Very much hoping AI doesn’t take over the screenwriters! The film industry’s future really jeopardized right now. I’m pretty sure it won’t happen, since writers need to be on set to make sure everything is going alright and making the script better. Also, and there are script supervisors that have jobs to do, etc. Hoping you can still become a screenwriter tho!!!❤
The AI wasn’t too bad, but it can’t compete with screenwriters! I’m hoping this AI issue ends well, I’d hate to see it take over😕. But it won’t, I believe we can fix this❤❤
I hope AI doesn't replace writers because writers can still make the story more understandable and bring creativity to the script. Creativity is something that AI can't do. I love the video! ❤️❤️❤️
If AI were to replace writers, I'm afraid that would mean no originality. Sometimes Hollywood seems formulaic already, but I'm afraid AI is just going to prevent screenplays with original ideas from being written at all.
What a great video, the idea and content. Carefully done! I thank you for uploading content worth of watching! At the end you asked to comment the word spider, so SPIDER! Thank you again! Subscribed
I honestly love the Wednesday Original better, captivated by the authors work to the point I wanted the hear you read the whole script without even looking at the visual.
As a visual artist... I agree completely. Tell a gamer that AI is going to do the gaming and you only have to give the final hit so it counts... Its not fun! No artist, no actor, writer, musician, painter..wants that. AI needs to be regulated! (I am actually from Brazil but I am pretty sure however you guys diced to regulate it in USA we will follow something similar)
THIS IS WHY AI IS ONLY A TOOL! You can’t ever capture human depth and emotion in a robot. Thank you for doing this Makayla! It’s so important for people to see this❤️ spider
I’m definitely excited for the future of Hollywood and just acting and film in general. The only thing is AI is very concerning considering that so many people would loose jobs.
also AI just isn't as creative or dynamic as human writing. if someone wrote a whole show/movie using only AI, it's very likely that we as an audience would recognize the vaguely inhuman quality, kind of like a cinematic uncanny valley. or, at the very least, we'd find it incredibly boring.
@@jayebird1138 but at the same time who knows how much it will advance in the future. I just hope companies don’t resort to ai in certain instances just because. That does make a lot of sense though it would be very vague and wouldn’t provide emotion.
As an actor myself it’s scary to realize that AI maybe writing the words I say. This can’t happen we need writers to breathe life into a script let alone a scene. I hope and pray that this writers strike ends soon and we can all go back to living out our best artistic lives
Aren't you more concerned that you'll be replaced with a digital actor that isn't paid, does whatever it's told, and never ages? (and, more importantly, can't ever strike and never has scheduling conflicts).
@@Hedgehobbit no right now I’m only concerned about the writers strike because that is what’s happening now. I don’t think they’ll be digital actor’s because the industry needs it’s actors audiences aren’t going to want to see a digital actor on screen it’s not going to make the industry money
@aliusaho7537 the thing is, no matter how advanced or "close" to human intelligence that AI gets, it will never be able to truly replicate empathy. and in the end, empathy is what drives creativity. you can't convert emotions or our innately human understanding of them into ones and zeroes, no matter how much dating apps or chat gpt tried to convince you that they can. our empathy is what separates us from the animals, and now it's what's gonna separate us from AI.
Writers have the privilege of creation through showing and not telling. Sure, AI can write; however, it cannot tell a story. It cannot replicate the individual style and nuances of human storytelling nor replicate the emotion derived from it. Great video, Makayla!
Not yet, but tbh with AI it's so inhumane, and even if it will able to write emotions, it's going to have inconsistencies/changing behaviors of the characters and most of them will act as inhumane as the script everyone is going to be emotionless and monotone.
@@denisablaskova3269 I'm not sure about that ... 20 years ago no one imagined computers become this powerful and smart ... who knows what will happen in 20 more years... specifically with ai the speed of development is just insanely fast ! ... I think the future is going to surprise us all.
Spider 🕷️ This was very interesting to watch. I definitely see Ai just as a tool, cause seeing the examples of scripts it wrote in this video it showed it can definitely give you ideas to develop a script of your own…but it can’t make one as good and creative as an actual writer can. I hope that Ai doesn’t take over…cause writing and film along with Hollywood is about creativity and originality, and if Ai does take over…Hollywood is just gonna loose way more of what it’s supposed to stand for. ✨Writers create stories, and they’re stories create Art✨
Spider! 🕸️🕷️ Script writing is an area of movie making that me and my sister have started reaching into more. The depth of emotion that as writer you have to reach in order for your audience to feel something is amazing! I think that is something that AI just won't be able to recreate.
Spider🕷️✨I really loved this video. AI is definitely lacking a lot of what it takes to create truly engaging shows. I was pretty surprised too though. The AI did much better than I expected, but still not nearly good enough. Thanks for the video Makayla!
Alright, about AI, how did you create that AI prompt, what context did you put in, and how many times did it run? Also, what version of GPT did you use? It's useful to know. There is a huge difference between GPT 3.5 and GPT 4 - there's a year between them. Probably, In the future, something like a GPT 6 might even write scripts just like a human. But it doesn't mean everyone working with information will be jobless. We'll just have to adapt to this technology. Thanks a lot for video!
