Why Didn’t Palpatine Sense Darth Maul Survived After The Phantom Menace? (Legends)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 янв 2020
- Star Wars Gaming Channel: / @starwarsgamingclub2526
Twitch: / swrcgaming
Twitter: @SWReadingClub
Looking for Star Wars books? Check out our Amazon Influencers page and help support SWRC: www.amazon.com/shop/influence...
Thank you very much to our amazing Patrons for their support of the channel, including our Darth Bane and Grand Admiral Thrawn Tier level Patrons:
Ben Lewitt
Daniel Kim
Rvmuller
Jasmine (Thatzer)
Andrew Seiner
The Non-Canon Expert looks at why the Dark Lord of the Sith Darth Sidious didn't sense that his apprentice Darth Maul survived his defeat to Jedi Padawan Obi-Wan Kenobi on Naboo, having no understanding of Darth Maul's survival until over a decade later during the Clone Wars, explaining the significant events that occurred at the time of Darth Maul's defeat, and then the important information that is relevant over the next twelve years.
This is a Legends story for Darth Maul and Palpatine with information found in a number of Legends sources, but primarily "Star Wars: Jedi vs. Sith: The Essential Guide to the Force," "Star Wars: Darth Plagueis," "Star Wars: Death Star," "Star Wars: Dark Lord: The Rise of Darth Vader," and "Star Wars: The Wrath of Darth Maul." The brief elements described from Canon are found within the Canon novel "Star Wars: Ahsoka." I hope that you enjoy it!
Decisions by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...)
Source: incompetech.com/music/royalty-...
Artist: incompetech.com/
A Dream Within a Dream by Twin Musicom is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...)
Source: www.twinmusicom.org/song/301/a...
Artist: www.twinmusicom.org 
Развлечения
![Remble - Colors (ft. Mozzy & Stoneda5th) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KF-3AU9g9xg/mqdefault.jpg)
Maul, reaching out with the force: “Master, I’m still alive. Come save me.”
Palpatine: “Gosh that slave kid from Tattooine sure is interesting.”
Master Haansen: "Take a seat."
Maul: Master, save me. I did as you taught me, i kept myself alive with my hatred.
Palpatine: Damn that's some strong space wind.
I saw you in other video
Elyseon HA
@@Elyseon god that is so fucking funny, where is the tcap community when you need them
He could hide himself from the Jedi, but couldn't sense Darth Maul.
Ironic.
@Legendary Vocalists new Dinsey canon. In Eu there was no such temple basement. All skill zero cheap exploits from Sidious.
A lesson well learnt 😂😂..if only i could do that in school
@Legendary Vocalists I don't like that lame explanation, it was Sidious that was clouding the minds the Jedi not some dumb Sith Temple
Well not necessarily. If you are hiding yourself from the Jedi meaning that you are cutting yourself off for my part of the force then that must go both ways then
In the old Plagus books Plagus had a hard time detecting him
Imagine being one of the most powerful people of your time only to get killed in your sleep by a guy named sheev
Well if his name had been Shiv or Shank it would have been too obvious.
@@jlokison BRUH LOL
Like a dyslexic part of a shirt, long Sheev or short Sheev?
Sean Wadey 😂
Makes sense, the name sounds like shiv. In other words, an improvised knife, perfect for a surprise attack.
Because no Sith Lord could ever sense a retcon :D
LMAO 😂😂😂
The real answer
No one can sense when uncle palp came back
"Ha! That was so...funny........"☺
I just assumed Palpatine didnt care
Didn't care. The boner for Anakin's medaclorian count was too strong to continue to dwell on fallen apprentices.
😳😳😳
Goddamnit whyd you have to word it like that?!
@@Fit_soldier did you come back to get electricuted a second time
@@Fit_soldier You are to Star Wars what Kenny is to South Park. The fact that you didn't die again just by getting out of bed astounds me.
@@Fit_soldier space lesbians...?
Maul: Master Im still alive..
Palpatine: I don’t know this person..
Maul: oh cmon man!
Obi wan: how are you still alive!?
Maul: I was saved by a bunch of fans!?
Yoda: hmm convenient that is.
Qui gon: you guys are totally ruining my funeral!
Ha I get it
lol hishe
Russel yeah this copied how it should have ended (hishe) I saw this 2years ago
.....no
The flip flop Gang Noo really. Ya wouldn’t say...🙄
Well his mind was full, he had become chancellor of the republic, he had murdered darth Plagueis and he still had Anakin Skywalker in mind, besides that he had Dooku who had left the Jedi order. His mind was clouded with these events.
vitor kennedy no.
