This is so crazy. This show is one of my favorites, always something interesting being discussed, deep dive topics and perspectives. As a viewer I always felt like you guys go out of your way to be fair to the guests and present info in an unbiased way. I hope they will reconsider.
How ridiculous, right!? I haven't followed Mark's podcast in a while cause I wasn't much of a fan of Nsema (however you spell his name), but that's still just crazy to me... What a mess.
This is madness. If Mark Bell can get instantly removed from RUclips for allegedly “dangerous” content for making an awesome podcast about health and fitness, then they can justify deleting anyone for any reason.
@amazin7006 what? That's a pretty naive take, not to mention they don't even give you an explanation as to how they make the decisions they make. They don't even follow their own guidelines (which aren't even well defined in the first place) because there are countless things they leave up on this site that are infinitely worse than the people they censor. Mark didn't simply "brag about steroids" anyways, so you're defeating your own argument.
@@amazin7006 how's that boot leather taste. they're far too in bed with the government to be considered a private company. you know google owns youtube right?
@@amazin7006 they cant just act as private company any more than Facebook can. This is a serious problem when the platform reaches is magnitude of size
Companies that fund the ads make the rules. RUclips is a private platform, not public. Break the ToS, they can do whatever they want. YT is in the wrong here but being we agree to their terms, not much we can do. If we don't want this kind of "censorship", we have to go back to pre-Google RUclips where there were no ads but also no payouts. No money to be made. Wherever money is made by ads, the corps putting the money into the ads end up making the rules 😔
@@Real28pretty much so we are stuck in a way. Unless Rumble can make massive improvements and start to compete but then they will run into similar problems down the road
The ad companies could give a shot about the content they are worried about the activist organizations putting them on blast and threatening boycotts. This is most likely a government campaign to censor “disinformation” that questions the scientific orthodoxy on healthcare. YT just demonized doctors who advocate diets like keto claiming that to dangerous for the public. I think it Dr Eric berg if I’m not mistaken. At the end of the day the elites don’t want us communicating alternatives. We must defer to the government on issues. Remember the most dangerous thing facing us today is not war or collapsing economy; it’s misinformation and disinformation. Their words not mine.
@@brianmeen2158 Rumble is a private company too and relies on advertisers. Even if they become mainstream, mainstream demand means mainstream advertisers, which means mainstream rules.
This is ironic because in a world of juicing influencers Mark and co were probably some of the most open and responsible people to talk about strength sport, peds etc. YT is loosing its mind.
ooooh . That'll do it. kratom is not quiet a full opiate but it's not something you should use unless you're ironically trying to get off of actual opiates and then stop kratom too. @@floridamanHooning
@@floridamanHooninglol i stopped watching after his producer had a sarms salesman shill his sarms to him, took like 5 sarms at once with no test base, crashed his T and proceeded to go on pellet trt within a month. Shit was the funniest series ive ever seen
@@floridamanHooningHow does someone get you addicted to opioids? He forced pills down their throats? Your decisions are your decisions. You should ge boycotting doctors as well. RUclips is not a private corporation. They have special section 230 immunities to shield them from lawsuits. They have an obligation to operate as a platform and not as a publisher. Outside of removing illegal content censorship should not exist on their platform.
Didn’t realize this even happened, thanks for the video - Mark has made great content for years, as straightforward and well intentioned as they come from everything I’ve ever seen.
Mark Bell was my lockdown training partner. His channel served an important purpose for me during those times and though I don't watch a lot of his recent content, I will always be grateful for his openness and efforts to connect with his viewers.
@@uns33n I used to think Derek was a cool guy once, but its all about the money realy. Turkesterone and microneedeling for hairloss is the biggest scams so far.
I don't have a yt channel but I've noticed comments of mine that are critical of psychiatry for instance getting removed. It is pretty frightening as people won't know what they are getting into if experiences aren't allowed to be shared. Just like with steroids. It's not like people are going to stop using them if they are interested in it. But they'll be doing it less informed. Of course specifically "pro steroids" content should be reviewed carefully, but if it is a nuanced information to begin with there should be no problem.
I can't believe Mark Bell out of everyone. I mean i think YT censorship is beyond ridiculous but the Power Project specifically is so nuanced and full of really solid fitness info on all fronts. What a bizarre first martyr choice by YT.
This is the issue with broad support of a couple of platforms owned by the largest tech comanies... People didn't habe to create the platform themselves but they also don't retain ultimate control of their own content. Creators and consumers will have to act otherwise this will definitely get worse imo.
I flew into Sacramento one day. Drove immediately to Mark’s gym. I got a selfie with him and his brother Chris then left….They were both unbelievably kind…love you Mark, Nsima, Andrew
hate to be that guy but this discussion has been going on for nearly a decade with youtube and social media censorship. It's just now seeming a little more real to some people because it's in their circle of attention, the fitness industry niche in this case. Censorship and authoritarianism always begin in a way that can be sold to the public, once they're normalized, they can spread
Censorship for sure but how exactly is the private company RUclips “Authoritarians”? it’s a company for videos it’s not the government. The private company is doing what it deems best for its own interests. Much like Mark or any of these channels, In this case with Marks channel it seems way off base but i dont see how a private company doing whats it believes is in its own interests, would be Authoritarians.
I work at a gym Mark comes to pretty often, the guy is nothing but helpful and kind and only wants the best for everyone in their pursuit of self development and betterment of themselves. I pray he gets his channel back 🙏
Wow holy shit I just realized what this video is about. Why would RUclips do that?! So much amazing and insightful content just gone like that. They’ll come back right?
Somehow, the answer is money. That's always the answer to corporate decisions. If it doesn't benefit the company financially, gone. They don't care about right or wrong. They care about profits.
Absolutely insane! They’ll do whatever they can to shut someone up if they want to. Mark revolutionized content creation in this space and it shouldn’t be taken so lightly that he was abruptly removed from it
I used to make money from instagram and once they demonetized it just wasn’t worth it anymore. I went and by hand removed almost 10k followers and set my account to private. That instagram has been my training journal since I started to learn weightlifting from Alex Lee in 2017. Contemplating going and screen recording my entire profile as a backup because I just don’t trust these massive social media companies anymore. It’s getting easier and easier now to pull the plug on my smart phone with how social media is unraveling. Time to disconnect.
