Thank you guys for all the support! Reminder that this is my opinion, and if you disagree, that's totally fine! Leave a like and subscribe if you haven't already ;)
He mentioned in the show that the jedi would consider him a sith. He has a red lightsaber, which means he bled his crystal using the dark side of the force. He is manipulating the force to his will, thats what a sith does. And fs thanks for the advice I'll add the clip next time!
@@ConnerBlue He said "might" consider him a sith, and red lightsabers are darkside based not sith specifically. PS: I am pretty sure crystal bleeding being the only way to make a red blade is legends and not canon. There are more dark side force using groups than just the sith. In ep 3 they mentioned "sects" of force users. Most of the rage is mistakes like that.
@@ConnerBlue " In Star Wars canon, red lightsabers are most commonly associated with the Sith, but they are not exclusively made by them. The key to the red color lies in the process of "bleeding" the kyber crystals. Kyber crystals, which power lightsabers, are naturally attuned to the light side of the Force and come in various colors, typically blue and green for Jedi. However, the Sith corrupt these crystals through a process called bleeding. By pouring their anger, hate, and dark side energy into the crystal, they bend it to their will, causing it to "bleed" and turn red. This process is described in the canon novel "Ahsoka" by E.K. Johnston and in the Marvel Comics' "Darth Vader" series. Essentially, any dark side user, not just Sith, can create a red lightsaber by bleeding a kyber crystal. Therefore, while red lightsabers are strongly linked to the Sith, they are not exclusively made by them, but by any Force user who embraces the dark side and performs the bleeding ritual." Inquisitors are not sith for example. The smoke dude from Ahsoka who worked for the witch was not a sith. Now do you see, you are looking for mistakes and making them yourself friend. Rage at a show leads to the dark side it does.
@@ConnerBlue "What are you" "I HAVE NO NAME" to *What* THEN he said "You might call me sith" which reads more like he was mocking the jedi's need to classify everything or put things it hates in evil buckets" If he was a sith he would have said A sith or "you could call me a sith" without the refusal to take a label. Now, do you see how it is not as bad as you painted it and it does not break canon? For all we know this is a knight of ren, let the fucking story finish and actually think about it before you join the hate train. cause brother, there is a ton of competition in the angry white nerd space and the algo wont carry you. Good, FAIR, reasoned analysis might.
@@Matisaro What does me criticizing a show have to do with race? I never mentioned anything about the races of the characters... A lot of my crticism comes from the poor dialogue and writing. For me, the show is just so weak. Compare this to House of the Dragon and it's night and day. Not sure why you're bringing up race man lmao.
I’m on board with the Disney destroying starwars thing because they are namely Kennedy has done serious dmg to series in several adaptations. And this show isn’t good but I wouldn’t say it’s bad either. There were some watchable parts. Overall tho, not great.
The Rule of Two is kind of ignored pretty often in Legends continuity. I mean most Sith usually had an apprentice or two even when they were not yet the master. Canon is probably working more of Legends feel into this using this show. I've noted how often the recent Star Wars shows have taken Legends material and reintroduced it into the Canon universe. Which is interesting because the fans often then hate the material that has been reintroduced. I'd agree that Legends did things better, as they usually used books, and comics that allowed for far more information to be given than a few minutes of screen time ever could. Still, I give them a gold star for effort, though not execution. Anyways, to me the protagonist of this story is pretty clear. This isn't the story of Mae, or the Jedi or whatever. We're really being given a story of how a failed Jedi Padawan thought she could become a something "positive" in the world, but really will fall to the Dark Side because she was always meant for the Dark Side. To me, more than Mae, it's Osha (spelling?) that is more prone toward passionate choices. So, if the show is given the time to tell the story in full, I'm sure that we'll get Osha becoming the Sith Acolyte. Side note, I don't think Disney Canon will follow the Plagueis novel despite how amazing it was. My guess is that we'll see them try to milk this time period for all the money they can get, writing their own timeline of what happened and how Palpatine became a Sith. If so, that means anything is possible be it good writing or bad.
Love this man! I love reading when people dive deep into the lore. Disney will probably not follow the novel, but the way its written its kind of cannon. Who knows though!
