I soured on them over the years. I really like the current Project Runway with Christian and without Karly. The show has a more diverse set of contestants and minorities are treated better. Christian is kinder and more compassionate. So are the current judges.
While I miss Hiedi and Tim on Project Runway, I do still watch it and love Christian Siriano. I am not a fan of Kloss though. I am a super fan of Making the Cut! love the show, love the global aspect of it. And I am happy that Heidi and Tim got to do what they wanted in spite of Project Runway. I can't wait for season 3.
I love Christian Siriano too and was so glad to see him replace Tim Gunn, whom I never liked, partly because his catch phrases were so trite and extremely boring and irritating to listen to. I often muted the TV when I thought he was going to utter one of them again. Also Siriano gives very helpful advice - Tim Gunn's advice was often very bad and usually not helpful. I'm also not a fan of Kloss, but I still like her better than Tim Gunn. What I miss most is Michael Kors as a guest judge. I do not like the new PR as much, but for other reasons, although I do think that replacing Heidi Klum with Kloss (can't remember her first name) was a bad idea.
@@dariajordxn I don't dislike Karli, but she doesn't do a lot for me, and she's not as funny at Heidi, who may not have even been trying to be funny, but I thought she was more entertaining and more or less inoffensive. I liked that Heidi had her own ideas and stuck to them. I also very much liked Nina Garcia, but I think she is still on the new version. She was my second favorite judge after Michael Kors. I didn't like Isaac Mizrahi (boring), and I really got tired of him being introduced as "iconic" but I guess that was the only word they could come up with to make him seem special, and to me it made him seem common, since that word is used to describe almost everything.
Heidi and Tim are such an iconic team. Bravo lost big when they allowed these two to walk away. I will follow Tim "Make it Work" Gunn to the other side of the earth through broken glass. Tim Gunn is a precious gem in this world.
Not the same without them. Some of the guest judges need help with their own choice of wardrobe. Heidi had a way of helping a designer with improvements or suggestions and always supportive. A couple of judges are very judgmental and harsh. This past season had so many great designers and Christian has a unique way of critiquing. New judges please!
Kind of ironic that Tim says they wanted to focus more on the designers sewing skills on Project Runway and then they launch Making the Cut where the designers have seamstresses do the sewing t night. Give me Project Runway any day although I miss Tim.
I’ve been binge watching PR and find it disturbing how the judges would comment on outfits making a model look fat and then went overboard gushing over having obese models and a grossly obese season-winning “designer.” I think Siriano was the only PR winner to be remotely successful.
That’s how I felt when Michael Kors said to one of the designers “No one wants to have a big butt” when there are plenty of people that have a big butt naturally and embraces it.
I really wish Heidi and Tim were still on PR. Tim always had sage advice as a mentor & teacher. I think he was very blunt and straightforward and most importantly you could trust his judgement. He wasn’t afraid of calling out designers who didn’t deserve a win like Gretchen. He called out Anna Wintour and the industry on not being plus sized friendly and criticized the judges for making s16’s Ashley a winner just cause she was big & not cause her designs were good. Edit: Christian should’ve replaced Posen immediately. Would’ve been much more balanced in terms of judgement and i think a previous winner would give the added understanding and benefit as being a judge.
I still love Project Runway and I still watch it now. But I do think that Making The Cut is on another level. It sucks that Heidi and Tim aren’t on Project Runway anymore. But I do feel that it was a good thing that they decided to do their own thing.
I kinda do agree that project runway shouldn’t be changed... I think creating a new show (Making the Cut) was really the best option. I still watch Project Runway and I love Making the Cut. I also love Christian and love to watch him.
I'm not interested in the ideas that Gunn and Klum wanted to implement. The business end of it is not why I want to watch the show. I always wanted to see more of the WORK the designers put into their designs, and the fabrics, etc. I could not stand the petty dramas that seemed to be manufactured. I guess I am one of the few that was more interested in the designs than the designers.
I still enjoy PR and don't miss Heidi and Tim. I love Christian as the mentor. I didn't make it through the first season of Making the Cut after some dubious cuts.
