I wanted to give Kang Minji and Lee Hayoung both B's because they didn't have the best dance but I rmr on PD101 they sometimes wanted to have "strong vocals" in A class or whatever class and A class didn't have enough based on my grading. If re-evalutated (like how they did with Black Mamba, they both failed, so likely in PD101, they would have dropped down.
i think you shouldn’t really judge based on whether the door opened or not for example for river stage, the mentors were amazed by their performances however because the audience were blind the door didn’t open. in my opinion eunwoo and yerim did very well and definitely deserve an A
Honestly all the trainees ranked C+ here have so much debut potential even some of the D ranks like all the girls on this show are all so amazing and talented! I’m still salty that no one from 3rd grade got through since that was my favourite grade and I watched every single clip of them :( Like Yerim, Inhye, Hyunhee, Taerim and Seonyou were my favs from the start and surprisingly only one of them made it. Love the line up tho stan classy!
3:23 If i were the one to rank, i would actually rank Seojin a D, and not an F because her high notes are quite pleasing to hear (imo), but Yeseo with the offtune and offbeat singing tho...
Song Yerim was my favorite. So sad she got eliminated. Her vocals were top notch, her dance was crazy good and she had great stage precance. She still didn't get praised or as much attention as some other trainees who didn't even do half as good as her and I'm almost certain that's because she was chubbier than other trainees. Seriously, such a huge loss. She deserved better.
Oh I was shock that you put jimin in the B grade but after watching it I REALLY ARGEE WITH YOU her facial expressions was not as relax as hyolin because of the high note and in term of dancing she did kinda ok but I enjoy hyolin clean movement and facial expressions more
Idk why you gave Cho Yeju a C but she couldnt dance during that performance bc she had an injury. She can dance really well (you should have seen their practice) but it was really a shame she could only sing during the audition. She was my main pick too :'( I hope she recovered now.
I weirdly agree with this. From my point of view, I wouldn't give Kim Hari an A although she got 3 votes from the judges. She would get a C from me, because of the lack of "star quality". You can do well on stage, but drawing the viewers attention and at the same time represent your "unique spirit" is just as important. That's also why I agree with you giving Yunseo an A. She lacks dance technique but her aura and energy make up for it.
Ok I see a lot of people say that river team deserve an A but based on the vocal they will get a B or C and the dancing yewon get an A and the eanwoo will get a C
Not gonna lie they both deserved a B at best, they were definitely better than a lot of girls that had their doors opened but that song was out of eunwoos vocal range, especially the "shut your mouth baby stand and deliver" part, she switches to a higher register and strains through it, and although with an impressive amount of control, it certainly lacks professional technique. Neither of them "performed at their best" is what I'm trying to say; a different song could've benefited them more (although the audience is definitely blind and deaf)
My opinion: Song Yerim: A Kang Eunwoo: A - B Takei Karina: B Fukomoto Hina: B - C Choi Soobin: A Kim Subeen: A - B Kim Suhye: A Ryou Jayhyun: A - B Kim Lina: C Park Hyolim: C Kim Minsol: B - C Kim Jiyeon: C Won Jimin: A - B Kim Minjoo: C - D Lee Mihee: A Hong Hyeju: A - B Kim Dasom: B - C Koo Hyunkyung: A Choi Yunju: D Ko Eunchae: B - C Park Yoora: A - B Cho Sui: B Pak Jinhyun: C - D Kim Nahyun: B Lee Sumin: B Park Haneum: B - C Lee Hayoung: A - B Kang Minji: B Cho Eun: A - B
7:15 I think Sumin need to get a C although she was not chosen by the judge but I think her vocal was good and her dancing….eee kinda sloppy but atleast a C for me
@@shanadan5876 there is some girls like mihee yerim soobin seungju yongchae hye ju .... That are also A tier girls but she gave them B bc of some reasons
@@diveclikey6504 Mihee, Hyeju - Nasal/pitchy vocals but overall amazing performance (best performance) Seungju Minchae - Very good but they are too young and could use some more training to be the best (almost like CNC in pd 48) Choi Soobin - Mentors gave 3/4 rating compared to kim subeen 4/4. same reason as seungju. she’s great but training could make her great. kim subeen gets A because talent and star power, she might go down in “revaluation”
And 9:43 ehhh both get a C for me their dancing WERE AMAZING but the rap is just messy and I khow the song is very hard to sing live but I think they shouldn’t choose that song for an audition(or maybe the producer choose the song)
A good chunk of the rankings I agreed, but Yooyeon getting F doesnt make sense lol especially with some of the other girls like Siyul and Yuju getting a C and D like Yooyeon definitely is more D or at least C compared with those girls
little late but siyul deserved a d or even an f because how weak she sounded in so many notes, also personally i think jungyun and minsol did a lot better then sara, id keep sara in c and move minsol to c and jungyun b
@@eggsnhashbrowns Yes, but yet she did decent enough to get a D/C Her only really bad perfomance was Leon, the rest were very ok and her last episode perfomances were actually good, she is definitely not deserving an F
@@linapetrova7284 yeah but you’re saying that because she hasn’t been trained that much. she lacked performing skills and we can’t just say it was okay for someone who’s never done this before. thats unfair to every other contestant ☠️☠️
@@eggsnhashbrowns yes we can gurl, every other girls did very high, like b or a deserved, the onces from c to lower were definitely weak contestants, so its okay
@@KPOPTrashLyrics I agree for LokixD because they did amazing, but people don't want this powerful concept, so they don't pass 1st stage. So, I will give both A.
