@@sarahc3295 It's always suspicious when someone tries SO HARD to come off squeaky clean and perfect. Like dude, why? What are you so afraid will come out?
If Jimmy Bob is so protective of his girls then why DIDN'T he protect his girls from Josh...why has JB protected and covered up for Josh??? I can't wrap my brain around any of this...it's a very SICK AND TWISTED family dynamic.
@@kristywebb3471 - thank you 😉. Let kids be kids. I have 2 boys who are 18 & 21. My 21yr is a fireman & paramedic and the other is doing the same thing but In the Army. I can’t imagine if they told me they were getting married. 🤨 to their girlfriends now 🤦🏼♀️ Their father & I married at 27 but started dating our sophomore year of college.
The thought of “ North Korea “ leaders came to my mind !?!? The people there have pictures of their “leader” in their homes. A picture of your dad doesn’t normally belong in your bedroom !
@@MeganVictoriaKearns North Koreans fear their Dear Leader, Kim Jung Un. They have his photograph in every room because they fear being reported for lack of admiration.
Yeah, I’d never keep a pic of my parents in my bedroom! I love them dearly, don’t get me wrong, but I can’t look at my parents while being intimate withy husband, lol.
I kinda feel bad for these kids having rumors swirl. I went to a private IFB college (being a 28 year old freshman after leaving the Army) and you couldn't as much as sit on the same bench or couch in the common areas with someone of the opposite sex without people asking if there's something there. It was really annoying.
I feel bad for Jinger as far as rumors go. Imagine how Jinger felt having a whole website named after her, hoping she would rebel. It must have put her in a very horrible position with her parents.
@@jessestewart169 n not every family has infant s a. If they do I am sure that u are glad to see this. But a feeding frenzy of extra gossip is inappropriate.
It sure does. Was watching escaping polygamy the other day. Even when escaping the one took her picture of Warren with her. They are brain washed too. They call him the father. Just creepy.
JB probably does think he was the Cult God in another life and Shellie was apparently the only one who wanted anything to do with him, so, he probably since, he couldn’t get too many wives they probably ended up kicking him out of his position. Therefore he probably never made it to the celestial kingdom neither.
@@DANNYTHEFROG123 agree. Makes sense that JB would pay legal fees for Josh for fear that Josh will squeal. I suspect Josh will be convicted and at that point, he will let all the skeletons out.
If only Joshs' sisters would speak up and file charges against him! He's never had a consequence for his actions and until that happens he will continue with his despicable behavior!
ALso, normally girls would have posters of their teen idol or some such on their walls. Having your father's picture is one thing, but as a young man at their age is creepy 2.0. May explain why Josh's actions were allowed to go unpunished. Dad runs the tribe, right?
I’ve always had a photo of my dad as a teen in my house. It hangs on a wall. He gave it to me when I was 16. It’s his official military photo. He was so handsome. I’ve had it 44 years now.
OMG sooooo creepy! I can't seem to put my finger on what, exactly, is wrong with this daughter-dad dynamic, but it really bugs me. Somethin' ain't right.
I’m sure there are caring dads that express an opinion on clothes. They’re men after all. Perhaps they want boyfriends to be attracted to their hearts first The hair? I do not think my dad cared.
P.S. The Duggars aren’t doing their sons any favors, either. What is one of them marries, has some kids, and his wife dies? He’s never been taught how to care for children or a house. It’s ridiculous.
Jim Bob seems to be a narcissist, which has been discussed here on your channel Katie. This man has no right to have TOTAL control over his kids, especially the adults. The girls seem to be targeted by him constantly. I feel most sad for Jana, we know what she’s about and God I hope they let her out is her invisible prison soon… she seems to have no life with JIMBO constantly checking in on her… GET A LIFE OF YOUR OWN JIMBO!!!
JB has hit the next level of creepy on this one. I wouldn't have a photo of my younger Dad in my bedroom as a teen. That was just not cool when I was that age. Bobby Sherman or David Cassidy was the ticket back then. Yes, I am old.
I remember during Joy's engagement 💍 someone asked her about her clothing and she said, "I like to wear what Austin likes me to wear." At her wedding, Joy and Austin saw each other prior to their vows. Regarding her veil, Joy asked "Do you like it or no?" He gives kinda of an idk, and Joy's like "No. Whatever YOU want" (All this is said with a goofy stars in the eyes type of grin. I know this isn't exactly scandalous info, but it strongly supports the idea that women in this cult defer to men (dads, brothers, husbands...) in almost every instance. It makes me sad that Joy would never think to just wear what she liked, to trust herself, to express her own personality, her own preferences.
I remember that! Made me so sad! Like she was just beginning her life as someone else’s wife, no personal identity, didn’t know who she was and only saw herself as an attachment or belonging to someone else
@Defenestrate where there is a will there is a way. She could start in community college and take remedial courses to catch up. If I were Jill I would let her live with me and go to school. Sadly, the girls don’t have as much freedom as the boys when they get to the age that this is possible, so probably not likely to happen unless that girl has a true rebel spirit or some influence from Jill....most like the reason she is not allowed around unless Jim is there...sad!