Lol what
It is funny because if a plot point like this was established in the Sequels, everybody would rip them apart in countless video essays saying how it is nonsensical and incoherent writing. But with the Old Star Wars, excuses like these make perfect sense. "He was busy."
@@kungolaf4499 Too busy to Maul.
@@vitorkennedy1862 Well I guess it makes sense since he is the galactic chancellor, but at hindsight, it is a clear late add-on to the movies.
In a way the Jedi believing that 1 of their own had killed the 1st Sith to surface in a millennia was probably quite helpful to Sidious moving forward, as it further increased the arrogance that blinded them to the Jedi Trap weaving itself around them xx
That's a very good point. Also the sith lord was killed by a padawan
Ali Baghdady but he also killed a jedi master
@@AT-gt8cb True. But I think that the Council could rationalise this by telling themselves that a skilled bounty hunter can also kill a Jedi. Also the Order had seen a lot of Jedi deaths at this particular time, having seen more deaths in the last 12 years than in the previous 50 (according to Chancellor Valorum). So the death of a Sith was the greater focus I imagine xx
@@alibaghdady9710 Thank you 😊 xx
I feel a presence I haven't felt since....
* leaves dramatically, and without explanation *
The fandom: lucus didn't know maul would be so popular or he would've kept him.
Ironic how lucus could give his characters the power of foresight but could not foresee himself .
Lucus?
Lukas
Lucius Malfoy
It was his plan for the sequels to bring maul back as the new sith lord
@@sciencecentral2972 is that legit or a joke?
Me after watching clone wars:
At last maul revealed himself to palpatine, at last he had revenge
And then he got owned...again. Maul is the Krillin of Star Wars. Both are short, bald martial artists who die every time they step out of bed.
@@dixonb.tweenerlegs4225 maul ain't short tho
@@invictus6176 He was one of the shortest people in the prequels, aside from Yoda. Most of the main characters and villains are 6ft or over. Maul was like 5'6.
@Joe Curr well, he killed Obi Wan's lover right in front of him. So there's that
@Joe Curr you need yo rewatch that scene, did you not see the pain in Obi wan's eyes? The way he held her in his arms? They loved each other man. It's a very Sith thing to do to use that against him
Maul:Is he the chosen one?
Obi wan:Yes
Maul:He will avenge us.......
MAIL XDDDDDDDD
@Brendan chelsea um what?
sadly rise of Skywalker shits on this
Mail was my favorite character
Maul: why is my return a surprise? Couldn't you sense or see where I was?
Palpatine: I did not see because I did not wish to see.
Maul: oh, you didn't see because you didn't wish to see. Ah! Well that makes everything fine then, doesn't it?
"And next you're going to say 'Everything has unfolded exactly as I have foreseeen!'"
"Everything has un- Wait, what?"
"And next you're going to say 'And now you shall experience the full power of the dark side!'"
Holy crap, I did not expect a Prince of Egypt reference on a video like THIS, of all places.
Bravo.
@@Elyseon Maulseph Darthstar
“MAN TOO ANGRY TO DIE”
I mean... we can also just figure that Darth Maul isn't completely stupid and knows Palpatine would be as likely to finish the job as to help him in any capacity and, as such, concealed himself. Both from Palpatine and any potential Jedi. Maul is a trained Sith Assassin, Force Concealment should be second nature to him, as a prior video had gone on at length about Palpatine concealing himself from the Jedi as well. I doubt Palpatine would've neglected to teach Maul at least some levels of Force Concealment such as were useful in his capacity as an Assassin.
you know what I don't get is how did Maul know Kenobi's name and how did Obi-wan know Maul's name? Both of them just randomly say the other's name as if it was common knowledge
Good point
Never thought of that . after all they never spoke during the whole duel . the only word spoken was "nooooooooooo" by Kenobi when maul killed Quigon
I cant explain how kenobi knew maul, but its pretty likely that maul knew who he was going to fight before he even landed on the planet, because who just goes in blind and attacks without info, especially a sith
Probably the force, the same way as Maul knew everything of Erza with just look ik the eyes at one of his friend.
Cop out answer is they sensed each others past through the Force.
“Far above, far above, we don’t know where we’ll fall!”
Far above, far above what once was great is rendered small
Isn't this from the darth maul book that takes place right before the events of episode 1 ??