Love this & all of your videos Makayla! It helps me feel better that there are other people who value quality art over profit! I learn so much from you. Spider 🕷️🖤
SPIDER🕷️ Makayla I absolutely love you and your content! You have inspired me so much. You’re amazing ❤️❤️❤️ (Also you should definitely watch Wednesday!) I hope AI doesn’t take over, it’s really a shame🙁. I LOVED THIS VIDEO THOUGH!! It’s fun to see the differences between AI and people when writing a script ❤️
I loveee this experiment 🎬 AI cannot replace writers! Art moves you, it makes you feel Ai can't recreate that, A human experience can only be conveyed by HUMANS.🎭🎞️
spider🕷️💜I must agree: AI’s work was impressive, however there is one thing AIs will never have… the passion that screenwriters put into doing their job, that love and personality that define the style of a screenwriter and make the final product unique. This is the main reason why I hope AIs will never substitute actual people. Also, Makayla this was sooo interesting! I need more videos about analyzing screenplays!! 🙏😭
Love this video! I enjoyed hearing your opinions and breaking down the scripts. Very interesting script writing lessons. Please do more videos like this. Spider
I just asked AI this: write me an opening scene to a teen rom-com movie where we open at a high school everyone is normal except a young girl named summer who has a wheelchair and she as to try to navigate her hard life.... This is what they came up with The camera pans across a crowded high school hallway, filled with students laughing, talking, and jostling each other. Everyone seems to be having a great time, except for one girl. Summer is sitting in her wheelchair, watching the other students with a mixture of envy and sadness. She wants to be like them, to be able to run and jump and laugh without a care in the world. But she knows that's not possible. She's been in a wheelchair since she was a little girl, and she's used to being different. Summer sighs and pushes her wheelchair down the hallway. She's on her way to her first class, English. She's not looking forward to it. She knows that the other students will stare at her, and she'll probably be the subject of their whispered conversations. But Summer takes a deep breath and pushes on. She's not going to let her disability define her. She's going to live her life to the fullest, just like everyone else. Summer arrives at English class and takes a seat in the back. The teacher, Mr. Smith, starts talking about the day's lesson, but Summer can't concentrate. She's too busy worrying about what the other students are thinking about her. Suddenly, Summer feels a tap on her shoulder. She turns around and sees a boy standing there. He's tall and handsome, with dark hair and blue eyes. "Hi," the boy says. "I'm Jake. I just wanted to say that I think you're really brave." Summer is taken aback. "Brave?" she asks. "Why?" "Because you're in a wheelchair," Jake says, "and you're still going to school and doing everything that everyone else does. That takes a lot of courage." Summer blushes. "Thanks," she says. "That means a lot." Jake smiles and sits down next to Summer. They start talking, and Summer quickly realizes that Jake is a really nice guy. He's funny and smart, and he makes her feel comfortable. For the first time in a long time, Summer feels like she belongs. She's not just the girl in the wheelchair anymore. She's just a girl, like everyone else. I'm Kinda impressed
The AI wasn't really doing anything. It was entirely dependent on the prompts. Where the IA did well, it was using precise details provided in the prompts. Where it had to come up with something on its own, it was dull, generic, and generally unimpressive. I knew this would be the case before I started watching. I knew in the early 1990s when I first read James Cameron's screenplay for "Aliens." The opening words -- and this is from memory -- are: SPACE. The stars shine like the love of God: cold and remote. One day, AI may be able to set a tone that effectively, that efficiently, but by that time, we'll have to worry about giving it civil rights, and whether or not it will let humanity survive. Employment for writers will be the least of our problems.
This should make creators even more invigorated to create even more because now original works will be valued more than they ever have been AI doesn’t have individuality
I loved the video Makayla, you did a great job. The video is fun and easy to watch while learning a lesson. I watch your videos from Belgium and get everything you say. As an aspiring actress it's really helpful so thank you a lot.God bless you ❤ Ps : how did you get the original script ? On (Spider🕷) web🕸 ?
AI had A LOT of unnecessary descriptions. But the writers' version... i was extremely impressed. It was just amazing. Please don't get rid of these writers!!!❤❤❤😢😢😢😢😢😊😊😊😊😊😅😅😅😅😮😮😮😢😢😢
As a beginner in screenwriter whos trying to make a film of one of my scripts... I need to seriously work on my writing... 😭😭😭😭😭 On the bright side🌞 I now know I have a lot of editing to do!
Hello Makayla, as much as I like your content and movies and am concerned about AI replacing me in some areas, your video is not relevant. First, you are using GPT-3.5 and not GPT-4. The difference is huge in terms of thinking and writing even though it's slower. Second, prompting is an art and your prompt is not that great. There are literally 150K paying jobs out there for people who know how to talk to language models. So your experiment is not very relevant sorry. Wish you the best
Hey Makayla I love videos you're just such a great person ❤️, I want to start in the industry and I wanted to use backstage as I don't yet have an agent, so I will really appreciate if you talk more about the steps to follow on the app ,like give a more deep way on how to proceed, pleaseeee. Love u 😘
I am an astronomer, and in astronomy, AI is used extensively to identify galaxies, stars etc, so I am very familiar with how it works -- I will just say that AI works by human beings "training" it to do so certain things, and then the machine can do that very well . If the scripts produced by current AI is not considered "good" enough, that's because the machine has not been trained with enough "good" scripts, and can't replicate writing those "good" scripts ... ... for the mean time. BTW, I don't think that AI will replace screen-writers, but I do think that screen-writers will learn to use AI to churn out scrips, both good and bad.
