Core Exercises: The "McGill Big 3"

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 сен 2024

Комментарии • 81

  • @Scorpionwins23
    @Scorpionwins23 2 месяца назад +4

    I've been doing these for the past few weeks before going on my daily walk and I'm noticing a huge difference in my lower back (multilevel annular disk bulging with nerve root impingement).
    This is by far the best explanation on how to do these exercises. Thank you!

  • @emilydodgson1486
    @emilydodgson1486 11 месяцев назад +29

    There are so many videos on the migillis 3... This is the only one that perfectly explains what to do!

  • @user-vp7ku5eg2b
    @user-vp7ku5eg2b 6 месяцев назад +7

    Thank you for your thorough explanation! These 3 exercises have been instrumental in helping me recover from acute Sciatica.

  • @bigbattenberg
    @bigbattenberg Год назад +13

    Awesome. Just recovered from a rare but very severe episode of lower back pain. I found that hamstring stretching broke the vicious cycle and now I am determined to try as much as I can to prevent reoccurrence. Thanks to the YT comment section I was pointed to Stuart McGill and here I am!

    • @BB-nq1ps
      @BB-nq1ps 5 месяцев назад

      Stretching the hamstrings made it better or worse?

    • @bigbattenberg
      @bigbattenberg 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@BB-nq1ps Did not make it worse but the 'bird'dog' was what did the trick for me. I am doing both on an almost daily basis and have not had any problems since. Also my running has been feeling quite good.

  • @WaltLQ
    @WaltLQ 3 года назад +32

    I must say again that your form is one of the best I've seen on youtube for the McGill Big 3.

    • @Gazzaroo
      @Gazzaroo 2 года назад +2

      I concur. Brian Carroll also v good and Mcgill certified

  • @bigbattenberg
    @bigbattenberg 10 месяцев назад +1

    Actually a back pain flare-up two days ago was quickly fixed with the 'bird-dog' exercise, thanks. The diagonal movement pattern being able also to really stretch out feels great and will have to not ever forget to do these exercises regularly from now on!

  • @dr.yitzchackgaryfreemanthe9349
    @dr.yitzchackgaryfreemanthe9349 7 месяцев назад

    On the BirdDog, McGill recemmends against Abdominal Bracing, I think.
    For the SideBridge, with most people, I recommend they put thier head on a chair and hold onto something behind them (window sill, chair, table, shelf) to spare their shoulders. If they are a boxer, a supermarket shelf stocker or other who has strong shoulder, I skip that, but most others I am very careful.

  • @MichaelThomas-qx7fq
    @MichaelThomas-qx7fq 2 года назад +14

    Fantastic video and probably the simplist to follow I've seen! What sort of frequency would you recommend? Daily for a month and re-measure back pain or?

    • @edmontonwestprimarycarenet6583
      @edmontonwestprimarycarenet6583  2 года назад +13

      These exercises are great to incorporate into a daily routine for a back pained person. Even if your back pain resolves, I would suggest continuing with these exercises most days, or at least 3x/week to maintain core strength and endurance and to help prevent future bouts of back pain.

  • @danteaguefitness5663
    @danteaguefitness5663 2 года назад +3

    Great tutorial. Thank you.

  • @roberthepps6020
    @roberthepps6020 5 месяцев назад +1

    Excellent, thank you!

  • @evertonresende8664
    @evertonresende8664 6 месяцев назад +1

    Great vídeo!
    Thank you

  • @claudiomarticorena5298
    @claudiomarticorena5298 6 месяцев назад +2

    Hey looking forward to trying this out. Just for a reference point or starting point. About how many reps/sets/rounds should be done with each excercise? Sorry, Not trying to sound like a gym bro just curious as to what should be sufficient. Or is it more you should go to about 80% of when you feel tired and would lose posture. Anything would help. Thank you

  • @WaltLQ
    @WaltLQ 3 года назад +22

    Great form yet missing some info. Stu says that for the bird-dog you first do a cat-camel, about 8 times and not to the end range and find a neutral spine position and perform the bird dog. Second, the side plank should be held for no longer than 10 seconds. You can perform more reps (8-10 second holds), but do not increase the seconds.

    • @josephlopez5065
      @josephlopez5065 2 года назад +1

      Cat camel before the bird dog?

    • @edmontonwestprimarycarenet6583
      @edmontonwestprimarycarenet6583  2 года назад +27

      We did the 4 day course with Stu, and there was no mention of "having" to do a cat-camel pre- Bird Dog. Rather I think both are useful, and can be done in any order. The Cat-Camel helps with mobility and positions of relief, where the bird-dog focuses on stability and strength. I think you may also be confusing the 10 second hold. The bird dog is to be held for no longer than 10 seconds in a back pained patient (other populations longer holds are okay), but the side plank can be held until form failure.

    • @WaltLQ
      @WaltLQ 2 года назад +3

      @@josephlopez5065 in a video on RUclips Stu demonstrates doing the cat-camel to find a neutral position and use that as the basis to begin your bird-dog.

