affluent part of Paisley and worked in a chippy during her uni summer recess.
By ‘diamond’ you mean a gobby, middle-class fake from Ralston who tries to hoodwink with an unconvincing Gorbals and chips act!?
she is a diamond, when ever she back home she makes sure she speaks to my dad, and listen to his stories ( i been on the phone with him for 90 mins with his stories), they even exchange books about scotland. she is a Diamond and me and my family are proud of her.
An amazing performance, especially as it was Mhairi's maiden speech. This is one of the most impressive young women to enter politics in a very long time. We need far more like her.
Heaven help us!!
It is easy to spot when someone isn't in someone else's pocket - unfortunately the Tory party cannot compare with this level of authenticity
If only we could put on the ballot paper an individuals name for PM, she would win hands down. Like many I thought her to be too young to be an MP even after such a great maiden speech-but no she has gone to be the only MP I would trust and vote for..Pity I dont live in Scotland. Well done and thank you for being such a great role model.
My god I’ve never heard this lady talk before until today and my god she had me in tears
She is wonderful!
Pleased to see so many positive comments from so many English people. You need to know, understand and educate so many of your fellow countrymen who think that we hate you - we absolutely do not, as I'm sure most of you reading this will realise.
Most of us have friends and family who are English, or friends or family who live in England. We don't wish any badness to befall you. We support pretty much all of your athletes competing internationally, apart of course from your football teams, we'd support Iraq playing against them.
I've lived in England for a year or so, and worked in and out of England from Scotland about 50% of my working life. I've never had any problems there at all really, always found people to be professional and friendly. My son lived in England for years too, in York. I think he really liked the place. I found it pretty charming too, despite facing legal execution by bow & arrow.
Mhairi Black's maiden speech was absolutely sensational. Words spoken with passion for the well-being and representation for so many people whose voices are utterly unheard and totally unrepresented and have been for decades.
Words for people who are now finally being sacrificed to death by starvation, by some right-wing policy sell off French quango murderers called ATOS, which isn't being entirely ignored by the Tory party. Ian Duncan Smith is currently refusing to bow to a 1/4 million signatory or so petition to release figures of how may have died directly after having their "Benefits" (such as misnomer) sanctioned.
This is surely the greatest scandal in recent British history? Is it hundreds? Is it thousands? Of British citizens basically starved to death/suicide!?!? We need to know the body count. We need to know who made the key decisions. We need to prosecute them to the full extent of the law. We don't need this to take as long as Hillsborough has taken to come close to a righteous and just ending. That this isn't the number one story in all of the newspapers, on TV, and the lips of every politician, all of the time smacks of a very nasty conspiracy indeed.
Tony Blair stole the Labour Party and moved it centre-right and with catastrophic mismanagement, utterly destroyed the soul of the Labour Party, forever. As Tony Benn and Mhairi Black would put it "there are weather-cocks and signposts". Well Tony Blair was tumble-weed for the Labour Party. I think they need another total revolution, or better a new left-wing party to evolve to replace them and steal their (our) identity back.
About time we had some real left-wing politicians, speaking with passion, and ripping into the proto-fascist state that Britain is becoming. And better still, engineer a way for Scotland's Independence to happen.
MinceCFC Amen to that - SPOT ON
MinceCFC I am English born but have lived in Scotland for 35 years. From my experience in Scotland the SNP do the most damage to Scots reputation regarding the English. A joke of a party that just blames Westminster for everything, Lies about Scotland's assets (Jimmy Krankie Sturgeon overestimated Scotlands Oil revenue by as much as £34 Billion pounds over 20 years. Thats £68000 per head of population . £3,400 per year. And she wants fiscal control of the Scottish economy! Are you kidding!
