Good to be back on TPE as always and surprised to see so many positive comments. Kudos to Shehzad for maintaining a quality audience on this precious platform. Hoping it grows more and more. Best wishes to all the listeners here. Cheers !! -Muzammil
Thanks. Muzammil bhai can you plz explain, one person i met at the black hole said 'Muzammil on one hand says that he prefers freedom over egality, thats why he doesn't like China bcz they are authoritarian, but on the other hand he also says that only a Kemalist type government can fix things; isn't that a contradiction?'
This man Syed Muzammil Shah is very honest in his analysis of Pakistan's internal problems. Such people are are prone to violent backlash from establishment. I pray that he remains safe.
He's only applying logics to Imran Khan and find all issues he ever read, drawing analogies But on the same time he's dead silent whether it's Zardari, Ganja League or Corrupt Generals of army. & it makes him anti IK, biased, very subjective.
It's worthwhile and pleasing to see and hear the discourse you are having with this sensible, sane voice of reason, integrity, honesty and clarity of Syed Muzammil Shah. Sach bolne ke liye kirdaar ki zaroorat chahiye jo Syed Muzammil Bhai me saaf nazar aata hai.❤
Muzammil is the only journalist/political analyst to come out of this nation who focuses on finding the truth rather than pushing agendas for their own personal benefit or is party backed. He is a gem and inspires people to do research on their claims and back it up by evidence which is one of the biggest problems the modern world faces today. He indulges you to think critically and observe everything with skepticism.
Hi this is Anand from India..I have listened a few of your RUclips podcasts very recently..but really those have been really eye-opener guys..kudos to both of u..lots & lots of love to u guys❤❤ keep up the good work man👏👏👏
Muzammil is one of the best thinking mind in Pakistan 🇵🇰. Good to see him in Ur show.👍🏼 His eloquence and clearity without beating round the bush is like a straight forward arrow approaching the target 🎯
Taoism aur Confucianism padha hai - Buddhism and Samkhya ko nahin - ajeeb chutiye hote hain pakistani. Confucianism ko compare akr raha hai indic philosophies se while buddhism is accused of being individualistic.
I listen SM shah for 2 hrs or more.. just like OSHO . I cannot even bear an ads break.. the way he puts his thoughts..its hypnotic kind. He has studied a lot. Love from India ❤️
As an Indian living in US, I find it quite refreshing to hear sensible and sane podcast such as the ones by Shehzad Shaikh and his eclectic selection of guests. I am grateful for the educative value of such content which these days has replaced my previous favorite show err nighttime sleep aid - the mind numbing entertainment by Lal Topi aka Zaid Hamid.
Visited this channel after a long time . I am so glad and proud to see that there are now more followers than there were previously . Atleast shows sensible minds are being understood and are coming forward!
If only few more people like Muzammil are born in the province of Punjab, prosperity of the people of land is just around the corner. Sir Muzammil has really inspired me to read more books and it is very inspiring to listen to him. Love from Sindh
Great work from both of you. I have recently subscribed to Muzammil's RUclips channel and almost listened to his majority of videos where he depicts great knowledge. In this society where establishment have imposed its fear to public, such individuals are a great asset to educate people and help them to think rationally. Say NO to dictatorship mindsets and institutions!!
I am very happy for very rare voices like Syed Muzammil. I am his big fan since his program in The Black Hole Islamabad about philosophy, Political Science, Fascism, Critical Thinking regrading situation and affairs in Pakistan...
This is what a podcast is, nowadays people have made podcasts so lame that any naive come and put their opinions... But syed Muzammil, it was something i really liked in your podcast and especially the method of implementing comparative politics in the contemporary era.....u earned a sub!
AOA Shehzad, I belong to Jhelum. I do not comment but I am your regular viewer. Wonderful work you have been doing. Please keep doing this. Not just the remote areas, this platform is also enabling us to learn so much valuable. It is a treat to listen to Syed Muzammil's views. Best wishes to you both. In the end, I have a request. Please invite Shahzeb Khanzaada and Umer Cheema to your Podcast. Many Thanks!
What an amazing amazing podcast! Pls share a list of all the books Muzammil shared in the description. Noted them to read. But would love it if more people do!