WHERE do these IBPL people get their definitions?? Help meet (êzer in Hebrew) means to bring aid or be a helper and in NO WAY implies servitude! Not to mention, submission literally means to support the mission of and also DOES NOT imply servitude! Everyone is equal in God's eyes with differing gifts and roles. To suggest men are more important or more valuable is heresy!
Sadly it seems like none of the girls are interested in college or having careers. I hope Johanna will stay focused on wanting to be a doctor and be able to achieve it.
She can't become a medical doctor with a GED. She wouldn't get accepted into Med school. She would need to at least attend a very good university for her undergrad, and they would never let her. She has gaps in her education, especially in science, so she would probably struggle in any secular academic setting. Jill still believes the earth is 6000 years old. It's just very sad.
I found deeply disturbing that Jessa, Jinjer and Kendra seem to care deeply for their baby girls to be precocious in their early milestones. Their only chance to be considered smart, as girls, is to be an early talker. After that, it's only chores and abnegation and thinking about a housewife life
They weren't. They've said so, and that makes it all so much worse. Maybe if they had been raised that way they would have realized how awful it is. They didn't have to live this crazy weird life. They were normal teenagers.
@@mygirldarby Michelle was a cheerleader and wore bikinis; something tells me that JB brainwashed her. Her situation reminds me of my mother. She was outgoing and was "normal", until she got with my father, then she became very submissive and followed everything the church told her
That first clip Michelle acts like she has NO IDEA how to control her own kids. You can tell she’s not used to dealing with her own kids. Hahaha. What a flake.
@@nuggetsofchiken They loomed around after the 1st scandal yet they became foster parents?? The courts also approved it. I’m shaking my head PROTECT THE KIDS
I wonder what the bedrooms look like now that so many of the Duggar kids have become married. It makes me really wonder (totally crazy and off the wall) that maybe Janna has stayed around because of Josh and Anna moving onto the property after the skeletons came out if the closet. To not only protect her baby sisters but her nieces as well. That perhaps the younger girls took over their aunts/big sisters room. I mean I can’t see all of those kids living in the guest house.
She is 15 years old! CPS should be watching this family before underage force marriage happens, aka look at what the parents did to josh duggar! These kids need to be adults and go to college and have a career before they get married
Btw thank you for the content. Me and my family has been going through alot and this channel has provided a great distraction and your are bringing awareness to important issues
i always think my opinion and perception of this family can’t ever get worse, but then there’s this 😐 it’s insane that jim bob (and people close to the family) considers himself “protective” of his daughters....... UNTIL it comes to protecting them against josh’s perversions. simply refusing to orchestrate the marriage of his minor child isn’t praiseworthy at all
I agree. My grandma always said, "You don't get rewarded for doing what you're supposed to do." Like people who say, "I take care of my kids!" You're supposed to! You want a medal 🏅 for being a decent human being? Praise? Sorry, no.
Here's what people can't comprehend, which is why you will find yourself hitting a wall with people in regards to Anna and Josh: Anna doesn't WANT to leave Josh. So it's irrelevant if she can or not. She won't. You could offer her all the means to get out of there but she won't take it. And people attacking her for not doing so or pressuring her is reinforcing to her why everyone else's opinion has no basis for truth in her reality.
Exactly! Thank you for this comment. It drives me nuts to hear people constantly say “she can’t leave”. Yes she can! While I won’t comment much I don’t believe she’s in physical danger from Josh so... she absolutely can and most likely will stay with him.
@@angelacardova1911 Well, I agree mostly with that, but I don't think that she's been in an environment that even harvests the idea of divorce or leaving your husband. The idea only ever presents itself to her when she's being pressured or attacked. So if that's the only way it comes up, it seems ridiculous and will automatically be dismissed. She will only leave her husband in an immediate life or death situation and that has not presented itself.
@@sleepycalico His pose as a young man is Masonic. It is very interesting that this photo would be placed for all the world to see --for a moment. Most people don't pay attention to Masonic poses, handshakes, etc. I do.
Why must the parent make decisions for their child? Isn’t it our responsibility to raise up our children and teach them that we support their decision?
I remember watching that video when it was first released to the public..I was thinking that there is no bonding and that Michelle was counting down the minutes to dump the little ones on their older sisters..
The Duggar’s had all those kids so they could get a tv show, then the older kids can “babysit “ the younger kids. Oh and yes, they worked really hard to marry off their daughters. The younger the better. If they marry off a 15/16 year old daughter, then that is just sick. But no surprising with this dysfunctional family.
During those interviews, she tries to keep her cool, but my gosh....toddlers are freaking exhausting, especially when you have more than one (or five).
Michelle is acting in that scene. Michelle didn't do the mothering in that family. That is why Johanna is putting up such a fuss. She is uncomfortable with that woman who's holding her! I believe Johanna's sister-mom was Jessa.
