Pink Floyd could enter the stage and perform almost 50 minutes 3 songs that nobody ever heard in that time. Who can do such things now? Seventies were fantastic time in music.
@John6yt Swans and Godspeed You! Black Emperor are very well known, especially within the post-rock scene (in which most bands perform huge songs that the audience won't have heard before but still keep them completely enraptured. If you haven't heard of them I highly recommend looking them up. Start with Lift your skinny fists like antennas to heaven for GY!BE and with To Be Kind for Swans
@@Balkons131 Yeah, all the songs from this set are on spotify (Raving and Drooling, Shine On You Crazy Diamond and the whole The Dark Side Of The Moon), but this song isn't available.
I was at this when I was 15. Still got the ticket, a whopping £2.50. Got the bootleg LP of this called "Screaming Abdabs" and it is terrible. Stick to this version. 👍
3 versions of dogs. 3 wonderful solos. 3 differents expressions of sadness. what a musician is gilmour. the greatest sublimator of emotions ever. no one like him.
@balkons131 There's a 1975 version that is clearly transitioning towards Dogs. Look for Live at Boston 1975 posted by Mamagog666. That gig also includes Shine On You Crazy Diamond (with Have a Cigar dividing parts I-V from VI-IX) but it must've been before the release of WYWH as after that it's all DSotM with Echoes as an encore. Brilliant stuff.
Dogs has been my favorite song ever by Pink Floyd. My friend just recommended this song to me and holy freak it is the best. Pink Floyd never fails to restore the life back inside me. These men have changed my life. PINK FLOYD FOREVER!!!!!
@@GreggOld No brother, this raw version has more soul and a better “feel”. I wish they kept this one and promoted it more during live concerts, but then again I’m glad we have two slightly different tracks.
You can hear that this was written for 'Wish You Were Here'. It sounds like a fit on that album with the tone, speed, atmosphere and angle on guitar effects. However, I'm glad they polished it up and made it it's own beast (Pardon the pun) on 'Animals'. Think this song suits a darker tone than what WYWH offered, the darker subject matter for sure.
Definitely. Most people don't seem to grasp the politically charged lyrics and what they actually mean. The album points out the disgusting nature of corporate greed.
i thought the same, it have much of wish you were here on it, mainly the second half of shine on you crazy diamond. But the reason why is that they made it before the songs of wywh and abandoned the idea, later they rework it for animals.
8:28 - the amount of electricity going through me at this point is insane, major goosebumps, their voices together here just deliver so much emotion and pain - Floyd is perfection!
For me, this song defines quite a moment in my life and I can’t listen to more than a minute of any section without getting choked up. This is musical power to astronomically other degree.
Mind blowing song and I much prefer this version to Dogs. It literally takes you to another better place. Over 18 minutes long but it seems like 5 minutes and you don't want it to end. Very few songs have that kind of power. Echoes is another sublime example.
This sounds like Dogs, but this is much calmer. It being calm helps it fit in with the much more relaxed tone of Wish you Were Here, rather than Animals.
You gotta be crazy, you gotta be mean You gotta keep your kids and your car clean You gotta keep climbing, you gotta keep fit You gotta keep smiling, you gotta eat shit You gotta be small to be a big shot You gotta eat meat to stay at the top You gotta be trusted, gotta tell lies You gotta be able to narrow your eyes You gotta believe they've gotta believe you You gotta appear easy to see through Gotta be sure you look good on the TV Gotta resemble a human being You gotta keep one eye over your shoulder Gonna get harder as you get older Gotta fly south and hide in the sand Gotta forget that you're gonna get cancer And when you lose control You'll reap the harvest you have sown And as the fear grows The bad blood slows and turns to stone And it's too late to lose the weight You used to need to throw around So have a good drown As you go down Alone Dragged down by the stone Gotta be sure, you gotta be quick Gotta divide the tame from the sick Gotta keep some of us docile and fit You gotta keep everyone burying this shit You gotta get you started early Processed by the time you're thirty Work like fuck 'till you're sixty five And then your time's your own until you die I gotta admit to a lot of confusion Pain in the head is the child of collusion Gotta resist the creeping malaise You gotta believe in the way you get out of the maze But you, you just keep on pretending You can tell a sucker from a friend But you still raise the knife to Stranger, lover, friend and foe alike Who was born in a house full of pain Who was sent out to play on his own Who was raised on a diet of shame Who was trained not to spit in the fan Who was told what to do by the man Who was broken by trained personnel Who was fitted with bridle and bit Who was given a seat in the stand Who was forcing his way to the rails Who was offered a place on the board Who was only a stranger at home Who was ground down in the end Who was found dead on the phone Who was dragged down by the stone
I like it. I love being able to hear where the song came from. I think dogs is better & shows much more confidence from all four guys. But for live music this is incredible!