Look man, your channel is small and still growing. But hoping on the hate bandwagon might get you views but it won’t make you a meaningful voice in analyzing media. Choose integrity. The show has plenty to criticize but it’s average at worst.
I appreciate the criticism! This isn't me hoppin on the bandwagon to hate, this is just me voicing my opinion on a show that has writers and producers that have publicly bashed fans for not liking content. We as fans should vocalize what's going on in the industry and stand up against corporations that come in to inject politics. I encourage you to research a little more about the show, you might understand where we're coming from!
Padawans more op than masters, masters slayed by fodder level assassins. Honestly, my head hurts after trying to watch this travesty. I'm going to watch Andor again, as that was how it's done.
SAME HERE. I guess people are just ok with mediocrity nowadays. Nothing compares to eps 1-6. Andor was awesome, shows that Disney is capable of making good stuff!
What’s funny is starwars was made for teens . Grown men and women getting upset there childhood show isn’t the same . I showed my wife the first starwars movie . Unless you watched it as a kid and love for it. It’s a hard watch in 2024 as an adult
@@themrmezbahah yes let’s toss out the entire prequel and original trilogy for this acolyte show that no one likes 😏 just check rotten tomatoes and the watch count for proof
Some of it was defitinetely super cool, but it doesn't fit into the cannon. I can't understand how he can exist without darth tenebrous or plageius comin after him. Maybe they will, who knows!
Some people can be negative with no actual constructive criticism but I genuinely believe this show suffers from bad writing. It’s such cool concept but none of this buildup is paying off.
Thank you guys for all the support! Reminder that this is my opinion, and if you disagree, that's totally fine! Leave a like and subscribe if you haven't already ;)
This is getting ridiculous. This was a great episode
Alright but that fight scene was awesome
Yea it was solid! Unfortunately after that tho.... LMAO
So im trying to make Darth Queef a thing. Lol
Please make a video thingy showing where he said he was a sith.
"You might call me a sith" /= Sith.
Tourist.
He mentioned in the show that the jedi would consider him a sith. He has a red lightsaber, which means he bled his crystal using the dark side of the force. He is manipulating the force to his will, thats what a sith does. And fs thanks for the advice I'll add the clip next time!
@@ConnerBlue He said "might" consider him a sith, and red lightsabers are darkside based not sith specifically.
PS: I am pretty sure crystal bleeding being the only way to make a red blade is legends and not canon.
There are more dark side force using groups than just the sith. In ep 3 they mentioned "sects" of force users.
Most of the rage is mistakes like that.
@@ConnerBlue "
In Star Wars canon, red lightsabers are most commonly associated with the Sith, but they are not exclusively made by them. The key to the red color lies in the process of "bleeding" the kyber crystals.
Kyber crystals, which power lightsabers, are naturally attuned to the light side of the Force and come in various colors, typically blue and green for Jedi. However, the Sith corrupt these crystals through a process called bleeding. By pouring their anger, hate, and dark side energy into the crystal, they bend it to their will, causing it to "bleed" and turn red.
This process is described in the canon novel "Ahsoka" by E.K. Johnston and in the Marvel Comics' "Darth Vader" series. Essentially, any dark side user, not just Sith, can create a red lightsaber by bleeding a kyber crystal. Therefore, while red lightsabers are strongly linked to the Sith, they are not exclusively made by them, but by any Force user who embraces the dark side and performs the bleeding ritual."
Inquisitors are not sith for example. The smoke dude from Ahsoka who worked for the witch was not a sith.
Now do you see, you are looking for mistakes and making them yourself friend.
Rage at a show leads to the dark side it does.
@@ConnerBlue "What are you"
"I HAVE NO NAME" to *What*
THEN he said "You might call me sith" which reads more like he was mocking the jedi's need to classify everything or put things it hates in evil buckets"
If he was a sith he would have said A sith or "you could call me a sith" without the refusal to take a label.
Now, do you see how it is not as bad as you painted it and it does not break canon?
For all we know this is a knight of ren, let the fucking story finish and actually think about it before you join the hate train.
cause brother, there is a ton of competition in the angry white nerd space and the algo wont carry you.