You've done amazing work on this reporting, Katie. I see the jealous, content-less haters re-emerging from the wood-work in an attempt to lazily gain subs from your name. Please do not let them affect you or the work you are doing. Their motives are so transparent... and it sadly seems to have become almost a coming of passage to success on this platform... so if I were you, I'd choose to celebrate it!😉❤🙏
Michelle was probably forced to have kids by JB. I know a lady who’s husband literally thinks the only purpose of women is to have kids and he continually forced his wife to have kids (I think 10 or 12 can’t remember) but she now has grandkids and is traumatized and doesn’t even want to hold them. She never wanted more than like 1-2 kids.
@@sweetbeep I’m actually friends with her daughter and they turned out pretty well (at least some of them) my mom has 10 of us but she actually wanted us all. And she is the happiest person people know. We’re all best friends and I love having all my siblings but not every women is cut out for that. I’m pregnant with my second and we’re thinking we might be done after this one
I see this and I watch the Handmaid's tale and they wonder if it can happen and everything in the Handmaid's tale has already happened and is happening. This just proves that one more time.
Off subject, but your dog just kills me! He’s (She) is always laying behind you on the couch, and one day he stood there with ONE of his hind legs up on couch, as if he were stretching. Cool dude.
When I was growing up, I had a photo of my mom as a teenager on my wall - but that was because she had died when I was a young child. It definitely would have been weird if I'd had a photo of my dad as a teen on display in my room!
@@TheSnyderWeb I’m not trying to funny…but you said on your dresser….not on your vanity where you wash your face and do your makeup two different places to place a picture🤔 I had pictures of family members on my dresser too not my sink or vanity or bathroom even. That’s the weird part.
Framed pic of your parents... together... mom AND dad. Nothing creepy about that.... a single picture of just your dad as a youngin. Mehh, with everything else about this family. Definitely creepy It's probably one of those things that they have to look at as they get ready to remind them what's okay and what's not. Lol
@@TheSnyderWeb ok, so my comment doesn’t apply to you. A dresser and sink is two different objects and place so I don’t feel you are weird if that’s your concern but for the whole on the bathroom sink yes weird.
@@suzh7301 You're right. Jimmy's not going to do anything that could invite criticism. He knows we've figured him out, and if he takes one misstep people will be all over it.
She’s really just trapped. If she does leave Josh, she’ll likely spend the rest of her life alone. I mean, what man is going to raise another man’s 7 kids. If she had left him about 4 kids ago she may have had a chance at a decent life. But she’s trapped herself in now and really has no other option than Josh. Sad.
I'm sure there's some man out there who doesn't mind her having seven kids. Maybe a man with seven kids himself. Have you ever seen the movie Yours Mine and Ours?
Amen to that I have been slammed on other creators Pages because they have such 8. But I see that they just get surface information and something they see on RUclips and that's is how they get their content. Katie Joy has gone above and beyond and I think she is rocking this
I noticed that the girl's channels started posting again. No comment on josh in the comment section. Some desperate deleting going on...I dont blame them though, who would want all those comments?
No wonder Josh did what he did just look at his father not a very good role model they need to stay out of their childrens adult lives maybe Josh and Jim bob should share a jail cell together
I just found your channel two days ago and binged. This is a RABBIT hole. I realized my cousin is in something similar. My aunt and uncle raised their children in a similar way (without the dress code stuff and they were educated). My aunt and uncle left when their middle child got pregnant and hid it for four months. (Pregnancy loss warning below⚠️vvv) She was hiding her pregnancy and my aunt was still giving her anxiety medication. She ended up having extreme abnormalities and had to carry until 8 months. They had to vacuum the baby out. Her sister around the same time married a guy who was even more extreme. She has never seen the world outside of her honeymoon trip or hiking locally with my uncle. My cousins were shamed for my cousins pregnancy and ended up leaving. The cousin who married into it became even more extreme and does not speak unless spoken to. Her husband speaks for her at holidays. My aunt called it a cult yesterday when I saw her and is afraid of how extreme her daughter became. She has even shunned her sister who was a teen mom and miscarried (she has had another baby since then 😊)
This everyday speculation is getting old. I'm not a Duggar fan by any means but daily speculation on the kids as a clickbait scheme to watch your videos is getting old. The never-ending speculation on Anna leaving is getting old. The lawyers would have told her not to do anything before the trial to put on a united front. The story of the boy and the wolf fits here, the more you cry scandal, scandal and it turns out to be nothing the less likely people will watch.
Hi Katy..I just discovered your channel....andI love it, especially the videos about the Duggars. I’ve watched them since their first few videos. I appreciate all of the work you do behind the scenes to prepare for each of your videos. Non Duggar related question...what color is the neat couch behind you? dark blue or purple?
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
If only Jim Bob would protect his daughters from their brother!
Jb is a monster like his son the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree
I totally agree.
Kkkkk
I thought the same thing
Who thinks Josh knows something about JB that he doesn't want revealed?? That's maybe why JB is protecting him.