@@kevinr.3542 Couldn’t find the actual quotes but pretty sure I saw David say something about Roger not being a very good bass player. i’ve read so much Pink Floyd stuff through the years I can’t remember all the sources. it is supposed to be true that David actually played bass on probably half of the albums
@@bmille2121 thats crazy if true. That quote about RW bass playing, whoever said it, always sticks in my mind when i heear performances like this where his playing is very effective and awesome. He understood his role and how to contribute in ways that were subtle but perfect
This version of dogs is still so fucking cool, it's like if it was still part of The Dark Side and Wish era. It's much more spacey and slower. Don't get me wrong dogs is my favorite Pink Floyd but this alternate version is also incredible. It's more passive but the lyrics are way more aggressive, it makes you feel really uncomfortable. A masterpiece in its own way. Shame it's not on Spotify
ohh man i wish there was something we could do to get it on spotify, as well as the echoes from '74. Don't understand why shine on, raving and drooling and the DSOTM were released of this show but these songs weren't!
There's something magical about the live Floyd performances; bare, stripped-down, meat and potatoes. There isn't a wall of production backing them up. It's just them; the true magicians at their craft and in their prime. This, Raving and Drooling, and the other tunes (Darkside of the Moon live and Wish You Were Here live) are the purest (and my personal favorite) versions of these great works of art.
If you think of this song like a bridge between albums, you can feel how the relaxed and nostalgic mood that was set on WYWH fades out slowly, and the resentment that started in Welcome to the Machine evolves into the anger that creates Animals around 9:00
This version is every bit as great as "Dogs"! Pink Floyd is by far the greatest band ever. No contest. I've already gotten a ticket to see Roger in Tacoma WA in June 2017!!
@@zyrrhos The first half of the concert was great, with him singing a lot of the great PF classics. Then after break, he started good then went into his post-Floyd songs (which suck) and then he became very political with anti-American and anti-trump rantings and songs. He attacked Trump with an extremely hateful vengeance that must have surprised a lot of people because people started leaving (I should have also but was hoping he'd get back to PF music, but he never did). Even if you don't like Trump, a Brit shouldn't come over here and attack our president! He's garbage.
@@whitebeardInn Not something I would really care for, but he's a political activist so I would expect that going in. He goes after the West's foreign policies in general, so he's equally reviled in his home country. I actually agree with a lot of his viewpoints, and he goes after politicians on both the right and left. No one is spared if they serve power. And I'm pretty sure he never fell for the RussiaGate nonsense because he certainly didn't support the war in Ukraine. Anyway, all that blather to say, it's Roger Waters and he's pretty outspoken about his views, so what you're saying doesn't surprise me.
Beyond incredible also shows Roger Waters is genius to have such amazing lyrics and then completely change them on the album a few years later when it was released with different but still incredible lyrics
I gotta say, I really enjoy the falsettos on the "DrAAAgged down by the stone" part. I know they scaled it down for it to be more easily achievable on the studio version, but it adds something different for me. Also, less effects on Roger's voice is something nice to have.
The recording quality is fantastic for this version a lot of Bootlegs are terrible sound qualities and it's hard to love as much as this one but anger is present in the undertone
From 8:03 to 9:18 ... that for me is the most emotive moment here. Love their voices,for example at 8:28 when both sing "the bad blood slows and turns to stone or at 9:13 with "dragged down by the stone"
So good to my ears!!! Animals is my favorite album and i haved listen it probably a thousand time so it's really nice to hear the roots. I'm going to by this box set asap instead of the price...Pink Floyd... Priceless!
I saw Gilmour live apr 8 2016 at United Center Chicago, was sooooo intense! no empty seats 20 thousand ppl 3 hours long, hope he comes back before the great gig in the sky
I can listen to both versions back to back and still enjoy it, both have merits I actually marginally prefer this version with Davids vocal performance and the mix on the bass
Yeah. I believe this epic and mellow sound was the ultimate vision, at least musically, that Syd Barrett in at least 1967 had in mind for Pink Floyd. However at that time he was frustrated in being unable to help Pink Floyd realise that vision with him. Sadly by time the Floyd had finally realised Syd's vision completely in 1975 they soon threw it away through their bitter fallouts which combined with their marital and other personal issues left the band a twilight shadow of their former glory by 1987-1994.
Ive been listening to this whole night, repeatedly, staying awake and on mushroom/alco/hero combo and I think I got post-Barrett Floyd tiny bit right. Both David and Roger tried to pursue Syd's madness, in their own way. David - musical, Roger - lyrical. Both failed, but also captured This is why Division Belll sounds a lot like The Wall. David openly hates Roger, but down in his soul he admits Roger in his lyrical madness captured bit of Syd Roger openly hates David, but he puts Gilmour-like guitar solos on all his subsequent post-Floyd recordings, because he silently admits David is Barret's post-Floyd as much as he is Its almost perfect philosophical love-hate relationship
@@elitesennabubbleOh, but it does. Heavy-hitter percussion, pomposity. Division resembles Wall even more than it resembles Darkside. I think David respects Roger as much as Roger respects David, this is why he put out an album so similar in nature to Wall. Regards (MT).
