What is The "Cost" of Justice in India? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- What is The "Cost" of Justice in India? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
The Supreme Court of India granted interim protection to activist Teesta Setalvad on Saturday despite being on a holiday. Politicians of all parties and celebrities have also received such "fast track" assistance. Is influence and expensive lawyers the key to expedited justice? Palki Sharma explores the "cost" of justice.
Firstpost | World News | Vantage
#firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
We have two brand new shows for you to check out.
Flashback with Palki Sharma:
ruclips.net/p/PLEVkQGIATCXLJLVyPJAAUuIEUbdkyZiEq
Between the lines with Palki Sharma:
ruclips.net/p/PLEVkQGIATCXLZqGVWVzA7p3QOhkZ545gK
It feels like she has cold 🤧🥶
My father passed away in 1995 in a car accident and since then we have been waiting for a resolution from court. The case is now pending in SC since 2018...it's tiring to wait for your rights for more than 27 years.
Sorry for your loss, and lack of justice. Our justice system has definitely failed you.
Younger generation has no faith in the Judicial proceedings in India. They themselves have to comeback with Major Structural changes.
You pay a good amount to lawyer and get justice this is the Judicial system in India
@@ratangiri6361 no. Even if you pay a hefty fee to your lawyer, the time taken is not in his hands. The other lawyer can keep on getting adjournments. You need to have both money and lot of time, wt least 20 years
Sorry for your suffering. Costly lawyers can wake judges midnight for hearing and justice for ordinary people will be delayed (denied) like your case. Judges will lecture Doctors and other professionals about working hours and duties. Proud to be an Indian.
Thank you for covering this, Indian local media has a lost cause. One of the reason why staying in India is a crime itself
Respect to you Ma'am, this is a topic no media tells 🙏🙏🙏
Wonderful 👍
I always felt sad seeing Indian justice system. It is 100% true you need to have money to get justice. Or need high public attention. If both are not there with you. Forget about justice and live with compromise.
If this continues there will be god fathers giving justice soon, Robin hoods offering compensation... I just hope Indian justice system improves 😢
I salute you- Palki sharma , you are also bold enough to bring the fundamentals issues that needs to be addressed as India Need to show case, what is justice, democracy, care the people.
3:47
Please continue to be bold and differentiate yourself from bad/negative news channels.
I foresee you as a world news spokesperson by 2025.
Cheers
Veepee
Also why does SUPREME COURT has a 45 day Summer VACATION, School ke bachhe hai kya , no other profession has this STUPID policy when you have countless cases pending for AGES, WHAT A SHAME
This is British era pampering facility provided to Gora.
Not just supreme court. Lower courts also have summer vacation. The reason given is that they need to study judgements given by other courts in recent cases, as they can be precedents. I believe judges are too sheltered to understand the impact delays have on the life of people. Soon we are going to have a parallel justice system run by local muscle men or influential people. In fact it already exists in some places. Our system has failed us.
Good to see Palki covering this
Absolutely on point.
Justice is not equal for all !!!
I advocate Manish khanna thank you for this program.
You have said what the people are scared to say.
You have done your duty of whole life.
Thanks.
If you need more information, even more draconian, do message
Our Maharajas were 100x better than today's justice system...
Where the rich hv a different law and the poor has a different law
No, you are just being delusional now.
@@All.I.speak.is_truth No...but u r being a white slave! Or a liberandu
Go check the justice system under jamm and kashmir state
People like u deserve the farce of democracy, and the US is not even a democracy, a 2 party system in a diverse country cannot be democracy
These people have no idea how good things were under native Indian states like Jaipur, Mysore, Travancore or Jammu Kashmir state
People had great security where women could travel with hold ornaments at nighg and great public services like there were literally garbage collection trains in some states
@@All.I.speak.is_truth Kings used to reason with the criminals...
Find out the root cause for their mistakes...
Counselling was a routine process in the Ancient kingdoms of India...
King Rajendra Chola had many assassination attempts on him during his life ..
He did not give capital punishment to any of his assassins!
No hands/heads chopped off..no hanging
If the cause was due to hunger or frustration due mismanagement of the kings..criminals would often be pardoned..
Nothing was personal!
The democratic concept has its roots in India which the Greeks carried it back to their land during their travels and trade
A king/queen was selected based on his ability even by his own father/mother
Their training began at the age of 6 and
Unfit Kings were often figure heads and the able ministers would run the kingdoms..
Multiple legends are available in India.. ofcourse our brainwashed education system never allowed us to learn these things!
They had big circ*mcised d!cks to s@ck
Thanku mam for raising this issue😊
Supreme Court of India has done this time and again. Justice is more accessible to the rich and the influential. There was no need for the CJI to bend backwards and constitute a division bench for hearing Teesta Setalvad's application. Supreme court also similarly helped the former PM Manmohan Singh when was impleaded in a criminal trial. An application filed by him in the SC was allowed and stayed. It has not yet seen the light of the day.
