the thing i liked about seoyeon is how her lack of a lot of stuff didnt scare her if that makes sense?? like she was Definitely yoloing/idgaf but she didnt go on terrified because she was a new idol, she had fun and that makes me respect her idk i definitely think shes gonna improve
Elly and Juri's up/down score are such bullshit. I wonder why the others were at their throats like that. Elly especially, cause she literally kicked off the show with one of the best performances.
I think Suyun should have gotten an A because I personally don’t think Taemin sounds very good on that song either, but she sounded just as good a him, and Juri’s performance was good, but I don’t think it was as good as Suyun’s, so I don’t think they should have the same ranking. Just my personal opinion
I feel like if only Wooyeon tried to hit those high notes and nailed them, she's probably part of the final group now. But regardless of what happened, she got complimented by Taeyeon which was already a win. It takes some guts and high vocal control to not fail those high notes esp singing in front of the original singer, who, nonetheless, was someone you look up to. For me, she has the most growth in the show out of everyone else. From this person, who wasn't confident that she could nail it, to the person who nailed her high notes in Wannabe and even showcased her lower registers in the final stage with Billionaire. From one of the lowest to being in the Top 9 is already an achievement.
Like I love rina (my 2nd bias in h-1key cause of pd48) but likeee I’d give her a d cause pd101 judges are more strict about voice cracks. But besides that I think she would get a b (i literally love her perf, but it was the shame about the voice crack)
ur reasoning and logic makes sense too. i think in pd48, when she was a contestant she got a B and her pop performance was obv way better, but that was when she was a trainee
Fun idea! Nice ratings, but I disagreed slightly on some of them 😅so I'm gonna do it too and pretend I'm a Queendom Puzzle 101 Judge.....LMAO... Dohwa - D Zoa - C Jiwoo - D Jiwon - B Suyun - A Nana - B Chaeyeon - B Fye - C Riina - B Jihan - B Wooyeon - D Yeoreum - A Bora - A Juri - B Yeonhee - A Soeun - B Soojin - C Seoyeon - F Miru - C Yuki - C Sangah - D Yeeun - B Haein - C Chaerin - F Elly - A JooE - F Hwiseo - A Kei - A 3 F's, 4 D's, 6 C's, 8 B's, and 7 A's!
yeah Suyun is A she's so strong and brave to cover Advice and made her own version and that highnotes it's not shouting though, she is just like that cause she can highnote fr cause she's main vocal in their group. Plus her dancing is so good. Elly too should be A.
jihan remind me so much of somi in this program... idk, i have that feelings and actually i thought she was going to debut, at least we will have a weeekly comeback soon
Nice grading! I agree with everything here except maybe Miru and Kei I'd give Miru a C, since I actually think she did great, she's stable and her energy was on par too. Major issue was that the stage was very bland and her song choice didn't help that at all. Kei is certainly not an A, I'm sorry, I'd objectively give her a C. The only thing that carried her performance was her vocals. That does not excuse her lip synching, especially since she's one of the most veteran idols here. Second, like Chaeyeon her expressions were also barely visible / not there.
since i stand strong vocal, stability and stage presence, if i were the judge, only 3 people would get an A, bora hwiseo and yeonhee, i would rank other perfect performance at B, usual at C, lipsync performance at D, and if it's failed would be F
For Kei I think it’s fine to lip sync even if it was a bigger chunk. Even if she lipsync’d the whole thing you’d be able to tell her technique would pull her to be one of the best on the show. Lipsync doesn’t allow people to grasp if you’re stable while dancing but imo technique can always make a shaky vocalist alright in my eyes as you’re not always dancing in a kpop group. Sometimes groups will just stand or sit to perform a song and if the dancing is hard enough shakiness will be prevalent.