Tim and Heidi are so adorable together, so supportive and you can tell best friends, that my young daughter thought they were married and totally in love! :)
MTC is not about the best designer. It is only about what will and will not sell on Amazon. They also have taken the suspense of who is going home out of the format that PR still has. People have come to love watching the designers rush around Mood then rush to get the sewing done. PR is just more fun and exciting and that's one more aspect that keeps fans glued to it after all these years. I LOVE Tim Gunn. He was a wonderful mentor. I wish both Heidi and Tim had stayed with PR.
Right because the end goal is retail. You can make the most beautiful things but if they aren’t relatable or won’t retail it doesn’t matter. The end goal is always will it retail. 45 years in buying at the luxe retail level.
Saw the first season of MTC and although it added a much-needed commercial aspect to the Runway format, it fell flat for me. Tim and Heidi's segments were so contrived! The critiques were so cringe-worthy, it just wasn't enjoyable to watch. Without Klum and Gunn, I think Runway lost a chunk of its gravitas. The contestants NEVER disrespected Heidi or Tim the way they do Christian! They borderline dismiss his critiques. For me, Runway is just a lot more fun. I like the prize of a CFDA mentorship, and honestly I'm ok if the winner doesn't become a global brand. There's enough marginal, vanilla clothing out there already.
Totally agree! MTC is an OK show but certain aspects that make PR so addictive are missing. I love Tim Gunn. I do wish both Heidi and Tim had stayed on. I've watched a few episodes of MTC but it's missing the hook that makes PR addictive. The winners are chosen by what will sell on Amazon not by who is the best designer.
I honestly thought I wouldn’t like PR anymore because I cannot stand Karli Klauss but I actually enjoyed the past 2 seasons. The designers were given more time and money so the output is much better. The challenges were not too crazy either. I tried MTC because of Tim Gun but they made me cringe and the deliberation made no sense.
While I was shocked with their exits I must say that I love Christian on PR and I particularly enjoyed this latest season's format, without Kloss. I cannot say the same about MTC 2nd season, it had something missing... It was shorter and very... Business oriented? Also, we must remember that PR had one bad issue of judges just being MEAN. I'm rewatching some older seasons, now on season 8 and OMG they were unnecessarily harsh and mean, even Tim Gunn complained about this before. So yeah i get their decision but as it stands right now, PR is winning, to me.
i ABSOLUTELY LOVE TIM*** A PERSON WITH SO MUCH LOVE AND COMPASSION FOR PEOPLE i WOULD LOVE TO HAVE HIS AUTOGRAPH AUTOGRAPH TO CHERISH FOR EVER TIM*** IS A BIGG PLUS TO THE SHOW⭐
My first guest was that they didn't want anything to do with Georgina Chapman and her husband/producer Harvey Weinstein after he was first accused, but maybe were locked in a contract that kept them there for a while until they could leave.
If the changes they wanted to make are the ones in Making the cut… the should’ve better stayed in Project Runway. It’s just a great show and great formula. No need for any change just like Ru Paul’s Drag Race. I love Tim Gunn, but PR remains my fav show no matter who’s in!
They have only aired a few seasons of this program here in the Netherlands. I loved watching it so it's a shame it only showed 2 or 3 seasons here.I think Heidi and Tim are a nice duo! Nice people with no attitude.
I like MTC for how interactive the show is with the audience. PR is all about the drama, but MTC is more about the bsuiness side of things. I love the pop up shop segments of the show towards the end of the season. Love Siriano and Kloss too. However, I cant wait for the new season of MTC
I didn't care for the show, " Making the Cut". I didnt like the business aspect of it..it wasn't fun to watch. I much prefer the format of " Project Runway", even though Heidi and Tim are no longer there.
Watching the other hosts, you realize how amazing Tim Gunn was. His unique ability to encourage and inspire holds the show together. Christian and Miss Anne are horrendous.
I wasn't crazy about the show Making the Cut. I loved the original Project Runway. It was a good formula. I can see why they wanted to change things up but not sure it helped designers
Same here. Designs need to be evaluated by professional designers, not by models or actresses :-). The show host doesn't need to score or evaluate designs.
MTC is a disaster! First off, the clothes are in limited supply on Amazon, often selling within minutes. Then, the judging is very catty and clicky. Finally, there are silly premises that don't work, like Heidi and Tim sword fighting....oh please! At times, it feels like they're making it up as it goes. PR's format has gotten better, especially since getting rid of Kloss, although they definitely need a host. That whole judge as host thing sucks. Oh and can they get rid of Elaine too....annoying!