I’m just loving this great song and all the different versions. Brings great joy to my life in 2021. 2020 was crazy and looks like a crazy start to 2021. Playing this song takes away the harsh reality of the dire times.
esta version es demasiado hermosa, me siento afortunado de poder escucharla todas las veces que quiera, el final de esta cancion es muy conmovedor, de lo mejor que he escuchado
This is just freakin amazing.I am waiting for my box set to arrive. I will not be opening it until Christmas time since it is a present.This soundboard audio beats the heck out of the audience recorded piece of crap that was floating around.Don't get me wrong the band did a good job of performing.
Great quality thanks for sharing, I remember hearing this long ago but the quality was not so great: "Work like f**k 'till you're sixty five And then your time's your own until you die"
true bro, you can't do shit when you're 65. i mean not those things you could do when you're like 16 or 18, they don't care about the life of people, i think we're just puppets for them. work puppets
Esta temprana versión es fantástica!! Tengo el CD doble de edición Italiana llamada" Black holes in the sky" con el concierto completo del "winter tour 1974" grabado en Wembley.
The remarkable thing about these early versions of "Dogs", is that even though "Dogs", is a writing collaboration between Waters and Gilmour only, the whole of Pink Floyd sounds just as solid and in their element here as on their earlier whole band epics like "A Saucerful Of Secrets" title track, "Careful With That Axe, Eugene", "Atom Heart Mother" title track and "Echoes" even as things began to fall apart offstage post-Dark Side.
As far as I know David came up with the riff and then they worked it out all together. In the end the writing credits were given to Dave and Roger in the final album version. Just listen to what Rick adds here to the sound. I'm sure he wasn't told to do exactly all of that by Roger or Dave ;)
@@Goldhand28 In my opinion these 1974 versions of "You've Gotta Be Crazy/Dogs" along with the live 1975 versions are my favorites. The 1974 live versions of this epic have the classic watery Farfisa Organ parts from Rick and the melancholy guitar from David. At least at the 1974 Wembley gigs, the slow middle section of "You've Gotta Be Crazy"/"Dogs" had a pastoral feel recalling the lovely atmospheric "A Saucerful Of Secrets", "More", "Ummagumma", "Atom Heart Mother", "Zabriskie Point", and "Meddle" and the pastoral parts of "Careful With That Axe Eugene" and "Piper At The Gates Of Dawn" with the watery Farfisa Organ and David Gilmour's soothing vocal chords. One of the last ever times that pastoral sound was used in Pink Floyd music. Its always lovely. I miss it. Its a shame the twilight Pink Floyd of 1986-1994 never took the opportunity to revisit "You've Gotta Be Crazy/Dogs" in their last tours, especially this arrangement.
@@Craigevansagain yeah you can hear the transition from DSOTM to WYWH here already. More mellow soundscapes and less aggressive guitar sounds than a Time or Money solo for example. Obviously the Animals album version sounds alot more rough and angry again. It is a shame really ... I would have thought that they would maybe play Dogs as Gilmour co-wrote it but the post Waters Floyd or Dav Solo never played it :(
@@Goldhand28 Near the end of Gilmour's 2001 "Meltdown Festival Concert", a fan requested, "Can we have something from 'Animals' please?" but Gilmour just quipped, "We'll be here 'till gone turf out time if we did that!" Yet again, that's surprising as the mellower 1974-1975 live arrangements of "Dogs" would have worked very well with a semi-acoustic concert setup as seen in the "Meltdown" versions of "High Hopes" and "Comfortably Numb".
I believe this epic and mellow sound was the ultimate vision, at least musically, that Syd Barrett in at least 1967 had in mind for Pink Floyd. However at that time he was frustrated in being unable to help Pink Floyd realise that vision with him. Sadly by time the Floyd had finally realised Syd's vision completely in 1975 they soon threw it away through their bitter fallouts which combined with their marital and other personal issues and Roger Waters leaving, left the band a twilight shadow of their former glory by 1987-1994.
Perdi a conta de quantas vezes ouvi essa música nos dois dias que passaram. Da letra ao mais singelo acorde tocado, é simplesmente hipnotizante. Parabéns aos mestres do bom e velho Pink Floyd, a obra prima mais elevada do mundo progressivo do rock. "And when you loose control you'll reap the harvest you have sown And as the fear grows the bad blood slows and turns to stone And it's too late to lose the weight you used to need to throw around So have a good drown as you go down all alone Dragged down by the stone"
During the first nine months of 2019, I did an amazing ton of DMT, like several times a day sometimes for days and weeks at a stretch. Certain things give me little “flashbacks,” and listening to this for the first time it just happened
I can't help but feel that this version had more input from Rick Wright than the one that ended up on "Animals". Floyd's music felt harsher once Wright's influence declined. While musically it's nice that the key is a tone higher (Em instead of Dm) that, as well as the way thr lyrics were written, made the song very hard to sing (it's a strain for them to hit the high notes) although Gilmour does surprisingly well.
