Dealing with Theological Differences in the Real World - Dr. Yasir Qadhi | 1st September 2013
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2013
- Sunni, Shīʿa, Salafi, Sufi, Deobandi, Ahl'l-Sunnah wa'l-Jamā'ah - Why do we have all these labels can't we just say we're Muslims and that's it!
To often our communities become divided on differences in thoughts and ideas, acknowledging & welcoming the various levels of religious beliefs is an important first step towards building diverse communities & bridging the gap to put all titles aside.
Join Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi in this special address to the Muslim Students' Association (MSA) entitled 'Dealing with Theological Differences in the Real World'.
A talk not to be missed!
Pledge of Mutual Respect and Cooperation Between Sunni Muslim
Scholars, Organizations, and Students of Sacred Knowledge
Hold fast to the Rope of Allah, all together, and be not divided. (Qur'an, 3:103)
Surely, those who have made divisions in their religion and turned into factions, you
have nothing to do with them. Their case rests with Allah; then He will inform them of
what they used to do. (Qur'an, 6:159)
Recorded at the MSA National 2013 on 1st September 2013
Shkh Yasir Qadhi is a man who seeks to unify the Muslims. May Allah increase the Ummah with people like you.
No thank you. We unite upon tawheed, the Quran, the Sunnah according to the early generations of Muslims. Not with people of falsehood and innovation
@@beardedbloke2521 BarakAllah fee kum
Enthralling. My ears are open. My heart is absorbing. My brain cells are rejuvenating. I want to gain more knowledge every day. Mr. Yasir Qadhi is person of great knowledge. I would like to meet him for clearing the cobwebs that can help me out of my ignorance.
YASir qadhi is a scholar
a very great scholar, Mashallaah
Yasir Qhadi is the donkey that the Scholars ride upon.
Thats a double edged compliment, none the less Mashallah
YASMIN ZAMAN I agree with you
God bless you. Very clever man speaking. We Christians desire the same: openess, tolerance, mutual help, respect and yet the courage to seek for God even if worshipping him in different way. I, as a Christian pastor, deeply respect many muslims, debate with them calmly, and can proudly say, they are my respected friends. We would need some speaker and scholar like dr. Qadhi in christianity today.
I have been benefiting from every speech you have been delivering ,May Allah bless you and protect you from every evil ustaz Yasir .
I'm glad someone finally tackled this sectarian stupidity head on. It's about time we stop trying to do the scholars' job and start respecting each other despite our differences and letting this self righteous zealous attitude go.
It really upsets me when a scholar of his stature gets called a shaytaan just because he isn't siding with their particular group. This tribal mentality has done enough harm.
We are all muslims before we are Sunni or Shia or Sufi or salafi after all.
thanks for sharing this. Very knowledgable
May peace, mercy and blessing of Allah “azw” be upon you brother!
may Allah bless his knowledge to me he usually has a very balanced opinion about an issue. I love sheikh Yasir Qadhi for the sake of Allah.
I am Shiite Muslim from Indonesia, may ALLAH bless and protect Dr Yasir Qadhi in this world and in the next world
I'm also from Indonesia, never seen or met any shiite here.
Where do you live?
Dr Yasir, I really love you in Allah! I can never get enough of your talks!
I am very happy to hear this bayan mashaAllah, we have enough problems in Muslim world than differences between madhaabs brother, like Islamophobia, hatred, racism low literacy in our community, poverty etc. addressing all these things also Sunnah of Rasoolullah swa brother. Because Rasoolullah swa was more concerned about the self reliance, financial good and education of Sahabah a lot.
for the salafi brothers, be just with yasir qadhi. I as a salafi sunni, don't see anything wrong in co-operating for the common good of society. But for the manhaj, we make clear are differences, there are many instances where the Nabi (saas) co-operated with the Kuffar quraysh. wa Allahu alaam
@yomomo100 My opinion is that muslim should cooperate on that which is good and beneficial. But to leave of takfeer where is valid is not right, if someone worships saints and claim love for Allaah and his messenger that is not valid.