Wel they were right and the network was wrong. It’s working so don’t change. It’s not change it’s evolution which is what fashion is. I don’t even watch lifetime with its sappy movies, reruns and shows that can’t evolve. The best thing I can say about them is they aren’t TLC.
OMG the narrator of this video actually knows how to pronounce the name “Marie” Shocker. I wonder if she also knows the difference between a jumper and a jumpsuit or that miniskirts were a fashion of the sixties and not the seventies. Those were just a few of the teeth-gritting mistakes that finally caused me to stop watching Heidi and Tim’s version of Project Runway. In their defence I will add that even the editors of Marie Claire gave the first name as Mary. The only person I heard before quitting who could pronounce the name was a contestant/designer.
I love the recent seasons with Christian Siriano as mentor. They have some really gifted designers and not a one who is reminiscent of Anya who could not sew a sttitch.
The idea of buying their clothes is a very good one. The cattiness of Project Runway makes me fast forward past their drama and lame speeches before they leave. I don't have Amazon Prime, so I will be missing out.
PR just isn't the same without those two. And Christian Soriano didn't deserve to win his PR season, and is in no position to coach others. My opinion...
Love that the changes they wanted to make were fashion and business related and not political. Project Runway is getting more woke and less watchable by the season 🤢 Will def check out Making The Cut 😀
Also they can't even get a decent host for the show now. They have an older person who sucks not a supermodel at all. Really who puts an older women who looks awful and her style is just as bad..
Stopped watching it because it's not the same with Tim and Heidi plus MK. The new judges are awful and self centered and just SUCK.. love making the cut.
California??? 🫠 Well, outside of choosing a sinking state for its location and only being available on Amazon 🙄, I love the idea of being able to buy a piece from the show; brilliant!
What are your thoughts on Tim Gunn And Heidi Klum?
They are the best . What else is there not to say?
They actually were the best.
They are genius and their new show is so good!!💚💙
I soured on them over the years. I really like the current Project Runway with Christian and without Karly. The show has a more diverse set of contestants and minorities are treated better. Christian is kinder and more compassionate. So are the current judges.
Tim and Heidi made a good team. Maybe the network should have listened to them. A little change can be good; it keeps things fresh and interesting.
This was favorite show! It just was never the same after Heidi and Gunn left. I am happy about their new show!
While I miss Hiedi and Tim on Project Runway, I do still watch it and love Christian Siriano. I am not a fan of Kloss though. I am a super fan of Making the Cut! love the show, love the global aspect of it. And I am happy that Heidi and Tim got to do what they wanted in spite of Project Runway. I can't wait for season 3.
I love Christian, too, but Gunn has always had my heart big time!
I love Christian Siriano too and was so glad to see him replace Tim Gunn, whom I never liked, partly because his catch phrases were so trite and extremely boring and irritating to listen to. I often muted the TV when I thought he was going to utter one of them again. Also Siriano gives very helpful advice - Tim Gunn's advice was often very bad and usually not helpful. I'm also not a fan of Kloss, but I still like her better than Tim Gunn. What I miss most is Michael Kors as a guest judge.
I do not like the new PR as much, but for other reasons, although I do think that replacing Heidi Klum with Kloss (can't remember her first name) was a bad idea.
@@larsedik Karli! However, I do like how respectful yet clear she was with critiques. But it does feel like an entirely new show
@@dariajordxn I don't dislike Karli, but she doesn't do a lot for me, and she's not as funny at Heidi, who may not have even been trying to be funny, but I thought she was more entertaining and more or less inoffensive. I liked that Heidi had her own ideas and stuck to them. I also very much liked Nina Garcia, but I think she is still on the new version. She was my second favorite judge after Michael Kors. I didn't like Isaac Mizrahi (boring), and I really got tired of him being introduced as "iconic" but I guess that was the only word they could come up with to make him seem special, and to me it made him seem common, since that word is used to describe almost everything.
I too love Christian Siriano. And Tim, and Heidi.