"Wright's influence declined" He lost interest. E.g. Dave worked hard on those Wall band demos and Rick not so much. That's part of the reason Roger, Dave, and Nick fired him. If he hadn't wanted producer's money to not really produce much on The Wall he might have stayed, but that was adding insult to injury.
@@thebrazilianatlantis165 You are endeavouring to correct me, are you? But even supposing you are completely correct about what happened during The Wall sessions, that does not actually negate my point (what are you ostensibly responding to) in the least. For one thing, I am not even talking about The Wall. Did you just happen not to notice that minor detail?
Pink Floyd could enter the stage and perform almost 50 minutes 3 songs that nobody ever heard in that time. Who can do such things now? Seventies were fantastic time in music.
TtarArm Check out Swans and Godspeed You! Black Emperor: both modern bands who prettt much fit the bill for what you're looking for.
Waters performed Dogs and Pigs live and unabridged in his recent tour.
swans and godspeed you! black emperor are very well known though
@John6yt Swans and Godspeed You! Black Emperor are very well known, especially within the post-rock scene (in which most bands perform huge songs that the audience won't have heard before but still keep them completely enraptured. If you haven't heard of them I highly recommend looking them up. Start with Lift your skinny fists like antennas to heaven for GY!BE and with To Be Kind for Swans
@John6yt Please re-read my comment
OH HOW I WISH, HOW I WISH THIS WAS ON SPOTIFY
It used to be, it's where I first discovered it. No longer available though :/
Mikaeleo this is so sad
strange how Raving and Drooling is still there and this is not
Buy the 2 CD Experience edition.
@@Balkons131 Yeah, all the songs from this set are on spotify (Raving and Drooling, Shine On You Crazy Diamond and the whole The Dark Side Of The Moon), but this song isn't available.
Imagine "Dogs", but in the style of "Wish You Were Here"... wait! you don't have to - this is it
nop
This is not in the style of wish you were here
Not at all... Is it in the style of ummagumma?
@@maks886 I don’t think it’s in the style of anything but itself. It just has its own style, only my opinion tho👍🏼
I like this more than Dogs from Animals, when Roger, Rick and Dave sing together at the end it's a glorious moment.
This is why I bought so many Pink Floyd bootlegs all those years ago.
same hear buddy it was tapes and vinyal when i started
Agree
I was at this when I was 15.
Still got the ticket, a whopping £2.50.
Got the bootleg LP of this called "Screaming Abdabs" and it is terrible.
Stick to this version. 👍
3 versions of dogs. 3 wonderful solos. 3 differents expressions of sadness. what a musician is gilmour. the greatest sublimator of emotions ever. no one like him.
3 versions of dogs? have i missed one?
@balkons131 There's a 1975 version that is clearly transitioning towards Dogs. Look for Live at Boston 1975 posted by Mamagog666. That gig also includes Shine On You Crazy Diamond (with Have a Cigar dividing parts I-V from VI-IX) but it must've been before the release of WYWH as after that it's all DSotM with Echoes as an encore. Brilliant stuff.
Totalmente de acuerdo!!!!!
Totalmente de acuerdo!!!!
@@Balkons131the alternative take
One does not simply...
Get bored of Pink Floyd
Dogs has been my favorite song ever by Pink Floyd. My friend just recommended this song to me and holy freak it is the best. Pink Floyd never fails to restore the life back inside me. These men have changed my life. PINK FLOYD FOREVER!!!!!
Dreamier than the album version.
Benjamin Mackie it’s not really meant to be a dreamy song tho, that’s why the album version is better, in my opinion of course.
This sounds like it's from an alternate reality version of Wish You Were Here.
User 5748 traduce al español
@@luispunk88 Esto suena como si fuera de una versión de realidad alternativa de Wish You Were Here.
@@GreggOld
No brother, this raw version has more soul and a better “feel”. I wish they kept this one and promoted it more during live concerts, but then again I’m glad we have two slightly different tracks.
You can hear that this was written for 'Wish You Were Here'. It sounds like a fit on that album with the tone, speed, atmosphere and angle on guitar effects. However, I'm glad they polished it up and made it it's own beast (Pardon the pun) on 'Animals'. Think this song suits a darker tone than what WYWH offered, the darker subject matter for sure.
Definitely. Most people don't seem to grasp the politically charged lyrics and what they actually mean. The album points out the disgusting nature of corporate greed.
James yes, its almost pt 2 of have a cigar
Well said
@@johncotter1600 I think most people at least grasp it. They’d be listening to the wall if they didn’t
i thought the same, it have much of wish you were here on it, mainly the second half of shine on you crazy diamond. But the reason why is that they made it before the songs of wywh and abandoned the idea, later they rework it for animals.
8:28 - the amount of electricity going through me at this point is insane, major goosebumps, their voices together here just deliver so much emotion and pain - Floyd is perfection!
For me, this song defines quite a moment in my life and I can’t listen to more than a minute of any section without getting choked up. This is musical power to astronomically other degree.
Lllllllllllllllllc😢😢😢😢l😢 3:45 😊😢 3:46 😊😢 8:42
Mind blowing song and I much prefer this version to Dogs. It literally takes you to another better place. Over 18 minutes long but it seems like 5 minutes and you don't want it to end. Very few songs have that kind of power. Echoes is another sublime example.