I believe suyun deserves b and shouldn’t even be considered for c. You have to belt those high notes out if you haven’t had the right training to make it to the note in your head voice. She’s definitely got pipes though. Just needs to refine her range.
for me it was (I'm not cosidering Up/Down votes) A: Bora, Yeonhee, Elly, Hwiseo, Kei B: Jiwon, Suyun, Nana, Chayeon, Riina, Jihan, Yeoreum, Juri, Soeun, Yeeun C: Jiwoo, Fye, Yuki, Sangah D: Dohwa, Zoa, Wooyeon, Soojin, Miru, Haein, JooE F: Seoyeon, Chaerin honestly, Nana and Yeoreum didn't got me like people are saying, for me it was just a Ok stage. Chaeyeon, Wooyeon and Yeeun can do better than that, but here I'm judging especifcally the Up Down Battle. Suyun and Jiwon was really great, but I foudn their stages kinda empty
I would put Kei at B for lipsyncing (also to only have 7 people at A) Yuki at C (for the error), Fye at C for the performance, and sadly put Haein at F. And keep the rest as is
@@KPOPTrashLyrics exactly :( I was most excited for her actually. I remembered how she demolished The Unit with what little lines she get during performances
@@KPOPTrashLyrics I actually see Haein demolishing Nxde, DTNA, Web, Overwater, Weekend. Not sure where she would have been assigned in the semifinal songs
I’d put Kei at B just because I know her vocals are good but for the performance she didn’t go all out not bad but also not A worthy in my opinion so B instead. Miru I’d give a C maybe even B cuz she sang well while dancing and has great stage presence. Haein I’d give and F cuz she didn’t even seem to try? Chaeyeon I’d give a low B or C just cuz she also didn’t seem like she cared and even her dancing was lackluster which she’s known to be one of the best dancers in the industry so.
@@FrostyPlayzYT legit omg so funny seoyeon did get a lot of training she missed from debuting in 1 day kinda like hyeju AND she made it rlly far too so i think this show was a good “bootcamp” for her
Imo Yeoreum is low a worthy as she’s not proficient enough vocally. It’s not very noticeable since her lower range is her comfy range and that’s what she got to perform but I ult wjsn
She was just acting to give the program some fun or something that could left the viewers like “😦”, she knows well mnet and just wanted to cause some drama for the program as a joke, and then Chaeyeon left it like the queen she is.
its actually in the process of being made I'm just super busy rn ahha. there's also a lot of contestants to go thru too so it might take awhile. but do look out for it!
Imo kei deserves B/C, everyone keeps overhyping her when she lipsynced half the performance plus nothing actually stood out in the performance, no high notes or anything
the thing i liked about seoyeon is how her lack of a lot of stuff didnt scare her if that makes sense?? like she was Definitely yoloing/idgaf but she didnt go on terrified because she was a new idol, she had fun and that makes me respect her idk i definitely think shes gonna improve
Rocket Punch Yeonhee & Suyun, Weeekly Soeun and Weki Meki Elly were robbed! They definetely deserved a much higher score during the up/down voting.
im so happy it ended up working for yeonhee :)
seoyeon winning the idgaf war because she still has tripleS as her main group 💀 i love her sm
she was so funny for it and u cant even blame her
Elly and Juri's up/down score are such bullshit. I wonder why the others were at their throats like that. Elly especially, cause she literally kicked off the show with one of the best performances.
That Hwiseo performance was what sold me to H1-KEY. Those 9 long years of training didn't lie.
She was actually preparing to debut solo before joining H1-KEY and it shows
h1-key is coming back in august! please tune in for them!!
what they did to elly was EVIL. the fact that she got so many downvotes made me mad. her stage was arguably one of the best from the show so far..
Hwiseo the only reason i still watch the show but I disagree for giving yeoreum high rank,her vocal doesn't heard as much as others
Wooyeon's performance was heartbreaking. If Taeyeon wasn't there, she would have definitely gotten a B.
Yeah I think she was nervous because performing this song in front of mother Taeyeon😭😭
So EL7Z UP is made up of 6 A graders and 1 B grader
Sorry for my bad english
I think Suyun should have gotten an A because I personally don’t think Taemin sounds very good on that song either, but she sounded just as good a him, and Juri’s performance was good, but I don’t think it was as good as Suyun’s, so I don’t think they should have the same ranking. Just my personal opinion
I feel like if only Wooyeon tried to hit those high notes and nailed them, she's probably part of the final group now. But regardless of what happened, she got complimented by Taeyeon which was already a win. It takes some guts and high vocal control to not fail those high notes esp singing in front of the original singer, who, nonetheless, was someone you look up to. For me, she has the most growth in the show out of everyone else. From this person, who wasn't confident that she could nail it, to the person who nailed her high notes in Wannabe and even showcased her lower registers in the final stage with Billionaire. From one of the lowest to being in the Top 9 is already an achievement.
THIS remind me of why I really hope Bora in final lineup. But now her popurality going doing down every episode. .