Because he didn’t have a ladder
Last time I was this early Mace windu was still alive
Is master qui gon still with us?
It's treason then...
Last time I was this early I wasn’t cut in two
Last time I was this late The New Galactic Empire was already destroyed by Cade Skywalker
This makes perfect sense. Jedi and Sith can sense familiarities in each other. Confusion in the Force can hide them sometimes. Or if their focus is on something else. Like Palpatine killing Plageous. Obi-Wan remained himself,while Anakin became Vader. Obi-Wan could sense Anakin,while Vader could sense Obi-Wan. Ashoka tried to sense Anakin,but he was gone. She couldnt sense Obi-Wan because of terrible shock and emptiness in the Force. Same for Yoda. Imagine her surprise when she meet Luke :) They didnt know about each other. And like for Morley
So maul went completely under the radar because of very great timing from the dark side
It was the will of the force that kept him hidden from his old master.
In Legends Sidious was disappointed with Mauls defeat alive or dead or undead because he considered to use Maul in a similar way to General Grievous with Dooku as commander but in Canon Sidious was disappointed in Mauls defeat because he saw Maul as a true successor prior to Mauls failure on Naboo
Sidious when Maul loses a fight and gets cut in half: “You fucking DONKEY”
Sidious when anakin loses a fight and gets cut in half: “Oh dear, oh dear, precious”
Difference was when Maul got defeated Sidious already had back up insurance apprentices planned in case Maul became a failure while with Vader only Luke would be able to best him and he tried to pit Vader against people that he thought would execute Vader after Vader got his cybernetics but all except Luke failed to even being close to eliminating him yeah
I always figured that Maul, having been defeated and sliced in two, was no longer of any use to him, and just didn't care anymore. It's not like giving a damn about your own forces is much of a trait the Sith possess
“Surviving only through his rage and force abilities” this sounds familiar
I guess rage and The Force can replace whatever damaged or missing vitals he had after his bisection. Still seems weird.
the sith moto
people have survived getting cut in half IRL, I'm more concerned about how he survived the fall.
... including his pp, @@SoloAxlion?
@@IndianaJoe0321 to answer your question, H.
Just another epic vid mate! Keep up the awesome work u do👍👏👏👏
"The creature who had once been Darth Maul"? Did he have an over-wrought symbol for a name instead of an actual name?
Yayyy. Another Maul video!
👍👍
For Morley!
Well you know.. pure RAGE can do all kinds of things for you!
When it comes to the Sith lords, Maul is the true embodiment of rage and anger.
@@orbyboy123 Bruh, Vader is far more angrier and have far more rage as well then Maul
@@Borr77 Vader had more hate, but i think Maul had more rage. That's just my personal opinion/thoughts on it.
The worst thing about maul being cut in half, is he lost his pp
Love your videos dude!
My guy just needed a lil vacation with out the sand tho
Because until.the clone wars series, george.lucas said he was D-E-A-D. DEAD
Im not really complaining that he lived though.
@360 Overdrive Yeah. Not like bringing dead characters back for fanservice can lead to anything bad. What are they gonna do, bring back Palpatine?
Oh wait
Lucas said the same about Palpatine after the original trilogy... Then Dark Empire happened.
360 Overdrive Did Mark Hamil really day that? 😂😂
@@lordnul1708 Apparently George didn't want a Darth Vader imposter to be the main antagonist in Dark Empire.
To be fair, the sheer power of fandom was stronger than the darkside...
And why could Palpatine not detect Yoda on Dagobah? Yoda hid in the presence of the darkside on Dagobah!
Very well thought out
Great analysis.
Poor old Maul wasn't an apprentice, just an enforcer/assassin. Palps just didn't care, end of video
Nah, he was absolutely intended to be a successor, but then Anakin showed up.
In canon and legends he was considered an apprentice however anakin was then seen as the future prospect. If anakin had not been found or even existed then maul would've been side by side with sidious throughout the clone wars and later empire.
Incorrect. Maul was a Sith Apprentice and was 100% intended as a successor.
@@TY-km8hj In most Legends statements aside from later 2008 TCW Maul was meant to be sith which is true but not one that would be a successor to Sidious even before Dooku And later Anakin were on Sidious radar most implications say that Sidious saw Maul as a prized possession not for his midichlorian count and potential but because of his physical abilities and martial arts skills as well as blade to blade combat that beats most other blade users he had his sights on Dooku even before Mauls defeat dead or alive just as Plagueis did Dookus potential and midichlorian count and power and skill as well as political know how was so high that Plagueis saw Dooku as a potential apprentice if Sidious becomes handicapped or dead while Plagueis did not see Maul as little more then a errand person yeah.