Go to Acharya Prashant for Vedantic philosophy of India , His Hindi channel is Amazing . Syed muzzamil Shah seems to be in love with Western philosophers jo ki theek hai , but Indian Vedantic(Upanishads) literature deals with the deeper layers of Human consciousness. Sunoge/padhoge to jaanoge
Clearly, as listeners we have so much to gain from valuable discussion like these. I am working on myself tbh to gain more knowledge and put myself through the rigorous process of unlearn and reeducation based on unbiased and factual information. Once again, very challenging feat to distinguish right from wrong and factual from biased narratives. Thanks you, it was a treat regardless if I agree with everything said. 😇
Syed Muzammil great honest journalist you have in Pakistan May god bless him with good health and long life we need such wonderful people lots of regards to him
Great podcast and Muzammil is a show stopper as always. The viewers’ profiles tells you that the history of the sub continent is a bigger unifier of minds than any political theories or agendas- whether in the current political scenario or in the pre independence period.
1:23:00 Individualism ki philosophy tab tak survive karti hai jab tak whole society prosperity ke peak tak nahi pahunch jaati. Europe me bahut countries is level pe pahunch gayi hain. To wo ab society harmony ke philosophy pe shift kar rahe hain. Wokeism ka base bhi to yahi hai. Usme individual thoughts ko zayaada respect nahi hai.
the conscious personality of the individual in a crowd is submerged and that the collective crowd mind dominates; crowd behaviour is unanimous, emotional, and intellectually weak Gustave🔥 Will sure look into this book The Crowd⚡
For the last question Why we do what we do ? The answer is simple Acknowledgement (not famous) You may not want to achieve fame or validation, but you don't want to waste all what you have to offer either It might be rejected or even hated by the masses, but you still do it to make some kind of sense of your skill, knowledge, or opinion That's human nature Zarathustra (Nietzsche) could have stayed in that isolation, but nooooo. He had to come. He had to address the masses. It's human nature to share what you have discovered Be khudi besabab nahi Ghalib Kuch to hai jis ki parda dari hai There is no selfless act.
Great one 👌 Muzammil's ideas & points are always interesting & intellectually gratifying to listen to but things get even better when Shehzad's sharp counter questions, calm demeanor, amazing mimicry skills & hilarious jokes get added to the mix as well 😂👌 Thanks for what you do Shehzad, this podcast may not be your passion or dream but it's definitely a wonderful delight for viewers like me, hope you continue it as long as you're enjoying it yourself. Take care 🍁☘️💕
Eagerly waiting for Muzammil Sir. Can't take eyes off from him..I Always wonder he's from that region that represents extraordinary bankruptcy of ideas since its inception.
GOD BLESS BOTH OF YOU INDIVIDUALY I LIKES YOUR JOURNALISM FROM PAKISTAN AND YOUR VLOGS ANG BLOGS I LIKE YOUR ANALYTICAL VIEWS MOSTLY MR SYED MUZAMIL SAHIB HUMARAI REHNUMAI KARNAY KA SHUKRIYA BOHAT BOHAT
Good to be back on TPE as always and surprised to see so many positive comments. Kudos to Shehzad for maintaining a quality audience on this precious platform. Hoping it grows more and more. Best wishes to all the listeners here. Cheers !!
-Muzammil
@ 45:30
Clarity in statement 🙏🏼
@ 46:07
What quantum of growth !!
🤗🤗
💕
Welcome bro
Thanks for such an educational
Podcast! Learnt a lot from you today - would definitely read the book you recommended!
Thanks. Muzammil bhai can you plz explain, one person i met at the black hole said 'Muzammil on one hand says that he prefers freedom over egality, thats why he doesn't like China bcz they are authoritarian, but on the other hand he also says that only a Kemalist type government can fix things; isn't that a contradiction?'
That nihilism question was mine, thankyou for discussing that! My 17 year old self is satisfied!
This man Syed Muzammil Shah is very honest in his analysis of Pakistan's internal problems. Such people are are prone to violent backlash from establishment. I pray that he remains safe.