Wednesday was great because Jenna Ortega broke from script when needed frequently. AI is very much Garbage in Garbage Out . Try programing it with the best of Oscar Wilde . You might get something better than a living writing is you focus all 75 years dead writers . As few wrters made anything worth watching the last 3 years do not use their work to program AI ro do anything useful
Wow Makayla, I am fascinated with every video you make! They are made perfectly. it shows that you spend a lot of time on it! and it also shows what your passion is! congratulations, you will go far💗💗🤩
It doesn’t work. I tried getting it to write a pilot script and at most it produces ONE page of lame cringy writing. Not even close to usable 😅 I’ve also tried other programs and nothing writes a proper screenplay
Very well spoken and put together and Makayla! Without supporting Grace Kaufman on Man With A Plan as a carryover from La Vida Lab Rats, I never would’ve virtually met ya the way I did in 2020. I also made a video about the WGA Strike so I look forward to seeing your Vlog of it. Spider 🕷️
Okay, I dunno if you will see this Makayla. But I've had my screenplays reviewed over the years and the actual written scripts in this video are exactly how I write mine. Except, everyone who read mine says I'm too "flowery" with my action lines. Despite the fact they were concise. Also, the way the AI wrote these screenplays is what they told me to replicate. I have to mention I got this advice before ChatGPT came around. I have no idea if they were trying to sabotage me or if they didn't know anything about screenwriting at all.
That was hilarious and educational😂 the scene with the remote control in Wednesday AI had me cracking up. I hope AI doesn't take over too many jobs though. From this video, I would say writers are really talented and special. I would really love to be in a movie you write someday🙏🏾 Spider
I tried to write one paragraph for one of my books with this, because I was stuck with the story. I had to tell it to at least rewrite it 5 times with different instructions each time and then modify it. However it was very useful to get out of that writer's block. I also find it very useful to filter information, that way if you have to make research is easier. I'm not saying it's the only tool you should use, but for example if you know nothing about Ireland and you want to know possible real locations in Ireland for your scene, you might just ask AI to tell you 10 beautiful places and then you check them in other sources to see if that's what you're looking for. I also found AI-generated art useful to have a picture in mind of specific places that don't exist anymore, like kingdoms, mansions, etc., especially if there's not a lot of information out there about that specific time.
Hey Makayla, I loved the video I thought it was great and brought a new perspective on how impactful and needed writers are in our movie life. I am fully on your side when it comes to this discussion as an AI might be able to write but will never be able to feel and feeling is the one element that an actor needs to portray the best stories, writers are way to valued in this industry to be replaced by a source that cant and will never experience true life, true emotion or even truth in this world. This video has also shown me the importance of the English language and has helped me see what techniques might be useful for the play I need to create in drama. I am very fond of acting and would love to start, thanks to you I have found the wonderful source backstage to help me begin this journey. As I have just took my first few steps into this journey I do not have enough support, supplies or money for necessities like acting classes or good camera quality. So I was wondering if in a new video maybe you could show some great activities and task to help improve our acting abilities kind of like coaching us through a small acting class and showing us things to make us a better actor/actress. Thankyou for all the videos you have made they are all so inspiring and have helped me through small steps of trying to start my acting career, I understand if this idea does not turn into a video I just thought I would tell you because for some reason it feels like I would have your support over a lot of people I know, also I am pretty desperate to get better at acting as being actress is a dream that I don't just want to just feel at night but experience in the day to. I appreciate everything you have done, keep on inspiring people and having fun I will be alongside watching your journey that you share as you have started mine. Thankyou very much Makayla Lysiak. Lots of Love Dhanvi. 💕
Spider!!! Love everything about this!!!! I hope to see a video on writing a TV show and what your process is or what types of scripts/genres you love to write.
I'm nerding out with you! 😂 I'm a writer hoping to get into the business as well and I love reading scripts. When a script grabs your heart, it's because the writer put their heart into the story. I hope the strike gives them everything their hard work has earned ❤ Spider 😊
To me I think the Original Scripts are perfect as they are Hollywood CEO's shouldn't take advantage on AI Programms to take over their Employer's job because every Media company needs a Screenwriter not an AI Robot behind the Computer screen that's just my Opinion but overall this has to be one of my best favorite videos so far keep up the good work Makayla
with chatGPT you can ask it to write a certain way - for example, when you write your prompt, you can ask it to describe less in dialogue but to put more visual elements into it, and it will do so.
Wow, I must say that a script writer with creativity imagination is much better than the A.I writing the story stuff. Easy to say because A.I don't have a heart when tried to create a meaningful script, just like how the A.I voice did. And I shocked because now A.I is writing a script instead of us human. 😯🤖💖
That's crazy how the AI had Pugsley saying a line in the script before Wednesday is able to pull the tape off of his mouth. Obviously, real human writers would do a better job at writing than AI. A blinking remote control? Oh no, AI, you so disappoint me! Piranhas are so much scarier.
Spider 🕷 The way that the AI wrote the scripts were ok but human writers definitely is more creative. I love watching tv and it wouldn’t be as good of a tv show if an AI wrote it. Thank you for making these videos ❤
In other words no, AI can only be used as a way to stimulate ideas or as a hobby when you're bored. I use ChatGPT as a way to study for my oral exams or as a way to practice my speech or writing skills. It's shocking how corporations wanna use it as a way to replace screenwriters and actors completely despite its limits.
“Netflix hit….” Translation? “Derivative unoriginal show that pays $0.036 monthly residuals to the featured SAG/AFTRA members. Queue the Netflix executives’ maniacal laughs.
If AI wants to replace humans in ANY job they need a human associated with it. I don’t know why someone would want AI to replace them. But if they did ; they need to make sure this AI isn’t doing horrible. A big thing about TV company’s is money. Not just money since they want to be rich. Money since they will be able to afford more props and sets. They will have money to build and make those. If people don’t like the new AI shows it will make some shows low budget or LOWER budget. And most entertainment AI made will get taken down if it isn’t doing well. #WeWriteYouWrong
Written scripts were best. Also, I’ve got to rewatch “Wednesday”. That’s a great show. Currently, watching “White Lotus.” Looks good. Watched 1st season of “Succession.” Didn’t like it.
