Great overview. I've used the Cotton Carrier G3 on a bike and hiking with an A7iii and a Sigma 150-600. The trick was to mount the cotton carrier disc onto the lens' tripod foot at an angle, so it locks in when the camera and lens are perpendicular across my chest, instead of hanging straight down. Also found that rotating the tripod foot to the left side of worked well for me, so the top of the camera body was facing up instead of forward. Took a bit of fitting, but now I've been able to get up some sketchy mountain tracks on foot, and to ride wide and flat tracks on a mountain bike.
I've used them all and settled on the cotton carrier. Full support and the front weight is better than a $7k camera and lens swinging around and hitting stuff. Also if I fall I can brace myself using both hands. With the side slings I have to sacrifice one hand to grab the camera and use one hand to break my fall. Simply put, the Cotton Carrier is the most comfortable and safe system on the market and it makes it a breeze to bend over and pick up lighting gear or other gear off the ground without dipping my camera in the dirt or mud. I can use both hands to carry gear and not worry about my camera swinging and banging into C stands. Hiking is a breeze with big lenses because I also have a backpack on which balances front to back loadouts. It's rugged and I have zero issues or concerns with it securing my camera.
I use the peak design strap, its just easy to carry and walk with, use mine on a 600mm, I hike with a back pack with that strap over the top of it, its just simple and works. Also people forget - you can go to a car shop and get the pads you put on seatbelts if you feel like you want more softer connecting part with your shoulder or chest. the rubber on inside top is perfect for not moving so much while walking.
Great review, Scott. I use the Cotton Carrier G3 harness for two cameras and highly recommend it, especially for the even weight distribution and security. I have carried a 300mm and 500mm lens comfortably on the front and use the hip mount for a shorter lens (landscape or macro). It works really well for me and is quick to unholster/holster. Everything feels secure even when hiking, cross-country skiing or snowshoeing with a wildlife lens. I got an attachment for accessories that I put on my tripod so I can have my tripod mounted on my hip and still be hands-free when hiking. As you mentioned, the Cotton Carrier Scout is terrific for landscape and macro. I've used it with 70-200mm and I'd say that's the limit for my personal comfort level. Overall I prefer the harness, though.
Great Information Scott Thank You. A quick note on the Peak Design Slide, they supply their own connector rings to attach the red anchor connector to their connector ring and then the camera post on the body. Not the OE connector you used in the video. I noticed that those Peak metal connector rings (not sure of the proper name) have begun to stretch out on my camera this is a major weak point I had to bend them back in with needle nose pliers. Something I will contact Peak about because they recommend using their connector rings versus the OEM ring that came with the camera.
Great review and comparison Scott. I teach a class in wildlife photography and it's amazing how many people want to talk about how to carry and manage the big lenses that are so important to our craft. Cheers!
Great video Scott! For the last month, since falling into some granite rocks, while climbing down to get closer to a river for landscape shots, Lol, I whacked my shoulder/rotator cuff. So I broke out my old Cotton Carrier, and re-fell in love with it!! I can shoot Bears all day, at Taylor Creek, South Lake Tahoe, and it keeps all the non shooting time/camera and long lens weight on my front, and NOT on my shoulder. (I used to cruise around with my monopod, fluid head, all on my shoulder, then shoot as needed. I'll get back there, but the Cotton Carrier is super convenient.
Great Vid. My 70-200mm f/2.8 Hub attached to my extended battery pack is a bit heavy for the battery pack attachment point. Installed the hub to the Lens foot and the extended battery pack is in the way for the twist on/off. Now I need a bushing extension for the Hub mounted on the hub foot. Or remove the extended battery pack.
Scott, thank you for the video. The Peak Design Anchor Mount can be set on the inside of the zoom lens foot (between the foot and the lens) and that way you can leave it there permanently and use your tripod at any time. This also allows the use the whole length of the zoom lens foot when I want to use a tripod - so I can balance the zoom lens when I change focal distance - this is helpful when I use my Wimberly Monogimbal. I use a Peak Design Slide to carry around a Fuji X-H1 and a 100-400mm lens. It is cushioned, so I find it preferable to the slide lite - I also have a Black Rapid but the anchor is too tall and it doesn't fit between the foot and the lens, so it is placed at the bottom of the lens foot and I need to remove it to use a tripod. Its annoying.
This was awesome feedback Luis. I would have never thought of that set up but it makes allot of sense. I think you helped quite a few of us out here with that response. Thanks again.
When i first saw this idea, I was thrilled, exactly what I wanted. Except the lens foot on my Tamron 150-600 doesn’t have that inside screw hole so it doesn’t work. I was so bummed when I realized that. :-( So depends on the foot.
After watching this video, I remembered I actually won one of the Peak light version camera straps but never used it. It worked perfectly on my trip. My Sony A7 III camera and 75-200 with a teleconverter lense were comfortably secured and the rubber on the shoulder kept it in place. Thank you.
Great review Scott. As someone who suffer a back injury I need to be careful when carrying my gear. I can no longer throw the heavy tripod mounted camera over my shoulder. Lighter backpacks are fine but the shoulder straps and hip setups pull my spine awkwardly to one side. I have found the Cotton carrier harness to work the best for me. The D850 with a 500PF lens feels great. I can hike great distances jumping creeks and scrambling up and down hills without any problem. I can see where the 400 f2.8 or 500 f4 might be to much though.
Nice summary. I use BlackRapid straps, both the sport for carrying a single camera/lens including my Z9 and 800 PF, and the double when carrying two bodies with smaller lenses, and I use the QD swivel connectors instead of the screw-in connectors. The QD connectors make it real easy to disconnect the camera if I want to mount it on a tripod or hold it down low. I find the Peak Design straps slip too much, especially when I need to run down a trail, cross a stream, etc. I have thought about trying the Cotton Carrier.
I use the Cotton Carrier G3 harness and I love it. Watts wildlife used it for his 600 mm a lot, in fact it is through him I heard about it. I don't even notice the camera set or the weight and I do have a bad back.
Great video! I carry my wildlife lens and camera with the bigger cotton carrier (G3) harness and a backpack for extra lenses or a tripod. We hike thru the marsh in rubber boots or hip waters and climb over rocks and other weird terrain. So I need my hands a lot. It helps to have the camera securely attached. The harness keeps my hands free, it distributes the weight perfectly in combination with a backpack and it fits me great. It’s higher off the ground, further away from the water. Hands down one of the best investments I’ve made and I use it every time when taking the camera out. This being said, the longer the lens, the more it restricts movement (especially the hood), as mentioned in the video. Which would probably effect any carrying system, but it still works sufficiently. If I had a large prime lens, it would travel in my backpack while hiking and I have a medium size zoom attached to my camera for quick deploy and general use while getting to a site. I enjoyed this video comparing the different options and I’m glad I got the cotton carrier, it just works best for our adventurous lifestyle.
Thank you so much for this. Trying to plan for a cruise to Alaska and had no idea where to start in terms of carrying equipment. Any more suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
I have a slide lite and love it! When hiking the camera hangs down my back which is very comfortable, I’m totally hands free. It’s easy to grab it and swing it around to shoot. I use it with a smaller lens and a mirrorless (18-400).
I bought the Black Rapid double carrier a couple years back and love it. I can separate the straps and use it as a single or have two cameras on me at the same time. Great review and food for thought on the other systems. Lots of people I've spoken with like the Cotton, I just like the grab and pull up to your eye advantage that the Black Rapid give you.
I've been using the Peak Design Slide strap for about 3 years without issues, including the strap creep that use mentioned. It is attached to a Canon 7D II, Canon EF 400mm f/4 DO IS II + 1.4 extender. Rather than 1 of the strap attachment point being on the lens foot as you showed it, I have it attached to the bottom of the camera. I'm a birder that carries a camera rather than a bird photographer and this system works well with binoculars
I just jumped weight from a Nikon 80-400mm to a 200-500mm lens. Three days into having it and I seriously have to work out how to carry it. My Nikon 80-400 is a breeze compared to this monster! I like the idea of the plates attached to the tripod foot for extra security as well as a two-point system of attachment. I really like the freedom of handheld, but though numerous videos and reviews call the Nikon 200-500 a "light" lens, carrying 6 pounds comfortably is an issue, especially to raise it quickly to photograph birds in flight. The 200-500 photos are outstanding when I am braced correctly and pay attention to the lens light needs. This is a timely video for me. As a female with certain anatomical features, some of the placement of the harnesses do not look like they will work for me. I will look into the Arca plates and peak design. though if Black Rapid makes a design that might work for me, multiple attachments would be my preference as I walk and hike. Any additional thoughts or suggestions would be appreciated. Thank you!
I love my Black Rapid made specifically for women. I’ve used it through various gear changes, starting with a Canon 7DM2,+100-400 until today with my Sony A1+200-600. They stopped manufacturing this model (have not re-checked recently) but was able to get a second one off eBay. I have also used my husband’s Black Rapid. Although comfortable, I can absolutely say their design for women is preferable.
I love getting this perspective. So many reviews don't include the perspective of women. I tried to make a note in the comments about them making a strap designed for women. Both wildlife and RUclips can feel very one-sided at times.
New to your channel and loving it because of videos like this! I do event, sports and school photography and often need 2 cameras. They are usually 24-70 and 70-200 for events and 70-200 and 200-500 (all Nikon) for sports. I am also 74 and can use a break from carrying. I thought I found my answer with Cotton Carrier (2 cameras) but found that the hubs rotated slightly from going in and out of the holster frequently. This usually resulted in not being able to get the camera out when needed. I had to try many different angles to get it out finally. The hub would get loose and rotate. I tried tightening as much as possible but still had slippage. I finally settled on the Spider system but hate the big plate. Still hoping for the perfect option. Thanks for your great videos.
Great comparison. I've been using the black rapid but not for long lenses. I will give the cotton carrier a serious look. Thank. As usual a great review.
For many years while having a 500f4 I carried it over my shoulder on a triood, with occasionally using the black rapid.. When using a walk around lens, I used the black rapid for over 12 yrs... But, last summer I purchased the cotton carrier with two extra side holsters and the binocular/tripod attachment.. What a game changer!!! I now have a camera/bins "tactical vest"... I can now carry a multitude of combinations, like two bodies with lenses attached plus bins... or monopod, bins, body/lens etc... all secured without them flailing around and Im completely hands free which allows me to have walking sticks or catch myself if a trip or lose footing... Even works great with my backpack on... Trying to do this with a black rapid was not ideal.. and definitely out of the question to carry the multiple items. I'm a little bummed I waited so long to try the cotton carrier. I can't imagine going out without it now.