Something that sucks about this is that it undercuts all of the content that talks about the downsides of PEDs. People are going to look at nuanced content from people like Derek and Greg who legitimately discuss the pros and cons of ped use and think that they are exaggerating the cons in order to appease youtube.
I'm both shocked and not shocked. I bet not a single channel that promotes hormones for changing your gender will have their channels shut down but Mark Bell's channel that is all about working out, proper diet, and using PED's in a healthy way is shut down. They want all men to act like stereotypical male feminists. Strong men are a threat to the machine.
100%. Chemically altering yourself with limited long term data is fine to RUclips as long as it's LGBT but knowing how to use PED's safely is a big no no
Imagine being a male feminist in ‘24. Information is free - the internet is vast. It’s not difficult to find info on feminism and its relation to Marxism. Yet you still have men and women believing in said toxic ideology. Insanity.
I am from Sacramento & I have known Mark Bell for about (12) years. He has always been a straight shooter & has the best interest of his followers, etc. Mark doesn’t need RUclips, RUclips needs Mark Bell.
This is interesting in my ai ethics class we discussed stuff like this, my teacher told me, in europe we will soon have laws to control stuff like this. RUclips is damn near a monopoly and as such, then cant just act as a "private" company. Basically the laws are going to protect people like youtubers from gettin unjustly banned, just like a worker getting fired for no reason.
RUclips (and Google obviously) are 100% monopolies. They have used antitrust breaking practices to kill all possible competitors. Every boot licker saying they're a private company & can do whatever they like have no principles & believe in nothing. At this point it's clear only the EU will take any action against Google.
I highly doubt laws will be put into place to protect anyone but RUclips. You got to realize, the ultimate purpose of RUclips and similar apps is to control and distort your perception, drive agendas that the elites want and push propaganda. It is obvious and has been obvious since Covid started - even large channels get abused by RUclips - there are no monetary considerations.
I can never wrap my head around this kind of madness. Rarely anything controversial is ever going on with the channel. If anything, Mark Bell and the team has been so helpful in terms of understanding fitness. Funny how RUclips slam them down meanwhile Nikocado Avocado and whoever creator known for raunchy content gets to slip on by. Yes, RUclips is a private platform and they have the final say on whatever. However, it does come off as something so heavy-handed. Online censorship is hella weird.
I don't buy into the conspiracies, there are tons of channels that talk about "equipped" lifting and thrive on youtube. Most likely some minimum-wage-earning content moderator made a bad judgment call on it and now youtube is seeing how big of a backlash this will generate and whether they can stand behind the bad judgment call or have to reinstate the channel. Their content moderation is and always has been trash.
youtube can easily blame it on the steroids being the reason while hiding that its the carnivore promotion that was the actual reason.. Why is Rich Pianas channel still up?
No, their stupid AI censorship program eliminates any channel talking about drugs in a way that the AI program doesn't like. You can write to YT and all you get are automated replies. YT is run by clowns.
Yes, they are on YT, but for how long? Dr. Eric Berg just got censored, and he is not a dedicated carnivore. These bastards are determined that you "eat zee bugz", and anything that gets in the way will be suppressed. Just my opinion BTW, but I don't think I am far off the mark.@@JeffO-
....Mark bell's channel removed, thats absolutely insane. Watched the guy since the day i started training over a decade ago, hell i got a slingshot ages ago aswell. So the 1 channel that was the most open and honest about steroid and steroid safety to be carefull, gets banned in 2024 for mentioning steroids? When every newer channel openly discusses it to an insane amount and dont get banned, i can only remember "docter tony huge" getting removed because he went "to far" besides that everything was almost allways allowed, and it sure didnt get your channel just REMOVED fully. Maybe with the support from other youtubers this can get overthrown because it makes no fucking sense, the bell family has been making great stuff for that long and to just get removed is crazy.
Mark was right he made a community post on RUclips saying he uses steroids not TRT and he does it for his personal enjoyment, RUclips probably saw that as him promoting the use of substances
Dude mark bell was such a inspiration to me. Him and all the guests he had on his channel provided so much information for strength athletes and enthusiasts alike.
Mark Bell is definitely OG. I remember him from -Bigger Stronger Faster- I wonder if other hormone treatments or procedures are deemed as harmful by You Tube?
All the big social media platforms are run in a way where they can take everything you have and not even tell you why. It has already happened to plenty of content creators, some of them small, some of them huge. Just look at what happened to Dr Disrespect on Twitch. I know that at least Hydrid Calisthenics cross-posts on Rumble. They just post the same video here and there (or at least used to). I feel like that's a fairly smart move, getting another basket for your eggs with very little additional work.
RUclips has had problems forever. But it definitely seems to be getting worse. People that rely on YT for income shouldn't be able to be pushed off the platform without detailed and reasonable evidence, rather than just a generic blanket statement.
I got to be honest here, it kind of reminds me of the Joe rogan whole thing. Getting on different platforms. And tailoring content towards, or inside the guide lines seems to be the right way to go. Crazy stuff. Personally I would want some one to make a RUclips creators union. Its pretty fair if you think about it, job is a job.
THANK GOD his original channel didn’t get taken down. There is sooooo much gold on that channel from years ago with all the powerlifting greats. Go watch ‘em all now before that’s gone too.
Insane reaction by RUclips. I've seen saying for a decade now, that I'd hate to have RUclipsr as a career. You can NEVER trust the RUclips team. They will stab you in the back in an instant and leave you penniless.
And it has only become WORSE during that decade of observing them ruin people over bad decisions. RUclips is a woke company run by ideologues. They do not run their company to make money. They do not run their company to be fair. They run their company to push their preferred agenda and hurt people who don't fit within it.
