@Li F if you know anything about m'sia, then you'd know they are the most passive aggressive people.... especially the Malays. Aku orang melayu, but even I know some people who peddle ketuanan bs but then buckle the minute you ask them to act on it. It's all rhetoric and for show. I believe the young generation are fed up dengan orang tua punya kerja... I don't live there, but I still want to see M'sia be for all MALAYSIANS.
3:54 "Someone can be both Malay, a dominant group, and Christian, a non-dominant group." Oof in theory it should work like that, but in reality religion was never a personal matter in Malaysia.
3:54 - "Someone can be both Malay [ethnicity] -- a dominant group -- and Christian, a non-dominant cultural group..." Although this example may work elsewhere, this is a poor example in context of Malaysia, as this will almost NEVER happen /or will never be allowed to happen (politically); as the definition of being Malay [ethnicity] is explicitly defined in the highest law of the land, The Malaysian constitution 160(2) which states: "Malay" means a person who professes the religion of Islam, habitually speaks the Malay language, conforms to Malay custom..."
Well articulated and explained video. Was surprised to see my country highlighted in the thumbnail. Coming from Malaysia myself, it’s upsetting and disgusting that some politicians in Malaysia hide behind religion to divide and conquer. Often, they equate race to be the same as religion. They even claim the Malay word of Allah to be exclusively used for Muslims only. Holy scriptures and Malay Christian bibles were banned because politicians took claim to language. It’s utterly disgusting. Xenophobia is a cancer in society that needs to be removed. Thanks for highlighting this. Much ❤️
I found this very helpful. It concisely explains the idea of culture in a scholastic way yet still shows consideration for the people it uses as examples. Nice.👍
Half my family is from KL, and it was great seeing familiar places featured on a CC video. KL is a beautiful place, and I encourage everyone to visit if they can :)
I'm very happy with this video. Understanding culture is very important, but it often gets overlooked especially when not accustomed to encountering cultures other than your own.
Welcome to Montreal! I had the same culture shock as you but in reverse when I travelled to New York to visit my friends! ("What?! All the packaging is in English?!" 😆)
at minutes 3.54, Alize said "Someone can be both Malay--a dominant group -- and Christian". as far as i remember Malays cannot be Christians. Lina Joy went to court because she wanted to be identified as a Malay Christian but she lost her case...😊
would have loved for you to have mentioned the California Genocide but thank you for mentioning residential schools and forced assimilation-great video as always!
3:55 - Can a Malay individual have Christianity as his/her religion? Because from what I know, it is almost impossible for a Malay individual to be a Christian due to the strict Syariah law. Please educate me on this :)
This is refreshing to see attention brought to this. Maybe if more people know about this globally the Canadian government will try to help the First Nations communities rather than have symbolic holidays and false promises.
I can tell this is going to be a totally enlightening series and will absolutely not create racial/cultural division through historical struggle sessions.
Great episode packed with learning opportunities. Thank you. I wish my social studies courses in high school were this well produced and informative. Bravo.
6:55 People adopt a culture that they look up to. People make fun of a culture that they look down on. Cultural appropriation is not a negative thing. Cultural degradation is.
Grew up in Ithaca huh? Given its 10 square miles surrounded by realilty I'm not too surprised you had major culture shock. FWIW my ex- father-in-law lived in the residential "schools" near Hagersville, Ontario. He called it "The Hole." He was a tough guy but every time he talked about it, he would start to shake.
We lived several years in the southern tier of New York (not far from Ithaca). We constantly drove to Toronto, Montreal, Quebec, and Manhattan to get away from the cultural desert that is most of the USA. We ate real food and sat in cafes and subways and sucked in the different skin colors and languages. It did not matter that we did not understand many of the languages and did not look like many of the people. We just needed to see some diversity. Then we went back to a pearly white place where Taco Bell is considered ethnic. We left for good 8 years ago.
It’s still recent enough tho folks still alive to carry the memory. And the mental scars. Trauma can also be carried down through generations so the “history” is still very much affecting people today.
@@chad_b well newfoundland and nova Scotia do have their own unique customs and dialects, New Brunswick is officially bilingual, so other than Ontario the east is quite different from the rest of Canada.