I use the peak design system and actually mount both attachments to the arca plate. since that is on the lens plate, it banances the lens. There are a couple of mounting plaates they have. One is a thin plate and the other is an arca mount. I have had a problem with the thin plates pulling our of the lens. (200-600 Sony lens) No problems with the ARCA plates. No problems islipping. The Because it is adjustable, it works well with a second strap and camera across the opposite shoulder with a smaller lens.
I use the Kirk brand sling with my 5D series and my 100-400 and 300 2.8. It works great. It has a very aggressive friction pad, that holds the lens in place on you shoulder, but if you flip it around it slides nicely for quick action.
Very well done overview! I have an older version of the Cotton Carrier Harness. I don't use it all the time, mostly when I'm wandering around and have my 70-200mm f/2.8 on it with my pack on my back (currently my biggest lens). I also have 2 Black Rapid straps (1 being their backpack strap, only use it if using one my 2 smaller lens). I've been looking at other systems for different situations, applications or would work better for me. Much food for thought, thank you!
Great video, Scott, as always. I went back to look at this video because I am considering a modification to what I'm doing. I'd welcome your advice. Background: I shoot with an OM-1 and a 300 mm prime, commonly with a 1.4x teleconverter when in the field (I do mostly small bird photography). I have been using a Black Rapids sling and it works beautifully; I could wear the thing all day and forget that I'm wearing it as the system is so light to begin with. But I also own a 2nd body (Olympus OMD EM5iii fitted with a 12-200 mm lens) which is very light. Sometimes I'd like to carry both systems because there may be an opportunity for a shot of a landscape or flower or person where the extended range of my primary system won't work. But I have no way to conveniently carry a 2nd body other than to use a neck-strap, which will quickly get tangled up with the Black Rapids sling. I also wear binoculars on a neck-strap and, to top it off, when it is warm weather I may wear a shoulder strap carrying a water bottle. Obviously this system is ridiculous and if I'm wearing everything I risk strangling myself. After looking at your video, I am considering the Spider Holster (the one designed for a single camera) to carry my OMD EM5iii. It seems it would work swell to unobtrusively carry the secondary system. Am I wrong? What might you suggest in terms of the binoculars? My wife wears a harness for hers but she does not carry a camera. As I've looked at that design, it seems like the binocular harness would cause problems with the Black Rapids sling as the straps may bunch up and tangle with each other. What are your thoughts in this regard? Thanks much!
The peak design is great with 70-200. If you put one on the tripod collar and loosen the tightness so it rotates as you bring it up ro your eye, it is amazing how it just works so well. Tgis is with a gripped dslr mind you. So I can go from portrait to horizontal super easy
I use the D850 with 500PF with the Peak Design standard version sling. I love it. I use it out in the field in many of my videos, but being a wildlife photographer in hot Florida, not wearing a jacket with this sling can cause the tough "seatbelt like fabric" to dig into your neck or shoulder after long periods of time. Even with a lighter wildlife setup. Love this strap otherwise. I'd just recommend to wear a backpack or jacket to prevent irritation. Also having a backpack or hiking bag too tight can cause the strap to lock in place tightly from the rubber on the one side of the strap and you will have to lightly lift your bag on your back to release the tension to move the strap up and down your body. Only cons I've found, but they are very minor for what you get with this strap. Hope this helps someone and feel free to take a look at my channel. Great video as always!!
I used the Peak Design Slide on two cameras simultaneously over 4 days of Tanzanian safari in 2019 without any problems. Worked like a charm, both cameras slung crosswise across torso. Nikon D850 + Tamron 150-600 mm f/5.6-6.3 and Nikon D610 + Nikkor 70-200 mm f/2.8.
good to know! I actually found a great use for the slide lite on my binoculars and i love it. 2 point attachment, easy to adjust and i can take it off really quickly!
Scott - Great information as always. To me, a little bit of concern for the belt would be having the weight of the long lens pulling on the mount of the camera - over time there will be issues.
definitely dont connect to the body, i have seen disaster pics of camera bodies coming apart when mounted like that. I tried to add a graphic that said "dont do this at home"
Hi Scott , I watched your few videos so far. Thank you so much for the superb explanation regarding this strap method. I set it up, fantastic for me as I carry a 200-500mm lens. Also I gave a comment on your photo in Flickr which was Explored. Thanks for sharing with us your experience. Greetings from Sri Lanka.
I opted for the Optec strap, very comfy, with my R7 and sigma 150-600 I can walk for miles. Another point ref any carry method, not always a good idea to use the camera body, that's a lot of weight on a mirrorless camera body, so I use the loop on the foot of the lens, and the spare loop on the camera for when I am carrying a small lens, plus the wrist strap loop on the other body connector. Covers all my needs.
wish I had this video in my recommendations a week ago, I ordered 9 or 10 shoulder straps from Amazon and tried them all out and ended up going with a Waka Rapids 32" strap for my Sigma 150-600.
Thank you for a complete, informative review! I have used the Black Rapid for years, but wanted to see if other systems might work better for me. As I've aged, I've noticed more discomfort with the BR sling. You've given me some great information toward making my decision. I couldn't help but notice that the video seems to be reversed. I thought at first that you are left handed, but then noticed the buttons and dials on you cameras are backwards. Just an interesting detail. Thanks again for the great video!
Excellent video! Detailed and educational. I use the Peak Design slide but with a Black Rapid FR5 connector on the lens foot and both Peak Design anchors looped through the FR5. The issues is that with the 70-200 or 500PF with a D4S the lens faces upwards as the camera is heavier at the anchor point which is not ideal. Thanks for a great video.
I use a Black Rapid strap and use a plate from "Fusion Photo Gear", Its great if you use a monopod or tripod but still want to wear a strap to carry your camera. All you do is clip the Black Rapid clip onto the plate attachment loop and when you want to attach your camera to a tripod/monopod you simply unclip the Black Rapid clip and flip down the attachment loop on the Fusion Plate and just attach your camera to your tripod/monopod, easy peasy. I've used mine ( I have the Manfrotto replacement one) for several years now and haven't had any issues, though the clip on the Black Rapid has developed a groove in the metal from rubbing against the plate attachment loop so I'll have to buy a new Black Rapid strap soon since there's no way to remove the clip only. But the plate itself shows no sign of wear whatsoever. 👍🏼
I feel like you're asking for scoliosis using any of the asymmetric systems for super telephoto lenses. I have the peak design and I can't use it for longer than half an hour with my 200-600 without getting pain on one side (I'm also significantly stronger than the average adult male). Now I use a Nicama harness. It's a poor man's Cotton Carrier at only half the cost. I also still keep the peak design strap loosely over my neck, because I do have trust issues.
I took the Peak Design Slide out for a spin. I used to think of the design as a gimmick. I now use the PDS daily. There is no slippage. It is smooth and comfy. The strap, without padding, is comfortable for hours with a Z9 and 500mm PF. Most important for me is the elegance of simplicity. If something special occurs, I can grab my z9 and it's in front of my eye in an instant. It is smooth and simple. My old shoulder strap was far more clumsy for me. The peak design gets out of the way and lets me shoot. I have those Peak Design "ears" hanging from my D850 and Z9 already. I am sold on the system and the versatility. It adjusts with ease. It is really well-designed.
Great input. I may switch! I really feel like the peak doesnt swing as much which is my problem with black rapid. For Hiking I need something that doesn't swing as much!
Peak wide, Canon 5D mkIV, 100-400 II, I place one loop directly through the hole on the lens foot so I can also install tripod plate. I also hike with a day pack. It all works well. I also place two loops on my camera so I can switch to a 90mm macro lens quickly. I don’t use the included loop attachment bracket which cane with the strap. Slippage not a problem.
I love th black rapid. I spent 20 years in the Navy as a photographer, using a regular strap that always slid off shoulder. I went to Hawaii for a friend’s wedding and saw the photographer using the double rig, and said to myself “where have you been, all my life”! I asked the photographer where he got it, and went to that camera store before we left the island. That was 15 years ago, and I’ve never been unhappy with mine.
I first learned of BlackRapid from attending a Remembrance Day ceremony and the photographer from the air base had on her dark green dress tunic and the black double breath harness just seemed to discretely blend in to her military appearance, which is what you what for an occasion like that. It didn't look like a camera accessory she had slung over her shoulder like an average photographer working the crowd. So I hunted down the brand name later that day. I'll probably order one in the next two months before my outdoor shooting ramps up.
Really great review Scott! As a wildlife photographer, I currently own both the Rapid Strap and the Cotton Carrier CCS G3. I do a lot of hiking with my kids, so having the freedom of being able to explore and be comfortable while carrying my gear was really important. While I like the easier method of throwing my Rapid strap over my shoulder, I’ve quickly found that it can easily come lose causing my camera to fall and it’s a bit tough when bouncing around on the side of my hip. Always make sure it’s screwed lightly to the lens or camera body to ensure safety of your gear. Cotton carrier has been a dream. It rests comfortably and is easier to access when needed. I’m also able to use the side holster for a second camera body for landscape or macro. My gear has never once come unholstered making it a much safer choice for carrying around. I’m really glad you did this review! Awesome content as always :)
Another great and informative video. I have both the Black Rapid and Peak design (wider strap) systems. I really prefer the Black rapid and use it in combination with a Quick Release Plate on the tripod foot. The Peak Design is what I use for my camera with a wide angle lens. As to your opening comment on carrying a lens I want to warn people that you could actually injure yourself with extended carries. I spent a summer and fall carrying a Sigma 120-400 with my Canon 80d. I ended up giving myself 'tennis elbow' in both arms. This year with the Black Rapid and a Sigma 150-600 lens it is so so much easier. Oh and I have a second Black Rapid strap which attaches to my backpack straps. That is another great Black Rapid product!
For your heavier lenses you should use the Peak Design Slide, which is the wider version. I use it with my Canon R5 and RF 100-500 with no issues at all. I am a fan of the Peak Design system. I also use the Peak Design Capture which I have connected to my strap on my camera backpack. It is also great for carrying my camera at the ready when I have my RF 24-105 on my R5 body.
I like the black rapid, but for big/long lenses, even a 70-200, it’s mostly a no. It swings too much, and the shoulder strap slips off easily when I crouch/kneel/get low, which I do frequently. I don’t like lenses and camera bodies chaffing off my clothes and vice-versa. It is mainly useful if I’m actively shooting and only momentarily might have to lower it and let it hang to gain use of both hands. My big lens is in a backpack until I’m ready to hand hold it. I’m looking also into sling bags that would fit it, and permit fairly quick load/unload if I was on a joy hike or walking about. I’m glad to have all these options but will take the protection and reliability of a backpack over any of them…the convenience isn’t worth bashing my expensive gear against the earth getting from point to point.
