I love it when they introduce American designed engines and vehicles in the Thomas universe!!! However, I think some of the voices should’ve been exclusive to the UK 🇬🇧 dub such as Timothy’s, Marion’s, and Philip’s.
I have a headcanon that Timothy, Marion, and Philip were built in Crovan's Gate Works Also, I don't like Connor and Caitlyn being American engines with Irish accents, it just feels wrong
As an American, I found it odd that Thomas never revisited American during the entirety of BWBA. If he did, then I would have loved him to reunite with Hank.
They should've just gotten me to voice Philip in the US dub tbh. Loved this new style of video bro, and it'd be cool to see more of it! Happy fourth Samster, and take care.
There’s a theory that Connor and Catalan were built with a lot of Irish immigrants in the shops and that’s how they got their accents. I actually really like this because a lot of Americans were and still are Irish with or without the accent.
Stanley (RWS) was shipped to be built on sodor in the great war, his parts came from Pennsylvania, and as for Vinnie, he is Actually a mix of American and Canadian
That is an interesting video regarding the American-built engines in Thomas (especially for 4th of July). The fact that a few ones had English accents rather than American accents always boggled me when watching both dubs of the show (weird how some of the main cast in the US dub have American accents, while the American characters have British accents as the same as was in the UK dub, same goes for other characters who have the same voice in both dubs). Even the Class 08 diesels in the Great Race spoke w/ US voices in both dubs despite being British built. I may think possibly they did that for these new characters from that country was through the production team looking through the real basis of the specific one and then picked it randomly (while not giving them the specific dialect from their backstory). In my headcanon, I tend to have Philip and Marion being built on Sodor instead of America hence the British accents. Vinnie is an okay pile, but it annoys me how he's dubbed as all American despite being a Canadian design. Carlos is from Mexico and that country is part of North America. Would've been cool to have two separate engines to represent Canada and the US: One a Canadian Pacific 'Royal Hudson' class (I would've given the name of specific character as 'Roy', short for 'Royal) and the other either Connor, Caitlin, Beau or even Hank (a missed opportunity to bring him back in TGR).
Honestly my favorite American engine in Thomas is Sam. I’m a big fan are Articulated Steam locomotives, especially ones that originate in the Appalachia coal fields, so Sam really hits close to home for me
@TrainsRKool1999 I have strong bias for Sam just for the mere fact that he's American and shares the name with me. As well as being the largest engine in the series.
I have a headcanon that Timothy, Marion, and Philip were built in Crovan's Gate Works Also, I don't like Connor and Caitlyn being American engines with Irish accents, it just feels wrong
HAPPY FOURTH OF JULY GRAAAAAAAAAH 🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅 Also very interesting essay style video this time around! It was cool to hear your take on why designs don't align with accents for the CGI series. I think I share most of your take on the matter.
@ThatOneOSCGuy Well maybe not a common thing but if you guys would like to see more of these kinds of essay videos, I could try. But I'm not necessarily good at writing things like this.
Well, he's brothers with the Flying Scotsman, and Thomas did say in Thomas and the Royal Engine that Gordon was built in Doncaster, so he's got those for implication.
TbH I not a fan of most US locomotive in the show. All of them feel they don't feel right running around on. It probably helps if they pick bases that can fit on the UK loading Guage.
I kinda find it weird how Rosie had an American accent in seasons 13-16 in the US dub, then in season 21 onwards in the same dub, she gained a UK accent. PICK A LANE ROSIE!!!
@ljandthomas I mean I like Mavis but I honestly just have an easier time writing for other characters in my series. The most that I can really do is acknowledge her in some kind of way.
I love it when they introduce American designed engines and vehicles in the Thomas universe!!! However, I think some of the voices should’ve been exclusive to the UK 🇬🇧 dub such as Timothy’s, Marion’s, and Philip’s.