@@ThePakistanExperience Ameen 🤲🤲🤲🤲
He's only applying logics to Imran Khan and find all issues he ever read, drawing analogies But on the same time he's dead silent whether it's Zardari, Ganja League or Corrupt Generals of army. & it makes him anti IK, biased, very subjective.
@@ThePakistanExperience a,
Very few people can speak so clearly.
@@abccde6778 u need to listen carefully.
It's worthwhile and pleasing to see and hear the discourse you are having with this sensible, sane voice of reason, integrity, honesty and clarity of Syed Muzammil Shah. Sach bolne ke liye kirdaar ki zaroorat chahiye jo Syed Muzammil Bhai me saaf nazar aata hai.❤
Muzammil is the only journalist/political analyst to come out of this nation who focuses on finding the truth rather than pushing agendas for their own personal benefit or is party backed.
He is a gem and inspires people to do research on their claims and back it up by evidence which is one of the biggest problems the modern world faces today.
He indulges you to think critically and observe everything with skepticism.
These podcast should be a part of Pakistan studies syllabus rather than actual syllabus.
We were eagerly looking forward to it! Thanks for inviting Syed Muzammil to the show.
Hi this is Anand from India..I have listened a few of your RUclips podcasts very recently..but really those have been really eye-opener guys..kudos to both of u..lots & lots of love to u guys❤❤ keep up the good work man👏👏👏
This man is so vocal and sensible. And talks clear. Understantable and convincing.
Biggest Fan of the biggest Intellectual to ever Born in Pakistan since independence. Love and regards from Gilgit Sir... 😍😍😍
Muzammil is one of the best thinking mind in Pakistan 🇵🇰. Good to see him in Ur show.👍🏼 His eloquence and clearity without beating round the bush is like a straight forward arrow approaching the target 🎯
Taoism aur Confucianism padha hai - Buddhism and Samkhya ko nahin - ajeeb chutiye hote hain pakistani. Confucianism ko compare akr raha hai indic philosophies se while buddhism is accused of being individualistic.
Roger that🌹
Yes! My favorite personalities here once again!
Now after reading Nietzsche, I understand him more than ever. Syed Muzammil is a gem of a person❤
which book you read
Such a brave man , Syed Muzammil. MashaAllah. May he be safe, always.
Shehzad's witty jokes in between a serious conversation are so refreshing!!
I listen SM shah for 2 hrs or more.. just like OSHO . I cannot even bear an ads break.. the way he puts his thoughts..its hypnotic kind. He has studied a lot. Love from India ❤️
As an Indian living in US, I find it quite refreshing to hear sensible and sane podcast such as the ones by Shehzad Shaikh and his eclectic selection of guests.
I am grateful for the educative value of such content which these days has replaced my previous favorite show err nighttime sleep aid - the mind numbing entertainment by Lal Topi aka Zaid Hamid.
One of the best. I'm always impressed by Muzammil's brutal honesty and he doesn't mince his words.
One of THE BEST PART of this vlog
That million dollar smile on Muzamil 🥰🥰🥰
Just have a feeling that this guy's Syed is gona go a long way!! Sincere person!!
Visited this channel after a long time . I am so glad and proud to see that there are now more followers than there were previously . Atleast shows sensible minds are being understood and are coming forward!
Such a mess Pakistan has got itself into 😔 but always a pleasure listening to Muzammil 👍
If only few more people like Muzammil are born in the province of Punjab, prosperity of the people of land is just around the corner. Sir Muzammil has really inspired me to read more books and it is very inspiring to listen to him. Love from Sindh
One of the finest podcast series on the internet easily. Keep up the good work guys!!!
What a treat of a podcast!! And yay! my question got asked 😀 and answered very well. Thanks Shehzad and Muzammil!
I'm a fan of Syed Muzamil Shah, the more I listen to him the more I agree with him
Man I'm addicted to your show.
much respect for both the men! thank you for such a wholesome discussion
🙌
@@ThePakistanExperience please share the names book he tell during this video
Just love this man ! Hes too good 👍thanks for inviting him shahzad
Great work from both of you. I have recently subscribed to Muzammil's RUclips channel and almost listened to his majority of videos where he depicts great knowledge. In this society where establishment have imposed its fear to public, such individuals are a great asset to educate people and help them to think rationally. Say NO to dictatorship mindsets and institutions!!