I've used a Joby sling for years and it has never failed me. It is only attached to tripod collar so it does also swing, as your black rapid strap. I'm curious about the peak design one...
I am a birder and beginner with the pro-am range of DSLR cameras. I have a Nikon D500 with a 180-400 Nikon lens. The problem I see with the cross-body strap like Black Rapid is, combining it with a binocular strap around your neck results in the camera bumping into the binoculars or the bino strap when you pull the camera up to shoot. So I was using a Spider holster system with the camera hanging off the hip belt. No interference with the binoculars that were hanging around my neck. BUT since the camera only had a hand strap, I had to careful to hang onto it as I pulled it out of the holster. Also, the camera tended to bounce on my hip as I walked, and the longer lens felt more vulnerable to hitting something. So I purchased a Cotton Carrier G3 system with the camera up front, and my binoculars on a second Cotton Carrier side-mount holder (no neck strap on the binos, just a single security strap in case I dropped them). This way, the camera doesn't interfere with the binoculars at all (except for the bino security strap wrapping around the camera sometimes). It's worked great so far. However, I recently I purchased a bigger Nikon 200-500 5.6 lens so I'm concerned whether its size will be too big or too uncomfortable for the Cotton Carrier. So I'm planning on jury-rigging a system using my existing Spider hip-belt and holster, with a Carry Speed Pro Mark IV strap (similar to the Black Rapid but beefier). Unlike the Black Rapid strap, which has each strap end attach to the camera, so you have to slide the whole strap around your torso as you bring the camera up, the Carry Speed has an camera-mounted plate with a rectangular "ring" through which the strap goes, so the strap doesn't move; you just slide the camera up on a non-moving strap. I'll attach the strap to the Spider belt so the strap doesn't move, and reduces "movement slap" from the camera. The binoculars will be clipped into the second Spider holster on the opposite hip. So again, no interference between camera and binoculars, both of the independent of each other and never interfering. Wish me luck.
I use a peak slide light for the nocs on the left hip and the sling for camera on right hip. Works pretty good for me, I can see the cotton carrier working well for bins as well.
One thing I will say. Atleast with my setup, a battery grip olympus and 300mm prime, mounting the peak design to the bottom tripod mount rather than the lens actually works very well. This to me makes it pretty convenient, I don't have to unattach the strap when changing lenses, while also being comfortable for carrying large lenses (or atleast large in my equipment range, the 300mm has nothing on the real big boys). And I replaced the default mounting point with a tripod plate mounting point which I would have on the camera regardless. Having the lens vertical, atleast with that setup makes mobility a lot easier. I can quickly cinch it tighter and confidently climb a short cliff face without worrying about the camera flopping around and hitting anything. My left hand lightly resting on the camera stabilizes it pretty well for a light jog. The only thing that irks me about it is the slippage. Which only happens with my 300mm prime, which is my biggest setup. I was gifted the peak design strap, and I believe it is pretty old, no clue how it does when new.
G'day Scott, very useful information. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I had already spotted your Black Rapid strap and clamp arrangement in a prior video. So I went with that idea already. The only issue I have is that the clamp tends to be a bit hard on my hip. Also wonder if you have come across the long telephoto lens carrier from Mr Jan Gear. It looks like a good idea. Cheers.
I always make sure the knob is pointed away from body, it will poke you. I use an smaller clamp that is doesnt have hard edges. I think currently its a Sunwayfoto 30mm clamp
I use the Peak Design slide (full size) for my Nikon D500/500m pf. It works perfectly, and I'm a big fan of their equipment. I won't ever own a very large lens because I prefer being nimble and hand holding for wildlife. The dual connection to the camera and lens feels very comfortable with minimal swinging. I connect the lens anchor right to the lens by removing the foot on the 500mm pf (which I don't need anyway). The "slide" feature works as it should even on what you would call "sticky" surfaces. For example, if I sweat through a T-shirt or wear a certain type of jacket (wind, rain, winter, etc), the strap keeps sliding as it should. The gummy side feature words fantastic, too. Sometimes I forget to flip the strap from the gummy area and find myself tugging my jacket/shirt forward, it's that sticky. I purchased an extra set of anchors. The anchors have a "time to replace" color coding built in. If you see some of the underlying color, it means it's a good idea to change out. However, I've never reached this point but change them out every year anyway. Indeed, when you see how slim these anchors are, it's a bit disconcerting but they area are strong. I've had my camera snag on branches, bushes etc. and they are tough. I still would like to have a tether or safety so I'll look onto their website for this feature. Better safe than sorry. By the way, what material do you use for your own tethering?
great insight. The little tether I showed is a basic thing you can purchase on amazon and add a carabiner to the end. I am working on a video that shows some "safety" items for your gear and I will try to show it on that video, but it is nothing fancy.
I have used Peak Design straps for years and never though of this setup for my lens. I use the full size strap on my FX body and and the light strap on my DX body (the hand grip strap is good too). I never had a slipping issue the you referred to. Never had any issues with the connections either. I will try your method next time I go out. Also, could you tell me the Arca Swiss clamp you used on the Black Rapid strap? Glad I found your channel, enjoying it!
I have a bunch of arca plates and sometimes they migrate, but I have not had issues with any of the lesser brands. Sunwayfoto, i have found both cheap and reliable, but don't just use it on my recommendation. If you are concerned about quality get a brand you are familiar with, I am just sharing my experience using a clamp by them for several years
Another excellent review, I’m using the black rapid strap, and the cotton carrier vest. They both have there pros and cons. Need to try using arca Swiss set-up like you use on the black rapid, the cotton carrier arca adapter won’t work for me because I need the longer foot to balance the lens and camera on the tripod.
I love my Black Rapid Curve (made specifically for women…you ladies understand). However it does feel a little awkward with the longer lens. I’d love to hear more about your second security strap you use. Peak Design looks interesting for the more vertical carry.
Hello. Great video. I am taking my 80 yr. Old mom on her bucket list trip to Alaska to film the brown bear sows and their cubs. We are staying on a boat in a cove and will be hiking in knee deep+ water and over some fallen trees here and there. Ill have backpack with her camera and lens and a second body and lens for myself. Im trying to figure out the best way to carry my A1 and 600 F4 lens. I have full intentions of not falling in the water. Ha. Maybe the Cotton Carrier would balance the backpack weight a bit? Is there a way to strap the lens horizontally across the top of my backpack? Looking for any feedback on options. Thanks!
Hi. Nice test. I think the Cotton Carrier harness ist the best for heavy lenses. I would like to carry Canon R6II with 2x Extender and the EF 600/4 MK 2. Do you think it works with the CC?
I use the Peak Design Slide with my Z6ii + 200-500mm (one end connected to body, one to lens plate - would love something that doesn’t require the anchor to be removed to use tri/monopod though). I also use their everyday backpack, my only wish is that I bought the 30L instead of 20.
If you lens has a slot on the side you can use that. I dont think the 200-500 has that but the other primes usually have 2 of these little slots that you can use as anchor points.
My favorite Peak Design mod: attach those QR dongles to each side (bolt post) of one of their Capture Clips (put some material like rubber between the two sides of the Capture housing, in place of a pack shoulder strap), and connect the camera strap (the wide one) to those dongles, as intended. So you have a circular "bandolier". Attach the Capture plate to the lens' tripod foot. That way, you can just pull the lens off the strap via the Capture QR to use the camera unencumbered by a strap, then slap it back on the strap/Capture to walk. Secure enough and really convenient.
I use and enjoy the Blackrapid sling, connected to my 200-600 lens. I did add a second slide connection to the camera so I have two connection points in the unlikely event one fails. Very comfortable and allows this old guy to hike for long distances
Scott, I like the Peak Design strap, but I’m concerned that with a large lens it may put undo pressure on the camera/lens mount; one pulling up and to the side on the camera body, and the other on the lens foot pulling back and up. Should I not be concerned?
i dont think so, but I have found a lens foot (Hejnar) that has 2 QD connectors and I use that now in combination with the Peak strap. Works well for me.
I've been using the peak design strap for a while. Certainly very durable, it does slip a little bit, but the biggest down side I have with it. Is if I am carrying a backpack and I have my lens on the strap, it can be really difficult to actually get the lens up to my eye because it does rely on the strap sliding across your body.
I use Peak Design. Have a L bracket on the camera. Cotton: the hub is on the way when using a tripod, too much work to screw on /off, good for handheld. I have it but don't use it. Long lens I carry on my shoulder with cushion on my tripod. For a steady grip I rub clear silicone with a knife in the fabric... so it will not move much and hold everything in place. The same I did to my shoulder straps (cushion on top of the shoulder strap with some spots for better grip ) . Works well for me. I hate the bouncing of heavy lenses on my body. I am older and sometimes I feel like to lose balance on difficult situations.
I have just stumbled across your channel when looking for monopods ... and then I watched this video. Thanks for all of the information. I have a Sigma 150 - 600mm lens on a Canon 80D and so far have just used it for short walks with a tripod and gimbal head. I am looking to go to a monopod and also a system to carry a second body with a macro lens with the goal of being able to hike with it. My question is what do you do with your big lens on a monopod when you are shooting with the macro lens? Currently I can just leave it on the tripod but if it is on a monopod I can only imagine laying it on the ground and I am not sure that I would want to do that. I have a Black Rapid Strap already (love it) but if the camera and big lens were attached to that I don't know that I could balance that and use the macro lens. I am a 66 year old female weakling. LOL
while it would be a little odd, you could hitch the monopod to a sling. If you used a spider system, you could add a plate to the camera on the monopod and clip it on the spider belt as you used the macro lens (though this would be a little awkward). Yes I usually just lay it on the ground, and I know that is not ideal.
@@WildlifeInspired thanks for getting back to me. I have a think tank belt system but nothing big enough to hold the camera and lens. Maybe I need to start carrying a plastic garbage bag to lay it on. I am going to look like a pack mule if I keep adding to the things that I carry. LOL Thanks again.