I've nothing against this young girl. But I wouldn't trust the SNP to run a church fete, Let alone a country. A party of Liars, Bigots, Hypocrites. I despair that this shower could probably eventually win independance. If the Scottish people don't wake up and realise that a vote for the SNP is NOT a vote for Scotland. Unless your vision for Scotland is a highly taxed independant minnow country with no clout, nothing to bargain with and a leader who seems to have no clue about how an economy works
I blame labour for being a shower of shit as well. That's how this has happened. No way Scotland would vote Tory. So the nationalists got all the votes from the void. So looks like we're stuck with the Tories in power, The only thing worse is SNP running Scotland
Philippe Coutinho Name me a political party in the UK that aren't liars, bigots or hypocrites? It doesn't matter to me who wins Independence for Scotland, just that it is won and we break free from Westminster, which is the biggest monster in the history of the entire world. They've ruled over the invasion of 90% of nations on this earth and killed tens of millions of people, now they are killing their own.
"Name me a political party in the UK that aren't liars, bigots or hypocrites? "
-OK you got me there
Talkin about the British Empire seems Moot to 2015, not sure where your going with that?
"Westminster the biggest monster in the History of the world!"
-Seriously mate?
"now they are killing their own."
??
You've lost me
Philippe Coutinho Yes, seriously. The British Empire make the Nazis look like hippies. They've invaded 9 out of every 10 countries on earth.
And 'killing their own' refers to both British soldiers and more importantly, to those sentenced to starve to death by "Benefit" Sanctions, who number in the thousands.
She is stunningly competent, eloquent and charismatic.
..and naïve.
She spewed out a load of shite there. Why are people so infatuated with this clown.
donna blues Or perhaps people who understand very little about politics or how the law works enjoy listening to her poorly informed rhetoric. Which is all this is.
You really don't get it do you Stuart.
She is from a drilled anti Anglo capitalist ideology, embroiled in over sensationalised and baseless nationalism.. and can clearly be seen consuming substances even during parliament sittings
Here is what the Uk needs, an MP in touch with her community, not an old grey man, in an old grey suit, from a family with money. Mhairi understands her peers, her parents generation and actually sees the people around her. This is inspiration! A brutally honest talk on the state of, but mainly, about the people that live in it, the people she represents! Mhairi hold fast, stay true, do not be sucked into the grey old man politics, keep it fresh and exciting!
So proud that someone so young has a command of the English Language and is able to display it so well. She rises above the baying herd of most M.P.s of all parties. I pray that she does not fall to the temptations of power and the corrupting influences of the "Establishment". She inspires, Johnson corrupts.
All current politicians take note. You have just witnessed a display of compassion. Please learn the lesson well.
Chult Ampala The concept of compassion is quite beyond their comprehension.
Nice alliteration :)
A wonderful young lady, a credit to her party. Brilliant maiden speech, keep going Mhairi!
I can't put it any other way than I'm very proud of her. She hasn't just raised the bar but thrown it through the window. Inspirational stuff from a young woman talking from the heart. Her and Caroline Lucas are a force to be reckoned with.
It doesn't matter what party your from, this is seriously something. For a 20 year old to put her voice across in this way, in the most famous Parliament on earth says a hell of a lot.
That was the Maiden Speech of the one day not very far, future First Minister of Scotland and may be of an independent Scotland.
@HaywireOfAlba With a wee deoch an doris I guess (joke)
Aye walking into the most famous Parliament in the World wearing a grubby old sports jacket and jeans this lesbian needs some lessons on etiquette Black is showing contempt for Authority .
@@martincosgrove5961 No she is showing that scotlands future generation needs to be respected, but to mention what she wears !!!! shows you do not understand what she saying, so go away and look back and then come back and say sorry.
@@martincosgrove5961 perhaps you should concentrate more on what she is saying rather than what she is dressed in or her sexuality which is actually not your concern
I'm actually a wee bit chocked-up after listening to this speech. Much wisdom, passion and compassion in someone so young, or any age for that matter. Well done. It's good to know Scotland has this calibre of woman working for us.
😂😂😂😂😂😂 what !!!! HIGHEST DRUG DEATH RATE IN Europe!!!! NHS in shambles , police Scotland is in a shambles ! Scotland is fkd due to the SNP ! Not West minister ! She watched them decline because the SNP steel so so much money and put 0 back into
The community! Cut the rehab budget ! But yeah they really do care huh !!!!