I have a headcanon that Timothy, Marion, and Philip were built in Crovan's Gate Works
Also, I don't like Connor and Caitlyn being American engines with Irish accents, it just feels wrong
Yea true
I love your channel😊
@@koolykidnik4087 Thank you so much! ☺️
As an American, I found it odd that Thomas never revisited American during the entirety of BWBA. If he did, then I would have loved him to reunite with Hank.
Yeah that would be awesome hank is one of my favorite engines and i would be happy if thomas meets hank again
They should've just gotten me to voice Philip in the US dub tbh. Loved this new style of video bro, and it'd be cool to see more of it! Happy fourth Samster, and take care.
Yea true
Since I’m American, I find it very fitting that this video was uploaded today.
This is perfectly analyzed after seeing through this video. Great job, Sammy Clark! And have a Happy 4th of July to you, too.
The Logging Locos gone LOCO in their southern accents; no wonder Ferdinand is a Shay locomotive.
“That’s right, boss.”
(gasps) “BOSS!? 😡”
There’s a theory that Connor and Catalan were built with a lot of Irish immigrants in the shops and that’s how they got their accents. I actually really like this because a lot of Americans were and still are Irish with or without the accent.
That is a very interesting theory on the American built engines and some of them had English accents!! Happy 4th of July! 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
3:29 WE FAILING GEOGRAPHY CLASS WITH THIS ONE 🔥🔥🔥💯🚫💯🚫💯🚫💯🚫🗣🗣🗣❗❗❗
They be getting an F for Falling off 🤣🤣🤣
Stanley (RWS) was shipped to be built on sodor in the great war, his parts came from Pennsylvania, and as for Vinnie, he is Actually a mix of American and Canadian
That is an interesting video regarding the American-built engines in Thomas (especially for 4th of July). The fact that a few ones had English accents rather than American accents always boggled me when watching both dubs of the show (weird how some of the main cast in the US dub have American accents, while the American characters have British accents as the same as was in the UK dub, same goes for other characters who have the same voice in both dubs). Even the Class 08 diesels in the Great Race spoke w/ US voices in both dubs despite being British built. I may think possibly they did that for these new characters from that country was through the production team looking through the real basis of the specific one and then picked it randomly (while not giving them the specific dialect from their backstory). In my headcanon, I tend to have Philip and Marion being built on Sodor instead of America hence the British accents.
Vinnie is an okay pile, but it annoys me how he's dubbed as all American despite being a Canadian design. Carlos is from Mexico and that country is part of North America. Would've been cool to have two separate engines to represent Canada and the US: One a Canadian Pacific 'Royal Hudson' class (I would've given the name of specific character as 'Roy', short for 'Royal) and the other either Connor, Caitlin, Beau or even Hank (a missed opportunity to bring him back in TGR).
Roy sounds like a cool name
Fun fact: Vinnie’s basis is actually from Canada
Honestly my favorite American engine in Thomas is Sam. I’m a big fan are Articulated Steam locomotives, especially ones that originate in the Appalachia coal fields, so Sam really hits close to home for me
@TrainsRKool1999 I have strong bias for Sam just for the mere fact that he's American and shares the name with me. As well as being the largest engine in the series.
@@sammyclark4992 Him’s a big dude
I’m a British person but I have an American accent, I most likely got it from all the American shows, movies and games I watched.
Have you done voice acting before?
@@dylanlyles9453 yeah I have
@@Ryder-a-Blaze cool
Happy 4th of July!🇺🇸
2:35 “Like 4 and 7”
*shows footage of Seasons 6 and 8*
I don’t know that made me feel like something was off.
It is great to see a video of American engines, yay.
Vinnie is sadly a Canadian National streamline locomotive
Maybe he was from Grand Trunk and was either A built in Canada but sent to work in america or B built in America but modified.
I have a headcanon that Timothy, Marion, and Philip were built in Crovan's Gate Works
Also, I don't like Connor and Caitlyn being American engines with Irish accents, it just feels wrong
You made some pretty good points
AMERICAN RAHHHHHHHHH 🦅🦅🦅
they don't know that several british express engines went to the states
My favorites are a tie between Connor and Sam.