Always a treat listening to Muzammil! He is the voice of sanity that should prevail!
Amazing interview where both talked pragmatically. Honestly learned a lot about Imran khan. Thanks!
🙌
I am very happy for very rare voices like Syed Muzammil. I am his big fan since his program in The Black Hole Islamabad about philosophy, Political Science, Fascism, Critical Thinking regrading situation and affairs in Pakistan...
Amazing guest and amazing host! more power to both of you!
This is what a podcast is, nowadays people have made podcasts so lame that any naive come and put their opinions... But syed Muzammil, it was something i really liked in your podcast and especially the method of implementing comparative politics in the contemporary era.....u earned a sub!
Genius approach to each matter by MUZAMMIL.
Can we pls make this guy our next pm.? I never even knew about him before this video. Shah g and others like him need to b protected at all costs.
He has his RUclips channel...
Take care Shehzad and Muzammil, stay safe and keep spreading the positivity.
How can you be rationalist and muslim at the same time?
AOA Shehzad, I belong to Jhelum. I do not comment but I am your regular viewer. Wonderful work you have been doing. Please keep doing this. Not just the remote areas, this platform is also enabling us to learn so much valuable. It is a treat to listen to Syed Muzammil's views. Best wishes to you both.
In the end, I have a request. Please invite Shahzeb Khanzaada and Umer Cheema to your Podcast. Many Thanks!
Specially for Muzamil
“There is more wisdom in your body than in your deepest philosophy.”
It's nice to hear the guest more rather than the usual argument with them.
Good podcast!
اچھے سوال اور اچھے جواب، مدلل گفتگو، گو ہمارے ذہن میں بھی کم و بیش یہی خیالات تھے، لیکن ان کو ان الفاظ میں اتنے اچھے طریقے سے پیش کرنے کا شکریہ ۔۔۔
happiest moments on earth when you listen like minded people, thank you
One of the best podcast series on the RUclips . Keep it up bro👍
What an amazing amazing podcast! Pls share a list of all the books Muzammil shared in the description. Noted them to read. But would love it if more people do!
Go to Acharya Prashant for Vedantic philosophy of India , His Hindi channel is Amazing .
Syed muzzamil Shah seems to be in love with Western philosophers jo ki theek hai , but Indian Vedantic(Upanishads) literature deals with the deeper layers of Human consciousness.
Sunoge/padhoge to jaanoge
I was expecting a podcast recorded in studio
They are always better in term of quality
Loving the conversation. Buhat kuch seekhne ko milta hai when two great minds talk
My excitement for this podcast crosses inappropriate. No man should want it this bad! YAAAAAAAAS
Clearly, as listeners we have so much to gain from valuable discussion like these. I am working on myself tbh to gain more knowledge and put myself through the rigorous process of unlearn and reeducation based on unbiased and factual information. Once again, very challenging feat to distinguish right from wrong and factual from biased narratives. Thanks you, it was a treat regardless if I agree with everything said. 😇
Syed Muzammil great honest journalist you have in Pakistan May god bless him with good health and long life we need such wonderful people lots of regards to him
Wow.. such intellectual discussions and open podcasts in your country is rarely to see.. nice one..
Great podcast and Muzammil is a show stopper as always. The viewers’ profiles tells you that the history of the sub continent is a bigger unifier of minds than any political theories or agendas- whether in the current political scenario or in the pre independence period.
Jazakallah
May both of you stay Blessed.
True analysis 👌 👏 👍
1:23:00 Individualism ki philosophy tab tak survive karti hai jab tak whole society prosperity ke peak tak nahi pahunch jaati. Europe me bahut countries is level pe pahunch gayi hain. To wo ab society harmony ke philosophy pe shift kar rahe hain. Wokeism ka base bhi to yahi hai. Usme individual thoughts ko zayaada respect nahi hai.
Love and respect you both from core of my heart.....
Brilliant podcast. This should be a must listen fot anyone growing up in Pakistan. More power to you both!
One of the most awaited podcast . Thanks TPS for bringing this gem on your podcast keep it up.