JB protective of his daughters??? Where was that protectiveness when his daughters were sa by Josh?
JB is just plain sick, PERIOD! I wouldn't be at all surprised if he has dark secrets like Josh!
E.X.A.C.T.L.Y
@@sarahc3295 It's always suspicious when someone tries SO HARD to come off squeaky clean and perfect. Like dude, why? What are you so afraid will come out?
I think if he could marry this girl off he would if there is money Involved . He is a idiot
Yeah, that's not the definition of the word I'm familiar with.
If Jimmy Bob is so protective of his girls then why DIDN'T he protect his girls from Josh...why has JB protected and covered up for Josh??? I can't wrap my brain around any of this...it's a very SICK AND TWISTED family dynamic.
What is the hurry marring your kids off so young. Let them grow up to be an adult first!!!!
This family is messed up.
Mrs. Golden I completely agree with you.
@@kristywebb3471 - thank you 😉. Let kids be kids. I have 2 boys who are 18 & 21. My 21yr is a fireman & paramedic and the other is doing the same thing but In the Army. I can’t imagine if they told me they were getting married. 🤨 to their girlfriends now 🤦🏼♀️
Their father & I married at 27 but started dating our sophomore year of college.
They want them brainwashed and young. So they can get as many babies out of her as possible.
the sooner they're married, the more kids they can have.
get married before they get ruined in their opinion
If Jim Bob was protective over his daughters he wouldn't allow Josh around them
The thought of “ North Korea “ leaders came to my mind !?!? The people there have pictures of their “leader” in their homes. A picture of your dad doesn’t normally belong in your bedroom !
You're right! I hadn't made that connection. Geez, this gets worse and worse...
Same as the people in that cult of Jeff Warren. They are all some very sick people.
@@MeganVictoriaKearns North Koreans fear their Dear Leader, Kim Jung Un. They have his photograph in every room because they fear being reported for lack of admiration.
Or the FLDS 🤮
Yeah, I’d never keep a pic of my parents in my bedroom! I love them dearly, don’t get me wrong, but I can’t look at my parents while being intimate withy husband, lol.
I kinda feel bad for these kids having rumors swirl. I went to a private IFB college (being a 28 year old freshman after leaving the Army) and you couldn't as much as sit on the same bench or couch in the common areas with someone of the opposite sex without people asking if there's something there. It was really annoying.
I feel bad for Jinger as far as rumors go. Imagine how Jinger felt having a whole website named after her, hoping she would rebel. It must have put her in a very horrible position with her parents.
I'm sure most of the gossip about the Duggars is untrue. Even if some is true. Thier no different than any other family. Everyone has secrets.
@@jessestewart169 n not every family has infant s a. If they do I am sure that u are glad to see this. But a feeding frenzy of extra gossip is inappropriate.
That picture reminds me of the FLDS and the
Picture of Warren Jeffs each family has on their walls.
Yes Jimbob profit of the fundys
It sure does. Was watching escaping polygamy the other day. Even when escaping the one took her picture of Warren with her. They are brain washed too. They call him the father. Just creepy.
JB probably does think he was the Cult God in another life and Shellie was apparently the only one who wanted anything to do with him, so, he probably since, he couldn’t get too many wives they probably ended up kicking him out of his position. Therefore he probably never made it to the celestial kingdom neither.
If that is true, JB is sick! I cannot help but wonder if JB has dark secrets like Josh?
Just wait. The other shoe has yet to drop. Them girls are trained to be slaves to there master or aka handler.
I think he was involved somehow. That is the only reason he is helping Josh so his dirt dont come out.
Probably
Like father like son wouldn’t surprise me what so ever
@@DANNYTHEFROG123 agree. Makes sense that JB would pay legal fees for Josh for fear that Josh will squeal. I suspect Josh will be convicted and at that point, he will let all the skeletons out.
Can we appreciate the dog in the background running in his sleep?
Get that squirrel, Buddy! Get him!
That dog is cute.
If only Joshs' sisters would speak up and file charges against him! He's never had a consequence for his actions and until that happens he will continue with his despicable behavior!
Unfortunately the statue of limitations has expired.
It's too late now. Josh is in jail now tho. So at least that's good.
Jm Bob has always given me a creepy vibe.
he gave me a socially awkward vibe, and he says inappropriate things sometimes
ALso, normally girls would have posters of their teen idol or some such on their walls. Having your father's picture is one thing, but as a young man at their age is creepy 2.0. May explain why Josh's actions were allowed to go unpunished. Dad runs the tribe, right?
They can't listen to just any radio stations or hardly ever watch TV, so they wouldn't know 🤷 about having an idol and posters on the wall...so sad.
I’ve always had a photo of my dad as a teen in my house. It hangs on a wall. He gave it to me when I was 16. It’s his official military photo. He was so handsome. I’ve had it 44 years now.
How creepy is it that the fathers decide on the hair and clothes 😱😱
OMG sooooo creepy! I can't seem to put my finger on what, exactly, is wrong with this daughter-dad dynamic, but it really bugs me. Somethin' ain't right.