Thank you Mam for raising this issue which nobody dare to cover. Promotion in reservation case pending in the apex court since 6 years bt they don't found it necessary to pay attention.
Aur kitna promotion you want, your getting promotion while getting selected still you want the same for promotion ??
@@vikas2435 Nowhere in above comment I mentioned that apex court should give reservation in promotion.I m jst raising concern over pendancy.Kindly try to get a rid on ur anger over reservation topic.
As always Palkibehen brings in the insight of the broken justice system.
Not sure how judges get selected in the Indian justice system. Seems like it is similar to the way Nehru Dynasty used to work.
There are exemplary lawyers in India.
Clients are ATM’s for some lawyers and treating clients especially as cash cows.
Palki, I absolutely LOVE the way you have courageously articulated this. The way justice bent over backward to pander to an influential activist is positively shameful.
Justice system is sold to rich people😂😂
It's fearless journalism
Justice in India belongs to Political personal, not for average people of India. Justice already hijacked by the politicians as they have enough black money( example in West Bengal politicians)poor people can't effort to engage good lawyers to stand for them. Our Judiciary is also like that (It became a very good Business center) in the name of Justice.
telling that you bring westbengal as example. but i agree. only want to add that modiji himself, most chiefministers of all parties and more than half of the ministers from delhi or states would be behind bars if justice would be done in bharat.
Well said!!!
We have such a great Journalist...
Thank you so much for your standard information..
What a woman - much respect by calling out our justice system with being abrasive- salute to Palki sharma
You have raised a very important point in reference to this testa setalwaad Supreme Court instant night hearing.
The same anguish & deep concern were expressed by our President Smt. Murmu on couple of occasions but failed to impress the Collegium Mafia sitting in Kotha of Justice.
Very true
Eventually people will take law in their own hands...
and I do believe that it is fair to fight if you are victim by anyways.
Go and end it.
Be limitless
Exactly, and the first casualties of public uproar will be judges themselves.
@@kavishwarmokal124 Judges itself are the problem, they are pushing their own agenda on the country like recently CJI Chandra chud made comments on Gender which was more in line with the Woke Liberal thinking like - " There's no absolute concept of man or woman ".
Totally WOKE and agenda driven CJI bringing up western concepts in a country with Real* problems where 99.50 % population doesn't care about these things
Agree with your comment. Police acts as their Naukar.
The 'Corrupt' Justice of India Chandrachud left a Bharatnatyam program midway to oversee the night hearing of Teesta's bail at 9 PM!
Draupadi Murmu Our President expressed Concern over Pending
Cases Delayed Justice as Good
as Denied or Derailed.
Time for judiciary reforms
Don't complain about people getting bail . Indian democracy & justice system has always been a JOKE . On 1st Dec 1997 , 58 Dalits were massacred by the terrorist group named Ranvir Sena , at Laxmanpur Bathe in Bihar. 58 Dalits , including *27 women and 16 little children* . The youngest victim was one-year-old. A district court judge sentenced 16 to death and 10 to life imprisonment in 2010 , but ALL were acquitted by the Patna High court in 2013. 16 children slaughtered and not a single person has been convicted even after 25 years . Most Indians have never even heard of the Ranvir Sena & the horrific massacres they committed in the 90s. All are roaming free .
In democratic and capitalist India, it is logical and normal that justice has a cost. Nothing is free including justice.
In India judiciary has collapsed. No point of going to court unless you have lot of money to fight for year's
In addition to money, you need to have a good life span. God help you if you get involved in a civil case in your 50s. You will probably not survive to enjoy the benefits of winning the case. I don't know if the number of judges is inadequate or our laws have too many loopholes or if the court system is apathetic. It just isn't working. You pay taxes, registration duties, property taxes, and wonder what you get from the system in return.
The Judiciary which stands for the protection common people has always been serving the ultra rich & VIP's. You'll never get to see justice if you do get dragged into a criminal case.
🙏👍 Very good.
Fantastic information ❤
Very true presentation
SC is the Perfect example of "Nepotism" 😂 ..
Mario Puzo - 'One lawyer with a briefcase can steal more than a hundred men with guns ...' 😢😢
Can you do a video on the freedom of speech of prisoners??? The data on undertrial prisoners just poked my curiosity. 😊
The judicial perspective has been very rightly put.