Man, you can't get bored with Pink Floyd. When Dogs ends, i need more. Always happen with Pink Floyd, i want some more minutes haha.
Yes, it's so addiktive...
Gotta be small to be a big shot...love than line. Been listening to this for years, at least 3-4 times a month. Never get bored with it.
I love how Rick plays the guitar part with Dave on his keyboard
What?
@@JaceDanielFilms 4:11 Guitar and keys play the same notes.
This sounds like Dogs, but this is much calmer. It being calm helps it fit in with the much more relaxed tone of Wish you Were Here, rather than Animals.
that bass
You gotta be crazy, you gotta be mean
You gotta keep your kids and your car clean
You gotta keep climbing, you gotta keep fit
You gotta keep smiling, you gotta eat shit
You gotta be small to be a big shot
You gotta eat meat to stay at the top
You gotta be trusted, gotta tell lies
You gotta be able to narrow your eyes
You gotta believe they've gotta believe you
You gotta appear easy to see through
Gotta be sure you look good on the TV
Gotta resemble a human being
You gotta keep one eye over your shoulder
Gonna get harder as you get older
Gotta fly south and hide in the sand
Gotta forget that you're gonna get cancer
And when you lose control
You'll reap the harvest you have sown
And as the fear grows
The bad blood slows and turns to stone
And it's too late to lose the weight
You used to need to throw around
So have a good drown
As you go down
Alone
Dragged down by the stone
Gotta be sure, you gotta be quick
Gotta divide the tame from the sick
Gotta keep some of us docile and fit
You gotta keep everyone burying this shit
You gotta get you started early
Processed by the time you're thirty
Work like fuck 'till you're sixty five
And then your time's your own until you die
I gotta admit to a lot of confusion
Pain in the head is the child of collusion
Gotta resist the creeping malaise
You gotta believe in the way you get out of the maze
But you, you just keep on pretending
You can tell a sucker from a friend
But you still raise the knife to
Stranger, lover, friend and foe alike
Who was born in a house full of pain
Who was sent out to play on his own
Who was raised on a diet of shame
Who was trained not to spit in the fan
Who was told what to do by the man
Who was broken by trained personnel
Who was fitted with bridle and bit
Who was given a seat in the stand
Who was forcing his way to the rails
Who was offered a place on the board
Who was only a stranger at home
Who was ground down in the end
Who was found dead on the phone
Who was dragged down by the stone
Thank you sir for the lyrics 🙏
Nick's drumming in the last couple minutes is from another planet..
I gotta admit
That I'm a little bit confused
sounds a little better than dogs
Gotta stay awake
Got to try and shake off
This feeling that this is better then dogs tbh
I like it. I love being able to hear where the song came from. I think dogs is better & shows much more confidence from all four guys. But for live music this is incredible!
It’s much better than dogs IMO. An amazing song and for a live version it is amazing
@@eldubya7972 i legitimately think some so songs they played live was better then studio version. And usually its the opposite
@@Laughing__Emoji__ The music is on POINT. The lyrics needed improvement, and got it in Dogs.
If anybody has any doubts about Roger waters bass playing especially live listen to this. Roger is a phenomenal very nuanced bass player live
All that nonsense from Dave after the split about Roger being a poor bassist was just sour grapes.
I always thought that came from Roger himself. Claiming he wasn't a great bassist. Did David actually say that?
@@kevinr.3542 Couldn’t find the actual quotes but pretty sure I saw David say something about Roger not being a very good bass player. i’ve read so much Pink Floyd stuff through the years I can’t remember all the sources. it is supposed to be true that David actually played bass on probably half of the albums
@@bmille2121 thats crazy if true. That quote about RW bass playing, whoever said it, always sticks in my mind when i heear performances like this where his playing is very effective and awesome. He understood his role and how to contribute in ways that were subtle but perfect
@@kevinr.3542 i agree
This version of dogs is still so fucking cool, it's like if it was still part of The Dark Side and Wish era. It's much more spacey and slower. Don't get me wrong dogs is my favorite Pink Floyd but this alternate version is also incredible. It's more passive but the lyrics are way more aggressive, it makes you feel really uncomfortable. A masterpiece in its own way. Shame it's not on Spotify
I can't stand dogs 😢
ohh man i wish there was something we could do to get it on spotify, as well as the echoes from '74. Don't understand why shine on, raving and drooling and the DSOTM were released of this show but these songs weren't!
This feels like listening to dogs for the first time its so damn good
@@BarbieChaitehow shit is so good some of gilmours best guitar work
14:24 That guitar is absolutely beautiful.
Man and what about that bass-line? Love it all!!!!
he's got that Phase 90 dialled in to perfection
Best Floyd bootleg ever. Great show, 2nd night at Wembley. Solid Raving & Drooling as well. Just Floyd perfection!!
I love it when The three sing together.