What the Ai gave any writer worth anything would have in 5 seconds after hearing the prompt you wrote. There was no actual useful work completed by it there, in that there were no surprising ideas at all (beyond your prompt). It was just the obvious dull way of executing your prompt. I find it not at all useful to use Ai while writing - I kinda don't want to know the cliche and after reading the dreck cliche then it's stuck in your head
Bravo Spider, U were/are totally right... & because I never want 2 C A.I. replace ur future endeavors/accomplishments, B aware of what U teach ur diabolical enemies { A.I. & those behind it }. Believe me, they're watching & learning. FYI, I enjoyed ur wide view lense. Seeing more of U is an extremely pleasurable treat.
AI can't replace fiction writers with creativity and originality being their weakest spot. BUT. Even if AI gets to that point, they shouldn't replace people. It'll just be another voice with it's own personal writing style. Some of the most famous poets are Shakespeare, Maya Angelo, Dr. Seuss, and Shel Silverstein. Replacing every writer with AI is like only having Dr. Seuss and no one else.
I got to say, the AI script is kind of making me laugh because it reminds me of Terminator 2 where John points out the way the Terminator talked. I'm a bit disappointed Wednesday didn't say "affirmative" anyway in the script. Also I wonder if the people who speculate that AppleTV movie “Ghosted” might actually have been written by AI because the script reads like something the studios only paid a writer to come up with a idea and base draft, then they just used cheaper AI to actually write the script. Forgot to add: "Spider"
Here's the biggest problem with your video........ It can literally be used to make a I even more smarter in this time next year you're going to get a form or Superior version of chat GTP....... Because of this video 😰 Basically you will help this AI to become even better and not just chat GTP by itself but also other variants other types in versions. Essentially you're feeding the machine 😰 but honestly this was a very great and informative video and I wish you all the success!
I also tested this on ChatGPT and I feel that AI couldn’t replace writers as the script doesn’t have any personality. It also says everything your character is doing when we can see it. I asked for broadway and I only get half of what I asked for. It was horrible and when I said to change it the only thing it would change is the music letter ; I asked it to change the lyrics and that’s what I gave me. The first time I asked it said it was very close to another musical and it would get copy righted. That is a good sign AI won’t replace writers. #WeWriteYouWrong
Makayla should be a writer professor if that's even a thing. So good explanations for people who don't know anything about script writing. 💯 writers win.
This was interestingly informative. I am writing a script for a full featured animation my studio is producing and, based on this video- I tried "chatgpt" and entered one of my scene. As you said, AI can"t take the place of a writer but, it can help the process. spider
I came across your video about stepping away from Hollywood then decided to watch one more of your videos and this was great. Makayla, you will be an amazing writer and make wonderful movies one day. Don't stop. The Lord has a plan to prosper you and you will understand it later.
What did you think of the AI's script scenes?🤖
Very much hoping AI doesn’t take over the screenwriters! The film industry’s future really jeopardized right now. I’m pretty sure it won’t happen, since writers need to be on set to make sure everything is going alright and making the script better. Also, and there are script supervisors that have jobs to do, etc. Hoping you can still become a screenwriter tho!!!❤
The AI wasn’t too bad, but it can’t compete with screenwriters! I’m hoping this AI issue ends well, I’d hate to see it take over😕. But it won’t, I believe we can fix this❤❤
Honestly, I think a spider has more personality than some of those scenes.
makayla are you still giving shoutouts
@@graceandlove945 yes in vlogs!
I hope AI doesn't replace writers because writers can still make the story more understandable and bring creativity to the script. Creativity is something that AI can't do. I love the video! ❤️❤️❤️
they’d still prolly have writers look lthrough the scripts
Some people in the industry would replace writers with AI if they had their way, because it's more easier for them.
Using AI to write a movie is the dumbest thing ever. Look no further than Ghosted to see why it’s an issue.
If AI were to replace writers, I'm afraid that would mean no originality. Sometimes Hollywood seems formulaic already, but I'm afraid AI is just going to prevent screenplays with original ideas from being written at all.
So how creative have these writers been for the last three years. Re-making someone elses work or adding a 2 is not very creative.
What a great video, the idea and content. Carefully done! I thank you for uploading content worth of watching! At the end you asked to comment the word spider, so SPIDER! Thank you again! Subscribed
I honestly love the Wednesday Original better, captivated by the authors work to the point I wanted the hear you read the whole script without even looking at the visual.
I love your necklace would you comment the link to it or tell me where you got it?
Even if AI can write, the joy us writers feel pursuing our craft can not be replicated by a machine!! 🕷️
I love this.💜
@@MakaylaLysiak 🥰
That's great but don't u need to eat
As a visual artist... I agree completely. Tell a gamer that AI is going to do the gaming and you only have to give the final hit so it counts... Its not fun! No artist, no actor, writer, musician, painter..wants that. AI needs to be regulated! (I am actually from Brazil but I am pretty sure however you guys diced to regulate it in USA we will follow something similar)
nobody wants to pay for your joy
THIS IS WHY AI IS ONLY A TOOL! You can’t ever capture human depth and emotion in a robot. Thank you for doing this Makayla! It’s so important for people to see this❤️ spider
I’m definitely excited for the future of Hollywood and just acting and film in general. The only thing is AI is very concerning considering that so many people would loose jobs.
also AI just isn't as creative or dynamic as human writing. if someone wrote a whole show/movie using only AI, it's very likely that we as an audience would recognize the vaguely inhuman quality, kind of like a cinematic uncanny valley. or, at the very least, we'd find it incredibly boring.