Like I love rina (my 2nd bias in h-1key cause of pd48) but likeee I’d give her a d cause pd101 judges are more strict about voice cracks. But besides that I think she would get a b (i literally love her perf, but it was the shame about the voice crack)
ur reasoning and logic makes sense too. i think in pd48, when she was a contestant she got a B and her pop performance was obv way better, but that was when she was a trainee
Fun idea! Nice ratings, but I disagreed slightly on some of them 😅so I'm gonna do it too and pretend I'm a Queendom Puzzle 101 Judge.....LMAO...
Dohwa - D
Zoa - C
Jiwoo - D
Jiwon - B
Suyun - A
Nana - B
Chaeyeon - B
Fye - C
Riina - B
Jihan - B
Wooyeon - D
Yeoreum - A
Bora - A
Juri - B
Yeonhee - A
Soeun - B
Soojin - C
Seoyeon - F
Miru - C
Yuki - C
Sangah - D
Yeeun - B
Haein - C
Chaerin - F
Elly - A
JooE - F
Hwiseo - A
Kei - A
3 F's, 4 D's, 6 C's, 8 B's, and 7 A's!
yeah Suyun is A she's so strong and brave to cover Advice and made her own version and that highnotes it's not shouting though, she is just like that cause she can highnote fr cause she's main vocal in their group. Plus her dancing is so good. Elly too should be A.
Sorry but jooe is clearly D
Her performance was better than most
jihan remind me so much of somi in this program... idk, i have that feelings and actually i thought she was going to debut, at least we will have a weeekly comeback soon
juri ate whyd she get so many downvotes
I miss the produce series... I know that it ruined lives and dreams of teenage girls but, I think that comes with being in a tv show in general.
Nice grading! I agree with everything here except maybe Miru and Kei
I'd give Miru a C, since I actually think she did great, she's stable and her energy was on par too. Major issue was that the stage was very bland and her song choice didn't help that at all.
Kei is certainly not an A, I'm sorry, I'd objectively give her a C. The only thing that carried her performance was her vocals. That does not excuse her lip synching, especially since she's one of the most veteran idols here. Second, like Chaeyeon her expressions were also barely visible / not there.
And if you are not aware kei was singing only her parts and she did it perfectly
Some of the up down scores are so unjustified.
The fact not one but two people downvoted Bora's performance shows some pettiness in the crowd. IDK...
since i stand strong vocal, stability and stage presence, if i were the judge, only 3 people would get an A, bora hwiseo and yeonhee, i would rank other perfect performance at B, usual at C, lipsync performance at D, and if it's failed would be F
For Kei I think it’s fine to lip sync even if it was a bigger chunk. Even if she lipsync’d the whole thing you’d be able to tell her technique would pull her to be one of the best on the show. Lipsync doesn’t allow people to grasp if you’re stable while dancing but imo technique can always make a shaky vocalist alright in my eyes as you’re not always dancing in a kpop group. Sometimes groups will just stand or sit to perform a song and if the dancing is hard enough shakiness will be prevalent.
I believe suyun deserves b and shouldn’t even be considered for c. You have to belt those high notes out if you haven’t had the right training to make it to the note in your head voice. She’s definitely got pipes though. Just needs to refine her range.
seoyeon did not wanna be there. She just wanted to go home and rest.
for me it was (I'm not cosidering Up/Down votes)
A: Bora, Yeonhee, Elly, Hwiseo, Kei
B: Jiwon, Suyun, Nana, Chayeon, Riina, Jihan, Yeoreum, Juri, Soeun, Yeeun
C: Jiwoo, Fye, Yuki, Sangah
D: Dohwa, Zoa, Wooyeon, Soojin, Miru, Haein, JooE
F: Seoyeon, Chaerin
honestly, Nana and Yeoreum didn't got me like people are saying, for me it was just a Ok stage. Chaeyeon, Wooyeon and Yeeun can do better than that, but here I'm judging especifcally the Up Down Battle. Suyun and Jiwon was really great, but I foudn their stages kinda empty
I think this is how I would rate a bit too if it wasnt for up/down! Fair rankiing and i like ur reasoning
wtf was girlie doing 13:43
ik 😭😭😭😭
Jiwon was robbed
Dohwa came back recently to perform Come on guys...
I would give Jiwoo solid A because you can clearly hear her live vocal and how she sounded really stable throughout the performance
i was praying that chaerin would be D not F 😔
You gave an A to 6 out of the 7 that debuted. Good eye.