During cov*** they became hysterical about punishing and holding their creators "within line". It's still going on and people still can even write certain words even void of of any "dangerous opinions". Another example is that people have now spent years having to say "un-alive" rather than what they're trying to relay, because it was used in a joke RUclips doesn't like.
RUclips is a on a Twitch trajectory. As the cheap money runs out, they'll have to make a business decision to not be an activist platform anymore or lose out to a new contender. IBM used to be THE computer company, MyFace THE social media network, Office THE productivity suite; until they weren't. I wish them luck with this amazing strategy or pissing off their paying users and sole revenue stream. 🙂
@@irfuel I think it's more so that office is just is word processing software now, and full on productivity suites like google docs/drive are overtaking it for free.
@@irfuel in the 90s and 2000s, the first thing anyone would install was Office or Works if it weren't already installed. Now it's given away free with a $ 10-a-month Outlook email account, and even still, I haven't bothered installing it in over a decade. People forward documents in PDF pretty regularly now too so even just a documents reader usage case is far from the defacto standard it was prior.
@@adampb23 No real compeition for it. There's many more visually pleasing word processing apps, especially on mac than word, but even google sheets can't compete with excel.
To be fair, if someone like Natural Hypertrophy could get his channel back, why couldn't Mark? Mark is a much, much bigger deal with way more views. People just have to rally round and support him, keep spamming RUclips to put the channel back up.
About a year ago I believe, Natural Hypertrophy got his channel unfairly taken down because of an anime company and YT but despite the odds the community gathered and revived his channel. Hope for something similar to happen with Mark's podcast.
It is sad, sorry for Mark. But use it as a lesson RUclipsrs, get an alternative channel on another platform like Uncle Joe, leading the pack. The adult viewer will follow. RUclipsrs work for RUclips and you can get sacked just like that 💥
That sucks. Never watched his content much but he's been around for as long as I've been watching fitness content. Unfortunately this is something all youtubers must live with, at any second your channel and everything you've worked for can be deleted. There doesn't need to be any real reason either. It sucks but it's something we all know can happen.
These guys will still have a voice but their reach will be greatly diminished without youtube. It hits home because I’ve been very positively influenced by Natural Hypertrophy and he went through a ban scare before I found his channel.
It's been a while since i saw one of your video, been really busy, but you're still one of the guys i prefer listening to ! It's crazy what happened to Mark's podcast !
It's the AI. The sheer amount of video uploads and watch hours this platform is churning out is hard to wrap your head around. That coupled with companies like RUclips announcing layoffs for the sake of implementing AI to replace that workforce is going to create many more situations like this in the future. The rules are changing as RUclips is no longer the wild west of viewing consumption but rapidly replacing mainstream sources and becoming the prime source. Sorry to hear this happened!
Don't think thats how it works. Yes maybe if you have 100 subscribers but I am sure there are thresholds here where an AI decision will get double checked by a human. The said fitness channel I belive meets that criteria.
@@DConnectEmpire One of RUclipss biggest Instagram marketing channels recently got a copyright strike from Instagram itself for using it's logo in his videos. He was in danger of losing the entire channel. It turned out to be exactly this case, AI false-positive copyright flag. How big the channel is has nothing to do with it.
When Google bought RUclips I wondered how they'd mess it up. This is one detail. I did go to Spotify to listen to Rogan's podcast. I'm headed there now to catch Mark's podcast.
One of the most consistent policies youtube has had over the years has been no promoting steroids. You cant go through his library and tell me with a straight face he hasnt promoted steroids over the years. Not saying its right, but that would be my guess.
It's literally one of the most common topics right now, I haven't seen anybody get banned for it yet. I don't understand how you could consider it one of their "most consistent" policies if it's never enforced
It's so hard to even begin to guess why it was taken down, but I will admit they have walked a thin line for a long time... in terms of addressing topics that RUclips may not like (i.e. PEDs). As a trainer, I am obviously against them losing their channel. It could have been a channel flag driven by AI... it could have been a Google Exec finding their teenage child watching one of their podcasts on gear, then sending a few texts, and boom the channel is gone. You never know, and when you walk that line, you run a risk. I'm not surprised they lost their channel, and I think they'll get it back. Hopefully.
It is a combination of everything. All in different ratios for each case. AI monitoring, unapproved discourse, questioning the narrative, perhaps a rogue agent within RUclips. But you’re right, no one in the fitness industry is big enough for RUclips to even take a second glance at. And so another one bites the dust.
Also wanna say how much I appreciate everything you do, Zack. Your unbridled sincerity and unwavering authenticity is inspiring, and so, SO NECESSARY in this space..
I'm so upset I wrote RUclips a letter. Mark is such a good guy and a helpful and sincerely good health advocate. Just seeing the change i his body and the way he conducts interviews is topnotch.
Dude I couldn't imagine building a following and a channel and loosing it like that. I've recorded so many clips but never bothered to edit them or even plan to film things I do but once I'm in the moment its a lot of extra work and time to set up shots and film. I have a ton of respect for those who actually take time to do this. People that haven't edited videos or compiled clips have no clue the work involved with little to no reward for most.
This is actually great news. Totally sucks for Mark, he's a great person but EVERY fitness RUclipsr over the last 3 years talk about NOTHING but cycles, steroids and how to use them. It's ridiculous and dangerous. There's now 14 year olds on RUclips documenting their cycles and it puts a bad face on the subject. Stop talking about steroids for Christ sake. If you can't get views without talking about drugs, then maybe you need to find a new job.
Incredible I was since a week thinking WTF was happening that they don't post anything....maybe the podcast that more change my new chapter of healthy life. Honest content.... Unbelievable, sad to know
This is a shame, but there seems to be a serious pattern occurring even for small fish like me. Had my Instagram/Facebook account of 7 and 15 years respectively deleted for supposedly being “hacked” but had no email to ask if there was a mysterious login…nothing. And there’s no one to talk to either or to try and find out what happened. Then I just receive an email saying your accounts have been deleted and you will not get them back. No explanation or questions…just deleted. There’s something strange going on and now I’m looking for other platforms with better security and more freedom to start again. Even thinking to going back to an old school blog style website as at least can be independent and not be controlled by the likes Mega and Google. 15 years of content all gone and no one to talk to about it. But like Mark Bell, you just got to get up and do your steps. Can’t imagine what it’s like for him with so much content and subscribers, etc. However, this is a strong signal that these guys have too much control and these spaces are not safe. Great video and know Mark will come back stronger. We need to start looking for the next move.