@@jayebird1138that part and the fact that some of the dialogue might be repeated as I tried it out myself and noticed some of the lines were repeating
@@jayebird1138 I totally agree.
@@jayebird1138 but at the same time who knows how much it will advance in the future. I just hope companies don’t resort to ai in certain instances just because. That does make a lot of sense though it would be very vague and wouldn’t provide emotion.
As an actor myself it’s scary to realize that AI maybe writing the words I say. This can’t happen we need writers to breathe life into a script let alone a scene. I hope and pray that this writers strike ends soon and we can all go back to living out our best artistic lives
Aren't you more concerned that you'll be replaced with a digital actor that isn't paid, does whatever it's told, and never ages? (and, more importantly, can't ever strike and never has scheduling conflicts).
@@Hedgehobbit no right now I’m only concerned about the writers strike because that is what’s happening now. I don’t think they’ll be digital actor’s because the industry needs it’s actors audiences aren’t going to want to see a digital actor on screen it’s not going to make the industry money
AI cant truly understand how emotions work. Humans have feelings and experiences and that’s what builds strong writers
Not yet. But it likely could within the next 5-10 years.
@@kimkardashianruinedmylifeless than 5 years, it’s reported that gpt 5 would almost be human level intelligence
@aliusaho7537 the thing is, no matter how advanced or "close" to human intelligence that AI gets, it will never be able to truly replicate empathy. and in the end, empathy is what drives creativity. you can't convert emotions or our innately human understanding of them into ones and zeroes, no matter how much dating apps or chat gpt tried to convince you that they can. our empathy is what separates us from the animals, and now it's what's gonna separate us from AI.
@@jayebird1138yes and ai is replicating what's on internet it cannot create new emotion which human's can
This was great!!! I hope you make this a series because it truly shows how vital writers are.
Writers have the privilege of creation through showing and not telling. Sure, AI can write; however, it cannot tell a story. It cannot replicate the individual style and nuances of human storytelling nor replicate the emotion derived from it. Great video, Makayla!
Not yet ...
Not yet, but tbh with AI it's so inhumane, and even if it will able to write emotions, it's going to have inconsistencies/changing behaviors of the characters and most of them will act as inhumane as the script everyone is going to be emotionless and monotone.
@@denisablaskova3269 I'm not sure about that ... 20 years ago no one imagined computers become this powerful and smart ... who knows what will happen in 20 more years... specifically with ai the speed of development is just insanely fast ! ... I think the future is going to surprise us all.
Spider 🕷️
This was very interesting to watch.
I definitely see Ai just as a tool, cause seeing the examples of scripts it wrote in this video it showed it can definitely give you ideas to develop a script of your own…but it can’t make one as good and creative as an actual writer can.
I hope that Ai doesn’t take over…cause writing and film along with Hollywood is about creativity and originality, and if Ai does take over…Hollywood is just gonna loose way more of what it’s supposed to stand for.
✨Writers create stories, and they’re stories create Art✨
Totally agree with this. Thanks for watching!
Girl I'm so surprised you haven't seen Wednesday! it's most definitely worth your time, Jenna Ortega is phenomenal as Wednesday!
Spider! 🕸️🕷️ Script writing is an area of movie making that me and my sister have started reaching into more. The depth of emotion that as writer you have to reach in order for your audience to feel something is amazing! I think that is something that AI just won't be able to recreate.
Spider🕷️✨I really loved this video. AI is definitely lacking a lot of what it takes to create truly engaging shows. I was pretty surprised too though. The AI did much better than I expected, but still not nearly good enough. Thanks for the video Makayla!
Alright, about AI, how did you create that AI prompt, what context did you put in, and how many times did it run? Also, what version of GPT did you use? It's useful to know.
There is a huge difference between GPT 3.5 and GPT 4 - there's a year between them. Probably, In the future, something like a GPT 6 might even write scripts just like a human. But it doesn't mean everyone working with information will be jobless. We'll just have to adapt to this technology. Thanks a lot for video!
Love this & all of your videos Makayla! It helps me feel better that there are other people who value quality art over profit! I learn so much from you.
Spider 🕷️🖤
SPIDER🕷️ Makayla I absolutely love you and your content! You have inspired me so much. You’re amazing ❤️❤️❤️ (Also you should definitely watch Wednesday!) I hope AI doesn’t take over, it’s really a shame🙁. I LOVED THIS VIDEO THOUGH!! It’s fun to see the differences between AI and people when writing a script ❤️
Thank you for watching and I'm glad you enjoyed it!🥰
I loveee this experiment 🎬 AI cannot replace writers! Art moves you, it makes you feel Ai can't recreate that, A human experience can only be conveyed by HUMANS.🎭🎞️
It’s crazy how ChatGBT can write its own script based on the information you give it
spider🕷️💜I must agree: AI’s work was impressive, however there is one thing AIs will never have… the passion that screenwriters put into doing their job, that love and personality that define the style of a screenwriter and make the final product unique. This is the main reason why I hope AIs will never substitute actual people. Also, Makayla this was sooo interesting! I need more videos about analyzing screenplays!! 🙏😭
Love this video! I enjoyed hearing your opinions and breaking down the scripts. Very interesting script writing lessons. Please do more videos like this. Spider
I just asked AI this: write me an opening scene to a teen rom-com movie where we open at a high school everyone is normal except a young girl named summer who has a wheelchair and she as to try to navigate her hard life.... This is what they came up with
The camera pans across a crowded high school hallway, filled with students laughing, talking, and jostling each other. Everyone seems to be having a great time, except for one girl.