What a coincidence!!
Chaerin was so nervous
I'd give JoE a F tho
I would put Kei at B for lipsyncing (also to only have 7 people at A) Yuki at C (for the error), Fye at C for the performance, and sadly put Haein at F. And keep the rest as is
Haein was disappointing :(
@@KPOPTrashLyrics exactly :( I was most excited for her actually. I remembered how she demolished The Unit with what little lines she get during performances
@@TheOrangeAce19 I wish she stayed tbh she wouldve been so good in some of the stages
@@KPOPTrashLyrics I actually see Haein demolishing Nxde, DTNA, Web, Overwater, Weekend. Not sure where she would have been assigned in the semifinal songs
@@TheOrangeAce19 YESS web and weekend. i def see her doing overwater too
I’d put Kei at B just because I know her vocals are good but for the performance she didn’t go all out not bad but also not A worthy in my opinion so B instead. Miru I’d give a C maybe even B cuz she sang well while dancing and has great stage presence. Haein I’d give and F cuz she didn’t even seem to try? Chaeyeon I’d give a low B or C just cuz she also didn’t seem like she cared and even her dancing was lackluster which she’s known to be one of the best dancers in the industry so.
11:14 the best contestant on this show end of discussion. those who downvoted her are just mad they could never be anywhere near as talented 🤭
seoyeon had such a idgaf attitude while jiwoo was ijbol'ing her way thru the show 😭
@@FrostyPlayzYT legit omg so funny seoyeon did get a lot of training she missed from debuting in 1 day kinda like hyeju AND she made it rlly far too so i think this show was a good “bootcamp” for her
Aがほとんどデビュー組
Imo Yeoreum is low a worthy as she’s not proficient enough vocally. It’s not very noticeable since her lower range is her comfy range and that’s what she got to perform but I ult wjsn
My favorites were
Nana
Yeoreum
Suyun
Then
Elly
Hwiseo
Bora
Yeonhee
Hwiseo slayyy
Elly was truly the most underrated person on the show. As a weki Meki ult it hurt
"Lacked facial expression" stop
It's not related, but i really hated Chaeyeon's attitude of "i'm giving down everyone" like WTF
She was just acting to give the program some fun or something that could left the viewers like “😦”, she knows well mnet and just wanted to cause some drama for the program as a joke, and then Chaeyeon left it like the queen she is.
And we need to add the evil edits that mnet does. She ofc knew that if she down voted everyone she would be evil edited.
Considering riina got c on pd48 It’s accurate
can you do universe ticket? hehe
its actually in the process of being made I'm just super busy rn ahha. there's also a lot of contestants to go thru too so it might take awhile. but do look out for it!
GO JIWON
What do you mean by up down score
its from the show. the contestants rated each performance against themselves by voting up & down. up being above me and down meaning below me
@@KPOPTrashLyrics ok
Putting Wooyeon as a F and in the same tier of Chaerin's and Seoyeon's performance should be a crime
Seoyeon around C vocal her is top12
Not even close dude.
Imo :
A : Hwiseo, Bora, Kei, Jiwon, Suyun, Yeoreum, Nana, Yeonhee
B : Yuki, Elly, Juri, Chaeyeon, Riina, Yeeun, Soojin
C : Soeun, Jiwoo, Sangah, Jihan
D : JooE, Miru, Dohwa, Zoa, Haein
F : Wooyeon, Chaerin, Seoyeon
どう考えてもチェヨンはAやな
Imo jooE and sangah deserve F, the vocals and rap were wayyy to shaky and stage presence was awkward too
Jooe is clearly D
Her performance was way better than most
Sorry but i would have to disagree
Imo kei deserves B/C, everyone keeps overhyping her when she lipsynced half the performance plus nothing actually stood out in the performance, no high notes or anything
you don't have to show that you're good bc you're already top tier. Just that amount of live singing can show how seasoned her voice is
@@goldsummit174I don't understand this "she had nothing to prove" mentality. It's about the PERFORMANCE and hers wasn't the best.
And when wooyeon lipsynced, people be like giving her a F, so funny😂
@@goldsummit174 nothing to prove?? Bffr, there would be no point in the up/down battles if there was nothing to prove
@@w.g.m7029 fr if wooyeon gets F then Kei deserves a C at least