I'm from Malaysia, so I was intrigued by the Malaysian flag in the thumbnail. Then the video starts with a shot of Montreal, where I now live. :)
Yay Malaysia represent 🇲🇾
A beautiful multicultural country...with politicians trying to break us apart 😔
@Li F if you know anything about m'sia, then you'd know they are the most passive aggressive people.... especially the Malays. Aku orang melayu, but even I know some people who peddle ketuanan bs but then buckle the minute you ask them to act on it. It's all rhetoric and for show. I believe the young generation are fed up dengan orang tua punya kerja... I don't live there, but I still want to see M'sia be for all MALAYSIANS.
3:54 "Someone can be both Malay, a dominant group, and Christian, a non-dominant group."
Oof in theory it should work like that, but in reality religion was never a personal matter in Malaysia.
thank you for the reminder of how unique and beautiful Malaysia is! living here can make you lose sight of that 😭♥️🇲🇾
Any proud Malaysian in here? 👐✨
If you are, surely you can identify yourself with crispy rendang 😆
Hmmm yes, crispy rendang best rendang
3:54 - "Someone can be both Malay [ethnicity] -- a dominant group -- and Christian, a non-dominant cultural group..."
Although this example may work elsewhere, this is a poor example in context of Malaysia, as this will almost NEVER happen /or will never be allowed to happen (politically); as the definition of being Malay [ethnicity] is explicitly defined in the highest law of the land, The Malaysian constitution 160(2) which states: "Malay" means a person who professes the religion of Islam, habitually speaks the Malay language, conforms to Malay custom..."
Well articulated and explained video.
Was surprised to see my country highlighted in the thumbnail.
Coming from Malaysia myself, it’s upsetting and disgusting that some politicians in Malaysia hide behind religion to divide and conquer.
Often, they equate race to be the same as religion. They even claim the Malay word of Allah to be exclusively used for Muslims only. Holy scriptures and Malay Christian bibles were banned because politicians took claim to language. It’s utterly disgusting.
Xenophobia is a cancer in society that needs to be removed.
Thanks for highlighting this.
Much ❤️
I found this very helpful. It concisely explains the idea of culture in a scholastic way yet still shows consideration for the people it uses as examples. Nice.👍
Half my family is from KL, and it was great seeing familiar places featured on a CC video. KL is a beautiful place, and I encourage everyone to visit if they can :)
As a Malaysian I feel proud. Culturally we are diverse, though I do wish we can see past our differences and act together as one country.
I'm very happy with this video. Understanding culture is very important, but it often gets overlooked especially when not accustomed to encountering cultures other than your own.
I'm glad you're covering this element of geography - I happen to find it the coolest and most interesting.
Welcome to Montreal! I had the same culture shock as you but in reverse when I travelled to New York to visit my friends! ("What?! All the packaging is in English?!" 😆)
at minutes 3.54, Alize said "Someone can be both Malay--a dominant group -- and Christian". as far as i remember Malays cannot be Christians. Lina Joy went to court because she wanted to be identified as a Malay Christian but she lost her case...😊
would have loved for you to have mentioned the California Genocide but thank you for mentioning residential schools and forced assimilation-great video as always!
3:55 - Can a Malay individual have Christianity as his/her religion? Because from what I know, it is almost impossible for a Malay individual to be a Christian due to the strict Syariah law.
Please educate me on this :)
I am Indonesian Muslim.
I promise i will always welcoming refugees as long as the dont disrupt my values. Refugees are welcome here...
❤ from 🇲🇾 to the CrashCourse Geography team!
This is refreshing to see attention brought to this.
Maybe if more people know about this globally the Canadian government will try to help the First Nations communities rather than have symbolic holidays and false promises.
It’s sad what our county has done to First Nations and how much it’s tries to avoid accountability
Even within the US Culture Shock is a thing. I found moving from Chicago to Rural Missouri about as tough as moving from Chicago to Shenzhen
Whoaaa. Malaysia make it to Crash Course Geography! A mix Malay-Chinese Malaysian here.
Great to see appropriate definitions of terms that are tossed around without much thought 👍👍
I'm from Malaysia, there is so much truth in this video. The good and the bad
I can tell this is going to be a totally enlightening series and will absolutely not create racial/cultural division through historical struggle sessions.
Great episode packed with learning opportunities. Thank you. I wish my social studies courses in high school were this well produced and informative. Bravo.
This explains perfectly why the topics of race, culture and ethnicity are very hard to talk about.
Thank you.
I’m taking cultural geography this fall
I'm loving where this course is going 😊
Great video!
GL Wiley Opportunity Center High School, Waco, Texas! We watch EVERY DAY!!!!!!!