It's ridiculous they won't explain what the cause was. How are people ever supposed to know where the line is? This could all be for something none of us are guessing - we simply don't know. I've met Mark in person a few times and, unlike many here, I really don't care to ever see him again. But I have never seen anything from any of his content that I thought put him at risk for this. This is crazy.
I recall just the other day reading a (youtube) post by Mark putting steroids in the same light as coffee, alcohol, etc. I'm not commenting on whether or not he was right to do this, rather, "steroids" are illegal and he kinda forced their hand i guess? It does suck because he is being more transparent and not hiding behind the legally ok, "TRT" language as many others do. Idk, thats just my prevailing theory as to what was the final straw.
Ayyyy, glad to see more people becoming aware to how awful youtube as a platform is! Metal Outlaw, Louis Rossmann, Bluedrake42, among many others have espoused how this platform has been slowly spiraling downwards for the past 10 years. Truthfully, its as Zack says, there isnt a platform with as big of a brand recognition that’ll net them the same support and income as RUclips currently does. My personal choice of alternative platform is Odysee, but anything open-sourced and not beholden to a corporation, shareholder, or government would work.
Mark Bell, I have listened to you for years, and I have enjoyed many of your topics of discussion, thank you for all the information that that you have shared. RUclips, WHAT ARE YOU UP TO!!!!! freedom of speach!!!!
RUclips is like a neighborhood cop that doesn't like your car whether or not you're violating any laws whatsoever that bully cop is going to pull you over take time out of your life give you stress ect... just because he doesn't like your car and content creators need to take them to court and make them prove that there's a violation of their policies because in some cases this is the creators livelihood
RUclips is a platfom.... Creators didn't create source code for the front and backend components of the platform.... Creators have use the platform provided to post thier content and capitalize on it based on a number of factors. People who say they are creators should recognize these realities be willing to invest in contingencies to maitain thier established reach.... Unless they are willing to self censor and jusy complain about appealing to the algo gods....
Super important that people are honest about what it takes to look a certain way, or to achieve certain lifting goals We arent delusional we know gear is " essential" we/youtube need to grow up & understand that ... this isn't a taboo subject ... people are experimenting in dangerous ways, there needs to be a forum for honesty, caution & guidance We know our sports heroes are on gear, we know our favourite fitness personalities are on gear ... its not promoting taking gear to talk about it, it's just a reflection of our current reality
WE BACK BABY! Thank you Zack for your Support. We'll explain everything in a podcast coming out on our channel today.
was it the smell?
Right on man!! I already sent youtube a letter but oh well! Great news!
We'll be back guys. Zack, thanks for making this video brotha.
This is so crazy. This show is one of my favorites, always something interesting being discussed, deep dive topics and perspectives. As a viewer I always felt like you guys go out of your way to be fair to the guests and present info in an unbiased way. I hope they will reconsider.
For sure, We will wait and support your channel, still.
This shit is getting out of hand.
Yall are on Rumble?
Bro I would go to rumble to listing to the vids or any other platform give the details when u do PLS.
We’ve got everything on Spotify and Apple. Some episodes are on rumble, but not all.
Meanwhile Nikocado Avocado still has his channel.
Yeah and F to M trans people can inject test on air wtf.
cope 😂
@@welanduzfullo8496watch out everybody, we got ourselves an edge lord out here!
How ridiculous, right!? I haven't followed Mark's podcast in a while cause I wasn't much of a fan of Nsema (however you spell his name), but that's still just crazy to me... What a mess.
@@L1TEW8IGHTdude how could you not like Nsema hes one of the most likable guys on RUclips
This is madness. If Mark Bell can get instantly removed from RUclips for allegedly “dangerous” content for making an awesome podcast about health and fitness, then they can justify deleting anyone for any reason.
Duh, it's a private company. They delete anything that goes against what their advertisers demand. Simply don't brag about steroids and you're fine
@amazin7006 what? That's a pretty naive take, not to mention they don't even give you an explanation as to how they make the decisions they make. They don't even follow their own guidelines (which aren't even well defined in the first place) because there are countless things they leave up on this site that are infinitely worse than the people they censor.
Mark didn't simply "brag about steroids" anyways, so you're defeating your own argument.
@@amazin7006 how's that boot leather taste. they're far too in bed with the government to be considered a private company. you know google owns youtube right?
Meanwhile you can watch literal porn in yt. 😂
@@amazin7006 they cant just act as private company any more than Facebook can. This is a serious problem when the platform reaches is magnitude of size
RUclips censorship is so annoying. Endless scams are fine, but valuable information is not.
Companies that fund the ads make the rules. RUclips is a private platform, not public. Break the ToS, they can do whatever they want.
YT is in the wrong here but being we agree to their terms, not much we can do.
If we don't want this kind of "censorship", we have to go back to pre-Google RUclips where there were no ads but also no payouts. No money to be made.
Wherever money is made by ads, the corps putting the money into the ads end up making the rules 😔
And here I was thinking the censorship was lessening from what it was in a year or two ago .
@@Real28pretty much so we are stuck in a way. Unless Rumble can make massive improvements and start to compete but then they will run into similar problems down the road
The ad companies could give a shot about the content they are worried about the activist organizations putting them on blast and threatening boycotts. This is most likely a government campaign to censor “disinformation” that questions the scientific orthodoxy on healthcare. YT just demonized doctors who advocate diets like keto claiming that to dangerous for the public. I think it Dr Eric berg if I’m not mistaken.
At the end of the day the elites don’t want us communicating alternatives. We must defer to the government on issues. Remember the most dangerous thing facing us today is not war or collapsing economy; it’s misinformation and disinformation. Their words not mine.