India should change the Judicial system similar to US system
The Supreme Court in Delhi should deal with Matters regarding Constitution Amendments, Check on State & Central Government Policies etc
The High Courts of all states should be changed to State Supreme Court (Last/Highest Court for Civil and Criminal Cases)
City/District Court ( First/Lowest Court for Civil and Criminal Cases)
India needs more Judges in these Courts to Clear Backlogs
Supreme court bias was quite evident during Jayalalitha corruption case. The court convicted the other culprits like shashikala, but refused to pass judgement on Jayalalitha, saying she is dead. Soft corner not to "tarnish" her legacy!
Truth nobody dares to expose
You asked the cost of the Justice in India? It’s LIFETIME😢. I feel ashamed to be an Indian citizen just because of the laws and the justice system in India.
Judges are not answerable to delays. Adjournments are routinely granted as if lives of litigants are infinite. Litigants, witnesses die, evidence gets destroyed or tampered with. There is no punishments to inefficient judges and no reward for efficient judges. So mediocrity rules.
India expected this when this CJI was appointed . This continues till next CJI , not under collegium system . Kapil Sibbal is ruling Supreme court ,not judges, not even central govt . High court judges are honestly giving justice which is over turned in SC . Panch Parameshwer of kaliyug
👍 shameful state of affairs 😡
Anyone in India speak against the higher courts will be hauled for contempt, hence no one dares to challenge the God’s representative of earth- Indian judiciary
If anyone is related to judicial officers, a high ranking politician, a celebrity in whichever field, a businessman with money, favourite lawyers, leftists who are well known, NGO’s with foreign connections, media houses, people with ‘ connections’, certain sections of minorities etc will get immediate hearing during holidays/ court vacations, any time of day and night, weekend , during weather/ security emergencies,
The courts are for certain people and not for plebs, who as per certain religion will have 7 births and deaths- they may hope to get justice from courts before the last cycle of death if they are lucky
It is a fallacy to think that British rule ended in India. They have left their representatives in the form of judges to rule India without being elected
Until the plebs won’t revolt and bring in a revolution, the judiciary will rule and ruin the country without being elected
Well ringing of cash came openly from across the table OR from under the table.
Justice delayed is justice denied
It looks you have great faith in Supreme Court of India, which in my opinion is misplaced. Barring a few judges like justice VR Krishna Iyer, SCI judges have been elitist.
They are most pathetic neptoistic bunch who have no relation with the ground reality of India.
Mr Krishna Iyer came from politics to court so he knew about real issues
Lady justice may be blindfolded but people are not.
Whole country is watching and Indians are not stupid.
Your talent demands such critical social issues to bring to limelight .
I hope judges /cji get time to watch this. Lol
🛎️🔕🔔🔕
Hope all of us think and ponder where are we leading ourselves to🤔
Also what is the criteria to choose judges … I remember a Great Stalwart of the legal profession once said … To become a good judge you don’t need to know have complete knowledge of law … that the lawyers are there to assist the Judge BUT to become a Judge the foremost is BE A GOOD HUMAN … nothing will stop you from being a GOOD Judge 🙏🙏🙏
Where there is money there is justice......
True True True 😊
India will become a true democracy only when the common people gets complete justice..then being proud Indian has any meaning..
Today SC canceled hearing of home buyers and gave priority to a Bollywood celebrity. It’s all about money. Justice sells
Justice Delayed is Justice Denied
Contact details of cji personnel Number be made public, people can call him and seek justice early justice. He is very cooperative and humble person, he is ready to help all the time.
Sorry sir in that case CJI will not get time for normal work.
Judicial Reforms is must
We have a court case which open for 50 years
People are watching irrational whims and fancies of CJI and his actions favouring his coterie of advocates is only helping in lowering the trust, reputation and integrity of SC in general in the eyes of the common man.
Very Bad needs to be condemned. 👊
Stan Swamy, was given a sipper after 6 months, Vara Vara Rao, is denied later granted bail but can’t leave Mumbai, is forced to rent a flat, to go broke. Gautam Navlakha, Sudha Bhardwaj, all 150 booked under UAPA, amended in 2019 to charge with following (above names & cases: do NRIs know?)
(i) Commits or participates in acts of terrorism,
(ii) prepares for terrorism,
(iii) Promotes terrorism, or
(iv) Is otherwise involved in terrorism.
Strange as if these oldies poets, social workers can destroy India. Are we a banana republic?
How many years it takes police to frame charges?
All gang rapists of pregnant Bilkis Bano are set free after 14 yrs, in between have frequent paroles, (when such rapists of orgy, murder of kids and unborn are not eligible for freedom) & are garlanded by society as if some brave acts were done. This was approved by which was granted by the home ministry, led by Amit Shah, in July 2022.
What happened to these courts?
Did it add to Indian Govt Image?