I am trying to figure out how to carry my full frame camera and 200-600 lens attached to a monopod so that I can bird while I hike. So far my experience with the shoulder sling without the monopod is not very good and now I am adding more weight. The monopod is new to me and I use a peak design sling attached to the lens. I went out today to test things out. Nothing really seemed to work however I noticed that by the time my hike was over that if I have the lens sit sideways and rest on my hip it takes pressure off the shoulder. I tried it two ways: collapse the monopod and have it behind me or turn it and face it forward. Facing it forward definitely was better but the swing ultimately puts pressure back on my shoulder. I noted that if used the lens foot or monopod strap and pulled it up higher and stabilized it that it felt better. I am going to try attaching a peak connector to the monopod strap or the lens foot and tether it to the strap. I tried the cotton carrier and returned it. I didn't like a big long lens sitting in front of me. The spider holster doesn't seem to be designed for a smaller setup. So far I haven't found anything that is designed for carrying a cumbersome mounted setup that allows you to lift, point and shoot. The sling is close but developers really need to figure this one out. I tried carrying the setup on my shoulders as some photographers recommend but that didn't work out either. I always carry a backpack but I lighten it as much as possible and it is primarily for unloading the weight at the end of the day.
I just throw the whole thing in my shoulder and the monopod rest on my shoulder (long hikes it can be sore and I have noticed people will add a padding to the top of the monopod (even a pool noodle). There is also a connector made my Leofoto that goes around the monopod and a sling connects to it. This way the entire set up in held by the monopod (not the lens). I will try that set up one day and make a video
@@WildlifeInspired That would be interesting. I think that in all honesty what some developers forget is that women (generally) do not have the same shoulder strength or core strength as men. There needs to be a way to shift the weight and balance of equipment so it can be more evenly distributed and use the power of our hips which often carries natural padding. At least for some of us! Thanks for your input.
Yeah yeah yeah but where did you get your prints made at? :-). Ps. Love my Black Rapid Sport for sony 200-600. I am right-handed but bought the lefthanded version as I think maybe you did too. I use their quick release plate too if im switch to/from my monopod and the strap.
Did I flip the video again..... damnit. Like half my videos are flipped, I do for when I do live interviews because it makes me "look" into the screen, then I forget to change it back
Hi I loved your video, I am purchasing a Nikon 200-500mm lens and wondering if a BlackRapid Cross Shot Camera Sling would be ok attached to the lens foot? Thanks
it will screw in the base of the foot with not problem. You can also replace the foot with an arca style plate and use and arca clamp to attach from the strap to the foot. There are lots of options. I use the Peak Strap now more and find it to be a really nice option.
Great review Scott. I just purchase the Sony 200-600 that I use with the Sony A7iii. The question that comes to mind is can i use a system like the Cotton Carrier over a big winter coat? BTW i am a 5’1” woman. How do you carry your gear in winter, since you live in snow country?
I have the Skout and it's more than capable of carrying my 5DMkiii and any lens I want to put on it. It holds up really well to all day use. That said, my largest lenses are smaller than those 500mm/600mm lenses, but the quality of Cotton is superb and if you carry, say 300mm or smaller lenses, it's ideal.
your missing a critical part to your review: with the carry system attached how well (or not at all) do they attach to a tripod or monopod ? The QD system ( I hate dangles) is great for the tripod, but is totally incompatible with the cotton carrier system (I have both). Most of your systems shown are very problematic with using a arca plate to slide into a tripod or to be able to clamp at the balance point
I carry my Canon R5 with 600 mm lens with a blackrapid shoulder sling and no tripod or monopod. However, I have required physical therapy for AC joint issues as a result. (I'm 53.) I need to consider getting a monopod or tripod for the 600 mm but am stubborn about change.
I love your videos! I have been using the peak slide with the loop buttons wrapped around the little bracket thingies on each side of my long lenses (Z400 f/2.8 TC and Z600 f/4 TC. I have been using the same straps for several years, and I do notice some slippage. But I still like it better than Black Rapid. But I have been thinking about using the QR swivels with one on the lens foot (I have a Kirk) and one on my camera plate (I have a promedia gear). Does this put too much stress on the lens mount? It seems when I send my camera for a cleaning into Nikon, they often replace the lens mount, claiming it's bent...what do you thinK?
I have the heavier Peak Design Slide and it does creep a little bit over a long walk. For hiking I use the Slide and mostly carry by holding the lens foot plate in my hand with the strap over my neck and shoulder as a fail safe, the Slide lets me switch shoulders throughout the day and the anchor points allow for that without having to reconfigure to keep the camera where I want it. The anchor points did worry me to begin with but we check them frequently and replace as soon as we can see any type of fraying. I have replaced twice on my 150-600 and once on the D750 body in two years. I hated the Cotton Carrier chest system; I am a tiny woman and no matter how tight I adjusted the straps I found that the harness would rapidly slide downwards in the front and would start to feel even more front heavy, being tiny it was very awkward to carry lenses with any length as my torso is too short to use the harness effectively (not a fault of the system just a fact if you are small). I do use the belt attachment of the Cotton Carrier and like it for a second body and shorter lens, I also use their hand harness on the camera body and love it when I have smaller lenses on. For women looking at the Cotton Carrier; keep in mind that our chests also put the camera farther from our bodies and make it more front heavy. Some day I will find a better system but being tiny has serious drawbacks lol
Interesting. I know a lot of women who LOVE the cotton carrier based on anatomy. One very chesty woman, said she didn't like how straps cut into you and preferred this. Would like to see a woman give an honest review on this one. Since CC can be highly incentivised (like many products) often the review is biased to sell through links. I don't mind their system by the way. It's probably the best for hiking up rocks since it doesn't swing low on you hips if you climb.
@@WildlifeInspired I have used it for scrambling around mountain faces but I really do not like it. I find it very awkward, I have tried carrying the camera on an angle and straight up and down, I find that with my short torso that the lens interferes with my leg movements, on an angle it gets in the way of my arm. The 150-600 literally hangs down in front of my legs lol. The shorter lenses are ok with it but not the Sigma. I am just under 5 foot nothing and 100lbs on a heavy and tall day. I end up using a backpack more often than not. I have also rigged up a DIY carry system that lets me flip it over onto my back for scrambling but it is a pain to get into. It is two camera straps looped onto my shoulders then tightened down (one goes on the 2 camera mounts and one hooks to the lens foot) then a strap around my waist that also goes around the lens for stability. It ends up with the camera hanging straight down my back with the lens foot/plate to the outside. It is behind my hips so it doesn't interfere with me climbing or scrambling over rocks, but I have to be careful if I have to slide over a face of rock. It works but it's not pretty
I'd like to share my setup for hiking with my gear: I am using the Peak Design Capture Clip which I put onto the Straps of my evoc camera backpack. I use it with my Canon EOS 5D Mk IV and a Sigma 150-600mm lens and that works really well. I like the fact, that the camera is close to my body, doesn,t swing around, I have both hands free and can even use hiking sticks. The evoc backback has a separate compartment on the side to hold a hydration bladder (2 litres) which has a hole on the bottom. So in case your bladder geats leaky, the camera gear is safe. I can also strap on my sturdy Rollei tripod onto the evoc - so I can carry up to 33 lbs / 15kg of stuff around.
Also, I didn't want the arca swiss cotton carrier attachment because when putting a big lens on a gimbal or fluid head, you can't balance it because the hub still sticks out on the bottom.. So I just bought a few small arca swiss clamps with tether slots, and screwed them to all my cotton carrier hubs... So now I can clamp to any of my lenses that have a lens foot or any of my bodies, as I have L brackets on all my bodies.. Now all I have to do is unclamp and put it on a tripod. I've been thinking about doing a video on it. But I have no following on YT so I doubt anyone will see it.. One of these days I will start putting content on youtube 🤣
The Peak Design is great for a lighter setup. But when I tried to hike with it with a heavy zoom lens (Tamron 150-500) it really put a strain on my shoulder and I had to switch the strap to the other shoulder from time to time.
I have been using the Peak Design Slide with my Sony a6600 and 200-600 lens for sometime and quite often get around with my monopod attached at the same time which seems to work the only problem I have is that I only have strap and shouls probably look at getting another one. I loke that wiyh the slide it is always around my neck which vastly reduces the possibility of the camera hitting the ground if for any reason I drop it
Great overview. I've used the Cotton Carrier G3 on a bike and hiking with an A7iii and a Sigma 150-600. The trick was to mount the cotton carrier disc onto the lens' tripod foot at an angle, so it locks in when the camera and lens are perpendicular across my chest, instead of hanging straight down. Also found that rotating the tripod foot to the left side of worked well for me, so the top of the camera body was facing up instead of forward. Took a bit of fitting, but now I've been able to get up some sketchy mountain tracks on foot, and to ride wide and flat tracks on a mountain bike.
very cool
Hi Kenneth, do you mind posting a picture to show how the cotton carrier disc is mounted onto the lens's tripod foot a an angle? Thanks!
@@suetman1Yes, I would also like to see a photo of that set up. Thanks!
I've used them all and settled on the cotton carrier. Full support and the front weight is better than a $7k camera and lens swinging around and hitting stuff. Also if I fall I can brace myself using both hands. With the side slings I have to sacrifice one hand to grab the camera and use one hand to break my fall.
Simply put, the Cotton Carrier is the most comfortable and safe system on the market and it makes it a breeze to bend over and pick up lighting gear or other gear off the ground without dipping my camera in the dirt or mud. I can use both hands to carry gear and not worry about my camera swinging and banging into C stands. Hiking is a breeze with big lenses because I also have a backpack on which balances front to back loadouts. It's rugged and I have zero issues or concerns with it securing my camera.
Great input!
I use the peak design strap, its just easy to carry and walk with, use mine on a 600mm, I hike with a back pack with that strap over the top of it, its just simple and works. Also people forget - you can go to a car shop and get the pads you put on seatbelts if you feel like you want more softer connecting part with your shoulder or chest. the rubber on inside top is perfect for not moving so much while walking.
Great review, Scott. I use the Cotton Carrier G3 harness for two cameras and highly recommend it, especially for the even weight distribution and security. I have carried a 300mm and 500mm lens comfortably on the front and use the hip mount for a shorter lens (landscape or macro). It works really well for me and is quick to unholster/holster. Everything feels secure even when hiking, cross-country skiing or snowshoeing with a wildlife lens. I got an attachment for accessories that I put on my tripod so I can have my tripod mounted on my hip and still be hands-free when hiking. As you mentioned, the Cotton Carrier Scout is terrific for landscape and macro. I've used it with 70-200mm and I'd say that's the limit for my personal comfort level. Overall I prefer the harness, though.