Heidi and Tim are such an iconic team. Bravo lost big when they allowed these two to walk away.
I will follow Tim "Make it Work" Gunn to the other side of the earth through broken glass.
Tim Gunn is a precious gem in this world.
I love that making the cut gets deep into the industry and sets designers for success in the future while PR is all about the show
Not the same without them. Some of the guest judges need help with their own choice of wardrobe. Heidi had a way of helping a designer with improvements or suggestions and always supportive. A couple of judges are very judgmental and harsh. This past season had so many great designers and Christian has a unique way of critiquing. New judges please!
Kind of ironic that Tim says they wanted to focus more on the designers sewing skills on Project Runway and then they launch Making the Cut where the designers have seamstresses do the sewing t night. Give me Project Runway any day although I miss Tim.
They were the best.....not the same without them....🕊🇺🇲💕
I LOVE Timm Gunn!!! Absolutely love him!!!
I’ve been binge watching PR and find it disturbing how the judges would comment on outfits making a model look fat and then went overboard gushing over having obese models and a grossly obese season-winning “designer.” I think Siriano was the only PR winner to be remotely successful.
That’s how I felt when Michael Kors said to one of the designers “No one wants to have a big butt” when there are plenty of people that have a big butt naturally and embraces it.
I really wish Heidi and Tim were still on PR. Tim always had sage advice as a mentor & teacher. I think he was very blunt and straightforward and most importantly you could trust his judgement. He wasn’t afraid of calling out designers who didn’t deserve a win like Gretchen. He called out Anna Wintour and the industry on not being plus sized friendly and criticized the judges for making s16’s Ashley a winner just cause she was big & not cause her designs were good.
Edit: Christian should’ve replaced Posen immediately. Would’ve been much more balanced in terms of judgement and i think a previous winner would give the added understanding and benefit as being a judge.
It was actually s14 that Ashley won and I also could not stand that season.
The last season MTC they did not give the right person the win. The designers are not as good either
I still love Project Runway and I still watch it now. But I do think that Making The Cut is on another level. It sucks that Heidi and Tim aren’t on Project Runway anymore. But I do feel that it was a good thing that they decided to do their own thing.
I kinda do agree that project runway shouldn’t be changed... I think creating a new show (Making the Cut) was really the best option. I still watch Project Runway and I love Making the Cut. I also love Christian and love to watch him.
I can’t lie, I’d probably watch either or any show about fashion 😅
I'm not interested in the ideas that Gunn and Klum wanted to implement. The business end of it is not why I want to watch the show. I always wanted to see more of the WORK the designers put into their designs, and the fabrics, etc. I could not stand the petty dramas that seemed to be manufactured. I guess I am one of the few that was more interested in the designs than the designers.
I still enjoy PR and don't miss Heidi and Tim. I love Christian as the mentor. I didn't make it through the first season of Making the Cut after some dubious cuts.
Love Heidi and Tim, as well as the show format. I look forward to season 3 of Making the Cut!
Tim and Heidi are so adorable together, so supportive and you can tell best friends, that my young daughter thought they were married and totally in love! :)
Only Heidi (one day your IN, next day your OUT) , PR most unforgettable phrases.
I did binge watch making the cut. I liked it alot. Can not wait for the next season
If I could hang out and talk with someone it is Tim Gunn. He is one of the kindest and witty people I’ve heard .
MTC is not about the best designer. It is only about what will and will not sell on Amazon. They also have taken the suspense of who is going home out of the format that PR still has. People have come to love watching the designers rush around Mood then rush to get the sewing done. PR is just more fun and exciting and that's one more aspect that keeps fans glued to it after all these years. I LOVE Tim Gunn. He was a wonderful mentor. I wish both Heidi and Tim had stayed with PR.
Right because the end goal is retail. You can make the most beautiful things but if they aren’t relatable or won’t retail it doesn’t matter. The end goal is always will it retail.
45 years in buying at the luxe retail level.
MTC id really boring
Saw the first season of MTC and although it added a much-needed commercial aspect to the Runway format, it fell flat for me. Tim and Heidi's segments were so contrived! The critiques were so cringe-worthy, it just wasn't enjoyable to watch. Without Klum and Gunn, I think Runway lost a chunk of its gravitas. The contestants NEVER disrespected Heidi or Tim the way they do Christian! They borderline dismiss his critiques. For me, Runway is just a lot more fun. I like the prize of a CFDA mentorship, and honestly I'm ok if the winner doesn't become a global brand. There's enough marginal, vanilla clothing out there already.