Justive delayed is justice denied.... By this logic our courts are one of the worst
In India every thing can have paying money then why judiciary will be factories
Shame Shame Shame on vJustice 💰 💴 💰
Money 💰 talk bully walk
Supreme court of India.🤦
The Indian Judiciary is biggest comic thing... They do nothing... They knew nothing... 🤣🤣🤣🤣
THE COST IS RIGHT FOR HOW MANY INNOCENT BLACK MEN ENDED UP IN PRISON FOR DECADES DUE TO INCOMPETENT LAWYERS OR SHOULD I SAY LAWYERS WHO DIDN'T GIVE A DAMN FOR THEIR CLIENTS AS LONG AS THE COUNTIES PAID THEM. BUT DECADES LATER THEY WERE FOUND INNOCENT BY DNA???!!!
Palki all over the world it’s like this it’s who u know and who know u the ordinary people with the same crime as those at the top or related or associated with the top brass there is no equal Justice Palki the poor has u fortunate pay the brunt 😊
India's judiciary , America's health care system lengthy and expensive , if you are poor you are dead 😑
Do you know I would prefer that supreme court closes down.
They pick up useless cases.
A family system has developed in Supreme Court.
Common citizen cannot even afford to come to SC.
SC acts like a ruler of this country without zero accountability
High court and district court are sufficient.
The judiciary is a mockery in India.
Judicial system needs correction that too with same speed as was for shitalwad
There is a proverb in tamil " courtkku poniya ootu eduthiya ". Its an old saying.
means ?
Justice in India is only for rich.
There is no chance for poor to get justice there only "tarikh pe tarikh"
Dalali is what our Judges are. Seetalwad episode proves it. CJI and other Judges should be asked explain by Parliament and immediately make Judges accountable to Public. Impeach these B...
If you are a common folk and believe in Justice from the courts, you are either extremely childish or must be out of your mind
👍🏼
We need one lakh more judges, new courts and high court judges should not be retired
If required district court judges also not to be retired
What good is a higher number of judges if all they do is grant adjournments repeatedly? Simple property disputes, agreement disputes drag on for two decades. The culture needs to change, technology needs to be adopted, and a system to focus on clearing the cases should be established.
Corruption ugly corruption raises its ugly head.
Its easy to critize those who are governing the country. But to release those in jail could endanger those to the public.
she isn't saying release the criminals but the fact of the matter is lot of people are waiting in jails simply waiting for their next hearing, they aren't convicted yet !
just look at the civil matter cases like land and property dispute, those common people waiting for years sometimes results come after they are dead!! and our biased judges have time even on weekends for tista but not even a second for common man
Those in jail are most of them under trial and 70% of them even if convicted accordingly then they have been already completed their jail term and has to released.
So what would be your saying in this new founding? .. still you would say it will be endanger to the public?
खाकी वरदी आणि काय द्याचं राज्य याला सामान्य माणूस कंटाळला आहे त्याच्या आत्ता आं त होत आहे . जर वेळीच थांबले नाही तर फ्रान्स पेक्षा भयानक परिस्थिती देशात होणार आहे
Besides most of us have become very bitter to tainted news which does not project complete story and does not allow the people/ the audience to form their own opinion.
Thus most news placed before the public are structured in a way so that it only and only conveys the message who designs the news. This is unfortunate and alarming 🙏
No justice our ordinary people we have rich them only get required justice leaders get immediate and instant justice
Even if u employ the most expensive u dont get Justice
The top judges of India are decidedly corrupt or how one case gets expedited and the other lingers on for years. The government taking the congnizance of recent decisions of SC headed by the present CJI should hold high level inquiry into financial dealings of the judges afterall the judges draw salary from government coffers which are filled by money we pay in services/taxes.
Ordinary people won't get justice in our country
Keep eye on neeraj singhal of 56000cr scam n Delhi HC.
You'll see a similar thing soon.
Same faces, same speed , same long hearings
There must be a cut given to the S C Judges by the so called famous lawyers and I feel most of the middle class lnows about it. Stupid justice
Nobody in India believes they'll get justice they just hope
It's world of money. More the money better your survival chances simple as that.
😢😢
So many arrested in broad day light murdering girls ,but even having video footage ,these nikamme courts for 2 years on,couldnt deliver decisions...infact in some cases they got bail,to avail them set things in their favour by threatening victims family....hail collegium 😂😂😂😂😂😂
TODAY SC is bhai-Bhathija club. Now just is not, just is ice. Just ice. For monyed just ease. Just died in india when collegium was.born. moon crowned will not change it, because he is born of bhai-bhathija.
Insha Allah
Allah jalla jalal Give truth way.
Everyone has their cut ?
Our justice system is a joke
Rightly said...only country in the world where judges select judges.. no doubt according to their ideological disciple 😂😂😂😂...most nikamma dept of system...wokism of next level compare themselves to US UK EUROPE...contrary to working ethics of same very nations delivering justice in due reasonable time....hypocrisy is not abundant ...collegium matrers😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