33-Year-Old Japanese Guy Warns: Japan's Immigration Policy is Changing!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 окт 2024
- MrJapan
Japanese guy
Japanese man
Japan immigration
#japan #japanese #japanesereact
► MrJapan's's Twitch: / mrjapan0
► MrJapan's's Twitter: / mrjapan0
Thank you so much for watching🥰
I actually agree with you. People having a major influx of immigration changes the culture. As long as you have good immigrants who adapt and become part of the culture that's okay. But I don't want immigrants coming and breaking the law and trying to change the culture. That's not okay.
Pay is already fairly bad in Japan, it will become even lower when japan is flooded with immigrants, the same way it got lowered in US and Europe.
Yep all that new low cost labor, if the young in Japan were already having a problem affording to raise a family or couldn’t because of costs, they definitely won’t be able to now going forward.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts 🙏🙏🙏
Well the current temporary foreign workers (I can’t bring myself to say immigrants since none of us are expected to settle down, have a family and become members of Japanese society)
all receive minimum wage anyway. The exception might be English teachers and elder care staff.
Minimum wage here is very low anyway so unless they
are brought over on the terrible foreign worker trainee program (which is basically modern slavery ) the majority will get minimum wage or close to it.
The minimum wage was increased in the US so actually pay got better. The problem is inflation made things more expensive so the better pay doesn’t do much but that’s not because of immigration in the US.
@@shizuokaBLUES Is it like minimum wage and 0 unofficial overtime or do they try to shove something more you don't get pay for?
I am a Canadian living in Japan and have been here 29 years.
Personally I don’t think Japan can handle more immigration unless they continue to make it unnattractive for migrant workers to have families here.
The only path forward unfortunately is to continue to have migrant workers/student workers to fill in the cracks.
And to be clear : as a permanent resident retaining his Canadian citizen I don’t consider myself an immigrant.
For Japan I believe the definition of immigrants should be, those who are in the process of becoming citizens.
Otherwise we are all expected to “go home” one day.
Japan does not want immigrants. Japan wants temporary foreign workers.
And that’s the only thing that will work here. For everyone.
Thank for sharing your thoughts 👍 I think Japan wants those immigrants to bring their families from home too that’s a huge change😎
As an American who worked in Japan on a highly skilled worker visa, I can say that Japan absolutely needs foreign workers; they just need to be selective about who they bring in. Japanese tech companies are far behind on talent because universities in Japan have been slow to adopt to needs of the broader global market. The same is true in finance, manufacturing, and other sectors. Japanese companies need to learn from foreign workers' experience, skills, and work culture so they can abandon the older methods that are holding Japanese firms back.
Similarly, there are smaller tradesmen organization that are desperate for young talent because Japanese youth don't want to get into carpentry and skilled manual labor professions in the inaka.
So Japan would greatly benefit from focusing a lot on the skills of the people that they bring into the country; not just on bringing cheap labor.
It’s hard to find people with brain cells in the comments of these types of videos. Glad to see they still exist!
@@kayvondon4030 Yeah, the word "immigrant" is thrown around to scare people but skilled workers are a benefit to any country. It's just importing cheap labour that isn't necessary skilled that will cause massive issues. I hope Japan realise what the guy above is conveying
Just when you think Japan cant think of any worse ideas...
Hahaha🥹
This is a grave mistake that Japan will regret. I know most don't speak or understand English but you do and you can go research yourself to get an idea of the kind of discord that is in store for Japan.
Sad they have chosen the England route. Swindon & Birmingham level events in the future.
Yes I would make my future plan according to this new change for sure 🤔
@@MJapan0Problem is all the developed countries are going in the shitter bar few tiny countries. I guess third-world countries that are doing well and growing could be viable in the future.
Those who are in power don’t care. They are as greedy as any rich people are.
Unfortunately they've tried reversing the birth rate for decades and failed. Now they feel like they need to try something else. You can't just do nothing forever. And they've run out of time. They need to fill those vital job vacancies like truck drivers, construction workers and workers in plants asap. Also you can't compare South East Asian migrants who come to work with Arab "refugees" who come to suck money from the system. Apples and oranges
I am glad I spent 3 years in Japan, when Japan was still Japan. What an amazing country and culture, Unfortunately, it does not seem it will exist anymore.