@@brianmeen2158 Rumble is a private company too and relies on advertisers. Even if they become mainstream, mainstream demand means mainstream advertisers, which means mainstream rules.
This is ironic because in a world of juicing influencers Mark and co were probably some of the most open and responsible people to talk about strength sport, peds etc. YT is loosing its mind.
Yeah and also get people addicted to opioids LOL... Stopped watching after he started shilling with his brother for a kratom company.
ooooh . That'll do it. kratom is not quiet a full opiate but it's not something you should use unless you're ironically trying to get off of actual opiates and then stop kratom too. @@floridamanHooning
Yes. He taught me a lot
@@floridamanHooninglol i stopped watching after his producer had a sarms salesman shill his sarms to him, took like 5 sarms at once with no test base, crashed his T and proceeded to go on pellet trt within a month.
Shit was the funniest series ive ever seen
@@floridamanHooningHow does someone get you addicted to opioids? He forced pills down their throats? Your decisions are your decisions. You should ge boycotting doctors as well. RUclips is not a private corporation. They have special section 230 immunities to shield them from lawsuits. They have an obligation to operate as a platform and not as a publisher. Outside of removing illegal content censorship should not exist on their platform.
This is outrageous mark has done nothing but give open and honest content.
Ask Hoss how honest Mark is .
Mark spreads terrible misinformations
@@kapoioBCS And?
@@theoreticalfitness7701 🤡
@@kapoioBCSEven if he did, so what? RUclips is supposed to be a platform not a curating publisher. Section 230 requires this.
Didn’t realize this even happened, thanks for the video - Mark has made great content for years, as straightforward and well intentioned as they come from everything I’ve ever seen.
Mark Bell was my lockdown training partner. His channel served an important purpose for me during those times and though I don't watch a lot of his recent content, I will always be grateful for his openness and efforts to connect with his viewers.
This sets a pretty terrifying precedent. Greg and Derek have talked about specific compounds, cycles, etc in great length, hundreds of videos each.
Lets hope Greg gets removed.
Greg is annoying as fuck
Derek also own merrick health, the mill he sends his viewers to to get trt at 20 with other things on top etc.
@@uns33n I used to think Derek was a cool guy once, but its all about the money realy. Turkesterone and microneedeling for hairloss is the biggest scams so far.
I don't have a yt channel but I've noticed comments of mine that are critical of psychiatry for instance getting removed. It is pretty frightening as people won't know what they are getting into if experiences aren't allowed to be shared. Just like with steroids. It's not like people are going to stop using them if they are interested in it. But they'll be doing it less informed. Of course specifically "pro steroids" content should be reviewed carefully, but if it is a nuanced information to begin with there should be no problem.
I can't believe Mark Bell out of everyone. I mean i think YT censorship is beyond ridiculous but the Power Project specifically is so nuanced and full of really solid fitness info on all fronts. What a bizarre first martyr choice by YT.
This is the issue with broad support of a couple of platforms owned by the largest tech comanies... People didn't habe to create the platform themselves but they also don't retain ultimate control of their own content. Creators and consumers will have to act otherwise this will definitely get worse imo.
It's kinda like banning Mr Rogers while leaving pure hate channels alone. The hell did Mark and crew ever do to anyone?
I flew into Sacramento one day. Drove immediately to Mark’s gym. I got a selfie with him and his brother Chris then left….They were both unbelievably kind…love you Mark, Nsima, Andrew
0:35 "our harmful and dangerous policy"
The phrasing is accidentally brilliant
hate to be that guy but this discussion has been going on for nearly a decade with youtube and social media censorship. It's just now seeming a little more real to some people because it's in their circle of attention, the fitness industry niche in this case. Censorship and authoritarianism always begin in a way that can be sold to the public, once they're normalized, they can spread
Very fair point. Just see all these comments saying "they're a private company", because the "right" people are the ones getting cancelled.
Alex Jones
@@5thgearouttahere it seems some people like the taste of the corporate boot.
@@5thgearouttahere stonetoss got this one right
Censorship for sure but how exactly is the private company RUclips “Authoritarians”? it’s a company for videos it’s not the government. The private company is doing what it deems best for its own interests. Much like Mark or any of these channels, In this case with Marks channel it seems way off base but i dont see how a private company doing whats it believes is in its own interests, would be Authoritarians.
I work at a gym Mark comes to pretty often, the guy is nothing but helpful and kind and only wants the best for everyone in their pursuit of self development and betterment of themselves.
I pray he gets his channel back 🙏
How this affects your channel
You don't have a channel.
Wow holy shit I just realized what this video is about. Why would RUclips do that?! So much amazing and insightful content just gone like that. They’ll come back right?
17:55 I thinks that’s it… RUclips see content creators as employees
Risk the reputation of the company and your gone
Communist takeover of western culture
Somehow, the answer is money.
That's always the answer to corporate decisions. If it doesn't benefit the company financially, gone. They don't care about right or wrong. They care about profits.
Absolutely insane! They’ll do whatever they can to shut someone up if they want to. Mark revolutionized content creation in this space and it shouldn’t be taken so lightly that he was abruptly removed from it
it could be as simple as too many people reporting his videos because they don’t agree with them… and that is truly unfortunate
I used to make money from instagram and once they demonetized it just wasn’t worth it anymore. I went and by hand removed almost 10k followers and set my account to private. That instagram has been my training journal since I started to learn weightlifting from Alex Lee in 2017. Contemplating going and screen recording my entire profile as a backup because I just don’t trust these massive social media companies anymore. It’s getting easier and easier now to pull the plug on my smart phone with how social media is unraveling. Time to disconnect.
The most irritating bit is just the lack of an explanation. They are at least owed a reason.
Wtf!? This decision better be reversed. There is a huge community behind mark. We can’t let this happen.
Tο be fair, Mark spreads terrible misinformation and dangerous medical and nutrition advices plus promotes PEDs use etc
Something that sucks about this is that it undercuts all of the content that talks about the downsides of PEDs. People are going to look at nuanced content from people like Derek and Greg who legitimately discuss the pros and cons of ped use and think that they are exaggerating the cons in order to appease youtube.