I'm welling up here. Just brilliant. We need more like you! peace x
I cried too
What a speech that is. Mind. Blown.
Drew Layton I cried too.
sycophantic
+Kats987124 Yes,nice to see the Glasgow ned community having one of their own,representing them in Parliament!
Absolutely amazing!!! She's phenomenal and she speaks nothing but the truth. We need more people like this .
Thank god she got beat by a trans man 😂! She was so embarrassing for Scotland!
Being a Norwegian I have only a limited knowledge of UK politics but this MP heartbreaking story about the man really got to me and shows the human costs of political descisions.
The district Mhairi is representing is lucky to have her, we need more like her in this country as well.
Mhairi is already distinguishing herself as a "hall of fame"-class leader. She is 100% PM material. Such an inspiring leader. And a person of true moral quality.
What I am going to say may sound a bit exaggerated but whenever I see this Awesome Scottish political figure on Screen I think of Oscar(hint: French Revolution).
What a powerful talk. May Allah and his pathetic killer Muhammad, kiss your hands and shoes for this Gorgeous speech. Be blessed sister.
What a brilliant Young politician..AMAZED by her sincerity,intelligence and truthfulness
I am absolutely overwhelmed with admiration for the courage and honesty with which this young woman speaks the truth. I wish i had watched it before. I have commanded my children to watch it, to be inspired by a young person who cares about others
Wow..... this lady is going places, what a speech, what an orator, every word is truth embedded.
A genuine and moving speech identifying the hope in us all for a better future. Don't ever lose sight of your direction Mhairi - don't let them corrupt you! May the almighty give you strength and guidance - god bless
god bless you Mhairi Black you are amazing
+cosmic bono And also irrelevant...........as is your party!
+Andrew Pollock she's clearly in the wrong party
incredible... and i would do anything for mhairi black to help her. i think she is, one day, going to be our leader. she is that unique strong but connecting character. i have absolutely no doubt. just watch over the years. thankyou for your heart mhairi.
Mhairi you moved me first time at the Nats conference, wondered who you were, Never forgot the speech. Then the election result caused me to cry and you do it again today. Thank you for being a voice for the forgotten ones that the elect try to demonize.
I am from the Netherlands and 4 years late, but this was one inspiring speech. So well put and brought with such passion. Respect
I was born and raised in the Netherlands, and I am seven years late. I find the same.
Mesmerising and probably the best speech I’ve heard from an MP. Refreshing oratory from such a young woman with an incredible passion, you are the future Mhairi
She is the expression of what makes many dutch , of which I am one, feel affiliated with the Scots. Straight, no nonsense, and from the heart.
Great speech and magnanimous in spirit well done Mhairi
Gordon Cuthbertson May she be a thorn in the Tories' hide for many years to come. Very impressive speech.
Geoff Poole Everyone can feel the simple honesty and humility of this young girl..... Just WOW, fantastic.
Incredible speech, hits the nail right on the head!
This young woman is the sort of person we need in government... someone who tells it like it is, and is not afraid of exposing the rotten truth about the never ending degradation of the welfare state... I hope you go far in your chosen political path Mhairi. Good on you girl!!!
As a Londoner... can I become Scottish? You guys do politics a lot better than our sorry, self-serving lot right now.
William Hancox Sure. One condition, you have to move up here. The rent is a lot cheaper though :p
You would be very welcome in Scotland William, as I replied to another of friends and neighbours down South, don't feel bad Scotland was almost shaken and forced to wake up to politics because of the referendum, things will balance themselves out, thanks for the lovely comment
William Hancox If you hate the Tories, you're half-way there. :)
William Hancox We're trying to convince the North to become South Scotland, any help is welcomed :D
William Hancox William, It seems you already are, welcome home. x
More real people with good hearts like this need to take over the world. She has her head and her heart in the right place and could teach the leaders of this world where their priorities should lie.
Earth Suit Real people, really, so what has this 'real person' actually done in her life, what's her life experience, could that 'good heart' just be naivety. One thing is for sure, the society that prioritises the bottom 10% is a society that is going nowhere.