Also, happy 4th of July!
Happy 4th of July! I'd be interested to see more video essays like this from you if you have more ideas for them in mind
Isn’t the vehicle Flynn’s based on Japanese? If it is it makes me wonder why he never interacted with Hiro.
Oh well I wasn't aware that Flynn was based on a Japanese fire truck, the wiki doesn't mention that. They still state that he was built in America.
@@sammyclark4992 Flynn is built in America. The name of the Oshkosh Corporation must have confused you
Happy 4th Of July, Sammy.
Happy 4th of July!!
vinnie casually gets forgotten in the thumbnail
HAPPY FOURTH OF JULY GRAAAAAAAAAH
🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅
Also very interesting essay style video this time around! It was cool to hear your take on why designs don't align with accents for the CGI series. I think I share most of your take on the matter.
Happy 4th of July Americans
Despite Making No Sense What SoEver Besides Rosie, American Engines are on Sodor, Still like Majority of them tho, Also Happy 4th of July.
Cool
Nice my country
🎶AMERICA! F**K YEAH!🎶 😎🇺🇸🎆
Happy 4th of July Sammy!
You said Philip Wasn’t gonna be here :(
Oh and Happy ‘Merica day!
I said that the video wasn't just going to have Philip in it. I said nothing about Philip not being in it.
@@sammyclark4992Oh. Silly me. Sorry!
Arlesdale Productions made a movie about these characters taking over sodor
Well this is new, will this be a common thing?
@ThatOneOSCGuy Well maybe not a common thing but if you guys would like to see more of these kinds of essay videos, I could try. But I'm not necessarily good at writing things like this.
Thomas And Friends Is Amazing
Great video. I love seeing discussions of the USA and thomas
Well, happy 4th of July
A hem
🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅
Misty island rescue oh no
Happy 4TH Of July!🎆🎇
Happy 4th of July.
Good
Happy 4th Of July
Yee
0:42 I mean gordon’s never been implied to be from the lner in the television series but that doesn’t mean he’s not from the lner right?
Well, he's brothers with the Flying Scotsman, and Thomas did say in Thomas and the Royal Engine that Gordon was built in Doncaster, so he's got those for implication.
TbH I not a fan of most US locomotive in the show. All of them feel they don't feel right running around on. It probably helps if they pick bases that can fit on the UK loading Guage.
Happy Independence Day/4th Of July.
All I can think of now is that Connor and caytlin running about irland
*!OH JULY 4TH!* 🇺🇲
i used to watch ur grossery gang videos bruh no way you sound like this 😭😭
I kinda find it weird how Rosie had an American accent in seasons 13-16 in the US dub, then in season 21 onwards in the same dub, she gained a UK accent. PICK A LANE ROSIE!!!
Thank you bro
😅You really had me going before you said you weren’t going to stop people who think these characters didn’t pick up the accent after a time
That was good point not gonna lie
Happy 4th of July!
American Forever
WTF IS A KOLOMETER
I've hit unc status
Merican trains deserve better
Ayyyyy I was right
Now give me my $10😈
All I have is a 20.
Today is my Birthday
Happy birthday!
Happy birthday
@@CarlThePlotagonBoy5000 thanks
@@sammyclark4992 thanks ☺️
@@FoxyBoyGamer5678 your welcome 😎
I'm an American Have an accent
When is the new SC short coming out
@ljandthomas Not sure but I'll try to get it out during the summer.
@@sammyclark4992 thanks Sammy and also why isn’t mavis relevant in the series anymore?
@ljandthomas I mean I like Mavis but I honestly just have an easier time writing for other characters in my series. The most that I can really do is acknowledge her in some kind of way.
@@sammyclark4992 I like mavis too apparently other engines might have the same feeling and when will James marry Emily?
@@ljandthomas Never as I've concluded that whole James loving Emily persona 3 years ago.
Happy 4th of July.