You gave Yooyeon an F? I really liked her during the entrance exam, but then she kinda faded away afterwards. Personally I would've given her a C for the entrance exam
The narrative of the trainers led my decision as well. She was outshined by the other two and also all trainers said she lost her spark and only soyeon voted for her. she kinda reminds me of jung chaeyeon (ioi dia) on pd101 when she did good girl bad girl and she got a C so ig Yooyeon would be a C in that light
@@KPOPTrashLyrics Yeah, her 2 teammates definitely outshined her, she didn't do amazingly, but she did a pretty average job. I haven't watched any of the produce series so I don't know how they rated them or anything
Seungju is A in my opinion And wei Yi is F in my opinion Park hyewon is A in my opinion Lee jiwoo is B in my opinion Kang eunwoo is A in my opinion Kim seojin is D in my opinion and yeseo is....Lol if there was an eliminate in the beginning like mtg she will be the first to be eliminated And kim jiyeon is C or D in my opinion . She totally disappointed me And lee siyul is D in my opinion Oh yoojin is A Kim minjoo is B in my opinion Cho yeju is B or A in my opinion bcz for me vocals>dance And friends team is all A in my opinion And as i told you team inhye and yumin is B and taehui and dasom is A in my opinion And bang sunhee is C in my opinion And jung yuju is f in my opinion 'she will surely get higher bcz she slayed hot sauce and la vie in rose' And Ko eunchae is B in my opinion And yoora is A and sui is B in my opinion And nahyun is C in my opinion . I don't rlly like her tone but she did soo well And lee sumin is A in my opinion . She slayed her tone is just wow . This perf is on my list And haneum is B in my opinion . She lacks something in her perf but she is cute and i like her Accent And eun + sujin is A and juan is B in my opinion Jaye is def A in my opinion . She slayed
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
I wanted to give Kang Minji and Lee Hayoung both B's because they didn't have the best dance but I rmr on PD101 they sometimes wanted to have "strong vocals" in A class or whatever class and A class didn't have enough based on my grading. If re-evalutated (like how they did with Black Mamba, they both failed, so likely in PD101, they would have dropped down.
Can you explain why suyeon got D? I think she should get B
@@kkaenjixox She got only 2 votes, she was a bit dull
@@KPOPTrashLyrics as in facial expressions dull?
@@kkaenjixox yes and performance
Crazy how 5 members of classy got a and the other 2 got b. The group is full of talented members!
exactly!!!
Ikr
i think you shouldn’t really judge based on whether the door opened or not
for example for river stage, the mentors were amazed by their performances however because the audience were blind the door didn’t open. in my opinion eunwoo and yerim did very well and definitely deserve an A
True! im happy the trainers advocated for them. I used that as a factor to judge “star quality” and that was a test.
@@KPOPTrashLyrics I don't really think opening doors had much to do with star quality. It had more to do with the looks of the girls
@@juliaqian6480 Thats the outcome of the voters - sadly they were very looks biased and unfortunately thats how the kpop industry is.
when the door opened for the nonstop team... mannnnnnnn voters were wrong for that.
yes but the stage was not that great for 2 A
idk what the judges were thinking by giving jiwoo more votes than yunseo 😭😭 i don’t get it, jiwoo did good, of course, but yunseo is just >>>
i agree :(
Both deserve 4 votes
True, I'm still wondering what more did they want from her
10:08 Choi Sarang being robbed lmao if only her audition was aired, she would have many supporters. She is so good.
ik im so mad
Honestly all the trainees ranked C+ here have so much debut potential even some of the D ranks like all the girls on this show are all so amazing and talented! I’m still salty that no one from 3rd grade got through since that was my favourite grade and I watched every single clip of them :( Like Yerim, Inhye, Hyunhee, Taerim and Seonyou were my favs from the start and surprisingly only one of them made it. Love the line up tho stan classy!