Now in most Canon materials 2008 TCW and on sources claim and imply that Maul was meant to be a true successor before his facepalming error on Naboo after that breathing or not Maul was no longer worthy of being a possible successor in Sidious eyes getting cut in half and becoming insane the second he landed down the reactor shaft made Maul far to damaged up to reach his full potential or near it without nightsister magics which Sidious knew that Talzin would not agree to see Sidious for after Sidious stole her son from her. And at that point even before the bisection Maul was not as powerful, skilled, refined, knowledge, and experienced as Dooku even though he had the potential to be he never reached it even after Talzin restored his body and mind he never reached it or close to it so yeah.
I love that Maul’s brother is literally named “Savage Oppress”. Like, even for Star Wars that’s lazy AF.
They couldn't just give him a generic name. You can't have Maul, and his brother Robert.
@@willycheez7218 Maul and his brother Paul
@@ifyourmarriedyourasimpanda7440 Maul and his brother Warhammer
I like to think it's more along the lines of the apprentice sensing their masters. The person who taught you how to feel through the force, the constant presence as you learned to sense others. That would probably leave a mark in the apprentice much deeper than the master, who would of already been using the force for quite some time prior to taking on an apprentice. To the apprentice the master would be a parent, good or bad, and we already know family can sense each other intuitively i.e. Leia sensing luke while unaware of her sensitivity to the force. That's my theory anyway, I just think this would add to the relationship between apprentice and master. 🤔🤯
That final point good as hell
Literally the way he ends his videos is so grating to the ears. Especially when he does that pause for no reason
Fixing plot holes and explaining retcons is a art Star Wars has learned well over the years
What is it with this content creator and repeating himself multiple times to pad the times on his videos?
So at the time Maul was defeated palpatine killed his master... what if Maul felt the fall of Palpatine master and got distracted during the fight? It looks like Maul just froze in place.
Love your videos man,keep up the good work😎
Uhm..why maul never attempted to see Sidious,to tell him hes still alive?
Can you do alternate weapons the Sith and Jedi used?
Seeing videos like this reminds me that I can easily separate the sequels from my mind in terms of the enjoying Star Wars and its continuity without feeling depressed af.
Gotta ask... First, Ima fan, admittedly a new one. I very much appreciate your work. Haven't missed a new release for a 3-4 years now. And have dug into older significantly too... Now... I'm kinda surprised by your lack of episode 9 perspective. Are you covering it elsewhere (ie. different channel)? Or did I missing something? Or should I read your opinion between the lines in that you've been covering a lot of legends material in the last month?
Why would he want to address it
Ol Sheevy boy looks like Cotton Hill in the thumbnail
This is all very interesting. And another well made video on your part! But what I really want to know is how Maul pooped after this happened? If not for me...for Forcing one out.
It’s a great explenation but there is a one HUGE problem. Mother Talzin knew that Maul survived. How ?
Is it possible that she and other nightsisters had stronger connection with him from the early time of his life on Dathomir?
"Hello there!"
General Kenobi
@@717jeezy
So uncivilized.
Obiwan has the biggest history of being able to defeat opponents he never should hav been able to.
Guess this is why it's important to give people proper burials especially if they are on your side. No body no Death
Maul was just hired muscle to him. He got what he needed from the Naboo invasion
Because it wasn't Darth Maul he was insane and had no idea how to control his Force Powers after Obi-Wan Kenobi cut his ass in half
Kenobi didn't cut his ass in half. He cut his ass off!
...along with everything else below the waste line. Meaning Maul no longer has a dick. Poor Maul.
Failure is forgotten
Maul was left half a Sith, so half the presents?
Maul died in 1999 and basically resurrected in like 2010 or whenever he’s basically a retcon
Or he simply just didn’t care, I mean, what threat is Darth Maul to Palpatine, really?
@@iamsupernautThat was before he found out Maul had the aid of Talzin, Savage, And The Mandalorian Army yeah.
He was busy searching for a new apprentice.
The Dark side clouds everything, even from him!
I would also think that he knew that he was kind of breaking the rule of 2 temporarily and was scattered about it until he could make it right by killing of his master.