I am Salafi and I agree
May Allah bless and protect Shaykh Yasir Qadhi,he is doing the right thing, as much as other viewers in this forum talk against him, they will never reach the level of knowledge and Imaan the Shaykh has, thats a fact.
Shaykh Yasir Qadhi is trying to re-unite the Ummah, why are people so angry with this intention and motivation?
***** What falsehood is Yasir Qadhi preaching? I challenge you to show one thing he said that is against Ahlu Sunnah.
civilisationskerl: So are you saying the people he tries to reunite with are kaafir? They are just deviated maybe on some issues, not anything major, please stop the hate speech and help with the movement. May Allah show us the straight path.
Did you know that some scholars like Ibn hazm or al-qurtubi rejected the Hadith which says that 72 sects will go to hellfire? And you want to take this Hadith as fundamental for your creed?
Did you know that even the Sahaba differed in random aqida-aspects but never called each other innovators?
Did you know that even Ibn Taymiyya tried to unite Hanbalis/Salafis and Asharis?
Ibn Taymiyyah states [Majmū 'l-Fatāwā 3/227-229]:
“People know there was alienation and animosity between the Hanbalīs and the Asharīs. I was of those who strived to reconcile the Muslims’ hearts and unify them, in emulation of the command to hold fast to Allāh’s Rope. I removed most of the alienation that existed in the hearts. I clarified that al-Asharī was one of the most noble of the speculative theologians (Mutakallimūn) to ascribe to Imām Ahmad, may Allāh have mercy on him, and those like him who support his way, as al-Asharī himself mentions in his books.
@@hm9825 do u even hear what he said? He said he knows there r groups who have weird ideas and we should not make them a leader or something important like that. He said it in the video. What r u talking about? he is talking about groups who r basically doing same thing but have some theological difference. And that’s the job of Scholars to debate. bro stop hating and for oncee try listening
group mentality
Subhan Allah. One of the best modern day speaker. I love your style. Its balanced but very pressing. Mashallah, I learn how to supervise PhD students from your talks. Jazak Allah
Unity in Islam is fundamental. It is the Ulema's decision regarding theology differences.
There is a lot of immature responders to this video. Sad.
MashaAllah, JEZEK ALLAH KHEYRE YA
Shkh Yasir Qadhi what a wonderful speech .
Jzkl khairan for your talk it made a lot of sense.
Assalamo Alaikom, i am from philippines and i love dr. yasir for being muslim...
Jazaak Allaah Khayr for the upload. Beneficial reminder Alhamdulillaah
Subbanah Allah very great explained absolutely totally agree with Dr Yasir Allah SWT will be the judged.... Ameen
MashaAllah, what a wonderful speech :)
The sheikh hit it right on point.
Very good lecture. Unite the People rather than divide them.
Masha Allah very important lecture. Jazak allahul khairan
Say, [O believers], "We have believed in Allah and what has been revealed to us and what has been revealed to Abraham and Ishmael and Isaac and Jacob and the Descendants and what was given to Moses and Jesus and what was given to the prophets from their Lord. We make no distinction between any of them, and we are Muslims [in submission] to Him." (2:136)
Excellent. My friends and I think you are the best muslim speaker in the world.
جزاك الله خير
highly informative ~
In Islam's earlier history, female religious scholars were relatively common. Mohammad Akram Nadwi, a Sunni religious scholar, has compiled biographies of 8,000 female jurists, and orientalist Ignaz Goldziher earlier estimated that 15 percent of medieval hadith scholars were women.[121] After the 16th century, however, female scholars became fewer,[121] and today - while female activists and writers are relatively common - there has not been a significant female jurist in over 200 years
The big problem is that in our age, our most powerful enemy is the media, and even if you are taking the term "sunni" as adjective rather than a noun, this media group uses it to be a divisive weapon against us. Hence, I still strongly insist that the term must be very rarely use, in fact to be used only, when you are actually on the spot topic of differentiating us Muslims from the deviators of the followers of Qur'an and the Sunnah of Rasul SAW.