3 graders were all rounders the got robbed
@@KPOPTrashLyrics exactly 😭 couldn’t Mbc debut a 30 member girl group?/j
@@snowyloona354 AHAHAHAH
@@snowyloona354 Like NCT?..
This show has so many talented trainees I cant believe MBC chose to debut only 7!!
personally I don’t think Yooyeon would get a F if she were in PD series. She’ll get at least C or D. MTG’s standard are so high
3:23 If i were the one to rank, i would actually rank Seojin a D, and not an F because her high notes are quite pleasing to hear (imo), but Yeseo with the offtune and offbeat singing tho...
yesss seojin was a lot better
Song Yerim was my favorite. So sad she got eliminated. Her vocals were top notch, her dance was crazy good and she had great stage precance. She still didn't get praised or as much attention as some other trainees who didn't even do half as good as her and I'm almost certain that's because she was chubbier than other trainees. Seriously, such a huge loss. She deserved better.
survival shows are the best and worst thing
3:34
Honestly think that Kim seojin has the potential but the other one.....
kick it is funny cus its inspired by youngeun and jias iconic preformance on gp999 and the grading is quite similar
Justice for Birthday team, they did well than some of the ones that the audience chose to let the door open for
Oh I was shock that you put jimin in the B grade but after watching it I REALLY ARGEE WITH YOU her facial expressions was not as relax as hyolin because of the high note and in term of dancing she did kinda ok but I enjoy hyolin clean movement and facial expressions more
Thank u!! I think she did good at dancing but it seemed she was just screaming into the mic sometimes
Idk why you gave Cho Yeju a C but she couldnt dance during that performance bc she had an injury. She can dance really well (you should have seen their practice) but it was really a shame she could only sing during the audition. She was my main pick too :'( I hope she recovered now.
i personally feel its valid enough as some participants like goto moe was given an f bc she wasn't able to sing bc of her allergies
In produce 48, they gave goto moe an f because she only danced due to her pollen allergy, it's done to be fair to other trainees
I weirdly agree with this.
From my point of view, I wouldn't give Kim Hari an A although she got 3 votes from the judges. She would get a C from me, because of the lack of "star quality".
You can do well on stage, but drawing the viewers attention and at the same time represent your "unique spirit" is just as important.
That's also why I agree with you giving Yunseo an A. She lacks dance technique but her aura and energy make up for it.
Very true. I has trouble with Hari. She really blew me out of the water w her deep vocal, stage prescence and confidence, I think B is better
youngchae is an A for me
when you watch it you realise that how audience wasted 3rd graders' talent.. like almost all of them are allrounders
the contestants in mtg are full of talent🔥
Ok I see a lot of people say that river team deserve an A but based on the vocal they will get a B or C and the dancing yewon get an A and the eanwoo will get a C
I MEAN YERIM AND EUNWOO
Ugh I keep forgetting their names
So she made the right choice for yerim and eunwoo to get a C and a B
Both yerim and eunwoo are A...their performance are the best....
Not gonna lie they both deserved a B at best, they were definitely better than a lot of girls that had their doors opened but that song was out of eunwoos vocal range, especially the "shut your mouth baby stand and deliver" part, she switches to a higher register and strains through it, and although with an impressive amount of control, it certainly lacks professional technique. Neither of them "performed at their best" is what I'm trying to say; a different song could've benefited them more (although the audience is definitely blind and deaf)
My opinion:
Song Yerim: A
Kang Eunwoo: A - B
Takei Karina: B
Fukomoto Hina: B - C
Choi Soobin: A
Kim Subeen: A - B
Kim Suhye: A
Ryou Jayhyun: A - B
Kim Lina: C
Park Hyolim: C
Kim Minsol: B - C
Kim Jiyeon: C
Won Jimin: A - B
Kim Minjoo: C - D
Lee Mihee: A
Hong Hyeju: A - B
Kim Dasom: B - C
Koo Hyunkyung: A
Choi Yunju: D
Ko Eunchae: B - C
Park Yoora: A - B
Cho Sui: B
Pak Jinhyun: C - D
Kim Nahyun: B
Lee Sumin: B
Park Haneum: B - C
Lee Hayoung: A - B
Kang Minji: B
Cho Eun: A - B
Oooooo LOVE it I rlly agree with many in ur list
한음이 하늘으로 번역되었습니다..