Here we go Rumble! Hope MBPP relocates and HOPEFULLY he backed up his library of episodes.
I'm both shocked and not shocked.
I bet not a single channel that promotes hormones for changing your gender will have their channels shut down but Mark Bell's channel that is all about working out, proper diet, and using PED's in a healthy way is shut down.
They want all men to act like stereotypical male feminists. Strong men are a threat to the machine.
100%. Chemically altering yourself with limited long term data is fine to RUclips as long as it's LGBT but knowing how to use PED's safely is a big no no
Yeah 100%, the machine wants weak men to one day implement global communism tyranny
Imagine being a male feminist in ‘24. Information is free - the internet is vast. It’s not difficult to find info on feminism and its relation to Marxism. Yet you still have men and women believing in said toxic ideology. Insanity.
Constantly thinking about trans people eh?
@@drj-pp8hwsomebody has to in case the decepticons come back
I am from Sacramento & I have known Mark Bell for about (12) years. He has always been a straight shooter & has the best interest of his followers, etc. Mark doesn’t need RUclips, RUclips needs Mark Bell.
I wondered what happened, the last podcast they did with Dr. Mike and Vigorous Steve were some of my favorite videos to fall asleep to ...
Thanks for making this video, Mark’s the man, hope he keeps it up on a new platform.
For no reason, too
This is interesting in my ai ethics class we discussed stuff like this, my teacher told me, in europe we will soon have laws to control stuff like this. RUclips is damn near a monopoly and as such, then cant just act as a "private" company. Basically the laws are going to protect people like youtubers from gettin unjustly banned, just like a worker getting fired for no reason.
RUclips (and Google obviously) are 100% monopolies. They have used antitrust breaking practices to kill all possible competitors. Every boot licker saying they're a private company & can do whatever they like have no principles & believe in nothing.
At this point it's clear only the EU will take any action against Google.
> like a worker getting fired for no reason
Got some news chief, that ain't how things work in the states
@@FLYWHEELPRIME mostly shithole states
I highly doubt laws will be put into place to protect anyone but RUclips. You got to realize, the ultimate purpose of RUclips and similar apps is to control and distort your perception, drive agendas that the elites want and push propaganda. It is obvious and has been obvious since Covid started - even large channels get abused by RUclips - there are no monetary considerations.
I can never wrap my head around this kind of madness. Rarely anything controversial is ever going on with the channel. If anything, Mark Bell and the team has been so helpful in terms of understanding fitness. Funny how RUclips slam them down meanwhile Nikocado Avocado and whoever creator known for raunchy content gets to slip on by.
Yes, RUclips is a private platform and they have the final say on whatever.
However, it does come off as something so heavy-handed.
Online censorship is hella weird.
This is ridiculous. First guy I heard talk about this topic open and honestly and actually detoured me from jumping into that world. This is crazy
Zack!
I will 1000% consume your content on Rumble!!
I watch more than a few creator's on Rumble.
I don't buy into the conspiracies, there are tons of channels that talk about "equipped" lifting and thrive on youtube. Most likely some minimum-wage-earning content moderator made a bad judgment call on it and now youtube is seeing how big of a backlash this will generate and whether they can stand behind the bad judgment call or have to reinstate the channel. Their content moderation is and always has been trash.
YT is against anything that disrupts their narrative. Mark got bounced for (I'm guessing here) advocating a non-mainstream diet.
Totally agree
youtube can easily blame it on the steroids being the reason while hiding that its the carnivore promotion that was the actual reason.. Why is Rich Pianas channel still up?
Aren't there carnivores all over YT?
No, their stupid AI censorship program eliminates any channel talking about drugs in a way that the AI program doesn't like. You can write to YT and all you get are automated replies. YT is run by clowns.
Yes, they are on YT, but for how long? Dr. Eric Berg just got censored, and he is not a dedicated carnivore. These bastards are determined that you "eat zee bugz", and anything that gets in the way will be suppressed. Just my opinion BTW, but I don't think I am far off the mark.@@JeffO-
I’m always astounded in RUclips’s ability to consistently make the wrong decisions on everything
Yeah that sucks. Not sure what they are talking about. If they get him, they are coming for MPMD and GD next.
....Mark bell's channel removed, thats absolutely insane.
Watched the guy since the day i started training over a decade ago, hell i got a slingshot ages ago aswell.
So the 1 channel that was the most open and honest about steroid and steroid safety to be carefull, gets banned in 2024 for mentioning steroids?
When every newer channel openly discusses it to an insane amount and dont get banned, i can only remember "docter tony huge" getting removed because he went "to far" besides that everything was almost allways allowed, and it sure didnt get your channel just REMOVED fully.
Maybe with the support from other youtubers this can get overthrown because it makes no fucking sense, the bell family has been making great stuff for that long and to just get removed is crazy.
Mark was right he made a community post on RUclips saying he uses steroids not TRT and he does it for his personal enjoyment, RUclips probably saw that as him promoting the use of substances
Dude mark bell was such a inspiration to me. Him and all the guests he had on his channel provided so much information for strength athletes and enthusiasts alike.
Mark Bell is definitely OG. I remember him from -Bigger Stronger Faster-
I wonder if other hormone treatments or procedures are deemed as harmful by You Tube?
All the big social media platforms are run in a way where they can take everything you have and not even tell you why. It has already happened to plenty of content creators, some of them small, some of them huge. Just look at what happened to Dr Disrespect on Twitch.
I know that at least Hydrid Calisthenics cross-posts on Rumble. They just post the same video here and there (or at least used to). I feel like that's a fairly smart move, getting another basket for your eggs with very little additional work.
Serious topic of the video aside; I appreciate all the Deus Ex references including the back ground.
This is crazy, Google must be trying to send RUclips to the graveyard, the service has been running way too long for their own standards.
This is why people need to speak up about censorship BEFORE it affects them or people they know.