It is changing for sure😎
Exactly what I was thinking. I loved visiting Japan when it was very Japanese. Now, the reason I'm going is because my son wanted to take a trip with me to Japan. I am dreading the "diversity." That's why I preferred going to areas of Japan where they don't speak English.
It just needs to emulate the UAE and Singapore then it will exist for a million years, well as long as the the last Japanese couple decides to have children.
What happened to the idea of robots taking care of the elderly?
We need a ton of immigrants? Not really.
@@mariatolentino4516 It is really not that bad lol, it is still 98% Japanese. At most now you see foreigners in combinis but you guys really love to overstate how much Japan has 'changed.' But definitely the government there are taking a weird approach, when really they could just be encouraging having children + improving working situations. The fact is that people from developing countries will take up manual labour jobs because they'll do whatever they can to work and provide. I don't see why they couldn't just have those people prove their suitability and Japanese language knowledge prior to letting them in? But either way, there's a lot of doomsaying online.
Historically, population decreases are a normal event. If a population continues to increase, it puts stress on the environment/resources.
Here's my concern for this immigration plan:
The pay for work in Japan will be lower than it would be in the States. So Japan will likely have a hard time attracting quality immigrants. The ones who will work for super cheap may be from high-crime countries and low-trust societies. It wouldn't be worth the cheap labor if it also leads to lots of worthless people draining social services, increasing crime, and bringing in cultures that causes who knows what kinds of social problems in Japan. We have seen stuff like this in the States and throughout Europe.
Hopefully Japan's leadership will recognize this and be very particular about who they let in.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts 🙏🙏🙏
They are already being carefully vetted. There's RUclips vids out there interviewing them and they go into the details of the system. It's nuts, I'm amazed they even come.
Japan used to be a lucrative place for Vietnamese, Filipino and Indonesian blue collars, but now it’s better to go to Australia, Malaysia or Singapore because of the weak yen, and the high-learning curve of Japanese language.
The language of Japan is one of the best vetting systems there is, along with its isolated geography. Japan already has a hard time attracting ANY immigrants as it is.
You can't pick and choose what people you like to have as a lower member of your society with all the benefits to your county and lower benefits to those people though. The "high quality immigrants" you mentioned who are willing to work "super cheap" are only going to come from high crime countries. Why? because they are desperate for a better life. Why would anyone leave to another country, without knowing anybody, without understanding the language and culture, to get paid significantly less than the rest of the population if their home country was better? The problem is that people will believe everything they see on TV, specially the bad and disingenuous publicity from the US and Europe who continuously use immigrants as scape goats for the problems they themselves create
Don't do it!!! Why don't the Japanese listen to what their friends in America and Europe saying to them!?!? Why don't they travel to Paris or London or Deerborn, or Malmo before deciding? We ruined our own countries. Save yourselves!
Well Japanese don’t understand English my friend 😂
@@MJapan0 I know you are deleting Japanese comments.
You are laughed at by both Japanese and foreigners as a "Japanese who uses poor English to flatter foreigners."Poor guy.
@@ivorylemony-gd5meLooks like we have a migrant who wants to move to Japan in the comments. Why don't you do your people a favor and improve your own country with your presence?
Indians 🇮🇳 will be happy with the new policie
Welcome😎
There's plenty of skilled indian in Japan already
Japan should continue to vet immigrants carefully, and not screwup like eu with open door policy.
Uh oh, that’s not good. Police there definitely won’t be ready for the new way of life that’ll occur. Kawaguchi is already having trouble. In regards to crime and such.
Let’s see what happens 👍
The wages are terrible in Japan. In America, working at mcdonalds is better than working in Japan.
So true😂
I never understand fellow Americans that could save USD that want to go to Japan too early, American USD is like gold in other countries, you just need to live with roommates or with family and save as much as possible. Also, if you have a lot of USD, you can go to Thailand or the Phillipines and live in a villa, then visit Japan on vacation
But cost of living in America is far more terrible so what’s the point?
@@astrahcat1212 "if they can save"
In the US you can make over $100,000 as a truck driver
In Japan like $20,000 😱
@@MJapan0well, I swear man still better than however much is generated by 3rd world countries' drivers. But I still wish its higher nonetheless.
Teamsters?
@@MJapan0 Do they have a union?