    • @WaltLQ
      @WaltLQ 2 года назад +3

      @@edmontonwestprimarycarenet6583 I see, I see. Also good thing your reply stated it. Because in the video you said to hold as long as you could. If a back-pained individual saw this instructional video and held it for "as long as they can" they could worsen their pain. Right or wrong? There was no differentiation in your instruction.

    • @WaltLQ
      @WaltLQ 2 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/NA1Ve7FWqTY/видео.html
      2 min 45 sec mark

  • @nikolaj781
    @nikolaj781 Год назад +1

    Thnks for instructions

  • @mnchester
    @mnchester 9 месяцев назад +1

    Great video! 😀

  • @goodhtamh
    @goodhtamh 2 года назад +1

    thank you very much

  • @Noneya777
    @Noneya777 2 месяца назад +1

    Shouldn't the back leg go a bit higher on the bird dogs? Nearly in line with alternative arm?

  • @sovcast8760
    @sovcast8760 Год назад +2

    I've always heard the Bird dog referred to as the half Superman.

  • @neurore-crear
    @neurore-crear 8 месяцев назад

    Genial tu video, sólo te agradecería que hablaras un poco más lento para entender muy bien las explicaciones que indicas. Hablo español, sin embargo, entiendo muy bien inglés siempre que sea hablado más lento y bien modulado. Saludos desde Chile.

  • @Moogie777
    @Moogie777 2 года назад +7

    Hey, thank you for mentioning rotator cuff injuries! Where can I find the standing version of the side plank?

    • @Sh0n0
      @Sh0n0 2 года назад

      Hello allison my love

  • @juliekane7210
    @juliekane7210 2 года назад +6

    What plank is easier if we are having low back pain? My lower back seems like it’s always tight & sore

  • @i08dragons
    @i08dragons 2 года назад +51

    "Bird dogs" are breeds of dogs used for hunting birds. When they find a bird that's been shot, they "point" at it. I think that's where the name comes from.

    • @jamesjafari7353
      @jamesjafari7353 7 месяцев назад +6

      The bird dog points to where the live birds are. Said bird dog then retrieves shot birds.

    • @spankey88
      @spankey88 6 месяцев назад +2

      That’s what I was going to say. Obviously comes from a bird dog pointing

  • @littlebeebs1
    @littlebeebs1 5 месяцев назад

    Great explanation! Thank you !Is it safe for these to be done when in pain ? Or is this just for after the pain is gone ? I have pain in my sacrum from a desiccated l5 s1 disc . The pain is starting to travel down my legs and butt . Hopefully it helps me instead of making it worse .

  • @bigbattenberg
    @bigbattenberg Год назад +5

    The McGill crunch is especially killing muscles in my neck or rather throat area. Quite interesting to see how this progresses. The other two exercises are great and I will incorporate them. Do you have any tips for example on how many 3-10 second holds should be done? And if the side plank is done to failure on both sides, should I try again for 90 seconds? Or move on tp the harder version? (which I cannot do for 90 seconds).

    • @davidzamora9973
      @davidzamora9973 Год назад +4

      Hi. The video The 3 Best Core Exercises from Squat University addresses this neck issue directly when he talks about the McGill crunch/curl up. The video is also about the McGill Big 3. Hope it helps.

  • @wayne7071
    @wayne7071 2 года назад +4

    Hi thank you for sharing professor McGill big 3. Does this help to stabilise your back if you have a S1 protrusion?

  • @theflopdoodlechloebeantric1602
    @theflopdoodlechloebeantric1602 11 месяцев назад +1

    Question: I liked what you said about both knees up vs both legs down vs one knee up. I have a lot of pain sleeping. I was told to put a pillow under my knees. Based on what you say here, could it be better to put a pillow under just ONE knee for sleeping?

  • @SamLangPlus
    @SamLangPlus 7 месяцев назад

    I have the opposite back curving behavior of what you described. Large curve with legs bent. No curve with legs straight. Does that mean something?

  • @KarenBeckerPhoto
    @KarenBeckerPhoto 3 месяца назад

    I cannot get on my knees to do bird dog (bad knees that need replacing) so is there an alternative that is just as effective? thx

  • @chamboyette853
    @chamboyette853 Год назад +2

    Can you do this on a soft mattress?

  • @NikolaTeslaEE
    @NikolaTeslaEE 2 года назад +4

    Great video. Sets? Reps? Hold times?

    • @StephanBendallEng
      @StephanBendallEng 6 месяцев назад +3

      McGill recommends using 6, then 4, then 2 reps with 30 second breaks. He doesn't recommend holding the plank for as long as you can but doing it for 10 seconds as each rep.

  • @justinsperanza3673
    @justinsperanza3673 2 года назад

    Or is the point to work the thoracic spine and just the upper and mid abs? If you were to do a full crunch, would you brace your abdominals in a 360 fashion?

  • @dieterheinrich8377
    @dieterheinrich8377 9 месяцев назад +1

    The video doesn't say how many reps and sets. Also, how do they work to relieve pain, and which kind of back pain? A link to the video for "squeezing the belly" would be helpful too. Good, apart from that. Thanks.