RUclips has had problems forever. But it definitely seems to be getting worse. People that rely on YT for income shouldn't be able to be pushed off the platform without detailed and reasonable evidence, rather than just a generic blanket statement.
This is insane! Mark Bell is a national treasure.
I got to be honest here, it kind of reminds me of the Joe rogan whole thing. Getting on different platforms. And tailoring content towards, or inside the guide lines seems to be the right way to go. Crazy stuff. Personally I would want some one to make a RUclips creators union. Its pretty fair if you think about it, job is a job.
You should definitely work on a backup.
THANK GOD his original channel didn’t get taken down. There is sooooo much gold on that channel from years ago with all the powerlifting greats. Go watch ‘em all now before that’s gone too.
Love the Deus Ex clips btw.
Insane reaction by RUclips.
I've seen saying for a decade now, that I'd hate to have RUclipsr as a career. You can NEVER trust the RUclips team. They will stab you in the back in an instant and leave you penniless.
And it has only become WORSE during that decade of observing them ruin people over bad decisions. RUclips is a woke company run by ideologues. They do not run their company to make money. They do not run their company to be fair. They run their company to push their preferred agenda and hurt people who don't fit within it.
During cov*** they became hysterical about punishing and holding their creators "within line". It's still going on and people still can even write certain words even void of of any "dangerous opinions". Another example is that people have now spent years having to say "un-alive" rather than what they're trying to relay, because it was used in a joke RUclips doesn't like.
RUclips is a on a Twitch trajectory. As the cheap money runs out, they'll have to make a business decision to not be an activist platform anymore or lose out to a new contender.
IBM used to be THE computer company, MyFace THE social media network, Office THE productivity suite; until they weren't.
I wish them luck with this amazing strategy or pissing off their paying users and sole revenue stream. 🙂
Ah, nobody uses Office anymore? Tell me more ...
@@irfuel I think it's more so that office is just is word processing software now, and full on productivity suites like google docs/drive are overtaking it for free.
@@irfuel in the 90s and 2000s, the first thing anyone would install was Office or Works if it weren't already installed. Now it's given away free with a $ 10-a-month Outlook email account, and even still, I haven't bothered installing it in over a decade. People forward documents in PDF pretty regularly now too so even just a documents reader usage case is far from the defacto standard it was prior.
@@ConnorLipke Excel is still massive
@@adampb23 No real compeition for it. There's many more visually pleasing word processing apps, especially on mac than word, but even google sheets can't compete with excel.
I dont use IG or FB, or any other app as much as I use RUclips.
I am embarresed to admit how much I use youtube...
To be fair, if someone like Natural Hypertrophy could get his channel back, why couldn't Mark? Mark is a much, much bigger deal with way more views. People just have to rally round and support him, keep spamming RUclips to put the channel back up.
Because NT doesnt sell advertise sarms and TRT mills to 20 year old men
About a year ago I believe, Natural Hypertrophy got his channel unfairly taken down because of an anime company and YT but despite the odds the community gathered and revived his channel. Hope for something similar to happen with Mark's podcast.
It is sad, sorry for Mark. But use it as a lesson RUclipsrs, get an alternative channel on another platform like Uncle Joe, leading the pack. The adult viewer will
follow. RUclipsrs work for RUclips and you can get sacked just like that 💥
That sucks. Never watched his content much but he's been around for as long as I've been watching fitness content. Unfortunately this is something all youtubers must live with, at any second your channel and everything you've worked for can be deleted. There doesn't need to be any real reason either. It sucks but it's something we all know can happen.
RUclips right now
"noooo you can't watch videos that promote health and fitness, go watch videos of fat people eating themselves to death!!!"
...but why does youtube promote the unhealthy?
@@7sons484 blackrock
These guys will still have a voice but their reach will be greatly diminished without youtube. It hits home because I’ve been very positively influenced by Natural Hypertrophy and he went through a ban scare before I found his channel.
Holy shit, this is crazy.
Wouldn't have even heard about it without this video thanks Zack
Wow. Total BS. Weakness is never a strength, RUclips.
It's been a while since i saw one of your video, been really busy, but you're still one of the guys i prefer listening to ! It's crazy what happened to Mark's podcast !
Rumble is an alternative
Yes, I'm already on Rumble actually.
I think the youtube geeks didn't understand a word he said.
This is probably the nail in the coffin for my use of YT, as a consumer, really disgusting, thanks for reporting on this Zack.
Stop the madness!
Zack!
RUclips reinstated his channel!!
It's the AI. The sheer amount of video uploads and watch hours this platform is churning out is hard to wrap your head around. That coupled with companies like RUclips announcing layoffs for the sake of implementing AI to replace that workforce is going to create many more situations like this in the future. The rules are changing as RUclips is no longer the wild west of viewing consumption but rapidly replacing mainstream sources and becoming the prime source. Sorry to hear this happened!
Don't think thats how it works. Yes maybe if you have 100 subscribers but I am sure there are thresholds here where an AI decision will get double checked by a human. The said fitness channel I belive meets that criteria.
@@DConnectEmpire One of RUclipss biggest Instagram marketing channels recently got a copyright strike from Instagram itself for using it's logo in his videos. He was in danger of losing the entire channel. It turned out to be exactly this case, AI false-positive copyright flag. How big the channel is has nothing to do with it.
When Google bought RUclips I wondered how they'd mess it up. This is one detail.
I did go to Spotify to listen to Rogan's podcast.
I'm headed there now to catch Mark's podcast.
One of the most consistent policies youtube has had over the years has been no promoting steroids. You cant go through his library and tell me with a straight face he hasnt promoted steroids over the years. Not saying its right, but that would be my guess.
If this were the reason, there would be dozens of similarly big channels getting banned
It's literally one of the most common topics right now, I haven't seen anybody get banned for it yet. I don't understand how you could consider it one of their "most consistent" policies if it's never enforced
@@jimbojimson Who says they won't, in the future.
gotta call bs, Rich Pianas channel and bostin loyds channel never got taken down. This is the agenda of ending the meat consumption striking.