@@user-iy6rm6pm4j As a trainer specifically. In 2022 I made just under 300k (before tax). Otherwise if you’re teaming you would be splitting everything.
I am an American already visiting Japan for first time and as much as my dream is to live in Japan bring in people like me who know Japanese and have alot of admiration for the culture and people not just anyone like in America
The government could do this, but they are taking drastic measures without thinking enough about it in my opinion.
i hope japan will be selective on who can come and stay otherwise you'll end up like italy
What do you mean?
@@nyaruko-do2oklook at uk, France, Canada, Germany. At this point they might as well use shariah law
Italy’s economic issues regarding wages and job opportunities have little to do with immigration.
@@toya_senpai2470 Stop lying. Also, not all immigrants are Muslim - what kind of nonsense are you on? It’s weird.
@@hannah60000 stop gaslighting. dangerous immigrants all over europe. lots of rape, stick ups, murder. decline in language and culture as a byproduct
Very true, being anonymous online makes a lot of people feel powerful. Peaceful protests would be a good way for people to make their feelings known, but just staying silent won't change anything. Let's see how things go
You are so right about that 👍
Minasan konnichiwa! A random Russian here.
I don't know for now, but some time ago Russia took 2nd position in the world (between USA and Germany) by immigration. People were mainly coming from the other former Soviet republics. And judging not only from the Russian experience but also that of Sweden, Germany, USA I can conclude the following.
It feels like the governments opted for the easiest and "less expensive" solution. Why spend extra resources and money on ur own people if you can "import" someone who's gonna work for literal pennies and make many children regardless the income 😹 and often there's no social adaptation, because it's expensive. Sweden previously had a serious program of social adaptation, but their government canceled it in the past. And several decades later they opened borders so much that within 5 years their southern port cities changed their ethnic composition by 30%.
Beware, Japan! It's a dangerous route! In your place guys I would protest and make the government solve the well-being issues. It may be not money alone. Working hours, psychological climate and so on.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts 🙏🙏👍
Good video. You might explain in your video that the fertility rate in most western countries rivals Japan. But western countries quietly allow (illegal) immigrants into their territory, despite the opposition of their electoral bases. Pretty desperate, right? Western countries also happily recruit nurses, doctors & critical workers from the poorest of countries, fully aware of the harm they are doing by creating a brain drain. For sure, Japan needs more guest workers. Not troublesome people who are going to bring their religion, politics & customs to this country.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts 🙏🙏🙏
@@MJapan0 Lance Lee from the American Club in Tokyo is a great guy to interview. Perhaps you can do a "self made gaijin success stories type of video?
Ahhh good old Japan nationalism.
I think immigration in japan is good. However japan should be ready and prepared to NATURALIZE people and help them fit in. Having immigrants won’t make Japan worse as long as people have support and understand how to live in Japan.
if japan take migrant worker from southeast asia countries [the non muslim country like ; vietnam, laos, cambodia, thailand, phillipines and myanmar] japan will still safe, but if you take migrant worker from muslim country or african country or south asian country or middle east country japan will chaos, trust me, choose the right country is important or your country will chaos, just look at kurdis [muslim] in saitama
Great topic!
That’s really concerning bro, really really concerning.
Thank you so much my friend 🙏 Let's see what happens👍
@@MJapan0 Yeah… I hope anything or almost everything bad can be prevented on time.
Japan is in a tight spot. If it’s going to bring in people, these people will need to know the language and customs, for sure. It
seems like they need to attract hard working blue collar workers as well, and less weaboos. Some farmers too, very important. Hopefully, Japan can strike the right balance.
most that immigration will be from cambodia, vietnam, philippines, indonesia, nepal and myanmar, so other asian countries.
why can't governments just do the easiest thing possible - increase the quality of life? many people across the globe, not just in japan, just want to live a good life. but these days we cannot do it if we have to work long hours and then get sub par pay. i know so many people, myself included, that do not want to have children because that's a 1 way ticket to the poor house. it's SO expensive to have a child. more people would easily choose to have to children and a family if we had a good work-life balance and enough money to have a house. it feels like such a simple solution but these governments are going to wait until shit gets dire.
In Australia, we had 800k in a single year, just last year. And our population is less than a quarter of japans. And the government still says there is a labour shortage. Meanwhile worker salaries haven’t gone up while inflation rises, and no one can afford to buy a house
The reason they’re not protesting is two fold.