It is satisfying
There's something magical about the live Floyd performances; bare, stripped-down, meat and potatoes. There isn't a wall of production backing them up. It's just them; the true magicians at their craft and in their prime. This, Raving and Drooling, and the other tunes (Darkside of the Moon live and Wish You Were Here live) are the purest (and my personal favorite) versions of these great works of art.
"there isn't a wall of production backing them up" so you don't like Gilmour's Pink Floyd 🤔😁?
I couldn’t agree more. Pink Floyd stripped down is literally pure art magic.
If you think of this song like a bridge between albums, you can feel how the relaxed and nostalgic mood that was set on WYWH fades out slowly, and the resentment that started in Welcome to the Machine evolves into the anger that creates Animals around 9:00
also have a cigar
This version is every bit as great as "Dogs"! Pink Floyd is by far the greatest band ever. No contest. I've already gotten a ticket to see Roger in Tacoma WA in June 2017!!
How was it?
@@zyrrhos The first half of the concert was great, with him singing a lot of the great PF classics. Then after break, he started good then went into his post-Floyd songs (which suck) and then he became very political with anti-American and anti-trump rantings and songs. He attacked Trump with an extremely hateful vengeance that must have surprised a lot of people because people started leaving (I should have also but was hoping he'd get back to PF music, but he never did). Even if you don't like Trump, a Brit shouldn't come over here and attack our president! He's garbage.
@@whitebeardInn Not something I would really care for, but he's a political activist so I would expect that going in. He goes after the West's foreign policies in general, so he's equally reviled in his home country. I actually agree with a lot of his viewpoints, and he goes after politicians on both the right and left. No one is spared if they serve power. And I'm pretty sure he never fell for the RussiaGate nonsense because he certainly didn't support the war in Ukraine. Anyway, all that blather to say, it's Roger Waters and he's pretty outspoken about his views, so what you're saying doesn't surprise me.
This brings back memories - I was there.
I wasn't ever born then.. I'm so jealous on all of you.
+Bára Křepínská Same here.
+John Perriment I bet it's a bit of a mind trip hearing this again then.
That’s awesome. What was it like hearing it again?0
How lucky you are!!!
really amazing to see how this song evolved, both lyric wise and musically
Beyond incredible also shows Roger Waters is genius to have such amazing lyrics and then completely change them on the album a few years later when it was released with different but still incredible lyrics
Magnifique version !
Quelle créativité …
I gotta say, I really enjoy the falsettos on the "DrAAAgged down by the stone" part. I know they scaled it down for it to be more easily achievable on the studio version, but it adds something different for me. Also, less effects on Roger's voice is something nice to have.
I wish I could "thumbs up" this a million times. Man what an awesome song.
The recording quality is fantastic for this version a lot of Bootlegs are terrible sound qualities and it's hard to love as much as this one but anger is present in the undertone
Though I prefer the final version, this version is really cool.
I've seen you before. You're the pro-abortion guy
@@conradcutty lmao wtf
H u h
@@conradcutty what does that have to do with Pink Floyd, get that shit outta here.
@@conradcutty Yes, what does that have to do with Pink Floyd. This is indeed a cool version of Dogs.
This song speaks truthful from the soul. Floyd rhymes are just so simple yet reaches your inner soul. Hard to explain
You've gotta be pink you've gotta be floyd....
Georgios Papadopoulos You gotta be crazy about Pink Floyd to listen to this kind of stuff. 😎
Georgios papadopoulos I agree
This version with dogs lyrics would have been perfect! My god, the ending is fantastic all the three voices singing together.... Awesomeness!
It's great to see how Dogs developed. It's too bad bands stopped developing songs this way...on the road.
From 8:03 to 9:18 ... that for me is the most emotive moment here.
Love their voices,for example at 8:28 when both sing "the bad blood slows and turns to stone or at 9:13 with "dragged down by the stone"
Love it, both Dogs and it's origins, particularly the end my god!
A beautiful vocal arrangement by the lads. Well played.
So good to my ears!!! Animals is my favorite album and i haved listen it probably a thousand time so it's really nice to hear the roots. I'm going to by this box set asap instead of the price...Pink Floyd... Priceless!
Just a pure live raw stunning guitar work piece, pure magic.
Essa versão é maravilhosa, caramba!!!!!! Que coisa linda!
This puppy grew up to be one viscous dog!
I saw Gilmour live apr 8 2016 at United Center Chicago, was sooooo intense! no empty seats 20 thousand ppl 3 hours long, hope he comes back before the great gig in the sky
Love the strumming and guitar tone on this version
I can listen to both versions back to back and still enjoy it, both have merits
I actually marginally prefer this version with Davids vocal performance and the mix on the bass
1975 Richard Wright at his finest… Pink Floyd at its finest
Yeah. I believe this epic and mellow sound was the ultimate vision, at least musically, that Syd Barrett in at least 1967 had in mind for Pink Floyd. However at that time he was frustrated in being unable to help Pink Floyd realise that vision with him. Sadly by time the Floyd had finally realised Syd's vision completely in 1975 they soon threw it away through their bitter fallouts which combined with their marital and other personal issues left the band a twilight shadow of their former glory by 1987-1994.