Thanks for the imput my friend.. Hands off carrying is a big plus for some people
Great Information Scott Thank You. A quick note on the Peak Design Slide, they supply their own connector rings to attach the red anchor connector to their connector ring and then the camera post on the body. Not the OE connector you used in the video. I noticed that those Peak metal connector rings (not sure of the proper name) have begun to stretch out on my camera this is a major weak point I had to bend them back in with needle nose pliers. Something I will contact Peak about because they recommend using their connector rings versus the OEM ring that came with the camera.
Great review and comparison Scott. I teach a class in wildlife photography and it's amazing how many people want to talk about how to carry and manage the big lenses that are so important to our craft. Cheers!
Great video Scott! For the last month, since falling into some granite rocks, while climbing down to get closer to a river for landscape shots, Lol, I whacked my shoulder/rotator cuff. So I broke out my old Cotton Carrier, and re-fell in love with it!! I can shoot Bears all day, at Taylor Creek, South Lake Tahoe, and it keeps all the non shooting time/camera and long lens weight on my front, and NOT on my shoulder. (I used to cruise around with my monopod, fluid head, all on my shoulder, then shoot as needed. I'll get back there, but the Cotton Carrier is super convenient.
Great Vid. My 70-200mm f/2.8 Hub attached to my extended battery pack is a bit heavy for the battery pack attachment point. Installed the hub to the Lens foot and the extended battery pack is in the way for the twist on/off. Now I need a bushing extension for the Hub mounted on the hub foot. Or remove the extended battery pack.
Scott, thank you for the video. The Peak Design Anchor Mount can be set on the inside of the zoom lens foot (between the foot and the lens) and that way you can leave it there permanently and use your tripod at any time. This also allows the use the whole length of the zoom lens foot when I want to use a tripod - so I can balance the zoom lens when I change focal distance - this is helpful when I use my Wimberly Monogimbal. I use a Peak Design Slide to carry around a Fuji X-H1 and a 100-400mm lens. It is cushioned, so I find it preferable to the slide lite - I also have a Black Rapid but the anchor is too tall and it doesn't fit between the foot and the lens, so it is placed at the bottom of the lens foot and I need to remove it to use a tripod. Its annoying.
Great input thanks
This was awesome feedback Luis. I would have never thought of that set up but it makes allot of sense. I think you helped quite a few of us out here with that response. Thanks again.
@@krvp76 Glad it helps! You can do the same with your Black Rapid if the lens foot leaves enough space - sadly my Fuji 100-400 doesn't.
When i first saw this idea, I was thrilled, exactly what I wanted. Except the lens foot on my Tamron 150-600 doesn’t have that inside screw hole so it doesn’t work. I was so bummed when I realized that. :-( So depends on the foot.
After watching this video, I remembered I actually won one of the Peak light version camera straps but never used it. It worked perfectly on my trip. My Sony A7 III camera and 75-200 with a teleconverter lense were comfortably secured and the rubber on the shoulder kept it in place. Thank you.
awesome!
Great review Scott. As someone who suffer a back injury I need to be careful when carrying my gear. I can no longer throw the heavy tripod mounted camera over my shoulder. Lighter backpacks are fine but the shoulder straps and hip setups pull my spine awkwardly to one side. I have found the Cotton carrier harness to work the best for me. The D850 with a 500PF lens feels great. I can hike great distances jumping creeks and scrambling up and down hills without any problem. I can see where the 400 f2.8 or 500 f4 might be to much though.
So glad you commented!
I found your videos on RUclips today and immediately subscribed to them. You answer my questions in them. Thank you very much !
Wonderful!
Nice summary. I use BlackRapid straps, both the sport for carrying a single camera/lens including my Z9 and 800 PF, and the double when carrying two bodies with smaller lenses, and I use the QD swivel connectors instead of the screw-in connectors. The QD connectors make it real easy to disconnect the camera if I want to mount it on a tripod or hold it down low. I find the Peak Design straps slip too much, especially when I need to run down a trail, cross a stream, etc. I have thought about trying the Cotton Carrier.
I have switched to QD over the last year.
I use the Cotton Carrier G3 harness and I love it. Watts wildlife used it for his 600 mm a lot, in fact it is through him I heard about it. I don't even notice the camera set or the weight and I do have a bad back.
Thank you very much for your recommendations. I will consider them.
Great video! I carry my wildlife lens and camera with the bigger cotton carrier (G3) harness and a backpack for extra lenses or a tripod.
We hike thru the marsh in rubber boots or hip waters and climb over rocks and other weird terrain. So I need my hands a lot. It helps to have the camera securely attached.
The harness keeps my hands free, it distributes the weight perfectly in combination with a backpack and it fits me great. It’s higher off the ground, further away from the water. Hands down one of the best investments I’ve made and I use it every time when taking the camera out.
This being said, the longer the lens, the more it restricts movement (especially the hood), as mentioned in the video. Which would probably effect any carrying system, but it still works sufficiently.
If I had a large prime lens, it would travel in my backpack while hiking and I have a medium size zoom attached to my camera for quick deploy and general use while getting to a site.
I enjoyed this video comparing the different options and I’m glad I got the cotton carrier, it just works best for our adventurous lifestyle.
CC seems like a great choice for the more active person as you mentioned. Thanks for the input
Thank you so much for this. Trying to plan for a cruise to Alaska and had no idea where to start in terms of carrying equipment. Any more suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
I have a slide lite and love it! When hiking the camera hangs down my back which is very comfortable, I’m totally hands free. It’s easy to grab it and swing it around to shoot. I use it with a smaller lens and a mirrorless (18-400).
Thanks for input
Excellent info! I’ve often wondered about some of these! Thanks for the advice!
I bought the Black Rapid double carrier a couple years back and love it. I can separate the straps and use it as a single or have two cameras on me at the same time. Great review and food for thought on the other systems. Lots of people I've spoken with like the Cotton, I just like the grab and pull up to your eye advantage that the Black Rapid give you.
Agree
I've been using the Peak Design Slide strap for about 3 years without issues, including the strap creep that use mentioned. It is attached to a Canon 7D II, Canon EF 400mm f/4 DO IS II + 1.4 extender. Rather than 1 of the strap attachment point being on the lens foot as you showed it, I have it attached to the bottom of the camera. I'm a birder that carries a camera rather than a bird photographer and this system works well with binoculars
Interesting thanks for the input
I just jumped weight from a Nikon 80-400mm to a 200-500mm lens. Three days into having it and I seriously have to work out how to carry it. My Nikon 80-400 is a breeze compared to this monster! I like the idea of the plates attached to the tripod foot for extra security as well as a two-point system of attachment. I really like the freedom of handheld, but though numerous videos and reviews call the Nikon 200-500 a "light" lens, carrying 6 pounds comfortably is an issue, especially to raise it quickly to photograph birds in flight. The 200-500 photos are outstanding when I am braced correctly and pay attention to the lens light needs. This is a timely video for me. As a female with certain anatomical features, some of the placement of the harnesses do not look like they will work for me. I will look into the Arca plates and peak design. though if Black Rapid makes a design that might work for me, multiple attachments would be my preference as I walk and hike. Any additional thoughts or suggestions would be appreciated. Thank you!
I love my Black Rapid made specifically for women. I’ve used it through various gear changes, starting with a Canon 7DM2,+100-400 until today with my Sony A1+200-600. They stopped manufacturing this model (have not re-checked recently) but was able to get a second one off eBay. I have also used my husband’s Black Rapid. Although comfortable, I can absolutely say their design for women is preferable.
Thanks for the imput!
I love getting this perspective. So many reviews don't include the perspective of women. I tried to make a note in the comments about them making a strap designed for women. Both wildlife and RUclips can feel very one-sided at times.
@@WildlifeInspired Thanks. You are correct that photography is male-dominated.I appreciate your female perspective inclusion.
New to your channel and loving it because of videos like this! I do event, sports and school photography and often need 2 cameras. They are usually 24-70 and 70-200 for events and 70-200 and 200-500 (all Nikon) for sports. I am also 74 and can use a break from carrying. I thought I found my answer with Cotton Carrier (2 cameras) but found that the hubs rotated slightly from going in and out of the holster frequently. This usually resulted in not being able to get the camera out when needed. I had to try many different angles to get it out finally. The hub would get loose and rotate. I tried tightening as much as possible but still had slippage. I finally settled on the Spider system but hate the big plate. Still hoping for the perfect option. Thanks for your great videos.
Check out the PMG belt. maybe there is another smaller option? you can get a little 1/4 inch lug on a cage or maybe on the lens foot?
Great comparison. I've been using the black rapid but not for long lenses. I will give the cotton carrier a serious look. Thank. As usual a great review.
Thanks Bruce!
For many years while having a 500f4 I carried it over my shoulder on a triood, with occasionally using the black rapid..
When using a walk around lens, I used the black rapid for over 12 yrs...
But, last summer I purchased the cotton carrier with two extra side holsters and the binocular/tripod attachment.. What a game changer!!! I now have a camera/bins "tactical vest"... I can now carry a multitude of combinations, like two bodies with lenses attached plus bins... or monopod, bins, body/lens etc... all secured without them flailing around and Im completely hands free which allows me to have walking sticks or catch myself if a trip or lose footing... Even works great with my backpack on... Trying to do this with a black rapid was not ideal.. and definitely out of the question to carry the multiple items.
I'm a little bummed I waited so long to try the cotton carrier. I can't imagine going out without it now.
Thanks for the input, hoping to use this to get a lot of user imput. appreciated
I use the peak design system and actually mount both attachments to the arca plate. since that is on the lens plate, it banances the lens. There are a couple of mounting plaates they have. One is a thin plate and the other is an arca mount. I have had a problem with the thin plates pulling our of the lens. (200-600 Sony lens) No problems with the ARCA plates. No problems islipping. The Because it is adjustable, it works well with a second strap and camera across the opposite shoulder with a smaller lens.
very cool. feel free to send me a pic of your set up any time skeysimages@gmail.com
I use the Kirk brand sling with my 5D series and my 100-400 and 300 2.8. It works great. It has a very aggressive friction pad, that holds the lens in place on you shoulder, but if you flip it around it slides nicely for quick action.
I have not seen that used but will check it out.
Very well done overview! I have an older version of the Cotton Carrier Harness. I don't use it all the time, mostly when I'm wandering around and have my 70-200mm f/2.8 on it with my pack on my back (currently my biggest lens). I also have 2 Black Rapid straps (1 being their backpack strap, only use it if using one my 2 smaller lens). I've been looking at other systems for different situations, applications or would work better for me. Much food for thought, thank you!
Thanks !
Great video, Scott, as always. I went back to look at this video because I am considering a modification to what I'm doing. I'd welcome your advice.