Good, FAIR, reasoned analysis might.
@@Matisaro What does me criticizing a show have to do with race? I never mentioned anything about the races of the characters... A lot of my crticism comes from the poor dialogue and writing. For me, the show is just so weak. Compare this to House of the Dragon and it's night and day. Not sure why you're bringing up race man lmao.
"The Sith havent been seen in a millennium"
I’m on board with the Disney destroying starwars thing because they are namely Kennedy has done serious dmg to series in several adaptations. And this show isn’t good but I wouldn’t say it’s bad either. There were some watchable parts. Overall tho, not great.
The Rule of Two is kind of ignored pretty often in Legends continuity. I mean most Sith usually had an apprentice or two even when they were not yet the master. Canon is probably working more of Legends feel into this using this show. I've noted how often the recent Star Wars shows have taken Legends material and reintroduced it into the Canon universe. Which is interesting because the fans often then hate the material that has been reintroduced.
I'd agree that Legends did things better, as they usually used books, and comics that allowed for far more information to be given than a few minutes of screen time ever could. Still, I give them a gold star for effort, though not execution.
Anyways, to me the protagonist of this story is pretty clear. This isn't the story of Mae, or the Jedi or whatever. We're really being given a story of how a failed Jedi Padawan thought she could become a something "positive" in the world, but really will fall to the Dark Side because she was always meant for the Dark Side. To me, more than Mae, it's Osha (spelling?) that is more prone toward passionate choices. So, if the show is given the time to tell the story in full, I'm sure that we'll get Osha becoming the Sith Acolyte.
Side note, I don't think Disney Canon will follow the Plagueis novel despite how amazing it was. My guess is that we'll see them try to milk this time period for all the money they can get, writing their own timeline of what happened and how Palpatine became a Sith. If so, that means anything is possible be it good writing or bad.
Love this man! I love reading when people dive deep into the lore. Disney will probably not follow the novel, but the way its written its kind of cannon. Who knows though!
Look man, your channel is small and still growing. But hoping on the hate bandwagon might get you views but it won’t make you a meaningful voice in analyzing media. Choose integrity. The show has plenty to criticize but it’s average at worst.
Only Losers desperate for views and money over analyze media.
Only Losers over analyze Media who are Desperate for views and money. 😏
I appreciate the criticism! This isn't me hoppin on the bandwagon to hate, this is just me voicing my opinion on a show that has writers and producers that have publicly bashed fans for not liking content. We as fans should vocalize what's going on in the industry and stand up against corporations that come in to inject politics. I encourage you to research a little more about the show, you might understand where we're coming from!
Padawans more op than masters, masters slayed by fodder level assassins. Honestly, my head hurts after trying to watch this travesty. I'm going to watch Andor again, as that was how it's done.
SAME HERE. I guess people are just ok with mediocrity nowadays. Nothing compares to eps 1-6. Andor was awesome, shows that Disney is capable of making good stuff!
@@ConnerBlue The man has TASTE!
This Fanbase keeps getting worse. 😏
the show is literally plot breaking lmao throws the entire 1st movie out the window
@@da_chosen_one2927Like the plot of the first movie was any good. And don't come out of nowhere 😂.
What’s funny is starwars was made for teens . Grown men and women getting upset there childhood show isn’t the same . I showed my wife the first starwars movie . Unless you watched it as a kid and love for it. It’s a hard watch in 2024 as an adult
@@themrmezbahah yes let’s toss out the entire prequel and original trilogy for this acolyte show that no one likes 😏 just check rotten tomatoes and the watch count for proof
This was a good episode . I think qumir was a good villain . Seems a bit unhinged and he murked loads of Jedi in cool ways
Some of it was defitinetely super cool, but it doesn't fit into the cannon. I can't understand how he can exist without darth tenebrous or plageius comin after him. Maybe they will, who knows!
I hate this fan base y’all are so negative and petty all the time
Some people can be negative with no actual constructive criticism but I genuinely believe this show suffers from bad writing. It’s such cool concept but none of this buildup is paying off.
To quote a line the left often likes to use when we bring up criticism. "If you don't like it then leave, you won't be missed"