I know the IBLP are not polygamists but they sure have similarities to Warren Jeffs. It makes me shudder.
I’m sure there are caring dads that express an opinion on clothes. They’re men after all. Perhaps they want boyfriends to be attracted to their hearts first The hair? I do not think my dad cared.
P.S. The Duggars aren’t doing their sons any favors, either. What is one of them marries, has some kids, and his wife dies? He’s never been taught how to care for children or a house. It’s ridiculous.
Jim Bob seems to be a narcissist, which has been discussed here on your channel Katie. This man has no right to have TOTAL control over his kids, especially the adults. The girls seem to be targeted by him constantly. I feel most sad for Jana, we know what she’s about and God I hope they let her out is her invisible prison soon… she seems to have no life with JIMBO constantly checking in on her… GET A LIFE OF YOUR OWN JIMBO!!!
Excellent point!
They'd find some spinster shlub within the community to become a nanny/maid while the husband has his concubines.
they also all work for their dad, so they have zero freedom
They'll find him a new wife or baby sitter.
JB has hit the next level of creepy on this one. I wouldn't have a photo of my younger Dad in my bedroom as a teen. That was just not cool when I was that age. Bobby Sherman or David Cassidy was the ticket back then. Yes, I am old.
I’m old too! Big David Cassidy fan!
Don’t forget Donny Osmond!
Thumbs up for being old!
David Cassidy....lol. I had one too!
Don’t forget Donnie Osmand!!!😍😍
Jim Bob has always creeped me out. His relationship with his daughters seems off. I just haven't been able to figure out specifically what it is.
I remember during Joy's engagement 💍 someone asked her about her clothing and she said, "I like to wear what Austin likes me to wear."
At her wedding, Joy and Austin saw each other prior to their vows. Regarding her veil, Joy asked "Do you like it or no?" He gives kinda of an idk, and Joy's like "No. Whatever YOU want" (All this is said with a goofy stars in the eyes type of grin.
I know this isn't exactly scandalous info, but it strongly supports the idea that women in this cult defer to men (dads, brothers, husbands...) in almost every instance. It makes me sad that Joy would never think to just wear what she liked, to trust herself, to express her own personality, her own preferences.
All those little things start to add up.
I remember that! Made me so sad! Like she was just beginning her life as someone else’s wife, no personal identity, didn’t know who she was and only saw herself as an attachment or belonging to someone else
I think I read that Johanna wanted to be a doctor. If only that were possible...
It is possible, but that's up to her. People leave cults everyday.
It is if she leaves. I'm sure Jill would help her.
She's probably have to do some catch up education first. Duggar home school doesn't measure up.
@@twwdc True They get a Dugger Academy Diploma .The would have to take the state exam for their GED
@Defenestrate where there is a will there is a way. She could start in community college and take remedial courses to catch up. If I were Jill I would let her live with me and go to school. Sadly, the girls don’t have as much freedom as the boys when they get to the age that this is possible, so probably not likely to happen unless that girl has a true rebel spirit or some influence from Jill....most like the reason she is not allowed around unless Jim is there...sad!
WHERE do these IBPL people get their definitions?? Help meet (êzer in Hebrew) means to bring aid or be a helper and in NO WAY implies servitude! Not to mention, submission literally means to support the mission of and also DOES NOT imply servitude! Everyone is equal in God's eyes with differing gifts and roles. To suggest men are more important or more valuable is heresy!
Amen!!!
Yes!
JB looks more suspicious himself, the more he covers for others who are dangers to children.
If they think they are living right, then why hide everything. Smh
She is to young to get married,, let her be teenager
Are these conferences designed for them to mate their kids? I’ve noticed that all the couples mention they met at some conference.
Yes! My family is involved in a similar cult in OK and they are constantly getting big teen groups together. It's very weird.
Sadly it seems like none of the girls are interested in college or having careers. I hope Johanna will stay focused on wanting to be a doctor and be able to achieve it.
She can't become a medical doctor with a GED. She wouldn't get accepted into Med school. She would need to at least attend a very good university for her undergrad, and they would never let her. She has gaps in her education, especially in science, so she would probably struggle in any secular academic setting. Jill still believes the earth is 6000 years old. It's just very sad.
@@mygirldarby she can be a dr. With a ged, she’s just had to work harder
Nothing wrong with wanting to be a mom. Most young girls dream of becoming a mother.
@@mygirldarby You can get into college with a GED. I sure hope she does, she has a lot to learn!
@@mygirldarby she’d have to spend a lot of time in community college and taking make up courses
I found deeply disturbing that Jessa, Jinjer and Kendra seem to care deeply for their baby girls to be precocious in their early milestones. Their only chance to be considered smart, as girls, is to be an early talker. After that, it's only chores and abnegation and thinking about a housewife life
Ugh that Carver kid sounds like a real winner. 🙄
Sounds like he needs to be arrested
Bet Jim Bob and Michelle were not living under those rules when they were dating.