Summer is sitting in her wheelchair, watching the other students with a mixture of envy and sadness. She wants to be like them, to be able to run and jump and laugh without a care in the world. But she knows that's not possible. She's been in a wheelchair since she was a little girl, and she's used to being different.
Summer sighs and pushes her wheelchair down the hallway. She's on her way to her first class, English. She's not looking forward to it. She knows that the other students will stare at her, and she'll probably be the subject of their whispered conversations.
But Summer takes a deep breath and pushes on. She's not going to let her disability define her. She's going to live her life to the fullest, just like everyone else.
Summer arrives at English class and takes a seat in the back. The teacher, Mr. Smith, starts talking about the day's lesson, but Summer can't concentrate. She's too busy worrying about what the other students are thinking about her.
Suddenly, Summer feels a tap on her shoulder. She turns around and sees a boy standing there. He's tall and handsome, with dark hair and blue eyes.
"Hi," the boy says. "I'm Jake. I just wanted to say that I think you're really brave."
Summer is taken aback. "Brave?" she asks. "Why?"
"Because you're in a wheelchair," Jake says, "and you're still going to school and doing everything that everyone else does. That takes a lot of courage."
Summer blushes. "Thanks," she says. "That means a lot."
Jake smiles and sits down next to Summer. They start talking, and Summer quickly realizes that Jake is a really nice guy. He's funny and smart, and he makes her feel comfortable.
For the first time in a long time, Summer feels like she belongs. She's not just the girl in the wheelchair anymore. She's just a girl, like everyone else.
I'm Kinda impressed
The AI wasn't really doing anything. It was entirely dependent on the prompts. Where the IA did well, it was using precise details provided in the prompts. Where it had to come up with something on its own, it was dull, generic, and generally unimpressive.
I knew this would be the case before I started watching. I knew in the early 1990s when I first read James Cameron's screenplay for "Aliens." The opening words -- and this is from memory -- are:
SPACE. The stars shine like the love of God: cold and remote.
One day, AI may be able to set a tone that effectively, that efficiently, but by that time, we'll have to worry about giving it civil rights, and whether or not it will let humanity survive. Employment for writers will be the least of our problems.
Love this comment 💗
This should make creators even more invigorated to create even more because now original works will be valued more than they ever have been AI doesn’t have individuality
I personally prefer Humans!!!
I loved the video Makayla, you did a great job. The video is fun and easy to watch while learning a lesson. I watch your videos from Belgium and get everything you say. As an aspiring actress it's really helpful so thank you a lot.God bless you ❤
Ps : how did you get the original script ? On (Spider🕷) web🕸 ?
I don't only love your channel, your video ideas are always on top too!!
Thank you so much!😆
@@MakaylaLysiakHey, Makayla. I love your Videos 💓💖
Your passion for screenwriting is so sweet to watch. Great video as always, loved this idea!
AWWWW Thank you so much!☺️
AI had A LOT of unnecessary descriptions. But the writers' version... i was extremely impressed. It was just amazing. Please don't get rid of these writers!!!❤❤❤😢😢😢😢😢😊😊😊😊😊😅😅😅😅😮😮😮😢😢😢
Oh, just remembered! SPIDER!
Hii I am first
first
Even though I don't watch Wednesday I would say yes you should watch it.
I think that the writers' scripts were SO much better, btw spider!
Glad to see that you agree!🩷
As a beginner in screenwriter whos trying to make a film of one of my scripts... I need to seriously work on my writing... 😭😭😭😭😭 On the bright side🌞 I now know I have a lot of editing to do!
“WEDNESDAY “ is definitely worth it! 😊
i love ur vids so much ❤🫶🏼
Hello Makayla, as much as I like your content and movies and am concerned about AI replacing me in some areas, your video is not relevant. First, you are using GPT-3.5 and not GPT-4. The difference is huge in terms of thinking and writing even though it's slower. Second, prompting is an art and your prompt is not that great. There are literally 150K paying jobs out there for people who know how to talk to language models. So your experiment is not very relevant sorry. Wish you the best
Hey Makayla I love videos you're just such a great person ❤️, I want to start in the industry and I wanted to use backstage as I don't yet have an agent, so I will really appreciate if you talk more about the steps to follow on the app ,like give a more deep way on how to proceed, pleaseeee. Love u 😘
hi, I was wondering.. what if I live in Europe, but I AM WILLING to travel.. would this be good enough to enter a Netfilx movie???
I am an astronomer, and in astronomy, AI is used extensively to identify galaxies, stars etc, so I am very familiar with how it works -- I will just say that AI works by human beings "training" it to do so certain things, and then the machine can do that very well . If the scripts produced by current AI is not considered "good" enough, that's because the machine has not been trained with enough "good" scripts, and can't replicate writing those "good" scripts ... ... for the mean time. BTW, I don't think that AI will replace screen-writers, but I do think that screen-writers will learn to use AI to churn out scrips, both good and bad.
Wednesday was great because Jenna Ortega broke from script when needed frequently. AI is very much Garbage in Garbage Out . Try programing it with the best of Oscar Wilde . You might get something better than a living writing is you focus all 75 years dead writers . As few wrters made anything worth watching the last 3 years do not use their work to program AI ro do anything useful
I asked chat gpt to write a scene from my book, and it literally predicted a bunch of the stuff I do in my book...