  • @particles343
    @particles343 2 года назад +6

    I have sciatica running down my left leg It sucks to be in your 30's with this.

    • @sagebauer1077
      @sagebauer1077 2 года назад +3

      Consider yourself lucky, I have it in my 20s! Lol

    • @leadinglist1533
      @leadinglist1533 2 года назад +1

      @@sagebauer1077 me too man

    • @sagebauer1077
      @sagebauer1077 2 года назад +1

      @@leadinglist1533 take the PT seriously! Mine has been sloooowly improving

  • @lemon_crochet
    @lemon_crochet 2 года назад +1

    Great video. What's your suggestion for someone with an injured knee that hurts when doing bird/dog and cat/camel?

    • @danieldeleon5216
      @danieldeleon5216 Год назад +1

      try putting a pillow or rolled up yoga mat under your knees. when lowering to and getting up from the floor try squatting down to your butt and then slowly rolling over to your knees

  • @mammograph
    @mammograph 2 года назад +5

    I always thought it was called a bird dog because dogs bread for bird hunting do a position similar to this to signal to where the bird is

  • @tinjelic2848
    @tinjelic2848 Год назад

    Could you do these for chronic pelvic syndrom ? Thank you for answering

  • @Blue_Dun
    @Blue_Dun 3 года назад +2

    Can one eventually work up to using ankle weights around wrists and ankles when doing bird dog?

  • @davidkollar3459
    @davidkollar3459 2 года назад

    Are These Excersises Safe For Cervical Herniations as well?

  • @nephihernandez7943
    @nephihernandez7943 2 года назад

    Could this fix a lateral pelvic tilt? Anybody know?

  • @davidkollar3459
    @davidkollar3459 2 года назад

    I currently have Instability in L4-5 my PT has told me. He reccomended tehse excerises, do you think i should wait before doing them. ?or do them if i feel no pain during? and how many sets / reps?

  • @johngoh767
    @johngoh767 3 года назад +2

    Can an elderly man do the 3 core exercises? If not what's the alternatives?

    • @senioramericastrong4762
      @senioramericastrong4762 3 года назад +1

      John, this falls under the “it depends” category. There are modifications to the bird dog and side plank. If you aren’t able to support yourself on one arm in the bird dog, work on just the hip/knee extension. Or you can support yourself with a stability ball. This is a short answer, that requires a long answer.

    • @edmontonwestprimarycarenet6583
      @edmontonwestprimarycarenet6583  2 года назад +2

      There is no reason you can't do these 3 core exercises as long as your ability level allows. If not, you could also try our standing core exercise video on the same RUclips channel for easier alternatives.

  • @Immortalsoul669
    @Immortalsoul669 Год назад

    You don't wanna keep your back "flat". You want a neutral spine with natural curv

  • @justinsperanza3673
    @justinsperanza3673 2 года назад

    Question, with abdominal "bracing", aren't you supposed to push the air 360 degrees? So during the curl-up exercise why wouldn't you want to do this? For instance, while squatting or heavier lifts you would be bracing in the front and back part of your core so why wouldn't you want to utilize this for the curl up?

    • @TheCraydee
      @TheCraydee 2 года назад

      True, but I don’t think this guy is squatting heavy

  • @paulgeorge9228
    @paulgeorge9228 Год назад

    what does the arch n curl work on?

  • @Matt-ov1qp
    @Matt-ov1qp 2 года назад

    what's a standing option for the side plank?

    • @Sh0n0
      @Sh0n0 2 года назад

      Eliud kipchoge

  • @gladysma308
    @gladysma308 Год назад +1

    Standing version:.
    ruclips.net/video/77j8WBFxaAc/видео.html

  • @remiwulff8979
    @remiwulff8979 5 месяцев назад

    Hold for 3-10 seconds, BUT how many times? 10 each side? Thanks.

    • @mr.hughes5808
      @mr.hughes5808 5 месяцев назад

      3x each side 10 seconds.. beyond 10 seconds has been shown to be less effective

    • @stevethecat9194
      @stevethecat9194 5 месяцев назад

      I use a timer app and I cycle through an exercise circuit. 40 sec on and 20 sec off. I start with dead bug/bicycle, then the crunch he shows, then regular plank, then side plank each side, then superman, then cobra pose, finishing with birddog. I repeat this twice.

  • @pudjanursalim3500
    @pudjanursalim3500 2 года назад

    I cant see the demo. Hidden with the black screen

  • @nexxyyy1
    @nexxyyy1 2 года назад +1

    What are your thoughts on bird dogs?

  • @John-78
    @John-78 2 года назад

    Does the order matter? You chose a different order of exercises than other people who make youtube videos on McGill's big 3...

    • @exercisespecialist-primary7111
      @exercisespecialist-primary7111 2 года назад

      Not that I am aware of! Order does matter in more complicated lifting sessions but for these I think you'd be good in any order