Better than the studio version.
Igual que Raving and Drooling
My favorite version of it.
So much drive and even some funkiness to it.
Not as gritty as the studio version but more symphonic.
Ive been listening to this whole night, repeatedly, staying awake and on mushroom/alco/hero combo and I think I got post-Barrett Floyd tiny bit right.
Both David and Roger tried to pursue Syd's madness, in their own way. David - musical, Roger - lyrical. Both failed, but also captured
This is why Division Belll sounds a lot like The Wall. David openly hates Roger, but down in his soul he admits Roger in his lyrical madness captured bit of Syd
Roger openly hates David, but he puts Gilmour-like guitar solos on all his subsequent post-Floyd recordings, because he silently admits David is Barret's post-Floyd as much as he is
Its almost perfect philosophical love-hate relationship
agreed except I don't think The Division Bell sounds anything like The Wall
@@elitesennabubbleOh, but it does. Heavy-hitter percussion, pomposity. Division resembles Wall even more than it resembles Darkside.
I think David respects Roger as much as Roger respects David, this is why he put out an album so similar in nature to Wall.
Regards (MT).
I’m just loving this great song and all the different versions. Brings great joy to my life in 2021. 2020 was crazy and looks like a crazy start to 2021. Playing this song takes away the harsh reality of the dire times.
How was it bad
U got to sit around all day relax go out fishing walk keep fit enjoy exsisting
@@russell9378 It was _soooo_ bad people were convinced to take an experimental vaccine for a donut.
I know it has nothing to do, but never forget Syd. =)
intothevoid , I would never forget Syd! At the age of 59 I have recently got into his two solo albums!
sttgaegoaktd
sttgaegoaktd
God I love this song and Dogs too Thank you Pink Floyd, my favorite band of all time.
I can understand why he said he had trouble preforming this song now. Christ at such a fast speed and this many words it's a pain to do.
Agreed!
The guy that disliked this video gotta be crazy!!!
Make that 40 idiots now
Wow!! that was Beautiful!!! I wish they showed the filming of the concert... Gilmour and his guitar just make me melt!!!! #lovemyfloyd
It's absolutely unbelivable how you realize the transformation that it suffered! Amazing see that this song became a masterpiece (Dogs).
per me che la ascoltai all'epoca dell'uscita di Raving and Drooling rimane la migliore. Quando uscì Animals rimasi deluso....
esta version es demasiado hermosa, me siento afortunado de poder escucharla todas las veces que quiera, el final de esta cancion es muy conmovedor, de lo mejor que he escuchado
This song is perfect !!
Thanks. Great quality recording.
Fantastico! La loro miglior canzone e io le ho sentite quasi tutte!!
Best moments of the floyds like the live in Pompeii.
AND WHEN YOU LOSE CONTROL
no es fácil desechar una gran canción como esta para ajustarla a un álbum conceptual y mejorarla, simplemente los mejores de la historia....
Simply delicious!! Good old Pink Floyd
6:45 is SO good
Fantastic... i love pink floyd
that bass is so smooth
The bass sounds great.there are some haters out there saying waters can’t play bass.pendejos.
amazing......i was only a few months old when this was recorded live to stereo multitrack.
It is new, old Floyd!
We not alone in this space! this music comes from gods listen....
3 CHORD DRUGGIES OWN YOU, CUPCAKE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YOU GO GIRL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
MAMMA MIA...LOST FOR WORDS
great lyrics...great chords...great song.
I like Dogs, but I LOVE You've Got To Be Crazy
This working piece, being played live and even still, not to appear studio released until 1977 is in and of itself quite remarkable...
Can't wait for this to be on vinyl
I love Pink Floyd, I really do.
3 CHORD DRUGGIES ARE ALWAYS ADORABLE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YOU GO GIRL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This is just freakin amazing.I am waiting for my box set to arrive. I will not be opening it until Christmas time since it is a present.This soundboard audio beats the heck out of the audience recorded piece of crap that was floating around.Don't get me wrong the band did a good job of performing.
Great quality thanks for sharing, I remember hearing this long ago but the quality was not so great:
"Work like f**k 'till you're sixty five
And then your time's your own until you die"
true bro, you can't do shit when you're 65. i mean not those things you could do when you're like 16 or 18, they don't care about the life of people, i think we're just puppets for them. work puppets
I gotta say great music and great Pink Floyd
I love the people sceaming more at the end
DOgs (song) Begin... Early Version, It so Great Tanks for all
8:00-9:20 amazing sound
15:35 is HEAVENNN!
This is perfect, honestly
I kinda like this version more than the final one that's on the album. It Has more variations in atmosphereand tone.
Esta temprana versión es fantástica!! Tengo el CD doble de edición Italiana llamada" Black holes in the sky" con el concierto completo del "winter tour 1974" grabado en Wembley.
Their voices echoing in harmony at 8:40 OMG.