They weren't. They've said so, and that makes it all so much worse. Maybe if they had been raised that way they would have realized how awful it is. They didn't have to live this crazy weird life. They were normal teenagers.
@@mygirldarby Michelle was a cheerleader and wore bikinis; something tells me that JB brainwashed her. Her situation reminds me of my mother. She was outgoing and was "normal", until she got with my father, then she became very submissive and followed everything the church told her
That first clip Michelle acts like she has NO IDEA how to control her own kids. You can tell she’s not used to dealing with her own kids. Hahaha. What a flake.
I thought the same thing! Clearly she wasn’t lying when she said once the baby is weaned off the teet she goes to her big sister buddy. So ridiculous.
That was my thought too. It’s like asking a jr high girl with no siblings to babysit.
Actually no. She's not giving her unruly child the attention she craves. Spot on parenting.
@@saraschneider6781 unruly? She was just being a silly baby.
So...u don’t have kids?! lol
In 2 years they will be courting, with someone who she has knows all her life and have been friends for a long time, Just like Joy and Austin
Which is the way it should be.
@@saraschneider6781 why?
@@SaraHinata why what?
@@saraschneider6781 why is that the way it should be???
@@saraschneider6781 Yeah! What do you mean by that?
Jim Bob also doesn’t want to attract CPS
It's too late for that.
@@nuggetsofchiken They loomed around after the 1st scandal yet they became foster parents?? The courts also approved it. I’m shaking my head PROTECT THE KIDS
I want the younger kids to be remove from Jim Bob & Michelle’s custody. The icing on the cake would be if he’s forced to pay child support for them!!
I wonder what the bedrooms look like now that so many of the Duggar kids have become married. It makes me really wonder (totally crazy and off the wall) that maybe Janna has stayed around because of Josh and Anna moving onto the property after the skeletons came out if the closet. To not only protect her baby sisters but her nieces as well. That perhaps the younger girls took over their aunts/big sisters room. I mean I can’t see all of those kids living in the guest house.
I’m fairly sure that the images of children Josh downloaded were not just of girls. I’m concerned for any child Josh is in contact with!!
Yes very happy to hear Johanna is not courting.
I can't help but wonder if Jimbob has those hidden nanny cams to keep watch over them.
Ewwwwwwwwww.
Josh installed their security system so....
"He teaches people how to be men.." lol. Love it!!!
Teaches boys how to be a "manly" men? God I hope that's not just a euphemism for a "pray the gay away" type of camp / retreat.
I love everything you cover, but I have to say I was LOVING the pup sleeping on the couch behind you, lol!
165K(and counting). Yay, Katie. Keep it up!!!!
that's just sick. most fifteen year old girls are just dating but not serious until they are older 16 or 17.
She is 15 years old! CPS should be watching this family before underage force marriage happens, aka look at what the parents did to josh duggar! These kids need to be adults and go to college and have a career before they get married
Jim Dugger and is so creepy, I’ve always thought so.
He's so fake on camera.
Hello Lois :)
How are you doing?
Btw thank you for the content. Me and my family has been going through alot and this channel has provided a great distraction and your are bringing awareness to important issues
i always think my opinion and perception of this family can’t ever get worse, but then there’s this 😐 it’s insane that jim bob (and people close to the family) considers himself “protective” of his daughters....... UNTIL it comes to protecting them against josh’s perversions. simply refusing to orchestrate the marriage of his minor child isn’t praiseworthy at all
I agree. My grandma always said, "You don't get rewarded for doing what you're supposed to do."
Like people who say, "I take care of my kids!" You're supposed to! You want a medal 🏅 for being a decent human being? Praise? Sorry, no.
I wish Johanna was sneaking around seeing someone without JimBob’s permission or knowledge...I’m bad.
I wouldnt blame her one bit if she did
she is too young.
Hummmmm Josh might not be the only weird one in the Dugger family something not right with Dad
Here's what people can't comprehend, which is why you will find yourself hitting a wall with people in regards to Anna and Josh: Anna doesn't WANT to leave Josh. So it's irrelevant if she can or not. She won't. You could offer her all the means to get out of there but she won't take it. And people attacking her for not doing so or pressuring her is reinforcing to her why everyone else's opinion has no basis for truth in her reality.
Exactly! Thank you for this comment. It drives me nuts to hear people constantly say “she can’t leave”. Yes she can! While I won’t comment much I don’t believe she’s in physical danger from Josh so... she absolutely can and most likely will stay with him.
@@angelacardova1911 Well, I agree mostly with that, but I don't think that she's been in an environment that even harvests the idea of divorce or leaving your husband. The idea only ever presents itself to her when she's being pressured or attacked. So if that's the only way it comes up, it seems ridiculous and will automatically be dismissed. She will only leave her husband in an immediate life or death situation and that has not presented itself.
EEK. That picture would be fun in a family grouping on a piano, but it is just creepy in the girls' room.
ikr? 🤮🤮🤮
Not only that, but it is Jim Bob with a Masonic pose in the girls' room.