@@eun_se0드라이파크도...........
Cho Eun deserves better
but she lose I'm gonna cry 😭
TY for giving her B ❤️❤️
helicopter - slay-l-slay 😆😆
AAHAHAHAH YOU NOTICED IT
I really wanted yooyeon to debuet but now she might debute in another group and have more fun
3:35 i think Seojin was not so bad, maybe a D
Yerim deserves an A
I think Chi Yeju is an F because in PRODUCE 48 it was almost the same situation: Goto Moe didn’t sing and she got an F
Ahhh. I think that yeju’s singing was rlly good therefore C. With Moe, her dance was okay but i think a D wouldve been better for uer
Which one is she?
@@sharis-en3qoCrazy performance, sitting on table
Slay-L-Slay😭😭
Isn't there a team from Genie who made their debut? their vocals are really strong
None
I don’t understand why the Gotta Go team didn’t pass, they did rlly good
stiff dance and weak vocals. yujeong had
good star ability but weak vocals and dance
They did bad except for bang sunhee she was good if she hit that highnote she could've passed
love how at 9:34 they put "slay-L-slay"
:))))
i’m my opinion hyeju and mihee are both a
7:15 I think Sumin need to get a C although she was not chosen by the judge but I think her vocal was good and her dancing….eee kinda sloppy but atleast a C for me
I mean yumin
3:38 NOT F, A THE BEST FRR
jkjk 😂😂😂
Lee Jaye deserves more love😕
ikr :(
Total of
21 A
19 B
18 C
15 D
10 F
The most is a . This shows how talented the trainees in this show is .
@@shanadan5876 there is some girls like mihee yerim soobin seungju yongchae hye ju .... That are also A tier girls but she gave them B bc of some reasons
@@diveclikey6504 Mihee, Hyeju - Nasal/pitchy vocals but overall amazing performance (best performance)
Seungju Minchae - Very good but they are too young and could use some more training to be the best (almost like CNC in pd 48)
Choi Soobin - Mentors gave 3/4 rating compared to kim subeen 4/4. same reason as seungju. she’s great but training could make her great. kim subeen gets A because talent and star power, she might go down in “revaluation”
how did the FRIENDS performance get Bs. they ATE
then, all 3rd graders disappeared... ╥﹏╥
And 9:43 ehhh both get a C for me their dancing WERE AMAZING but the rap is just messy and I khow the song is very hard to sing live but I think they shouldn’t choose that song for an audition(or maybe the producer choose the song)
And it sounds like they were screaming
i think maybe i was biased for seonyu but ppl / judges received it well and yeah it was a bit messy
A good chunk of the rankings I agreed, but Yooyeon getting F doesnt make sense lol especially with some of the other girls like Siyul and Yuju getting a C and D like Yooyeon definitely is more D or at least C compared with those girls
little late but siyul deserved a d or even an f because how weak she sounded in so many notes, also personally i think jungyun and minsol did a lot better then sara, id keep sara in c and move minsol to c and jungyun b
I was so sad kim hyunhee and oh jieun didn't debute
Also Yooyeon F?? I think she is at least a D, maybe a C
(no hate) yooyeon in the beginning compared to everyone else wasn’t good and didn’t get a pass from the judges, probably why she was F
@@eggsnhashbrowns Yes, but yet she did decent enough to get a D/C
Her only really bad perfomance was Leon, the rest were very ok and her last episode perfomances were actually good, she is definitely not deserving an F
@@linapetrova7284 yeah but you’re saying that because she hasn’t been trained that much. she lacked performing skills and we can’t just say it was okay for someone who’s never done this before. thats unfair to every other contestant ☠️☠️
@@eggsnhashbrowns yes we can gurl, every other girls did very high, like b or a deserved, the onces from c to lower were definitely weak contestants, so its okay
lee jaye deserved better😭💗
(not from you, from the judges)
I KNOWWWW
Song Yerim and Kang Eunwoo = B and C ??
W.T.F
Is A!!
It’s because their door didn’t open
@@KPOPTrashLyrics Only because the voter weren't voting by talent just by visual
@@KPOPTrashLyrics I agree for LokixD because they did amazing, but people don't want this powerful concept, so they don't pass 1st stage. So, I will give both A.
mihee was an A she was the ace of this program
Koo hyunkyoung was still robbed..