6:55 People adopt a culture that they look up to. People make fun of a culture that they look down on. Cultural appropriation is not a negative thing. Cultural degradation is.
Grew up in Ithaca huh? Given its 10 square miles surrounded by realilty I'm not too surprised you had major culture shock.
FWIW my ex- father-in-law lived in the residential "schools" near Hagersville, Ontario. He called it "The Hole." He was a tough guy but every time he talked about it, he would start to shake.
We lived several years in the southern tier of New York (not far from Ithaca). We constantly drove to Toronto, Montreal, Quebec, and Manhattan to get away from the cultural desert that is most of the USA. We ate real food and sat in cafes and subways and sucked in the different skin colors and languages. It did not matter that we did not understand many of the languages and did not look like many of the people. We just needed to see some diversity. Then we went back to a pearly white place where Taco Bell is considered ethnic. We left for good 8 years ago.
Thanks for those valuable information!
Loving the series, from Hanoi Vietnam ;)
I loved the video! Human geography episodes are going to be great .
So important, so necessary. Thank you and keep up the good work.
You should make a malay subtitle, i believe this video will be good for malaysian
another great video :DD
@10:04 ...and the Bahai's in Iran
We live in a society.
Yeay...Malaysia🇲🇾🤘
This was such a great video!
The comments are going to be wild.☠
"This is not History, the last school closed in 1996." I find that sentence confusing.
Except one cannot be Malay and Christian at least not officially
I figured you'd have enough culture shock just seeing milk in plastic bags, eh?
Hello big like thanks for this good video see you later my friend top quality 🙏 👍
Delicate things presented in such an American way
Is that bonjour hello thing true because when I was in Canada I never heard anyone say that (Although I was in Alberta)
As I understand it is mostly a montreal thing/urban Quebec.
JTLYK
Majority the Malay can’t be a Christian in Malaysia
Because there are kinda strict law of Islam
Suddenly i felt like this image are from Tamil India not kuala lumpur Malaysia 3:22
could you please do the crash course of HISTORY OF ART???😍😍😍😍❤️❤️I woul be very happyHISTORY OF ART
So many people believe they’re the ones leaving the FIRST comment because it’s not showing them the full comment section, guess why.
Great video good shit crash course
I see Malaysia flag I CLICK ✨✨
you sound like harper from wizards of waverly place
Bonjour hi! Makes purist french goes nut in Montreal :D
DiVErSITy IS oUr StReNgTh
How is it not?
Yes, that's actually correct
yes?
It is.
Most of the time yeah, but who gives a shit about the 95% of the time where things are fine and most people barely even notice the differences.
❤️🇲🇾
Why the dislikes? Which of the scientifically proven facts presented in this video hurt conservatives this time?
"This is not history" Aauhhh, technically 20 years is the accepted "This is history" deadline.
It’s still recent enough tho folks still alive to carry the memory. And the mental scars. Trauma can also be carried down through generations so the “history” is still very much affecting people today.
"Because culture is always changing. "
So it is transient, impermanent and therefore not of any lasting value.
There you go using logic and reasoning again, we just can't have that now! 😉
If you go to any other part of Canada the culture is basically the same haha. It's just the east coast that is different.
There are still distinct differences from BC, to Alberta, to the prairies, to Ontario. Each has various different viewpoints and priorities.
@@chad_b well newfoundland and nova Scotia do have their own unique customs and dialects, New Brunswick is officially bilingual, so other than Ontario the east is quite different from the rest of Canada.
It definitely changes...dialect thoughts, beliefs, etc. It's a lot more diverse than you think...than Canada even thinks.
How can we apreciate diverse cultures when we are supposed to mishmash it all together?
👏👏🖖
The Bell Curve.
Are you talking about IQ?
What?
has been debunked
I have an 80 iq and what is this
what does that shit have to do with this
I thought RUclips was down too for a second but turns out I'm just the first comment
But you weren't genius
I think you mixed up RUclips with Facebook for a moment there... 😃
Great video, but the Uyghers have not been proven to be suffering any sort of genocide.
Prove it. As far as we know, the authoritarian Chinese government is committing a genocide.
I do find the cannibalistic cultures of Papua New Guinea and the Amazon quiteequal and beautiful to that of the western civilization #RefugeesWelcome
Didn’t want to mention black Americans huh 😒
what would you have wanted them to include?
♥ ♥
❤
First
first
1st comment