@@irfuel It's possible, but it's certainly not the precedent right now
It's so hard to even begin to guess why it was taken down, but I will admit they have walked a thin line for a long time... in terms of addressing topics that RUclips may not like (i.e. PEDs). As a trainer, I am obviously against them losing their channel. It could have been a channel flag driven by AI... it could have been a Google Exec finding their teenage child watching one of their podcasts on gear, then sending a few texts, and boom the channel is gone. You never know, and when you walk that line, you run a risk. I'm not surprised they lost their channel, and I think they'll get it back. Hopefully.
So much for free speech
This is musks version of free speech
It is a combination of everything. All in different ratios for each case. AI monitoring, unapproved discourse, questioning the narrative, perhaps a rogue agent within RUclips. But you’re right, no one in the fitness industry is big enough for RUclips to even take a second glance at. And so another one bites the dust.
This has got to be the last straw for me. I am cancelling my RUclips premium and deleting the app from my phone. Going over to rumble.
Also wanna say how much I appreciate everything you do, Zack. Your unbridled sincerity and unwavering authenticity is inspiring, and so, SO NECESSARY in this space..
RUclips starting to act like Hinge; ban people without warning or explanation
It's back up ? Was it ever banned?
I'm so upset I wrote RUclips a letter. Mark is such a good guy and a helpful and sincerely good health advocate. Just seeing the change i his body and the way he conducts interviews is topnotch.
Dude I couldn't imagine building a following and a channel and loosing it like that. I've recorded so many clips but never bothered to edit them or even plan to film things I do but once I'm in the moment its a lot of extra work and time to set up shots and film. I have a ton of respect for those who actually take time to do this. People that haven't edited videos or compiled clips have no clue the work involved with little to no reward for most.
This is actually great news. Totally sucks for Mark, he's a great person but EVERY fitness RUclipsr over the last 3 years talk about NOTHING but cycles, steroids and how to use them. It's ridiculous and dangerous. There's now 14 year olds on RUclips documenting their cycles and it puts a bad face on the subject. Stop talking about steroids for Christ sake. If you can't get views without talking about drugs, then maybe you need to find a new job.
Incredible I was since a week thinking WTF was happening that they don't post anything....maybe the podcast that more change my new chapter of healthy life. Honest content.... Unbelievable, sad to know
Probably not going to rumble until most of the channels I follow leave yt for rumble.
This is a shame, but there seems to be a serious pattern occurring even for small fish like me.
Had my Instagram/Facebook account of 7 and 15 years respectively deleted for supposedly being “hacked” but had no email to ask if there was a mysterious login…nothing. And there’s no one to talk to either or to try and find out what happened. Then I just receive an email saying your accounts have been deleted and you will not get them back. No explanation or questions…just deleted.
There’s something strange going on and now I’m looking for other platforms with better security and more freedom to start again. Even thinking to going back to an old school blog style website as at least can be independent and not be controlled by the likes Mega and Google. 15 years of content all gone and no one to talk to about it.
But like Mark Bell, you just got to get up and do your steps. Can’t imagine what it’s like for him with so much content and subscribers, etc. However, this is a strong signal that these guys have too much control and these spaces are not safe.
Great video and know Mark will come back stronger. We need to start looking for the next move.
This is crazy. I was looking for the channel and was wondering why I couldn't find it... RIP
I can still go to the channel and look up videos. What gives.
It's ridiculous they won't explain what the cause was. How are people ever supposed to know where the line is? This could all be for something none of us are guessing - we simply don't know.
I've met Mark in person a few times and, unlike many here, I really don't care to ever see him again. But I have never seen anything from any of his content that I thought put him at risk for this. This is crazy.
Because it's an automatically generated reply letter.
I recall just the other day reading a (youtube) post by Mark putting steroids in the same light as coffee, alcohol, etc. I'm not commenting on whether or not he was right to do this, rather, "steroids" are illegal and he kinda forced their hand i guess? It does suck because he is being more transparent and not hiding behind the legally ok, "TRT" language as many others do. Idk, thats just my prevailing theory as to what was the final straw.
Ayyyy, glad to see more people becoming aware to how awful youtube as a platform is! Metal Outlaw, Louis Rossmann, Bluedrake42, among many others have espoused how this platform has been slowly spiraling downwards for the past 10 years. Truthfully, its as Zack says, there isnt a platform with as big of a brand recognition that’ll net them the same support and income as RUclips currently does. My personal choice of alternative platform is Odysee, but anything open-sourced and not beholden to a corporation, shareholder, or government would work.
I have advocated for this for the last year. People should insulate themselves by starting, and advertising a Rumble channel.
Mark Bell, I have listened to you for years, and I have enjoyed many of your topics of discussion, thank you for all the information that that you have shared. RUclips, WHAT ARE YOU UP TO!!!!! freedom of speach!!!!
It's a strange situation that content creators are so dependent on RUclips for their income but have so little protections.
RUclips is like a neighborhood cop that doesn't like your car whether or not you're violating any laws whatsoever that bully cop is going to pull you over take time out of your life give you stress ect... just because he doesn't like your car and content creators need to take them to court and make them prove that there's a violation of their policies because in some cases this is the creators livelihood
Man Im completely bummed! How ridiculous it is...feel so powerless.
Look like power project and super training are both still existing or back up again
What can we do?
RUclips is a platfom.... Creators didn't create source code for the front and backend components of the platform.... Creators have use the platform provided to post thier content and capitalize on it based on a number of factors. People who say they are creators should recognize these realities be willing to invest in contingencies to maitain thier established reach.... Unless they are willing to self censor and jusy complain about appealing to the algo gods....
Super important that people are honest about what it takes to look a certain way, or to achieve certain lifting goals
We arent delusional we know gear is " essential" we/youtube need to grow up & understand that ... this isn't a taboo subject ... people are experimenting in dangerous ways, there needs to be a forum for honesty, caution & guidance
We know our sports heroes are on gear, we know our favourite fitness personalities are on gear ... its not promoting taking gear to talk about it, it's just a reflection of our current reality