Mihee & Youngchae were As imo
You gave Yooyeon an F? I really liked her during the entrance exam, but then she kinda faded away afterwards. Personally I would've given her a C for the entrance exam
The narrative of the trainers led my decision as well. She was outshined by the other two and also all trainers said she lost her spark and only soyeon voted for her. she kinda reminds me of jung chaeyeon (ioi dia) on pd101 when she did good girl bad girl and she got a C so ig Yooyeon would be a C in that light
@@KPOPTrashLyrics Yeah, her 2 teammates definitely outshined her, she didn't do amazingly, but she did a pretty average job. I haven't watched any of the produce series so I don't know how they rated them or anything
ju hyorin was robbed, REALLY robbed, she deserved that debut with jimin
I KNOW..
did she make it far in the competition?
@@tsuyuasui7297 no:( she was eliminated during round 2 i think
How did jiyeon pass but didn’t have another stage?
Only 10 of those ppl who passed has another stage
10:59 why never saw her before 😭
Barely any screen time and didn’t make it in pretty savage stage
I know right I wanted to see her she is really good!
I have a question. Students who did not appear on the show How do you know that 4 teachers have chosen you?
On wikipedia
No offense or anything, but I don't think you should judge by if door opened or not. SO many trainees deserved A's or higher ratings than they got.
2:56 JIWOO? C????
3:18 YERIM EUNWOO??M
Why hari is a? I think b
Very true. I has trouble with Hari. She really blew me out of the water w her deep vocal, stage prescence and confidence, I think B is better
How did you know the votes that girls got from the 4 teachers?
its shown on the show but i got it all from wikipedia
Oh Jinkyoung, F?
nasall vocal, did not stand out, unstable dancing
@@KPOPTrashLyrics Honestly, I think Jinkyoung did way better than Jiwon. I mean I really don't understand why Jiwon went that far.
@@sss91597although im Jiwon biased but why she is the one that got revival pass instead of Kim Sujin or Cho Eun
Why all trainee's voice sounds like robot?
autotune
I thought Jimin did better than hyorin 7:08
All my picks are A ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
And Yes … not have who debut
I'm laughing at slay-L-slay😭😭
OMG KİM JİYEON İS PERFECT SHE İS MY BİAS İN MY TEENAGE GİRL AND BE WAVE
Kim yooyeon deserve a c in mu opinion and karina ia b with hina
My*
Is*
Why did Jung Siwoo Get a B?
i based it on her getting only 3
and I felt wrong giving both 1st grade both A’s and boeun outshined her. She would prob get A in re evaluation
@@KPOPTrashLyrics yeah boeun outshined her bc they obviously put all the attention on her
@@patrykpop survival show narratives 😭😭😭😭😭😭
@hello her performance in adios 😍
Nonstop girls getting Fs are unsurprising to say the least. No offend to the girls but they need more training
Yoojin was not really give a chance to sing
Park Yoora is definitely an A
Seungju is A in my opinion
And wei Yi is F in my opinion
Park hyewon is A in my opinion
Lee jiwoo is B in my opinion
Kang eunwoo is A in my opinion
Kim seojin is D in my opinion and yeseo is....Lol if there was an eliminate in the beginning like mtg she will be the first to be eliminated
And kim jiyeon is C or D in my opinion . She totally disappointed me
And lee siyul is D in my opinion
Oh yoojin is A Kim minjoo is B in my opinion
Cho yeju is B or A in my opinion bcz for me vocals>dance
And friends team is all A in my opinion
And as i told you team inhye and yumin is B and taehui and dasom is A in my opinion
And bang sunhee is C in my opinion
And jung yuju is f in my opinion 'she will surely get higher bcz she slayed hot sauce and la vie in rose'
And Ko eunchae is B in my opinion
And yoora is A and sui is B in my opinion
And nahyun is C in my opinion . I don't rlly like her tone but she did soo well
And lee sumin is A in my opinion . She slayed her tone is just wow . This perf is on my list
And haneum is B in my opinion . She lacks something in her perf but she is cute and i like her Accent
And eun + sujin is A and juan is B in my opinion
Jaye is def A in my opinion . She slayed
OOOO I LIKE UR RATINGS
Sujin Deserve Better 💗💗💗
Kim lina B my opinion
I think bang sunhee could be a C
Lee mihee deserve A
Jaye was robbed
Why jioo c?
Weak vocals and not much stage presence
@@KPOPTrashLyrics but c is very low
@@user-so2kt6ms1s She might be B but she’s very mediocre
@@KPOPTrashLyrics what?
@@KPOPTrashLyrics I really don’t understand
5:53
6:19
3:46 YOOYEON F???your crazy
김수빈이 A??? ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
slay
Why are you making a video like this?
for fun!
@@KPOPTrashLyrics ok.so Why did you put the word trash in your nickname?
나만 이영상 불편하나?
7:21