Background: I shoot with an OM-1 and a 300 mm prime, commonly with a 1.4x teleconverter when in the field (I do mostly small bird photography). I have been using a Black Rapids sling and it works beautifully; I could wear the thing all day and forget that I'm wearing it as the system is so light to begin with. But I also own a 2nd body (Olympus OMD EM5iii fitted with a 12-200 mm lens) which is very light. Sometimes I'd like to carry both systems because there may be an opportunity for a shot of a landscape or flower or person where the extended range of my primary system won't work. But I have no way to conveniently carry a 2nd body other than to use a neck-strap, which will quickly get tangled up with the Black Rapids sling. I also wear binoculars on a neck-strap and, to top it off, when it is warm weather I may wear a shoulder strap carrying a water bottle.
Obviously this system is ridiculous and if I'm wearing everything I risk strangling myself.
After looking at your video, I am considering the Spider Holster (the one designed for a single camera) to carry my OMD EM5iii. It seems it would work swell to unobtrusively carry the secondary system. Am I wrong? What might you suggest in terms of the binoculars? My wife wears a harness for hers but she does not carry a camera. As I've looked at that design, it seems like the binocular harness would cause problems with the Black Rapids sling as the straps may bunch up and tangle with each other. What are your thoughts in this regard?
Thanks much!
I use a peak design lite strap for binoculars. Works well. If you like them clipped to your chest, Cotton Carrier also makes a nice carrier.
The peak design is great with 70-200. If you put one on the tripod collar and loosen the tightness so it rotates as you bring it up ro your eye, it is amazing how it just works so well. Tgis is with a gripped dslr mind you. So I can go from portrait to horizontal super easy
Nice review. I have been using the Black Rapid strap for several years and really like it. No malfunction so far.
Good to know
I’m going to check out the cotton carrier harness nothing else has worked for a small person
let me know how it works I dont have any other info about products for petite women
I use the D850 with 500PF with the Peak Design standard version sling. I love it. I use it out in the field in many of my videos, but being a wildlife photographer in hot Florida, not wearing a jacket with this sling can cause the tough "seatbelt like fabric" to dig into your neck or shoulder after long periods of time. Even with a lighter wildlife setup. Love this strap otherwise. I'd just recommend to wear a backpack or jacket to prevent irritation. Also having a backpack or hiking bag too tight can cause the strap to lock in place tightly from the rubber on the one side of the strap and you will have to lightly lift your bag on your back to release the tension to move the strap up and down your body. Only cons I've found, but they are very minor for what you get with this strap.
Hope this helps someone and feel free to take a look at my channel. Great video as always!!
I added a shoulder strap “pad” to my slide works great with my Sony 200-600
I used the Peak Design Slide on two cameras simultaneously over 4 days of Tanzanian safari in 2019 without any problems. Worked like a charm, both cameras slung crosswise across torso. Nikon D850 + Tamron 150-600 mm f/5.6-6.3 and Nikon D610 + Nikkor 70-200 mm f/2.8.
good to know! I actually found a great use for the slide lite on my binoculars and i love it. 2 point attachment, easy to adjust and i can take it off really quickly!
Scott - Great information as always. To me, a little bit of concern for the belt would be having the weight of the long lens pulling on the mount of the camera - over time there will be issues.
definitely dont connect to the body, i have seen disaster pics of camera bodies coming apart when mounted like that. I tried to add a graphic that said "dont do this at home"
Good review Scott been using the peak design had no problems , d500 and the z6 ii with sigma 150 -600
Hi Scott , I watched your few videos so far. Thank you so much for the superb explanation regarding this strap method. I set it up, fantastic for me as I carry a 200-500mm lens.
Also I gave a comment on your photo in Flickr which was Explored. Thanks for sharing with us your experience.
Greetings from Sri Lanka.
You're very welcome!
I attached a Peak Design Anchor link to a DC-38Q clamp and it works very well for longer lens
curious what that looks like. Feel free to message me or email me at skeysimages@gmail.com
cotton chest harness is what I use for my canon 80-d
I opted for the Optec strap, very comfy, with my R7 and sigma 150-600 I can walk for miles. Another point ref any carry method, not always a good idea to use the camera body, that's a lot of weight on a mirrorless camera body, so I use the loop on the foot of the lens, and the spare loop on the camera for when I am carrying a small lens, plus the wrist strap loop on the other body connector. Covers all my needs.
I used the Peak design strap with a sigma 150-600 lens. Its pretty heavy and I have never had a problem with it.
wish I had this video in my recommendations a week ago, I ordered 9 or 10 shoulder straps from Amazon and tried them all out and ended up going with a Waka Rapids 32" strap for my Sigma 150-600.
Thank you for a complete, informative review! I have used the Black Rapid for years, but wanted to see if other systems might work better for me. As I've aged, I've noticed more discomfort with the BR sling. You've given me some great information toward making my decision. I couldn't help but notice that the video seems to be reversed. I thought at first that you are left handed, but then noticed the buttons and dials on you cameras are backwards. Just an interesting detail. Thanks again for the great video!
totally reversed that was on older video, somehow I missed that it was backward after recording it! All good now
Perfect!!! Information that I was hoping to find. Thanks.
Excellent video! Detailed and educational. I use the Peak Design slide but with a Black Rapid FR5 connector on the lens foot and both Peak Design anchors looped through the FR5. The issues is that with the 70-200 or 500PF with a D4S the lens faces upwards as the camera is heavier at the anchor point which is not ideal. Thanks for a great video.
thanks!
Another excellent review, I’m using the black rapid strap, and the cotton carrier vest
thanks!
You saved me some money, I have both versions of Peak Design straps. I never though of using it like this with a telephoto lens.
You'll see lots of wildlife people with long legs talking about how they love it and they legit rate it to hold 200lbs
I use a Black Rapid strap and use a plate from "Fusion Photo Gear", Its great if you use a monopod or tripod but still want to wear a strap to carry your camera. All you do is clip the Black Rapid clip onto the plate attachment loop and when you want to attach your camera to a tripod/monopod you simply unclip the Black Rapid clip and flip down the attachment loop on the Fusion Plate and just attach your camera to your tripod/monopod, easy peasy.
I've used mine ( I have the Manfrotto replacement one) for several years now and haven't had any issues, though the clip on the Black Rapid has developed a groove in the metal from rubbing against the plate attachment loop so I'll have to buy a new Black Rapid strap soon since there's no way to remove the clip only. But the plate itself shows no sign of wear whatsoever. 👍🏼
interesting I will look into this
Excellent, honest review of these different systems. Thanks.
Thanks for watching!
I feel like you're asking for scoliosis using any of the asymmetric systems for super telephoto lenses. I have the peak design and I can't use it for longer than half an hour with my 200-600 without getting pain on one side (I'm also significantly stronger than the average adult male). Now I use a Nicama harness. It's a poor man's Cotton Carrier at only half the cost. I also still keep the peak design strap loosely over my neck, because I do have trust issues.
I took the Peak Design Slide out for a spin. I used to think of the design as a gimmick. I now use the PDS daily. There is no slippage. It is smooth and comfy. The strap, without padding, is comfortable for hours with a Z9 and 500mm PF. Most important for me is the elegance of simplicity. If something special occurs, I can grab my z9 and it's in front of my eye in an instant. It is smooth and simple. My old shoulder strap was far more clumsy for me. The peak design gets out of the way and lets me shoot. I have those Peak Design "ears" hanging from my D850 and Z9 already. I am sold on the system and the versatility. It adjusts with ease. It is really well-designed.
Great input. I may switch! I really feel like the peak doesnt swing as much which is my problem with black rapid. For Hiking I need something that doesn't swing as much!
If they are going to go full harness, they may as well add support for a hydration pack on the back with molle on the unused sections.
Thanks Scott👍
Welcome
Peak wide, Canon 5D mkIV, 100-400 II, I place one loop directly through the hole on the lens foot so I can also install tripod plate. I also hike with a day pack. It all works well. I also place two loops on my camera so I can switch to a 90mm macro lens quickly. I don’t use the included loop attachment bracket which cane with the strap. Slippage not a problem.
I love th black rapid. I spent 20 years in the Navy as a photographer, using a regular strap that always slid off shoulder. I went to Hawaii for a friend’s wedding and saw the photographer using the double rig, and said to myself “where have you been, all my life”! I asked the photographer where he got it, and went to that camera store before we left the island. That was 15 years ago, and I’ve never been unhappy with mine.
I have no issues with it!
I first learned of BlackRapid from attending a Remembrance Day ceremony and the photographer from the air base had on her dark green dress tunic and the black double breath harness just seemed to discretely blend in to her military appearance, which is what you what for an occasion like that. It didn't look like a camera accessory she had slung over her shoulder like an average photographer working the crowd. So I hunted down the brand name later that day. I'll probably order one in the next two months before my outdoor shooting ramps up.
Really great review Scott! As a wildlife photographer, I currently own both the Rapid Strap and the Cotton Carrier CCS G3. I do a lot of hiking with my kids, so having the freedom of being able to explore and be comfortable while carrying my gear was really important. While I like the easier method of throwing my Rapid strap over my shoulder, I’ve quickly found that it can easily come lose causing my camera to fall and it’s a bit tough when bouncing around on the side of my hip. Always make sure it’s screwed lightly to the lens or camera body to ensure safety of your gear. Cotton carrier has been a dream. It rests comfortably and is easier to access when needed. I’m also able to use the side holster for a second camera body for landscape or macro. My gear has never once come unholstered making it a much safer choice for carrying around. I’m really glad you did this review! Awesome content as always :)
Subscribed ;D
Good insight Lisa!
Another great and informative video. I have both the Black Rapid and Peak design (wider strap) systems. I really prefer the Black rapid and use it in combination with a Quick Release Plate on the tripod foot. The Peak Design is what I use for my camera with a wide angle lens. As to your opening comment on carrying a lens I want to warn people that you could actually injure yourself with extended carries. I spent a summer and fall carrying a Sigma 120-400 with my Canon 80d. I ended up giving myself 'tennis elbow' in both arms. This year with the Black Rapid and a Sigma 150-600 lens it is so so much easier. Oh and I have a second Black Rapid strap which attaches to my backpack straps. That is another great Black Rapid product!
Thanks for the input !!
For your heavier lenses you should use the Peak Design Slide, which is the wider version. I use it with my Canon R5 and RF 100-500 with no issues at all.
I am a fan of the Peak Design system. I also use the Peak Design Capture which I have connected to my strap on my camera backpack. It is also great for carrying my camera at the ready when I have my RF 24-105 on my R5 body.