This is Amazing!!!
Millones de gracias, esta cancion es la quinta esencia de Pink Floyd. Me encanta y para remate tenemos la letra. Te mereces un diez
Proc9lhaf7m
The remarkable thing about these early versions of "Dogs", is that even though "Dogs", is a writing collaboration between Waters and Gilmour only, the whole of Pink Floyd sounds just as solid and in their element here as on their earlier whole band epics like "A Saucerful Of Secrets" title track, "Careful With That Axe, Eugene", "Atom Heart Mother" title track and "Echoes" even as things began to fall apart offstage post-Dark Side.
As far as I know David came up with the riff and then they worked it out all together. In the end the writing credits were given to Dave and Roger in the final album version. Just listen to what Rick adds here to the sound. I'm sure he wasn't told to do exactly all of that by Roger or Dave ;)
@@Goldhand28 In my opinion these 1974 versions of "You've Gotta Be Crazy/Dogs" along with the live 1975 versions are my favorites. The 1974 live versions of this epic have the classic watery Farfisa Organ parts from Rick and the melancholy guitar from David. At least at the 1974 Wembley gigs, the slow middle section of "You've Gotta Be Crazy"/"Dogs" had a pastoral feel recalling the lovely atmospheric "A Saucerful Of Secrets", "More", "Ummagumma", "Atom Heart Mother", "Zabriskie Point", and "Meddle" and the pastoral parts of "Careful With That Axe Eugene" and "Piper At The Gates Of Dawn" with the watery Farfisa Organ and David Gilmour's soothing vocal chords. One of the last ever times that pastoral sound was used in Pink Floyd music. Its always lovely. I miss it.
Its a shame the twilight Pink Floyd of 1986-1994 never took the opportunity to revisit "You've Gotta Be Crazy/Dogs" in their last tours, especially this arrangement.
@@Craigevansagain yeah you can hear the transition from DSOTM to WYWH here already. More mellow soundscapes and less aggressive guitar sounds than a Time or Money solo for example.
Obviously the Animals album version sounds alot more rough and angry again.
It is a shame really ... I would have thought that they would maybe play Dogs as Gilmour co-wrote it but the post Waters Floyd or Dav Solo never played it :(
@@Goldhand28 Near the end of Gilmour's 2001 "Meltdown Festival Concert", a fan requested, "Can we have something from 'Animals' please?" but Gilmour just quipped, "We'll be here 'till gone turf out time if we did that!" Yet again, that's surprising as the mellower 1974-1975 live arrangements of "Dogs" would have worked very well with a semi-acoustic concert setup as seen in the "Meltdown" versions of "High Hopes" and "Comfortably Numb".
I believe this epic and mellow sound was the ultimate vision, at least musically, that Syd Barrett in at least 1967 had in mind for Pink Floyd. However at that time he was frustrated in being unable to help Pink Floyd realise that vision with him. Sadly by time the Floyd had finally realised Syd's vision completely in 1975 they soon threw it away through their bitter fallouts which combined with their marital and other personal issues and Roger Waters leaving, left the band a twilight shadow of their former glory by 1987-1994.
thank you
a wish many more soundboard recordings of this era were avalible in this Q
Perdi a conta de quantas vezes ouvi essa música nos dois dias que passaram. Da letra ao mais singelo acorde tocado, é simplesmente hipnotizante. Parabéns aos mestres do bom e velho Pink Floyd, a obra prima mais elevada do mundo progressivo do rock.
"And when you loose control you'll reap the harvest you have sown
And as the fear grows the bad blood slows and turns to stone
And it's too late to lose the weight you used to need to throw around
So have a good drown as you go down all alone
Dragged down by the stone"
This was the best thing that ever happened to me
During the first nine months of 2019, I did an amazing ton of DMT, like several times a day sometimes for days and weeks at a stretch. Certain things give me little “flashbacks,” and listening to this for the first time it just happened
I can't help but feel that this version had more input from Rick Wright than the one that ended up on "Animals". Floyd's music felt harsher once Wright's influence declined. While musically it's nice that the key is a tone higher (Em instead of Dm) that, as well as the way thr lyrics were written, made the song very hard to sing (it's a strain for them to hit the high notes) although Gilmour does surprisingly well.
"Wright's influence declined" He lost interest. E.g. Dave worked hard on those Wall band demos and Rick not so much. That's part of the reason Roger, Dave, and Nick fired him. If he hadn't wanted producer's money to not really produce much on The Wall he might have stayed, but that was adding insult to injury.
@@thebrazilianatlantis165 You are endeavouring to correct me, are you? But even supposing you are completely correct about what happened during The Wall sessions, that does not actually negate my point (what are you ostensibly responding to) in the least. For one thing, I am not even talking about The Wall. Did you just happen not to notice that minor detail?
@@amtlpaul "are you?" No, I'm explaining why Wright's influence declined.
Will Brazil and Montreal ever bury the hatchet in this legendary Floyd fued? let's watch...
@@kevinr.3542 Truly riveting
Absolute masterpiece in every sense