Could you cover why Anakin asked the gate keeper where is Shaak Ti during the temple raid?
What i like about these comics is it highlights alot of stuff the movies dont. Like how Kenobi actually failed his Jedi Trials originally and was en route to the mines or service corps for those dont make the cut, and by running into Qui-Gon on a mission, proving his worth there and becoming one of the most famous Jedi Master's in the Galaxy? Crazy, eh?
I always thought because Maul failed, sidious just didn’t care about him anymore
Retcon, it's one damn powerful ability
Well, to be fair, Darth Maul was only half the man he had once been after he met Obi-Wan Kenobi.
Sidious knew that maul wouldn't have a single leg to stand on
Take a shot every time he says "Maul"
How on earth did you manage to stretch this out for that length. Kinda ridiculous
Dude right?? I like this dudes videos but he repeats the same stuff over and over and over. They can all be much shorter!!!
@@anthonyc7418 it's either interpreting the same comic 5 times or asking random questions that everyone has already figured out, he could branch out and discuss more lore based things or something like that, because this is atrocious
The question is how he got cut in two and it’s hilarious
Maul hit his head in calling scene and lost memory
"Why didn't Sidious sense Maul" hmm let's see the same reason why he didn't sense Yoda, Obi, Luke and Leia.
Better apprentice options and cybernetics/night sister Alchemy is the easy answer. Like vadar cybernetics altered him.
I always thought Sidious enjoyed killing his master when did he feel loss or solitude after doing it?
Near the end of the Darth Plagueis novel. If you haven’t read it you should check it out. It adds a ton of depth to Palpatine and turns him into much more than a one-dimensional ‘cartoon’ villain.
Last time I was this early anakin liked sand
Why do we see blood when Obi Wan strikes down Maul? We never see blood (exept Ep.4 Cantina) I thought the hest of the blade closes the wound
DarkWolper is guess because he didn’t completely severe Maul with his strike. Look at how his legs stick to his body momentarily as he falls, the forces of the fall is what finally tips the sliver of flesh holding him together apart?
I believe we also see blood when Luke kills that creature in the ice cave on Hoth
If I had to guess I'd say it's because the cauterizing power of the lightsaber isn't effective of the blood flow is heavy enough
Can you go more in depth in force sensing and how it changes.
The plagueis novel too he not only felt.plagueis.die but he felt maul die too
This is funny since yoda was able to sense that he was alive in the same episode that savage found him
Really the short answer: The Emperor did not see Maul as a threat.
And even in canon. Maul was never a threat.
Maul was clearly a threat the fact that Palpatine had to deal with it personally
IMMA ASSHOLE Naa, palps just had enough of this “we are the true sith” bs
Piggy Blitz if he had enough of it why didn’t he send Doku or Grevious🥱
IMMA ASSHOLE he needed to get to the witch lady
@@immaasshole4964 Maul was never a threat. Mother Talzin was a VERY real threat though.
Rule of two, translation "These Sith Lords ain't loyal!"
When maul falls he walks backwards
9:33 am i having a stroke
I don't know about you guys. But I heard that everything at the Maul is half off!
I suspect ole' palpatine didn't care about maul surviving, after all is "sole" role in the old man's plan was to "reveal" the sith, he had played out his role, and thus ole' palpy simply didn't care
This video is drawn out to such a degree you could stop watching at 6 minutes in and skip to 11 minutes in
Understandable...I accept your explanation...coincides with my feelings on the force linked relationships between master and padawan.
I understand the continued force presence argument but Ashoka detects anakins presence in Star Wars rebels as he attacks her fleet in his tie and Vader knew she lived meaning both thought the other died
His force presence was cut in half
The same reason you don’t realize you’ve stepped in dog shit a week after you leave the park
So did Mace Windu survive getting hand cut off and going out window? Must be a possibility if Maul survived getting cut in half.
What would have happened if Maul had survived and been around when Dooku switched sides?
Are those North Face or Canada Goose jackets they're wearing in the first scene? 😁
Star Wars Reading Club This is why I prefer SW legends more than Canon.
That sounds like...Lazy writing.
"Page turners they are not."
100 percent
Because that's what it is.
It has a good explanation '-'
asdf jkl No it didn’t. Maul is supposed to be dead according to every pre TCW material. But this happened probably because Dave Filoni once again thought it’d be cool despite what little narrative sense it makes.
because Maul was half the man he had once been, and thus a sneeze in the force 🤣