I like the black rapid, but for big/long lenses, even a 70-200, it’s mostly a no. It swings too much, and the shoulder strap slips off easily when I crouch/kneel/get low, which I do frequently. I don’t like lenses and camera bodies chaffing off my clothes and vice-versa. It is mainly useful if I’m actively shooting and only momentarily might have to lower it and let it hang to gain use of both hands. My big lens is in a backpack until I’m ready to hand hold it. I’m looking also into sling bags that would fit it, and permit fairly quick load/unload if I was on a joy hike or walking about. I’m glad to have all these options but will take the protection and reliability of a backpack over any of them…the convenience isn’t worth bashing my expensive gear against the earth getting from point to point.
I just bought second a spider holster the second camera that i use . Fuji xt 30 never know of such a thing.
The orther is a fuji x t3 with 100 400
I've used a Joby sling for years and it has never failed me. It is only attached to tripod collar so it does also swing, as your black rapid strap. I'm curious about the peak design one...
Another option. I've never used that one !
I am a birder and beginner with the pro-am range of DSLR cameras. I have a Nikon D500 with a 180-400 Nikon lens. The problem I see with the cross-body strap like Black Rapid is, combining it with a binocular strap around your neck results in the camera bumping into the binoculars or the bino strap when you pull the camera up to shoot.
So I was using a Spider holster system with the camera hanging off the hip belt. No interference with the binoculars that were hanging around my neck. BUT since the camera only had a hand strap, I had to careful to hang onto it as I pulled it out of the holster. Also, the camera tended to bounce on my hip as I walked, and the longer lens felt more vulnerable to hitting something.
So I purchased a Cotton Carrier G3 system with the camera up front, and my binoculars on a second Cotton Carrier side-mount holder (no neck strap on the binos, just a single security strap in case I dropped them). This way, the camera doesn't interfere with the binoculars at all (except for the bino security strap wrapping around the camera sometimes). It's worked great so far.
However, I recently I purchased a bigger Nikon 200-500 5.6 lens so I'm concerned whether its size will be too big or too uncomfortable for the Cotton Carrier.
So I'm planning on jury-rigging a system using my existing Spider hip-belt and holster, with a Carry Speed Pro Mark IV strap (similar to the Black Rapid but beefier). Unlike the Black Rapid strap, which has each strap end attach to the camera, so you have to slide the whole strap around your torso as you bring the camera up, the Carry Speed has an camera-mounted plate with a rectangular "ring" through which the strap goes, so the strap doesn't move; you just slide the camera up on a non-moving strap. I'll attach the strap to the Spider belt so the strap doesn't move, and reduces "movement slap" from the camera. The binoculars will be clipped into the second Spider holster on the opposite hip. So again, no interference between camera and binoculars, both of the independent of each other and never interfering. Wish me luck.
I use a peak slide light for the nocs on the left hip and the sling for camera on right hip. Works pretty good for me, I can see the cotton carrier working well for bins as well.
One thing I will say. Atleast with my setup, a battery grip olympus and 300mm prime, mounting the peak design to the bottom tripod mount rather than the lens actually works very well. This to me makes it pretty convenient, I don't have to unattach the strap when changing lenses, while also being comfortable for carrying large lenses (or atleast large in my equipment range, the 300mm has nothing on the real big boys). And I replaced the default mounting point with a tripod plate mounting point which I would have on the camera regardless.
Having the lens vertical, atleast with that setup makes mobility a lot easier. I can quickly cinch it tighter and confidently climb a short cliff face without worrying about the camera flopping around and hitting anything. My left hand lightly resting on the camera stabilizes it pretty well for a light jog.
The only thing that irks me about it is the slippage. Which only happens with my 300mm prime, which is my biggest setup. I was gifted the peak design strap, and I believe it is pretty old, no clue how it does when new.
feel free to send me a quick photo of your set up skeysimages@gmail.com
G'day Scott, very useful information. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I had already spotted your Black Rapid strap and clamp arrangement in a prior video. So I went with that idea already. The only issue I have is that the clamp tends to be a bit hard on my hip. Also wonder if you have come across the long telephoto lens carrier from Mr Jan Gear. It looks like a good idea. Cheers.
I always make sure the knob is pointed away from body, it will poke you. I use an smaller clamp that is doesnt have hard edges. I think currently its a Sunwayfoto 30mm clamp
I use the Peak Design slide (full size) for my Nikon D500/500m pf. It works perfectly, and I'm a big fan of their equipment. I won't ever own a very large lens because I prefer being nimble and hand holding for wildlife. The dual connection to the camera and lens feels very comfortable with minimal swinging. I connect the lens anchor right to the lens by removing the foot on the 500mm pf (which I don't need anyway). The "slide" feature works as it should even on what you would call "sticky" surfaces. For example, if I sweat through a T-shirt or wear a certain type of jacket (wind, rain, winter, etc), the strap keeps sliding as it should. The gummy side feature words fantastic, too. Sometimes I forget to flip the strap from the gummy area and find myself tugging my jacket/shirt forward, it's that sticky. I purchased an extra set of anchors. The anchors have a "time to replace" color coding built in. If you see some of the underlying color, it means it's a good idea to change out. However, I've never reached this point but change them out every year anyway. Indeed, when you see how slim these anchors are, it's a bit disconcerting but they area are strong. I've had my camera snag on branches, bushes etc. and they are tough. I still would like to have a tether or safety so I'll look onto their website for this feature. Better safe than sorry.
By the way, what material do you use for your own tethering?
great insight. The little tether I showed is a basic thing you can purchase on amazon and add a carabiner to the end. I am working on a video that shows some "safety" items for your gear and I will try to show it on that video, but it is nothing fancy.
@@WildlifeInspired Excellent, yes that would be helpful since I'm trying to come up with some ideas - so simple not fancy is great. Thank you.
I have used Peak Design straps for years and never though of this setup for my lens. I use the full size strap on my FX body and and the light strap on my DX body (the hand grip strap is good too). I never had a slipping issue the you referred to. Never had any issues with the connections either. I will try your method next time I go out. Also, could you tell me the Arca Swiss clamp you used on the Black Rapid strap?
Glad I found your channel, enjoying it!
I have a bunch of arca plates and sometimes they migrate, but I have not had issues with any of the lesser brands. Sunwayfoto, i have found both cheap and reliable, but don't just use it on my recommendation. If you are concerned about quality get a brand you are familiar with, I am just sharing my experience using a clamp by them for several years
Another excellent review, I’m using the black rapid strap, and the cotton carrier vest. They both have there pros and cons. Need to try using arca Swiss set-up like you use on the black rapid, the cotton carrier arca adapter won’t work for me because I need the longer foot to balance the lens and camera on the tripod.
If you use the arca system consider a tether. I'll make a video about it soon
I love my Black Rapid Curve (made specifically for women…you ladies understand). However it does feel a little awkward with the longer lens. I’d love to hear more about your second security strap you use. Peak Design looks interesting for the more vertical carry.
working on a "safety" video that will include the tether. ill send you a DM.
The load must be evenly distributed for best comfort .😊
I use the Rapid and Spider together.
When I'm striding out it goes into the holster to stop it swinging.
Interesting!
Hello. Great video. I am taking my 80 yr. Old mom on her bucket list trip to Alaska to film the brown bear sows and their cubs. We are staying on a boat in a cove and will be hiking in knee deep+ water and over some fallen trees here and there. Ill have backpack with her camera and lens and a second body and lens for myself. Im trying to figure out the best way to carry my A1 and 600 F4 lens. I have full intentions of not falling in the water. Ha. Maybe the Cotton Carrier would balance the backpack weight a bit? Is there a way to strap the lens horizontally across the top of my backpack? Looking for any feedback on options. Thanks!
someone makes a horizontal "cradle" I think it Mr. Jan Gear. Check their website.
Hi. Nice test. I think the Cotton Carrier harness ist the best for heavy lenses. I would like to carry Canon R6II with 2x Extender and the EF 600/4 MK 2. Do you think it works with the CC?
I use the Peak Design Slide with my Z6ii + 200-500mm (one end connected to body, one to lens plate - would love something that doesn’t require the anchor to be removed to use tri/monopod though). I also use their everyday backpack, my only wish is that I bought the 30L instead of 20.
If you lens has a slot on the side you can use that. I dont think the 200-500 has that but the other primes usually have 2 of these little slots that you can use as anchor points.
My favorite Peak Design mod: attach those QR dongles to each side (bolt post) of one of their Capture Clips (put some material like rubber between the two sides of the Capture housing, in place of a pack shoulder strap), and connect the camera strap (the wide one) to those dongles, as intended. So you have a circular "bandolier". Attach the Capture plate to the lens' tripod foot. That way, you can just pull the lens off the strap via the Capture QR to use the camera unencumbered by a strap, then slap it back on the strap/Capture to walk. Secure enough and really convenient.
Feel free to email me a picture of this set up! Would love to see it. skeysimages@gmail.com
I use and enjoy the Blackrapid sling, connected to my 200-600 lens. I did add a second slide connection to the camera so I have two connection points in the unlikely event one fails. Very comfortable and allows this old guy to hike for long distances
Smart. I considered adding 2 small arca plates instead of the tether
The Lenscarrier of Mr Jangear is the best......
I have seen but not used I might look into that!
@@WildlifeInspired it comes with a harness, and without the harness you can attach it to yr backpack. You have perfect balance than.
Scott, I like the Peak Design strap, but I’m concerned that with a large lens it may put undo pressure on the camera/lens mount; one pulling up and to the side on the camera body, and the other on the lens foot pulling back and up. Should I not be concerned?
i dont think so, but I have found a lens foot (Hejnar) that has 2 QD connectors and I use that now in combination with the Peak strap. Works well for me.
I've been using the peak design strap for a while. Certainly very durable, it does slip a little bit, but the biggest down side I have with it. Is if I am carrying a backpack and I have my lens on the strap, it can be really difficult to actually get the lens up to my eye because it does rely on the strap sliding across your body.
Good point
Agree with Kyle here and also. Attach BOTH eyes to the big lens and not body. Your going to kill the mount.
I use Peak Design. Have a L bracket on the camera. Cotton: the hub is on the way when using a tripod, too much work to screw on /off, good for handheld. I have it but don't use it. Long lens I carry on my shoulder with cushion on my tripod. For a steady grip I rub clear silicone with a knife in the fabric... so it will not move much and hold everything in place. The same I did to my shoulder straps (cushion on top of the shoulder strap with some spots for better grip ) . Works well for me. I hate the bouncing of heavy lenses on my body. I am older and sometimes I feel like to lose balance on difficult situations.
interesting using the silicone!