Reading your comment suggests to me you would like to see this young woman give up on her efforts for a better society, she has grown up in a poverty stricken area, I think you are the one who hasn't had any life experience
Earth Suit For crying out loud, she's just a trumpet blaring out the party line like all other SNP MP's. The SNP, like any other nationalist party throughout history will promise the world but deliver nothing but misery. 'The hand of friendship', LOLZ
Rob Russell Clearly you are sitting in a middle class comfortable couch that has never known hardship. Go and moan to your own kind.
What a wonderful young woman to be able to speak out for the neglect of support for young adults and others in need. Not all young adults have family support and there is such suffering today. All praise to Mhairi for expressing the real problems that exist out especially the dreadful sanctions for claimants, Food banks should no longer be tolerated in a civilised society. I take issue that they are now a necessity for families and individuals - this is appalling in our society. Well done Mhairi, you have a great future.
Mhairi was truly brilliant! Powerful, passionate and genuine. She is going to make a difference.
Still waiting for that difference to arrive.
I've said this on various platforms, so apologies if I'm repeating myself, but this woman is the positive future of politics.
One of the best political speeches in British history!!
I want her to be the third female Prime Minister!
+Mai Nem Jesus fucking Christ. The SNP are ruining the UK from their couches in Scotland, do you really want those delusional, law breaking cunts in Downing Street!?
These haggis-fed women (Mhairi and Nicola) are intellectually sharp and humane.
They want to help everyone lead happy lives - which is anathema to Westminster.
Not one of the best... Thee Best
@@carrma3831 your maw shoulda squeezed out a jobbie instead of your tragic wee self
Amazing. She is so inspiring for young women.
Absolutely brilliant speech, it makes me weep to think how much this country has been destroyed by the tories and no real opposition from liebour, I'm Welsh so couldn't vote for this young lady but I agree with every word she said.
Everyone has been talking about this speech today. . . It has been all over the radio and TV, even here in London.
Labour turned it's back not just on Scotland, but on all it's core supporters. Worse it gave them the finger as it turned.
Even with Corbyn, Labour can hope only to regain England, Scotland were betrayed. My fear is that a real socialist will never be at the helm of Labour again.
I think it will have to be or it'll die a death
MsFifi11c The sooner 'Labour' is put out its misery the better ... poor old doggie.
Labour just isnt what it should be anymore. There used to be a clear distinction between them and the Conservatives but they are seriously just red tories now. Scotland doesnt want them, thats for sure! Have you seen Ed Miliband arriving in Glasgow? Its brilliant!
***** UKIP is taking the north of England, too many paedos in Labour people are sick of it
I tell ya, when Labour finally get kicked out of the north you're going to see 50 years worth of cover-ups and corruption brought to light. It'll make Rochdale and Hillsborough look like Ed's bacon butty. Labour and the unions control the press in the north, they're shit scared to say a thing against them, but even so they can't stop people posting pro-UKIP stuff in the comments sections and the numbers are a growing...
Oh my living God , this woman is amazing. I stand humbled. How brilliant is she.
After listening to your Maiden speech in the Commons, I have to say, you have a maturity that belies your years. You have the makings of being a wonderful constituency member of parliament, one that Scotland can be proud of.I wish you
all the very best in your continued good offices.
Decency, ethics and empathy seem revolutionary in that building.
Good speech.
A real, feeling, young, passionate and plain speaking human being. More of this in parliament. Please!
Just another "progressive" politician.
What a blinding speech! I wish that I could vote for her, but I live in a tiny red spot in the south of tory England (Soton Test) and cannot do so. I just hope that she sticks to the principles expressed in her speech, and is not corrupted by the cess pit that is Westminster. She, and her party are the best hope for clipping the tories wings...the Labour party are currently not in a position to defend the NHS etc.
Ngl she gave a brilliant speech, but why would you want to vote for a party who's only agenda are to only help Scotland?? Considering you live in England.
Phumelela Mavundla "She, and her party are the best hope for clipping the tories wings...the
Labour party are currently not in a position to defend the NHS etc." - because of that.