Great speech......unifying...
my hero
The Prophet (PBUH) never hated any of his brothers or sisters; what sunnah are you following?
Long wanted lecture! Hope some Muslims will take heed of it.
Masha Allah well said.
Thank you all!
funny how now people opposing unity as better smarter scholars than Yasir Kadhi .. Differences have always been with us. How did Rasul(saw) tackle it??
Allah has given each of us a mind, we don't need to agree with everything from every speaker, sheikh or scholar.
Great,,
for the most part, the brother is speaking some sense. Dont unite with them, just co-operate for the common good.
Subhanallah!
I am just confused. I have learned from Islamic Civilization class that Mu'taziliyyah is a branch of Sunni and that some Abbasid Caliphs adopted this ideology. Please someone enlighten me on this.
Great speech
Thanks
I like his lectures because they are logical.
Obedience to authorities(ameer) in Islam and Sufism.
In Islam Obedience to the leader (Ameer or Khalifah) of Muslims in matters that are allowed or approved of by Islamic teachings and by the conventions (Ma‘roof) of the society.
In Sufism, Unqualified and unconditional obedience and reverence that is reserved in Islam
Nice talk👍
Was waiting for Zaid shakir to speak
Is there anyway to hear what Imam Zaid had said?
Where can we see the speech you mentioned at 17:15 (ICNA speech)?
Like Dr. Sherman Jackson says, we have to identify our own causes within the West and apply Islamic solutions to them. Our lives have been directed by our home countries for too long. Sectarian divisions are common there. We don't need that baggage. And it is definitely baggage.
I want to join msa
very useful topic.
from what Surah did Allah said he called us Muslims? Jazaka Allahu khayr!
the prophet is reported to have warned against bid'ah in the deen
👍👍👍
dear sheikh ,is that ur son(the anchor).he looks like u . may ALLAH bless u.
some of the comments here are jokes! chill out dudes, we all know you go back to your netflix after your virulent takfir sessions
Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullah there is only one way, and that is to follow the Qur'an and the Sunnah following the Prophet and the believers (way of the Sahaba, Tabi'een and their students). Brothers and sisters we don't just respect the Sahaba we love them Fisibillah as Allah Ta'ala has mentioned their noble status.
And whoever contradicts and opposes the Messenger (Muhammad SAW) after the right path has been shown clearly to him, and follows other than the believers' way. We shall keep him in the path he has chosen, and burn him in Hell - what an evil destination. Surah An-Nisa 115
Lets talk Sahaba then.....and not disrupt those conversations with arab politics
how did you arrive to that conclusion?
He call you to himself not to Allah, beware of him.
oooo another thing..hes referring to the "Nation of Islam" but not saying there names..y?...who the hell knows
Alhamdulillah I'm a deobandi
In regards to the verse the Ikhwaanis always quote, "surely those who have made divisions in their religion and turned into factions you have nothing to do with them." Imam al-Baghawi said, "they are the people of BIDAH and desires." So this ayah is a proof AGAINST the Ikhwaanis. Yasir Qadhi and those who signed the pledge do not have true unity. Allah said about the Jews, "You would think they are united but their hearts are SCATTERED that is because they are a people who don't understand!"
if only Hassan al-Banna al-ikhwani could give such a speech destroying al-Wala wal-Bara, 'audhu billaah
Assalamulaikum, you have discussed about all other theology except Ahmedia. I know a leady from Ahmediat. Am I allowed to visit her ?
Ahmadias not Muslims
Rehana Perveen the ulama have said they are kuffar
even tho hes is very intelligent i view him as misguided in some issues but still beneficial at times..i agree with him 100% that names r good to use n some instances..like "salafi" im from Baltimore there r no real community of bidah far as i know where all on the same Aqeedah for the most part. so i see know reason living in baltimore city to use the term "salafi" so i understand where hes coming from on that point..but at the same time there is no cooperation and love n unity with people who u know r deviant.