1. Japanese education system and culture tells you not to speak your mind or fight for what you believe in. Just fall in line and do what you’re told and don’t make noise.
2. In order to protest you need to be engaged in community and physically meet and interact with other people. But in this digital age, nobody knows who their neighbors are.
The immigration problem is everywhere in aging countries. As an American priced out of housing, I intend to work and settle in Japan over the next 5 years because I enjoy the people and culture.
OK. I have one foot in Japan and the other foot in USA/Canada. Japan will never be my full home because it doesn’t allow dual citizenship. So I need to keep my Canadian one for my daughter in the future.
As far as importing workers… absolutely, Japan should! And not just skilled workers. Absolutely not. The people who work hard and make it to another country without being able to pay for extremely expensive (oftentimes) post-secondary education are the salt of the earth. Immigrants who were born with relative silver spoons are not what make places truly great to live in. As long as the government makes sure workers aren’t abused. And as long as the government itself does not abuse immigrants.
Japan needs immigrants who are truly grateful to live in Japan. It doesn’t need people who just come to have a bit of fun and then ghost out back to their homeland. I mean, sure, those people are OK, but they aren’t what will save Japan from the shortage it is facing.
Japanese people just don't want to be responsible for all the isekais.
But in all seriousness, I get why they want to bring in foreigners, but as a Western guy, I want Japan to stay Japan. Diluting Japanese culture would be a tragic loss to humanity. Look at what's happening in Europe. This has to stop.
I love working trucks and docks. In a way I would skip breakfast to work a dock for you. Choto, I want to study Aikido and Japanese literature.
It is very tiring being a trucker driving over few hundread of kilometers everyday, the pay is ok just this is not a job for the weak.
Yes being a truck driver is hard 😱
I hope not
The problem is that Japan and 6 other nations are caught in the crossfire with China right now.
The policies are there to move things around in a way that isn’t economically risky, but it is slowing the process if Japan is not willing to take risks and speak Western languages.
The West will learn Asian languages to protect ally nations from China’s attack. And India, the nation that Journey to the West references, is targeted by China and it will not look good if troops are going to be sent to a land too massive that it could lead to war disasters.
The land can be a massive trap to our troops and we cannot take that amount of loss anymore than we already have in our nations. Repopulation is the final frontier and it needs to happened sooner than the attacks from China.
Japanese is top priority right to the West and Western languages are a top priority to Japan.
TRUCKING AND NO MONEY ... whome you FOLLING brother . Truck drivers makes the most money and they wont come japan because wherever they are they making a lot
Hey, can you cite an English article talking about this? I would like to read more about this potential new immigration policy
how about they pay better to get more people doing these jobs, companies pays these guys cheaper but they these guys have a huge social cost
Japan will take Russia’s good example in order to protect it’s authentic bloodline of the people, it’s deep rooted culture, unique heritage, long authentic history and further protect itself from any self destructive Western neoliberal ideologies(despite of the damages being done already). Any foreigner who comes to Japan must be of exceptional talent and skills who shall contribute to its domestic growth and economy output without abusing its system designed for Japanese people. Most importantly but thankfully, the country will soon enter and uphold the Global Economic Security and Recovery Act law which will cover and enable the points and facts I’ve mentioned taking back control of its country and the people.
I am 23 years old South Korea College Student and i want to work in Japan. What do you think?
Well if you want to experience Japan go for it my friend 👍 But if you want to make money it is not good place theses days 🥺
They both seem like very similar societies, issue is you'd be stuck learning Japanese and you won't ever be able to catch up to the natives, you already being a citizen of Korea makes it not that great of a decision, unless you really like Japan. Something like US would make more sense, but heart wants what it wants.
Both Korea and Japan have similar cultures. It shouldn’t be hard for you you to adapt to Japanese society 😊
@@IgnasV Korean is probably one of the closest languages to Japanese other than Okinawan. In fact, it’s significantly easier for a Korean native speaker to learn Japanese and vice versa than it is for a Korean or a Japanese native speaker to learn English
@MJapan0 Why doesn't the Japanese government just give money to couples to have babies. Like 10000 dollars per baby?
You’d have to change the work culture to make it worth it. Moneys not gonna fix that.