Totally agree! MTC is an OK show but certain aspects that make PR so addictive are missing. I love Tim Gunn. I do wish both Heidi and Tim had stayed on. I've watched a few episodes of MTC but it's missing the hook that makes PR addictive. The winners are chosen by what will sell on Amazon not by who is the best designer.
There is no replacement for Heidi and Tim, not even close! Making The Cut saved us👏🏻👏🏾👏🏼
I honestly thought I wouldn’t like PR anymore because I cannot stand Karli Klauss but I actually enjoyed the past 2 seasons. The designers were given more time and money so the output is much better. The challenges were not too crazy either. I tried MTC because of Tim Gun but they made me cringe and the deliberation made no sense.
I can't wait for the new season to come out! I Love this show.
While I was shocked with their exits I must say that I love Christian on PR and I particularly enjoyed this latest season's format, without Kloss. I cannot say the same about MTC 2nd season, it had something missing... It was shorter and very... Business oriented? Also, we must remember that PR had one bad issue of judges just being MEAN. I'm rewatching some older seasons, now on season 8 and OMG they were unnecessarily harsh and mean, even Tim Gunn complained about this before. So yeah i get their decision but as it stands right now, PR is winning, to me.
Making the cut is okay, I've learnt more about the business end of starting a fashion brand watching making the cut.
Bravo blew it!
i ABSOLUTELY LOVE TIM*** A PERSON WITH SO MUCH LOVE AND COMPASSION FOR PEOPLE i WOULD LOVE TO HAVE HIS AUTOGRAPH AUTOGRAPH TO CHERISH FOR EVER TIM*** IS A BIGG PLUS TO THE SHOW⭐
My first guest was that they didn't want anything to do with Georgina Chapman and her husband/producer Harvey Weinstein after he was first accused, but maybe were locked in a contract that kept them there for a while until they could leave.
I loved Project Runway, I've seen every show but when Heidi and Tim left, so did I. It sucks now.
If the changes they wanted to make are the ones in Making the cut… the should’ve better stayed in Project Runway. It’s just a great show and great formula. No need for any change just like Ru Paul’s Drag Race. I love Tim Gunn, but PR remains my fav show no matter who’s in!
Making the Cut is terrible. Bravo and Lifetime was right to not add this branding nonsense.
This whole time I didn’t know Tim Gunn was from parsons lol I remember applying there back when I wanted to become a graphic designer
They have only aired a few seasons of this program here in the Netherlands. I loved watching it so it's a shame it only showed 2 or 3 seasons here.I think Heidi and Tim are a nice duo! Nice people with no attitude.
I wonder what changes they wanted to make im sure they would have been worthwhile
I like MTC for how interactive the show is with the audience. PR is all about the drama, but MTC is more about the bsuiness side of things. I love the pop up shop segments of the show towards the end of the season. Love Siriano and Kloss too. However, I cant wait for the new season of MTC
Wowww I never really thought about this. I notice the show switched networks which was strange. I wondered what happened to Tim & Heidi...!!
I liked Heidi and Tim on Project Runway. I don't like Making the Cut at all.
I actually liked Allysa Malono on Project Runway
We all are tired of the crazy characters and results of the fashion show. It was a bit better this year. (ie Project Runway)
I didn't care for the show, " Making the Cut". I didnt like the business aspect of it..it wasn't fun to watch. I much prefer the format of " Project Runway", even though Heidi and Tim are no longer there.
I’m not a fan of making the cut. I still love project runway but I miss Heidi and Tim.
Watching the other hosts, you realize how amazing Tim Gunn was. His unique ability to encourage and inspire holds the show together. Christian and Miss Anne are horrendous.
I'm still devastated today😥😥😥
Like making the cut very much!!
The show went downhill once Heidi and Tim departed. Glad that they have another show.
Making the cut is not as good as project runway.
Love,love,love Making the Cut!
Tim is the best!!!!