I know how you deal with ideological differences.
Taquia. Every body knows.
14:30 In the early days in Mecca, in Prophet's SAW time, Muslim community was also very very small. And they we're joint upon al-Haqq, weren't they?
which muslim sect drinking wine while praying?!! does anyone know?
Sharee‘ah ,Sharee‘ah is the body of rules and regulations for the maters of Deen given by Allaah and His Messenger.
Tareeqah rules and regulations devised by a Sufi order that a person must follow to progress in their invented spirituality.
All the ignorant commenters here are nothing compared to Yasir Qadhi but they talk as if they somehow know more [lol], fear Allah.
By Allaah, Yasir Qadhi has opended the doors of misgudance. Flee with your faith, O muslims!
Haiyyakamullah barakallahu feekum jazakallahu khairun!!!!
he attended a lecture delivered by tony blaire, we are muslims brothers and sisters, please think before you speak, speak with your minds not your hatred. we get knowledge from where it is available, hundreds of years ago islamic spain was well established for it advanced medicine studies and even before Iraq was well known for chemistry, maths and physics, but now this has shifted to the west, does this make the knowledge less valuable, by no means , knowledge is knowledge, doesnt matter whether from a kafir or muslim, didnt the prophet PBUH consult with a non muslim immediately after the first revelation why because this particular disbeliever was known for his knowledge.
Fear ALLAH we have enough hatred within the Muslims, leave your differences and keep faith in ALLAH, dont start unnecessary arguments without strong evidence.
v dnt hve d right 2 curse ny1 if u feel he is wrong den pray dat Allah guides him no human is perfect he cld b a better muslim in d sight of Allah who noes
The problem is the Quran and Sunna are ambiguous, hence the myriad of interpretations. The scholars are not going to give up their positions easily.
It’s pointless going to scholars. Even amongst the scholars of the same school they have differences they argue vehemently about
Nothing new. Differences and debates have been like that for all of humanity except when there was a prophet. What's the difference today then any other day of history?
Lay Muslim! Lots of Muslims fall in that category!
that ihkwani dawah popular amongst awaam in the West. advice to brothers and sisters take your knowledge from correct sources . read sharh us sunnah of barbahari amongst other books from our salaf 🙂
Shaykh why don't you address the deobandi barelwi divide? This divide is the most vicious and bitter inter divide in indo pakistan between 2 hanafi groups, and it is also theological in nature. The barelwis sunnis with the help of Ottoman scholars were able to apostasize the founders of deoband school. This also needs to be addressed
Assalaamu Alaikum. My Name is Sami Ullah Baloch. I am a Muslim I wanna say I think there's a difference between Yasir Qadhi and Subboor Ahmed. Yasir Qadhi belives in evolution and the other hand Subboor Ahmed does not?
praying behind a shia in a shia masjid?? Have you seen how the shia pray?? Do you know of their aqeedah? You will not allow a person to pray behind a man who says that Allah came down as a form of a man but you will a Muslim to pray behind a person who says that their imams are greater than the prophets and that their imams control the heavens and the earth??? SMH...
***** No, do not be be fooled by the taqqiyyah of the rafidah. Infact that is the belief of the of ithna- ashariyyah sect of shia which makes up the majority of shia today. Infact they curse the companions of the prophet in the salah.
In sha Allah we will never have to pray in a shia masjid.... but if there is no option then there would be no harm in doing so, as Allah s.w.t is the rahmaanu' raheem he will witness our niyah in the prayer... and since all actions depend on their niyah there wont be any azaab cause we of the Sunni theology have no grudge against any compainon... and may allah have mercy on us all
Maryam Abdulmumin when did he say pray behind a shia? He said you can use the mosque just like you can pray anywhere.
i don't understand why all this names , Allah called us Muslims following Quran and Sunnah that it
Nizar Naji Allah the most high in the Quran refers to Al Muhajirun and Al Ansar... are not both these groups Muslims? Spend time with a real scholar instead of social media
Also wanted to add shia and sufi are not part of Islam as yassir qadhi preaches. He is spreading falsehood. Allah religion is pure and we can't twist and manipulate to suit our agendas and desires.