AI scripts aren't as good as the ones made by the writers the AI scripts lack feeling and creativity . Spider 🕷️
Wow Makayla, I am fascinated with every video you make! They are made perfectly. it shows that you spend a lot of time on it! and it also shows what your passion is! congratulations, you will go far💗💗🤩
It was so interesting to compare the different scripts, I once again learned a lot thanks to you :) (Spider
Spider the AI was pretty good surprisingly but it’s no where near good as the actual writers and I hope AI doesn’t take peoples jobs
It doesn’t work. I tried getting it to write a pilot script and at most it produces ONE page of lame cringy writing. Not even close to usable 😅 I’ve also tried other programs and nothing writes a proper screenplay
Ai is already doing way better than script writers. The thing is you are biased and as we say in computer world. Garbage in garbage out.
OMG, I love this video! If you turned this into a series I would be ecstatic 🤩
Very well spoken and put together and Makayla! Without supporting Grace Kaufman on Man With A Plan as a carryover from La Vida Lab Rats, I never would’ve virtually met ya the way I did in 2020. I also made a video about the WGA Strike so I look forward to seeing your Vlog of it.
Spider 🕷️
Okay, I dunno if you will see this Makayla. But I've had my screenplays reviewed over the years and the actual written scripts in this video are exactly how I write mine. Except, everyone who read mine says I'm too "flowery" with my action lines. Despite the fact they were concise. Also, the way the AI wrote these screenplays is what they told me to replicate. I have to mention I got this advice before ChatGPT came around. I have no idea if they were trying to sabotage me or if they didn't know anything about screenwriting at all.
That was hilarious and educational😂 the scene with the remote control in Wednesday AI had me cracking up. I hope AI doesn't take over too many jobs though. From this video, I would say writers are really talented and special. I would really love to be in a movie you write someday🙏🏾
Spider
So happy you enjoyed the video!
Makayla!! Please keep doing what you’re doing. Your videos are informative AF!! 🕷️
I tried to write one paragraph for one of my books with this, because I was stuck with the story. I had to tell it to at least rewrite it 5 times with different instructions each time and then modify it. However it was very useful to get out of that writer's block. I also find it very useful to filter information, that way if you have to make research is easier. I'm not saying it's the only tool you should use, but for example if you know nothing about Ireland and you want to know possible real locations in Ireland for your scene, you might just ask AI to tell you 10 beautiful places and then you check them in other sources to see if that's what you're looking for. I also found AI-generated art useful to have a picture in mind of specific places that don't exist anymore, like kingdoms, mansions, etc., especially if there's not a lot of information out there about that specific time.
I love your videos and your incredible ideas 🥰.
Sis tbh I like more of the vlog style videos!! Could you post more of those, Day in the life ,routines etc.
That will be my next video 🥰
@@MakaylaLysiak ok thank you sm🫶🏾
I think you should try again with gpt4 and a prompt engineer to give it a fair shot
I love all of your videos and you inspire me so much and I hope AI doesn’t take over❤❤❤
In some ways, AI seemed to write more like a novel rather than a script. I think AI could write books well, but not scripts.
Yeah, I was thinking that with so much exposition dump it was more of "book" like writing rather than script writing.
I know that show. My friends love that show.
u should defiantly watch Wednesday, the show is amazing i think you would like it
I love your channel so much and your helping thousands achieve their dreams
Thank YOU for watching and supporting me!
I wish it was as easy for me as it is for you to act but I live in the UK
First to comment prrr💗💗😂
A.I is just a baby, it is learning...but this is not the future I want. We need too stop it now....also love your outfit, it is cute
Thank you for the compliment ❤
Did you go to vid con? If you did will you make a video of it??
Hey Makayla, I loved the video I thought it was great and brought a new perspective on how impactful and needed writers are in our movie life. I am fully on your side when it comes to this discussion as an AI might be able to write but will never be able to feel and feeling is the one element that an actor needs to portray the best stories, writers are way to valued in this industry to be replaced by a source that cant and will never experience true life, true emotion or even truth in this world. This video has also shown me the importance of the English language and has helped me see what techniques might be useful for the play I need to create in drama. I am very fond of acting and would love to start, thanks to you I have found the wonderful source backstage to help me begin this journey. As I have just took my first few steps into this journey I do not have enough support, supplies or money for necessities like acting classes or good camera quality. So I was wondering if in a new video maybe you could show some great activities and task to help improve our acting abilities kind of like coaching us through a small acting class and showing us things to make us a better actor/actress. Thankyou for all the videos you have made they are all so inspiring and have helped me through small steps of trying to start my acting career, I understand if this idea does not turn into a video I just thought I would tell you because for some reason it feels like I would have your support over a lot of people I know, also I am pretty desperate to get better at acting as being actress is a dream that I don't just want to just feel at night but experience in the day to. I appreciate everything you have done, keep on inspiring people and having fun I will be alongside watching your journey that you share as you have started mine. Thankyou very much Makayla Lysiak.
Lots of Love Dhanvi. 💕
As an actress, I applaud writers. I don’t know how they come up with these many ideas- and the quality is always so good.
Spider!!! Love everything about this!!!! I hope to see a video on writing a TV show and what your process is or what types of scripts/genres you love to write.
Thanks so much and I will try to make more writing videos!🥰
I'm nerding out with you! 😂 I'm a writer hoping to get into the business as well and I love reading scripts. When a script grabs your heart, it's because the writer put their heart into the story. I hope the strike gives them everything their hard work has earned ❤ Spider 😊
To me I think the Original Scripts are perfect as they are Hollywood CEO's shouldn't take advantage on AI Programms to take over their Employer's job because every Media company needs a Screenwriter not an AI Robot behind the Computer screen that's just my Opinion but overall this has to be one of my best favorite videos so far keep up the good work Makayla
i bursted out laughing at the “ time to show them the consequences of their actions “ 💀💀💀
😂
with chatGPT you can ask it to write a certain way - for example, when you write your prompt, you can ask it to describe less in dialogue but to put more visual elements into it, and it will do so.