I don't know anything about Masonics. Is he Masonic?
@@sleepycalico His pose as a young man is Masonic. It is very interesting that this photo would be placed for all the world to see --for a moment. Most people don't pay attention to Masonic poses, handshakes, etc. I do.
Notice there is a framed picture, facing the opposite direction, of Michelle beside the one of their dad.
I think the photo is so that psychologically they start looking for men that resemble their father
So creepy.
EWWWW! but you may be right. So sad!
I can't even anymore...Disgusted & angry. TLC is just as disgusting. Any sponsors drop them yet?
This family is sick I want to report this because if this happens to this child they need to be arrested
People that don’t think the state of Arkansas already is fully aware of this family are crazy.
No need to call CPS.
So why isn't Carter sitting in jail if he was at the capitol in jan 6th and everyone knows?
That’s a crime?
Why must the parent make decisions for their child? Isn’t it our responsibility to raise up our children and teach them that we support their decision?
I remember watching that video when it was first released to the public..I was thinking that there is no bonding and that Michelle was counting down the minutes to dump the little ones on their older sisters..
I’m new to the channel, so I have been binging on the videos. My sister and I always thought that Jim Bob was Hella creepy dude 😬.
That’s ridiculous, she’s way to young to get married, isn’t she like 15 tops?
The Duggar’s had all those kids so they could get a tv show, then the older kids can “babysit “ the younger kids. Oh and yes, they worked really hard to marry off their daughters. The younger the better. If they marry off a 15/16 year old daughter, then that is just sick. But no surprising with this dysfunctional family.
I remember when Johanna was born! I think she was the 15th baby when the “14 and Pregnant Again” started.
Johanna was baby number 16, Jackson was 15
@@savannahpontious4596 Oh ok. Thanks!
Your dog sure knows how to relax!
You sure have access to a Large Library of Duggar Videos.
During those interviews, she tries to keep her cool, but my gosh....toddlers are freaking exhausting, especially when you have more than one (or five).
At one point Michelle had 7 under 7... I can't imagine
Michelle is acting in that scene. Michelle didn't do the mothering in that family. That is why Johanna is putting up such a fuss. She is uncomfortable with that woman who's holding her! I believe Johanna's sister-mom was Jessa.
@@brewerrkjb Johannah's sister-mom was Jinger, not Jessa.
Did anyone already called CPS?
Will the judge that let Josh go be the same one that hears the trial or the plea bargain?
I hope Josh's girls find someone nothing like him.
Some people are so heavenly bound they are no earthly good.
You've done amazing work on this reporting, Katie. I see the jealous, content-less haters re-emerging from the wood-work in an attempt to lazily gain subs from your name. Please do not let them affect you or the work you are doing. Their motives are so transparent... and it sadly seems to have become almost a coming of passage to success on this platform... so if I were you, I'd choose to celebrate it!😉❤🙏
ABSOLUTELY RIGHT
@@gayeyount7948 🙏❤❤🥂
Hello Hybrid :)
How are you doing?
Surely social services ( child protection) should intervene ??????
Michelle was probably forced to have kids by JB. I know a lady who’s husband literally thinks the only purpose of women is to have kids and he continually forced his wife to have kids (I think 10 or 12 can’t remember) but she now has grandkids and is traumatized and doesn’t even want to hold them. She never wanted more than like 1-2 kids.
Wow.... Those poor kid she had
@@sweetbeep I’m actually friends with her daughter and they turned out pretty well (at least some of them) my mom has 10 of us but she actually wanted us all. And she is the happiest person people know. We’re all best friends and I love having all my siblings but not every women is cut out for that. I’m pregnant with my second and we’re thinking we might be done after this one
@@Sarahssafespace ..aw that's great. Yah I was just thinking that those kids had a mom that didn't really love to have so many.
15?! That's just demented I can't even...
🤣🤣🤣 I'm too busy looking at the dog...too cute...I literally had to watch the video again.
No way. Who will raise Jackson through Josie?
I thinkJim-Bob is a creep
Small children make lousy props.
I see this and I watch the Handmaid's tale and they wonder if it can happen and everything in the Handmaid's tale has already happened and is happening. This just proves that one more time.
OfJimBob would be so proud of herself
Off subject, but your dog just kills me! He’s (She) is always laying behind you on the couch, and one day he stood there with ONE of his hind legs up on couch, as if he were stretching. Cool dude.
His boys are getting married super young too. They’re like 18, 19 years old. It’s crazy. He’s pushing them all out the door.
When I was growing up, I had a photo of my mom as a teenager on my wall - but that was because she had died when I was a young child. It definitely would have been weird if I'd had a photo of my dad as a teen on display in my room!
Jimbob is a sickass!!! this is why I'm so proud of Jill
Oh Lord! I would love to wake up to my dad’s photo of him when he was young on my vanity 🤦🏽♀️ weird!!!