I hope Japanese wake up and vote for JFP before its too late 🙇♂️🙏
they should increase wages instead of importing low end skill people, more people will lower the wage farther, increase unemployment of jp people
Japanese companies are leaving Japan for other countries 🙃
Wages increase if productivity increase, not because a government raises them.
.... hopefully don't get any really unwanted groups... sort of like the first letter start with a P and ends with E. Those types.. do NOT GET THEM.
number_of_immigrants_required_for_stable_population = number_of_single_japanese_people/average_children_per_couple_count
So that's bad news. Japan will be destroyed. That's a fact because that's what happened to Singapore and other countries that allowed in many foreign workers & expats that bring their families. There'll be more homeless Japanese people who cannot find jobs. More grads will fail to find jobs. Foreign & local companies will hire cheaper foreigners than local grads. Today, foreigners working in 7-11s and Family Mart & some hotels are already behaving badly. I don't like eating Japanese food prepared by non-Japanese in Japan. I don't like non-Japanese cashiers in Japan.
Don’t do it Japan please don’t it’s warning don’t end up like United Kingdom.
Another covert racist.
Well it's your country Man so i didn't want to give my opinion.But i think more immigration is a good thing for Japan.I'm not from the US but from what i have seen.Their culture and heritage remains intact and it has become even richer with the culture that immigrants bring with them.From other nations.Sure it also has it's downsides.Just like everything in life.I mean i live in the other side of the world and the influence of Japanese culture has been very positive.Even tho i don't agree in everything you do.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts 🙏🙏🙏
"Their culture and heritage remains intact" Lmfao US European culture and heritage has become anything but intact since 1965. It's fucking mut land and everything has been going downhill for everyone but corporations ever since, look at the fucking rust belt. Young people can't buy fucking homes and everything costs a fortune plus it's car-dominated hell hole with nonwhite multi-ethnic dominated based crimes or rioting.
The US is absolute dogshit and it's only rich because it fucks its people over. Just look at the Rust Belt. Young people cant even buy or own homes
Everyone is making a huge deal about this immigration thing as if it really makes a big difference. Because of Japan's own poor choices, especially with the birth rate, Japan, as we know, will cease to exist and be successful invaded (probably by Chinese) either way unless a miracle happens and they straighten out.
And can we stop making this U.S or U.K with Japan comparison? Japan is not compatible into being in anything close to the situation with those 2 especially the U.S.
Better get to work developing those replicants and Gundams because mass immigration, especially from places culturally very different from you, will be disastrous. Just take a look at Western Europe.
No they don’t. Maybe they want more people from poor countries to fill unwanted jobs but they don’t want those people to stay forever lol
If Japan wanted more immigration they’d lessen the permanent residency timeline for skilled workers to 5 years or something
Maybe they are building up to it🤔
They already have that for the Skilled Worker Visa. There use to be only 2 types of workers that can get it, but now it’s about 15, mostly blue collar work.
Instead, maybe the Japanese government should give big tax benefits for Japanese to have more kids.
Many Japanese people think that’s also unfair to people who don’t want to have kids😂
@@MJapan0 Why? You said it your self that having kids costs lots of money. I'm sure you're aware that Japan needs more children. At this point choosing to have kids is a public service. They are doing the country a favor. I doubt the tax breaks for those that have children would be so great that they are living a better life than those that didn't have children, just balancing things out a little.
Feel like they tried that before and it didn’t work.
They tried it already, people don't care. Most people want more free time nowadays vs raising kids. Got enough stress and overtime from work already. The issue is far deeper than money. Hence Japan's failure to reverse the birthrate for decades. The problem is very very very old.
I hope they manage it better than in Spain, well... Europe in general at this point.
Europeans have to learn the bitter lesson by experiencing it and so will Japan. Remigration will be a big thing the next decades. Just have smaller populations. It’s not as bad as mass migration
As long as background checks and criminal records are checked, it could work out. But
Another important things is general love/interest for japans culture, and respect for most traditions.
And what will this do other than mess Japanese society if they get the wrong migrants and what about global south countries who will have their own labour shortage? Also who will go in droves if there is no good welfare to migrants? that coupled with Japanese working culture and it might not be a very good idea.