First! Love youuu ❤
Wow, I must say that a script writer with creativity imagination is much better than the A.I writing the story stuff. Easy to say because A.I don't have a heart when tried to create a meaningful script, just like how the A.I voice did. And I shocked because now A.I is writing a script instead of us human. 😯🤖💖
That's crazy how the AI had Pugsley saying a line in the script before Wednesday is able to pull the tape off of his mouth. Obviously, real human writers would do a better job at writing than AI. A blinking remote control? Oh no, AI, you so disappoint me! Piranhas are so much scarier.
Your videos are so good. They make me want to be a actor.
Spider 🕷
The way that the AI wrote the scripts were ok but human writers definitely is more creative. I love watching tv and it wouldn’t be as good of a tv show if an AI wrote it.
Thank you for making these videos ❤
In other words no, AI can only be used as a way to stimulate ideas or as a hobby when you're bored. I use ChatGPT as a way to study for my oral exams or as a way to practice my speech or writing skills. It's shocking how corporations wanna use it as a way to replace screenwriters and actors completely despite its limits.
“Netflix hit….” Translation? “Derivative unoriginal show that pays $0.036 monthly residuals to the featured SAG/AFTRA members. Queue the Netflix executives’ maniacal laughs.
You're stunningly beautiful ❤❤❤.......(stunningly if that's a word😅)
If AI wants to replace humans in ANY job they need a human associated with it. I don’t know why someone would want AI to replace them. But if they did ; they need to make sure this AI isn’t doing horrible. A big thing about TV company’s is money. Not just money since they want to be rich. Money since they will be able to afford more props and sets. They will have money to build and make those. If people don’t like the new AI shows it will make some shows low budget or LOWER budget. And most entertainment AI made will get taken down if it isn’t doing well. #WeWriteYouWrong
Written scripts were best. Also, I’ve got to rewatch “Wednesday”. That’s a great show. Currently, watching “White Lotus.” Looks good. Watched 1st season of “Succession.” Didn’t like it.
What the Ai gave any writer worth anything would have in 5 seconds after hearing the prompt you wrote. There was no actual useful work completed by it there, in that there were no surprising ideas at all (beyond your prompt). It was just the obvious dull way of executing your prompt. I find it not at all useful to use Ai while writing - I kinda don't want to know the cliche and after reading the dreck cliche then it's stuck in your head
Spider 🕷Great video Makayla! Loved your take on this and your fascination with AI's use of parentheticals! lol
Bravo Spider, U were/are totally right... & because I never want 2 C A.I. replace ur future endeavors/accomplishments, B aware of what U teach ur diabolical enemies { A.I. & those behind it }. Believe me, they're watching & learning. FYI, I enjoyed ur wide view lense. Seeing more of U is an extremely pleasurable treat.
Wouldn't using AI as a tool, at first, help to advance it's capabilities? What would it take for AI to replace human involvement? 😮 The Matrix...
You have great insights. You'll always have our support no matter what.
I used ChatGPT for developing a story not writing a full story or screenplay. If I write something in ChatGPT it usually comes out very generic.
AI can't replace fiction writers with creativity and originality being their weakest spot. BUT. Even if AI gets to that point, they shouldn't replace people. It'll just be another voice with it's own personal writing style. Some of the most famous poets are Shakespeare, Maya Angelo, Dr. Seuss, and Shel Silverstein. Replacing every writer with AI is like only having Dr. Seuss and no one else.
I got to say, the AI script is kind of making me laugh because it reminds me of Terminator 2 where John points out the way the Terminator talked. I'm a bit disappointed Wednesday didn't say "affirmative" anyway in the script.
Also I wonder if the people who speculate that AppleTV movie “Ghosted” might actually have been written by AI because the script reads like something the studios only paid a writer to come up with a idea and base draft, then they just used cheaper AI to actually write the script.
Forgot to add: "Spider"
Here's the biggest problem with your video........
It can literally be used to make a I even more smarter in this time next year you're going to get a form or Superior version of chat GTP....... Because of this video 😰
Basically you will help this AI to become even better and not just chat GTP by itself but also other variants other types in versions.
Essentially you're feeding the machine 😰 but honestly this was a very great and informative video and I wish you all the success!
Humans writing human experiences are better than machines doing it… hmmm 🧐
I also tested this on ChatGPT and I feel that AI couldn’t replace writers as the script doesn’t have any personality. It also says everything your character is doing when we can see it. I asked for broadway and I only get half of what I asked for. It was horrible and when I said to change it the only thing it would change is the music letter ; I asked it to change the lyrics and that’s what I gave me. The first time I asked it said it was very close to another musical and it would get copy righted. That is a good sign AI won’t replace writers. #WeWriteYouWrong
Makayla should be a writer professor if that's even a thing. So good explanations for people who don't know anything about script writing. 💯 writers win.
Your so cool !!
This was interestingly informative. I am writing a script for a full featured animation my studio is producing and, based on this video- I tried "chatgpt" and entered one of my scene. As you said, AI can"t take the place of a writer but, it can help the process. spider
I came across your video about stepping away from Hollywood then decided to watch one more of your videos and this was great. Makayla, you will be an amazing writer and make wonderful movies one day. Don't stop. The Lord has a plan to prosper you and you will understand it later.