ہر دفعہ کی طرح۔ بہترین شو
Brilliant talk
Keep it up Shehzaad
Totally relatable situation
Muzammil is one of the few people in Pakistan whom I aspire to become.
I love syed muzammil bhai,,he is smart by both mind and face,,,
Shehzad ek favour kero... jo bhi books aapke guests recommend kiya karien; unkay naam aap description main daal diya kero. Thanks. Wonderful episode btw!
thank you M for sharing your transformation journey.
Just finished the podcast
Had a great time listening to Muzammil and you
My only question is when are you having Muzammil again as a guest on podcast?
i always learn something new form SM , GREAT ONE, everyone SHOULD WAYCH THIS
Thanks for this. You people are the GREATEST
Here for anything Syed Muzammil has to say
Ap dono ki discussion sun k buhat maza ata hai....
Arshad Sharif's murder scared me. 'The Press Conference' made the fear go away, they seemed very weak.
Love to hear Muzammil talk such an intellect.
This talk is beyond praise.
the conscious personality of the individual in a crowd is submerged and that the collective crowd mind dominates; crowd behaviour is unanimous, emotional, and intellectually weak
Gustave🔥
Will sure look into this book
The Crowd⚡
I hope people have good head on their bodies. You guys are few of them. May we all have a good life which is already short.
Syed muzamil is a gem
For the last question
Why we do what we do ?
The answer is simple
Acknowledgement (not famous)
You may not want to achieve fame or validation, but you don't want to waste all what you have to offer either
It might be rejected or even hated by the masses, but you still do it to make some kind of sense of your skill, knowledge, or opinion
That's human nature
Zarathustra (Nietzsche) could have stayed in that isolation, but nooooo. He had to come. He had to address the masses.
It's human nature to share what you have discovered
Be khudi besabab nahi Ghalib
Kuch to hai jis ki parda dari hai
There is no selfless act.
Great one 👌 Muzammil's ideas & points are always interesting & intellectually gratifying to listen to but things get even better when Shehzad's sharp counter questions, calm demeanor, amazing mimicry skills & hilarious jokes get added to the mix as well 😂👌 Thanks for what you do Shehzad, this podcast may not be your passion or dream but it's definitely a wonderful delight for viewers like me, hope you continue it as long as you're enjoying it yourself. Take care 🍁☘️💕
Eagerly waiting for Muzammil Sir. Can't take eyes off from him..I Always wonder he's from that region that represents extraordinary bankruptcy of ideas since its inception.
Well done Muzamil and Shehzad. Keep it up
We have an entire 2 hours lectures. Yohoooo!!! ❤
GOD BLESS BOTH OF YOU INDIVIDUALY I LIKES YOUR JOURNALISM FROM PAKISTAN AND YOUR VLOGS ANG BLOGS I LIKE YOUR ANALYTICAL VIEWS MOSTLY MR SYED MUZAMIL SAHIB HUMARAI REHNUMAI KARNAY KA SHUKRIYA BOHAT BOHAT
Wow. How I missed this episode man
Muzamil bhae is a gem
I know Muzamil earlier, host is amazing.. like his mimicking of Muzamil at 1:54:54
The best interview hands down Muzzamil sb
Thanks for adding a few more great books to my to be read list.
I can listen to Muzzamil for hours.
TBH es insan ko me 24 ganty tak b continuesly sun sakta ho❤❤❤❤
If you want to solve a problem then first you have to address it and accept it.
Syed Friedrich Nietzche of Pakistan is here. 😍🤩
a talk that taught me a lot...
Thanks shehzad bhai ❤️
Love from india.
Great to see Muzammil here
Another masterpiece 🤩
You should have Spotify podcasts aswell
Love your podcasts!!
@@ThePakistanExperience That's a sad news for us for sure
Sometimes people don't want to hear the truth because they don't want there illusions destroyed.
~Nietzsche
Adi Shankaracarya, Nagarjuna,Dharmakirti and Vachaspati Misra are one of the best logicians ever born in India🥰
Love to see such calm intellectual discussion
@@ThePakistanExperience I'm from nepal 🇳🇵