Son son son listen just open asylum facility ...and trust me japan will get all type of cheap labour . Japan is flooded with skilled imirants just PLAY ASYLUM CARD like europe and usa
I'm a system's engineer, do you think I have a good chance in Japan or will end up in a black company ?
thanks for the good videos !!
This tells me I need to visit Japan ASAP before it changes forever. How SAD
Japan has consistently changed - it’s not the Edo period anymore. 🙃
It's already changed. I am so lucky to have seen it before overtourism was a thing. It doesn't get better so go ASAP.
@@hannah60000 I’ve been to japan 4 times over the course of the past 10 years. I’m happy it’s not Edo because my favorite eta of Japan was the aconomic boom 80s and renegade 90s. It still feels a bit frozen in time up until after the pandemic. With immigration you will get people who have no cultural roots in the country and won’t carry the same traditions. It’s sad all around but young Japanese are shrinking and also don’t care about their history too much (became globalized). It’s sad that the introduction of the immigrants will accelerate the unique life in Japan moving forward.
Truck driving in America still can pay well, but you need to get the right job, still dangerous though.
Son son son ... listen trucker in usa drives for an year and after that year he owns his own truck so stop fooling people 😂😂😂😂
I'll be really sad if Japan loses its' identity in my lifetime.
How will Japan “lose its identity”? 🤡
@@hannah60000 Just doomsaying, random people online are the defenders of racial purity in Japan now lmao
@@hannah60000 immigrants rarely ever assimilate it will ruin the country
@@hannah60000 from all the foreigners(invaders) not assimilating
You're right about the birthrate; there's no fixing it. The costs of living are only increasing with each passing year. The world is just going to adjust to having a lower population. Over time there will only be rich and pretty people left, right? Less people means less production but less people also means less people needing resources. The only major issues I'm seeing here are the lack of a pension system being funded for old people and cultures are going to change drastically or go extinct. Japan is going to become very different and deal with real crime rates like what we have in the US/UK.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts 🙏🙏🙏
Why would crime rate increase. You do release immigration has little to do with crime in the UK? All the covert racists need to mind their on with regards to Japan.
Will the world 🌎 still be here in 5 years 😱.
That’s a good point👍
Not if Trump has his way no
It gets harder every day to answer "yes" to that question if I'm being honest.
@@shizuokaBLUESWe're kinda cooked either way. I can't really trust most politicians but kamala is the lesser evil in comparison to trump. She's definitely popular among the people, but our input doesn't matter much tbh
@@oden-sama_bro she can't even get a clear sentence. And if guys like Xi and Putin treat Trudeau like a puss how do you think they're going to treat someone as ditzy as her? You think they'll even be able to stand five mins in the same room with her, the way she waffles on?
Lesser evil my ass. If she goes in, the wars in Ukraine and co will continue.
At least with Trump you know he's got some smart cookies around him. Tulsi, Vivek, rjk etc
Who's Kamala got? Oprah
Japan- don't do it in large numbers .
Interesting take. That's not a bad idea. That's factually a good one.
The issue of that policy, is that if you paid them cheap and threat them like sh*t, you will have the same problems like France.
+ you need them to respect traditions... That's quite hard.
I'm gonna move to Japan!!!
Welcome😀
しょうがないなー🤷🏻♂️
Actually しょうがあるよ
We live in democracies for a reason
@@robotermann How’s that great democracy working out for you lol
@@Rawbtala yea lol let’s just do nothing right. Conservative parties are making a comeback in Europe so apparently it is working. Just because people make dumb decisions for a while doesn’t mean it’s a shit system
@@robotermann sounds great I’m happy for you
@@Rawbtala you’re very cool
This will help the birth rate .
Possibly 🤔
Not really unless a lot more Japanese people move to Japan. Non-Japanese foreigners will not improve the birth rate of Japanese people in Japan 🇯🇵
why
Well it won’t help the birth rate since we foreigners in Japan are already have little to no incentive to have children here, and the foreign migrant workers will barely make a living wage anyway.
But it could help fill in the cracks in the low skills low
Pay jobs. We are seeing that already.
Well it won’t help the birth rate since we foreigners in Japan are already have little to no incentive to have children here, and the foreign migrant workers will barely make a living wage anyway.
But it could help fill in the cracks in the low skills low
Pay jobs. We are seeing that already.