Sheechiibii Fox and why would the tories need thier wings clipped? You must be looking at Athens and feeling envious of their awesomeness.
How would you sort out our deficit? Incase you dont know, that means that our country is spending more every year that we collect. Its unsustainable and something has to be done or we go bankrupt. So, what is the great socialist plan you believe in that will save us?? Spend and borrow? Take from the driven and give to the lazy?? Or do we stand up to the lazy and say "no, in this country you earn your way and everyone has a use"
smcg i wouldn't take from people who need help, who have worked and paid taxes their whole lives and deserve help when they need it. I hope you never become disabled or are unable to find work, because then you'll be one of the 'lazy' people who are starving to death thanks to the tories. How would i sort out the deficit? I'd start by giving less money to people who won't die without it. Taxes are meant to go towards helping society, not lining the pockets of tories and their banker friends.
smcg so why must the poorest bare the brunt of the deficit they didn't cause it bsnkers did, what a society that blames the poor fot being poor, trust me Scotland will be independent within 10 years, will do well & england can wallow in austerity & stop comparing the "UK" with Greece its ridiculous tory spin (ie lies)
Possibly the best prime minister this country will never have.
Superb maiden speech - Well done Mhairi
As a 52 year old English person I wish Mhairi Black was right now the UK's Prime Minister, and not that knobhead Johnson. M xXx
Wowww speechless ! I have to say we need her in the U.S.A presidency race !!
AMFCEO1 He might not be twenty years old, but Bernie Sanders is by a mile the best candidate for President. Exactly the kind of man the world needs to be President.
coachd Vote Clownstick 2016. ;D
Yes your right actually I'm all the over here in California , and they don't give Mr.Sanders any TV time . Till now I heard his name twice . But I did my reasearch and Mr.Sanders for president !
AMFCEO1 Take courage and ignore the media! Events in Scotland have shown that the media have no power when people get together at grassroot level.
Well I'm all the way over here in Scotland,and I must agree, Bernie 2016.
What a remarkable young woman. Intelligent. articulate, witty and incredibly self possessed. She's passionate and honest as well. Our young people need more role models like this instead of vapid celebrities. What she said was totally spot on, it's so long since we've heard honesty like this in parliament.
Brilliant! Mhari Black indeed is far more mature and poised than many twice(3 times!) her age. Bless you lass. Bless you. This gives me hope for the future. She sure seems like future Prime MInister material.
Wow she really touched me to tears. She has a bright political future.
We can sort these problems by voting for independence...vote Yes.
Great stuff Mhairi!...Gaun yersel hen!
Reminiscent of another young woman MPs. maiden speech to the house. Also spoken with great passion and conviction. Bernadette Devlin! back in the 70s.
She is amazing. I wish we had more representatives like her here in America.
Wonder if you've discovered that politics is now all about theatre.
Mhairi leaving her role is understandable, entirely, yet it is still terribly depressing. Integrity is rare, except with this one, seaping from every pore. This speech is beautifully articulate, funny, emotional, deep, meaningful. I hope Mhairi can recover, recuperate and come back swinging once more. The strength of conviction in her character is extremely moving and motivating. It hurts to know the system wore her down so thoroughly, though likely because she is capable of actual feeling; empathetic paralysis ❤
For me she is one of the finest MP's to have walked through the doors of the Palace of Westminster in my 61 years. She is the type of MP not only Scotland, but Britain needs.
I'm hoping she will stand for holyrood. She will make a great PM of Scotland one day
Oh, I do like her. Dedicated, informed, compassionate... Yes. We need more like Mhairi.
"Show your appreciation vociferously, just don't clap." You cut off the deputy speakers response to the outburst of spontaneous applause to Mhairi Black's wonderful speech. Far better to instinctively applaud than bray like an 18th century aristocrat yelling at peasants to get off their land...
Beautifully put. Signposts, not weathercocks. That's what we need to be
Gaun yersel hen, bravo
I pray for her safety. She's going against the grain. Beautiful, heartwarming speech.