I wasn't crazy about the show Making the Cut. I loved the original Project Runway. It was a good formula. I can see why they wanted to change things up but not sure it helped designers
I can't wait
I can’t wait love there show
What happened to the sound.
I only miss Tim Gunn and Michael Kors not Heidi Gloom
Same here. Designs need to be evaluated by professional designers, not by models or actresses :-). The show host doesn't need to score or evaluate designs.
Season 3 is already out
MTC is a disaster! First off, the clothes are in limited supply on Amazon, often selling within minutes. Then, the judging is very catty and clicky. Finally, there are silly premises that don't work, like Heidi and Tim sword fighting....oh please! At times, it feels like they're making it up as it goes. PR's format has gotten better, especially since getting rid of Kloss, although they definitely need a host. That whole judge as host thing sucks. Oh and can they get rid of Elaine too....annoying!
I do not like anything about Making the Cut. Very disappointed. Still miss Heidi & Tim, but will always be a loyal watcher of Project Runway.
Me too!
Background music 🎵???
Can't wait...
Wel they were right and the network was wrong. It’s working so don’t change. It’s not change it’s evolution which is what fashion is. I don’t even watch lifetime with its sappy movies, reruns and shows that can’t evolve. The best thing I can say about them is they aren’t TLC.
I loved the show when they were on but I left when they left.
OMG the narrator of this video actually knows how to pronounce the name “Marie” Shocker. I wonder if she also knows the difference between a jumper and a jumpsuit or that miniskirts were a fashion of the sixties and not the seventies. Those were just a few of the teeth-gritting mistakes that finally caused me to stop watching Heidi and Tim’s version of Project Runway. In their defence I will add that even the editors of Marie Claire gave the first name as Mary. The only person I heard before quitting who could pronounce the name was a contestant/designer.
Who ever does this vide obviously doesn’t like project runway. Also Christian and Karly are AMAZING!!!
I love the recent seasons with Christian Siriano as mentor. They have some really gifted designers and not a one who is reminiscent of Anya who could not sew a sttitch.
I don't like either of the shows as much as I liked the old Project Runway with Tim and Heidi.
Seasons 1 through 4 were the best. The show loss something after that.
Ive watched all 3 seasons of Making the Cut and I enjoyed all of them
I think Making the cut is such a boring show. I still like more PR even I miss Tim and Heidi.
Why did they want to make changes? Why change or fix something that ain't broke?
Not digging the cut it’s not as good as project runway
They could have left off Karlie Kloss she was so boring but it figures she is Jared Kushner’s sister in law
Klume?? It's Klum in North America.
love always heidi and tom and they are right ...make it work!!
Tom?
@@Ianisatool typo?
@@Dee010s oh ok.
The idea of buying their clothes is a very good one. The cattiness of Project Runway makes me fast forward past their drama and lame speeches before they leave. I don't have Amazon Prime, so I will be missing out.
"Heidy and I didn't want to work for a monster who was raping women right and left" #lookitup
PR just isn't the same without those two. And Christian Soriano didn't deserve to win his PR season, and is in no position to coach others. My opinion...
‘Another direction’ is company bs.
Ok
Love that the changes they wanted to make were fashion and business related and not political. Project Runway is getting more woke and less watchable by the season 🤢 Will def check out Making The Cut 😀
🙄🙄🙄
Not missing Heidi at all…did like Tim tho.
I don’t care for project runway after Heidi and Tim unfortunately.
i hate the show w/o them lmao and i used to watch the seasons over and over daily
I love making the cut
While I like both shows, I enjoy Making the Cut so much more.
Making the Cut is above and beyond Project Runway. There is no substitute for Tim Gunn...sorry Christian.
Also they can't even get a decent host for the show now. They have an older person who sucks not a supermodel at all. Really who puts an older women who looks awful and her style is just as bad..
Stopped watching it because it's not the same with Tim and Heidi plus MK. The new judges are awful and self centered and just SUCK.. love making the cut.
just look at the show today, so tacky....and siriano instead of gunn? get real...
Whatever...Change is Better we can't keep seeing Donald Trump as the President every year isn't it....?
California??? 🫠
Well, outside of choosing a sinking state for its location and only being available on Amazon 🙄, I love the idea of being able to buy a piece from the show; brilliant!