I have just stumbled across your channel when looking for monopods ... and then I watched this video. Thanks for all of the information. I have a Sigma 150 - 600mm lens on a Canon 80D and so far have just used it for short walks with a tripod and gimbal head. I am looking to go to a monopod and also a system to carry a second body with a macro lens with the goal of being able to hike with it. My question is what do you do with your big lens on a monopod when you are shooting with the macro lens? Currently I can just leave it on the tripod but if it is on a monopod I can only imagine laying it on the ground and I am not sure that I would want to do that. I have a Black Rapid Strap already (love it) but if the camera and big lens were attached to that I don't know that I could balance that and use the macro lens. I am a 66 year old female weakling. LOL
while it would be a little odd, you could hitch the monopod to a sling. If you used a spider system, you could add a plate to the camera on the monopod and clip it on the spider belt as you used the macro lens (though this would be a little awkward). Yes I usually just lay it on the ground, and I know that is not ideal.
@@WildlifeInspired thanks for getting back to me. I have a think tank belt system but nothing big enough to hold the camera and lens. Maybe I need to start carrying a plastic garbage bag to lay it on. I am going to look like a pack mule if I keep adding to the things that I carry. LOL Thanks again.
I am trying to figure out how to carry my full frame camera and 200-600 lens attached to a monopod so that I can bird while I hike. So far my experience with the shoulder sling without the monopod is not very good and now I am adding more weight. The monopod is new to me and I use a peak design sling attached to the lens. I went out today to test things out. Nothing really seemed to work however I noticed that by the time my hike was over that if I have the lens sit sideways and rest on my hip it takes pressure off the shoulder. I tried it two ways: collapse the monopod and have it behind me or turn it and face it forward. Facing it forward definitely was better but the swing ultimately puts pressure back on my shoulder. I noted that if used the lens foot or monopod strap and pulled it up higher and stabilized it that it felt better. I am going to try attaching a peak connector to the monopod strap or the lens foot and tether it to the strap. I tried the cotton carrier and returned it. I didn't like a big long lens sitting in front of me. The spider holster doesn't seem to be designed for a smaller setup. So far I haven't found anything that is designed for carrying a cumbersome mounted setup that allows you to lift, point and shoot. The sling is close but developers really need to figure this one out. I tried carrying the setup on my shoulders as some photographers recommend but that didn't work out either. I always carry a backpack but I lighten it as much as possible and it is primarily for unloading the weight at the end of the day.
I just throw the whole thing in my shoulder and the monopod rest on my shoulder (long hikes it can be sore and I have noticed people will add a padding to the top of the monopod (even a pool noodle). There is also a connector made my Leofoto that goes around the monopod and a sling connects to it. This way the entire set up in held by the monopod (not the lens). I will try that set up one day and make a video
@@WildlifeInspired That would be interesting. I think that in all honesty what some developers forget is that women (generally) do not have the same shoulder strength or core strength as men. There needs to be a way to shift the weight and balance of equipment so it can be more evenly distributed and use the power of our hips which often carries natural padding. At least for some of us! Thanks for your input.
Yeah yeah yeah but where did you get your prints made at? :-). Ps. Love my Black Rapid Sport for sony 200-600. I am right-handed but bought the lefthanded version as I think maybe you did too. I use their quick release plate too if im switch to/from my monopod and the strap.
Did I flip the video again..... damnit. Like half my videos are flipped, I do for when I do live interviews because it makes me "look" into the screen, then I forget to change it back
@@WildlifeInspired HAHAH.. pull it together man. :-) Damn ducks.
Thank you. Useful information.
Glad it was helpful!
great info, thanks
Hi I loved your video, I am purchasing a Nikon 200-500mm lens and wondering if a BlackRapid Cross Shot Camera Sling would be ok attached to the lens foot? Thanks
it will screw in the base of the foot with not problem. You can also replace the foot with an arca style plate and use and arca clamp to attach from the strap to the foot. There are lots of options. I use the Peak Strap now more and find it to be a really nice option.
Thank you. @@WildlifeInspired
Great review Scott. I just purchase the Sony 200-600 that I use with the Sony A7iii. The question that comes to mind is can i use a system like the Cotton Carrier over a big winter coat? BTW i am a 5’1” woman. How do you carry your gear in winter, since you live in snow country?
a black rapid strap
Thank you kindly, Scott.
The cotton carrier would fit you with any size coat. Very adjustable.
I have the Skout and it's more than capable of carrying my 5DMkiii and any lens I want to put on it. It holds up really well to all day use. That said, my largest lenses are smaller than those 500mm/600mm lenses, but the quality of Cotton is superb and if you carry, say 300mm or smaller lenses, it's ideal.
your missing a critical part to your review: with the carry system attached how well (or not at all) do they attach to a tripod or monopod ? The QD system ( I hate dangles) is great for the tripod, but is totally incompatible with the cotton carrier system (I have both).
Most of your systems shown are very problematic with using a arca plate to slide into a tripod or to be able to clamp at the balance point
I carry my Canon R5 with 600 mm lens with a blackrapid shoulder sling and no tripod or monopod. However, I have required physical therapy for AC joint issues as a result. (I'm 53.) I need to consider getting a monopod or tripod for the 600 mm but am stubborn about change.
no way are you 53!!! now you are bragging Doc!
I love your videos! I have been using the peak slide with the loop buttons wrapped around the little bracket thingies on each side of my long lenses (Z400 f/2.8 TC and Z600 f/4 TC. I have been using the same straps for several years, and I do notice some slippage. But I still like it better than Black Rapid. But I have been thinking about using the QR swivels with one on the lens foot (I have a Kirk) and one on my camera plate (I have a promedia gear). Does this put too much stress on the lens mount? It seems when I send my camera for a cleaning into Nikon, they often replace the lens mount, claiming it's bent...what do you thinK?
check out my video on QD and straps. I am using a Peak Strap connected to QD connectors and I like it so far.
I have the heavier Peak Design Slide and it does creep a little bit over a long walk. For hiking I use the Slide and mostly carry by holding the lens foot plate in my hand with the strap over my neck and shoulder as a fail safe, the Slide lets me switch shoulders throughout the day and the anchor points allow for that without having to reconfigure to keep the camera where I want it. The anchor points did worry me to begin with but we check them frequently and replace as soon as we can see any type of fraying. I have replaced twice on my 150-600 and once on the D750 body in two years.
I hated the Cotton Carrier chest system; I am a tiny woman and no matter how tight I adjusted the straps I found that the harness would rapidly slide downwards in the front and would start to feel even more front heavy, being tiny it was very awkward to carry lenses with any length as my torso is too short to use the harness effectively (not a fault of the system just a fact if you are small). I do use the belt attachment of the Cotton Carrier and like it for a second body and shorter lens, I also use their hand harness on the camera body and love it when I have smaller lenses on. For women looking at the Cotton Carrier; keep in mind that our chests also put the camera farther from our bodies and make it more front heavy.
Some day I will find a better system but being tiny has serious drawbacks lol
Interesting. I know a lot of women who LOVE the cotton carrier based on anatomy. One very chesty woman, said she didn't like how straps cut into you and preferred this. Would like to see a woman give an honest review on this one. Since CC can be highly incentivised (like many products) often the review is biased to sell through links. I don't mind their system by the way. It's probably the best for hiking up rocks since it doesn't swing low on you hips if you climb.
@@WildlifeInspired I have used it for scrambling around mountain faces but I really do not like it. I find it very awkward, I have tried carrying the camera on an angle and straight up and down, I find that with my short torso that the lens interferes with my leg movements, on an angle it gets in the way of my arm. The 150-600 literally hangs down in front of my legs lol. The shorter lenses are ok with it but not the Sigma. I am just under 5 foot nothing and 100lbs on a heavy and tall day. I end up using a backpack more often than not. I have also rigged up a DIY carry system that lets me flip it over onto my back for scrambling but it is a pain to get into. It is two camera straps looped onto my shoulders then tightened down (one goes on the 2 camera mounts and one hooks to the lens foot) then a strap around my waist that also goes around the lens for stability. It ends up with the camera hanging straight down my back with the lens foot/plate to the outside. It is behind my hips so it doesn't interfere with me climbing or scrambling over rocks, but I have to be careful if I have to slide over a face of rock. It works but it's not pretty
I'd like to share my setup for hiking with my gear: I am using the Peak Design Capture Clip which I put onto the Straps of my evoc camera backpack. I use it with my Canon EOS 5D Mk IV and a Sigma 150-600mm lens and that works really well. I like the fact, that the camera is close to my body, doesn,t swing around, I have both hands free and can even use hiking sticks.
The evoc backback has a separate compartment on the side to hold a hydration bladder (2 litres) which has a hole on the bottom. So in case your bladder geats leaky, the camera gear is safe. I can also strap on my sturdy Rollei tripod onto the evoc - so I can carry up to 33 lbs / 15kg of stuff around.
When using the capture clip on your backpack strap do you attach the camera body or the lenses tripod collar?
@@tdsw I attach the camera body. So the camera and lens is firmly attached, very close to my body and doesn't dangle at.
very helpful video thank you very much
Also, I didn't want the arca swiss cotton carrier attachment because when putting a big lens on a gimbal or fluid head, you can't balance it because the hub still sticks out on the bottom.. So I just bought a few small arca swiss clamps with tether slots, and screwed them to all my cotton carrier hubs... So now I can clamp to any of my lenses that have a lens foot or any of my bodies, as I have L brackets on all my bodies.. Now all I have to do is unclamp and put it on a tripod.
I've been thinking about doing a video on it. But I have no following on YT so I doubt anyone will see it.. One of these days I will start putting content on youtube 🤣
keep an eye on this. I may ask users to submit ideas and "hacks" and maybe I could feature you on that video.
@@WildlifeInspired awesome! Will do!
The Peak Design is great for a lighter setup. But when I tried to hike with it with a heavy zoom lens (Tamron 150-500) it really put a strain on my shoulder and I had to switch the strap to the other shoulder from time to time.
After an hour or so, I find the same!
The larger Peak Design strap has a pad in it
Very helpfull, thanks a lot!
I have been using the Peak Design Slide with my Sony a6600 and 200-600 lens for sometime and quite often get around with my monopod attached at the same time which seems to work the only problem I have is that I only have strap and shouls probably look at getting another one. I loke that wiyh the slide it is always around my neck which vastly reduces the possibility of the camera hitting the ground if for any reason I drop it
Thx for this. Helpfull
Grz from Holland
Glad it was helpful!
Spider Holster for me