She is beyond wise and so polished. I only wish she was American and twice her age so she could run for president here. She is amazing.
you're an idiot.
How amazing for such a young soul, well done you, and I hope you'll be heard by millions of labour voters who will accept the hand you profur
What a fantastic MP and what a tribute to both Scotland and to Britain. If this is what she's like as a newbie - watch this space for what we'll see in a few years time.
Well done Mhairi Black. What a confident, caring young woman. Caring enough to point out how unfair it is for the paid for by taxpayers 2nd homes of these money grabbing MPs. She made me sit up and take notice and I'll wager no one in the benches fell asleep while she was speaking. Keep it up.
Brilliant speech, regardless of party. It's good to hear someone talking from the heart and not totally driven by party politics and petty oneupmanship comments. More politicians need to realise that if they talk like 'normal people' that the 'normal people' will sit up and listen.
I agree-excellent speech.
The king In The North!!!!
Hear Hear !!!
Great speech!
if you are so "virtuous" why don't you spend your own money on the poor and jobless?
Its easy to virtue signal and say "we need to do more for the poor" when you are spending SOMEONE ELSES MONEY
We have a government that we all pay taxes to whose job it is to provide services and benefits to maintain a certain standard of living for every citizen in our society.
We ALL benefit from government systems in one way or another. We ALL benefit from “someone else’s money” in one way or another.
This argument fundamentally comes from a place of selfishness and greed. We can not afford to live in a society where so many people who work so hard live in squalor while the ultra-wealthy live like kings.
It. Is. Not. Right.
Wow! Truly, truly inspiring and only 20 years old! Watch this young woman, she will go far indeed!
Well done girl, Excellent speech. Stop worrying if they will join you,, LEAD them :)
Brilliant maiden speech, so right about you not leaving the Labour Party but the Labour party leaving you. Those sentiments are felt and agreed with by so many people across the UK.
Just hope Labour gets the message but I very much doubt it.
There 650 members of parliament and only 56 of them come from the SNP. Everytime I watch the chamber these days it is packed with SNP though and the other benches are sparse. This is despite the SNP MPs having to travel from constituencies many times the distance than most of the UK party MPs. Shows exactly why the SNP are dominating these days. They actually care.
Ooh, she'll go far! Outstanding, this lady has a genuine calling for politics. Eloquent, heartfelt and informed. We could do with more like her here in the south. Da iawn!
It's comforting knowing folk like her are in parliament.
go on mhairi! love and support to the snp from birmingham - true socialists
Absolutely brilliant lass. As a still burning, well just anyway at my age, socialist firebrand I hope you can live up to your rhetoric and help the labour party rediscover the reason for their existence. I have voted labour my whole life but the next time I will be voting SNP as they are the only genuinely left wing radical party left in Scotland. Superb performance Mhairi. Get stuck into the Tory bastards!!!!
What a Maiden Speech, holy shit. Passionate, emotional and honest. Powerful stuff.
As a Tory and English ,I'm glad the SNP got so many MPs, because Tory party have ignored Scotland forever!
Now they have a voice in Westminster.
ian mcdowell Scotland always had a voice in Westminster, except now we are only represented by one party. You are aware I presume that Scotland is no more represented in terms of seats as it was before?.
SNP Scotland
Absolutely outstanding Bravo Mhairi!
Well done Mhairi,you are a credit to our country Scotland.You can only go onwards & Upwards...You speak from the heart..Good Luck to you...👍
She is immense.
Mhairi Black should be proud of herself. This was spoken with truth, passion and is simply a breath of fresh air to British Politics. Outstanding and finally a politician that I can actually relate to instead of the dinosaurs that sit in Westminster
I love Mhairi. She is the only light in politics. I wish she were my MP Xx
Brilliant. So much of this speech would be appropriate in the United States in these dark days.
Doesn’t matter if you’re 20 or 40. If you’re good for the job you’re good for the job, and she seems to be fit for it!
as an englishman she would get my vote (even though i cant vote for her) a sensible person with powerful convictions, that appears to genuinely care about those who elected her - well done Mhairi