Yet some madkhali salafis will make a video slandering yasir qadhi lol what a shocking etiquettes of a Muslim
basically a Modernist movement and ideology. Please don't be fooled by this concept because this idea is from bidah which leads to shirk. What is batil will always be batil (falsehood) and we can't unite under evil and falsehood.
You tube is bidah lol thank Allah swt for the four Madhab
the brother quoted quran, ayahs disaproving of splitting up into factions and sects. But would the Prophet (saas) unite with those who revile his companions, his wife. or those whom distort Allah;s attributes. The answer is no. So we unite upon the truth, nothing but the truth. there is unity, upon falsehood. Is the muslim, like the mujrim (criminal)?
This is your problem. You feel the need to be the judge and jury. The Qur'an teaches us that if we're confident, after we have made our points through clear discussion, if they still do not agree we leave such issues to Allah(SWT) to deal with them. If they are not posing a real threat to the lives of people, then it is ok and you can work in society together. Otherwise, the results are as you see now... a ridiculous failure.
You either didnt listen to the talk or have trouble understanding plain and simple English.
Lay Muslims should be wary of scholarly consensus which excludes women as jurists.
Tamper Tantrum Adios feminist
This man sat with the people of desire and misguidance and thus has become one of them,enough said.
caldwell Case you watched his video and commented on it so you have become his supporter and are part of him- enough said...
What really happened Mr Yasir, you just said the word Shia, You had never ever uttered the word Shia before in all your lectures .All I heard was Rafidha.Rafidha. Rafidha. What really changed. When you talked about masjid, you should have said..... , We have sunnie masjid and Rafidha. masjid. You got to read Shia Theology and don't forget to read Nahj al-Balagha. This is all I can say to you.
The proof theat we can cooperate with nonmuslims for the goal of justice is the Fudool alliance (or the al Muteebeen alliance) from seerah.
you dad doesnt have tawheed then
What is this nonsense? You have a sunni muslim giving a talk about "bridging the gap" and there is no sufi muslim available to gove a talk too! Shameful!
ISNA*
Yasir so you want us to ignored the the advises of the scholars? No brother I don't think so..I advise you to returned back to the scholars of the ummah, your ideals have been refuted by so many like shaykh Al abanee, Al luhaydan, Al uthaymin the list goes on and on...o yasir what have became of you? Fear your lord...as for us the scholars are the inheritors of the Prophets and their are to be listen to...
Mr. PeopleOfHadiths,
Bother Qadhi is a scholor himself(at least in my opinion) who most of the time makes real sense. You should have to follow any scholar, and you definitely should not be lazy.
Do your own research and follow what makes sense. Allah give us brain for a reason. Before you listen or follow a scholar take a look at his educational backgrounds and see how knowledgeable he/she is. What degrees does the scholar have...
"academic" is your favorite word, lol.
you noticed too!
Qadianis pray 5 times a day,faces qibla and eat our jabiha.
Are they Muslim?
nice sounding speech but is BS how can u unite with extreme deviants, these are not minor as yasir claim, its emaan and kufr, the greatest kufr (disbelief) is associating partners with Allah
There are different circles of cooperation. You are trying to think of all of them as one circle
no sect within Islam is associating a partner to Allah (azzawajal). Not Asharis, not maturidis, not Shia, not Sufis
astaghfirullah this mans voice literally makes me quiver.. such a dodgy individual, wallahu a'lam..
Who?
Ahmed Karim you may need ruqya
Ahmed Karim since you are a scholar can you help with some of my questions?