I had a framed pic of my parents on my dresser as a teen 🤷♀️ I don’t think it’s weird. I also had framed pics there of friends, my grandparents, etc
@@TheSnyderWeb I’m not trying to funny…but you said on your dresser….not on your vanity where you wash your face and do your makeup two different places to place a picture🤔 I had pictures of family members on my dresser too not my sink or vanity or bathroom even. That’s the weird part.
Tamara’s Bargains yeah but I didn’t really have a vanity sink for makeup I just did my makeup at my dresser because it had a mirror on top
Framed pic of your parents... together... mom AND dad. Nothing creepy about that.... a single picture of just your dad as a youngin. Mehh, with everything else about this family. Definitely creepy
It's probably one of those things that they have to look at as they get ready to remind them what's okay and what's not. Lol
@@TheSnyderWeb ok, so my comment doesn’t apply to you. A dresser and sink is two different objects and place so I don’t feel you are weird if that’s your concern but for the whole on the bathroom sink yes weird.
This family gets creepier every day. I’m still waiting for a story about why kailyn is lying about baby daddy #4.....🤨🧐🤔🤔🤥🤥
Where did she read that from?
Thank you for clearing that up.
I just don’t see it joy has been the youngest girl to leave at 19
I agree. Nothing will happen until she’s at least 18. Jim bob wouldn't want even more heat on him.
@@suzh7301 You're right. Jimmy's not going to do anything that could invite criticism. He knows we've figured him out, and if he takes one misstep people will be all over it.
But joy said she had feelings for her now husbend win She was about 13 so anything is a possibility of eyeing another person at 15 lol
Considering Josh was betrothed to someone (not Anna) when he was around that age it wouldn't surprise me.
For Johanna's sake I hope it isn't true.
She’s really just trapped. If she does leave Josh, she’ll likely spend the rest of her life alone. I mean, what man is going to raise another man’s 7 kids. If she had left him about 4 kids ago she may have had a chance at a decent life. But she’s trapped herself in now and really has no other option than Josh. Sad.
I'm sure there's some man out there who doesn't mind her having seven kids. Maybe a man with seven kids himself. Have you ever seen the movie Yours Mine and Ours?
It does seem like there is a bit of a 'fire sale' going on as regards getting the children paired off and married before their big brother's trial.
New to your channel, just wondering where you get all this information from and how accurate it is?
Disgusting duggars selling their 15 year old daughter just sickening
This is highly disturbing. True or not. Worst family ever
I discovered your channel a couple weeks ago and I gotta say I love your content
Amen to that I have been slammed on other creators Pages because they have such 8. But I see that they just get surface information and something they see on RUclips and that's is how they get their content. Katie Joy has gone above and beyond and I think she is rocking this
I noticed that the girl's channels started posting again. No comment on josh in the comment section. Some desperate deleting going on...I dont blame them though, who would want all those comments?
I noticed that too. I'm glad Jessa has her channel back on. She does have the cutest kids.
No wonder Josh did what he did just look at his father not a very good role model they need to stay out of their childrens adult lives maybe Josh and Jim bob should share a jail cell together
I just found your channel two days ago and binged. This is a RABBIT hole. I realized my cousin is in something similar. My aunt and uncle raised their children in a similar way (without the dress code stuff and they were educated). My aunt and uncle left when their middle child got pregnant and hid it for four months. (Pregnancy loss warning below⚠️vvv)
She was hiding her pregnancy and my aunt was still giving her anxiety medication. She ended up having extreme abnormalities and had to carry until 8 months. They had to vacuum the baby out. Her sister around the same time married a guy who was even more extreme. She has never seen the world outside of her honeymoon trip or hiking locally with my uncle. My cousins were shamed for my cousins pregnancy and ended up leaving. The cousin who married into it became even more extreme and does not speak unless spoken to. Her husband speaks for her at holidays. My aunt called it a cult yesterday when I saw her and is afraid of how extreme her daughter became. She has even shunned her sister who was a teen mom and miscarried (she has had another baby since then 😊)
Send the police in!
What the heck he is as scewy as his son
I'm just here for Frida....love how she's dreaming away behind you Katie :)
This everyday speculation is getting old. I'm not a Duggar fan by any means but daily speculation on the kids as a clickbait scheme to watch your videos is getting old. The never-ending speculation on Anna leaving is getting old. The lawyers would have told her not to do anything before the trial to put on a united front. The story of the boy and the wolf fits here, the more you cry scandal, scandal and it turns out to be nothing the less likely people will watch.
I never realized how much bass was included in your intro song until I listen to this in the car. I love it
What is the podcast she was speaking about ? Thanks!
Hi Katy..I just discovered your channel....andI love it, especially the videos about the Duggars. I’ve watched them since their first few videos. I appreciate all of the work you do behind the scenes to prepare for each of your videos.
Non Duggar related question...what color is the neat couch behind you? dark blue or purple?
I think if anything. Carver & Hannah were maybe singing a song in a wedding and that could be why they were spending time together.
It took me about 3 installments to watch your interview with Kit but it was worth it! Very eye-opening!